Тёмный

The True Tragic Victims of Dinosaur Movies 

Gamma
Подписаться 6 тыс.
Просмотров 913 тыс.
50% 1

Jurassic World Dominion and other Jurassic World movies, Disney's Dinosaur etc. have a problem: they portray carnivore, Prey eating dinosaurs negatively (some exceptions: Blue the Velociraptor & the T. Rex, Rexy from JP/JW). Let's tackle this animal trope (similar to my Therizinosaurus herbivores are cute vid) that also appears in things like Jaws, Beast 2022 etc. and discuss its several instances in dinosaur movies
#jurassicworld #jurassicworlddominion #animals #dinosaur

Опубликовано:

 

12 авг 2022

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 2,8 тыс.   
@sphereunitedheroes7936
@sphereunitedheroes7936 Год назад
Honestly, it's true since us, humans, are always viewing carnivorous dinosaurs as vicious beast instead of considering them as ordinary animals.
@Gamma138
@Gamma138 Год назад
Yeah and I guess evolutionarily it makes sense since we were preyed on by many carnivores, so I guess it’s still a primitive remnant of it
@zandergonzalez5190
@zandergonzalez5190 Год назад
Carnivores aren’t evil there friendly even RU-vid allow people had pets which is a larger carnivore
@Tyresaurus
@Tyresaurus Год назад
@@Gamma138 Thank you so much for spreading this message. I am really sick of seeing carnivores being portrayed as monsters. I'm thinking of making a protest video about it too.
@AnAmericanMusician
@AnAmericanMusician Год назад
In all fairness, most people don't even consider humans as a part of the natural ecosystem either.
@sphereunitedheroes7936
@sphereunitedheroes7936 Год назад
@@Tyresaurus If they're going to portray carnivores as villains, they shouldn't let them be killed off. They can be defeated but they don't deserve death as they're only following their natural instincts.
@jacobcox4565
@jacobcox4565 8 месяцев назад
Oddly enough, the T. rex breakout scene from the original Jurassic Park does well to portray the T. rex as an animal. She was given a very light snack in the form of a goat. When she noticed the gates weren't electified, she broke free of her confinement. From then on she seemed more like a curious and hungry animal. The only prey available were the humans. The only times she attacked were when the humans drew her attention to themselves. The T. rex couple getting their baby back in Jurassic Park: The Lost World, and the scene in Jurassic Park III where Alan and the rest give the Velociraptors their eggs back also show how these predators are animals and not bloodthirsty monsters.
@minecad2828
@minecad2828 8 месяцев назад
And also how after that in The Lost World they run around the jungle knowing that t rexes aren't hungry anymore so they won't be aggresive
@jacobcox4565
@jacobcox4565 8 месяцев назад
@@minecad2828 Except the Buck will get the scent of his offspring from Harding's clothes and go to the camp in order to find his baby.
@roguetheoutlander8800
@roguetheoutlander8800 8 месяцев назад
​@@jacobcox4565Buck, not Bull
@thomasfplm
@thomasfplm 8 месяцев назад
​@@jacobcox4565, and even then, he's not a villain, but a victim trying to recover his family.
@Man_Aslume
@Man_Aslume 8 месяцев назад
Rexy is just eating lay chips compared to what a T rex needs to eat The 2 parents aren't villianzed, but just give the horror of encountering a angry T rex
@Darknimbus3
@Darknimbus3 7 месяцев назад
Interesting to note: In the DND world, much of the non-intellectual predators, no matter how vicious they are, like tigers, lions, etc. are rated as “Unaligned”, as they don’t understand the concepts of good and evil- only natural instinct and need for food for survival.
@Lickicker
@Lickicker 5 месяцев назад
Ya, people forget, we do the same thing. If i go and shoot a deer to eat, thats fairly morally gray depending on who you ask. A vegan might say its always evil, but hunters and alot of average people would most likely agree killing a animal is only evil if you waste the body. I cant fault anyone for wanting to eat.
@eestaashottentotti2242
@eestaashottentotti2242 5 месяцев назад
Some animals can act for revenge or gratitude. I think that needs some kind of understanding about good and evil.
@nevisysbryd7450
@nevisysbryd7450 5 месяцев назад
​@@eestaashottentotti2242Emotional responses do not require empathy or intent; they are automatic cognitive functions. Animals lack the sort of self-awareness to grasp more than a very rudimentary level of cause and effect or to empathize and by extension to act to deliberately affect others beyond responding to their impulses and conditioning. Animals are incapable of ethical consideration and the entire category of ethics is inapplicable to them.
@warthoggoulags1679
@warthoggoulags1679 5 месяцев назад
​@@Lickickerthere is nothing evil on killing other animals that's nature
@ItsCreaidan
@ItsCreaidan 5 месяцев назад
This is a great comment!
@joshuabond5223
@joshuabond5223 7 месяцев назад
I’m so glad someone finally said it. I’ve gotten tired of media portraying animals as evil creatures. There are very few, if any, truly evil animals out there.
@astalouroboros2955
@astalouroboros2955 7 месяцев назад
As far as i know the only evil animals had previous contact with humans
@Promislandzion
@Promislandzion 7 месяцев назад
Humans are truely vile creatures.
@riverman6462
@riverman6462 7 месяцев назад
The only truly utterly despicable animal out there is The Hippopotamus. This herbivorous devil is extremely vicious
@NicoEdgy
@NicoEdgy 7 месяцев назад
@@astalouroboros2955How did humans cause the evilness of dolphins? Explain yourself…
@Srcruser
@Srcruser 7 месяцев назад
Again, when you have a movie centered around wildlife (animals/dinosaurs) or whatever, something has to be the obstacle/villain that gives action scenes. There’s literally no choice besides a villainous human which they usually also include. It’s not accurate but accuracy is not an option
@austindavis4816
@austindavis4816 8 месяцев назад
That’s why I’ve always loved that quote of “to a mouse a cat is a monster, we’re just use to being the cat.”.
@thomasfplm
@thomasfplm 8 месяцев назад
Another one that is similar, but a bit in the opposite side: "Normal is an illusion. What is normal to the spider is chaos to the fly." - Morticia Addams
@AdrianMarinMarinoES
@AdrianMarinMarinoES 8 месяцев назад
Sadly most people do not realize that these carnivores are just following their instincts or just doing their jobs maintaining the ecological balance
@gamerstheater1187
@gamerstheater1187 8 месяцев назад
YES! On one hand, it's a fluffy baby, but to the bird it's a demon from hell
@ocinprofession
@ocinprofession 7 месяцев назад
@@AdrianMarinMarinoES Then people get mad when a carnivore eats a human humans are just animals which can be eaten like any other but apparently they're better then all of nature.
@peteralexandergraae2830
@peteralexandergraae2830 7 месяцев назад
good and evil looks very similar from the wrong side of the dinner plate
@Fauler1917
@Fauler1917 Год назад
I asked one guy once "A tiger trys to hunt a deer, who is running for their life?" The guy said it was obviously the deer. It was both..
@blobbertmcblob4888
@blobbertmcblob4888 Год назад
"When a tiger chases the deer, they're both running for their lives"
@terrytheinsane
@terrytheinsane Год назад
wrong tigers do not run after deer
@PaperClipping7412
@PaperClipping7412 Год назад
Imagine just walking in the woods and someone goes up to you and just a asks that question. I’m not mad don’t worry it’s just a lil funny if it wasn’t someone you knew lol
@severalkenobies9860
@severalkenobies9860 10 месяцев назад
@@terrytheinsane so....they fly?
@terrytheinsane
@terrytheinsane 10 месяцев назад
@@severalkenobies9860 tigers don't chase deer because they know deer can outrun them and it isn't worth wasting energy.
@parrycarry
@parrycarry 7 месяцев назад
In Jurassic Park 3, when the group come up on a dead carcass and a T-Rex pops up, it isn't chasing them because it is hungry... it has food, it is simply chasing the big group of tiny animals away from its food and territory. The rex inadvertently chases them into the Spinosaurus, and they fight over territory. It was a clever way to get them to fight.
@woolfyx
@woolfyx 6 месяцев назад
In reality he would just scare them off with roar and never move away from prey more than few meters. T-Rex and Spinosaurus also would never fight to death. In JP theropods act like monsters not animals, it's action movie not documentary.
@nickymejias5763
@nickymejias5763 5 месяцев назад
and that rex was big eattie mate.
@fmac6441
@fmac6441 5 месяцев назад
​@@woolfyxT. rex in The Lost World is well portrayed as an animal. Of course he probably wouldn't attack a bus but rather run away in the opposite direction, but at the end of the day movies need to entertain
@woolfyx
@woolfyx 5 месяцев назад
@@fmac6441 Of course, it's hard to demand from action movies to realistically portray dinosaurus behavior because they wouldn't be entertaining, key is to find good balance. Documantary series are for that.
@averagetectonicplateenjoyer
@averagetectonicplateenjoyer 5 месяцев назад
⁠@@fmac6441 it would likely attempt to intimidate the bus considering that from the rex’s perspective it is a large unknown thing that is “roaring” and moving quickly towards it but unless they actively tried to ram it into the rex or something dumb like that it would likely only threaten and if humans got out and started running it wouldn’t even bother chasing them
@Azoth5876
@Azoth5876 7 месяцев назад
I do recall reading an article that the Indominus Rex's behaviour in JW was based off accounts of escaped tigers that grew up in acaptiviry and didn't know how to behave as normal animals. Apparently they went on a killing spree when they escaped.
@Toadey2012
@Toadey2012 29 дней назад
No way pre
@megalodongaming7635
@megalodongaming7635 Год назад
In Disney Dinosaur it makes sense that the carnos are represented like that, since the story is told from Aladar's pov, and for a herbivore, a carnivore its a monster.
@m1sty033
@m1sty033 11 месяцев назад
True.
@the_blue_jay_raptor
@the_blue_jay_raptor 10 месяцев назад
If this was accurate (speaking about the species of dinos in the movie) then aladar would be fine (carno is much smaller than iguanodon)
@beastmaster0934
@beastmaster0934 9 месяцев назад
And on top of that, the Carnotaurs are probably desperate for a meal, due to the famine that was going on thanks to the meteor.
@rafaelcarpio7055
@rafaelcarpio7055 9 месяцев назад
In Jurassic world Henry wu says to a canary a cat is a monster
@GreaterGrievobeast55
@GreaterGrievobeast55 8 месяцев назад
They even had another Iguanodon act at a sort of societal antagonist in the movie. So it's not like herbivores are painted as perfect angels either
@Dakotaraptor_Official
@Dakotaraptor_Official Год назад
THIS IS SO TRUE, especially because herbivores can be more dangerous, because if they see you as a threat, you can't negotiate that you're not worth attacking, with carnivores you can negotiate that you're not worth hunting
@IceGodzilla619
@IceGodzilla619 9 месяцев назад
Well for carnivores depends A herbivore 9/10 will attack you no matter
@seankennethleblanc6235
@seankennethleblanc6235 8 месяцев назад
A hippo can eat you whole An elephant can crush every bone in your body A zebra/horse can kick you so damn hard your skull would cave in Same goes for ostriches if they didn’t run
@a_random_lizard
@a_random_lizard 8 месяцев назад
Meanwhile alligators and lions, after they eat, just looks at you and didn't even bother to chase you
@IceGodzilla619
@IceGodzilla619 8 месяцев назад
@@a_random_lizard go infront of a polar bear and komodo dragons first
@realdragon
@realdragon 8 месяцев назад
*cough cough* hippos
@beastmaster0934
@beastmaster0934 5 месяцев назад
It’s always funny when people portray carnivorous animals as hyper aggressive and who kill with little to no provocation, while herbivores are usually portrayed as shy creatures who’d much prefer to flee from danger, rather than fight. When in reality, it’s quite the opposite.
@KakeruHibiki
@KakeruHibiki Месяц назад
Just like snakes. Most snakes are shy and they would run away instead of bloodthirsty-like chase me to death.
@lydiegpe
@lydiegpe 7 месяцев назад
This is why I liked Prehistoric Planet so much, it portrayed dinosaurs as ACTUAL animals and not spectacle monsters like in most movies Okok, I know PP is mainly a documentary, but still enjoyable to watch if you love dinos, heck even in scenes where they could have gotten cheap views with predators hunting and killing prey, it shows you sometimes they fail (like real carnivores), and most often than not do more stuff than just hunt, for example the scene of the carnotaur 'dance' is was pretty funny and cute imo
@dannyx1991
@dannyx1991 5 месяцев назад
Oh yes. The Carnotaurus "spirit fingers" scene was the best thing I saw in PP.
@asejernberg4267
@asejernberg4267 5 месяцев назад
Fuly agree with you, PP its a real good documentary, show "right side" of things, I aswell dont like this Carnivore is bad killing machines..
@Edelweiss1102
@Edelweiss1102 5 месяцев назад
I love that we got like 4 T Rex scenes, which are all fantastic, and none of them involves active hunting or fighting another anachronistic big theropod for the sake of it.
@KhanMann66
@KhanMann66 5 месяцев назад
PP is good but walking with dinosaurs still tops it. PP felt too clean and not enough brutality.
@TheKingofCoral
@TheKingofCoral 2 месяца назад
@@KhanMann66yeh all bite marks just felt like litterally flesh wounds
@VarunPrabhakar104
@VarunPrabhakar104 8 месяцев назад
I knew Dominion would break my Jurassic Park-loving heart when I read this about the Giganotosaurus in an interview: "I wanted something that felt like the Joker," Trevorrow said. "It just wants to watch the world burn." Not only is that ridiculous, but he's also just describing the Indominus Rex.
@Gamma138
@Gamma138 8 месяцев назад
Yeah exactly when I read that I was like “really?”. Honestly it’s beyond absurd and so like, try-hard. I’m glad it didn’t really turn out that way but either way. I made a video on this where I discuss that more if you wanna check it out 😎
@nitrozeus6393
@nitrozeus6393 8 месяцев назад
@@Gamma138 hey can you please make a new video your videos are great
@snax7760
@snax7760 3 месяца назад
It’s funny how the only somewhat evil Dino is one 100% made by humans
@KingDrakoTyrell
@KingDrakoTyrell 3 месяца назад
WTF would a dinosaur want the world to burn the world?
@joebrat6809
@joebrat6809 3 месяца назад
Let's hope it doesn't get voiced by Jared Leto in the reboot lol!
@douglasphillips5870
@douglasphillips5870 8 месяцев назад
I remember in the first Jerasic Park movie when the girl was frightened by a dinosaur and the boy told her not to worry because it was a vegetarian. A rhino is vegetarian, a hippo is vegetarian, a buffalo is vegetarian. Vegetarian s can be really dangerous.
@bidoof4426
@bidoof4426 5 месяцев назад
Hippo are vegetarian but they kill more person per year than crocodiles and white sharks
@santi_super_stunts2573
@santi_super_stunts2573 5 месяцев назад
Yes VEGETARIANS ARE MONSTERS. let’s make movies on how evil vegetarians are they are disgusting taking the life of poor plants
@juliangonzalez304
@juliangonzalez304 4 месяца назад
Totally agree
@ayushmankar4100
@ayushmankar4100 4 месяца назад
Elephants & silver backed gorillas too
@Ieatpaste23
@Ieatpaste23 4 месяца назад
I'd rather come upon a pack of wolves then a momma moose any day. Herbivores are crazy dangerous.
@Gamergirl-172
@Gamergirl-172 7 месяцев назад
I think it would actually be more terrifying if the indominus Rex was a herbivore but still attacked people because it would show how insane it actually went and how Abuse and teeny tiny enclosures destroy an animal and could have been a lesson
@Anchorin
@Anchorin Месяц назад
That wouldn't have made any sense, but it's a cool idea.
@andrewdau1299
@andrewdau1299 7 месяцев назад
Thank you for making this. I feel like this trope doesn't get discussed enough in regard to carnivores. Funny enough, the only time a carnivore in a dinosaur movie I saw was portrayed positively was with Chomper in the Land Before Time sequels. As bad as those movies were, Chomper was still treated with respect.
@girlgarde
@girlgarde 8 месяцев назад
I tend to regard the Indominus Rex's villainous actions as her being psychotic due to not being raised with love and affection, being experimented on AND kept in a temporary prison for far too long. She wasn't evil, simply insane and full of primal rage at the world around her.
@zebimicio5204
@zebimicio5204 8 месяцев назад
And they kind of made that a point too (pratt mentioned about how it grown up only with cranes giving it food instead of actually got care like any natural born creatures had)
@librandojuanmiguel7335
@librandojuanmiguel7335 8 месяцев назад
Same im kinda insane
@CryosisOfficial
@CryosisOfficial 8 месяцев назад
I mean, it killed its sister as hatchlings. It is kind of its own fault that it was raised in isolation (it always bugged me that Claire never mentioned that fact to Owen when he was complaining about it being on its own). Though that also highlights the fact that the enclosure was way too small if they originally planned to house two Indominusi in there. It's been a while but I believe there was also a line where Claire said that it tried to attack and eat the human feeders which is why they now use a crane.
@Brandonutss
@Brandonutss 8 месяцев назад
@@CryosisOfficialexcept killing its sibling would be completely normal. Many birds, especially birds of prey kill there siblings within the first weeks that their born. And birds are dinosaurs so maybe that happened with other theropods too.
@CryosisOfficial
@CryosisOfficial 8 месяцев назад
@@Brandonutss Ok? Doesn't make it not its own fault that it is alone.
@netherdominater9960
@netherdominater9960 9 месяцев назад
Small note: the paddock they had Indominus in wasn’t its permanent enclosure, it was a temporary holding area until they moved it into its official exhibit in the park. However it does seem to be implied it was kept here for much longer than it was supposed to be, which likely contributed to its aggressiveness
@astalouroboros2955
@astalouroboros2955 7 месяцев назад
I think it was also said somewhere that it killed its sibling because they werent given enough food to support their rapid growth
@Kitty_Cat_24
@Kitty_Cat_24 Месяц назад
​@@astalouroboros2955 so being a carnivore, she must have eaten her sister. Perhaps the worst sibling in the world would do that but still it can be understood when it comes to animals.
@breadthealien
@breadthealien 5 месяцев назад
This is why I love Dead Sound's dinosaur animations, both the Dinosauria series and Sharp Teeth portray the carnivores correctly, as animals. One of my favorite scenes is from A More Ancient Spring, where the Lambeosaurus protagonist encounters a theropod (forgot the specific species), one that hunted it's mate earlier in the film. Instead of immediately attacking the lambeosaurus it roared and threatened it, trying to get it away from it's eggs and didn't chase it after the lambeosaurus ran away, being more concerned with if it's eggs were ok.
@TimeTravelerJessica
@TimeTravelerJessica 5 месяцев назад
Given the modern example of how aggressive bison and hippos can be, would love to see a dinosaur movie where the therapods are just chilling and the real threat is the triceratops.
@GamerMage2k-kl4iq
@GamerMage2k-kl4iq 2 месяца назад
Wonder how Hollywood would adapt that
@GamerMage2k-kl4iq
@GamerMage2k-kl4iq Месяц назад
@@Kitty_Cat_24 EXCUSE ME, WHAT?!?!
@Kitty_Cat_24
@Kitty_Cat_24 Месяц назад
@@GamerMage2k-kl4iq hippos often eat fishes. By swallowing them.
@65firered
@65firered Месяц назад
​​@@GamerMage2k-kl4iq Depends on if we're getting someone who can ACTUALLY write. Some may say, "just avoid Disney" but clearly that's not enough.
@GamerMage2k-kl4iq
@GamerMage2k-kl4iq Месяц назад
@@65firered That’s a good point
@AnAmericanMusician
@AnAmericanMusician Год назад
Remember in The Lost World where the group felt safe running through the jungle because they knew that T Rex wouldn't eat if they weren't hungry? Those were the days...
@marckrieger3277
@marckrieger3277 8 месяцев назад
Remember The lost world were the island was divided in a herbivore and a carnivore part? Makes totally no sense even for me as a child.
@thegoodreylo4749
@thegoodreylo4749 8 месяцев назад
The best Jurassic Park movie
@silent_stalker3687
@silent_stalker3687 8 месяцев назад
@@marckrieger3277only if it’s the ‘oh hey we put these animals in these locations as the park so the animals would in theory be divided by how the park would be divided’
@CryosisOfficial
@CryosisOfficial 8 месяцев назад
@@marckrieger3277 When was this? We literally see herbivores and carnivores right next to each other in the movie, completely unphased by each other.
@marckrieger3277
@marckrieger3277 8 месяцев назад
@@CryosisOfficial Lost World, the whole Plan of the Expedition of Hammond and Ludlow Was based on the fact (backed on infrared satelites) that the carnivores only lived in the Center of sorna, the herbivores lived on the outskirts.
@mikeydrago-dt8by
@mikeydrago-dt8by Год назад
I noticed you said that Kron from Disney's Dinosaur was the one that killed the Carnotaurus' mate. That was a mistake. Brutus was the one who killed the Carnotaurus' mate, but Brutus died in the cave in as well, playing the hero trope so that Aladar and the others could escape. He sacrificed himself to cause the cave in. This is humanising a herbivore, even though it was mainly a tragic accident. If you noticed. The Carno who died is the one who grabbed Brutus and threw him into the pillar. Now back to the moment with Kron. The Carno chose to go after him, because it was acting like an animal, picking out the straggler from a herd. Which is what they do in reality. They will often hunt the straggler because it wouldn't be protected by the herd. They will often hunt the one that falls behind. They also will often hunt a weak or dying animal. EDIT: But I agree with you wholheartedly. Carnivores are way too often depicted as villains in movies. The Jurassic World creators only had Rexy killing the carnivores that went after the humans, for fan service. And it got more and more farfetched every time.
@pokityrannus5471
@pokityrannus5471 Год назад
*Bruton
@NolanDraconis
@NolanDraconis 10 месяцев назад
And the carno (the larger one that survived the cave collapse) was named in the script Andrew, he was also seen in the beginning of the movie and possibly later found his mate who truly goes unnamed.
@ruyaki7057
@ruyaki7057 10 месяцев назад
Do the disney carnos have names? Are they mates or siblings?
@NolanDraconis
@NolanDraconis 10 месяцев назад
@@ruyaki7057 my previous message gave the answer, but I’ll say it again, the larger Carno was named in the script Andrew and the other smaller carno that died to Bruton and the cave collapse was Andrew’s mate. In short one has a name, and they are mates not siblings.
@ruyaki7057
@ruyaki7057 10 месяцев назад
@@NolanDraconis thx
@eminkilicaslan8945
@eminkilicaslan8945 5 месяцев назад
Dude: Carnivores Auto subtitles: Best I can do is 'p*rn of wars'
@michaelbaker7499
@michaelbaker7499 7 месяцев назад
Completely agree. I’d love to see a film that includes dinosaurs, maybe even reboots the Jurassic Park franchise, that portrays predators as just animals. Think how much of a plot twist and surprise it would be if the scary predator that had been following the protagonists all movie was just being curious. Think how good it would be to show a carnivore actually showing fear. You start waving a flaming torch at an animal, it’s likely to be unnerved by that thing and back down. You start firing at a carnivore with a gun, it’s likely to back down, especially if it has no experience of guns. How cool and refreshing would it be where the antagonist is facing the environment, or another person and it just so happens that carnivores are there.
@65firered
@65firered Месяц назад
Reboot everything after the first movie.
@WingedFish66
@WingedFish66 8 месяцев назад
Another thing about the Carnotarus is that it is the only time in a Disney movie where the villain gets the "death fall" treatment and you fully see the body afterwards
@MatteoBiondillo
@MatteoBiondillo 8 месяцев назад
Only because his skin was strong enough to not create a bloodbath after the fall 😂
@yaqubebased1961
@yaqubebased1961 7 месяцев назад
Mufasa? You see his body, too.
@WingedFish66
@WingedFish66 7 месяцев назад
@@yaqubebased1961 Mufasa isn't a villain
@yaqubebased1961
@yaqubebased1961 7 месяцев назад
@@WingedFish66 right
@Wicked_Weavile0808
@Wicked_Weavile0808 7 месяцев назад
Technically you see Clayton's body in Tarzan
@angryboi595
@angryboi595 8 месяцев назад
This is why I like Primal. Even carnivores are treated as animals. When Red dies (Fang’s boyfriend) we aren’t meant to cheer that the “evil” carnivore is dead, it’s a genuinely tragic moment. You even understood some of the dinosaur villains and they aren’t shown as evil. The truly evil villains are non-dinosaur abominations or humans. Which makes sense. Like the Night Feeder, it’s more like a strange being of witchcraft that violently kills everything, and the plague Sauropod, it’s seen as tragic due to the plague it suffered and it’s not shown as it’s fault, though I’m still glad we got a herbivore as a villain. I’m tired of carnivore villains tbh
@AdvancedGamer-
@AdvancedGamer- 8 месяцев назад
Yeah but if you think about it herbivore villains are kind of not fun,
@Flammifleure
@Flammifleure 7 месяцев назад
@@AdvancedGamer- Why not?
@AdvancedGamer-
@AdvancedGamer- 7 месяцев назад
@@Flammifleure because the herbivores just kinda hit you with a tail or stomp you, meanwhile the carnivorous starts chasing its fun and entertaining, a herbivore chasing wouldn’t be that entertaining
@nyctotheory
@nyctotheory 7 месяцев назад
There’s entire bloodsport festivals based around how entertaining and deadly bulls chasing humans can be.
@deleylerody3462
@deleylerody3462 7 месяцев назад
​@@AdvancedGamer-it wasnt entertaining it was terrifying
@elastico8576
@elastico8576 7 месяцев назад
Same with herbivores being portrayed as calm harmless creatures. Theri was the first herbivore they showed in Jurassic World that was territorial, perhabs a bit too much aggressive, but herbivores in the wild will most likely not just chill with you. They are more like wild Elephants and not domesticated cows.
@vrthief
@vrthief 7 месяцев назад
I like that camp Cretaceous (the newer Jurassic world show) would often depict the dinosaurs like animals, being social and having peaceful watering zones.
@nabuchodonosormcgalapatram6941
@nabuchodonosormcgalapatram6941 8 месяцев назад
Wasn't the reason as to why the Indominus was a total psycho exactly because it was mistreaded and in a tiny enclosure? It's seemingly a very intelligent and complex animal; it was said in the movie that its only positive relationship was with the crane that fed it, that it doesn't know what it is and what is its place in its environment, and the "killing for sports" thing seems to be more experimenting than anything else. Also considering it socialized with the raptors and (at least to me) seemed more perplexed than anything else about that other giant Theropod that didn't hesitate to attack it, it looks to me like it was actually not as solitary as it seemed... All of this to say that, yes, the Indominus was a victim of circumstances, and considering the whole "you wanted a monster" and "the animals are assets" thing, it was likely done on purpose.
@desmondedwards6628
@desmondedwards6628 5 месяцев назад
The indoraptor was treated the same way
@CreatureLove-A189
@CreatureLove-A189 4 месяца назад
It is as Owen said, "Animals raised in isolation aren't the most stable." And with how big the Indominus got the size of the enclosure was the equivalent of a orca in a tank.
@desmondedwards6628
@desmondedwards6628 4 месяца назад
@@CreatureLove-A189 Imagine if they made a male in dominus rex. They said that a male in dominus would be far more dangerous
@-drxxms-dxlight
@-drxxms-dxlight 2 месяца назад
​@@desmondedwards6628Wasnt there another Indominous made but the Indo we see in the movie, as stated by Claire, "She ate it"? /genq
@desmondedwards6628
@desmondedwards6628 2 месяца назад
@@-drxxms-dxlight It was her sister not a male
@dinoz7828
@dinoz7828 Год назад
I find it so funny that the v-rex's mainly focusing on that tiny human when they could really just gang up on Kong and attack him which would provide them more food if they were really that hungry but because they're focusing on the tiny human Kong is kicking their ass, and they should really just go for Kong first and then once they take down him they can kill the tiny human too like it's that simple
@saidi7975
@saidi7975 Год назад
Poor V.rex did not deserve to job like that.
@Train_lizard
@Train_lizard 11 месяцев назад
On the contrary, it’s because V. Rex were known to kill young kongs on sight to eliminate future competition. Considering that lady I forgot the name of smelled like kong, having literally been all over kong, I think y’all know exactly why it was chasing her. But yes, it still could have just eaten that corpse.
@paulofernandesroberto9336
@paulofernandesroberto9336 9 месяцев назад
I mean, to be fair, Weta did write a book about the Natural History of Skull Island, as if the species were indeed animals not monsters. Having said that I feel a more grounded take would be Ann stepping out from inside the log and realizing the V. rex eating its prey. Then another V. rex would appear, fight the first one for the carcass but lose, then find Ann and try desperatly to catch her because it was famished. When Kong would finally appear to save her, the first V. rex and a third one would join the second to try and kill Kong, not minding Ann anymore.
@sakuraice22
@sakuraice22 8 месяцев назад
The tiny humans are actually insignificant for them, it's like a lion eating a meerkat; too much trouble to catch for too little energy gain, unless it was already incapacitated and the lion didn't have to struggle to grab it, it's not worth it
@desmondedwards8234
@desmondedwards8234 8 месяцев назад
@@saidi7975 Just like finding nemo, a lot of people are calling the barracuda evil for eating Marlins kids and wife and then they going to have the nerve to say that they wish that Bruce killed it. Like what does the barracuda have to do go on a vegan diet. The barracuda was just trying to find something to eat
@blissypastell8304
@blissypastell8304 4 месяца назад
You know it's kinda ironic, movies treat carnivores and predators as bloodthirsty villains yet when you think about it humans are the ultimate apex predator
@CHADCONTEXT
@CHADCONTEXT 7 месяцев назад
Carnivorous animal: *breathes* Humans: And I took that personally.
@kennethsatria6607
@kennethsatria6607 Год назад
It'd be avery interesting concept if for once we would be on the carnivore's side of a story, Like Herbivores can be oblivious to passing creatures but sometimes they can be overly aggressive, looking to vent or vengeful towards smaller predators. Imagine like a whole herd of Triceratops acting like Cape Buffalo against a tyrannosaurus family.
@thorodinson6625
@thorodinson6625 Год назад
That's basically Camp cretaceous season 3 for Blue.
@FlyingFocs
@FlyingFocs Год назад
Kinda related, but I'm in the process of writing a novel in which two juvenile dinosaurs are displaced in a tsunami and half to survive on their own. It then follows both animals. The creatures in question are a Parasaurolophus and a Gorgosaurus. I like the idea because one is still a herbivore, but the other protagonist being a carnivore trying to survive reiterates (even with some mild anthropomorphism) that it is just an animal. Granted, another carnivore called Daspletosaurus is kind of the villain, but given that it was a competing apex predator, it's at least hopefully justified.
@axo2408
@axo2408 8 месяцев назад
@@FlyingFocsdamn u gotta send it here
@kaden.slone04_biology
@kaden.slone04_biology 8 месяцев назад
Wasn't that pretty much Speckles: The Tarbosaurus?
@nooneofimportance2110
@nooneofimportance2110 8 месяцев назад
Well, that's basically Speckles the Tarbosaur and Dino King. They need a Lion King for Dinosaurs. Also, it's not like there aren't any good guy carnivore dinosaurs. Primal's Fang, Momma Rex from Ice Age 3, and Blue. Not many others though.
@johngarry3723
@johngarry3723 8 месяцев назад
You are doing a great job pointing out the importance of ” is my prey worth it" in predator behaviour. Most movies get it wrong for making cheap drama.
@RaggedGothic
@RaggedGothic 7 месяцев назад
The carnivore as an archetype for evil (or at least antagonism) is older than dirt. It can be summed up easily in three words: "big, bad wolf".
@monzu4253
@monzu4253 5 месяцев назад
I found this channel at 4 AM, and it was definitely what I needed before sleep. Also, the video was super informative. Keep up the good work!
@Gamma138
@Gamma138 4 месяца назад
Thanks dude I appreciate the support!
@ElCarnesX20
@ElCarnesX20 8 месяцев назад
I am here to explain why the carno was to aggressive: In JW, the movie explains that dinosaurs are made to be bigger, more aggressive and with more teeth to earn more money on their park. So, basically, they're not animals, they are hybrid monsters.
@Anonymityfan
@Anonymityfan 8 месяцев назад
As a kid I always felt like carnivores are just trying to eat but it made sense why they would be portrayed as evil from the perspective of prey.
@aaronvoxous7806
@aaronvoxous7806 7 месяцев назад
You are the first person I’ve watch on RU-vid who actually liked Disney’s Dinosaurs which is so refreshing! I loved the movie growing up and I to felt so bad for the carnivores, even though I was against them. Everyone on their deaths made me sad.
@Drakevid
@Drakevid 6 месяцев назад
This actually is an interesting perspective, so good that I could rewatch this movies and feel different. Nice video
@MugiwaraZero
@MugiwaraZero 8 месяцев назад
Someone mentioned in another video that the reason the V-rexes were so interested in the woman was because they thought she was an infant kong The V-rexes and the kongs had been competitors for thousands of years Their feud only got worse as more of skull Island fell into the ocean forcing them to compete more and more due to lack of space We saw how powerful 1 kong was (capable of 3v1ing the V-rexes while protecting the girl at the same time) Killing competition before it can become a threat does make sense I subscribe to this theory solely because it allows me to properly enjoy the fight without wondering why they're so stupid
@AdvancedGamer-
@AdvancedGamer- 8 месяцев назад
The theory makes a lot of sense to be fair
@Man_Aslume
@Man_Aslume 6 месяцев назад
I mean, your not wrong
@unsureashell1947
@unsureashell1947 5 месяцев назад
You're wrong. That's a human way of thinking. In nature, you don't kill competition unless it's a competition for mating rights. A lion does not go out of it's way to hunt hyena, and will only kill them if they are standing directly between themselves and a meal. What the rexes did, besides extraordinarily stupid, giving their lives in a risky fight they had no certain odds against for a tiny meal, was also not at all how any predator would act. Predators, specially of such sizes, will carefully consider prey. If it will take more effort to hunt than the energy replaced from the meal, they won't do it. If it poses a threat and they are not so desperate, they also won't do it. For a miniscule human, not even a snack for any one of them, they would fight a Kong? Ridiculous.
@Edelweiss1102
@Edelweiss1102 5 месяцев назад
It's not a bad theory, but in my opinion still falls pretty flat in regards to the V. Rex scene. Predators usually don't go out actively hunting their competition, they will only do so if they get an easy kill, like getting the chance to ambush or stumbling uppon an animal that is already weakened. In that regard, it's still pretty stupid that the V. Rex wastes a large prey item just for a small chance to get a competition infant. And it falls completely appart the monent they start 3 v 1 ning Kong and risking their life.
@QuickStrikes84
@QuickStrikes84 5 месяцев назад
It's a stupid scene that doesn't make any sense. I wouldn't try to justifyit as anything different. Why is kong the only one in that movie if the species is so great? 🤨
@lionhart1517
@lionhart1517 8 месяцев назад
The worst part is: both Carno examples you gave had versions that were radically beefed up to be so demonic that the only real semblance of the actual animal was the osteoderms. As a kid, the Carnotaurus from Dinosaur terrified me. Then I learned what the real creature was like, and it's now my absolute favorite dino.
@mlgman138
@mlgman138 8 месяцев назад
See for me as a kid I thought the Carno was a apex because disneys dinosaur made them look like one of the coolest creatures, but like you mentioned "beefed up" even though they're just a cheetah/bull of the dinosaur world
@untrollquifaitdesblaguessa6922
@untrollquifaitdesblaguessa6922 7 месяцев назад
*insert the little dance from prehistoric planet*
@DgardsGaming
@DgardsGaming 6 месяцев назад
My faviorite are Raptors
@DgardsGaming
@DgardsGaming 6 месяцев назад
@@untrollquifaitdesblaguessa6922Oh my goodness, it was sad the Male got rejected.
@Wright805
@Wright805 6 месяцев назад
Out of curiousity, what was it about the Carnotaurus that made it your favourite?
@vrthief
@vrthief 7 месяцев назад
What annoys me even more about dominion was at least with the other movies, the villain was something that was a crime against nature, and something that rebelled against its oppressors that made it for the sole purpose of killing and looking cool. The dinosaur was an antagonist but also the scientists mainly. I thought the newer one could’ve been a lot better.
@titoaskeladd2639
@titoaskeladd2639 7 месяцев назад
Hey man, I just discovered your channel and your videos, and after watching just 1 of it (this one) I am immediately hooked! I see that you've not uploaded for a while now, but I am hoping you'll continue your work here since they are both very informative and entertaining. I hope you're doing great and that I'll see a new upload for you soon, cheers! 🍻😄
@pman56789
@pman56789 Год назад
I'm glad that the media is slowly starting to portray carnivorous dinosaurs as simply animals instead of bloodthirsty monsters, but I am disappointed that they are still being *seen* as the villains. Take the JW Giganotosaurus, for example. It did not act like a monster at all, but it was still killed off in the climax fight, simply because it attacked the protagonists likely because they entered its territory and disrupted it. I liked Dominion but this is the main part of the movie that really annoyed me.
@thorodinson6625
@thorodinson6625 Год назад
Tbf that's how nature is. Innocence doesn't mean anything to a predator or territorial herbivore. So while the scene failed to make the giga's death a joyful moment, it did succeed in showing the brutal reality of nature.
@roguetheoutlander8800
@roguetheoutlander8800 Год назад
@@thorodinson6625 no, it did not, it did exactly what Colin Trevorrow wanted: to let Tyrannosaurus win (Treworrow thinks dinosaurs are only for kids and also is T-rex fan, this type of peoples soudnt make Jurassic movies, because = If guy think dinosaurs are only for kids: movie gonna have good and bad dinosaurs and also gonna Tyrannosaurus win, because kids love Tyrannosaurs (Dominion have it) If guy is T-rex fan: Tyrannosaurus gonna win, even if it means it gonna die and wake up from death (Dominion have it)(and no, she wanst unconsciousness, when you are unconsciousness, your eyes are closed, she had eyes opened, she died and come back to life just because Colin wanted her to kill poor Zeb the giganotosaurus)
@mikaelangehagen7251
@mikaelangehagen7251 Год назад
@@roguetheoutlander8800 its a movie. I dont know about you but I dont go to the theater expecting realism
@McChubbz0
@McChubbz0 Год назад
@@mikaelangehagen7251 Ay hello fellow Mikael!
@mikaelangehagen7251
@mikaelangehagen7251 Год назад
@@McChubbz0 hello there Mikael
@marmalade8915
@marmalade8915 8 месяцев назад
I think the problem is that people often forget that these are real animals that existed, they're animals not monsters
@leeroyj7300
@leeroyj7300 5 месяцев назад
wanna point something out 2:00, carnotaurus is acting 100% within reason for a natural predator, when somethings happening that stresses out/confuses a creature of that size (IE a volcano literally erupting, or when tranquilized), its 100% normal for the to act erratic like that, their freaking out just like everyone else would
@Latrimie
@Latrimie 7 месяцев назад
Thank you for talking about this! This has bothered me forever :( Of course i love me some good ''monster dino'' movie, but this trope in dinosaur media is so tiring, my eyes roll right out of my sockets. Not to mention this legit gives some of people very warped view on dinosaurs, to a point where depicting dinosaurs more realistically has those people outraged..
@therealkingfisher.
@therealkingfisher. 8 месяцев назад
There’s an animated Japanese movie called “You Are Umasou“, which roughly translates to “You are Yummy!” It’s about a small tyrannosaur struggling to come to terms with being a carnivore, as he was raised by herbivores. I feel like it wonderfully explores a new perspective not often seen before in dinosaur movies. Check it out if you have the time, it’s a great watch!
@MemesToa
@MemesToa 8 месяцев назад
This whole situation is exactly why I desperately want an adaptation of Raptor Red: A story where the main cast of characters is a family of Utahraptors, and goes in great detail about their struggles to hunt for food and maintain their territory, while still having to protect one another from the various dangers of life.
@kerrex86
@kerrex86 7 месяцев назад
They’ve tried getting a film made for decades, it was actually one of two films The Jim Henson Company planned on making the other being Animal Farm, but that one must’ve not done as well as they hoped so that’s why it wasn’t made
@AnaLugia256
@AnaLugia256 7 месяцев назад
If you think abt it, Lion King is a movie from the carnivores' perspective
@Wright805
@Wright805 6 месяцев назад
Raptor Red was an awesome novel.
@infini_ryu9461
@infini_ryu9461 5 месяцев назад
​@@AnaLugia256And the Hyena's that time were depicted as stupid and evil. I guess every movie needs a villain or people will get bored.
@davidjensen6596
@davidjensen6596 4 месяца назад
Did anyone else notice the hole in the crocs head at 0:49 seconds?! He opened his mouth and the hole opened as well, I know crocs have their nostrils on the tip of their snout not on top of their head!? WHAT IN THE WORLD IS THAT HOLE??????
@AgentLevitar
@AgentLevitar 6 месяцев назад
Fun fact: The V. Rex in canon to the film are apparently an answer to the question, what would happen if T. Rex became inbred? Yes, those dinos are essentially an inbred family. Apparently the V. Rex that ran for Ann was a juvenile hence the wasting its energy part but yeah, the whole family wasting this much energy on Kong and Ann feels weird especially considering Kong is not just some easy prey item
@rhedosaurus2251
@rhedosaurus2251 Год назад
To be fair, I have noticed that a lot of JP fans didn't like how the Giganotosaurus was handled. Also, I find it interesting that you put the I. rex here, but not the JP3 Spinosaurus when it was argueably a rage filled psychopath as well via chasing Grant and others when they were out of its territory, as well as bow it should have been licking it's wounds from the propeller strike and whatever injuries it sustained from that one fight.
@mikaelangehagen7251
@mikaelangehagen7251 Год назад
How is it gona lick its wound thats on its sail
@Hecatia_cuddles
@Hecatia_cuddles Год назад
​@@goji3908 whoa that sounds cool can you send me the source so I can read it myself.
@blobbertmcblob4888
@blobbertmcblob4888 Год назад
@@goji3908 I think that would have also tied into why the spino was chasing the humans to begin with. Nothing big enough for it to eat. It was starving and when it saw small, slow, easy prey, like all predators, it took advantage of that.
@BasileJodar
@BasileJodar 11 месяцев назад
@@goji3908 No I think that just a random theory used by JP3 fans
@dragonstormx
@dragonstormx 8 месяцев назад
I have seen other people say the Giganotosaurus did nothing wrong and felt bad for the poor thing when it was brutally killed after its only crime was being a rival to Rexy.
@owellafehr5191
@owellafehr5191 Год назад
Honestly, even as a kid, I always saw the 'true' villains of Disney's Dinosaur as being Kron and Bruton (although the latter redeems himself). The Carnotaurs are, as you mentioned, just following their instincts; it's Kron who enforces a brutal 'survival of the fittest' ideology over his entire herd and threatens those who disagree with him with violence. The Carnotaurs are a natural threat, who challenge the main characters physically, but Kron is more of a sociological one, challenging them ideologically - and I think that's a rare example of a herbivore villain in an animal movie. If you like seeing carnivores be humanized, you might want to look at Land Before Time 2 and 5, as well as Ice Age 3. I know they're animated kids' film sequels, but they do show carnivorous dinosaurs as parents and nurturers who have enough intelligence and restraint to NOT attack the main characters in the end. That being said, they still go up against 'evil' carnivores who threaten the mcs, but I feel like that sort of thing is kind of inevitable in these kinds of movies. I believe there was also an episode of the Land Before Time series where a raptor spared the protagonists' lives in gratitude for them saving it. Again, it's something for preschoolers, but it's the best I can think of at the moment.
@jihunshin4864
@jihunshin4864 10 месяцев назад
I also highly recommend You Are Umasou. ;)
@Mortablunt
@Mortablunt 8 месяцев назад
Kron has terrible communication skills, but he has a very cogent point. The situation is dire, and the logistical needs of his charges are immense. If he had explained the situation, frankly, and logically rather than using a threatening, totalitarian tone, the pressure is, he was under as leader, and what the herd was facing, would have made him seem extremely sympathetic. He is currently dealing with a life and death situation, which could result in absolutely everyone dying. This is the ultimate unforgiving high-stakes situation. Logistical demands of the herd or immense every single member hundreds of them meeting hundreds of gallons of water and several tons of food per day in a desert. Every cooling pants, and every beat of the heart is moisture and energy lost against a ticking clock. Aside from being strictly speaking right about the need to keep moving, his methods were stupid. It would have made sense to split the herd in two or possibly three. I have a van guard at the front which scouts The Way ahead and tries to collect food and water have a second heard of healthy individuals who can move quickly and a third heard of the slow and weak. It increases the foraging capacity. It also means that, even if the slow and weak must die, not everyone dies with them.
@jacaredosvudu1638
@jacaredosvudu1638 8 месяцев назад
​@@Mortabluntthank you Luhansk
@Somerandomjingleberry
@Somerandomjingleberry 8 месяцев назад
And to be fair to the Sharp-Tooth examples we see in that series, they’re mostly depicted being stuck in a relatively barren wasteland with not a lot of resources. Of course they’d go after every little thing that moves, and of course even if there isn’t an immediate chase it would still become a total “me or him” situation anyway just by virtue of how desperate things were and are outside of the Great Valley.
@agentblackbird9435
@agentblackbird9435 8 месяцев назад
I felt the same about Kron and Brutus. It’s been ages since I’ve watched Dinosaur but I do remember thinking that
@Viyde
@Viyde 7 месяцев назад
To be fair, though. In the first jw movie the indominus rex being violent kindof made sense. It was raised in isolation and it killed its sibling when it was young. So when it escaped and was killing for sport it was probably doing so because it wanted to test its strength and was having fun because it was free.
@tx-1953
@tx-1953 3 месяца назад
damn ur vid goes deep keep going luv ya vids
@Gamma138
@Gamma138 3 месяца назад
Thank you I appreciate it! More guaranteed to come!
@Thurmos
@Thurmos Год назад
It’s not just carnivores being mistreated as well, but also herbivores. Always being prey to the “angry mad blood thirsty monsters” and when the herbivores get up and personal with the carnivore they can’t fight back or are too weak to actually defend themselves. It’s sad how people just view dinosaurs like that. They are just animals trying to survive after all, if went to the zoo you would see tigers and crocodiles try to attack the visitors.
@A3319
@A3319 8 месяцев назад
People forgetting that Herbivores are some of the most dangerous land animals
@BangBangNoee
@BangBangNoee 8 месяцев назад
@@A3319Yep, and I would say they were much more territorial than some carnivores. Hence, hippos, rhinos, elephants, etc.
@Ryou_Sensei
@Ryou_Sensei 8 месяцев назад
Im not gonna lie, I think the Land Before Time did a great job with the difference between herbivores and carnivores although selectively sometimes. In the first few movies, we see the carnivores clearly not speaking, only growling and roaring (with the exception of the villains from Journey Through the Mist, which was a Dinosuchus and a scavenger bird) but in the 5th movie, when Chomper returns, it shows that Carnivores and Herbivores actually speak different languages. That kind of thing is what makes me think is the reason the Carnotaurs and raptors dont talk in Disney's Dinosaur. However, when we first get a glimps of the raptors in that movie, im pretty sure the one we saw laughed, cuz when they spot it and it goes over the hill, you can clearly hear a "hehehe"
@agentblackbird9435
@agentblackbird9435 8 месяцев назад
Yeah I was about to comment about Chomper (and Ruby, an oviraptor from the cartoon series)
@BeardedWolfKing
@BeardedWolfKing 7 месяцев назад
Ngl if the Carnos in Disneys Dinosaur had dialogue, it would be one of the BEST antagonist in disney because its easy to make them sympathetic antagonist AND for the script to treat them like regular animals and not killing machines They saw their land destroyed, 2 of them are probably whats left, hungry and thirsty asf, and they had tragedy by the murder of the other carno. Imagine the desperation for food, and hate for that iguanadon that killed the carno and imagine the flexibility of the script on that
@zalla00
@zalla00 7 месяцев назад
The problem is the dinos in these movies NEVER STOP EATING. If they were written appropriately, they'd nail a kill then wander off, sated. But the creatures we see in movies are just gluttons who kill and eat without end, which is obviously unrealistic.
@Ahalaya
@Ahalaya Год назад
This is why this is why anthropomorphizing animals that are meant to be animals- not human-like creatures (ex., Zootopia)- is always a problem. Disney’s Dinosaur is a weird case, since there is a very anthropomorphic story for these non-anthro characters, but the Carnotaurus is not like the main characters. It does not talk. It does not interact in anyway except to hunt. It acts like an animal, yet we are supposed to see them as characters like the main cast.
@januszpolak254
@januszpolak254 8 месяцев назад
In case of Disney Dinosaur its kinda understandable because movie is from point of view of herbivores. Obviously buffalo don't think of a tiger as a animal that want to survive like them but as threat for its life.
@teawrecks1243
@teawrecks1243 8 месяцев назад
Or the Lion King, where the talking sapient predators are literally the government with talking sapient herbivores as their subjects, which raises uncomfortable questions.
@genghiskhan5701
@genghiskhan5701 8 месяцев назад
@@teawrecks1243 Lion King is basically a retelling of Hamlet first and an animal film second, so I kinda forgive them
@Trashgriffin
@Trashgriffin 8 месяцев назад
I've always seen the Carnotaurs as a force of nature, rather than characters. I would've hated it if they had added dialogue to them, and I think that the choice to leave it was for the better. It's probably one of the most natural portrayals of carnivores in a movie whose protags are herbivores. Imo.
@catpoke9557
@catpoke9557 8 месяцев назад
I actually like that about that movie. It illustrates the "to a canary a cat is a monster" idea. The carnotaurus in that movie is just an animal, but because we are seeing from the perspective of animals capable of rational thought, we start to view the carnotaurus as a monster for its animal like behavior.
@imachineheadi
@imachineheadi 8 месяцев назад
The thing is, in Fallen Kingdom, we literally see the Allosaurus doing exactly what a normal animal would. The Allo is running for it’s life, it’s equally afraid. Yet the Baryonyx and Carno act like complete monsters and, instead of trying to survive, only try to kill. I also heard that the Stegoceratops was gonna be in JW, and it was apparently going to be fairly docile, but they cut it so the Indominus felt more special
@noxen_nexon
@noxen_nexon 3 месяца назад
I think the Baryonyx WAS hungry given from where it appeared, and trying to hunt Claire and Franklin wasn’t the wrong thing to do if it WAS hungry. And the Baryonyx probably didn’t know what was going on either.
@WinkuzzVids
@WinkuzzVids 7 месяцев назад
Regarding the v rex chasing the woman after getting it's meal: I recently watched a documentary in which a pack of lions downed an ox, but then a smaller animal walked in on them (don't remember if it was a warthog or sth Antilope like) . Two or three of the lions broke off to chase and kill it because it was right there and it would mean more food for the pack. So I guess for pack animals it makes sense
@zombifiedgaming6485
@zombifiedgaming6485 7 месяцев назад
Man just exposed dinosaur racism 💀💀💀
@extremecacti6617
@extremecacti6617 Год назад
I love all these movies but I just feel bad for the so called “evil carnivores”, they were just following their instincts, of living life.
@IceGodzilla619
@IceGodzilla619 9 месяцев назад
Except the indominus,Indoraptor and spino All the other's just act like animals
@IceGodzilla619
@IceGodzilla619 8 месяцев назад
@Cool-qq7wr true but the spino has serious unnatural beef with trex's for some reason
@LzeniX
@LzeniX 8 месяцев назад
“Okay so they call me evil just because i try to get my dinner, that the most unfair stuff i ever seen” - Carnivore Dinosaur
@soumaiseu2470
@soumaiseu2470 8 месяцев назад
Bro nobody thinks that carnivores are actually evil but a dinossaur movie without bloodthirsty carnivores would be boring af
@AdvancedGamer-
@AdvancedGamer- 8 месяцев назад
@@Cool-qq7wrbruh
@creakingskull7008
@creakingskull7008 8 месяцев назад
It's important to note that the Carnotaurs were just as tired, hungry and thirsty as the herd
@vivianroman8600
@vivianroman8600 5 месяцев назад
I recently saw a clip of a man grabbing a broken tree branch, and rapidly hitting a snake that was attempting to consume a deer. Which was then cheered on by people who apparently ignored the abuse of the snake. The deer was even already dead, and I even saw a comment on said video saying “Thank God we have such good people. The poor deer just wanted to live, and that snake killed it.” It’s oh so sad that snakes, and carnivores in general, have such a large bias against them. The snake was trying to eat. And that snake was denied of its food. Hell, the snake even looked VERY thin for a boa of its size. I do hope that the snake was able to eat and survive after that.
@bigguy42_
@bigguy42_ 4 месяца назад
Even though I love the game, carnivores in ARK literally just roam around killing and eating non-stop, even sacrificing themselves just to kill something and they will never stop eating
@ppenmudera4687
@ppenmudera4687 8 месяцев назад
Interestingly, I think the therizinosaurus was done rather realistically in Jurassic World 3. It was just grazing around when it noticed there was someone else in his land. So he killed the deer and tried to kill the human not because it was a bloodthirsty psychopath, but because it wanted to protect its foodsource. And then there was the ending, which kinda ruined my boy Theri...
@dannybonsai7102
@dannybonsai7102 8 месяцев назад
yeh they got a bit carried away with the various "pose moments" for the dinos in the JP franchise, ah Hollywood.
@Lokitellus
@Lokitellus 7 месяцев назад
The therizinosaurus is a herbivore, sue they entirely changed it just because they wanted an escape scene
@oyoo3323
@oyoo3323 5 месяцев назад
​@@Lokitellusnope, they're omnivores. At least real ones were. I don't know what the JW ones are, given it doesn't exactly have a good track record for realism.
@lefishe2788
@lefishe2788 8 месяцев назад
The Gorgosaurus from Walking with Dinosaurs (2013) is another good example of this, they hunt for food and are even shown taking down prey for their young yet they're treated as the antagonists for merely doing what keeps them alive.
@tyrus_kitt
@tyrus_kitt 3 месяца назад
I mean, same as Dinosaur, the story is from the herbivores pov, so it makes sense (Also the detail of the Gorgosaurus leaving when it got its arm broken, wich is pretty accurate)
@Laserbeak316
@Laserbeak316 4 месяца назад
I’m honestly surprised you didn’t use the T-Rex family from Disney’s The Good Dinosaur as an example of how large Theropods don’t always have to be portrayed as antagonists. The moment Nash and Ramsey appear on screen, they look as though they’re fully intent on devouring Arlo and Spot. Even after they scare off Thunderclap and his Pterosaur gang, it just builds it up as though they’re another antagonist or obstacle Arlo and Spot have to get past. But then, they help the young dinosaur to his feet and ask him if he’s okay after that harrowing encounter. They and their father Buck (who is without question the second most badass T-Rex in pop culture, behind only JP/JW’s Rexy) end up helping Arlo find his way home and even teach him how to face his fears. I always admired the writers of the film for not portraying T-Rex as the antagonist of the film as one would expect. While still showing that they’re large and powerful predators regardless.
@angelawhalen3277
@angelawhalen3277 Год назад
People are so mean to carnivores when they don't do anything wrong they're just animals just like herbivores and they want to survive just like anybody else
@marshmallowmountains4636
@marshmallowmountains4636 8 месяцев назад
"Sharp Teeth" is an animation here on RU-vid that states the carnivores aren't evil. In their other animations, the carnivores are also depicted as animals and not bloodthirsty. There's one where one roars at a hadrosaur that got close to her nest. But as soon as the hadrosaur left, she ignored it and went back to her nest.
@waluigihentailover6926
@waluigihentailover6926 6 месяцев назад
I just watched it! Awesomeness!
@Bakedbean843
@Bakedbean843 5 месяцев назад
Having a psychotic herbivore dinosaur would be much scarier, it would feel more personal
@johnandrew5958
@johnandrew5958 7 месяцев назад
Damn I never thought that way But it makes so much sense Never stopped to reflect about the reality of both sides Thanks for the new perspective
@teawrecks1243
@teawrecks1243 8 месяцев назад
The worst case has got to be Sharptooth from the Land Before Time. There was a major disaster, and only the main gang of baby dinosaurs are around, and Sharptooth is pursuing them relentlessly--because they're the only thing left to eat for miles and he's likely desperately hungry. And then the novelization tries (awkwardly) to portray him as a psychopathic sadist, which is stupid.
@MatteoBiondillo
@MatteoBiondillo 8 месяцев назад
I agree, he was basically starving and there wasn't anything around.
@SpecLeader101
@SpecLeader101 7 месяцев назад
He injured littlefoots mom during the first chase. Instead of getting back up to go after her, he instead bee-lines it for LF and Cera.
@taliesincoleman6569
@taliesincoleman6569 Год назад
3:40 nope. it's really mainly down to it's upbringing, because animals that are mentally unstable DO sometimes kill to test things
@Jjo_Han-wen
@Jjo_Han-wen 2 месяца назад
But the I-rex wasn't just randomly doing it nor was it only "sometimes" doing it, there's a whole scene of the main characters finding lots of herbivores been slaughtered with no sign of any of them being chewed on, meaning the Rex was killing just because it felt like it, and not because it wanted to hunt for food
@Tkokat
@Tkokat 6 месяцев назад
I never gave it too much thought but you are absolutely right
@Riggy1991
@Riggy1991 7 месяцев назад
the youtuber Shadows kinda explained why the Fallen Kingdom Carno acted in such a way it was abused and locked away for its entire life so it had a broken mental state leading to extreme almost unnatural aggression, that's why it chose to hunt and kill during the volcano eruption rather than fleeing
@honeymxxnmalec2402
@honeymxxnmalec2402 8 месяцев назад
There’s a movie called Dino King where the main character is a Tarbosaurus and his family get killed by a T-Rex, and yes the villain is a carnivore but so is the main character
@user-tq6tf5wn1x
@user-tq6tf5wn1x Месяц назад
I remember that one and how wrong the size of aquatic dinosaurs was. Still loved it.
@thorodinson6625
@thorodinson6625 Год назад
1:37 Ok. I will admit that comparing this scene to birds is a little off. But I do know why this scene was added. Looking at the lore, we see that the ecosystem of the island was extremely unstable from the beginning, with carnivores outnumbering herbivores, not to mention volcanic activities in late 2017, which began poisoning plants and fish, as well as making places uninhabitable due to immense heat and ash in some regions. This means that some of the animals were deprived of food for prolonged periods. And such periods without food will not allow a creature to think rationally. What the carnotaurus did was not normal. But at least, it wasn't out of nowhere. Edit: this is the same reason why the baryonyx in the lava chamber attacked Claire and Franklin. The circumstances it faced before did not allow it to think.
@bensongriff2493
@bensongriff2493 Год назад
Cool I never thought of it that way!
@somerandomdudeonline637
@somerandomdudeonline637 8 месяцев назад
so the island ecosystem being unstable is kinda not true as these are all species on the island that we know of (im not counting hybrids as their time was not that long to have them in the food chain) herbivores: ankylosaurus apatosaurus brachiosaurus coelurus edmontosaurus euoplocephalous gallimimus microceratus nasutoceratops ouranosaurus pachycephalosaurus pachyrhinosaurus parasaurolophus parasaur lux pelorplites sinoceratops stegosaurus stygimoloch triceratops 19 herbis total carnivores allosaurus baryonyx carnotaurus ceratosaurus compsognathus dilophosaurus dimorphodon elaphrosaurus herrerasaurus pteranodon monolophosaurus segisaurus suchomimus tarbosaurus teratophoneus t-rex velociraptor 17 carnis total and only 1 omnivore not to mention the already native species on the island: Brown pelican Collared aracari Red-tailed boa Nublar tufted deer Green sea turtle Nublar's striped boa Nublar's tapir all species mentioned in the offical wiki
@thorodinson6625
@thorodinson6625 8 месяцев назад
@@somerandomdudeonline637 all that on an island of 30 square miles. Imo that is extremely small for that number of animals.
@somerandomdudeonline637
@somerandomdudeonline637 8 месяцев назад
@@thorodinson6625 some how a group of islands has the largest reptile some how so ig nature is on crack alot
@Jjo_Han-wen
@Jjo_Han-wen 2 месяца назад
​@@somerandomdudeonline637if you mean the komodo dragon, that's not a realistic comparison, dinosaurs were huge, while the komodo dragon(the largest reptile) is merely the same length as a grown man and the size of a fully grown bulldog, of course they will fit on an island and even more so for a collection of islands, especially since I'm sure their population size is relatively small as well. But having tons of Gigantic avain beasts on 1 island too small for any of them is definitely gonna cause environmental issues which will still result in dinosaurs acting out of control
@starsshallscream
@starsshallscream 4 месяца назад
the indominus would have turned out like a normal carnivore if it wasn't treated as an asset and something for marketing just to get sponsorships from big companies. it was trapped, and barely had any contact for most if not all of its life
@JamaicaZ160R1793010A
@JamaicaZ160R1793010A 7 месяцев назад
This says how that primal fear of being a meal for an animal ruined so much others. It also says how disassociated that humans became. Really fear ruined so much things.
@someguywithasword438
@someguywithasword438 Год назад
I've always rooted for carnivores in films, even when they're the main antagonist/villain.
@steakinbacon8593
@steakinbacon8593 8 месяцев назад
Same the poor thing is just hungy not evil.
@AdvancedGamer-
@AdvancedGamer- 8 месяцев назад
@@steakinbacon8593okay but rooting for them is a little much lol
@AdvancedGamer-
@AdvancedGamer- 8 месяцев назад
@@steakinbacon8593like I would still root for the humans or rexy [or blue] which I guess there are some carnivores you would root for but some there’s just no reason to
@infxnite4431
@infxnite4431 7 месяцев назад
​@@steakinbacon8593sure its just hungry but how would you feel if you were the prey? Or a beloved one such as your parent or pet? Creatures antagonizing each other are a normal thing in nature. Even animals can have grudges just as humans do, mostly because humans are animals as well.
@shortyPlayzYT
@shortyPlayzYT 8 месяцев назад
Indominus rex was the most evilest in here, yet the most broken since it's been contained her entire life, so she became insane and sick of it and her space was too small like you said. Indominus needed more space, at least a live animal to eat for entertainment or something I guess to waste it's stamina on at least. I think indominus was more victim than villian. Overall I think she was a villian from being a broken character, she had been destroyed. Not only that, she probably felt very lonely, that's the reason why she communicated to the raptors. This could be proved wrong since she had a sibling and yet she killed her sibling as a baby, I think she was trying to play around and accidently killed and it traumatized her to become like this I think of.
@caec.lan_is_tired
@caec.lan_is_tired 6 месяцев назад
There's a great subversion of this in the animated short "The Last Tyrant" by Dead Sound. Early on there's a scene with a bunch of various herbivores (Triceratops, Edmontosaurus, Pachycephalosaurus, and some kind of ornithomimid) gathered around a watering hole. A T-rex shows up, but doesn't attack the herbivores, instead just drinking water. It wasn't hungry, so it didn't do anything aggressive. Anyone who likes dinosaurs should watch it, and the Dinosauria anthology it's part of.
@ChargerBlockAndCrown
@ChargerBlockAndCrown 3 месяца назад
The final battle with Giga was soooooooooooooo unfair Giga's design is the best out of anyone and he stood no change R.I.P Giga
@digger450r
@digger450r 8 месяцев назад
Thank you! The way carnivores are portrayed has always bothered me. No carnivore is going to walk away from a kill to attack a human, or hunt when its not hungry. I honestly don't think a large predator like a t-rex would even consider something as small as a human as a prey item unless they were starving and desperate.
@Cyrus_T_Laserpunch
@Cyrus_T_Laserpunch 5 месяцев назад
Animals are smart enough when hunting to not chase something that will provide less energy than chasing it would cost, your thought is correct.
@daffierpython7755
@daffierpython7755 8 месяцев назад
This isn’t just movies but all media, carnivores are shown as unstoppable killing machines and the herbivores are shown as the cannon fodder for kill scenes enough matter how dangerous or harmless either are
@peteralexandergraae2830
@peteralexandergraae2830 7 месяцев назад
"it is my experience that very few things in this universe is evil. But most things are hungry. Hungry looks very like evil from the wrong end of the cutlery. Or do you think your bacon sandwich loves you back?"
@JJMDude
@JJMDude 7 месяцев назад
This was my thought about the Rex in The Land Before Time. Poor starving bastard was so desperate towards the end, it fell for a trap with a baby hadrosaur the size of a squirrel as bait.
@greenzillashorts
@greenzillashorts 8 месяцев назад
Thank you, finally someone who has some common sense. The Indominus Rex makes sense it was a monster because it was abused all its life, but all the other dinosaurs you listed, you are completely right. Especially about the giganotosaurus.
@brandonl7759
@brandonl7759 8 месяцев назад
Even when I was a kid I felt so bad for the Carnos from Dinosaurs. Man they just needed one of those big herbivores to fall back enough and the plot is over. The bronto alone would have fed them for a week and they'd reach water. Such an underrated dino
@squidbro6635
@squidbro6635 7 месяцев назад
A great example of role reversal comes from a show called Primal. It follows a neanderthal named Spear who befriended a T-Rex named Fang. One of the episodes includes a zombie virus that infects a brontosaurus and turns it into a literal unstoppable nightmare that has to get INCINERATED BY LAVA to kill it for good. Not only does it show that herbivores can be just as scary under the right conditions, but the vehement chasing makes sense because it's infected so all it's natural instincts are already gone.
@Bruh-Moment435
@Bruh-Moment435 7 месяцев назад
It really annoys me when people say predators are bad or evil. I understand if you get sad watching prey in a video get chased down and eaten, but they have no other choice they need to eat meat. Predators arent malicious to prey even if they're violent, they kill because they need to
@crystalcryptid2022
@crystalcryptid2022 8 месяцев назад
I think you'd like the movie "You Are Umasou". It's a kids movie with talking dinos, and the main character is a t-rex that was raised by herbivores. This movie- and its sequel especially(not rlly a sequel, just a story taking place in the same universe)- treated carnivores as what they were: They just had to eat meat to survive. That's it. The antagonists are still antagonists, but not just because they're carnivores. In both movies, the protagonists are carnivores, too. Instead, while the antagonists are still carnivores, they're antagonists because of what they've done, not because of what they are.
@TL4546b
@TL4546b 8 месяцев назад
That’s why I love Planet Zoo and Prehistoric Kingdom. In PZ, when a dangerous animal escapes it will just be curious and only sometimes chase humans. Case in point: once a dangerous animal escaped and when every NPC was running to the exits, it was just looking around wondering what had happened. In the trailer for PK there is a scene of what happens during an escape (although unlike Jurassic World Evolution, escapes are only a small fraction of PK and PZ) and it literally states this has happened due to the escapee being mistreated by humans.
@Spidey_Studios307
@Spidey_Studios307 Месяц назад
THANK YOU SO MUCH!
@Mattar03
@Mattar03 4 месяца назад
The reason why the V-Rex chased Ann makes much more sense when we take the history of Skull Island into account. Kong‘s species and the V-Rex are basically the top dogs and at war with each other after the island began shrinking. The V-rexes saw Ann as an infant Kong, so their instinct was to take her out, since in their eyes she‘s a potential danger if she grew up.
@citizenvulpes4562
@citizenvulpes4562 8 месяцев назад
I asked a question about morality to someone. Like "what defines evil?" They said that it was "harming someone else" so I then asked "Is a lion evil for killing a Gazelle?" They then exclaimed "yeah lions are evil" I just was stunned.
@Cyrus_T_Laserpunch
@Cyrus_T_Laserpunch 5 месяцев назад
Reminds me of those hippies in Futurama who taught (forced) a lion to eat tofu.
Далее
What's Wrong with Dinosaurs in Modern Movies?
28:06
Просмотров 75 тыс.
How To Do Dinosaurs RIGHT (Unlike Jurassic World)
4:06
OXXXYMIRON - МИР ГОРИТ (2024)
03:26
Просмотров 875 тыс.
The Sauropod Paradox in Dinosaur Survival Games
12:32
Просмотров 247 тыс.
What Did Dinosaurs Really Sound Like?
8:15
Просмотров 1,1 млн
Path of Titans But I Can't Leave The Circle!!
24:00
Просмотров 1,4 млн
The Dinosaur Jurassic World Dominion Got RIGHT (Sorta)
2:53
dinosaurs + analog horror is my worst nightmare
17:28
OXXXYMIRON - МИР ГОРИТ (2024)
03:26
Просмотров 875 тыс.