The REAL Meaning of the 4th Commandment - Jim Staley 

No particular day by name is mentioned here!

It says the 7th day. It is/was the celebration of creation week.

Shabbat Shalom

@@catholic4sure976Show us where they didn’t keep the sabbath. It’s in the scriptures that the apostles as well as the first church kept the sabbath.

@@kac0404 Are you willing to bet your eternal Life on it? 4th Commandment written in STONE!

@@kac0404 tha ceremonial law was nailed to the cross NOT THE 10 COMMANDMENTS!! Get REAL..the 4th commandment has the seal of God In the 4th Commandment and you want to take that away? let me guess you go to church on the false day of worship SUNday?

@@kac0404 my Bible says you will be judged by the law! You lawless? Ok. Good luck with that!!

@@kac0404 the law of moses was done away with, God's 10 commandments are forever! Including the 4th commandment! The only commandment that starts with remember you saying to forget.. 😆 🤣 😂 😹

Thank you Roger! Blessing to the Pacific Islands

I am so glad to hear it. The Sabbath is such a beautiful day and a real blessing. It is so different than any other day. People don’t know what they’re missing

John 10:27 NKJV My sheep hear My voice, and I know them, and they follow Me.

Nice!!! What a blessing!

@kac0404 thank you. I guess these People who celebrate Sabbath don't study The new Testament. You can even find lots of verses in the old testament.

@@MiCha13298 What good is it to study the New Testament if YOU aren't going to interpret it properly? This is to say that there's nothing in the NT to support profaning the Sabbath, as you suggest. And, FYI: None of the things @kac0404 (the guy you thanked) said amounted to a hill of beans. And, mind you, I'm prepared to prove that anytime you're ready.

​@@kac0404He just explained it and you still hold on to false doctrine. I hope you understand one day

Mr. Jim Staley says at aprox 5:30 mins in: "Did you know that even the Gentiles are expected to keep the sabbath in the NT..." No, I didn't know that. Where? Thats not in Acts 15:21. Acts 15:21 the subject of the sentence is "Moses." The action part of the sentence is "has had throughout many generations preach him (Moses) in every city" ... so, I would paraphrase that verse to say: Moses, (subject) has had the "law of Moses" preached in every city, by being read in the synagogues every Sabbath." ... ? ... Where is the word for Gentiles in that verse? The old covenant law was only for the Jews and those living with them (2Chr 6:11 the LORD made the Covenant with the Children of Israel, Not the World, or in Deut 5:3 Only those "here" at Mt Horeb). So, when it was preached, it was not for Gentile believers not living with the Jews. (Ninevites in the book of Jonah for example ) Imagine if the commandment, not to build a fire on the Sabbath, was given to the Eskimos?) And since it is making a statement on what HAS happened in the past; where does it say it's for Gentiles in the New Covenant (NC)? If someone makes the Statement: "Hitler taught that killing the Jews was the will of God." Are they agree or disagreeing with Hitler? It doesn't say. ... Its just stating a fact. Hitler taught... Same with Acts 15:21. It says nothing except that, Moses had the Law of Moses taught in Synagogues on the Sabbath. You are Extrapolating the text. You are telling New Covenant gentile Christians that they are expected to keep the Sabbath. My dear friend, for your own wellbeing, ... You better be careful to be standing on the WORD of GOD, not your own private interpretation of a verse that you have add content to, to get it to say what you want it to say. Where in the Bible are NC gentile Christians expected to keep the Sabbath, like you said? ... If not, my dear friend, you are violating Deut 4:2 and Rev 22:19. Acts Chapter 15 plainly instructs NC Christians that Circumcision is not required (the sign of the Abrahamic Covenant), and only the four listed things are brought into the NC.@@truebeliever81

Glad you agreed with him but 7th day Adventism is also false

@@truebeliever81many of their beliefs stand firm with what Mr. Staley believes. Just a few small disagreeing beliefs, like “investigative judgement” which is a man made doctrine

@@kac0404 actually Sir, they 'broke bread' daily - see Acts 2:46. and Paul did speak on Sabbath that weekend (Acts 17:2), but when it got dark out, that Sabbath became the 1st day aka Sabbath evening. you even wrote: _'...spoke to them and continued his message until midnight.'_ the Sabbath was kept in all the NT as well as the OT. if It weren't, it would have been clearly noted, since the God who doesn't change, didn't change. and interestingly too - Sabbath will still be kept by those who go to Heaven (Matt 19:17, Rev 22:14) and those who will be in Heaven - Isaiah 66:22-23 thanks for reading, Sir!

So glad to hear your story about keeping the Sabbath in Jail, and continuing to when you got out. The Bible says, if you regard iniquity in your heart, the Lord doesn’t hear your prayers. Now that you’re doing what is right He answers your prayers. God be with you.

To God be the glory, Jesus loves you and am so happy you found the truth by searching the word and through prayer. Keep holding on soon Jesus will be coming in power and great glory.

Sometimes in life we need to crash before we become still and just listen. Shalom brother ❤

Hi , im a Christian that’s worships on Sunday , the Lord has been putting the Sabbath on my heart and want to keep it ,, what are high holy days that your speaking of ? Thanks in advance !

​@@Cristinepedraza01m.ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-SuWyRq8KwMg.html&pp=ygUhdG9tb3Jyb3cncyB3b3JsZCBzZXZlbiBmZWFzdCBkYXlz

The God who said both Saturday and Sunday are days of rest (Exodus 12:16; Lev 23:7-8) is the God who was worshipped on Sunday (Matt 28:17). If you decide to believe that Jesus is God, worshipping Him on Sunday guarantees you salvation. He is the Mediator of the New Covenant. Believe in Jesus and you enter His True Sabbath (Matt 11:28).

@@robbymuzhama90 highlighting replies doesn’t magically make them true🙄😂🤣🤦‍♂️

Where does the Bible say Saturday or Sunday?

@@ocirej0008 it says the seventh day. Even the pope agrees 🙄

@@robbymuzhama90 Jesus is God, read and study the book of John

Leviticus 23:3 says that the Sabbath day it has to be kept having a holly gathering, a holly convocation, not just ceasing working and laying in the bed. 3. 'Six days shall work be done, but the seventh day is a Sabbath of solemn rest, 👉a holy convocation👈. You shall do no work on it; it is the Sabbath of the LORD in all your dwellings. Leviticus 23:3

Sabbath represents God's power of creation, all flesh must observe it,aisiah chapter 66vs23..

7th day Adventists is a cult

And the feasts also

@@katherineking3174 the feast days were done away at the cross, they are part of the Ceremonial Laws. Jesus fulfilled them all

Seriously! It’s a gift of YAH.

Amen!!!

​@@kac0404I think he's Hebrew Roots cult too, based on some of his teachings.

@@kac0404 What you teach are half truths by twisting scripture like Satan!

Remember Jesus talks about doing good on the Sabbath. God requires mercy not sacrifice. Nursing is a high calling, taking care of Gods people, showing mercy. God knows your heart, you are not breaking his commandment.

Luke 13:10-17: Jesus heals a woman with a spirit of infirmity Luke 14:1-6: Jesus heals a man with dropsy John 5:1-18: Jesus heals a sick man at the pool of Bethzatha John 9:1-41: Jesus heals a man who was born blind Matthew 12:9-13: Jesus heals a man with a withered hand Mark 3:1-6: Jesus heals a man with a withered hand IMO I think your doing a good work. If I were in your shoes I would try to move life decisions towards being off work on the Sabbath, and pray for His blessing in that, but I also wouldn't sweat it until He provides. Shalom

It's a privilege and a blessing!

God don't like the word proud It's a privilege and Grace

@@elsieaugustin-pw3yu we should worship God, not sabbath worshipers.

The formula of "keeping the Sabbath holy" remains a covenant, but you need an event that determines your counting. Two known events in the bible determine the Sabbath. 1. Creation - determined the seventh day - which in the days of Jesus fell on Saturday. 2. Deliverance or Redemption - this event determined the seventh day falling on Sunday - brought about by the Resurrection of Jesus Christ. That is why disciples worshipped Him on Sunday Matthew 11:28. Also Pentecost fell on Sunday. Jesus is God.

Remember, it's an ongoing journey of learning and growing. Your heart is to keep shabbat, that pleases the Father :) Blessings and shalom. Lisa - PFT Staff.

@@PassionForTruthVideo thank you, I appreciate this 🙏

Wonderful! Share this video with others as well!

@@PassionForTruthVideo i have, not only this but others. Because the truth will send people free.

You will look forward to his Sabbath rest once you start keeping it.l will always look forward to it and l truly believe HE has blessed my home with peace once l started keeping the Sabbath. Even my cat doesn’t chase my chickens now ,even my animals have Shalom .lol

@@mcanultymichelle So true!

He does forgive you, because you didn't know. And now that you DO know, you are doing things as He wants. Shalom.

That is exactly correct , but what days are they talking about here, it can't be the seventh day Sabbath because GOD has said " remember the seventh day keep it holy " so it must be talking about other holy days other Sabbaths that the jews kept , maybe , yom kippor, or the feast of unleven bread , there are so many in the jewish calendar,

These texts in Colossians 2: 14-17 are speaking of the ceremonial laws being nailed to the Cross. The Ten Commandments were NEVER called Handwritings of ordinances which were contrary to us or against us. The ceremonial laws were the sacrifice of animals for sins, Feast days, meat a drink offerings connected with the feast days, the ceremonial sabbath days, which were yearly, on different days of the week because they were controlled by the New Moon. The seventh day Sabbath was never called sabbath day(s), nor written in lowercase or with an s plural, they were never said to be against us or contrary to us, never called ordinances. The Ten Commandment’s are eternal, including the seventh day Sabbath. The ceremonial laws were contained in the Book of the Law written by Moses, the Ten Commandments were written by the finger of God. The ceremonial laws contained in the Book of the Law were placed in the side of the Ark of the Covenant Take this Book of the Law, and put it in the side of the Ark of the Covenant of the Lord your God, that it may be there for a witness against thee. Deuteronomy 31: 26(the same lingo as Colossians 2:14) the Ten Commandments were placed inside of the Ark of the Covenant along with a golden bowl of manna, and Aaron’s Rod that budded, they are eternal. But the ceremonial laws were place on the outside to show they were taken away, no longer to be kept, because Jesus was the sacrifice that was slain, and fulfilled the animal sacrifices, feast days, meat and drink offerings, and the ceremonial sabbath days. All throughout the Old and New Testament it says to keep the Ten Commandment’s, all Ten, including the Sabbath. You break one you break them all. James 2: 10. Sin is transgression of the Law. 1 John 3:4 The Bible says we will be judged by the Law of Liberty ( Ten Commandments) , James 2 even quotes a couple so you know what commandments he is referring to. If you love Me Keep My Commandments. John 14:15 He that hath My Commandment’s, AND KEEPETH THEM, he it is that LOVETH ME: and he it is that loveth Me shall be loved of My Father, and I will love him, and will manifest Myself to him. John 14: 21 Read also Matthew 19:17 1 John 2: 3-5, Revelation 22: 14 Revelation 12: 17 At the end of Revelation 12: 17 says the Remnant Church keep the Commandment’s of God and the Testimony of Jesus Christ. The Bible interprets it’s. Revelation 19: 10 says the Testimony of Jesus Christ, is the Spirit of Prophecy. Only one Church that has that. These were a shadow of things to come-the crucifixion. Jesus fulfilled all of these. Circumcision was done away too, instead of literal circumcision, circumcision was of the heart. Romans 2: 28,29 All those that believe in Christ are now spiritual Israel, Romans 9: 6-8, Galatians 3: 26-29

@@dianechapmanbettyboop happy Sabbath !!

@@gordo191no I believe Paul is talking to the minority not the majority I’m pretty sure the people of Colossians wasn’t keep the sabbath day so who would be judging a pagan society for something they didn’t keep it was the minority that was keeping it and being judged for turning to the one true God keeping his sabbath and high sabbaths new moons they was be judge or frown on by the pagan society of Colossians

​@@gordo191The annual Sabbaths were given by God also, they are to be kept, just as Yahshua and the disciples kept them. The "jewish" days - purim, the 9th of Av (I think that's one), Hanukkah, etc. - are man's days, not Yahweh's, any more than x-mas and easter are.

Keeping the Sabbath is how we get God's mark on our foreheads and not the beasts mark. Sunday law when enforced will be the mark of the beast, don't worship on Sunday your praising the sun God.

Hi,let me state from the outset that I'm not a SDS but would like to ask you a qs hope you can give an answer; here it is - which commandments don't you keep ...

⁠@@waynecharles5331 the Ceremonial Laws we don’t keep, they include offering of animals for a sacrifice, feast days, meat and drink offerings, the Ceremonial sabbath days, which were yearly, on different days of the week, these because they controlled by the New Moon. These are described by Colossians 2: 14-17 were handwritings of ordinances which were against us and contrary to us, nailed to the cross. When Jesus said, It is finished , the ceremonial laws were completed. The ceremonial laws were in the Book of the Law, written by Moses. Take this Book of the Law,and put it in the side of the Ark of the Covenant of the Lord your God, that it may be there for a witness against thee. Deuteronomy 31: 26, the same lingo as Colossians 2: 14 The seventh day Sabbath was never called Handwritings nor ordinances. Ephesians 2: 15,16, 2 Chronicles 33:8

@@dianechapmanbettyboop hi, thanks for replying but apparently you didn't read my question correctly so I'll ask it again ( I'm asking YOU which of the Ten Commandments you do not keep) there i hope you understand it now thanks...

@@Elizabeth-rk3do Hello Elizabeth,..there are many instances in scripture that our Father calling characters of low places to repentance, and then then use them for His purposes. Paul was such a one, didn't he persecute the church? Didn't even David have Elihu slain inthe heat of battle? And was Judah right to ho into Tamar? It is easy for us to point a finger, but ate we without any sin Elizabeth? Let's continue to test everything being taught and cement the promises to those that remain faithful until the end.

I was a cradle Catholic too and Jesus brought me out of the false RCC! Praise God!

@@kac0404that verse actually means when we are doing it the right way and the world is saying it’s wrong. The doctrine of man (the pope) says the sabbath was changed to Sunday. That’s why the verse says let no MAN judge you. Who cares if MEN judge us, we should care if YAH judges us. The next verse says which are a shadow of things to come, but the body is of Christ. We will be observing the Sabbath in heaven. Stop arguing with everyone. Pray that your eyes are open instead. YAH bless.

@@kac0404 The pope changed the sabbath to Sunday. Look at the Vatican website. The pope claims to be Christ on earth and the website tells you it is evident in that we follow the change. It is easily looked up. The pope made the change.

@@kac0404 lol I see you still are twisting scripture:)

@@kac0404 Now I know you have no clue what you are talking about for if you study the history of the Church you would learn that the first Pope actually was Constantine who placed himself above the Church and all the bishops. Peter was the head bishop in his time up until he was crucified. And if you took the time to research it you would see that when Constantine made the law that all would work Saturday and take Sunday to rest it was the church bishops that went along with it and stated that Christians will not Judaize Christianity. As Daniel prophesized man would change law and time and Paul stated man would place themselves equal to or above God. Give it a rest for scriptures also says in Proverbs to not be a foolish person.

So the question must be asked did you did you love your neighbour as your sel?f

@@Elizabeth-rk3do Jesus said not a jot or a tittle of the commandments will change till heaven and earth pass away. The Sabbath was instituted in Genesis when God created all things In six days and rested on the seventh day, “The Sabbath” God hollowed the sabbath day. The only law we are no longer under is the ceremonial law since Jesus was the sacrificial lamb In our place. God Bless, I hope you will continue to study.

@@kac0404 There are two laws, the ceremonial law regarding the Sanctuary., and the Mosaic law, the Ten Commandments. When Jesus died on the cross for our sins, the ceremonial laws were null and void. He was our sacrifice. Jesus said if you love me, keep my commandments. He also said heaven and earth will pass away but the law will not. He said if you love me, keep my commandments. He said I new not sin but by the law. God Bless You

@@catholic4sure976 JESUS SAID “ If you love me, keep my commandments “ I love Jesus.

@@kac0404 What's is sin? Sin is the transgression of the law. 1John.3:4. But sin is not imputed when there is no law. Romans 5:13. If there's no law before Moses, How can adultery be a sin? Romans 5:14. said; Nevertheless death reigned from Adam to Moses, How that's death came, what brought death to this world? SIN, that's mean that's the law have to exist before Moses. Romans 5:12, Romans.4:15. Mark.2:27,28. And he said unto them, The Sabbath was made for man, and not man for the Sabbath; Therefore the Son of man is Lord also of the Sabbath.

@@kac0404 The Mosaic law came to be, because of sin. The law of God was before sin.

Why did the apostal meet on the first day of the week? That would be Sunday

@@bobmiller1615 To avoid being persecuted in those days it was bad for Jews to follow another belief. Example is Saul before he talked to Jesus on the road to Damascus. What was he doing? Hunting Jews that converted to Christianity!

It is so nice. I'm hearing this right now about the Sabbath. but I also often have to work on Saturdays. Of course, if everybody would do this there wouldn't be people who also need help on Saturday. What can we do?

All we can do as parents Allen is pray that the Holy One will speak to them and they will listen....keep praying!

What a blessing Ellen! Praise Yah for revealing these gems to you. We pray that the time will come when every believer will recognize this truth. Meanwhile, we do our best to share it with those around us, sowing seeds that God will bring to fruition. Shalom! -Vivi

It's a lie Ofelina....Here's a good explanation...ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-98hq1AGzkR8.html

You mean Bless, Pastor Jim 😊

Thank you for sharing this with me. Much love always ❤🫂🙏🏼

Hi Jim, I'm Tom. I don't understand. I love you guys. But I'm worried for you. Here was my reply. Mr. Jim Staley says at aprox 5:30 mins in: "Did you know that even the Gentiles are expected to keep the sabbath in the NT..." No, I didn't know that. Where? Thats not in Acts 15:21. Acts 15:21 the subject of the sentence is "Moses." The action part of the sentence is "has had throughout many generations preach him (Moses) in every city" ... so, I would paraphrase that verse to say: Moses, (subject) has had the "law of Moses" preached in every city, by being read in the synagogues every Sabbath." ... ? ... Where is the word for Gentiles in that verse? The old covenant law was only for the Jews and those living with them (2Chr 6:11 the LORD made the Covenant with the Children of Israel, Not the World, or in Deut 5:3 Only those "here" at Mt Horeb). So, when it was preached, it was not for Gentile believers not living with the Jews. (Ninevites in the book of Jonah for example ) Imagine if the commandment, not to build a fire on the Sabbath, was given to the Eskimos?) And since it is making a statement on what HAS happened in the past; where does it say it's for Gentiles in the New Covenant (NC)? If someone makes the Statement: "Hitler taught that killing the Jews was the will of God." Are they agree or disagreeing with Hitler? It doesn't say. ... Its just stating a fact. Hitler taught... Same with Acts 15:21. It says nothing except that, Moses had the Law of Moses taught in Synagogues on the Sabbath. You are Extrapolating the text. You are telling New Covenant gentile Christians that they are expected to keep the Sabbath. My dear friend, for your own wellbeing, ... You better be careful to be standing on the WORD of GOD, not your own private interpretation of a verse that you have add content to, to get it to say what you want it to say. Where in the Bible are NC gentile Christians expected to keep the Sabbath, like you said? ... If not, my dear friend, you are violating Deut 4:2 and Rev 22:19. Acts Chapter 15 plainly instructs NC Christians that Circumcision is not required (the sign of the Abrahamic Covenant), and only the four listed things are brought into the NC. Galatians chapter 4 plainly says the "Mount Sini Covenant" ... and to "Cast out" the Mount Sini Covenant.

Amen! thank you for sharing. Very well said.

You are very welcome!

Your emotions deceive you. The Sabbath is a sign between God and His people. And, make no mistake about it, the Most High expects you to keep it. That is, if you belong to Him. _Ezekiel 20:20 HCSB Keep My Sabbaths holy, and they will be a sign between Me and you, so you may know that I am the LORD your God._

⁠@@sourmilkministries9445 I’m not a Jew. And I’m not in the old covenant. show me in NT scripture where it’s says i should keep the sabbath? Then I will believe that I’m deceived. Till that you trying to deceive me by putting burden on me.

​@@suganemmenaul You said at least four things that are wrong: 1.) The Sabbath is not for Jews. It's for EVERYONE who's in Covenant with God, including you! Isaiah 56:6-7 NKJV "Also the sons of the foreigner (NON-JEWS) Who join themselves to the LORD, to serve Him, And to love the name of the LORD, to be His servants- 👉Everyone who keeps from defiling the Sabbath,👈 And holds fast My covenant- (7) Even them I will bring to My holy mountain, And make them joyful in My house of prayer. Their burnt offerings and their sacrifices Will be accepted on My altar; For My house shall be called a house of prayer for all nations." 2.) You're right, you're not under the Old Covenant, you're under the New Covenant, which means that Yah's Laws (His Torah) is written in your mind and on your heart. So then, how is it that you suppose that the Torah doesn't include the Sabbath? Particularly so when you consider that the Sabbath is one of the TEN Commandments, NINE of which you keep! Thus, your "I’m not in the old covenant" contention is 90% self-defeating right from the very start, at least as far as the Sabbath is concerned! Hebrews 8:10 NRSV This is the [New] covenant that I will make with the house of Israel after those days, says the Lord: I will put my laws [Torah] in their minds, and write them on their hearts, and I will be their God, and they shall be my people. (And, oh, BTW: If you're in Christ then YOU are Israel. I can prove that too!) 3.) Why do you suppose that any particular Commandment has to be explicitly repeated in the New Testament in order to be valid? Where do the Scriptures tell you that? Nonetheless, let say for the sake of argument that the Sabbath Commandment isn't explicitly repeated, because it's actually not. But, then again, keep in mind that neither is the Commandment to not have sex with animals. So, do you really want to go there? Moreover, the fact of the matter is that NONE of the first four Commandments (of the TEN) are explicitly repeated. So, do you think that you can also have other Gods? Make idols? Or use the Lord's Name in vain? Of course, not! 4.) The Scriptures say that Yah's Commandments are not a burden. Though, it would seem that you currently think otherwise. I said "currently" because hopefully you are a truth seeker, which would mean that you would welcome sound correction. I guess we'll see. 1 John 5:3 NKJV For this is the love of God, that we keep His commandments. And 👉His commandments are not burdensome.👈 Mark 2:27 NKJV And He said to them, "The Sabbath was made 👉for man👈, and not man for the Sabbath. Isaiah 58:13 NKJV "If you turn away your foot from the Sabbath, From doing your pleasure on My holy day, 👉And call the Sabbath a delight,👈 The holy day of the LORD honorable, And shall honor Him, not doing your own ways, Nor finding your own pleasure, Nor speaking your own words, Shalom

​@@suganemmenaul _"I’m not a Jew."_ What does that have to do with the Sabbath? Are you suggesting that the Sabbath is only for "Jews". If so, then you are mistaken: Isaiah 56:6-7 NKJV "Also the sons of the foreigner Who join themselves to the LORD, to serve Him, And to love the name of the LORD, to be His servants- 👉Everyone who keeps from defiling the Sabbath👈, And holds fast My covenant- (7) Even them I will bring to My holy mountain, And make them joyful in My house of prayer. Their burnt offerings and their sacrifices Will be accepted on My altar; For My house shall be called a house of prayer for all nations." The Sabbath is for anyone in Covenant with the Most High. _"And I’m not in the old covenant."_ Of course you're not under the Old Covenant, and nether am I. But, again, what does that have to do with the Sabbath? Being under the Law of Christ (AKA: The New Covenant) simply means that God's Laws (His Torah) is written in your mind and on your heart. So then, just why do you suppose that the Sabbath is not one of those Laws? Particularly in light of the fact that it's one of the TEN Commandments, NINE of which you keep! _"show me in NT scripture where it’s says i should keep the sabbath?_ Are you suggesting that a Commandment of God must be specifically reiterated in the NT to be valid? Where do the Scriptures say any such thing? They don't, because that's not true. And, mind you, this Commandment is also not specifically reiterated in the NT: Leviticus 18:23 NKJV Nor shall you mate with any animal, to defile yourself with it. Nor shall any woman stand before an animal to mate with it. It is perversion. Surely, you're not going to suggest that we can that, are you? _"Till that you trying to deceive me by putting burden on me."_ 1 John 5:3 NKJV For this is the love of God, that we keep His commandments. And His commandments are not burdensome.

Yes you can rest any day you want, but still there's only 1 day He set apart, only 1 day He made Holy and that's the SABBATH day. It's a test whether you obey Him or not not. ITS UP YOU.. be bless my sister.

There are 7 Festivals/Feast that the bible commands us to observe . Within those Feast some days are considered High Holy days. On those days we are to follow the same rules as for Sabbath

Great questions. From my experience most folks are not interested in changing what they grew up knowing and hearing and practicing especially when faced with facts to prove they were "wrong".... Pride I think was one of the first sins.

@@clasreid2571 amen thank you for your comment you make a great point. Yeah I see you also wonder how in the heck can’t they not know just by the scripture alone then not be convicted and lead by the spirit? Yeah it continues to cause complexities in my own thoughts how can they be so right about so much but wrong about the sabbath day knowing? Then I think maybe I’m wrong but I look for it in scripture and I can’t find it? Ok brother appreciate you peace to yoi

Great Question! So let me answer you this way. Did you know there are over 45000 different religions in Christianity? Yet there is only one Word of God! Each one has there own church doctrine. Why is that when there is only one Word? Study the history of the church and you will find a lot of changes man has done. You will also find that millions over the ages were persecuted if they spoke up and disagreed with the church.

Are you suggesting that Exodus 16:29 forbids us from leaving our houses in general? If so, then that's simply not the case. The context is clearly that of not leaving your house in the search of Manna. If not, then I'm not exactly sure what you mean.

Glad it was helpful!

So how are you suppose to keep a job, if the sabbath changes all the time? Like, I'm just going to randomly not come in every week or every other month on different days?? I can't find a good job as it is that won't have me work on Sat. God help me, I'm so sick of the confusion.

GODS calender never changes, it is the same today as it was at the time of creation , GOD bless

The months revolve around the lunar cycle. The weekly Sabbath does not move.

​@@shellyvandyke7362The 7 day cycle was given by God, ordained independent of the lunar and solar cycles. Don't despair, keep the 7th day Sabbath with confidence. If there was any error, Yahshua would have corrected it while He was here. He didn't.

@@shellyvandyke7362 follow the world or follow God your choice but there are plenty of examples of this in scripture.