The song is really good, the only "bad" thing is the mv. It's kinda boring and doesn't show their unity as a group but represents them as soloists. BUT that doesn't mean that the song isn't good! The girls worked really hard to debut and obviously the mv making isn't something they can control at all. People shouldn't be so harsh towards them. It's still their debut and their first mv. They'll improve. The song is good, really good. Personally I think it's a bop ^^.
Maybe because from the thumbnail you can't even tell that it's the actual MV, because it's so low-quality... I seriously wonder why they put a picture like this as the thumbnail
no it isnt, don't lie, it has the same amount of views, dance practise have only 50k likes, this has 59k likes, if really you want to compare. people can view and dont like it, but to really like it you have to physically click like, so people like the MV.
I think they need a better promotion too, seriously I don't even know they've debuted yet, I thought this is a cover or something, whereas I've watched all the episodes of YWY 2
MY OPINION: Each of the member’s individuals talents and characters are so magnificently great that this mv just looks like they’re competing with one another, leading to a “hot” mess. There’s not much chemistry or teamwork, I wish their their next mv will look like they will all complement each other’s strengths and weaknesses rather than looking like princesses fighting to win the queen’s crown. This is not their fault but their entertainment management and producer!! If this isn’t solved in the future I can quickly see this group disbanding and going off in separate ways because right now it looks like they are better off with their own debuts.
I was trying to figure out why sphinx and not me seemed off, and you're comment put my thoughts into words exactly. When I was watching the show I wanted almost of all of these girls to debut but now when I see them together, It's kind of awkward and on top of each other. Their personalities are so different and strong that it doesn't blend very well...I hope they can get better music/choreo that works for them...without the culture appropriation.
In China they are achieving many successes that dissolving I think is impossible right now, the only thing that failed them a bit was the world premiere with such a poor MV.
Now I realized what's the wrong with the MV lol. They seem like doing a solo shoot, and it just showing their face. At least have them singing while dancing in the group not solo. Also make them have interaction with each other, I don't know maybe it just want to show their solo at first and show other things later. But yeah it totally feel like watching 9 soloist in 1 group n MV. Also maybe should add something more interesting like them acting lil bit or whatever. It just feels boring having them looking solo like that
I’m honestly so pissed. They totally did the group dirty with this. Who the heck even passed this editing?? It looks like a shitty fanmade MV instead of a legitimate one. I honestly think the shots by themselves aren’t bad but the flashing lights, fuzzy filter, and rapid cuts are dragging this to filth. This is such a talented group and it’s a shame that they get this treatment. Even the dance performance wasn’t as great as it could be because they only had TWO days of practice. 🤦♀️ *EDIT:* I’ve finished watching the MV and I still have no idea what kind of concept the directors are going for. Again, poor planning.
the music is really great and the girls are talented, but the quality of the mv is not good. Bonbon Girls MV is also terrible. what's wrong with chinese synegrafistas?
Keyin made her part the killing part of this song! So charming and slay! Proud of this girl, slaying in writing rap lyrics, rapping and even vocal singing!!!
I really wonder why I don’t see many praising Shaking comments from fans Look at The Duke,Andrew piluko, Gaweii (music reaction maker)They all praising Shaking too much
They made high class show to debute this gold artist but they dont have enough money to give the work they deserve. AND THE MAIN THING this song doesn't have english subtitles which is imp
Yu Yan and Yu Shuxin shined for me in this MV. Shuxin "Winner Lalala" is still stuck in my head and her "C U Bye Bye Bye". But overall Yu Yan was PERFECT from her aura to her high note, I feel like this song was made for Yu Yan
if you’re going to debut a group: -give them a decently budgeted video, not a ton of editing. -have a eye catching thumbnail, not a far away blank white background shot -make the song title something catchy, not “sphinx” -production should be not forgettable and have a ring that makes people want to listen more -choreography that’s out of the ordinary land eye catching These are all beautiful talented girls. In my opinion, this debut was not well on the company’s part. debuts are arguably a very important part in groups careers and if it doesn’t hit a good mark it may be harder to gain exposure in the future
Literally the girls are so great and they’ve shown it throughout the whole show. Even when having 3 days to practice with unfamiliar ppl they were able to still have a harmonious stage the company did they so dirty with a low budget and bad debut. Like they weren’t living up to expectation on there parts.How are u gonna have an idol show group where 100 sm girls sign up just for a chance of exposure and debuting in a sub group but fail on the final rewards part ?
@@nuages8915 so what, if they only show YuXin, what's the point of making a GG when some members gets 3s screen time lol, just get some dancers instead.
guys, let's remember that this is not KPOP, so obviously the MV's will be different, inted of saying that this is bad or low budget, let's support them and expect them to have a better comeback, it's the best we can do .
since this is debut there’s always mistakes. i hope next comeback they can improve. this MV was all over the place and it felt like 12 soloists. hopefully next comeback they can go with a more stable concept and have them actually as a group. and especially have a visually appealing thumbnail since thumbnails draw more attention.
The company shouldnt allow any mistakes since the group's time is limited. Im rly upset with the company. They prepared the debut for almost 3 months for this shitty song & mv
i agree! the whole direction is messed up... - the mv is low budgeted : the sets just scream CHEAP and empty - poorly edited : very messy, too much solo shots and not enough group shot - the costumes weren't able to bring them together (lack of coordination and some did not fit the concept of the song) though the song is quite a good song actually (maybe not enough for a debut song but it's still a pretty good song), the whole direction did not help the group to bring them more together. too many mistakes and too low quality for such a long wait. though i kinda expected this bc during this three whole months, i feel like the girls were busy shooting CFs. do they even have enough time to prepare and polish this debut? added to that this such messy and low quality production ...
The mv isn't perfect. However, the song is extremely catchy and the girls' visuals really kill me. Hope the next comeback will be even greater❤️THE9❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Damn, Xin’s groove is so swag. I love her balance in dance. I can’t keep my eyes off her at chorus, also didn’t realize her voice is so sexy with natural reverb. Looking forward to their stage! Let’s get it XIN!
OMG！！！ Yuxin slays the stage！！She was just born for it！！How she perform those dance moves so fluent and professional !! She had put me on fire!！XQueen make you crazy！！！Again！！💙💙💙💙💙💙
I think the song is incredible. It’s the mv that has problems. But these nine amazing girls can't do anything over the mv. It's out of their hands. And many are asking that what does this song mean. I wish you would watch their interviews they said that they are not like other girl groups around them. The song was explaining THE9.And it makes sense cause It's their first MV.
Lol everyone has fair line accordingly to lyrics distribution , their a girl group not a solo singer. Stop complaining this & that, instead let's support them as a whole group.
