The REAL Secret of the In Between.... | Tales From The SMP Theory 

I just wanna say you're vastly underrated in the community, these videos are god-tier.

I was the 101th person to like

Bruh, Look at Ramboo skin then look at the castle

I think you have been grasping at straws 90% of the video Exhibit A:you assume it’s the egg because of “nether” and don’t point out at the start anything else besides that it’s red and black ignoring the flowers also the blue is supposed to take away sadness because it was incited in a clip (that I do not have but search it up) Exhibit B:you say Karl’s signature color is purple and ignore the green and say purple is time travel and you say that the nether portal THE FUCKING NETHER PORTAL is connected with the story bruh I just can’t also in the same after the tales that the Karl’s have been in the in between for to long you say dream put a manifestation of himself in Ranboos head when it was confirmed that it’s his conscience by the voice or it’s the other side of him dream had never had god power over Ranboo he never had that kind of power it was just him simply being friends with ranboo’s other half I would say more but I put no commas in it and pretty much was me ranting.

Otherwise decent video

Same

I think everyone does

Same

thats crazy, when I think purple i think purple too!!! lmao

Big Bain

@Akshita Nerkar yes, if he ever does get more lore then being a capitalist hitman I do hope that Dream isnt involved because istg if every minor gets traumatized by the blob- well it will be interesting but still we got to have someone who is normal

Cool idea! I could see this coming tru

YO I NEED THIS PURPLED LORE IN THE WORLD???

nice idea the only problem is that he built his spaceship way before the inbetween and tales of the smp existed but i still think this idea is pog

@@PNP-pi8ip that's not really a problem the entire story of tales of the smp is literally time travel

@MillerTheTaco been sittin' here since July my man. Life was simpler then.

I’ve been just checking in occasionally for a good bit. Sometimes I watch streams, usually I watch vods or videos covering the streams.

I do I was watching live on the first stream of the Dream SMP when it was just George and Dream

@@randovilclip as one would say *ahem* “sheeeeeeeeesh”

I do😂

Yes we can

you can thank Plutoren for that he's/she's (don't know his/her gender) the builder or the main builder of the tales you can see him/her at the end credits

Yes we can

no

ikr they’re amazing

seconded!!

That makes sense

There would be a reason why they want Karl to stay then

This might have to do with the egg in Karl’s time line where the egg is controlling bbh

By that I mean like in every good there is evil that evil in good is the egg in controlling bbh and other ppl

nice

Great theory..👍🏻👍🏻

mine theory noice

oo

Anyone forgetting DreamXD?

correct,the other side is a collective entity meanwhite the inbetween is a being of eternal μ3|/

GOOD IDEA the other side sends the eggs out to scout,push things in the right direction

What if the in between is destroying the other side and the eggs are sent to make more other sides so the other side can still exist?

Mind: blown

The entity that controls the other side is a bird/lizard and the eggs are it's kids and scouts

Honestly I kinda think the lands are cursed, that when you step foot on it, you just forget about your past. I mean, have you seen that one video where Foolish actually had some relation to Eret, and Foolish brought up something they did together in the past, but Eret doesn't remember it....

Doesn't matter ghostbur the only one out of the 3 with memorie problem and cant be effected by the egg, well and tommy but he doesn't have memory problem

She hit her head when her ship crashed that's her reason

@@dargonlord8362 canon?

@@nightlypiano4116 yep

Maybe it's supposed to symbolize The in between looks Calm and peaceful but is actually dark and evil

Also Ranboo has memory loss and doesn’t know his origin And Time traveling On dream smp is shown to cause memory loss Or if you want to put it with this theory the inbeetween causes memory loss when it steals your power

@@BetterNicholas that too and whats the deal with Ran anyway and ranbutler

@@BetterNicholas Wait that could mean that maybe ranboo was/is a time traveler but the inbetween made him lose all of his memories, but instead of dying or becoming a “clone” he survived (Maybe because he is half enderman and not fully human) and in the lost city of mizu the evil person was like a future mix of dream and ranboo....

I just came up with this theory Basically Ranboo was a time traveler who was full Enderman Who went to the inbeetween he winded up escaping out his power was partially drained and his memories gone he escaped to the main dream smp Were he would be left memory less The black part of Ranboo is the Part that we see from the perspective of He experiences his Enderwalks which are when the part him that’s power has been drained or the white part Takes control He walks around aimlessly like the Karl’s lost in the inbetween and is easily manipulated what’s to say the Karl’s lost in the inbetween aren’t also easily manipulated both and that’s it

Well who knows maybe they are right or they are wrong :)

purpeled isnt a very big character ... but karl wasnt before tales of the smp too

I think I started that. My point wasn’t about Purpled being part of the lore, it was more about Purpled having represented the color purple long before Karl did. And before you say that doesn’t have anything to do with lore, I will say that the lore was created by the members of the Dream SMP. If they wanted a color the represent Karl/time travel, they could have picked a different color. Maybe Purpled is connected to time travel, maybe he isn’t. Only time will tell.

he's been getting more into lore now but a person can hope

@@KittyandLychee carl's been all about purple since before he even joined dreamsmp I dont think they made him purple just for the lore

Or or just a theory the person who is sending the books to karl is timetraveling tommy just think about it it would be sick because idrk

@@pinky_xen lol imagine tho and he recruits normal Tommy

10 months from then, we got to know it's jack manifold (or maybe some other character played by him)

So :] is bad but :) is good?

@@ZefpyhrI'm sure :) is also bad

@@Zefpyhr yeah :) triggers ranboo's enderwalk. (: is also bad i guess, people use it instead of :) because on twitch it turns into the stupid white face thing

@@impossible9690 yeah its so freaking annoying

So it could be dream, ranboo (in his enderwalk state) or quackity

under the tree is purple flowers ... idk if that means something but its there

Thank you sir!

Ty

If you want, you can try and find more evidence and make it a video, just credit me in it

I don’t get this

@@Aurraislame it can be hard to understand, but I kinda makes sense

It literally is based off of nothing dream doesn’t torment Ranboo also dreamXD isnt majorly canon because he just is dream trying to in force rules

@@Aurraislame well dream does torment Ranboo in the way that he speaks to him in his head, and while DreamXD had never been said to be canon, they also never said he's not canon (dumb I know but still)

*im gonna have fun reading this*

@@DeadBushRonnie lol

*I MISREAD FRUITBERRIES AS FURBYS AND I CANT GET THAT IMAGE OUT OF MY HEAD NOW*

@@waterbelow0degrees LOL

Ok this is part 2 to my theory: i actually have more evidence!!! Ok so dream smp season 3 is basically tales from the smp except all the stories take place in present day and give the focus character of that episode character development and a chance to be the main character. You've got Tommy and dream, Sam and puffy vs the eggpire, Ranboo, tales of the smp, las navadas, and Fundy's nightmare. I'm honestly suprised that my dreamon theory is still plausible. Ok so I'll explain how all of these plots are relevant and how they all fit into my theory. Tommy was stuck in prison with a possible dreamon descendant aka dream which is the obvious one. Sam and Puffy fighting the eggpire is them fighting the egg which was also obvious. Now the Ranboo thing is also obvious but it's really interesting.... So the dreamon in his plot is obviously the enderwalker aka his sleep walk mode which *posses* him like the egg does to it's followers. Also i think i have a out there theory on why the ender walk state has the same voice as dream. I think the enderwalker dreamon is the same dreamon that possed dream back when the dreamon hunters were formed. And then when they did the ritual and banished it, it was gone for a while but it latched onto Ranboo. And since dream was the last person it latched onto, that's the voice it communicates with. Tales of the smp i mainly went over in part one but basically the keepers of the in between are just like the enderwalker dreamon where it's a super natural being that causes people to lose their memory and is associated with a smiley face. And the other side is probably the birth place/original home of the egg and maybe other dreamons as well. Now las navadas is a bit tricky it's the only one i haven't really figured out yet. It was implied in chapter one that bbh and big q may have a rivalry in the fiture which would make the las Navadas plot nicely connected to the egg but i honestly don't have much else. And last but not least Fundy's nightmare. This one is both obvious but also kinda weird because of how new it is so I'll probably look over it again. Just like karl with the in between, Fundy is sent to a place out of this reality that sends him on an easter egg hunt that leads him to mysterious books written by an alternate versions of themselves and just like karl with the in between, whenever Fundy searches for more knowledge than the place wants him to find, an evil entity chaces him. And obviously it ended with ANOTHER SMILEY FACE that looks like the one on quackity's skin hmm.... maybe there's a connection there... anyways i think it's cool that when u step back and really take in all the similarities of these very different storylines, it's really amazing how well they fit together. Also i want to establish the difference between spirits and dreamons to set up a fun theory llike the fruitberries one. Ok so dreamons aren't affected by sunlight or the surface like spirits such as a *G L A T T* are. Also i think that ghostbur can survive on land because of his blue i mean we've already established that blue is an object that comes from dreamons. Maybe dreamons bleed blue and that's why they aren't affected by the surface. Because the antidote is literally in their bloodstream. Anyway the other difference between spirits and dreamons are that spirit are dead players and dreamons are characters. Ok so my fun little theory is that Mexican dream is a good dreamon. He's a entity that somehow can traverse the surface in order to reach *G L A T T's* gym without blue, you could also say that he possesses quackity and that's why big q doesn't canonically know about him and also he's associated with a smiley face and is a made up character and isn't an actual version of quackity or a reincarnated/undead ghost version of another character. Anyways that's all I've got. sorry for the long comments 😅

That is so cool, it makes me feel like I’m more part of the lore

we are the inbetweeners.

Now I feel part of the story

I am now a time traveller. Cool

THAT SOUNDS SO COOL

Bruhhhh

So you say....

Totally not suspicious

Wow XD

Yeppo

Yin-Yang momento

I lost my shit at that part, i was shocked I had to run to the comments

:]

@@Snukkuri :]

I am amazed how humans just design the responsible for one place and another.

Wasn’t it a white blob tho?

That my theory

Prolly neutral

It is a seal ok tru

@@VietNguyen-ye4xb i think it’s bad judging off the red banquet-

I'd go with Evil towards opposers, but benevolent (50/50 on this) by the standards of Regis video. But I'm just ayakng

Just get twitch and wacth the vods or if you can’t find them just look them up on RU-vid

Go onto quackinnit playlist

He has to be because there is a murders ranboo like character almost every tale so what if ranboo is a murderer and is hiding it to gain people's trust

@@pinky_xen Good theory, but that doesn't prove that Ranboo is connected to time travelling.

@@hi-oc2su it most likely does tbh cuz lost city of mizus ranboo is just dream haveing full control of ranboo I think

AGREED

@@lartts7483 THANK YOU! Sorry, just have some pent-up frustration with theories that rely on HUUUUGE stretches just to make sense. I went a little crazy with this one as you can tell! XD

I might have to re-watch the video to make sure, but I don't think he said that the "Inbetweners" WERE Dream. He said that they were demigod-like persons LIKE Dream. Similar abilities, maybe due to their origins, but the Inbetweeners are NOT Dream. Ani was talking about power levels in the sentence prior, and used Dream as a comparison to show how much power the Inbetweeners might have. I think the reason why the smiley faces are different is to make sure there no mix up. I was also skeptical after the first time the Inbetweeners used a smiley, but they use brackets instead of parentheses when talking to Karl to avoid confusion. Everyone in the DSMP fandom knows how integral the smile symbol is to Dream and his brand, so they had to do SOMETHING different in order to still get a smiley face on that page without accidently saying that this is Dream talking. From what we've seen, the " :) " is basically Dreams signature now. Karl wouldn't be confused as to who's speaking to him if that symbol were there. Because Karl didn't react, I think it's safe to assume that the difference in symbols is big when it comes to smiles in the SMP. Sorry I went on such a rant in regards to your FIRST point. I did end up reading the rest, I promise. Semantics are a big deal to me, and it shows. Overall, I can agree with your points, but I can also see how Ani came to his conclusions. It's like an episode of Game Theory. In order for a theory to work, you have to ignore some aspects of canon, or you'll never post any content. Theorist are typically well aware when they are making leaps in logic, or leaving things out to make a timeline coherent. If they're not aware, there are always kind folk like you there to bring it to their attention. I'm a big fan of fantheories, and I've typed too much already. Bye bye!

@@sicilyfranklin3157 But he called Dream a demigod. That is what I was debunking. I know he didn't say that the in-betweeners were demigods. I know that is what I was saying. Ani tried to make a connection between the smile from the in-between and Dream that wasn't supposed to be there. Yeah and I love to go through a friendly civil back-and-forth with theories! It's half the fun to me! So your response makes this more fun! :D

@@Starpublic94 YAY! Someone else who speaks in paragraphs!! I guess my only response to this reply would be that, based on what Ani has seen of Dream's character, it could be that his head canon is that Dream is a demigod. Depending on how you look at the Dream SMP and it characters, there are many who would agree with the sentiment. Whereas some see Dream as a power hungry teletubby with a god complex, the mystery behind his actions give credence to the idea that there is something "more" about him. His status as creator and admin of the SMP, along with the emergence of the "DreamXD" character, no mater it's real world explanation, fuels that belief. You won't believe how many fanfics there are with this head canon at the center. If Ani is using this POV as a starting point in regards to Dream character, you can see how he would come to such conclusions.

woah

Ikr

And he seems like the type to want all the variables like in a casino

LMAO

DreamXD is a god

Karl is alive and fine, he’s shown up in other lore and helped Tommy kill the withers after the main takeover

@@thatoneguyontheinternet4639 it all seems a little convenient though. Techno kills Karl 3 times in the war, makes plans to rebuild L’Manberg and then doesn’t show up again. We know from deaths like Jack Manifold that sometimes the 3 canon deaths aren’t instant as he still had time to walk the prime path before going to hell and telling Satan “no I’m Jack Manifold I’m gonna live”.

@@Josh-wj7jj and why wilbur got to the recreation of the van before he ended stream (wilbur as in alivebur)

@@Josh-wj7jj If all of Techno's kills were canon, everyone would have one life or be dead, it was also around this time when Karl started to get more involved with lore, so I don't think he would want to be dead. Also, tommy just visited Kimiko kingdom, and Nihachu and many other members have namedropped it (Kimiko kingdom is the city founded by Karl)

Or maybe the egg does does not have a strong connection to this and just happend to land near al, the stories maybe it’s like attracted to the power that clearly comes from time travel?

Pls credit me if you are doing a video about this :)

I know it’s a veeeery long shot, but maybe?

And Quackity also probably has inhuman powers, like when he went inside Fundy’s head, as seen in a previous video of yours.