Theory Reacts to CLONE WARS: BATTLE OF THE HEROES - A Star Wars Fan Animation 

I’d love for them to recreate palpatine vs mace and the other masters that way it was supposed to be done if Ian didn’t have the physical restraints.

I love what we got with clone wars, but this really is something else

I've wanted a Clone Wars animated adaptation of Episode 3 for forever. If this is the closest we'll ever get to that, I'd be perfectly happy with it: this was an amazing video!

So good, I wonder if they'll animate other fights like Mace vs Palpatine. Disney should be taking notes

I wonder if someone could edit this into the finale of The Clone Wars. As great as the finale was i always felt it lacked something by us not seeing the fall of anakin as part of it

One extremely tiny insignificant thing that has been driving me crazy ever since I watched the movie for the first time is when they first connect the mask to his cowl, the joint in the bar that runs from his ear to the point on the mask doesn't line up completely. I'm so glad they fixed that in the animation. It just makes it feel so much more complete.

The duel goes hard. Especially right at the start. I actually enjoy how it doesn't feel like it's 100% ROTS or 100% TCW. Kinda like SC38 it feels like its own project with heavy influence from both

I think this hit me so hard because we spent so many years with the animated versions of these characters. It felt like all the emotions of the Clone Wars were behind this. So good. I would love it if some how they could do all the prequals as well as the original trilogy. I know we will probably never get that buy we can hope and dream.

This was absolutely Incredible. The amount of work, Love and Dedication that went into This is Amazing. As Someone who grew up with The Clone Wars, It was My Whole Childhood so this Fan Film was very Emotional for Me.

Absolut master class in how to do Star Wars! The Fans are the ones doing it for the love. Not the dollars and look what we get. ''THE FANS DO IT BEST''. They're giving this old man hope that the next generation will continue what Lucus started. George would be proud. Reply

Watched it three times. Sure hits differently seeing it in animation

Yeah, I watched the full clip earlier today and was BLOWN AWAY. Then I caught your review and your reactions were the same as mine. Lucasfilm need to hire this guy now and pay for him for the clip. The work is GENIUS and MASTERPIECE. I WANT MORE!

I would love to see the original 6 recreated like this, this was well done

Now it’s possible to watch Clone Wars straight thru!

Top tier. Favorite Star Wars fight

This certainly has put a smile on my face.

I was hoping you would review this incredible fanmade project

the subtle look of Anakin’s regret-filled face at the start adds so much more weight

it hits different with the animated because from 2008 weve had the movie and a weekly journey and with the conclusion with the bad batch coming up you spend more hours with the animated characters than the 2hrs with the live action

Id love to see them do a clonewars version of the battle of corusaunt

So fun and a trip to watch. I really REALLY enjoyed this!!🎉

just watched it with my dad before new years. I just really enjoyed watching it almost like new as i’ve seen it so many times. It just felt really special with my versions of anakin and obi wan while obviously the movies still mean so much to me. it’s just different but so cool i love it.

I feel like the lines are taken from Lego Skywalker Saga since in the game the PT characters are voiced by the Clone Wars VAs

I swear I feel like it’s harder to watch the end of this fight animated Maybe because I’m so used to this version of Anakin being construed as a hero while Hayden Christensen was the one that turned into Vader But this seals the fact that, they’re the same character and this man that was compassionate, a mentor, a hero always trying to do the right thing Let his emotions and his insecurities get the better of him to fall so far from what he was It hurts more, Yaknow Edit: I didn’t think theory would talk about the same thing after the scene lmao, great minds think alike

wait was this edited? ive seen a longer version

I like that this is only fan made as if they made one animated officially I think it would've taken away from the original

That ( I hate you) didn't have the same feeling towards it

7:19 they added the heart beats 😮‍💨🤌

That is brilliant!

19 years later Vader sitting in a bacta tank fighting rebels and a moaster farmer totally not his son helps led obi wan right to him Vader : it’s over obi wan I own the high ground that I looked at for 19 years and made a castle on it making it even more higher rematch Obi wan : 😇🔫🪓

Battle of the heroes is phenomenal 👍

I would love to see them show the battle at the temple. Anakin V. All the Masters like Cin Drallig and the other Jedi in the Temple. Also Mace v. Palpatine and Dooku v. Anakin and Obi Wan. I really hope he does more scenes it was an amazing job

The best thing for SW in 2023

Jesus, from those different angles of the fight , I can see why if Kenobi wasn't a tank.He wouldn't have lasted long.Building a defense over time against the most dangerous Jedi Anakin.

when disney is not making star wars this happened, where are reva and sabine mary sue wren?

Feels legitimate.

Now do the whole movie 😅

This 4 hours long revenge of the sith

Fans fans fans ❤❤❤❤

I mean its very good done and all but we already have the epic real version.... They should make their own scenes

the wet noodle bendy sabers are so incredibly goofy and stupid and distracting...only thing i always hated about clone wars...looks like theyre fighting with ropes..so dumb

It’d be cool if someone did the battles or best moments from the OT in Clone Wars style animation

It was phenomenal. The animation style is so reminiscent of Clone Wars, Star Wars Rebels and Bad Batch so the style is seamless. And the emotion of the lightsaber battle between Obi Wan and Anakin hits very different in this animated version of Revenge Of The Sith. Great job!!!

I love the detail when anakins eyes change from blue to yellow when he says "you underestimate my power" at 4:14

I wish they’d of done an alternate ending

The future of SW is in the hands of the fans. I hope this lights a fire under Theory's butt.

If you’re all wondering how the scene has Matt and James’ voices: remember that there’s a certain Lego Star Wars game out there that has the clone wars actors voicing their prequel counterparts for the most part

I love how you can almost feel a sadness there with Anakin as if he has some regrets and he wants to undo his mistakes but he's gone past the point of no return and must see it through.

Star Wars for the fans, by the fans. Fuck Disney Star Wars.

That “I hate you”. Damn I felt that!

I'm a little late to the upload here but man when I watched this for the first time I was so shocked as to how well the animator did on Obi-Wan's face when Anakin was burning in the lava. The EMOTION he was able to show on with just a few glances of Obi-Wan was the part that truly moved me. Almost like I was watching it again for the first time.

The faces are way more expressive

This was 10 out of 10! Now I would Also love to see a TCW Version of Duel of the Fate Darth Maul vs Qui Gon and Obi Wan In The Phantom Manace! What do you think Theory?

I thought it was well done and the animation was amazing

Before the Vader helmet was fully on Anakin, I heard Anakin slowly whisper "Padme help me" am not joking I literally heard that, replay the scene if you don't believe me

I hope this remove any doubts you might have about whether it was the right decision to go with animation for the Vader fan film

It’s wild to me that the fans with absolutely minute budgets in comparison to Disney can make amazing content like this. I just wish Disney would hire real fans to create content. But they never will.

Animated Anakin was a hero, we saw more of his transformation over a longer period of time so when he turns, it hits hard. Like damn, we’ve watched this guys demise for real.

They should produce the son of dathomir book into a full animation

Did you notice the Padme help me?

5:20 Says the Jedi that followed a Jedi code that forgo emotional attachments. 😂😂😂😂 Can you believe the feminist activist writers blamed this scene of Anakin turning to the Dark on “Toxic Masculinity” ????

Its like Palpatine traded his old toyota(Dooku) for a ferrari (Anakin) and obi-wan slashed its tires making Palpatine settle for a Black Jeep Wrangler

solace, not semblance

his getting ideas now

If the prequels were really good like I mean were in production for about two decades good

They need to do Within a Minute Documentary on this animated short lol

Can you please hire these people and make us fan film Star Wars. So we can finally get the Star Wars we wanted.

weeks its from yesterday i got this it was late for me 😂😭😭😭😭😭

Not enough diverse women in that film

Time to watch the Original one now!

Paetron for vader is a good ide do that

Yes!!

11:21 i did not know that thx for the info :D

Someone should do a side by side

Never thought I get the FEELS again for a StarWars scene…and they did it perfectly. Glad you reacted to it.

4:25 I was amazed by the clone wars version of the battle of heroes.

This got recommended to me because I love listening to Star Wars What Ifs, and needless to say it was incredibly well done...so...rare RU-vid W.

What if Obi-wan saved anakin and put out the flames and took him and Padma back to yoda. Couldn’t obiwan turned anakin back from the dark side by doing that by, by him seeing two Jedi try to save his wife after what he done.

I was hoping for faster movement, maybe skipping some frames to match the IRL speed of Ewan and Hayden.

Dude seeing this with the animated characters hits to fkin hard because like... that's our guy we've SEEN him be the hero

@Star wars theory plus please try to reach out to Ewan McGregor or Hayden Christensen and ask them to make a reaction video on this

I’d like them to do the whole movie 🎥 if possible and to do a fan animation of the removed episodes beforehand that were never released.💙💚♥️🖤😎

For me, it is the canon translation of EP3 Battle of the Heroes into Clone Wars style. It adds so much depth!

You could still hear “padme help me” when the mask was closing on him. That detail the pain man the pain

6:33 that shot was from the BF2 2017 trailer. That was a sick ass shot

I like people who do this. Thank you for the nuggets of info where it's from. Best fight ever

Your reaction is great and honest. Thank you.

Woulda loved a bit of clone wars tarkin walking off at the end

Star wars would be so much better if all was animated, imagine a movie likes this

As much as i dislike TCW i really think this is dope

🐨

How do you not give them the respect they deserve by cutting out 20% of the scene in your reaction?

Disney honestly just needs to hire these fans

😂

This semi-disappointed me

almost feels better than the real version🤩

If a guy can do this ..woth no money and buy him self.....dave falloni...really isn't that special is he !!

Now a TCW animation of episode 3 4 5 or 6

No nothing is going to beat the original

This fan film cannot be hyped too much - it's that good