the REAL reason why JVKE says you can't play "GOLDEN HOUR" on piano... 

this is NOT jvcxb 😭

my sense exactly... no rocket science, and the kid should move on, show us something else than this song

*intentionally

@vanta ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-QgtzOafdoOQ.html

and bon iver

r/angryupvote take it you bastard

😂😂

Fuck, that was a good one LMFAO

He can but in cmajor key haha😂

@@Punch_is_thinking haha I found that out after this I already posted this comment

At least he sing ulike ur useless mouth

​@@Punch_is_thinking he can but not in the exact key

Btw there's a piano where u can pitch a the keys

I so much agree, my friend introduced me to it and I can’t unhear them. I have always loved dissonance as well and it’s beautiful.

id recommend Sevish and Skueue. they are amazing with micro tonal/Xenharmonic music. ive used ideas like that in some of my own works like using 53 edo for a song and i just performed a song in 19 edo for my music theory final the other day. micro tones are so cool but sadly are a bit harder to get a hold of to perform with without a interment. Ableton has a microtuner on their software or if you don't have ableton you have use a vst called simplemicrotonalsampler and that has so many different tuning systems. also just someting imma say cuz i get annoyed and small stuff like this. this is just a micro tuned song not a microtonal song since it still have 12 notes in 12et just moved down a few sense. hoped you found this interesting to read

it sounds very different

king gizz

I love the other emotions the micro-tuned music can create, but I never considered it unpleasant to listen to or dissonant. A great example of this is, “Everybody Wants to Rule the World” by Tears for Fears which is tuned slightly sharp. While the original key does a lot for the emotions that the song evokes, the microtonality of the song provides more intrigue and feeling. I never once thought it to be dissonant though lol.

Exactly right. I think a lot more people use microtones and keys without even realizing it especially when using some tape emulators or varispeed in logic. But you absolutely right. JVKE is actually a genius at social media and marketing and wouldn’t be surprised if this was planned to get people talking. His strategy to get his music out is really smart and I am noticing more artist have similar marketing strategies

Facts Glad someone Said it.

Sam, if some guy plays it on the piano tuned to 440, most people won't be able to tell the difference without the contrast of the original song playing along side it.

@@mikeekim242 i know

It's not valid. The song is really generic, simple and shallow.

I mean this won't work for every piano lol. But I would guess that strings almost always get looser when out of tune so it might be right at that 8 hz down

but then every single key has to be perfectly out of tune. it has to be out of tune in a specific way

Just another narcissistic creator.

@@CosmicApe bruh look at his collaboration list 🙇‍♂️ don't just post a comment without actually knowing

@@CosmicApesipping on that haterade

@@CosmicApe I think if you don't market your music hard it'll be even harder to get big

Milking that ass song for the white people

Fr

it is fucking good as fuck tho lets be real

@@m1rac1e no, it's an above average singer songwriter song i could think of like 200 songs in this genre off the top of my head that are better

​@le4che henry please do share some, I would like to explore more

😂😂😂

He's an industry plant anyways lol

He really needs new music. Artists generally release new music every few or so months and he should've had a new title track by now.

artists who make it big need to milk. that's why drake became such a phenomenon, then the weeknd after, they milk the same song over and over until it runs dry because it's something they know works, and the bigger the spectacle behind a song, the more people will remember it. It's efficient marketing even though it's annoying.

Gonna be like cilene dions ‘my heart will go on’ its gonna ‘sink’

If it wasn't for all of those shorts that he did, I wouldn't have heard Golden Hour because I gave up on current music a long time ago. I have been listening to all of his released music and I really like his recent album. Regarding his being active for a decade prior to Golden Hour, he's only 21 so that would mean he was active when he was about 11 years old? I don't think he was songwriting at that time. Also, his being active 10 years ago, where exactly? TikTok was created around 2017 or about 6 years ago so he couldn't have been active there a decade ago.

I'm glad more musicians can exploit their songs because the music industry can be ruthless. Songs are products that need to be sold, so these recording artists promote and market their products to potential listeners, licensees (record labels & music publishers) & synchronisation execs/producers (TV & Film) to maximise profit. Good on him and his team.

Oh I've seen keyboard with those. You could theoretically play any microtonal changes.

Average human can do

This is a video about golden hour and jvke, sir

Jacob would agree with Jvke, when you move away from A440 by a number of cents, it evokes a different emotion. My response was to the commentator at around 1:00

it's not possible by only a few cents it's like you can tell the difference between 60fps and 63fps functionally it's the same

@@JinnyWin5 I can tell the difference between about 5 fps because I used to troubleshoot GPUs all the time. Some people are just more sensitive to things than others, just because you can’t doesn’t mean it’s impossible.

Which part.?

me lying on the internet

Good work with the comment shadowkiller123.

How is that cheating? C Major is one of the hardest keys to play in

jea hes a complete rat like most of those tiktok "artists"

No hate towards him. Pretty white boi that can sing and play piano. It's obvious he is industry promoted.

Why exactly is being a plant a bad thing? It’s no different than your favorite rapper lying about a certain lifestyle to garner attention and views… it’s the music business a profit needs to be turned and an investment must be recuperated. We all do it when we sign. Get used to it or don’t pay attention either way the machine will keep running.

I heard that too lmaoooo

Thank you 🙏

Black midi composers foubd a way to do it anyways.

Don't worry, he basically said it himself in a comment to a video that he's too busy to actually learn the piano cuz he's writing new music LOL

More like he plays in C so he avoids hitting the black keys ... making the piano do the work of transposing it to the key we hear... He's a phony lol.

@@Nimoot it's out of topic, but i am tempted just to say lol

u can actually play golden hour on the piano just a different key :> not the original pitch tho

@@Nimoot I'd argue transposing a piano isn't inherently a bad thing, not all songwriters need to necessarily be good pianists. It is a little annoying how stuck up he seems about the whole thing though Also the fact that the audio in all of his "piano teacher reacts to my song" videos is the song audio rather than his actual playing is really misleading and stupid

Every video that he milks about Golden Hour is just the original audio playing in the background.

its just technical ability, and not really fair to compare la campanella to golden hour howeverrr i agree with you

mate you didnt finish the video?

Makes it feel old fashioned

yeah

So, c major isn’t a key?

@@Eatencaviar c is the key, major is the scale

So, is C major a key?

He does lol.

I would argue that modes would resemble different emotions more than key sigantures, but even then it can be subjective. Thats why in written music you would get performance directions telling you the mood of a piece for interpretation purposes. Tempo could also be relevant to emotions as well but its also not one size fits all. Slow tempo could help convey sadness in a piece, but you could make a piece thats slow and also happy. And then when you add lyrics theres a lot more context involved.

@@kyleharris2980 I do agree with you and I'm not arguing the emotional effect of modes, tempo etc. But my point was that purely transposing a key does not change anything for me. So all keys played the exact same, relative to each other, doesn't have any effect on me other than 'oh... This sounds different'.

@@guycollishaw1957 same tbh, i like use the transpose button a lot cause im curious to hear what the piece sounds like. I mean to me its just like a different flavour

Exactely, the emotions that arise from the music are all in funcional harmony/modulations. If i transpose a piece a semitone up its gonna give me the same feeling. One thing that needs to be said is that the instrument's timbre changes if you change octave, so it's not JUST about playability.

@@iCrimsonKing true, like you could make an argument that some sort of emotion is being convoyed if you are changing key signatures. But if the whole piece is just in one key then its just really a preference of the composer. And sometimes also the limitations of what instruments are being used.

In case someone is wondering what the fuck I'm talking about. Our 12 tone system is built around 12 fifths being the same interval as 7 octaves. Sadly they are off by around 23 cents. On keyed instruments the solution is to just spread the error over every interval so normal people can't hear that something is off. On stringed Instruments like the violin this would be extremely difficult to pull off, so what we do instead is just play all the important intervals perfectly and then move the error along until we find a place where we can get rid of it, that sounds better anyway. (no it's not really a conscious process, it's just the result of fixing whatever intonation mistakes you can hear and getting better at hearing them etc.)

I was thinking the same thing, like it sounds so cryptic but really its as simple as shifting the frequency of the final track those 30 whatever cents and it'll be the same result lmao

I agree that JVKE is a lying marketing clown, but the song's pitch is lowered, not raised