Тёмный

The State of Russia's Defense Industry After Two Years of War and Sanctions 

Center for Strategic & International Studies
Подписаться 305 тыс.
Просмотров 34 тыс.
50% 1

Please join the Europe, Russia, and Eurasia Program for a discussion about the state of Russia's defense industry today.
Max Bergmann will moderate a conversation with Maria Snegovaya, Samuel Bendett, and Dara Massicot from the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace to discuss the findings of the recent CSIS report, "Back in Stock? The State of Russia's Defense Industry after Two Years of the War."
The conversation will cover the contents of the report, its implications for the ongoing war in Ukraine, and the future of the Western sanctions regime leveled against Russia.
This online-only event will take place on Monday, June 24, 2024, from 1:00-2:30 PM EDT.
This event is made possible by a grant from Carnegie Corporation of New York.
---------------------------------------------
A nonpartisan institution, CSIS is the top national security think tank in the world.
Visit www.csis.org to find more of our work as we bring bipartisan solutions to the world's greatest challenges.
Want to see more videos and virtual events? Subscribe to this channel and turn on notifications: cs.is/2dCfTve
Follow CSIS on:
• Twitter: csis
• Facebook: CSIS.org
• Instagram: csis

Опубликовано:

 

23 июн 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 222   
@victorzvyagintsev1325
@victorzvyagintsev1325 2 дня назад
Half of the time you hear "unfortunately"....makes this Russian bot smile :)
@brandonlance3601
@brandonlance3601 День назад
😊
@TysonFuryTheGOAT
@TysonFuryTheGOAT День назад
Especially nice to hear that from a Russian libtrd traitor who fantasizes about Russia breaking apart.
@bardsamok9221
@bardsamok9221 22 часа назад
If you are helping yourself to cope, all is good. Keep going.
@victorzvyagintsev1325
@victorzvyagintsev1325 21 час назад
@@bardsamok9221 How unfortunately unfortunate that you can't come up with anything beyond "cope"
@bardsamok9221
@bardsamok9221 21 час назад
@@victorzvyagintsev1325 It's the correct word. Maybe you're trying so hard that you missed the rest of the sentence? Google: 'Coping mechanism'
@Slapdab
@Slapdab 3 дня назад
So many details that I haven’t heard discussed anywhere else. Thanks for presenting this.
@ericwillis777
@ericwillis777 20 часов назад
I mostly agree with what everyone else has said.
@GeoScorpion
@GeoScorpion 16 часов назад
You may want to also check out CFR, Hudson Institute, Aspen Institute, and then for respectable Russo-Ukraine coverage, there's Jake Broe, Artur Rehi, Anna From Ukraine, Ukraine Matters, Operator Starskey, etc.
@GeoScorpion
@GeoScorpion 15 часов назад
Also ANYONE who has Fiona Hill as a guest...
@Slapdab
@Slapdab 15 часов назад
@@GeoScorpion will do
@Erik-rp1hi
@Erik-rp1hi 3 дня назад
It is a shame the US and our allies do not see increase production of all the items we are lacking (weapons) is needed. We are setting ourselves up to fail big time.
@immysw7087
@immysw7087 3 дня назад
The volunteering effort at drones and quad copters and those monthly production estimates was particularly startling.
@user-mz3in7vo5b
@user-mz3in7vo5b 3 дня назад
Politicians ARE idiots!
@ericm3089
@ericm3089 3 дня назад
Our federal budget now spends more on paying interest on national debt than defense spending. Our Politicians continue to win popularity by spending money we finance add on to that long term debt. U.S. dollar is approaching loosing reserve currency status. Time to shrink debt and federal government agencies. 65% of payroll are government sector jobs.. grow private business and industry not debt producing government.
@stevemuir5384
@stevemuir5384 3 дня назад
😅😂😂😂 how? You ignoramus
@chillxxx241
@chillxxx241 2 дня назад
Ukrainians can’t afford weapons. Most of its allies are taking out loans with interest to pay for Ukrainian aid. Russia really doesn’t have allies in the same context. They are paying for everything they receive.
@alko_xo
@alko_xo 2 дня назад
To all those who feel sorry for wasting 1 hour 27 minutes 16 seconds of their lives, a short summary - "Well, who could have predicted this before? How good it is that we take no responsibility for our previous predictions! What a good thing!"
@krazyswede11
@krazyswede11 День назад
Yes indeed well said
@Kirfx
@Kirfx День назад
Thanks
@Miomi-dh4hx
@Miomi-dh4hx День назад
Indeed, any talk about the Russian invasion is like group therapy. Rather spend energy to implement 100% sanctions on Russia and on any country or company dealing with Russia. That goes for China as well, we complain about China and their desire to increase their influence in the world, and we keep trading and manufacturing in China. Once China reverse engineers our products we complain about theft of intellectual property rights
@AlexPronovealexcooper1
@AlexPronovealexcooper1 17 часов назад
I was about to watch and then I saw your comment. Thank you.
@pedrob3953
@pedrob3953 5 часов назад
You're dealing with Washington apparatchiks, just as disgusting as the Kremlin ones.
@conflict_monitor
@conflict_monitor День назад
This must have been very painful for the panelists. Thoughts and prayers.
@roselynjrserrano970
@roselynjrserrano970 3 дня назад
The economic cost of war is a primary consideration.
@imperator_danny
@imperator_danny 3 дня назад
Dara Massicot is fantastic. Very smart person.
@juliasegura7421
@juliasegura7421 3 дня назад
Thank You.
@andreasmai9265
@andreasmai9265 2 дня назад
Thanks for dealing with that matter. I Always ask myself If the politicians are enough aware of a possible Russian win with enourmous amounts of Refugees, enourmous follow Up costs of ramping Up Military and the immininent danger If Russia sitting Just behind Poland 🇺🇲🤝🇺🇦🤝🇩🇪
@roselynjrserrano970
@roselynjrserrano970 3 дня назад
The reason why the U.S.S.R pull out of Afghanistan is economic cost.
@mavalupindo7672
@mavalupindo7672 День назад
Some or most"Russian expects" have never been to Russia even once
@jonnieinbangkok
@jonnieinbangkok День назад
Probably don't even speak or read Russian so can't even work from primary sources 🙄
@GeoScorpion
@GeoScorpion 16 часов назад
No, but they know how to spell 'expert.' Most have actually been to Russia. Who is it that you think hasn't been to Russia?
@zollen123
@zollen123 3 дня назад
Considering the widespread adaption of scoters, golf carts and motorcycles on the frontlines, I say they are doing great.
@mylessalmon2569
@mylessalmon2569 2 дня назад
By using those means, indicates Russia lacks armored vehicles to transport troops.
@david7384
@david7384 2 дня назад
Why do nafo bootlickers cope so hard instead of having intelligent military tactics and strategy discussion?
@kaloyan2090
@kaloyan2090 2 дня назад
​@@mylessalmon2569 Armoured vehicles = warfare Levy (trucks and other tps automobiles = transport It indicates that both sides are using stop gaps and preserving heavier equipment
@mylessalmon2569
@mylessalmon2569 День назад
@@kaloyan2090 They may not have the equipment. Russia is pulling from Soviet supplies which are dwindling. Russia cannot manufacture enough to replace their losses. Russia has turned to China for motorcycles and the 4-wheel drive carts.
@bardsamok9221
@bardsamok9221 21 час назад
​@@mylessalmon2569True. And North Korea for broken weapons and meat.
@luminyam6145
@luminyam6145 2 дня назад
That was so good, thank you.
@johnnyhotwiel5409
@johnnyhotwiel5409 2 дня назад
Interesting. T34 versus Tiger comes to mind
@johndewey6358
@johndewey6358 3 дня назад
Very good discussion. I wish there was more about the triangle of Iran, China and Russia, with the emphasis on Iran; since Iran seems to have made great progress on copying some of the most common and high efficiency Jet Engines for applying them to the Gas Turbine applications and later to commercial jets that it might be developing on its own or in collaboration with the Sukhoi for fitting up the Russian Sukhoi commercial jets. Since modern high-efficiency large jet engines maybe a stumbling block for Russia's commercial aviation at this time.
@JosephGibson
@JosephGibson 3 дня назад
When reading what you said, I was like where is this going when i get to Iran, China and Russia with emphasis on Iran until it spun off... I thought you were going to the trade routes from the Indian Ocean/Pacific going through Iran instead of the Red Sea. That is something we should focus on.
@Pierluigi_Di_Lorenzo
@Pierluigi_Di_Lorenzo 2 дня назад
2:32 The IMF is using Russian-provided statistics.
@tonymills5086
@tonymills5086 18 часов назад
You got that right , Somehow Putin , Has a person on the inside , Or just straight up bribed them , He is cooking the books The numbers Putin gave the IMF Are his numbers , And the numbers don't lie Russia has been in deficit spending For Two years , Something's Gotta giive Every legitimate economist Knows You cannot Spend more Then what you bring in For any left of time It can only produce catastropic Results The war is ripping putin a new asshole , Another? Well known economist Said a year ago Watch for this sign Is putin will raise Taxes On an economy That is teetering
@GeoScorpion
@GeoScorpion 16 часов назад
Same with CCP-provided statistics.
@justingoretoy1628
@justingoretoy1628 3 дня назад
Q: "We have been wrong about nearly everything in regards to The Ukraine War, how do we explain away and cope with the fact, that Russia is winning the war and their defense industrial base is outperforming all of NATO combined?" A: "Well it has nothing to do with our corrupt military industrial complex and the fact we greatly overpay for boutique systems, it has nothing to do with the fact that it costs as much as a couple new cars to become a welder in the US, it has nothing to do with the fact that Russian tech is designed to be more affordable/mass produceable AND is designed specifically for the conditions it is being used in. It's globalization and North Korea and China and the USSR even! " These people are experts at coping and applying ideological blinders to their conclusions. Whatever they are, they aren't "Russia" experts.
@Blake_87
@Blake_87 3 дня назад
The concept of being an expert on a country you’ve never lived in or understand the culture. We’ll see who breaks first, the west or east
@NathansHVAC
@NathansHVAC 3 дня назад
Yeah. The us can easily support $100 trlion of.debt
@harveybrown37
@harveybrown37 3 дня назад
? The 2nd largest Army in the World now occupies far less Ukrainian Land than it did in 2022.
@roscoerosario6992
@roscoerosario6992 3 дня назад
do you get paid in potatoes and vodka?
@NathansHVAC
@NathansHVAC 3 дня назад
​​@@roscoerosario6992 I'm a bot. any post against another just nato waaaar for freedom and democracy is obviously a bot.
@CheeseLovingGuy
@CheeseLovingGuy 3 дня назад
Fascinating. Well worth the time.
@gcrav
@gcrav День назад
The self-styled smartest people in the world now have to cope with the fact that they really aren't.
@GeoScorpion
@GeoScorpion 16 часов назад
... says the guy who posts mindless comments for RMB¥0.50 per comment... or because of budget cuts is it "two dimes" now? Do they even bother paying you, anymore? When was the last time you saw a paycheck? 🙄🤭
@ruthwolfer4154
@ruthwolfer4154 3 дня назад
Great discussion very necessary infos
@jagchahal1393
@jagchahal1393 3 дня назад
These expert have never spent any lenth of time in russia. Yet are expert of inside of russian state working.
@rmdomainer9042
@rmdomainer9042 3 дня назад
How would you know?
@crogeny
@crogeny 3 дня назад
_“These expert [sic] have never spent any lenth [sic] of time in russia [sic]”_ Maria Snegovaya is a native Russian speaker who graduated with a BA in Economics and Finance *in Moscow* in 2005. She then worked as a Research Assistant for five years at the Higher School of Economics *in Moscow.*
@rmdomainer9042
@rmdomainer9042 3 дня назад
@@crogeny Samuel Bendett also speaks fluent Russian, according to the web.
@JosephGibson
@JosephGibson 3 дня назад
@@crogeny who cares, I'm still waiting for anything said about Russia since the first weeks of their attack on Ukraine to actually be factual. A lot of Russians they have, haven't been there in years and typical turncoats - you get people who hate their Country, history, people, government or all..., a lot of them in West. I've not watched this, nor will I, likely full of shit but I actually could be wrong but wouldn't be surprised if any facts they do spew are spun out of context to suit whatever picture their painting.
@crogeny
@crogeny 3 дня назад
@@JosephGibson 'I'll carefully assess the validity of the content of this video by not watching it.' Thanks for your contribution.
@terjeoseberg990
@terjeoseberg990 21 час назад
“Two years after the war.” The way is over?
@roselynjrserrano970
@roselynjrserrano970 3 дня назад
The U.S.S.R did not destroy Afghanistan but even build roads.
@charlesshaw223
@charlesshaw223 3 дня назад
So you are saying that the Soviet troops Afghanistan essentially were performing purely peaceful functions: building houses, hospitals, roads, and wells? Ah yes, the famous Soviet Hearts‐and‐Minds campaigns. The reality is that though both the U.S. and Soviet Union invested heavily in road construction there from 1950 through the Soviet invasion in 1980, Afghanistan still has the lowest density of paved roads in Central Asia
@kaloyan2090
@kaloyan2090 2 дня назад
​@@charlesshaw223 Most of the infrastructure was destroyed during the Afghanistan war and Soviet intervention.
@bardsamok9221
@bardsamok9221 21 час назад
​@@kaloyan2090And millions of people destroyed.
@AntonDev-cw3kc
@AntonDev-cw3kc 23 часа назад
Drones with AI had already became a changegame ammunition long time ago. I seems to me, the best Players are awaiting something to begin to demonstrate their best examples. If so, this war is an another example of "strange war".
@narcissusnarwhal7141
@narcissusnarwhal7141 3 дня назад
Excellent! Thank you.
@kevinwaalker
@kevinwaalker 3 дня назад
Hu all this from a country where 30 % of the population does not have indoor plumbing Bloody hell
@alexanderhildermann9761
@alexanderhildermann9761 3 дня назад
The 30% love shitting in the forest with the bears! Then they ride home on the bear!🤣🤣 Could it be that you are underexposed?
@jonnieinbangkok
@jonnieinbangkok День назад
Everything is "unfortunate." 😂 😂 😂
@ericwedin4154
@ericwedin4154 3 дня назад
And then diversity came up as a critical russian disadvantage😂😂😂
@ericwillis777
@ericwillis777 20 часов назад
Why argue about it ? - all we have to do is wait a while and we'll see how Russia gets on with this war. I can't see it making Russia into a 'Great Power', but let's see what happens.
@yoxat1
@yoxat1 День назад
You folks better realize that China is already making things for the Russian war effort and from here on its going to grow. China can produce millions of modern war drones and can field a 200,000,000 man fully equipped army.
@ericwedin4154
@ericwedin4154 3 дня назад
From ”russia is out of shells” to ”Ooops, russian use of massive stockpiles”? What stockpiles, they were out of ammo and had ”already lost the war” last year? Poor analysis then and perhaps now as well…
@trogdortpennypacker6160
@trogdortpennypacker6160 2 дня назад
After the 90s we lost all our Russian expertise. We have no clue when it comes to the place I've concluded. I think in general we were so enamoured by talk of the end of history and being something beyond a superpower that we lost our ability to perform analysis and conduct diplomacy etc. How many Russian and China experts do we probably have that can speak the language and read their media/journals/papers etc. Very few. If China had a US expert who couldn't speak English we would never stop laughing.
@bardsamok9221
@bardsamok9221 21 час назад
They begged North Korea recently because they needed more shells. They had massive stockpiles of 1970s tanks, thousands have been destroyed. They had to change to war economy because of losing massive amounts of resources in the field.
@bardsamok9221
@bardsamok9221 21 час назад
​​​​​​​​​​​​​@@trogdortpennypacker6160Multiple of these on the video speak fluent Russian. English is spoken ubiquitously around the world. Ruzzian, not so much. It's unimportant. Chinese speak English because they are clever at communication and business, they understand their trading partners which is wise. Countries that don't understand each other can often communicate well in English together. Soon Ruzzian language will be Chinese and Kazakh, because the clever Ruzzians leave for nice countries, or become meat waves. They import many replacements. Ruble is already tied to Yuan now, permanently. China also wants a land around Manchuria back, that's how things start. Kazakh, Dagestani.. Also recently India population no longer need to apply for Ruzz visas, to replace numbers. They can just go there. Also Tens of thousands of North Koreans recently. Very different country in 10 years! Ruzzian men are given to the Ukrainian fields.
@trogdortpennypacker6160
@trogdortpennypacker6160 10 часов назад
@@bardsamok9221 They are at 7-8% of GDP on defence spending, although we say it is a war economy we were at 15% of GDP in the Korean War and at 45% in WWII. I agree they've turned up spending but war economy by any definition is wrong. We are at like a 7% deficit and the Russians are only running a 2% deficit. Doesn't scream war economy in my view, even though we use that narrative.
@TheLucidscreamz
@TheLucidscreamz 2 дня назад
when you boycot facing the armys on your mission you get to follow home the hunters prize you seek
@Digmen1
@Digmen1 3 дня назад
I only skimmed through it, but I did not see any details (or actual facts or figures). Unless I missed something. I am getting sick of experts and all of their talk fests on RU-vid (esp Times Radio)
@MrBorceivanovski
@MrBorceivanovski 3 дня назад
This business model creates unbelievable number of family's and personal tragedies 😢
@crogeny
@crogeny 3 дня назад
If you’re fed up with “talk-fests” then why did you watch the video? Is anyone forcing you to watch CSIS and Times Radio content?
@david7384
@david7384 2 дня назад
​@@crogenynobody forced him that's why he skimmed it 😂
@samsungtap4183
@samsungtap4183 3 дня назад
Julian Assarge freed. The free world rejoices.
@JosephGibson
@JosephGibson 3 дня назад
with conditions... I wonder what they are.
@bardsamok9221
@bardsamok9221 21 час назад
​@@JosephGibsonNo Twitter after bedtime.
@chuckbeattyo
@chuckbeattyo 3 дня назад
Thanks, I appreciate such programs. QUESTION: What percentage of the population of Russia understand they are actually fighting Ukraine, and that the Ukrainians are fighting in the degree that the Ukrainians are? QUESTION: What is the "heartstrings" of the Russians for their Ukrainians neighbors/brothers? QUESTION: Do the public Russians have the concept they are at war, or do they still have ignorance of the degree of deaths on both sides? It seems like the issue of the Russian's population understanding of how costly the war is in terms of lives of lost Russians, and lost Ukrainians (neighbors, brothers) would play a huge huge factor in the overall END to the conflict. Do you have research on this angle, or not the purview of your think tank? The obvious best counter attack would be to get the Russian public to become turned against this war, and dry up support for killing Ukrainians and losing their citizens lives fighting there.
@NathansHVAC
@NathansHVAC 3 дня назад
I'll answer below on separate posts
@NathansHVAC
@NathansHVAC 3 дня назад
1 Percent that know they are at waaar with ukraine and not the us? The same percent that watch cnn
@NathansHVAC
@NathansHVAC 3 дня назад
2. Why does russia care about life? The same reason the us didn't care about Iraq liffe. Many citizens in both countries
@NathansHVAC
@NathansHVAC 3 дня назад
3. Do the russians know the west is trying regime change on them? Yep.
@NathansHVAC
@NathansHVAC 3 дня назад
4b. Do the russians know the def count? No. But the cnn russians know it is over 50 million so far.
@plebius
@plebius 3 дня назад
Video starts at 1:54
@TheLucidscreamz
@TheLucidscreamz 2 дня назад
ilya ponomarev and the congtress of the peoples deputies of russia has the protocol completed , the unfolding ofrequirements is occuring ,
@zoeylivermore3400
@zoeylivermore3400 День назад
This discussion seems weirdly very one-sided?
@georgedoolittle9015
@georgedoolittle9015 20 часов назад
New fresh off the line production for Russia appears very good...far better than in the USA which can barely make 155mm howitzer ammo let alone M777 Howitzers. Still clear that Russian Industry is not at all prepared for their World War 3 nor is that moving in a direction that says Russia is becoming so either. This has as a consequence afforded rather not "smartly done"(slow) Western response an awesome amount of time to now change the situation on the ground materially in favor of Ukraine against Russia to include the remarkable changes in Warfare as a result of dirt cheap drones and cell phones/Starlink. I see no way for Russia to recover from their disaster #military_adventure in Ukraine for the time being (6 Months) as a consequence with quite the opposite now currently on the table #war_machine great subject a lot that is now knowable but best to start with a Map and how primitive Russian Military logistics in fact is.
@TheLucidscreamz
@TheLucidscreamz 2 дня назад
is the ticket bought by the congress of peoples deputies of russia, ilya ponomarevs batallions have this common current protocol
@jonnieinbangkok
@jonnieinbangkok День назад
If this is the state of "expert opinion" in Washington, it's no surprise Joe Brandon is loosing his war in Ukraine 🙄 Slava Rossiya 🇷🇺
@SpaceAlien69-kc7zx
@SpaceAlien69-kc7zx 3 дня назад
i wonder if i should try, yet. haha.
@hughgeorgechannel
@hughgeorgechannel 3 дня назад
Shell companies, heh
@nicksanta
@nicksanta 3 дня назад
Hello! Thanks for the analysis. Should I believe this? After all the earlier talking heads believed the second best army in Ukraine would take over in less than a year. Both the army and the TH's failed. Russia has a disposable soldier program! Regards
@Digmen1
@Digmen1 3 дня назад
We just need to look at what Russia did in WW2 when they moved all of their factories to behind the urals. They are on a war footing and the whole economy can be directed towards it. Whereas in the west we struggle to spend 3% of GDP on defence But I do belive that the west can easily out produce Russia and with better weapons
@NathansHVAC
@NathansHVAC 3 дня назад
It is going to be funny when cnn reports that all the russian cities are evacuating and they tell americans to shelter in place. the drones will wiiiinnn ww3.
@randomguy7175
@randomguy7175 3 дня назад
US had defence budget nearly 900 billions
@kevinwaalker
@kevinwaalker 3 дня назад
The equipment the west gave Russia was why they were victorious against Germany.
@jnucleo
@jnucleo 3 дня назад
The US defense budget is an economic disaster. in fact, it's a positive feedback system which will either spark a catastrophic war or break us economically.
@Pierluigi_Di_Lorenzo
@Pierluigi_Di_Lorenzo День назад
Yes, if: - automobile factories, for instance, are retooled to produce simple tanks and aircraft - the labor force in the armaments industry is significantly expanded by the inclusion of women and minorities - supply chains are made more robust and less complex, relying heavily on domestic production and simple logistics networks - the governments play a direct and extensive role in financing and directing production.
@TheLucidscreamz
@TheLucidscreamz 2 дня назад
arms trader jackpot init
@Lynnek8
@Lynnek8 3 дня назад
One innovation is the ‘glide cocoon rocket pod’, where some poor fellow gets inside a pod and gets slingshot out whereupon a little rocket accelerates him via gps glide and like base jump parachutes at the end and he simply hatches out with all his kit. If accuracy was decent they could land safely in good spots. If there’s mobile launchers it’s like loading up artillery except with poor wretches in little re usable plastic or metal planes like theme park ride styles, they could even have macabre humour by painting over the camo, like the ‘red baron’ or ‘led zeppelin’ mig ufo
@yoxat1
@yoxat1 День назад
You don't need a person to guide a bomb.
@bardsamok9221
@bardsamok9221 21 час назад
You just described their space program. 'To the moooon!'
@danielcunningham2394
@danielcunningham2394 День назад
made it 10 minutes, still no substance if you follow the war.
@hawklord100
@hawklord100 9 часов назад
The russians are running out of wire brushes scrapping and brushing 50 years of rust off all those ancient chunks of metal they inherited from the old bust soviet empire 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@TheLucidscreamz
@TheLucidscreamz 2 дня назад
victory looks like the sbu version of sas film in russia finding putin and prooving its over for him
@LR-jk2jk
@LR-jk2jk 20 часов назад
I did not have to watch this babble to summarize it for you: if russian defense industry is still functioning, then we are not serious about winning this conflict.
@stevemuir5384
@stevemuir5384 3 дня назад
😅😂😂😂
@jerkerplobeck2922
@jerkerplobeck2922 3 дня назад
Very competent indiviuals totally focusing on just one side of the issue, exept for the last couple of minutes. Economy stupid! The russian economy take a massive beating right now; the currancy, inflation and the revenues from oil and gas. The strong economic figures right now reflect a boost from the war economy, not from fundamentals and is not going to last for long. 2026 Russia will have problem to continue the war; Ukraine has no alternative...
@david7384
@david7384 2 дня назад
2 more weeks
@user-ci3rk5bl2k
@user-ci3rk5bl2k 3 дня назад
😂😂😂😂😂
@TheLucidscreamz
@TheLucidscreamz 2 дня назад
the trojan horse of moscow has names dugin , putin lavrov peskov
@jimcroft3633
@jimcroft3633 3 дня назад
I imagine they come up with this report using an otjie board. Political science is opinion not science but opinion. Engineers would be better qualified to analyze military production since they know math
@NathansHVAC
@NathansHVAC 3 дня назад
For some reason all sources are ukranian. Must be true, say the swammp
@MercuryCold
@MercuryCold 3 дня назад
That's quite the imagination you have
@rmdomainer9042
@rmdomainer9042 3 дня назад
It is ouija board, moron
@TheLucidscreamz
@TheLucidscreamz 2 дня назад
the trojan horse of moscow
@jackiebinns6205
@jackiebinns6205 День назад
So just get on hear and say you dont have a clue and all this other bs talk is mute ! YOU DONT KNOW DUH 😮
@samsungtap4183
@samsungtap4183 3 дня назад
The Russian economy is booming in a phenomenon not seen since the US in the 1940s. Shall I be so bold as to say Keynesian military economics. However i feel that Russia may face the same problem as the US. How do you stop fighting when war has become so profitable. Here in Vietnam we know all about it.
@barracuda7018
@barracuda7018 2 дня назад
Russian economy is booming 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@Unknown-gi1uj
@Unknown-gi1uj 3 дня назад
Not sure if its worth my time. Ill simply highlight that 1991 saw the collapse of the Russian defence industry as the bad advice saw it crumble. Unlike western countries, these capabilities were mothballed, not that Russia is at war these old factories are again back in operation and you see the economy doing well. In terms of completion with western defence industry who have held a monopoly over the last 30 years, i think there is no better example then the 6th gen fighter program that will see the fewest number of jets ever acquired in a new generational airplane which will be supplemented with highly disposable, highly advanced and very expensive in terms of acquisition and research. Key point here id disposable, since when did anything in terms of the most advanced research become disposable? The U-2 was grounded over a single lose, the lose of a F117 was considered a complete disaster. So id be more worried about the western defence industry, rather then speculating on the Russian one considering once this war end and the sanctions are removed your going to be dealing with this giants Russian defence instrutry that is going to be exporting brand new, proven, military capabilities while the west is building disposable crap as if they following the China model of exports. Maybe speculate the SU-57 is still in prototyping, likewise the Armada Tank. What going to happen in 10 years when these two military capabilities are pitted against some crap the western military has concocted as "disposable" when they have more of the most restricted manufacturing bases in terms of expansion? Which we have seen with an inability to deal with shell shortages. Should be looking in your own back yard and be critical there, before you sit on your high horse talking about a Russian defence industry that is outproducing the collective western world by themselves and actually making ground. Less about Russian capabilities and more related to the fact western defence is a joke that hasn't won a conflict since WW2 and just goes around killing people who can't really fight back inwhich they still lost too.
@Unknown-gi1uj
@Unknown-gi1uj 3 дня назад
Western defence industry is incapable of producing the correct weapons to fight a conflict. Which ultimately stems from corruption of these companies who undermine democracy. It doesn't help that US politics is considering a pathway for the socialist construct of the military. The military feeds you, houses you, makes your exercise and stay healthy. That sort of baseline failure of basic human function path wayed into decision making is a high degree of corruption based entirely on the networks they have created within this socialists construct.= And you see this very poor level of discipline, in terms of saying in your own lane, when it comes to things like accountability of war-crimes. Amount of American in Ukraine that say they don't take prisoners, basically admitting to murdering people who surrender. That level of "the rules don't apply to me" is seen within the defence sector and when your talking about commercial competition. Well enjoy your Chinese 6th gen jets... im sure many countries can't wait to get their hands on those AI wingmen to use in their own mass producted creations. Maybe drone swarms or soemthing aye? When can i expect to be able to find AI just lying around on the ground because its military based AI is disposable.
@MercuryCold
@MercuryCold 3 дня назад
Wasn't worth the time, your analysis is trash
@JosephGibson
@JosephGibson 3 дня назад
I'll sum up what you; just how much of our tax monies in the West is siphoned off by god knows who as it was in the Russian sphere? Yeah, we should be focusing more on our own backyard and investigating every single b*tch and d*ckhead enriching themselves at our expense.
@jonathanbowen3640
@jonathanbowen3640 2 дня назад
Weird comment. The F117A was considered a successful aircraft overall and saw plenty of service in its lifetime from 1983 to 2008. Its talked about as as being one of the best light bombers ever. A total revolution over previous bombers that struggled particularly in the Vietnam theatre for example. F117 had a great mission success rate. That one got shot down by a lucky shot that was never repeated was not a big deal for the USAF. They just tweaked a few things and it was never shot down again.
@Unknown-gi1uj
@Unknown-gi1uj 2 дня назад
​@@jonathanbowen3640 Id like to remind you that it was shot down in 1999, so yeah its shoot down was a big deal as within a decade the aircraft was considered obsolete. I think you fail to grasp the concept of losing one aircraft in combat, and losing compounding aircraft in combat and what kind of capabilities that gives your enemy. A good example of this is Iran with the RQ-170 drone, it wasn't shot down, they captured it fully intact. Inwhich they reversed engineered it now have a domestic product that is in use in Ukraine. You may have heard of the Shahed drone. Point i am getting at, is advanced research is NEVER considered disposable. It loss to the enemy is considered a political nightmare for policy makers as billions in research funds and handed over to your enemy. So when we consider AI controlled wingmen, well i would call it blatant corruption and international interference at the highest levels of research and development. Coming from either the defence complex themselves, or within public office putting forward buzz word capabilities or its both and the complex is full of traitors. I don't think you really grasp the whole concept of an AI piloted wingman in an atmosphere of jamming technology. Your not merely losing manufacturing secrets like the honeycomb structure of the F117. But the software, i don't think you really grasp the concept that American coders are subpar when considering their counterparts who have much less processing power and have to optimize their code a hell of a lot more. With hundreds of J-6 aircraft already set up as drones, a single AI windman that has the AI stolen could pilot an entire fleet of hundreds of obsolete fighter aircraft is swarm formations. Quantity has a quality of its own and you just handed the people with quantity a pilot that can fly anything, everything, at the same time. Has to be the dumbest conceptual thinking that has ever propagated within the defence industry. Even movies like Matrix and Terminator leaves questions like how did humanity lose air superiority? There is something seriously wrong in American. Personally i think its NAZI ideology within the Military, this sense of national identity with this leeching off the tax payer because they are lazy and entitled. They care more about themselves, then the nation and actively work to undermine both the country and its politics. All is pursuit of money and power. Not grasping the growing threat of China, Globalists, NWO and Climate Fanatics that want to see the oil producing giant that is the USA crumble and banned from the energy market.
@jonnieinbangkok
@jonnieinbangkok День назад
Slava Rossiya 🇷🇺 😂 😂 😂 #FUkraine
@black__bread
@black__bread 2 дня назад
The report takes Russian output data at face value (despite it being a weapon in an information war), underestimates visually confirmed Russian tank losses in 2023 by c.20% and references output without giving numbers (the International Institute for Strategic Studies estimate new build T90-M production might reach 90p.a. in 2025 up from 40 pre invasion, so just 50 more tanks!). Then there's the obvious point that Russia's drone warfare is based on Iranian drones and assembling Chinese kits. For whatever reason there's a stink here of better to exaggerate than to underestimate.
@barracuda7018
@barracuda7018 2 дня назад
Russian propaganda is the most powerful weapon of this criminal regime...
@TheLucidscreamz
@TheLucidscreamz 2 дня назад
crimea is a lost cause for putin , his expenses lost in airdefence and naval capbility and lost of logistical supply security of territory ,crimea will not be a holiday location next summer for muscovites
@ioneliordache3699
@ioneliordache3699 3 дня назад
Bla,bla,bla !! Pathetic propaganda !!!
@krazyswede11
@krazyswede11 День назад
All you need is Brian Berletic New Atlas and you'll know more than these educated idiots.
@krazyswede11
@krazyswede11 День назад
Its soooo painful for these Neoliberals sad reports of growth and their problems of expanding 😂😂😂
Далее
I Built a SECRET McDonald’s In My Room!
36:00
Просмотров 6 млн
🎤Пою РЕТРО Песни ✧˖°
3:04:48
Просмотров 1,7 млн
Задержали в аэропорту
00:56
Просмотров 213 тыс.
Balaji Srinivasan on Fiat Crisis, Russia, and China
1:19:16
EU bypasses Hungarian veto | Jowanka Jakubek-Lalik
14:50