At least for me, thighs are normally better when thiccer, if it's incredibly plump it's very good too, just don't exaggerate too much to make it look like the upper and lower body are from two different people merged into one However, I need to say firmness is something very important too, so actually it doesn't matter if it's thin or thicc, if the thigh is firm enough, it's likely to be appreciated 😭😭