@@user-ys7kl1kt1lbro in Norway the apples fall from trees and ferment! The moose eats those apples and gets drunk and attacks cars! Those apples are also naturally alcoholic! Would you say that’s halal as well?
This is so stupid. Alcohol is haram because of the intoxicating and addictive effects. Non-alcoholic beer has too low alcoholic percentage to be intoxicating or addictive.
@@alamk716 It creates a logical problem. This way people can mix 0.5 % v/v solutions of vodka with water and call it halal vodka. Doesn't make sense. Haram in large amounts is also haram in diluted form (small amounts). "Whatever causes intoxication in large amounts is also prohibited in small amounts." ~ Prophet Muhammad SAW
I guess wheat n barley are fruit drinks for u 🥴 🥴🥴😵💫😵💫🤡🤡 banana n orange also have a small amount of alcohol ranging from 0.77 to 0.05 So I guess fruits are haram as well Learn how to read @@redlionesv
If it’s Heineken, it would still be forbidden, as it promotes the use of their alcoholic version of same brand. I would say, Athletic Brews would be better choice because they only deal in AF brews
Smh the point is that if it’s intoxicating in large amounts then it is prohibited in small amounts. If you think something is true and it sounds silly then it probably isn’t true
@@salihazim1"If it is intoxocating in large amounts then prohibited in small amounts'- Drinking 6 non alcoholic beers would still not make you intoxicant.
Before pasteurization all fruit juice had alcohol. In the Greek language, oinos is the word used for fruit juice or fermented juice. The best wine was the freshest wine. It was written in Hebrew text that the abuse of alcohol was wrong but that consuming it was permitted. The only people that alcohol was forbidden was priests while on duty and kings. The prohibition by Islam is not founded in mosaic law and remains as antithetical to an Abraham's faith as its mock prophet.
What about orange juice or Kombucha - same amount of alcohol. Ripe banana's and bread contain alcohol as well. Some sourdoughs are over 1% Alcohol by volume. Are those not allowed?
@@sibtainansari2525 i am not sure about that because prophet Muhammad (saw) said something that can intoxicate. I don't think that little amount is intoxicating (I am not sure)
@@salmannizar7571problem is it starts with little and then gets out of control. It was allowed earlier in Islam but people couldnt control the quantity and then it was fully banned
Non alcoholic beer is made without fermentation process through which sugar and yeast produce alcohol,but yeast is not used in no alcoholic beer ,it can't contain alcohol.
By these metrics a very ripe banana or a slightly overripe fruit like a strawberry or a grape would be "sin". I am not trying to criticize but sometimes being too strict for something like these leads to logical fallacies and open flanks in the inconsistencies with the same logic in other fields.
No,first of all you should learn the types of alcohols ,you know most of the medicines are made of alcohol in an inevitable purpose,but who the hell told you that banana contains alcohol, I think you should spend more time in study than using phone brother😊
@@globalcomparisons1973 You can take medicines that contains a huge amount of alchohol, hence asking that is consuming banana haram,isn’t it ridiculous?
@@globalcomparisons1973 okay,brother if you are really curious to know it go to the mosqe nearby your house and ask the mufti/teacher about it cuz whimsically without knowing about the actual reason I can't tell you
Cough syrups have very low concentrations of alcohol ....if your juices sit for some time they start to ferment, making alcohol Your reasoning is OFF....
He didn't actually answer the question. He said there even though it's a very low amount, non alcoholic beer still contains alcohol. So is it allowed????????
Jesus said He would not drink with the desciples again until they were together in the Father's kingdom, not that Christians could never again drink alcohol on Earth.
Isnt the sahih ruling: anything that intoxicates and or harms the body, by that logic one should remove all of the “drugs” from ones regime, like sugar for instance…
I guess you are from India. You are talking like Indian Islamophobes. Answer me, If Saudi Arabians start pooping in the railway tracts should all Muslim do it?
Cooking various dishes can produce minute amounts of alcohol due to natural fermentation processes that occur when ingredients like fruits, vegetables, and grains undergo certain chemical reactions. For example, ripe fruits and some bread doughs can ferment slightly due to the natural yeasts present on their surfaces or in the environment, leading to the production of small amounts of alcohol. So brother zakir, Don't need anything.
.5% alcohol would take ten beers to get the same alcohol as 1 beer. With such a miniscule amount of alcohol I wouldnt think it shoupd matter if you have some.
In earlier days, Prophet Mohammad himself used have Wine. Nothing wrong if you drink in limit. There are many thing Haraam. Who follows… “Hangama hay kyu Barpa, Thori si jo pili hay. Daka to nahi dala, Chori to nahi ki hay”
Its still haram bcs of the *intention*, bcs one *want to enjoy the taste of khamr*.. naturally occuring akcohol in fruit were not meant to be intoxicating, not intended to be made to khamr and not made by the khamr industry and not contaminated by khamr..so its still allowed.. why is it so hard for people to understand the simplicity of this deen 😂
Telling people what to do is the Problem Not Alcohol. Only God can Judge. Serve God the way you feel is Right to you not serving a Religion so you can Reach God. Look at the Mess the World is in Right now Muslims and Jews Blood Fighting ,Killing One Another, Hindus abusing Christians in India. None Stop Killings over and over because of Different Beliefs/Religion. I say Skip Any Religion and live your Life One on One with God
