The XY Ring: A Classic Sudoku Technique

Подписаться 604 тыс.

Просмотров 74 тыс.

50% 1

▶ OUR NEW ARROW SUDOKU APP IS OUT ON ALL PLATFORMS!
Here are the links:
Steam:
store.steampowered.com/app/16...
App Store:
apps.apple.com/us/app/arrow-s...
Google Play:
play.google.com/store/apps/de...
*********************************************************************
Today's sudoku was created for a Discord speed-setting competition y Sam Cappleman-Lynes. It's called Delirium on the basis that Sam was almost in a a trance state when he made it due to lack of sleep! Please have a go at it at the link below:
app.crackingthecryptic.com/su...
Rules:
Normal sudoku rules apply.
SPOILER: There is some detail on the technique Simon uses in the video at the very bottom of this video description!
▶ PATREON MADNESS ◀
Jovi_al's 20-puzzle Sudoku Extravaganza is just OUT. We also are offering an incredible prize created by Anita Berge - many many thanks Anita - which is a pillow throw featuring the first puzzle in Jovi_al's set. To have a chance of the prize, send the message you get when you've completed puzzle 20 to us at crackingthecryptic@gmail.com
Remember that we will also be releasing a new Murder Mystery Sudoku Hunt for everybody if we reach 5000 patrons.
/ crackingthecryptic
▶ NEW CTC PODCAST - PILOT EPISODE ◀
You can listen to our new podcast at the links below.
Apple Podcasts: podcasts.apple.com/au/podcast...
Google Play: podcasts.google.com/feed/aHR0...
Spotify: open.spotify.com/show/4lr4ojq...
**************************************************************
▶ OUR NEW KILLER SUDOKU APP IS OUT ON ALL PLATFORMS◀
apps.apple.com/us/app/killer-...
store.steampowered.com/app/14...
play.google.com/store/apps/de...
▶ SIMON REACTION BOARD (!) ◀
With thanks to Andrea for creating this :)
simonreacts.avris.it/
▶ OUR MIRACLE SUDOKU APP IS OUT ◀
Steam: store.steampowered.com/app/13...
App Store: apps.apple.com/us/app/id15273...
Android: play.google.com/store/apps/de...
▶ CTC FAN DISCORD SERVER◀
/ discord
NEW: Guide To Our Discord Server:
tinyurl.com/CTCDiscordGuide
▶ OUR BACK CATALOGUE - ALL CATEGORISED WITH LINKS!◀
tinyurl.com/CTCCatalogue
▶ OUR NEW THERMO SUDOKU APP IS OUT!◀
AppStore: apps.apple.com/us/app/thermo-...
Android: play.google.com/store/apps/de...
Steam: store.steampowered.com/app/13...
▶ NEW CRACKING THE CRYPTIC MERCHANDISE◀
teespring.com/en-GB/stores/cr...
▶ OUR CHESS SUDOKU APP IS NOW OUT!◀
AppStore: apps.apple.com/us/app/chess-s...
Steam: store.steampowered.com/app/12...
Android: play.google.com/store/apps/de...
▶TRY OUR CLASSIC SUDOKU APP◀
AppStore: apps.apple.com/us/app/classic...
Steam: store.steampowered.com/app/11...
Android: play.google.com/store/apps/de...
▶TRY OUR SANDWICH SUDOKU APP◀
AppStore: apps.apple.com/us/app/sandwic...
Steam: store.steampowered.com/app/11...
Android: play.google.com/store/apps/de...
▶SEND US PUZZLES TO SOLVE/CONTACT US◀
crackingthecryptic@gmail.com
▶FOLLOW US◀
Twitter: #crypticcracking
@crypticcracking
Instagram (for how to solve daily clues from The Times): crackingthe...
▶SOFTWARE◀
Play the puzzle in the video by clicking the link under the video (above). We are building a website which will allow you to enter your own sudoku puzzles into the software and this is coming soon!
▶Logo Design◀
Melvyn Mainini
▶ABOUT US◀
Hi! We're Simon Anthony and Mark Goodliffe, two of the UK's most enthusiastic puzzle solvers. We have both represented the UK at the World Sudoku Championships and the World Puzzle Championships.
Thank you for watching!
Simon and Mark
SPOILER: As the title of the video notes, the technique is called an XY-Ring. It shares some logic with techniques like an XY-Chain and a Continuous Nice Loop. We can cover these in other videos if there is interest.

Опубликовано:

4 июл 2021

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 239

@colinbrash 3 года назад

I don’t know what you have done to me. I cannot solve sudokus without an inner narrative in an English accent. Bobbins!

@hummakavula3750 3 года назад

Same 😂

@BozoTheBear 3 года назад

I have an inner monologue saying things like "The 2 goes in, the 3 goes in, this is absolutely beautiful!"

@icedbear 3 года назад

Sayme here, and I'm not even an native english speaker.

@notthatseanbean 3 года назад

My wife and I solve together, and can't say "pair" anymore. It's "peh".

@nathanielnizard2163 3 года назад

I would permanently pincil mark that lovely word on my left buttock if I had not to be a role model

@Mark199201 3 года назад

"How many ones do we have? Only 4" Poor old Sam, he's given Simon more digits than his last 10+ puzzles combined, and Simon still has the gall to use "only"! Great puzzle, thank you

@puppetsock 3 года назад

Yeah, but it's a classic puzzle. The hardest classics often are the ones with more clues just because they are forcing such structures as this ring to exist. I really enjoyed this one. I would be glad to see more really tough classics. Speaking only for myself of course.

@Rubrickety 3 года назад

It’s remarkable that a man of such obvious dexterity, with hundreds upon hundreds of hours of practice, should get no better at typing the intended digit on the first try. 😊 Love you, Simon.

@knightry 3 года назад

I think he got the correct digit on the first try less than 50% of the time in this video. Might be a new record? Interestingly, he always seems to err on the low side (left side) when mistyping. Left brain confirmed?

@elizabethgrosvenor153 3 года назад

left HAND, probably, and right hand on the mouse

@tommihaapanen846 3 года назад

Using the numpad is the cheat code on typing numbers.

@briannelson605 3 года назад

What are those black symbols located in the middle of the grid?

@adamheywood113 3 года назад

They look similar to the blue symbols present in a completed grid but beyond that, I'm not sure

@afrayedknot81 3 года назад

These are called "givens". Ask your grandfather - he'll tell you all about them.

@adamheywood113 3 года назад

@@afrayedknot81 "Grandad what are... guy-veens?"

@toneloc7910 3 года назад

Some of these sudoku variants and rules are just getting crazy.

@PhilBoswell 3 года назад

You watch, somebody will be calling this variant "naked sudoku" soon enough ;-)

@jovi_al 3 года назад

We judge anonymously for these competitions, but I knew this was Sam's the moment I saw it. A clear winner in my eyes!

@avisian8063 3 года назад

Feels meaningful that humans can have a distinct voice in any one of a million languages. Including the setting of puzzles of all things. I also thought this "feels" like his puzzles I have solved .

@siorac1147 3 года назад

I'm very pleased with myself: I managed to do this without reading anything but the rules. The loop around the central box was very... satisfying, somehow. Took me 32:29 so I was slow but I'm still happy.

@danielblandin6089 3 года назад

Very pleased here also, did it in 43. But I didn't do anything weird, just checked boxes, column and rows over and over again

@kieranholden7964 2 года назад

An hour 40 for me😂

@Sam_weiqi 3 года назад

Ahhh, the classic "looping round bent quadruple". How I've waited for this day!

@_hhk 3 года назад

I may or may not be on my second drink on a Monday evening, alone in bed watching an English guy solving sodokus (please, this is a judging free zone, let me have my two drinks in peace). But I just needed to point out that it should be called a bent qualoopdral. Thank you and cheers.

@flackbyte 3 года назад

For the first time I've done a puzzle faster than Simon. I feel like a child who won in chess against their dad for the first time. But, to be fair, the title of the video gave me a clue of what to look for.

@susanne5803 3 года назад

Ha! Found something without looking at the end of the description. First I obviously checked for SET. No luck but I'm still a beginner and wouldn't see all options. Then I just started pencilling in like in those years before CtC. Boxes, rows, columns. And then my specialty: whenever I find at least four digits given in a box, row or column, I can keep juggling five digits in my mind - and I pencil optional digits in only if there are no more than two digits in a cell. That's how I found that rectangular quadruple or whatever it is called. But since I have no idea how to proceed I'll watch the video now. Thank you very much! (Edit: I did it! Took me a little less than an hour and lots of colours, and I pencilled the two alternatives all the way up/ down/ right/ left the topple chain: one way with corner pencils, the other with central pencils. That helped me see the pattern.)

@victorfinberg8595 3 года назад

"Entering a trance-like state" can give you access to parts of your mind that aren't normally accessible, if you do it properly.

@ronmasters751 3 года назад

Great fun! I saw the quadruple as well, didn’t realize it was such a powerful constraint. Once you pointed it out, I was able to force a row, a column, a couple of X-wings, several naked pairs, and the whole thing then collapsed. Thanks!

@thereoncewasalimerickwriter 3 года назад

36 minutes for me. I saw the bent quad quite early, but it took me a while to see its effect on the rows and columns. Well, I'm only 74. Still learning.

@hellomynameisdiablo 3 года назад

I feel proud I only did this 3 minutes slower than SImon, I feel like that's an accomplishment lol. Fun puzzle!

@pjbrady47 3 года назад

Spent an hour on it, figured out the bent quadrangle, but managed to somehow mess up my 3,5,8s at the very end with no idea where I went wrong. But I'm happy to see I was on the right track!

@longwaytotipperary 3 года назад

I first looked up XY chain - then realized that wasn't it - it was XY RING. Looked that up XY ring and the first option was this video. Think I'm just going to rely on Siimon's explanation.

@DirkieB 3 года назад

"They only take a few minutes each time" ... That hurt Simon, that hurt.

@SmartHobbies 3 года назад

The bent quad is very cool to see (Simon already spoiled this in the description). It works like an XY-Chain, or Nice Continuous Loop, and it's powerful because you can eliminate all additional candidates from the row or column that contains 2 of the candidates (for example, you can eliminate the rest of the 9's in row 3). What makes it really cool is that you normally can't "rotate" the XY-Chain to make more eliminations, but with this you can because it loops. Yes, please show more videos that have these types of techniques. Thanks for sharing this puzzle.

@chocolateboy300 3 года назад

It's very rare that I'm able to do a Classic Sudoku from this channel, however, this one clicked me with me very well. I even did it under half-an-hour. Really good puzzle!!!

@wade_23 3 года назад

my time 17:58 I'm proud of myself, that is the first time I have EVER gotten a faster time than Simon. No way that would have been possible without all of the methods I've learned from the channel

@raylong3825 2 года назад

As always, Simon's logic is fantastic, and probably handy for speed. I'm not racing the clock and I don't see everything Simon spots. Funny that he says "don't go looking for an XY chain," which I don't think I would go hunting for, but when you've got one highlighted for 9 minutes, it's kind of hard to ignore. And this one was great to use 4 times and make progress.

@TheDrexxus 3 года назад

I love how excited this dude gets when he is on a roll.

@WesleySpikes 3 года назад

I really appreciate how Sam guided the solver towards the strategy at the very start of the puzzle. I'd solved in in ~25 minutes today. Seeing so many numbers in a 2-wide ring created a feeling to start by filling in the candidates in those rows/cols, and quickly finding the pairs in the corner that created the ring. After that, the puzzle was quite approachable. Feels good to solve!

@crystalgehrt8861 3 года назад

I am watching Lion King (original movie) with my 4 and 6 year old. They can't concentrate on the movie because they say Zazu, the red-billed hornbill is Simon! I'm cracking up over here!

@cj719521 3 года назад

Loved this one! Finished in ~1hr! I broke it and had to back out a ways, so the 1hr is even with back tracking! Fantastic puzzle. This is one I wouldn't have been able to do before I found this channel and started learning about sudoku technique beyond scanning rows and columns. haha Thank you again for the fantastic context!

@cj719521 3 года назад

By the way, I'd _love_ a blank grid demonstration of hypotheticals to demonstrate the advanced techniques from the "spoiler" section of the description.

@minamagdy4126 3 года назад

I think that, far from trying to distract you, maverick is actually trying to drop some knowledge bombs into the video

@gregorysantos7624 3 года назад

Disappointed in myself for not seeing the naked single 1 dead center when the time was right. The puzzle fell into place after that. I enjoyed this one!

@Afterthoughtbtw 3 года назад

I can never spot bent triples. I managed to spot this quadruple, though. Shows what a good setter he is.

@mute1085 3 года назад

What a beautiful puzzle! 10:08 for me. Somehow I was always looking just at the right spot to continue and managed to breeze through without ever stumbling for a moment. It may be not as difficult as other puzzles featured on the channel, but it provides a different kind of joy, when everything falls into place and keeps going round and round.

@itamarolmert3549 3 года назад

13:38 Great sudoku! A funny story: About two months ago, while solving one of my first-ever CTC sudokus, I stumbled into this technique. It didn't help with the sudoku, and I was a total noob at the time (until then I would only ever do easy sudoku, never so much as pencilmarking or using logic). For these past few months, I've been dreaming of creating a puzzle to showcase the technique, since I couldn't find anything when looking up "bent quadruple" (which was the only name I could imagine for it after learning "WXYZ wing" was something else). When I saw the title I kinda just knew it was this. "XY chain" certainly sounds better than what I thought of. I guess it's time to stop thinking about the technique every night before I go to sleep, lol.

@jessicaham9985 3 года назад

91:46 for me. I got stuck for like 20 minutes because I had the central box as being a 1 or 9 and didn’t think about the fact that the 39 pair resolved it and it gave me so much sympathy for when Simon gets stuck on something that I can see. I’ve always loved playing sudoku but I’ve only just started learning how to use more advanced techniques and do puzzles that aren’t just classics! I never knew there was things like arrows and thermos in sudoku until I started watching the channel a couple weeks ago.

@BozoTheBear 3 года назад

Hats off, Sam, very nice puzzle! I needed the tip for what to look for, but once the cells were highlighted, it was super clear.

@DaliwolfBacon 3 года назад

I was able to finish this puzzle on my own, and I feel a real sense of accomplishment! 6 months ago, I struggled with the easiest of puzzles! I really appreciate you sharing your wisdom with us.

@MrBlackHawk888 3 года назад

You know what is really amazing - to solve this yourself and realise that you have taken a different path than Simon did. This happened to me in this puzzle. TBH after 60+ minutes on my own and pencil-marking all worthy cells I had to peek a hint in this video - and it was the XY Ring "elimination" property. I used it on the *9* 's in row 7 and it allowed me to restrict *9* 's in block #9 and thus put a *9* in block #3, cell #1. This unbounded the Ring and then it was easy to solve.

@ThatGuy-dj3qr 3 года назад

I never tire of watching Simon solve a classic Sudoku. He rarely misses patterns and the logic that flows from them.

@johnpauladamovsky86 3 года назад

Sam Cappleman-Lynes is a brilliant Sudoku setter. He should focus his efforts on writing a computer program which will compose Sam Cappleman-Lynes style logic puzzles on demand, forever...! That way, Sam Cappleman-Lynes shall never die. Long live Sam Cappleman Lynes...!

@Crocodile_Appreciator 3 года назад

Pretty easy for me knowing that there's some type of "loop" strategy used. But I pencil mark everything to bits, so I don't think it would have taken me ages to find without any knowledge. Really fun!

@JPCruz 3 года назад

10 minutes! After the first scanning and placing of easy digits, I've just pencil-marked the possibilities of rows/columns with five digits already placed (rows 3 and 7, columns 3 and 7), and that square pattern emerged, then it was very easy to remove digits. Thanks again for showcasing great puzzles that I can now solve for myself after watching this channel for more than a year!

@pokemonfanrock1 3 года назад

I feel like maverick is like a side character from a tv show. I find myself thinking during the day: How's Maverick doing?

@davidfwooldridge3430 3 года назад

That was a lovely puzzle. It wasn’t hard, per se, but very satisfying.

@remoteviewer8524 3 года назад

OMG! 21:42 to completion, a time on par with Simon (or Mark?) for the first time. I'll take it. :)

@markp7262 3 года назад

14:48 finish. Loved the break-in for this. Once I spotted the ring, everything fell neatly into place. Well done!

@constanza1648 3 года назад

I discover the ring for myself! My time: 17:30. Nice one!

@connierobinson1090 3 года назад

Thank you so much for the in-depth explanation!

@shawnheidingsfelder8179 3 года назад

I started filling in candidates in columns/rows when I had 5 digits in them, and combining that with the Phistomofel Ring, I was able to see a pattern with 3s in column 3 and 7, which helped me figure out that the center digit of the entire puzzle was not a 3, which gave me the 2-3 pair in box 5. That, with the x-y ring Simon explained, got the puzzle cracked for me.

@bokmcdok 3 года назад

I didn't know what an XY loop was but I was able to learn it just by solving this puzzle.

@tananari47 3 года назад

Huh. I did this completely differently and got the same conclusions. By using the Phistomofel ring. Turns out it was a great way to eliminate the same digits Simon was eliminating.

@eduardosolistinoco9698 3 года назад

19:50 "Before we got the one, we could't make the 2/3 pair", technically before. The 2 was already locked in 2 places in box 5, so the moment you got the 3/9 pair on R5 the 3 could only go in those exact 2 places, forming the pair (and forming another 7/9 pair in C5 that can instantly be resolved, which Simon did earlier). The order doesn't matter though, you still get the pair, the 1 and the rest of C5, so I'll shut up and finish the video.

@CoreyHaines 3 года назад

Beautiful puzzle and excellent explanation of the technique! Thanks!

@renauddommergue7671 3 года назад

Thank you for this wonderful puzzle !!!

@eternalblasphemy6526 3 года назад

Sam has proven once again he is a genius setter. Not only has he made it geniunely approachable, he has also set it in a way that may help people understand what a bent triple/XY-wing is since it's easier to spot when it's "circled" around.

@WombatSlug 3 года назад

Always interesting to see these techniques. I am still quite new to "advanced" sudoku and have no chance of seeing break-ins or even recognizing patterns like this. Still love learning!

@kgeiger61 3 года назад

Very nice... Finished in exactly 14:00. Never heard of an XY-Ring, but I recognized the power of the four corners right away.

@AhsimNreiziev 3 года назад

I propose naming the XY-Ring a "ringed quaduple".

@AllenMS828 3 года назад

I surprised myself by being able to find the advanced technique and use it to solve the puzzle (without watching the video or reading the spoiler in the description). Usually I can't spot those special techniques, even when I know to look for them. Maybe there's hope for me yet! :D Very nice puzzle, Sam! I enjoyed solving it!

@amoswittenbergsmusings 3 года назад

This was super fun, in 18.03 for me. I got lucky and spotted the ring very early on and understood its implications, including the rotational elimination. From there on it was plain sailing. A thing of beauty, for sure. Thanks, Sam & Simon.

@onman999 3 года назад

Solved it in 13:08. One of the easiest sudokus here (I usually can't solve Simon's puzzles).

@jinbe-san 3 года назад

I knew those 4 corner cells were important, but i didn’t quite figure out what they meant. The rest was straight forward. Interesting one!

@Kelters 3 года назад

I surprised myself when I found the ring around the centre. I linked lines through the "corners". Unfortunately I ended up bifurcating as I couldn't see which way round the loop went. Really enjoyed it despite having to back-track after breaking it on the first guess. Thanks Sam. Thanks Simon.

@neilcharnock4167 Месяц назад

Hi Simon love your work. I found bent quad 3's and 5's early - like two L's so a sort of Z which solved it pretty fast. It gave me the 2-3 pair vertical in the middle box early. Only learning from your logic, but this faster method got me to the exact same solution which I gather is the only way to get it right. Just different ways to get there. Great fun late at night. Cheers mate from NSW Australia.

@zagrizena 2 месяца назад

This is a beautiful one! First CtC sudoku I have been able to solve myself only reading the rules. Granted I did it in bits and took me 1.5h, but it was flowing so nicely. I don't know much of the techniques, but I found the restricted loop just by looking for weak cells and row/column restrictions, then the "windmill" pattern appeared, a few more pencilmarks and the central digit. From there it took some more row and column checking, but once I found the 7 in box 2 it unfolded magnificently. Really satisfying, albeit slow.

@Waggles1123 3 года назад

15:48 for me. I spotted that XY-Ring at the start only because I was looking for weak cells that could only be a couple digits. Like you, I had no idea about the technique, but I thought it looked odd and tried looking at it like a bent triple.

@mtg823 Год назад

Finished in 09:38. Looking for naked singles in the corners of the inner ring is an obvious first idea to look at (which only results in the pairs), but if you then just focus on completing the lines that cross-hatch through those, the 1 in the middle is discovered and the rest of the puzzle is a simple solve.

@aaronjustin8424 3 года назад

Fantastic, I liked the way you solved the puzzle.

@dagoashax 3 года назад

The first time i solved a puzzle faster than CTC in 15:22, i mark this day golden in my calender!

@andrewsparkes8829 3 года назад

19:33 "I'm maligning myself unfairly", he says. After completely skipping over r9c3 needs to be a 7 and thus solves the bent-complicated-xy-quadrule-ring-chain he was previously enamored by, by forcing r3c3 to be the starting 6 of the ring!

@kemika3629 3 года назад

After watching Simon for so long, I think I've determined that his biggest weakness is not resolving his pencil markings. He finds so much logic that he forgets to double check what he already has.

@emphyriohazzl1510 3 года назад

Had already seen another nice example of XY ring in Lapidaire by Shye, so this one was easy :).

@williamwester9203 3 года назад

Figured out the xy-ring. I don't normally do this, but I happened to pencil mark all allowed digits in the center box. That's what helped me find that naked single 1 in the center.

@meirkara17 3 года назад

I ended up solving the puzzle without really using the XY-ring logic. In column three and seven it is relatively easy to deduce what numbers should be in the squares that are not a part of the XY-ring. From there on it is easy sailing. I'd say, not focusing on the XY-ring makes the break-in easier to comprehend but Mark's solution is more elegant. Anyone else used that logic when trying to solve the puzzle?

@Rikoshima 3 года назад

22 minutes for me, this was fun and the ring logic wasn't too hard to spot (only because of experience gained from watching this channel, of course haha)

@maxiamler713 3 года назад

Great video. I would like to see more classic sudokus on the channel

@coolpapabell22 3 года назад

This puzzle made me actively grumpy about how good Sam is at setting. :D Really amazing.

@colinreed9587 2 года назад

What an excellent tutorial, thank you.

@frankbowman9493 3 года назад

I love classic sudoku. I usually only play the classic. I played up to when I had the ring but did not know what to do. I then watched you explain the way the ring works and was able to finish with only a little bother.

@noiplah 3 года назад

Good lord this was a fun puzzle. My solve path after the xy ring turned out completely different to Simon's and was immensely satisfying, involved a lot of pairs exposing a naked single and then chaining around the board in big flurries. Lovely work as always Sam!

@kyosukemazaki3635 3 года назад

10:48 for me...pretty proud of myself tbh, it's the first time i actually take the chance and try to spot a " logic " for myself, finding the hidden pairs was kind of unreal to me and i was scared that i was wrong all along...yeah..pretty proud ahahah nice video and nice sudoku aswell =)

@andyparkerson 3 года назад

This was really nice. Found the XY-Ring, and solved it. Lots of fun.

@4thright 3 года назад

Got it in 15:17 without too much difficulty - definitely not 'delirious' in solving it. I think I saw the intended technique, which I feel like I'd seen before somewhere here and made the tough parts pretty manageable. Now to watch the video and find out!

@Tombsar 3 года назад

Very nice classic. I did it in 22 minutes without the hint, mostly by marking candidates then following 50/50 possibilities in the restricted cells that eliminated those digits from other cells, and repeat. Missed the central 1 for a while, because I had it as a 1/3 and didn't pay enough attention to r5.

@idannen 3 года назад

You're not strange, Simon. At least no more than the rest of us here.

@TheXcathii 3 года назад

I usually get a little disappointed when I hear Classic sudoku but then I watch it anyway and it never disappoints. Great puzzle.

@andrewnelson2525 3 года назад

I'm absolutely terrible at spotting bent triples, so I was doubly (quadruply?) proud to spout the ring as quickly as I did nd use it to smoothly unwind the entire puzzle. I don't really want to know how quickly Sam set this puzzle -- probably in half the time it took me to solve.

@honigschlecker1 3 года назад

Really beautiful puzzle. The interaction of the ring was so enjoyable. Actually not too difficult.

@lynk5902 3 года назад

Took me over 40 minutes, 10 minutes of which I was just staring at it until the lightbulb moment for the 1 in the middle, after the 15 minutes of figuring out how that weird quadruple affected the rest of the squares in its rows and columns.

@srwapo 3 года назад

13:51, surprised I persevered long enough to solve it, I probably would have normally stopped, but the title of the video made it sound like there's a "trick" and I took a few minutes to find it.

@Drgn8DDragonsDungeon 3 года назад

Another case of "what weird trick do I not know for this yet - Oh!" And now I try to use this in future :D more advanced techniques, please! ;D

@Thungon 2 года назад

12:21 was my time, though I wasn't explaining it to anyone either. What a fun classic!

@tarotcomPauloEvoLua 3 года назад

Stunning

@diederikvandedijk 3 года назад

Very pleased to have found the looping quadruple.

@christopherwiles2934 3 года назад

Its amazing to see progress with sudoku. i managed to finish this puzzle in only 3 min longer than it took simon. (23min 35secs to simons approx 20min 40secs). i managed to start the puzzle the same way with the 2s then simon and i split ways but ultimately got the same answer.

@kr12a2y 3 года назад

Oh, I saw the 23 pair in the middle before noticing the 1 because of the 39 the other way and the 23s in boxes 2 and 8. You finding the 1 first is better I think.

@tantaluscapital6350 3 года назад

19:52 for me. Very good puzzle tonight!

@Numberplay 3 года назад

my solve was 18m33s before watching the vid. Very happy with that time. Knowing beforehand that an XY wing was in play kinda helped I'm gonna be honest.

@Leyrann 3 года назад

Okay but what are the chances that I set a puzzle using THIS EXACT TECHNIQUE earlier today, and got Sam to test it for me? Edit: Also, 9:55, though it's slightly off as I forgot to press play after pausing, but also got distracted for a little bit afterwards, probably more like 10:30.

@comface 3 года назад

18:18 for me - happy with that time as I had not seen this logic before!

@livedandletdie 3 года назад

It was quite easy, 10 minutes. Oh how I love simple classic sudokus.

@insectbah 2 года назад

Learned a lot :)

@Stephen-Fox 3 года назад

I would definitely be interested in seeing you cover a Continuous Nice Loop, because I can't even imagine what that means while I had an idea that an XY-Ring was going to be similar to an XY-Chain but... More circular... Even if I didn't expect it to work how I discovered it did when I read the title.

@emphyriohazzl1510 3 года назад

Edit : I mixed up, sorry, bad memory.. XY-ring is indeed this specific setup with 2 states, one of them being a 90° rotation of the other. And continuous nice loop is a more generic thing : basically it seems to be any alternate inference chains that loops back to a contradiction. In the case of the XY ring, the continous loop would be for instance the AIC started by puting a 6 somewhere on column 3, as it would chain from that 6 to r3c3, r3c7, r7c7, r7c3 and end up with a strong link between 6 in r7c3 and that starting 6 in the column.

@sebrofniloc 3 года назад

Lovely puzzle.

@Stephen-Fox 3 года назад

Very enjoyable puzzle. Not sure I'd have been able to solve it without the video title, but that's neither a critique of the puzzle nor the video title.