The Truth Behind Malaysia's Chicken Shortage & Farmers' Woes | Talking Point | Full Episode

Подписаться 1,8 млн

Просмотров 265 тыс.

50% 1

Malaysian authorities made the unprecedented move to halt exports of fresh chicken in June, putting a dent in the supply of Singapore’s most-favoured meat. In the second of this 2-part special (watch part 1: • M’sia Chicken Ban: Can... ) on the export ban, Rai Kannu travels to Malaysia to investigate the heart of the problem - why are farmers not producing enough chickens and what’s being done to stabilise supply so that exports can resume.
Watch more #TalkingPoint: • Talking Point | Full E...
0:00 Introduction
0:49 Why the chicken shortage in Malaysia
2:11 Inside a chicken farm in Malaysia
8:14 Can chicken feed be cheaper?
11:25 Automated farm = more chickens?
15:09 Are chicken cartels behind shortage?
19:00 Is there really a chicken shortage?
20:32 Why chicken export ban could cause more shortage
About the show: Talking Point investigates a current issue or event, offering different perspectives to local stories and revealing how it all affects you.
================================================
#CNAInsider #CNATalkingPoint #Chicken
For more, SUBSCRIBE to CNA INSIDER!
cna.asia/insideryoutubesub
Follow CNA INSIDER on:
Instagram: / cnainsider
Facebook: / cnainsider
Website: cna.asia/cnainsider

Опубликовано:

6 авг 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 684

@Davyjones5454 2 года назад

As a Malaysian. This reports has more information than all the local television channel put together.

@machaimiloais 2 года назад

As a Malaysian. I approve this comment 👍🏻

@meownyannyan8262 2 года назад

local Malaysians are busy creating issues amongst themselves. When everything went bad, they just blame politicians, easy target. ignorance vs convenience.

@hafizullahmuhammad4204 2 года назад

Is more informative than Mat Kilau

@--kennychan3880 2 года назад

Not at all my friend! It's not like that at all! It's wrong!

@ch13t 2 года назад

As a Malaysian, I agree.

@ylihao 2 года назад

It feels somewhat embarrassing that I have to rely on foreign documentaries to get a grasp of what really is happening in my own country. Another great documentary from CNA Insider, learned a few new things here. Great job guys!

@faizalfuad75 2 года назад

me too, our journalist are more interest on entertainment and crime coverage..

@paperonthewall4526 2 года назад

Worang2 Singkapore datang investigate ayam sapplai kami rasa malu jer.

@NK_Khoo-Malaysian 2 года назад

TV3 produces good ducumentary about Malaysia agrobussiness in Malay language. If you are not aware, please blame yourself.

@astella3 2 года назад

Not surprising when the country is run by low standard people

@astella3 2 года назад

Malu apa bossku?

@somytony9713 2 года назад

My understanding 1. Producers increase price to compensate for lockdown losses. 2. Government fix price. 3. Producers retaliate by lowering production to drive price up. 4. Before the effect could be felt, Government ban export to hurt producers. 5. Chicken shortage never felt in Malaysia as producers need to break even.

@r.i.t.randominterestingthi4031 2 года назад

indonesian also have the same problem, only worses, our government is unreliable to control the prices, when the egg prices goes down so bad, we have nothing but bankrupcy

@bengoh3907 2 года назад

Problems: many humans do not exercise their critical-thinking abilities given by GOD. They let the minority to do the thinking n fighting all the "evil agendas" by "hideous people " everywhere.

@sallydeguzman4854 2 года назад

Its normal if no vaccination will got sick the chicken especially raining season

@kesatria_gelap 2 года назад

Indeed..after gov increase ceilling price..suddenly chicken stock increase and more bigger..that capitalist work...tokey always win..

@musya2508 2 года назад

@@kesatria_gelap Me as a small chicken farmer, the feed pricing is true. For me, 2years ago 50kg feed is around rm107. Now its around rm157. Feed price increased drastically but chicken price fixed. I usually got rm300 per month profit with my chickens last 2years, last month my profit was rm50. Think bro think. Imagine you doing your office work with same workload but lower wages after pandemic hits. Everyone would quit.

@bGzzzzz 2 года назад

Looks into the bag of dead chickens and asks “are these chicken dead” 😂 I would’ve responded “No, they’re making a bondage video in this bag”

@EmongTimothy 2 года назад

No they are meditating!

@htf5555 2 года назад

they were merely hibernating. the absolute rancid stench is because they havent been in jacuzzi for a while

@TheWotageek 2 года назад

No, they are pining for the fjords. Standard reply for any dead feathered creature.

@soha8618 2 года назад

Some of them use this dead chicken as keli fish feed 😂😂😂😂😂😂

@insidenblaceth1586 2 года назад

No they are a stunned chichkens

@carsten9168 2 года назад

Excellent documentary, well researched with spot-on reporting by Rai Kannu. A good explanation and observation too by Dr. Ferlito on the cartels.

@deaniman3297 2 года назад

Aduyai..camni la baru etika dan apa yang wartawan perlu tunjukkan pada penonton..wartawan tempatan dan stesen tv boleh belajar cara melaporkan berita macam ni..terbaik👍

@LiveHMH 2 года назад

Just watched 02 Talking Point videos back to back. Thank you for the highly informative and creative contents. Definitely these kind of videos should have more likes. Thanks CNA.

@syepha_alhabshee 2 года назад

Wow very credible sources of news content. Kudos again CNA Insider. You not just educate us on the issue but also resolve the whole misunderstandings. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

@Schneizel1208 2 года назад

I used to think like most people why can't they just build more farms, automate more? After working in the agricultural industry, I understood the process. It isn't as straightforward as people think. I can already think of genuine reasons why setting up broiler farms in Singapore isn't feasible. I'm pretty sure the government has thought about it as well and came to the same conclusion.

@pondeify 2 года назад

only Elon Musk can save us now.

@boy88888 2 года назад

No labors now gov want local malays do those works so they have a job but sadly they can't handle the job

@MrDanisve 2 года назад

They can, but at a cost. Will be much more expensive to produce chicken in Singapore. Due to land cost and labor costs compared to Malaysia. If Singapore wants food security, they need to bear that cost. I live in Norway, we have horrible agriculture. Only about 1% of farmable, and only 1/3 of that can be used for grains. Seasons are short, and 2/3 of farmland can only support grass. The farmland we have is tucked into small valleys, making big agriculture impossible. So farming here is very expensive compared to a place like Malaysia or USA for that matter. We have very expensive labor here too. But we subsidize farming so we have food security, sure we still import alot of foods (Tomatoes from Spain, vegetables from Netherlands. But the staple foods are farmed here, like meats, wheat etc. We want food security here in Norway, so we bear the cost of our expensive agriculture. Its a human neccessity after all

@RazielKirin 2 года назад

@@MrDanisve Nothing good in life comes cheap. Let alone free.

@luakabsalam1816 2 года назад

That teaches us on how not to rely on foreign imports of food including animals feeds and foreign workers.

@bobafett5757 2 года назад

*Well Done CNA you did it again this is an incredible informative and brilliant documentary so keep it up always with world class well directed documentary and that handsome host is excellent in all his deliveries*

@harukrentz435 2 года назад

Ffs!

@lobsterparity7514 2 года назад

Im a Malaysia and I love this series! Thanks CNA 🇲🇾🇸🇬

@chanjacky7807 2 года назад

do u mean *Malaysian*??

@lobsterparity7514 2 года назад

@@chanjacky7807 no. I'm a country.. Singapore's neighbor.

@touro603 2 года назад

spelling failed

@akari3354 2 года назад

@@touro603 so what

@asiaone9609 2 года назад

@@touro603 lol why low standard? We have our own language! English is not our mother tongue! You as a Singaporean should be ashamed! Where is your country identity?! Worship English language ah?? Hahahhaha.. Shipper doggy!

@catsozen 2 года назад

I imagine Rai only did this piece just so he could eat chicken rice in Malaysia 😂 Jokes aside nice reporting! Really gives me the different perspectives on the issue at hand. Just hope the supply really does catch up sooner and we're not bogged down with high prices for too long.

@Honestandtruth 2 года назад

I hear Jealousy 😂

@1989cpy 2 года назад

At least he can travel to KL. No need to go JB.

@moongal3510 2 года назад

Thks so much to CNA for doing this documentary, gave me much better understanding on the chicken shortage situation. I’m a Malaysian, wonder if any local media have done something similar? Well they really should…instead of just reporting on sensational news, we need documentary like this that give us insights into the industry, possible solutions etc…that will give people more hope instead of just grumble and complaints…

@sharilsamad9727 2 года назад

I totally agree, documentary-like this helps us tackle fake news. Fake news is the weapon of choice for our scrupulous politicians.

@wanr5701 2 года назад

Majority of Malaysians unfortunately, did not like documentaries nor prefer to consume anything like it. Too heavy for their liking and thought that this sort of thing only for those educated and nerds. Otherwise, 7pm drama and all those entertainment shows will not obtain high ratings.

@fhetfet6402 2 года назад

solution is dont buy msia chicken or any other poultry.

@soha8618 2 года назад

@@fhetfet6402 bagus ma beli ayam yang lagi mahal atau jangan makan ayam pi tangkap katak belakang rumah tu lagi sedap . 😂😂😂😂😂😂

@boy88888 2 года назад

Malay news more focus on crime rape natural disasters accidents and Islam related news only

@wh6055 2 года назад

Functionally speaking, an oligopoly and a cartel are the same. The only difference is whether their bosses talk or not, not the easiest thing to police. Guy only stops short of calling them a cartel to avoid losing his corporate clients.

@MrKattie123 2 года назад

Explanation from Dr Ferlito is the 10/10 answer during an economics test.

@alexcantos3879 2 года назад

Agricultural education is key here. Instead of encouraging the use of machineries for soil tilling, start adopting no-till practices with topsoil health management as main focus. Good soil will remedy all production related issues and cut down costs needed on repetitive application of chemical fertilizers and pesticides that end up with poor quality feed, thus poor quality poultry.

@smaug.the.stupendous 2 года назад

Only in Malaysia can u find two persons talking in two different languages to each other and they understand each other perfectly.

@koboi_tanah5874 2 года назад

ayam kampung yg senang,tidoq atas pokok,makan segaala mak nenek,mandi hujan buat taktau saja😂😂 aku pernah tgok bapak ayam lawan ulaq tikus,kucing dn helang,..anjing pon dia pukui,hari hari main dlm hutan,mahgrib baru balik😅🤭

@larrykay4061 2 года назад

Very infornative report on current chicken supply situation..just wondering if situation the same all over Malaysia😟

@tanengliang2749 2 года назад

Malaysia has been using automated and close house system for more than 10 years.

@s._3560 2 года назад

Studies have already been done in the world about using stabilised rice bran to feed chickens instead of wheat bran. Universities here should do studies about utilising plants that are indigenous or easy to grow in this region to feed chickens.

@timschulz3714 2 года назад

Why not use plants that are indigenous/easy to grow to feed humans?

@rollinghippo2940 2 года назад

@@timschulz3714 aren't that is what we are doing rite now? rice is life in the whole asean

@TOTO-mj4zt 2 года назад

Cost is the main concern for breeders

@namazlur78 2 года назад

Thats kind of wheat is costlier than dedak

@1989cpy 2 года назад

rice bran? There's plenty of them in Kedah.

@catzhakury 2 года назад

Great story.. thank you for an eye opening video

@jasonl4218 2 года назад

the fact is that we are separate nation for many many years. for me, if malaysia not able to supply or don't want to supply . . . it is up to them, unless we have a contract like water. as a singaporean, i am thinking that after so many years of independence ... it is our government responsibility to ensure food supply, not other nation job to do so for us .

@chawza8402 2 года назад

If so, what should the Singapore's government do to "ensure food supply"?

@rayiscoolandawesome 2 года назад

As Malaysian, I know there are many people who share similar mentality as you in Singapore. Your government is more than capable to take a good care of Singaporean well being. This chicken thing may be a hot issue now but it's for sure you'll be able to get over it at some point.

@eadiey3681 2 года назад

@@chawza8402 let the gov resolve it . . . we always said we are the high class country with high educated people compare to other asean. let our brilliant ministers come with solution. this matter were raised in late 90s and early 2000s, more than 20 years ago when the population not like today. i remember that some experts had advice for our gov to allocate just some space for agriculture with technology support like solar. they also advise gov to venture on producing food like chicken at other asean countries and to export back to spore. what gov did is just invest heavily on palm oil in indonesia which we own ~ 50% of their palm oil production. gov looking more into something that more profitable and more money. gov comfortable on depending the food supply from other countries esp malaysia. there still not much effort on producing food ... an it is more than 20 years ago !

@leealex24 2 года назад

Yeah Singaporeans can eat the organic chicken what. All chicken exports already resumed except the broiler which I think is perfectly acceptable since local needs take priority

@ML-yu5ij 2 года назад

@@eadiey3681 Singapore never had a comparative advantage in food production. Are you going to rear 10,000 chickens in your HDB flat? what a dimwit

@alfonsojee81 2 года назад

why is it when the Malaysian fella speak english, there's a subtitle, but when the Singaporean speak english, there's no subtitle

@fhetfet6402 2 года назад

anything wrong with that?

@PetaniModern40 2 года назад

Mantap dr carmelo mudah dipahami penjelasannya,,salam dari Indonesia

@ncode03 2 года назад

"This system while expensive..." How expensive? How much would one closed house would go by? The cost is the most important detail which determines the decision to switch but unfortunately, nobody knows this. Even if it has many variables to consider for the cost, at least you can give a range so viewers can estimate accordingly

@weiskl887 2 года назад

LOL reminds me of days in the past when LKY complains bout media being all special effects n soundtrack instead of concrete numbers of information.

@yengsabio5315 2 года назад

The cost of one building is mentioned somewhere in the video.

@RayMak 2 года назад

Thank you for this...

@ramatgan1 9 месяцев назад

Singapore how can you be a country when you can't even feed yourself. You import 90% of your food. All your food, fruit and vegetables comes from a truck in Malaysia. 🤣🤣🤣

@davidjardenil8393 2 года назад

Chicken shortages in Singapore and Malaysia which can be addressed by the Philippine chicken producers. Get some of your chicken supply from the Philippines if ever there is a shortage in your country. It can cover the chicken shortages you are experiencing in your country. We have more chicken broiler production in the Philippines as well as backyard poultry. This means the big three islands of the Philippines namely: Luzon, Visayas and Mindanao.

@Blaze6432 2 года назад

The problem is in order to meet the market demand, they would have to be HALAL certified, which much of the meat is not.

@observer9051 2 года назад

@@Blaze6432 If they only care too much HALAL than there is no hope for malaysia 😔. I dare you if someday we out of food let see if u care HALAL or not HALAL

@beautifuldurian 2 года назад

The young chickens in the first farm look very tired.

@elainectlow 2 года назад

Thanks for your true sharing. We hope that very soon the shortages would be adjusted to the Singapore demands. After all fresh chickens are much tasty!

@fhetfet6402 2 года назад

not without price jacking

@yenfoonlai9886 2 года назад

A very well presented video

@AnilKumar-my5jl 2 года назад

Being a chicken producing farmer the farm shown was very dirty unhygienic and methodology aslo very bad

@fhetfet6402 2 года назад

you cant expect msians to do any good, just be glad they at least understand basic human communications.

@zenchang7799 2 года назад

@@fhetfet6402 racist fucktards

@slyzero9803 2 года назад

@@fhetfet6402 and yet those Malaysian can't do any good Malaysian supplying clean water and chicken,btw in this video chicken coop only for Malaysia market not for Singapore,Singapore have regulated about chicken,oh btw stop talking only in social media be a gentleman and help fixing this issue if u from Singapore

@fhetfet6402 2 года назад

@@slyzero9803 you wanna talk about water? where have you been? msia always threatening to cut of water even with binding legal contracts. good msian? where? you have absolutely no stand, none at all to talk about being a gentlemen for the blaring fact you dont even have basic grasp of near past history issues between the 2 countries and here you are trying to be a "gentlemen"? I would say typical dumb/blind msian of you.

@jenaranggoro2951 2 года назад

lol. we have same problem here in Indonesia.. feed price are sky rocketing. chicken price also jumping only in the market but for farmer they got nothing. so many of them close their poultry

@richardtan8797 2 года назад

Sorry 77777877788877g777g7g7g😄G7YLmZEcB1s on 7😅🤗🤗

@richardtan8797 2 года назад

Zzzz zzzzzz zzzz

@arx8848 2 года назад

Bener

@akari3354 2 года назад

betul tu

@matmamat9690 2 года назад

Bela sendiri pasti hemat di setiap rumah gak perlu beli.. jangan malas!

@simonchoo1108 2 года назад

Fun fact: The reporter is holding a living chicken to pay last respect to the fallen chicken the farmer holding while face to face talking about the disease 😷

@buyrealweedonlinemalaysia7714 2 года назад

haha so funny, i got good green🌿🌿🌿🌿🍁🍁🍁💨💨🤙🏻🤙🏻🌿🌿🌿🌿🍁🍁🍁💨💨🤙🏻🤙🏻

@yahyabuang5596 2 года назад

Well done documentary.Right to the deepest root caused of chicken shortages. Rearing system need reinvention to a modern tech.

@yzyz7779 2 года назад

Alasan terbesar adalah dari kenaikan harga makanan ayam, pengilang makanan ayam mengatakan kenaikan harga chemical,jagung dan gandum yang di import.

@alixsonpl7973 2 года назад

Harga jagung memang banyak naik. Sebelum covid rm25. Sekarang jd rm50++ untuk 20kg

@yzyz7779 2 года назад

@@alixsonpl7973 kerana itu kerajaan patut mengalakkan penanaman jagung .

@kzmOP 2 года назад

good report

@DanSolowastaken 2 года назад

I grew up on a closed house chicken farm. In a place as hot and humid as Malaysia I'm surprised that it isn't the default. We didn't have them in little bins, but that might help isolate disease as a trade off to a higher foot print.

@bowlampar 2 года назад

In the past, every cost in chicken farming can go up, except the price of chicken meat sell to consumers. Now the accessibility of higher profit foreign market is blocked by government, foreigners are banned from buying Malaysian's chicken, it is tough all around for chicken businessman, time to close farm and go into retirement. ☹☹☹☹

@wjthor 2 года назад

Very good documentary. Well done! Maybe Singapore could look in to vertical poultry farms, maybe even floating poultry farms for long term food security.

@SM-ce1uy 2 года назад

or just go vegetarian ...

@deltahunter2302 2 года назад

@@SM-ce1uy 🤣🤣🤣🤣

@ckevin33 2 года назад

Just eat Fish lor…

@brownyadam 2 года назад

Still need manpower too.. i dont think singaporean interested in farming.. same with Malaysia, they need more migrant workers to help

@hal7ter 2 года назад

VERTICAL!?!? Look at all the green grass there between the cages. Fence that all in and with the chickens living on that, the grasses and the chickens would prosper, they would have a more na ural diet, not as many would die and the meat would taste a lot better. After looking at this, I would never want to eat one of these sick looking chickens!

@najwannaim9363 2 года назад

The modern chicken house shown in the video is not fully utilize as close house chicken farm as it is mainly use for post-graduate students projects. Full utilize close house chicken farm can be seen at 18:33.

@edensmith2426 2 года назад

It is dangerous to ban your only export market. If Singapore can't buy from Malaysia, they will have to buy from somewhere else, and they may well find that they can get a better deal from another country. Then when the supply situation stabilises, and Malaysia decide to open up exports again, they may find that Singapore no longer wants to buy

@bengtack 2 года назад

Price and freshness wise may still be hard to match our causeway neighhours's. If its that easy trust the gov to have explored this way earlier for food security ? #justsaying

@slyzero9803 2 года назад

So u gonna say that frozen chicken better then fresh slaughter chicken?

@wpariah 2 года назад

Very clear explanation by Dr. Ferlito about the causes for the shortage, and for why the gov't should not cap prices. Allow the free market to work.

@xponen 2 года назад

it is not 100% because it ignore details. If price spikes too fast, it causes a negative sentiment in the supply-chain; "chicken price is seen as volatile or uncertain", this has negative effect on demand-side as businesses try to absorb uncertainty by passing high service-fee to consumer which abate consumer purchasing power, dragging the whole economy down.

@fhetfet6402 2 года назад

msian corrupt officials need to drink kopi.

@JohnnyFarmingLife 7 месяцев назад

This guy is really good at his job. We love watching him

@terence3908 2 года назад

Very informative. But i can't help but wonder how do you signal to farmers the profit opportunities from 'high prices' when there's a price ceiling for chickens set by the government?

@princesssupernova5300 2 года назад

they don't profit

@MrWaterbugdesign 2 года назад

Closed chicken houses = more dependence on energy costs. Sounds risky to me.

@kewinjames7496 2 года назад

Solar?

@RayMak 2 года назад

Our government "kurangkan makan telur, ikat perut"

@tegarrdaneal6800 2 года назад

You eat pork u don't eat chicken shut up u

@monsakjasingh5320 2 года назад

Very good👏👏👏

@chekeocha4923 2 года назад

But how much is the rent of a building and the utility bills for close house breeding?

@DK-ym6wh 2 года назад

in another video they said 40% of cihckens are from brazil ...which is it ?

@sg_hokkien_opera 2 года назад

Other countries run out of food item, it can cause starvation and deaths. Singapore is crisis because it run out of fresh chicken and impact chicken rice stalls 😮

@powerbar1981 2 года назад

Hahaha... Go to East Malaysia in Sabah and Sarawak where you can find how we got treated chicken ceiling price are RM15 per kg. You have just know a little bit lah 😅😅😅

@toxicly 2 года назад

Kalau import kat Singapore diorang nak high quality jer🥴 So ayam mmg mahal nye lah

@daddyraffles7083 2 года назад

CNA insider should investigate about cartel in the poultry industry in Malaysia..

@papaalphaoscar5537 2 года назад

I love the title. 😁

@yiseng4602 2 года назад

Actually there isn't any shortage of chicken meat in Malaysia.But then Malaysians have to ask themselves why this is happening now which was unheard of previously. Yes,of course,there is a shortage of foreign workers and that has caused a labour shortage.But the goverment in power fails to address this issue. Then there are cartels that are controlling and deciding the supply,demand and the price of the chicken meat.These cartels are from a prominent political party in the country.

@puterirosidi3286 2 года назад

there is shortage? on 1st july 2022 as soon as price increased, we suddenly have a lot of large size chicken in the market that day.

@jasonbourne6531 2 года назад

Sad to see those chicken are not really healthy.. dropped alot of feathers..

@sharilsamad9727 2 года назад

They're still in diapers if they are human, even human baby don't look right when they still growing. Hiya! City people.

@macawism 2 года назад

The feed

@matmamat9690 2 года назад

Every thousands of it hundreds are dead each time for the farmers low technology

@darthbike189 2 года назад

of course it is..grew up in unhealthy environment... free range chicken or ayam kampung is the answer.

@xponen 2 года назад

@@darthbike189 still need to consider worm & parasite from soil, need to remove this parasite from the free range chicken, otherwise the chicken will grow too slow.

@aqiltank 2 года назад

Good video. In addition, why do not many people talk about the overconsumption that is happening in Malaysia? We have mega-corporations that make billions by selling fried chicken. Chicken is not supposed to be consumed in the way that most of us are doing it now! This fast food chain has to end, or this might be our last century here.

@Al-iu1nz 2 года назад

I did heard news of chicken shortage this month and it even reached to my country to the point they cancelled chicken menu in every restaurant and fastfood in here... So sad.. what's the worst thing is gonna happened

@Lai-so6jl 2 года назад

kudos to reporter and crew for conducting interview under the barn (super smelly weiiiii)

@namazlur78 2 года назад

I find its suprising that sinjiapore depends so much on Malaysia. Get your chicken somewhere else will be better. The domestic supply also problematic want tk export some more ah?

@NotLikeWhatYouThink Год назад

Huh they depend on water supply,petroleum,gas,raw and fresh vegetable,electric,cooking oil sawit also😁oh ya durian too.

@marduk3633 2 года назад

When the last tap dried, when the last tree lost its leaf.... U will start realise u cant eat Sing dollars.

@ML-yu5ij 2 года назад

You will also realise that the SGD allows us to source for alternative food sources. Oops did we just flex in your face?

@kuatkongket8893 2 года назад

How come you didn't report on the issue of chicken poo smell? How come the farm that you visited is free of flies? Something is also not fully transparent. The main issue with open farms is the menace of flies. And the 'organic' stench of the chicken manure. Eventhough closed system, farms need to be considerate to their surrounding residents that there are meshes to prevent flies from going in - feasting on the poo and replicate into thousands.

@DaniTrejo45 2 года назад

Now... Singapore and Penang kartel just eat capati with buffalo meat curry from Bangla kartel shipping in frozen mutton container.... some other richer still continue to eat expired quinoa from Mexico kartel

@johnwong8890 2 года назад

Last month I email to DBKL, MBPJ suggesting that grass cutters of town council pass grass cuts to cattle farmer s to feed their cattle. But no positive feedback. Traditionally Chicken eat grass, not corn

@kyril98741 2 года назад

Not all chicken are the same. Most of chicken breed for meat in Malaysia are specific breed that their diet are already figure out to ensure they meet the specific weight and dateline. Although there are farm that breed a chicken that could utilise other feed, it isn't really that profitable to be use. Beside they really need tonne of feed and grass clipping from your suggestion probably only help solve 1% of the problem while creating huge hidden cost to process it.

@muhammadhafizudinidris1592 2 года назад

Normal commercial chickens dont eat grass, they may starve to death

@NotLikeWhatYouThink Год назад

Aiyoo not all grass chicken eat bro..they eat madre agua..tu ketum ayam atau napier ke tu ayam organic..agak2 la.. nanti ayam tu k.o..tauge jagung rice bran boleh terima lagi.

@lindatang4955 2 года назад

It is better to plant more fresh organic corn for chicken feeds. Well I believe the chickens will more healthier and organic.

@daengmappatoba9585 2 года назад

HEBAT PAK DAENG NI,,

@michaellee3314 2 года назад

Singapore is a very versatile country. You banned this, we get it somewhere else. Singapore is rich and money talks. Others are lining up to sell to Singapore any product we need. In the end, the country banning the product will likely to be shooting its own feet. They will lose the market where its people have the purchasing power. They will not get back the market that is lost. At best a much reduced market.

@auxlixa 2 года назад

its so sad even though theres still chicken rice, it just doesnt taste as good as it did before :(

@noproblematallmate 2 года назад

It's all temporary. Soon we will have better chicken from other countries.

@MrBoliao98 2 года назад

That's why they try to bohong us with frozen chicken, our mouth can't bluff.

@auxlixa 2 года назад

@@MrBoliao98 yea haha. a few weeks ago, i ate chicken rice and the chicken tasted disgusting but i could definitely tell it was frozen chicken.

@Dandelion_flight 2 года назад

Just thinking of satisfying your taste buds… the poor chickens are suffering 😕

@MrBoliao98 2 года назад

@@Dandelion_flight pls lor want to eat, process and wash the meat. Don't want then don't eat.

@wapleviathan4006 2 года назад

The best is to diversify your food source (in this case, chicken). Also Singapore may invest in Indonesia to build poultries and pig farms. We are more than happy to have your investment.

@ramatgan1 9 месяцев назад

Singapore how can you be a country when you can't even feed yourself. You import 90% of your food. All your food, fruit and vegetables comes from a truck in Malaysia. 🤣🤣🤣

@hooiyewlim 2 года назад

it all depends on the government and politicians. If the government offer money for all small farmer to upgrade to closed house, you bet all will ask for a cut in the business.

@SquatterLoki 2 года назад

Those aren't even their money they subsidize to the small farmers. It comes from tax payers. Things like these was the reason big local business moved overseas e.g. Robert Kuok.

@matmamat9690 2 года назад

@@SquatterLoki yea yea he's the only one that i Heard of moving out..so good for him..as billionaire

@SquatterLoki 2 года назад

@@ytexplorer7977 Now perhaps the next big move is the non-Bumi forwarding business, should they not scrap the 51% equity.

@nomad90125 2 года назад

You must have emergency back up generators when rearing birds on mass scale. During a hot summer, opening windows won't be enough.

@ericong4100 2 года назад

But there's no summer in Malaysia. It's hot and humid almost whole year long.

@ZeroConZx 2 года назад

lol what summer

@za7v9ier 2 года назад

Feed the chickens black soldier fly larvae.. Black soldier flies decompose food waste, let them mate, producing more larvae for chicken feed. Very sustainable and cost effective. No need water to grow wheat, corn, soybeans etc...and you cut down the time needed producing chicken feed.

@secretdoorgaming2024 2 года назад

Look at those poor birds they live in digusting and horrible conditions. No wonder they are dying, the conditions they live in is deplorable and people are eating their fecal diseased flesh. The government should help these farmers, it's not only the birds health that is at stake and farmers livelihoods but the health of the people that eat chickens.

@gibsonobare 2 года назад

Sunlight is actually essential for all animals to be healthy. Pharmaceutical industry will obviously want this less known.

@buyrealweedonlinemalaysia7714 2 года назад

thats right🌿🌿🌿🌿🍁🍁🍁💨💨🤙🏻🤙🏻🌿🌿🌿🌿🍁🍁🍁💨💨🤙🏻🤙🏻

@NK_Khoo-Malaysian 2 года назад

If Singaporeans thought sourcing chicken from Indonesia or Thailand is solution unless SG consumers are willing to pay 3 times the price in Malaysia.

@nuraishah809 6 месяцев назад

So thankful to that corn guy

@MrRickjovi 2 года назад

gap planks on floor isnt good for chickens..they find it very uncomfortable. this is for its feaces to drop down easily but its not nice for chickens

@hal7ter 2 года назад

Looking at all the green grass there between the cages; if it were fenced, the grasses and the chickens would prosper, a more natural diet, not as many would die and the meat would taste a lot better. These are sad looking chickens!

@od5569 2 года назад

How much is electricity cost for closed chicken house?

@viswanathan2054 2 года назад

Give loans to chicken breeders at highly subsidised interest rate to build large hygenic concrete chicken breeding farms. Help them lah. Barulah betul.

@Happykakaru 2 года назад

Misleading coverage - the chicken farm that covered by CNA is not that the type of chicken farms that exported chicken to Singapore. This small scale farm that covered by CNA is dirty, not well managed & one man show, this is the village farm for local or nearby consumptions.

@sdqsdq6274 2 года назад

whats shocking is the feeds they are buying from european and the states ?

@rektredumqondom7957 2 года назад

thats why charoen phokphand ID have done chicken meat export recently to singapore, maybe kartel

@rosemalinamdisa1978 2 года назад

thank you for your reveal

@johnardygoh6245 2 года назад

Singdollar are strong,can buy anywhere,go and buy from Indonesia or Thailand,why busybody what’s happening on chicken industries in Malaysia,and don’t except the ban to lift until next year

@matmamat9690 2 года назад

Yeah don't buy in Malaysia there's a lot of choices to buy either Indonesia or Thailand or Myanmar they have a lot just don't buy Malaysia just bad and low quality

@leealex24 2 года назад

Sure Singaporeans can buy $20 chicken hence Malaysia dont have to export anymore, pay for $30 cab fares, $5 gas and of course, $110k COE. No issue la.

@henrybryan5092 2 года назад

@@leealex24 Malaysia deserve to eat sand.. don't buy anything from them

@fhetfet6402 2 года назад

@@leealex24sour grapes...lol

@wmchan44 2 года назад

By banning export to Singapore, Malaysia is forcing a glut of supply of fresh chicken in Malaysia to force down the price for their own consumers. But this artificial low chicken price is a double edge sword that will hurt Malaysia eventually as their farmers will cut their loss (escalating feed and labour cost) by producing less or no chicken. When Malaysia then tried to resume chicken export to Singapore they will find that alternative suppliers from Thailand and Indonesia had already taken their place. This is the reality of competitive trade. A classic case of: 搬起石頭砸自己的腳搬起石头砸自己的脚 (lifting up the rock but to have it drop on to own's foot) That is "shooting yourself in your own foot."

@sharilsamad9727 2 года назад

Let me remind everyone, that Malaysia and Singapore are not one country. Since both countries practice an open economy, supply and demand are King. If the precious SINGAPORE no longer wants our chicken, does that spell the end for Malaysia? Here is another old saying, a door shut another door opens. It is not all gloom without SINGAPORE!

@wmchan44 2 года назад

@@sharilsamad9727 Hey keep cool. It is Malaysia not selling the chicken to Singapore and NOT Singapore not wanting to buy from Malaysia. You are correct to say that when the Malaysia door closes it opens another door to Thailand and Indonesia. This is happening now.

@sharilsamad9727 2 года назад

@@wmchan44 WE cant sell it because our people need it. Profit sometimes has to take the second seat next to OUR people's needs. Being a Muslim country we also understand the concept of rezeki. By not selling to you, our chicken stays cheap for our people. That is our rezeki. You do as you please, not for us to question it.

@wmchan44 2 года назад

Actually the correct strategy for Malaysia to do is to encourage higher production of their chickens and export the surplus to Singapore since fresh chickens are selling in Singapore for about SGD$6 per kg while the same chicken can only sell at about RM10 (about SGD$3) per kg in Malaysia. The additional income can then be used to cover the increased cost of the chicken feed. That is the smarter move.

@sharilsamad9727 2 года назад

@@wmchan44 I actually watched the documentary, but thank you for your summarisation. Perhaps you SINGAPOREAN think that we watch the documentary for its moving images, not understanding any of it. I really do appreciate your patronizing way. Now MALAYSIA is able to find its way out.

@secrets.295 Год назад

It is so easy to solve this issue. Malaysia has 2 state owned banks. SME banks and CGC corporations. Why not distribute loans to chicken producers like Daim? Why not distribute loans to medium size or large chicken producers to build a closed house chicken breeding facility? Why not provide tax breaks for small and medium size chicken producers? What did the government do instead. Give money to people freely and increasing the money supply in the economy while at the same time food supply is still in shortage. The result is what? Higher inflation. I was laughing my a** off the other day when Rafizi's answer to solve the chicken crisis is to stop buying chicken with high prices. 😅😅😅. First of all, where do u even find low price chicken these days. Secondly, he spend weeks holding meetings with different agencies, ministers, etc. And yet this is the conclusion that he came up with. What a joke.

@Amitdas-gk2it 2 года назад

Interesting

@Honestandtruth 2 года назад

HOW many years To Be mature for chicken to be Harvest...❓❓❓❓

@joeharry32817 2 года назад

Demand will drive up prices.. salary in SG is higher, yet Malaysians are competing for the same chicken.. how is this a balanced issue?

@ramatgan1 9 месяцев назад

Singapore how can you be a country when you can't even feed yourself. You import 90% of your food. All your food, fruit and vegetables comes from a truck in Malaysia. 🤣🤣🤣

@ssangyongA230 2 года назад

Hey everyone if you are in yr 50s above, all these happenings are not new. For Sg pls expect such things to happen. As its not first time Malaysia executed a ban. Previously was cabbage vege. Then got durian, then other saga 🙄. In between water. The solution is to have diverse supply source from all over the world. Same as now we import vegetables from Taiwan, China and Indonesia and even further away. Malaysia govt policies have always backfired in the past to the detriment of their own farmers /producers. What to do ......Mahathir 3.0 akan datang on the way, expect more rocky roads ! Many new Malaysian leaders will copy and paste what the past leaders minds have done. So sad.....for Malaysian farmers.

@iceking5902 2 года назад

Whateva little kiasu islander...we still prosper way better than your chicken coop flat house and your tiny island and puny mindset.

@ShinRa 2 года назад

And this is why I love to watch CNA instead as a Malaysian. They do a better job accurately reporting Malaysian news than our unreliable local news.

@Wendy-dm5ox 2 года назад

The news media at Malaysia are too lazy to move their butts.

@kcchong8784 2 года назад

and there is someone who said "eat less if it's expensive"

@Coco762011 2 года назад

Maybe people should stop eating corns, cornflakes and popcorns so that with the reduced demand by humans, more corns can be sold to farmers at a lower price. After all, there’s not much nutritional value to humans compared to other grains.

@kelvincostner7775 2 года назад

My father is a chicken farmer and yeah our number of chickens are dwindling day by day

@luakabsalam1816 2 года назад

Closed house must be very expensive to establish.

@johnsonjohnson3122 2 года назад

Price ceiling is ridiculous. 1st its difficult to apply to all level. 2nd it kills the producer incentive. Producer can just slowing their production increment to force governement hands. Will people rage because high price or rage because out of stock like indonesia cooking oil?