Тёмный

They did the impossible (One Piece Live Action Review) 

Mr B
Подписаться 115
Просмотров 13 тыс.
50% 1

Hey guys, in this one I want to talk about my thoughts on the One Piece live action. It took a lot longer to make but here it is. Hope you guys enjoy!
If you're interested, check out my last video where I talked about the Zom 100 live action:
• The Zom 100 Live Actio...

Опубликовано:

 

27 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 50   
@aaaaaaaaooooooo
@aaaaaaaaooooooo Год назад
I thought the live action Arlong was excellent. His speech style and his snarling grin was truly intimidating.
@lightningjadejavier
@lightningjadejavier Год назад
Plus the laugh was accurate
@jessicajayes8326
@jessicajayes8326 9 месяцев назад
@@lightningjadejavier His Sh-hahaha!
@mreverything7056
@mreverything7056 Год назад
Honestly, seeing how bad Marvel and DC CGI has started to dip, I thankful that Arlong looked tolerable, instead of some weird inconsistent CGI freakshow that looked like it was done by a college student
@seandimarukot
@seandimarukot Год назад
the spirit , the heart and the respect to the author they hit it bigtime that's the main reason for me why this live action works.
@jacobbukler8534
@jacobbukler8534 Год назад
I think Netflix hasn't gone far with the budget because of the failure of the other adaptations One piece life action did a really fine job I haven't watched the anime but I've started watching because of the live action especially how the introduced Dracule Mihawk that was epic af.
@kasual_kai2986
@kasual_kai2986 Год назад
Finishing the live action also caused me to want to watch the anime lol I’m on ep 34 rn😂
@zionox688
@zionox688 Год назад
@@kasual_kai2986that’s awesome to hear, you’re in for one hell of a ride!
@lightningjadejavier
@lightningjadejavier Год назад
​@@kasual_kai2986LET'S GOOOO!!! A NEW NAKAMA!!! 😂 As someone who is at episode 819 rn, i can say to you YOU WILL LOVE THIS!!! It's not called the king of Shonen for no reason, plus it also has the best world building cause every character actually feels real!
@critica77y77
@critica77y77 3 месяца назад
I don't think Arlong being smaller than his Manga counterpart is that much of a problem. First off, Arlong isn't even close to the biggest guy in the manga. And even in the Live-Action, sure, he's not Goliath, but he's still a big guy. And he _felt_ big and strong. He had a threatening presence that made him believable as the biggest, baddest dude in the East Blue. I certainly never questioned whether he had earned his reputation.
@marplatense31
@marplatense31 Год назад
Props to them for using practical effects, but honestly I think the Fishmen was an area where it might have looked better if they had used CGI. I agree that it's way overused these days, but sometimes it is the better option. Overall though, I really enjoyed live action One Piece and not only am I excited for future seasons, but it did something I thought could never happen; It made me excited for the potential of more, hopefully GOOD, live action anime that actually stay true to the source material.
@MrB2022
@MrB2022 Год назад
I get what you mean but I do disagree. If this was a movie with a very large budget maybe it could work but for a series, personally I don't think it would work. I do agree sometimes it is a better option and maybe we'll start seeing more cgi especially with Chopper next season. As long as it's good and not too distracting, I'm all on board for it
@Hezmarglive
@Hezmarglive Год назад
Witcher writers and directors: "hmm so does this really work??" Everyone: *points at live action one piece. I just wish it becomes another, into the spider verse, a paradigm shift in terms of production.
@lightningjadejavier
@lightningjadejavier Год назад
Tbh arlong's actor carried arlong, like sure he didn't look as close as arlong but he still was alot like arlong, like even though he isn't as big as manga arlong, he was still felt big like they use the same thing with Morgan I'm talking about perspective like the actor's don't look big but they still feel big cause of how the perspective is done right.
@cwega2463
@cwega2463 5 месяцев назад
i think one piece fans are really weirdly pick and choosy with the size of characters. and they should get used to the adaptation using normal sizes for most people as the weird 8-10 foot people are only gonna be hard to adapt. like yeah, people like Whitebeard and Big Mom, and the giants, are so big they have to keep them that way. but like Arlong obviously would be smaller. but yeah one piece fans are weird with the height thing. arlong is 8”7 in the manga being placed by a 6”1 actor. but garp in the manga is 9”5, being played by a 6 foot actor. people complained about arlong a lot, but no one complained about garp
@pavelbreza9190
@pavelbreza9190 Год назад
I hope they will adapt all chapters in the future
@lightningjadejavier
@lightningjadejavier Год назад
Well... They will be adapting 6 seasons aka going up to marineford 😂 and if those are good they'll make more going up to wano so... They're thinking of adapting 1k episodes into live action... Holy shi- oda is a fkn god
@timpi845
@timpi845 5 месяцев назад
​@@lightningjadejavier Would be weird to end the series with luffy in pstd
@MaciekRabizo
@MaciekRabizo Год назад
Best show Ive seen in years
@stefanogrillo6040
@stefanogrillo6040 Год назад
The only insane error was to cut the fight of monkey.d and krieg
@asphaltpilgrim
@asphaltpilgrim Год назад
Hey OP fans - who should they cast Henry Cavill as? Netflix owes him. 🤣
@mega_jonne1546
@mega_jonne1546 Год назад
The new zoro sword is cool aswell the 90 degree one
@zuzu7308
@zuzu7308 11 месяцев назад
1:31 👏👏👏👏
@porky1118
@porky1118 Год назад
2:30 I think, One Piece is good from the beginning. It's just getting bad after they entered the Grand line.
@androidgaming5243
@androidgaming5243 Год назад
If Oda reveal his photo and why they take cover his face when the actor play Luffy meet Oda
@MrB2022
@MrB2022 Год назад
I didn't see the video so I didn't know they covered his face. Maybe he didn't want to show himself for some reason but there are a ton of pics of him online and I think I've seen interviews of him showing his face so I don't think he wants to be anonymous but I might be wrong on that
@cwega2463
@cwega2463 5 месяцев назад
@@MrB2022Oda hasn’t shown his face in interviews or any media at all in about 15 years as he wants his privacy; since privacy in the public eye in japan is almost impossible to achieve. if you think social media is toxic and bad because of shit like cancel culture over here, in japan it’s worse. twitter stalkers and obsessive fans are just inherently just a lot MORE over there. celebrities can have whole careers ruined for just associating with different people, brands, media, etc that their fans don’t like. it’s like a tight rope. Oda just wants to maximise how much privacy he has now.
@flavio.zaninie979
@flavio.zaninie979 Год назад
👉#LucasForAce🍩
@brandongreenhill6977
@brandongreenhill6977 Год назад
Live action Zoro is written poorly and comes off as a parody that deliver mumbling oneliners and he whole stick is that he is a hot guy that younger girls will wanna tune in to see for every episode. Live action Nami is written porrly and comes off as a bad imitation that stares off into space with an expressionless porcelain face and a cheap orange wig and her whole stick is to make young boys horny so they will tune in to see every new episode. In general what is bad is not the story but the god awfull cringy acting. If the original wasnt popular enough, nobody in their right mind would stick to watch this for over 3-4 episodes. Also most costumes are cheap looking and some changes to the characters are a 180 from what is the original. Yes one piece live action might be the best live action but there is not actually any competition, any other live action is hot garbage with shit smeared all over it. Cheap souless wanna be imitation of the original one piece. Greed doesnt make good art. If you watch the story of Oda you will see that he actually had some ambition apart from being rich. I dont know why he let his lifes work get butchered so bad. What a shame.
@coffeelatte8616
@coffeelatte8616 Год назад
ngl i was distracted watching the first episode and had to rewatched it because of zoro AHAHAHA they made him too cool dude.. i just can't lol but it's not that bad.. this live action really open the path for those whose intimidated by one piece episodes that already surpassed 1000 episodes your statement "I dont know why he let his lifes work get butchered so bad. What a shame." i don't think so at all, if he felt that OP is butchered this movie will never be here in the first place... there are so many people who are too afraid watching the anime and now started watching it because of these 8 episodes... maybe you come from the prespective of a person who already watch the anime but for those who haven't this actually pretty good... and from the person who read the manga i certainly unsatisfied in some of the scene, characters and also story writing.. but hey i'm not dissapointed and waiting for the 2nd season to come ^^
@brandongreenhill6977
@brandongreenhill6977 Год назад
@@coffeelatte8616 well then i guess your standards are too low. And you are unsatisfied with scene and characters but you disagree? Weird. And one last things. One piece didnt need to launch a live action to become popular. Everybody in every country and their grandma knew what one piece is. Also people today want to bing watch series that have many episodes with many seasons. You personal experience of people getting intimidated by 1000 episodes is nothing compared to the litteral millions of people that sit their ass and watch a whole season of a series in one day or they finish the whole series in 2-7 days depending on how bit it is. 1000 episodes would take those people something close to a month or a month and a half if they didnt skip anything. Now once again, speaking for cinematography and costumes and not speaking for what i like and dislike, The acting, the writing for some characters, the line for some characters, the costumes and the cast for some characters is amateurish, if not outright garbage. It is the truth. Doesnt matter how much you like the hot zoro or hot nami, doesnt matter how much of a fanboy you are, the show is bad and NOTHING close to the original. And the worst thing is that apart from good actors, every other thing is easily fixable. They just had a low budget and they chose to throw all the money for scenery and cgi. This LA is for 15 kids and people that only watche one piece casually. A real fan would be dissapointed. You no real fan.
@coffeelatte8616
@coffeelatte8616 Год назад
@@brandongreenhill6977 well sorry if my standards are too low for someone like you.. i said unsatisfied in some of the scene i think they could have done it in different scenario but i'm just saying, it is an entirely different from manga and even anime.. before the LA came people always compared the manga and anime it's no different this time.. you gotta separate them to get the full view of what it is, can you imagine putting in like what 40 ish episodes into 8... it is not the same as anime but doesn't mean it's not one piece.. i watched the anime until like 980 ish in 2 months and rewatched again from time to time and then went to read the manga after that and become a manga reader.. have been waited for it every week now.. i am actually a casual anime watcher but only one piece had got me hooked up like this to the point i'm buying their merch especially luffy :> and i only have one piece merch so far.. people are loving this movie and people are loving one piece.. if you hate the love one piece has recieved you are no better either than your so called 'no real fans' right here... so define to me what real fans mean.. you don't have to like this movie but you don't have to trash talk either
@chrisdurand1441
@chrisdurand1441 Год назад
That's a lot of words for "I'm a butthurt weeb who's angry that this isn't Japan-sama cartoon" I've been a fan for over two decades. It's good stuff. Stop crying.
@brandongreenhill6977
@brandongreenhill6977 Год назад
@@chrisdurand1441 If i wanted to go in-depth for as to why the live action is poorly made, i could write a whole essay for each of its offenses and then some. I could also write three words like ''bad acting, bad writing, bad costumes'' and be done with my comment but i chose to go a little more indepth. Now you assume i am a weeb and also you say its good stuff without giving any reasoning whatsoever, other that the alleged fact that you have been a fan for over two decades. This is proof that you are the definition of a butthurt person whereas i could be defined mostly as an unsatisfied viewer. I wasted my time replying to a keyboard warrior that only said X is good because i like it, so dont bother giving me a reply because that is is the only two minutes i will ever waste.
@MrMCKlebeband
@MrMCKlebeband 10 месяцев назад
well... for now, i am hopeful. season 2 is really gonna make or break this... there are HUGE challenges ahead... chopper, mr3 and crocodile are gonna be challenging... little garden might get cut entirely... on the other hand, we can't have onepiece without giants, so they might as well try now, because they can't cut all the giants, fans would hate it.
@cwega2463
@cwega2463 5 месяцев назад
they literally cannot cut little garden. it could easily be condensed into one episode, but cutting it would be a huge mistake. also crocodile is honestly one of the easier things to adapt. he is purely just sand particle effects.
@MrMCKlebeband
@MrMCKlebeband 5 месяцев назад
@@cwega2463 i know that... but they also ended up cutting hachi for budget...you see where i am coming from? but with recent events in mange, yes, little garden is 1000000% not gertting cut.
@cwega2463
@cwega2463 5 месяцев назад
@@MrMCKlebeband hachi is a lot more complex than particle effects though. don’t worry, crocodile has no issue. he will be just as badass 😫😫
@MrMCKlebeband
@MrMCKlebeband 5 месяцев назад
@@cwega2463 naaah, i was talking about little garden, ... hachi was also important to the plot, but needed to be cut because of budget... but little garden is too important... i know crocodile is very much possible for netflix, my point is, they have so MUCH budget intensive content for season 2, we might get another hachi situation. yes particel effects are not the challenge here... but it's still gonna be expensive to animate the fight...its not just patricle simulations... its also blending that stuff with the acter and making it actually look like a logia AND chopper, AND giants... i think mister 3 might go... but the wax key.... hmmm... my point is, its very much budget intensive content to adapt for season 2.
@MrMCKlebeband
@MrMCKlebeband 5 месяцев назад
@@cwega2463 i am also aware of the fact that hachi's fight would have been on a whole other level of difficult to make happen in live action and not comparable to crocodile. ... mr 1 tho... so much expensive stuff in season 2
@Jibril_UwU
@Jibril_UwU Год назад
Just think about the fact that a live-action adaptation makes me question my "yes real hatred" of one-piece.. like what is that? I would describe myself as one of the last people on the planet who would be a one-piece fan.. I have Seen the show now...twice...that says it all 😅
@lightningjadejavier
@lightningjadejavier Год назад
Ey... Now all you need to do is watch the best world building of anime, aka the king of shonen, yes those are the title of one piece.
@cwega2463
@cwega2463 5 месяцев назад
i think it goes to show it’s not the story of one piece you dislike. it’s the anime’s terrible pacing. if you like the live action this much then you will LOVE the manga.
Далее
What Netflix Did Better Than The Anime!
15:01
Просмотров 375 тыс.
An Honest Review of Netflix One Piece
54:12
Просмотров 865 тыс.
Как он понял?
00:13
Просмотров 129 тыс.
The One Piece Theory Iceberg Explained
1:26:21
Просмотров 4,3 млн
The Dark Rise of One Piece: Anime's Loneliest Creator
28:19
Why not sail The One Ring to Mordor?
10:23
Просмотров 34 тыс.
NEW ONE PIECE THEORIES TO SLEEP TO Ft @Smokey.Dee.Luff_
1:45:14
How The One Piece Live Action Misunderstood Arlong Park
18:50
The Genius of LUFFY | The Anatomy of One Piece
22:54
Просмотров 384 тыс.