Тёмный

The Untold Truth Of Robert The Bruce 

Grunge
Подписаться 2,4 млн
Просмотров 38 тыс.
50% 1

Опубликовано:

 

17 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 120   
@GrungeHQ
@GrungeHQ 2 года назад
What do you think about the story of Robert the Bruce?
@melm4760
@melm4760 2 года назад
Interesting
@johncrouch8988
@johncrouch8988 2 года назад
I’m glad you pointed out that French was the language used at court by the king. Scots are not taught their own history and believe that the English knights and warlords spoke with a BBC/oOxford accent. But they were Norman Knights etc descended from the Norman barons that were given land after the invasion. Many ordinary men fighting against the Scots people would have probably still felt to have had more in common with them than their masters that decided whether they and their families that lived on the Lords land lived or died! Oh and English children aren’t taught their true history either. Education has been taken over by lefty politics while we all slept. 🤷‍♂️
@NellieKAdaba
@NellieKAdaba 2 года назад
I like him.
@bennichols561
@bennichols561 2 года назад
He da man
@countrydawn418
@countrydawn418 2 года назад
Very good work.
@harris9375
@harris9375 2 месяца назад
As a Greek, I love Scotland and it's history I have been there once it really felt like home, I wish to get back soon see more places learn more about the beautiful Scottish people their history and visit the magnificent Highlands again that their beaty takes your breath away! Long live Scotland.
@Fires755
@Fires755 10 месяцев назад
I'm a Richardson, Rollo descendant,thier is a reconstruction of Robert the Bruce, looks just like My father,,i took after them too, it's all Great!!! Thank you for sharing!!!
@frasermanley9903
@frasermanley9903 2 года назад
I actually walk the 3 waterfalls of Clyde route quite often, there's a plaque there that notes Wallace's attack on the Lanark sheriff and their subsequent escape that included laying low in a small cave system along the same path I walk. I never realised this was like his first foray into rebellion. Makes the walk a lot more significant.
@corinnepmorrison1854
@corinnepmorrison1854 2 года назад
Scotland has a tumultuous history... I have been to Scotland and did visit Sterling Castle... There is a sculpture of Robert the Bruce...and looking over the castle’s wall, you can see the Wallace Memorial in the valley below... Also went to Scone Palace and learned about the “Stone of Destiny”... The Scots had possession of the small artifact centuries ago, but the Brits reclaimed that cherished treasure... Countless UK monarchs have knelt nipón the stone during their coronations...the most recent being Queen Elizabeth II, in 1952...
@Zenhumanist
@Zenhumanist 2 года назад
Hey. Btw it’s Stirling Castle and at the time it would have been the English reclaiming the stone not the Brits.
@corinnepmorrison1854
@corinnepmorrison1854 2 года назад
@@Zenhumanist You are correct!!
@corinnepmorrison1854
@corinnepmorrison1854 2 года назад
@@mariemarie2888 Did I make a major error?
@corinnepmorrison1854
@corinnepmorrison1854 2 года назад
My visit to Scotland was in late Spring of 1999...
@corinnepmorrison1854
@corinnepmorrison1854 2 года назад
@@mariemarie2888 We were in Scotland for our son’s wedding...at Dundas Castle in South Queensferry...
@garethmclellan7985
@garethmclellan7985 Год назад
This is the first American I have ever seen give a pretty accurate and well Presented synopsis of this story. Excellent 👌👏👏👏
@normaesquillo5463
@normaesquillo5463 Год назад
Nice to learn from Scottish history. That was never taught in school. Thank you so much.
@Dishfire101
@Dishfire101 2 месяца назад
Best film is to watch Outlaw King ❤
@isabellamill-benseman8934
@isabellamill-benseman8934 7 месяцев назад
I was always told about him, not till I was older did I understand what an incredible heroic man he was. Now I know it is an honour that i am a decedant of Robert the Bruce. My son is named after him.
@torbjrnlund903
@torbjrnlund903 4 месяца назад
Isabella did you kmow? Robert Bruce's sister's name was Isabella, and she was to become the Queen of Norway.
@MilkshakeEnthusiast1992
@MilkshakeEnthusiast1992 2 года назад
Braveheart wasn’t accurate at all. But I love that damn movie. I remember being 8-9 and watching the battle scenes constantly. So thanks Mel for getting me into medieval history
@denverrandy7143
@denverrandy7143 2 года назад
Frrrrrreeeeeeedddddoooommmmm!!!!!!!🤘🤪👍
@jamesmorton4443
@jamesmorton4443 Месяц назад
We are free.🎉
@elainegoad9777
@elainegoad9777 2 года назад
Many were named Robert the Bruce. Which decendant /generation are you referring to? The original Robiert de Bruis came from Normandie, France and was a decendant of Northmen/ Norsemen (Vikings) as Rollo, (Rolof the Viking) married the French King's (Charles) daughter and was awarded the 1st Duke of Normandie position. His Christian name was Robert. William the Conquer also from Normandie and great grandson of Rollo 1st Duke of Normandie. They were are related Norsemen.
@jasonpercy184
@jasonpercy184 2 года назад
That's very interesting Elaine . With that type of subject matter knowledge I'm sure you can deduce which Robert this guy is speaking about .
@brain_g00p25
@brain_g00p25 Год назад
@@jasonpercy184 fantastic response to something like this hehe
@razatare
@razatare Год назад
Learning about my ancestor is the most coolest thing
@Aussieboy329
@Aussieboy329 Год назад
we must be related
@Imachowderhead
@Imachowderhead Год назад
He is my 21st great grandfather.
@halzandrae
@halzandrae Год назад
25th Great grandfather direct blood relative here 😄
@SmokeyDaGoat
@SmokeyDaGoat 11 месяцев назад
@@Imachowderhead He's my 23rd great grandfather haha.
@SmokeyDaGoat
@SmokeyDaGoat 11 месяцев назад
@@halzandrae Wassup relative.
@CarlaHennen
@CarlaHennen Год назад
I recently discovered that I am a descendant of King Robert de Bruce. Abbey Bruce was the last ancestor to carry the Bruce name, she married into our Straight lineage in the 1600's. It's been pretty neat tracing our ancestry, seeing the many castles they have all lived in. Because of the Royal bloodline, I'm still tracing back past King Robert De Bruce, into the early 1000's
@RadBruce.
@RadBruce. Год назад
My family can trace our ancestors back to three Scottish brothers who traveled to America. And from there we can roughly trace it back to Robert the Bruce and from there to Odin. The man the norse god was named after. Also we still have the Bruce name
@SmokeyDaGoat
@SmokeyDaGoat 11 месяцев назад
Me too recently found out I'm a descendant of King Robert de Bruce too. My great great great grand pops yo pretty interesting stuff.
@Fires755
@Fires755 10 месяцев назад
I'm Rollo and Bruce, My father side My mother's side William Sinclair and her mother MacDonald, Wilkerson,read holy blood holy Grail by laurance Gardner and his other book Mary Magdalene!!! We have 3 black Leon's on our Crest,that got me started 20 year's ago doing Genealogy!!! Fun and rewarding!!!
@paulbutterworthbillericay
@paulbutterworthbillericay 9 месяцев назад
Robert de Bruce held the Manor at Writtle, the Church & font are as they were then, its likely his son The Bruce was born there & Baptised thier
@JustCallMeHorse
@JustCallMeHorse 9 месяцев назад
My great-grandad is a Turnbull, apparently, the Turnbull name was given to a guy by King Robert because the guy saved him from a bull :)
@scottmac2436
@scottmac2436 11 месяцев назад
The Guardians of Scotland asked for Edward I to intervene to decide the rightful claimant to become King of Scots and his 104 judge panel decided for John Baliol late in 1292 and disallowed the Bruce family claim derived from a younger sister to Baliol's ancestral royal sister. That Bruce claimant then was The Competitor , the grandfather of the future King Robert Bruce. He then made a claim to the tribunal that Scotland should be divided in to 3 parts among the 3 leading claimants who included himself and John Baliol. Later after Edward invaded Scotland William Wallace led one of at least 4 rebellions against the English occupation but a least 2 of them were a few earlier than his May 1297 rising.. Those 2 were the Comyn related MacDougalls in Argyll and Moray's rebellion in the Black Isle and Inverness areas. This story leaves out he entire part about Robert Bruce signing a pact with Edward I in 1320 and staying as his liege man until 1306 along with the families that were allied to the Bruces in Scotland. During this period John Comyn was a staunch defender of the Scottish independence until France made peace with King Edward and left Scotland stranded alone to fight Edward so all of the Scots not on Edward's side then agreed to a peace with Edward in February 1304. Bruce did not have to agree because he was already on Edward's side for 2 years. On Feb 10 1305 Bruce did not strike Comyn he knifed him with a weapon (concealed in his winter clothes) near the altar inside church where weapons were banned by church law as everyone knew. Bruce's wound to Comyn was fatal and he died inside the church. The story of others coming in to finish off Comyn was a later story put out to make Bruce seem less evil for the murder n a church. The man in the story said to have killed Comyn was actually 1 mile away at the Sheriff assizes in Dumfries Castle at that very moment. After Bruce stabbed Comyn this uncle Robert Comyn outside the church heard his cry but Bruce's companions the Seton brothers killed him immediately - a crime for which they later died a traitor's death in Dumfries though one other man survived and thrived with Bruce later. These facts are easily verified. What is also forgotten is that after Bruce died his wee son was forced into exile for 9 years by the return of John Baliol's son, Edward Baliol who became King Edward Baliol though he lost power in a few years for being too supportive of the English king King Edward III. The Bruce's son, David II returned from exile in France in 1341 but England had a lot of control over part of southern Scotland for deceased after that. .. All in all it is not a simple story but Bruce's story should be told factually.
@jenniferlivingston2383
@jenniferlivingston2383 2 года назад
Because James The Black Douglas ended up being a cousin to Marjorie's husband Walter(ancestor's of mine), research said he&60 men dressed as beasts to overthrew Roxurgh castle leaving only a woman(and her baby) caring for caged Mary alive. There's no soldier exchange for sis but was for Beth DeBurgh & Marjorie.
@albertdehn8381
@albertdehn8381 2 года назад
Thanks for sharing 👍😀
@jesusreigns222
@jesusreigns222 Год назад
Good video.. He is my 18th Great Grandfather on my Father's side
@andrewkeefe1358
@andrewkeefe1358 Год назад
Life to live on in the crag im sure 😉
@jesusreigns222
@jesusreigns222 Год назад
@@andrewkeefe1358 Whatever The Most High deems appropriate
@andrewkeefe1358
@andrewkeefe1358 Год назад
@@jesusreigns222 only the folks who knew God would not seek to harm more people. Peace be with you 😉
@jesusreigns222
@jesusreigns222 Год назад
@@andrewkeefe1358Thanks ..Back at you... A rarity to find one who knows. Ezekiel 21: 24 - 27, Psalm 2
@SmokeyDaGoat
@SmokeyDaGoat 11 месяцев назад
He's my 23rd Great Grandfather 😀😀
@maureenhannivan8043
@maureenhannivan8043 2 года назад
My grandmothers ancestors including her, were named Lockhart, (Lockheart) who I understand fought with Robert, and carried the lee penny.
@tysonmaillot
@tysonmaillot Год назад
just finished doing some deep research on my my family ancestry and found out we are descendants of robert the bruce, my grandfathers mothers great x4 mothers side a long ways back
@IosuamacaMhadaidh
@IosuamacaMhadaidh 8 месяцев назад
Outlaw King beats Braveheart in historical accuracy. It isn't perfect but much better, especially arms and armour.
@ConchRepublic2047
@ConchRepublic2047 2 года назад
I’m related to the house of Wessex, House of Alpin, House of Gorm, House of Dunkeld, House of Bruce, House of Stewart, but actually spelt sturat and king Robert 1st was born I think 1273-1329, then the royalty stops at king James which then tags off to Robert Sturat then Earl Menteith, Fife, duke of Albany, then Murdock sturat 2nd duke of Albany and then leads to Isabel Sturat and m. Sir Walter Buchanan which eventually leads to father Buchanan, after that I can’t disclose what way the family tree went, but it’s pretty cool when you can find a video like this and get a full understanding on Robert Bruce in general, I happened to find some documents written by my great great grandmother which were then checked and confirmed by a historical professional in stuff like this. The problem is that when I share information like this people say I’m fibbing so believe what you want I just thought I’d share this
@darlenemestas5839
@darlenemestas5839 2 года назад
Because if you were part of those lines, you'd be verified by dna and written with records. You'd also be in family groups. Your professional should have known that. Men have to be verified by dna.
@jeremywatson4860
@jeremywatson4860 Год назад
@@darlenemestas5839 not true at all. I descend from Robert the Bruce as well 29 generations ago. Have you thought about how many people that entails? Or did you just jump straight to calli ng people liars.
@SmokeyDaGoat
@SmokeyDaGoat 11 месяцев назад
@@jeremywatson4860 I descend from Robert the Bruce 23 generations fr we relatives.
@robertmaynard4654
@robertmaynard4654 2 года назад
Robert in some way betrayed William,in order to preserve his line
@idrisabdulrahman2042
@idrisabdulrahman2042 Год назад
In the end everyone look out for themselves
@xo121w
@xo121w Год назад
History is rewritten by winners.
@Dishfire101
@Dishfire101 2 месяца назад
Long story short King James 6th of Scotland took over England in 1603 under the House of Stuart ❤❤❤❤❤
@Pixdust77
@Pixdust77 7 месяцев назад
I'm a year late, but great video!
@JustCallMeHorse
@JustCallMeHorse 9 месяцев назад
Apparently, my ancestor saved him from a bull and he named him Turnbull. Turnbull is my grandma's side of the family treeline :)
@aliciamarie9704
@aliciamarie9704 2 года назад
Hello! John Comyn is an ancestor of mine. The name evolved to Cummins in America. It’s very difficult to trace history this old unless you find the royalty you come from.
@doomdrew4772
@doomdrew4772 10 месяцев назад
Yeah this is true I'm a Cummings but where my dad is from Belfast (Scots Irish) it's difficult to trace ancestry past 1800s since the records in Ireland are pretty bad. My mother's side managed to trace back as far Mary QOS as the Scottish records are much more comprehensive.
@thehornboy
@thehornboy 8 месяцев назад
alexander 3rd wasnt heading south, he was heading north. edinburgh to kinghorn (in Fife)
@wulfcogle9988
@wulfcogle9988 2 года назад
Saor Alba gu bràth 2023.
@rockingthemike
@rockingthemike 2 года назад
why does this sound like it was recorded in the 14th century?
@corinnepmorrison1854
@corinnepmorrison1854 2 года назад
I disagree...🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿
@13Kormoran
@13Kormoran 2 года назад
7:13 -Horse Mounted- Cavalry: the first 2 words are redundant since that is implied by the 3rd. word.
@ihaveaboyfriendmeh1026
@ihaveaboyfriendmeh1026 Год назад
Please don't add music in serious discussions. My ear was getting noises and my mind distracted
@patricktitters
@patricktitters 2 года назад
👍
@kingbob3757
@kingbob3757 2 года назад
My name is Robert to
@garmo98
@garmo98 2 года назад
cav·al·ry: (in the past) soldiers who fought on horseback. cal·​va·​ry: an open-air representation of the crucifixion of Jesus
@bluedragonfly5
@bluedragonfly5 2 года назад
Robert the Bruce murdered my ancestor Red John Comyn (Cummings) in a church in 1306. Red John Comyn was to be the king of Scotland.
@darlenemestas5839
@darlenemestas5839 2 года назад
Hmm is that the scene in the movie?
@darlenemestas5839
@darlenemestas5839 2 года назад
And the real king of England is in Australia. That's not the legit line.
@bluedragonfly5
@bluedragonfly5 2 года назад
@@darlenemestas5839 No but it is in the history books.
@Dishfire101
@Dishfire101 17 дней назад
Scotland has never been conquered, your talking about England buddy Romans, Normans, and then in 1603 King James 6th of Scotland took over England ❤
@hottubmobileneil
@hottubmobileneil 4 месяца назад
I am not Neil , I am a roommate You have mistakes in this video , King Robert did not kill John Comyn he wounded him and his friends finished him off . King Robert and Comyn fought at Grey Fryers Church .
@IntrepidFraidyCat
@IntrepidFraidyCat 2 года назад
The Battle of Bannockburn...😳 A powerful bonk on the noggin.
@imagemcriacoes1161
@imagemcriacoes1161 2 года назад
that's a sad thing to realize that William Wallace was a Tiradentes of Scotland.
@fumanpoo4725
@fumanpoo4725 2 года назад
Was he sly?
@robertlyon8876
@robertlyon8876 6 месяцев назад
I am a descendant of Robert Bruce through his grand daughter who married my ancestor Sir John Lyon .
@Timeticker81
@Timeticker81 2 года назад
HAHA SCAAATLAND...
@BeccasMovieChannel
@BeccasMovieChannel 4 дня назад
This is upsetting to me because His real last name is La' Parkier he was renamed De Bruce by the queen who sent him there because queen Mary wasn't old enough yet. (Parker)
@BeccasMovieChannel
@BeccasMovieChannel 4 дня назад
So your heritage info is probably incorrect
@BeccasMovieChannel
@BeccasMovieChannel 4 дня назад
He was My Great Great Great I think 19th Great Grandfather so I want people to know the truth
@dr.d5920
@dr.d5920 2 года назад
Balliol.....the i is silent and the o is long.....so it's not Balleol but Balloyl. Sheesh!
@universallymarred4978
@universallymarred4978 2 года назад
Terrible music.
@casey5654
@casey5654 10 месяцев назад
The Roberts? I think you meant the Bruce’s?
@Reedc16
@Reedc16 11 дней назад
I did my DNA test to see if I was related to Robert the Bruce turns out I am related to him because I would be his grandson today
@Mademoiselle_Co_
@Mademoiselle_Co_ Год назад
This information is incorrect-
@dulynoted8655
@dulynoted8655 2 года назад
Why can’t people correctly pronounce CAVALRY???
@СвпетарГајтан
@СвпетарГајтан Год назад
Asterix
@stephene.barbin8036
@stephene.barbin8036 2 года назад
I'm a descendant of Malcolm II [via Brusse/Brus/Bruce & De Braose lines, as well as Kings Duncan, Malcolm III, David I & William I via the De Ross line (Roslyn)] as well as from John Balliol, John Comyn III and Kings Edward I, II and III of England. A very complex family tree, to say the least.
@donaldsimmonsjr
@donaldsimmonsjr 2 года назад
I'm a descendant of them too, via my Ulster Scotch family, the Grahams - in Northern Ireland, that is. In Scotland, they're Clan Graham. In addition to the royals you mentioned, I'm also descended from Clan Lindsay, Clan Seton, Clan Abernathy, as well as the Campbells, James I + II + III + IV + V of Scotland, Henry I & II of England, Isabella of Hereford, plus Isabella de Clare, 4th Countess Pembroke, as well - and the list truly goes on and on.
@obcl8569
@obcl8569 2 года назад
That would be one helluva family reunion 😂 Fascinating.
@obcl8569
@obcl8569 2 года назад
@@donaldsimmonsjr and yours as well! My goodness, they could never have imagined having descendants with such heritage - history is so intriguing and captivating. Thank you both for sharing your thrilling family trees!
@SmokeyDaGoat
@SmokeyDaGoat 11 месяцев назад
@@obcl8569 I'm a descendant of Robert the Bruce found out yesterday so interesting
@ronaldpalmer451
@ronaldpalmer451 Год назад
The English never got the real stone
@ronaldpalmer451
@ronaldpalmer451 Год назад
@CrazyKid61854 well you will know the The Bruce was the man known as braveheart ,not William Wallace and that on three occassions the english offered Scotland the stone that they stole back but the Scots were not interested
@anthonyodonnell6105
@anthonyodonnell6105 2 года назад
Pronounced ar-BROATH
@hellorobloxen8665
@hellorobloxen8665 2 года назад
I am related to Robert Bruce
@rleitros9378
@rleitros9378 2 года назад
So also is HM Queen Elizabeth II who is a direct descendant both through her father and mother
@xo121w
@xo121w Год назад
THEY WILL NEVER TAKE OUR FREEEEEEEEDOMMMM
@jamesmorton4443
@jamesmorton4443 Месяц назад
Don’t need to take your freedom your already FREE.
@albertdehn8381
@albertdehn8381 2 года назад
Thanks for sharing 👍😀
Далее
СТАЛ КВАДРОБЕРОМ
00:34
Просмотров 112 тыс.
What They Don't Say About the William Wallace Monument
17:03
Alfred the Great - Saviour of the Saxons Documentary
55:30
Which Clans Fought at Bannockburn?
11:31
Просмотров 107 тыс.
The Problem With Elon Musk
42:46
Просмотров 4,6 млн