Тёмный
No video :(

The Smoking Ban | Yes, Prime Minister | Comedy Greats 

BBC Comedy Greats
Подписаться 707 тыс.
Просмотров 2,7 млн
50% 1

Hacker goes up against the tobacco lobby in an attempt to secure tax cuts from the treasury, but Sir Humphrey weighs up the moral argument against the financial incentive.
Subscribe: bit.ly/BBCComed...
WATCH MORE:
Yes, Prime Minister: bit.ly/CGYesPr...
Blackadder: bit.ly/ComedyGr...
Live at the Apollo: bit.ly/2L9SAuA
Fawlty Towers: bit.ly/2L9FRYH
Welcome to BBC Comedy Greats, home to the best comedy from the BBC! Whether you're a fan of the classics or if stand up comedy is more up your street then check out our hand picked playlists full of the funniest clips by the best performers. From Only Fools and Horses to Live at the Apollo we can guarantee plenty of awesome Comedy Greats.
Want to share your views with the team? Join our BBC Studios Voice: www.bbcstudios...
This is a commercial channel from BBC Studios. Service & Feedback www.bbcstudios...
#Comedy #YesPrimeMinister

Опубликовано:

 

26 авг 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 612   
@DarkPriestess1
@DarkPriestess1 2 года назад
"You can prove anything with statistics." "Even the truth."
@BradyPostma
@BradyPostma 2 года назад
I'm going to remember that line.
@muhammedcankucukaslan
@muhammedcankucukaslan 2 года назад
2:02 + "You can prove anything with statistics." - "Even the truth." + "No!"
@stevehendon4076
@stevehendon4076 2 года назад
I think 9 out of 10 people would agree and I'm 75% inclined to agree with you.
@hugohackenbush1554
@hugohackenbush1554 2 года назад
There are not enough superlatives to describe just how good the writing was for this magnificent series.
@TPRM1
@TPRM1 2 года назад
Can you save one superlative for the fact that this video is exactly 4:20 long...?
@hugohackenbush1554
@hugohackenbush1554 2 года назад
@@TPRM1 Absolutely. That's now become 'not enough + 1' 👌🏼
@michaellavery4899
@michaellavery4899 2 года назад
@@TPRM1 What is the significance of 4.20? Please elaborate. Edit. Is it related to cannabis day?
@TPRM1
@TPRM1 2 года назад
@@michaellavery4899 Correct.
@fariddennoun1715
@fariddennoun1715 2 года назад
And the ACTING
@rabgabro6595
@rabgabro6595 2 года назад
Brilliant and current. " your statistics are truths and my truths are merely statistics" Love it
@Konstantinos1648
@Konstantinos1648 2 года назад
Facts
@jornzwaagstra1150
@jornzwaagstra1150 2 года назад
@@Konstantinos1648 stats* :P
@JonatasAdoM
@JonatasAdoM 2 года назад
@Jorn Zwaagstra That's a statistic.
@fariddennoun1715
@fariddennoun1715 2 года назад
The one with Russia and the BOMB!, in the words of Mercury “send shivers to my spine “! 🤢😩😩😩🙄🪳
@french6013
@french6013 2 года назад
@@JonatasAdoM i rhink he meant the truths, which he says facts not truths
@nicholashylton6857
@nicholashylton6857 Год назад
_"Thank you very much for your cigarette paper... I mean, your paper on cigarettes."_ 🤣🤣
@billybobbins9416
@billybobbins9416 2 года назад
Yes Minister and Yes Prime Minister the most realistic, meaningful and accurate way to learn about politics and Government.
@Gastel
@Gastel 2 года назад
I'd agree, but it is far too intelligent for modern politics. To think a conversation like this would ever happen in modern day is, in my opinion, laughable.
@billybobbins9416
@billybobbins9416 2 года назад
@@Gastel Yes, you are right, my mistake. We all have our 'senior' moments every now and again !
@MultiVinniemac
@MultiVinniemac 2 года назад
That's cause these things happened
@marktaylor4962
@marktaylor4962 2 года назад
The Thick of It too
@muenchhausenmusic
@muenchhausenmusic 5 месяцев назад
@@Gastel It is also too intelligent for past politics, because it was written by genius writers (which is why it is so incredibly entertaining and illuminating ofc). Although I agree with you that we're currently in a populism crisis in politica and media, there's no way politicians and government talked like this in the 70s. Perhaps the top cleverest people...
@JamBar1873
@JamBar1873 2 года назад
This documentary series gets more relevant with every passing year.
@MrJustbrowsing12345
@MrJustbrowsing12345 2 года назад
Absolutely, people will never stand for a euro passport 🙄 the British people will never put up with showing their papers to get into a pub 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@rajc1382
@rajc1382 2 года назад
So right..
@amarjittalukdar1967
@amarjittalukdar1967 2 года назад
Especially in India
@andrewrobinson8305
@andrewrobinson8305 2 года назад
In what way? Be specific. How is it “more relevant” now than 5, 10, 20 years ago?
@dariomeneses5756
@dariomeneses5756 2 года назад
This is clearly a work of fiction. Just take into account how the Prime Minister is shown to be, in general, well meaning and moral.
@malcolmabram2957
@malcolmabram2957 2 года назад
I remember the 1996 statistics (okay a long time ago). It cost the NHS £965 million to treat smoking related illnesses. The tax on tobacco was about £4,500 million. That is before savings on state pension due to premature death.
@zarabada6125
@zarabada6125 2 года назад
Though that doesn't include loss of productivity in the economy related to smoking related illnesses or associated social care bills. As they say in the video, you can prove anything with statistics. It all depends on what you choose to leave in or out of your considerations.
@Bialy_1
@Bialy_1 2 года назад
​@@zarabada6125 You need to read it few times then maybe you will be able to accept the truth...
@zarabada6125
@zarabada6125 2 года назад
@@Bialy_1 I've read it, understood it and pointed out some of the factors that are missing. Is there any particular point you wish to make about the "truth" (whichever truth you intend to promote)?
@magnetospin
@magnetospin 2 года назад
That would only be a problem if people aren't going to spend their money on something else if they don't smoke. They will. Those £4,500 million will come back in some other avenue.
@Sunshine-zm1fx
@Sunshine-zm1fx 2 года назад
@@zarabada6125 Trolls gonna troll. Rock on with your bad self.
@aliali-ce3yf
@aliali-ce3yf 2 года назад
i just discovered this show for myself a few days ago and can't stop watching clips - this is better than any government class
@jayone8891
@jayone8891 2 года назад
Start with Yes, Minister the prequal series. It is a genius show all the way through. Both are excellent
@jayone8891
@jayone8891 2 года назад
Start with Yes, Minister the prequal series. It is a genius show all the way through. Both are excellent
@RhysOlwyn
@RhysOlwyn 2 года назад
@@jayone8891 And after you've finished Yes Minister & Yes Prime Minister, get stuck into The Thick Of It
@wisteela
@wisteela 2 года назад
@@RhysOlwyn I still need to watch that.
@apersonlikeanyother6895
@apersonlikeanyother6895 2 года назад
The one about national service and polling is one of the most important things I’ve ever learnt.
@mrjones29
@mrjones29 2 года назад
I grew up in the shadow of this British comedy great as a pre-teen in the early 1980s far too young to appreciate it's deliberate slow pacing, witty dialogue, dry humour complicated life as Westminster politics. Not when the zip bang action of the likes of Doctor Who, Buck Rogers and Dukes of Hazard TV shows were on. Never understood why my parents loved Yes Prime Minister until I was much older and life got serious and the cost of living on my own was very real. Then catching this legendary TV show on reruns and marveling at these great British actors at the top of their game reminding me that TV was best in the 1970s and 1980s by far.
@nicholashylton6857
@nicholashylton6857 2 года назад
We are kindred spirits of a sort.
@mrjones29
@mrjones29 2 года назад
@@nicholashylton6857 Cool 😎
@mauricebrocklehurst2358
@mauricebrocklehurst2358 2 года назад
Mr Jones where's Smith🤣 Yeah definitely 70s and 80s were the best i watched all the things you mentioned and loved it but the 90's were also 👌 great sorry about the joke 😐 but that's just my sense of humour.
@mrjones29
@mrjones29 2 года назад
@@mauricebrocklehurst2358 I get it lol. The 1990s tv was still good but by then it was dominated by all time great American tv shows that captured my appeal once I started college.
@mauricebrocklehurst2358
@mauricebrocklehurst2358 2 года назад
@@mrjones29 yeah I did like the American tv I'm still stuck in the 90's watching friends haha quantum leap as well. Phaps sam could drag me back to the present. I also absolutely love blackadder that's where i get my sense of humour from wasn't to into the first one though i liked the sarcastic witty retorts he uses
@wedgeantillies66
@wedgeantillies66 5 месяцев назад
The number of about faces that Humphrey does during this scene in order to not antagonise Jim are hilarious brilliant and well executed facial expressions of shock and about turn.
@MonkeyspankO
@MonkeyspankO 2 года назад
Fun fact, they never had to clean the ceilings, because Humphrey hit it so often it may as well have been self-cleaning.
@ASB117
@ASB117 2 года назад
I thought it was steamed regularly. There was always plenty of hot air being blasted about the place.
@MonkeyspankO
@MonkeyspankO 2 года назад
@@ASB117 hehehe, true
@banksterkid5930
@banksterkid5930 2 года назад
Humphrey's laughter should have its own award category 🏅🏅🏅
@sheerluckholmes5468
@sheerluckholmes5468 2 года назад
Boris: "Write that down, write that down" Lackey: "Yes Prime Minister."
@markwilliams7461
@markwilliams7461 2 года назад
What got turetts
@ssz2150
@ssz2150 2 года назад
3:12 "No! They're government stat..... they're facts" Jesus Christ! I whish I could go back in time and give him a kiss on the cheek for that one!
@nicholashylton6857
@nicholashylton6857 2 года назад
Humphrey's microsecond pause kills me every time! 😂
@Sunshine-zm1fx
@Sunshine-zm1fx 2 года назад
Every time I see snippets from this show, I just look at Sir Nigel Hawthorne and cannot believe the same actor played Georgie in Mapp and Lucia. What an incredible range he had. It's just amazing to me.
@TheRealist2022
@TheRealist2022 2 года назад
@Sunshine Absolutely right. And to think the man spent his early years, up to his 20's in South Africa, too! I think a great example of the importance of casting, is that the show was revamped in 2013 starring Henry Goodman as Sir Humphrey and David Haig as Hacker. It was a disaster. About as funny as getting an eviction notice handed to you...and then getting a paper cut off it. Goodman and Haig are outstanding actors... but completely miscast in YPM. However, if the original had never happened, it might have been ok. Perhaps the comparison between the two, contributes to the downfall of the latter.
@AnthonyWilliams-ew3wp
@AnthonyWilliams-ew3wp 2 года назад
The Madness of King George anyone? A magnificent performance.
@TheRealist2022
@TheRealist2022 2 года назад
@Ken Fullman foWlds. SERGEANT Blaketon. Carry on.
@TheRealist2022
@TheRealist2022 2 года назад
@Ken Fullman Yeah. I really ought to get out more, don't I Ken?
@harripursiainen5420
@harripursiainen5420 2 года назад
Also he was Dr Raymond Cocteau in Demolition man.
@pizzaguardian
@pizzaguardian 2 года назад
Indeed we should be thankful to those smokers, who heroically shorten their lives to fund our social medical services. Their sacrifice will never be forgotten!
@aidy6000
@aidy6000 2 года назад
That's why they will never totally back prohibition
@lsd8497
@lsd8497 2 года назад
😅
@Tht1Gy
@Tht1Gy 2 года назад
@@lsd8497 You can't smoke LSD. You put in on blotter paper. Lol
@lsd8497
@lsd8497 2 года назад
@@Tht1Gy Actually, these are the initials of my name. :))
@davidjordan9759
@davidjordan9759 2 года назад
@@Tht1Gy And then smoke the blotting paper.
@glyn6170
@glyn6170 2 года назад
I knew a smoker many years ago. who in the early 80's said it was his patriotic duty to smoke and theraby provide taxes for the govt to help prop up an ailing economy. I now apply that arguement to drinking.
@nicholashylton6857
@nicholashylton6857 2 года назад
I salute both of you for selflessness and devotion to your country! 🖖👍
@sithonsithon1012
@sithonsithon1012 2 года назад
I loved this series. Especially Sir Humphrey's ability with the English language. His ability to lie while being factual
@stephenphillip5656
@stephenphillip5656 2 года назад
...and 30 years later, tobacco advertising & sports sponsorship was banned by the government of the day. Prescient methinks... Yes Prime Minister was *way* ahead of time.
@DomWeasel
@DomWeasel 2 года назад
As they would say in the show, such a thing would have been a 'courageous decision' back in the 80s. By the 10s, merely 'controversial'.
@ribbonsofnight
@ribbonsofnight 2 года назад
I only just remember when Australia banned cigarette advertising in 1993 so I was a bit surprised to find UK took until 2003-2013 while the USA seems to have been in the process of banning it from 1971 to ? I'm a bit surprised that the UK was so slow
@brianglendenning1632
@brianglendenning1632 2 года назад
And tobacco advertising seems to have been replaced with advertising for gambling…
@brontewcat
@brontewcat 2 года назад
And in Australia- plain packaging and packs are in a cabinet so you can’t see them at point of sale
@ryanalving3785
@ryanalving3785 2 года назад
@@ribbonsofnight in the US I think you'll only see cigarette advertisements at point of sale. Maybe on the windows of a 7 11. But our government isn't really out to eliminate smoking. I don't think our public is really interested either. Most people in the US are more interested in legalizing prohibited substances than stopping people from using legal ones.
@johnbanks4761
@johnbanks4761 2 года назад
This show was and is timeless in its genius..grom writing to acting to directing...absolutely brilliant
@MindinViolet
@MindinViolet 2 года назад
The funny thing is that Hacker’s suggestions are all used by Australia to fight smoking.
@pi4t651
@pi4t651 2 года назад
They're used by the UK too. There's been quite the social shift since the days of yes minister.
@marmite8959
@marmite8959 2 года назад
@@pi4t651 Eh, I'm 20 and I smoke and so do most of my friends. Despite the ridiculous prices and health campaigns and supposed social stigma loads of us still smoke, we just can't do it inside anymore and we have to pay £10+ for a brown pack of ciggies with a stock image of sad people on it. Still pissed that I can't buy clove cigarettes or menthols anymore though.
@citycrusher9308
@citycrusher9308 2 года назад
@@marmite8959 yes, just like the anti drug campaigns didn't change a thing either. For what ever reason people pick these habits up
@DOZDDMGator
@DOZDDMGator 2 года назад
@Noel Coward rates of smoking in aus are going up lol
@DomWeasel
@DomWeasel 2 года назад
@@pi4t651 The policy they end up taking in this episode is the one used in real life by the various British governments. Instead of banning smoking outright and losing the massive tax revenue from it, they instead discouraged it, first by banning the advertising, raising the age you can buy tobacco, the warnings on the packaging etc, all to slowly decrease the number of smokers so that the cost to the nation from smoking related illnesses would continue to be paid by the revenue from it. Both would shrink over time but together. Basically, instead of enforcing cold turkey on the nation, they've been weaning people off them for decades and will keep on doing it until smokers become an absolute minority. Quite clever really.
@pienjopienjo7697
@pienjopienjo7697 Год назад
So glad I discovered the series. Better late than never.
@BobSmith-fx9sz
@BobSmith-fx9sz 2 года назад
An actuary once told me that, overall, UK smokers contribute more through taxes than cost the government because of related healthcare costs. Same for alcohol. Mad.
@DomWeasel
@DomWeasel 2 года назад
It's astonishing when you go to Europe and buy alcohol that doesn't come with a 50% plus mark-up. Lorries carrying cigarettes in the UK are unmarked because the cargo is too valuable. Even a small lorry can have over half a million pounds worth on board. That same cargo is barely worth anything in Europe.
@ribbonsofnight
@ribbonsofnight 2 года назад
It's hard to add up all their costs to the government let alone their cost to society. If you add the value of the people that die as a result of second hand smoking it's hard to say anyone is coming out ahead.
@embreis2257
@embreis2257 2 года назад
that's highly improbable. that actuary seems to have got the numbers wrong
@nigelsharratt933
@nigelsharratt933 2 года назад
Brilliant writing, brilliant performances, proper comedy. Now we get …..gogglebox
@silentdogfart4892
@silentdogfart4892 2 года назад
Watching lazy people watch tv… brilliant😣
@nigelsharratt933
@nigelsharratt933 2 года назад
@@silentdogfart4892 you must be a fan
@nigelsharratt933
@nigelsharratt933 2 года назад
Of?
@warnpassion
@warnpassion 2 года назад
What is a gogglebox?
@nigelsharratt933
@nigelsharratt933 2 года назад
@@warnpassion it is a TV programme where miscellaneous people are filmed watching TV in their own living rooms.
@djackmanson
@djackmanson 2 года назад
It's fascinating that the policies mentioned in this episode, which were considered impossible in the 1980s, are now well-established policy in at least Australia. Cigarette advertising is banned, all cigarettes are sold in drab olive boxes plastered with gruesome health warnings, and a pack of 25 Peter Stuyvesants costs "about the same as a bottle of whisky" thanks to massive tax increases over the last 15 years or so.
@kenchristie9214
@kenchristie9214 2 года назад
Back in the 70's my cousin's cousin, a pathologist, used to graffiti smoking billboards in Perth. He was a member of a goup who called themselves BUGA UP - Billboard Using Gaffitists Against Unhealthy Promotions.
@djackmanson
@djackmanson 2 года назад
@@kenchristie9214 I remember BUGA UP! At least, I remember knowing about them. Our family went to Sydney once for a holiday and we saw a billboard they'd graffiti'd. My mum, who wasn't a fan of most lawbreaking, liked it because it was witty and she didn't smoke.
@jasonquigley2633
@jasonquigley2633 2 года назад
It's more or less the same in the UK and Ireland. The next generation won't even understand this clip. "Cigarettes used to be smoked indoors and advertised on TV???"
@Tw1stStr3am
@Tw1stStr3am 2 года назад
Same in England, 20 pack of cigarettes is more expensive than a 70cl standard whisky.
@seagecko
@seagecko 2 года назад
Perfect writing. Impeccable acting. Ages deliciously.
@mikmop
@mikmop 2 года назад
Interesting how 30 years after this episode was broadcast, (Dec 2012), the Australian government implemented exactly the same policy. With even no branding allowed on cigarette packets, just plain paper packaging, that's embellished with a photo of a person's ulcerated gums. And at this point in time in 2021, a packet of 25 cigarettes inc tax, costs $30 Australian dollars = (GBP £16 or USD $22). So someone who smokes a packet per day would be spending every week: AUD$210 = (GBP £112 or USD$154). And twice that for heavy smokers that smoke two packs a day, AUD$420 = (GBP £224 or USD$308) per week. This has taken smoking outside the affordability of kids and low income earners. And smoking is no longer allowed inside public buildings. You can't smoke inside pubs, restaurants, shops, office buildings, or pretty much no where. And as for outdoor areas, you can't smoke on railway station platforms, or where people congregate, like bus stops, etc. The health minister at the time faced exactly the same attacks against her, by tobacco industry lobbyists and supporters of smoking. The Conservative federal opposition at the time, had branded it a tax on battlers (i.e. on the working class); and they promised to repeal these new purportedly draconian laws, should they win the next election and come back into government. However, the public had become strongly supportive of these anti-tobacco policies, so the laws remained in place, even after there was a change of government. And within a decade, rates of cigarette smoking have halved from 30% of the population to 15%, as the next generation of school age smokers, (and budget-constrained existing smokers), simply do not get or remain addicted, due to the expense and unaffordability of the product. This has saved Australians billions of dollars in healthcare costs. And compulsory worker's superannuation contributions (50% paid by the employer and 50% by the government) which began in 1992, has meant that these longer living and healthier Australians will not be overburdening the government's pension system when they become elderly.
@janickpauwels3792
@janickpauwels3792 2 года назад
We have exactly the same in Europe, where this process started around 2011 (depending on the country). As a non-smoker, this makes life a LOT more pleasant, as I can now smell the wine at a restaurant instead of someone else's burnt leaves.
@gio-oz8gf
@gio-oz8gf 2 года назад
@@janickpauwels3792 Alcohol is the next legalised poison we need to ban. In England and Wales, smoking in enclosed public places, which includes restaurants, has been banned since 2007, 2006 in Scotland.
@fifthof1795
@fifthof1795 2 года назад
@@gio-oz8gf bollox to that. The Jocks are pi££heads so They need to curb their drinking : ) Ban this, ban that...state control of this and that....stuff that and stuff socialism.
@andyclayton9204
@andyclayton9204 2 года назад
@@gio-oz8gf Yeah, let's ban alcohol. What a fun world we'll live in.
@gio-oz8gf
@gio-oz8gf 2 года назад
@@fifthof1795 I agree, get rid of the socialist NHS and the socialist state pension for a start. While we're at it we can get rid of all state benefits, all state sponsored education, the state sponsored police force, fire brigade and ambulance service. If you won't work or are too ill to work tough, you'll just have to starve. if you're attacked you'll just have to be hard enough to look after yourself or die. You should be careful what you wish for but first, learn what socialism actually means.
@mustafakhan519
@mustafakhan519 2 года назад
"Thank you for your cigarette paper" 🤣😁 that's so brilliantly slipped in!!
@LoftBits
@LoftBits 2 года назад
Brilliant. That's the first word that comes to my mind whenever I re-watch these. Just brilliant.
@SignumInterriti
@SignumInterriti 2 года назад
This is an interesting one. Hacker's moral arguments usually come across as genuine, seeing that he sounds just the same when he makes them just for show without commitment demonstrates his skill and untrustworthyness as a politican. He fools Humphrey into thinking he is sincere and he might have fooled the audience on other occasions.
@ernstschmidt4725
@ernstschmidt4725 2 года назад
Despite his apparent lack of witb and constant need for approval, hacker does often shows a savvyness with public communications, more exactly knowing what other people want to hear.
@malcolmrowe9003
@malcolmrowe9003 2 года назад
A while since I last properly watched, but he does seem to be more proactively devious once prime minister than when he was a minister.
@ernstschmidt4725
@ernstschmidt4725 2 года назад
@@malcolmrowe9003 yeah. Hacker does get less helpless once he is PM. All that time with Humphrey teached him a trick or two
@Wraithfighter
@Wraithfighter 2 года назад
I’d argue that Hacker’s moral arguments were sincere. Just because you know something is the morally right thing to do doesn’t make it the most practical thing to do, after all, and he’s a politician, not a priest. He has to keep an eye on what’s practical and achievable, even as much as he might want to do the moral thing. So in this case? It’d be that he agrees that smoking is something that should be stamped out and curbed, but knows he can’t do anything about it… but he can use that as a lever to get something else he wants, so he speaks the truth about the morality. It can be viewed as hypocritical, and perhaps it is, but I’d rather have those in power who know what the right thing to do is but can’t do it yet, than those who only know what the wrong things to do are and go to great lengths to do them.
@andreashaynes3346
@andreashaynes3346 2 года назад
Absolutely fantastic. Timeless comedy and satire of the finest!!! 🤣🌟🤣🌟🤣
@Steampunksaly
@Steampunksaly 2 года назад
This was one of Margaret Thatcher’s favourite shows, I heard her say in an interview, of how scarily real this programme portrayed the goings on at number 10 Downing St! The writer’s were genius!
@beeman2075
@beeman2075 2 года назад
This was such a brilliant show with razor sharp writing.
@louisanow
@louisanow 2 года назад
All I've seen of this show are the short YT clips, and not one has failed to amuse. I'm going to have to binge this series eventually! 😁
@fleurpeffer5212
@fleurpeffer5212 2 года назад
I love it when the minister is so onto Humphrey he gets backed into a corner
@albion4044
@albion4044 2 года назад
I remember watching this on UHF. One of the best TV series ever made.
@trustwithin7188
@trustwithin7188 2 года назад
Definitely 😂
@mathewkelly9968
@mathewkelly9968 2 года назад
We have all this in Australia, tax is sky high , no advertising , plain packaging etc its worked quite well .
@rawyld
@rawyld 2 года назад
Yep and it works.
@mosspally6995
@mosspally6995 2 года назад
Oh same here. It’s one of those lovely antiquated scenes that looks a bit insane nowadays considering how much of a hammering tobacco firms took.
@joepublic8582
@joepublic8582 2 года назад
It grew a multi-million chop chop business that invested in narcotics, shame they swallowed the lies about vaping but then again, only the UK didn't.
@ribbonsofnight
@ribbonsofnight 2 года назад
The insane part is that plain packaging took so long and a ban on advertising took so long in some countries like the UK
@LHRTW
@LHRTW Год назад
Replaced by vap
@odiedodieuk
@odiedodieuk 2 года назад
Just started watching yes Minister again. It’s great to see how their relationship evolves.
@jamesratcliffe8470
@jamesratcliffe8470 2 года назад
Dominic Lawson wrote in the Sunday Times along similar lines. Smoke like a chimney, drink alcohol, drive everywhere,pay your taxes and NI stamp,:pop your clogs at 65 and the country is sound fiscally.
@abhijitoka
@abhijitoka Год назад
Even the minute things "Thank you for your cigarette paper" cracks it.
@nettaglover8183
@nettaglover8183 2 года назад
What a spin! I am surprise Humphy didn’t fall flat on his back. How I love him
@jeremy1860
@jeremy1860 2 года назад
Some of the best comedy actors the BBC ever had 😊
@justinfuller3957
@justinfuller3957 2 года назад
The writing was absolutely brilliant on this show!
@andrewbernard8752
@andrewbernard8752 10 месяцев назад
Great old Humpy must be laughing now
@jamesmcgrath578
@jamesmcgrath578 2 года назад
This is political business education for the public in light-hearted form
@roadwarrior144
@roadwarrior144 2 года назад
What depresses me is that I can see both sides of this logic! The phrase “necessary evil” keeps rattling around in my head. I wonder if this makes me a “moral vacuum” like Humphrey?
@freebornjohn2687
@freebornjohn2687 2 года назад
I do hope so.
@rin_etoware_2989
@rin_etoware_2989 2 года назад
think of it this way: what the government saves in healthcare and pensions because of smokers dying young would be significantly counterbalanced by medical spending and lost productivity, *both from smokers and the people around them.* second-hand smoke and so on. in any case, eliminating preventable diseases as much as one humanly can-in other words, making your people as healthy as possible-would drastically reduce the cost of national healthcare. at that point you'd really only be needing to treat those who get sick either out of sheer bad luck or old age.
@McRocket
@McRocket 9 месяцев назад
Man...the writers had a field day with this one. Well done. ☮
@kennethdrewary1094
@kennethdrewary1094 2 года назад
Today on 05/10/2021 the home Secretary announced a public enquiry, Sr Humphrey used to say, If you don't want anything done, hold a public enquiry. Makes you wonder
@FoxDren
@FoxDren 2 года назад
Well yea, a public enquiry gives people time to forget about what ever the enquiry is about while creating the image something is being done
@merleboyd9962
@merleboyd9962 2 года назад
They can always agree on principal but then do nothing about it.
@stephenpegum9776
@stephenpegum9776 2 года назад
Not entirely in the same vein as this hilarious sketch, but back in the early 00's I was working in part of the MoD. One of the regular publications that crossed my desk was Civil Service News (or something similar). One edition had a lengthy & very detailed letter from an unnamed civil servant working out that smokers who were entitled to smoking breaks during office hours worked x% less over their full working lives than non-smokers. The writer was dead serious - it certainly was not a joke !! 😎😱
@jazzman1954
@jazzman1954 2 года назад
British humour at its long gone best.
@stephenturner9097
@stephenturner9097 2 года назад
What Hacker suggested, raising tax sky high, banning advertising, especially at point of sale, is exactly what Australia did to great effect.
@davidwebster5946
@davidwebster5946 2 года назад
Hunphrey in this scene is absolutely brilliant
@alanwayte432
@alanwayte432 2 года назад
Genius writing and comic timing
@stevenburton6785
@stevenburton6785 2 года назад
As Billy Connoly once said smoking takes 10 years off your life ,The Worst 10 Years.
@chriswatson7965
@chriswatson7965 2 года назад
It's actually an even spread. You simply age quicker.
@DieFlabbergast
@DieFlabbergast 2 года назад
Yeah: but Billy gave up, at an early age.
@bingbong7316
@bingbong7316 2 года назад
@@DieFlabbergast Apart from cigars. He used to do an outrage piece about that; the woman in the hotel bar who started coughing the moment he unwrapped one.
@DomWeasel
@DomWeasel 2 года назад
He did a wonderful bit about the white bread vs brown bread crowd, pointing out that at best you get an extra two weeks to your life and not your young life when 'you're shagging everything that moves'. No, at the other end of your life when you need help being fed and taking a shit.
@ribbonsofnight
@ribbonsofnight 2 года назад
I assume he's dropped that because his audiences have started to think he's got it terribly wrong
@trishna_6815
@trishna_6815 2 года назад
Brilliant that Australia's Nicola Roxon, as Health Minister and then Attorney General, actually managed to do this and more. No-one thought it was remotely possibly to take on big tobacco. Now most countries around the world have same rules.
@staypositive5718
@staypositive5718 2 года назад
It’s scary how real this is
@2411509igwt
@2411509igwt 2 года назад
Good thing financial incentives would never affect the relationship between Public Health Policy and Pharmaceutical companies in the event of a major health crises like a pandemic.
@WildBikerBill
@WildBikerBill 2 года назад
@Johann Sebastian Bach While it certainly was developed quickly, I believe the jury is still out on how effective, or safe, it is.
@kappleby8503
@kappleby8503 2 года назад
20 years ago today, Nigel Hawthorne (Sir Humphrey) passed away
@zara9730
@zara9730 2 года назад
Bless their souls those two were perfect.... RIP
@TheRealist2022
@TheRealist2022 2 года назад
@Zara It was marvellous to see Paul Eddington get a starring role and to be lauded for it. He usually played "second fiddle" on telly and despite being excellent in those roles, he never truly got the credit he deserved...until YM and YPM, anyway. The man was very cultured and thoughtful, too. He was a Quaker and regarded by all as a truly lovely man.
@zara9730
@zara9730 2 года назад
@@TheRealist2022 So True
@bingoreddraaz7363
@bingoreddraaz7363 2 года назад
I need a brain like Humphrey's 🤣🤣🤣
@viviennepopek
@viviennepopek 2 года назад
I'm so glad i have the complete box set of this series. I just have to make sure i have a big box of tissues when I watch it for the tears of laughter! A brilliant cast 💖 😂👋💕😂💖😂💕👋😂 👋......Yes.Minister......👋 💖..............&.................💖 👋.Yes.Prime.Minister👎 😂👋💕😂💖😂💕👋😂
@allenjenkins7947
@allenjenkins7947 2 года назад
I have the books.
@calebwhymark1789
@calebwhymark1789 2 года назад
Why is this so perfectly accurate decades on?
@Pfth
@Pfth 4 месяца назад
The values it explores are universal, aren't they... timeless.
@ericlarson7556
@ericlarson7556 2 года назад
Intentional 420. Genius move
@thetenthplanet_
@thetenthplanet_ 2 года назад
I've been trying to think about where I recognise the Humphry guy and I finally got it. He's the bad guy in Demolition Man other than Wesley Snipes.
@akshayiyer8897
@akshayiyer8897 4 месяца назад
Sunak did this... Man this just a documentary
@Grace66983
@Grace66983 2 года назад
I watched these series in the 80s and am still watching then in 2022.
@trillianmcmillian2660
@trillianmcmillian2660 2 года назад
I love it because Humphrey says exactly what the tea party is thinking
@jordanhodgkins8164
@jordanhodgkins8164 2 года назад
Oscar from heartbeat 🥺 ❤️
@iainballas
@iainballas 2 года назад
It sounds like an arguement with your mother. When you have reasons, they are 'excuses' When *she* has reasons, they are iron-clad facts.
@MasterofSpiders
@MasterofSpiders 2 года назад
3:10 - I died.
@ediblebouquet
@ediblebouquet 2 года назад
So did all the smokers
@Snufflegrunt
@Snufflegrunt 4 месяца назад
Ah, perfect timing.
@lamar7bn
@lamar7bn 2 года назад
Why these british sitcoms are making me feel cozy watching them bedtime?
@michaelbme1983
@michaelbme1983 3 месяца назад
Look up the yes minister and yes prime minister radio adaptations
@parthoroy9141
@parthoroy9141 2 года назад
Loved this show; I used to watch the reruns every weekend on PBS twenty years ago up in Maryland when I was a student there
@tezfitz7863
@tezfitz7863 2 года назад
British comedy at its best 😂😂
@gentblue
@gentblue 2 года назад
Comedy? This is a documentary!
@garviniantso
@garviniantso 2 года назад
Same now here in Australia, but swap out the tobacco industry with the mining industry.
@chrisdeangerous
@chrisdeangerous 2 года назад
2022 and we're still having this very debate in Switzerland about banning tobacco advertising... With the same arguments, to boot!
@AviAvikesh
@AviAvikesh 2 года назад
Check the video's length. Very nice.
@richposports7030
@richposports7030 2 года назад
Desert island 🏝 This makes my Top 10 dvd 📀 list. Yes Minister was arguably even better!!
@godfreygalea8181
@godfreygalea8181 2 года назад
Simply brilliant!
@jeremyhaines4481
@jeremyhaines4481 2 года назад
👏 Brilliant comedy I have Yes Minster and Yes Prime Minister on DVDS
@darylcheshire1618
@darylcheshire1618 8 месяцев назад
Was this the episode where the Minister for Health is a smoker with a hacking cough?
@grease_monkey6078
@grease_monkey6078 2 года назад
Humphrey justifying the death of smokers is pretty bold and pretty cold at that, assuming that the dead smokers would of been a burden on society if they lived healthy lives
@markwilliams7461
@markwilliams7461 2 года назад
What just like the jolly pple
@clovermark39
@clovermark39 2 года назад
They could talk about anything in those days. The good old days!
@Sunshine-zm1fx
@Sunshine-zm1fx 2 года назад
Anti-smoking was pretty popular back then. And truthfully, less people do smoke now.
@Sunshine-zm1fx
@Sunshine-zm1fx 2 года назад
@@clovermark39 Of course they couldn't talk about anything. They could just talk about different things.
@oberstleutnant787
@oberstleutnant787 2 года назад
One of my favourite british shaw, the other ones are "are you being served" and " some mothers do have 'em".
@Vegimite-Butter-Sandwich
@Vegimite-Butter-Sandwich 2 года назад
I love how this is 4min and 20sec long, perfection👌
@qwertyuiop98320
@qwertyuiop98320 2 года назад
sky high tax and no ads, even at point of sale. That won't happen ....oh, it did
@genildomiranda1690
@genildomiranda1690 2 года назад
Humphrey could give s MasterCards in rationalizing
@roberthiggins6401
@roberthiggins6401 2 года назад
And that's why I still smoke! Just doing my bit!
@andyrob3259
@andyrob3259 2 года назад
Weird this was seen at the time as impossible- but actually smoking bans came in pretty quick in the end with barely a whimper except from the tobacco lobby.
@rdrrr
@rdrrr 2 года назад
I think the real reason is a re-evaluation of the costs vs benefits of smoking showed that, in fact, smoking caused a deficit to the budget (as another commenter said, if you include lost workdays due to smoking related illnesses etc., you get a different financial picture). Governments never have and never will care about preserving the lives of ordinary people.
@awqsed1029
@awqsed1029 2 года назад
Shouldn't had cut the next line "smokers are national benefactors"
@richposports7030
@richposports7030 2 года назад
....The Larry Sanders Show! Genius
@Gavin_1990
@Gavin_1990 2 года назад
I wish I was around when this show was new
@citycrusher9308
@citycrusher9308 2 года назад
ahh, life before 900 channels to surf. You would like that
@frankbarbaro6845
@frankbarbaro6845 2 года назад
I was just 24 when this show first appeared. It was on the ABC and so it didn't receive the promotion that the commercial networks gave their new programs. The critical acclaim it received was, from my perspective, unprecedented. But it mainly spread through word of mouth. It aired on Monday and every Tuesday you would here people talking about this astonishing new comedy/political satire/documentary/ tragedy. The shows reputation spread and eventually it became a sensation. Soon, our Monday nights were dedicated to Yes Minister.
@frankbarbaro6845
@frankbarbaro6845 2 года назад
@Noel Coward Indeed. I recall seeing an interview in which Thatcher said that if you want to see an accurate portrayal of what occurs in the corridors of power, your best option is to watch Yes Minister.
@LeftLib
@LeftLib 2 года назад
The downside would be that today you would be my age. Maybe we can do a swap?
@ribbonsofnight
@ribbonsofnight 2 года назад
too many smokers back then
@johnbull9195
@johnbull9195 3 месяца назад
It's so laughable an idea it's now government policy! 🤣🤣
@abhijitoka
@abhijitoka Год назад
This is the best Anti Smoking ad I have ever seen.
@christopherdewhurst8812
@christopherdewhurst8812 2 года назад
I truly l,oved this programme and what made it so much nicer was to read the pm and sir Humphrey both insisted on Bernard been given better lines so there was the three of them not the two plus Bernard.
@cristianchivu6126
@cristianchivu6126 2 года назад
Perfect British humour. ..
@ajs41
@ajs41 9 месяцев назад
It's good, in itself, that fewer people smoke, but it's probably also responsible for the fact that so many people are obese or overweight, because smoking used to kill people's appetites.
@sirdigbyminge1639
@sirdigbyminge1639 2 года назад
Such beautiful acting.
@JonatasAdoM
@JonatasAdoM 2 года назад
These should be subtitled in every language possible.
@tonysegadelli9421
@tonysegadelli9421 2 года назад
Amazing how times have changed
@0ceanicify
@0ceanicify 2 года назад
When COVID killed 17,000 people, Boris had a party
Далее
А ВЫ УМЕЕТЕ ПЛАВАТЬ?? #shorts
00:21
Просмотров 880 тыс.
ПОЁМ НАРОДНЫЕ ПЕСНИ🪗
2:04:11
Просмотров 1,1 млн
Blackadder - Sensible policies for a happier Britain
4:29
Why the UK is in the EU
3:31
Просмотров 4,8 млн
You're a Banker | Yes, Minister | BBC Studios
3:08
Просмотров 3,1 млн
Clip: Yes Minister  S03E06 The Whisky Priest
4:50
Просмотров 1,1 млн