This COMPOSITION Tool Eats the RULE of THIRDS for Breakfast!! Landscape Photography

Подписаться 294 тыс.

Просмотров 249 тыс.

50% 1

Go to www.squarespace... to get a free trial and 10% off your first purchase.
markdenneyphot...
☝️Subscribe For FREE Photography Tutorials & Get My Top 4 Compositional Tips
In this week’s episode, we discuss a composition tool that eats the rule of thirds for breakfast!! I think by this point we're all familiar with the more popular composition techniques for creating powerful landscape photos. We know to use leading lines to draw the viewer into our photos, we know to use layers to create depth in our images and we frame our photographs using the rule of thirds, but are these really the best approaches? Now as far as the first two points go, I'm a big fan of both, but I'm not 100% sold on the rule of thirds as a long term solution for composition.
In this video, I discuss what I think a better compositional technique is for replacing the rule of thirds. I think the rule of thirds has it's place when you're a beginner, but once you become comfortable with applying it to your landscape photos where do you advance from here? One of my favorite aspects of landscape photography is that it cannot be perfected, there's always something you can improve and there's always something new you can learn. I think composition is perhaps the most difficult aspect of landscape photography so whenever there's a new technique that can be applied to improve upon this, I'm all for it!
I hope you enjoy this week's video and are able to get some new composition tips out of it that you can apply to both your on-location and post processing workflow moving forward!
The Golden Spiral:
craftwhack.com...
Thanks for watching everyone!
-Mark D.
🔻WATCH THESE PLAYLISTS NEXT
Composition Tips: geni.us/compos...
Beginners Guide: geni.us/Beginn...
Editing Tutorials: geni.us/Editing
PHOTO GEAR I USE
🔺Full Photo Kit: geni.us/photokit
🔺Stills Camera: geni.us/a7riiSony
🔺Wide Lens: geni.us/sony16...
🔺Long Lens: geni.us/sony10...
🔺Prime Lens: geni.us/sony55...
🔺Ballhead: geni.us/rrsbh40
🔺Gloves: geni.us/photog...
🔺Backpack: geni.us/actionx
🔺Backpack: geni.us/explore40
🔺Filters: geni.us/nisikit
🔺Printer: geni.us/canonp...
🔺Backup: geni.us/gnarbox2
VIDEO GEAR I USE
🔺Full Video Kit: geni.us/fullvi...
🔺Video Camera: geni.us/M8SIy
🔺Video Lens: geni.us/fuji10-24
🔺Microphone: geni.us/0pHRt
🔺Key Light: geni.us/aputur...
🔺Gimbal: geni.us/DJIRon...
🔺Pocket Cam: geni.us/DJIosm...
🔻MY ENTIRE KIT
kit.co/markden....
🔻FREE TRIAL: Music & Sound Effects I Use
goo.gl/Qh9scf
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. I earn a small commission on the above links if you decide to purchase the item at no additional charge to you.
#composition #landscapephotography
🔻LETS CONNECT
Newsletter: markdenneyphot...
Instagram: / markdenneyphoto
Facebook: / markdenneyphoto
Twitter: / markdenneyphoto

Опубликовано:

26 сен 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 621

@MarkDenneyPhoto 4 года назад

How often do you use the Rule of Thirds?

@0oTHEJACKo0 4 года назад

every third photo of course

@saddamhussain1312 4 года назад

Almost 50 % shots i use rule of thirds 😁

@MarkDenneyPhoto 4 года назад

0oTHEJACKo0 Haha! Exactly!

@MarkDenneyPhoto 4 года назад

saddam hussain Thats about the amount I used to as well.

@JungleEddie 4 года назад

I almost always start holding my camera with the subject along one of the thirds lines and then I swing the camera lens around in circles until I see something pleasing and then I set up the tripod.

@KimRormarkphotography 4 года назад

The ROT and the Golden spiral are based on the same principles originating from art. In most landscape photos it's easy to overlay the spiral in Lightroom and rationalize that it’s working. If the photo is shot with the ROT in mind it’s even more likely the Golden spiral will work. In practical use for landscape photography I find the ROT more convenient as it also helps positioning and leveling the horizon and vertical lines if present in the composition.

@sudarshankar9094 3 года назад

My thoughts, exactly. The Golden Spiral rule seems more like twisting facts to suit the theory.

@bubbajones5905 3 года назад

..."rationalize that it’s working". Yes, it seems very contrived. The Emperor's new cloths.

@calebplumleephotography 3 года назад

I've always felt the rule of thirds and golden spiral are essentially the same thing. Overlay the spiral and a thirds grid and they nearly line up... natural photo elements rarely align perfectly with either, so they are each a good approximation of one another in composition terms. I also think if you try hard enough, you can make almost anything line up with these concepts... I believe people want to find patterns in things more so than true patterns exist.

@ewoutgsa 4 года назад

Thanks Mark for showing you can just take the photo and choose the rule that fits it best in post...

@MarkDenneyPhoto 4 года назад

Glad to do it👍👍

@woodamsclark 4 года назад

Honestly, I have yet to see an image with the Golden Ratio that makes sense to me - not that it doesn't work! It just doesn't make sense to me. With your images I see how you're lining it up, but the spiral is never the direction my eyes flow across the image - in fact it's usually backwards. It seems to be a bit hokey, and the fact that it 'works' is more to do that the center of the spiral is close to an intersection of the Rule of Thirds. For the Rule of Thirds, I see it as a way to just divide your composition. I actually didn't know you were 'supposed' to put things on the intersecting lines. I've always just used it to place things into one of the three columns or rows. With your image of the tree on the coastline as an example (03:58), I see it as the tree belonging to the right 1/3 section (I might pull the right edge to the left a bit more), and the other 2/3 is empty space/ocean. The land mass creates a bit of a leading line pointing out to the empty space that pulls your eyes over, and creates a bit of a story about standing on the edge of emptiness. That makes more sense to me than a spiral - my eyes never spiral around in the image. I appreciate all your content Mark, it's been a pretty big inspiration and I've learned a lot. Hope this comment doesn't come off as a shot at you 😅

@jimmyb4982 4 года назад

Now, that's how you respectfully disagree!

@fernandoish9194 4 года назад

Yeah, I agree. I don’t think the ROT necessarily means that there has to be a point of interest in one of the intersections (for landscape photography). If your image has a house in the foreground and mountains in the background placing the house in one of the intersections works pretty good, but sometimes you just don’t have that clear point of interest (the house). In the images he’s shown at the beginning of the video I just see the ROT as a way to divide the picture in 1/3 and 2/3, like you said. You chose which of those is sky or ground (or sea/ground/ sea/sky, whatever) depending on what’s more interesting. There are many situations where the clear point of interest just isn’t there. Maybe in other styles of photography you do have a clear subject separated from the background and you need to place it in one of those intersections (like a bird standing in a branch with a blurry background) but in landscape photography is not the same story.

@jeffluo9591 4 года назад

My eyes did spiral around in the image in the video, but only when the spiral is shown. Without the spiral overlay, not so much.

@freddyfleal 4 года назад

He is using the spiral as a a leading line which is, at least, a little odd. When I studied the Golden Ratio in art school it was about proportion, how each segment is multiplied by 1.16(...), so as I understand, a photo that REALLY follows the Golden Ratio would have each element not only in the place of the line but with it's proportions changed more or less by this ratio, otherwise I would argue it's just a leading line as any other

@nolejd50 4 года назад

The thing is, Mark is not using the golden spiral properly.

@terrysparkshiking 4 года назад

I'm a newer photographer and serious student of this endeavor. While reading about composition a few months ago, I took the advice offered and made a cardboard 6” X8” cutout to help me visualize framing my photos before setting up the camera. The second thing I did was make a ROT grid overlay from a transparent sheet of plastic for the cardboard cut out and another for my camera screen, so it would always be visible. After watching a webinar on photographing flowers, I added another cutout with the golden ratio affixed to it, of which I still use, and will continue to use until I can visualize it without thought. Your video drives home what I'm training myself to do, and I am again thankful for your great tutorials Mark.

@tobiasyoder 4 года назад

lol at the start I swear I was thinking "okay... I feel like anything would fit this" and was so glad to see you call that out haha

@MarkDenneyPhoto 4 года назад

Hahha! Right👍

@catchlite5196 4 года назад

I still think this is the case... so I am still searching.

@ianmichael9224 4 года назад

Really glad I came across this ,very useful!

@BenelliMr 4 года назад

I learned that Leonardo da Vinci developed the concept and the golden rule; I use it since then ... well, only a few hundred years later ... as a kid at school I learned about it; since then whenever I go to a museum to get inspiration for my photos, I see it almost everywhere. Only many decades later I learned that some people don't use it and have simplified it to rule of thirds. I never understood why. Well, I must admit that there are so many myths in the photography world that need to be dropped. Just go from time to time into museums and learn from the grand masters For example, you want to learn how to shoot landscape photography with interesting skies and dramatic clouds? Just look at some paintings of William Turner Mark, I love this video and I hope that you continue to make some more videos to clean up our oversimplified world and bring back some high level class into photography.

@SimonBoothPhotography 4 года назад

I think you show here that both the third grid and the golden spiral can be made to fit most if not all your images. This is because you have a developed eye and compose naturally. In essence, when you start out, you need to keep these visual cues in the back of your mind when in the field, but as you grow, they become second nature. I don’t feel the latter eats the former for breakfast though!

@MarkDenneyPhoto 4 года назад

Thanks Simon! Yes, I like to think so as well, but every once and awhile I come back from a trip wondering what in the world I was thinking with a particular composition. My biggest fault with regards to composition is probably trying to get overly complicated with it. I've found over the years that my favorite images generally are the ones that are composed in a simple fashion - suppose less is more! Appreciate you checking out the video Simon!

@SimonBoothPhotography 4 года назад

@@MarkDenneyPhoto You're very welcome Mark. I try to watch them as often as I can!

@SimonBoothPhotography 4 года назад

@@MarkDenneyPhoto I also agree that in many cases less is more too!

@jonathanfmarin 4 года назад

BTW... all your “golden spiral images” also fit into the rule of thirds.

@thomsonsunil7394 4 года назад

I thought it too

@alexmacchalatte 3 года назад

The Rule of Thirds is a simplification of the Golden Mean.

@alexgraefe.photoYT 3 года назад

Isnt that exactly the point?! You can say in almost every situation, that its the rule of thirds in landscape photography, but that doesnt mean, that this is enough to make a photo composition beyond just "okay".

@jonathanfmarin 3 года назад

@@alexgraefe.photoYT My comment was written because I am not exactly sure what the point is!? A great image is a great image. Out of focus, poor white balance, grainy etc... if you are trying to fit every image into a very specific formula you are missing the point. It's kind of like playing jazz without being willing to improvise.

@alexgraefe.photoYT 3 года назад

I believe that those rules exist for a reason. I'm really new to photography and I feel like, thinking about how I could improve the angle I'm taking a photo from, really makes my shots better. Those rules can help with that. That said, I also think that often times I take a photo because I think it just looks "cool" and later find out, that it matches one of those rules and in post production I can crop my image to match it even more. Subconsciously we do a lot of things that just feel right which actually is following a rule of some sort. Not only in photography. Of course this is just my opinion and as I already said. I'm a photography noob (;

@sassytbc7923 3 года назад

Leading lines is a very good for new photographers when they are just starting out. I taught it to my students last year, they very much appreciated it because it was quite concrete.

@BrianNorthmorePhotography 4 года назад

Mark, I feel you have done the same with the golden spiral as you did with the rule of thirds. If you compose with the rule of thirds the end of the spiral will nearly always line up with the spiral. I think for beginners rules are essential to provide guidance on what to do. As you train you’re eye to see compositions, you start to compose naturally creating balance, tension, or whatever the subject needs. I also think it’s true that most of these compositions will be able to retrospectively apply a rule if you look for it. I think the point you make people about the spiral creating a sense of visual flow in the image, a natural pathway for the eye to move along is very relevant, and worth exploring more. Strangely I shot a video yesterday where I discuss composition, and touch on rules. Thanks 🙏 for sharing this, has got me thinking a little more about using the spiral to create flow.

@jakeoneil1476 4 года назад

Love Fibonacci sequences and spirals. I’m also a day trader and it’s amazing how often fib sequences can predict price movement. Editing to it makes all the difference too!

@pjay3028 3 года назад

Wow, isn't it amazing that a spiral that you can change completely in terms of it's size, shape, location and orientation can be vaguely fitted over the features in your photographs. Haha

@maxdiditagain 4 года назад

I have watched a handful of your videos, I plan to watch more. What I respect the most is that you have liked the positive comments...sometimes where there are hundreds! It shows your taking you're time and energy to read them. Thanks for that. Cheers

@tallaganda83 4 года назад

I don’t use any rules I just find interesting subjects and then try to find the least distracting way to frame them and then look through the viewfinder and scan the frame from things that don’t feel right. Sometimes I squint my eye a bit so everything just looks like shapes and I guess try to balance shapes and tones.

@marekfoolforchrist 3 года назад

you said you didn't use any rules then described the rules you use

@nimmira 4 года назад

This video brings back some memories. Around the period 2012-2013, I've just joined a photography group back then, and we got involved somehow in a seminar held by the award-winning Iranian-French photographer Reza Deghati. He mentioned something (in answer to some question) which involves how we see things. I can't remember his exact words but he stated that the rule of thirds is actually not "the thing" and it was mainly based on observations by some researchers and scholars who were mainly based in Europe. He said, I remember, that according to his experience, most people in the Orient and Eastern regions, do have a tendency to see things in a way fitting the spiral (he didn't specifically say golden spiral) rather than fitting some intersecting points on a grid. All in all, he didn't really believe in the importance of such guide lines, as far as I remember. I've encountered his viewpoints later on books by other photographers, like Bruce Barnbaum. Barnbaum, I remember, even believed that it is wrong and a mistake to teach art students the law of thirds altogether (or any compositional structure) and to leave things to the instincts. By the way, the golden spiral or ratio is not 100% fitting in nature as many people think. There is a video on Numberphile channel here on RU-vid that talks about these spirals, and what people typically call golden spiral (which is a structure built around the golden ratio) is not exactly that. But there are other spirals with other metallic names, e.g. silver spiral, bronze spiral, that are built on different ratios than 1.618; and those are MORE common in nature than the golden ratio actually.

@aronaldharper543 Год назад

My issue is that if the golden spiral is everywhere then finding the rule of thirds everywhere is essentially the same concept

@rakim7484 4 года назад

The most interesting in the Golden Ratio is that it is a mathematic rules, and it is everywhere around us. This ratio is from the Fibonacci sequence? Absolutely passionating

@Bigweave74 4 года назад

Been shooting for 10 years and I’m still getting taken to school! Excellent video once again Mark! I’ve been a follower since you were sub 10K subscribers and I learn something new from you every week.

@MarkDenneyPhoto 4 года назад

Always appreciate your comments Jared and definitely appreciate all the support as well man - really means a lot!

@andreip9378 4 года назад

To me it seems like the images that fit the golden spiral rule also fit rule of thirds.

@sandyhancock2020 Год назад

I found a golden spiral camera app on my phone .. while this is not the camera I would use for a final shoot, it could be helpful in practicing using the golden spiral

@Mikyll1969 3 года назад

I am a total newb to photography, and have been attracted to landscapes, and portrait styles... Thank you for the informative and engaging help videos

@BitterClinger1947 4 года назад

One of the reasons I like going to museums is to see how principles of composition have developed over hundreds of years, in painting.sculpture etc. It’s also interesting to see how modern artists break many of these rules.

@Kevinabreu Год назад

The first couple of examples of the ocean and El Cap (or whatever mountain it is) are actually more emblematic of the 20-80 rule. The later photo of El Capitan actually had some slight visual interest leading the eye to the sunset spot on it.

@stefanhansen5882 4 года назад

In primary school a math teacher once came in and drew 15-20 rectangles of various sizes on the blackboard. Then he pointed to each in turn and asked us to raise our hands if we liked it. Some rectangles got a lot more votes than others, although they seemed different, some being small, others large, some wide, some tall. The teacher then measured the sides of all the rectangles and wrote the ratio between the width and the high in each rectangle. To our astonishment it turned out that all the rectangles with a lot of votes had a ratio super close to 1.62 (the golden ratio). Being a math teacher myself, to this day this is the math class which stands out to me more than any other, and I wonder why cameras do not allow us to choose an aspect ratio of 1.62.

@brendalg4 3 года назад

Is that what inspired you to be a math teacher?

@stefanhansen5882 3 года назад

@@brendalg4 It might be part of the reason. However, I always had a fascination for math. Today, however, I am a self-employed language teacher. :)

@awsmithjr 2 года назад

Mark, I wish I’d found your videos years ago. You are a marvelous teacher. Thanks

@CalvinGomes Год назад

I like the golden spiral but I found my eye drawn in different directions to what Mark said. Like the one with the wave breaking on rocks. My eye went the opposite way...from the right side, over to the left from the bottom, following the rock ledge over to thr three jutting rocks. The one with the forest with the small waterfall...my eyes rested on the waterfall rather than the rock (suggesting the spiral probably should be flipped to have the end at the watefall). I think rule of thirds works really great and closely achieved the result. If you overlay rule of third over the golden spiral, you may find a sweet spot. I tend to compose using rule of thirds and leading lines. This golden spiral is a new useful tip in my toolkit though.

@ronkathyballard5923 4 года назад

I don’t use the rule of thirds too much in landscapes but was never able to clearly visualize the golden spiral when taking a landscape photo. As a result I quit even considering it when composing a photo. Your suggestion of visualizing the rotation of the number “9” was a great idea and I will start using it as a tool in my compositions. I will also go back through some older photos and see if the golden spiral was actually applied.

@MarkDenneyPhoto 4 года назад

Maybe one day a camera manufacturer will give us more than the rule of thirds built in - that would make things so much easier if we had the option to change it in camera.

@DevinePhotography 4 года назад

Mark, you are correct in that the "Golden Spiral" is a better compositional tool than the "rule of thirds". The area where the spiral terminates indicates the area of the frame known as the "Golden Section" which is often the best place to locate the main area of interest in the composition. The "rule of thirds" is often used by beginners as the main compositional guideline, as it is easier to use. Where the lines intersect in the rule of thirds approximates the Golden Section but it's positioning is generally not as pleasing as using the Golden Section. Of course this is just a guideline for placing the main subject of a "dynamic composition". There are many other rules of composition regarding the other areas of the frame and balancing points. The other use of the "Golden Ratio" 1.618 is to multiply the short side of a rectangle by that figure to get a "Golden Rectangle" which has ideal proportions for the overall composition. Any landscape photographer would be advised to study the formal rules of pictorial composition that where often used in the late Nineteenth and early Twentieth centuries. The rules of composition in photography are not quite so rigid nowadays but knowing when to use the rules and when to break them will help anyone's images!

@fahadarisulhakim428 2 года назад

thank you for all that’s you explaining about avoid the rule of third and focus on the problem in the main point.

@adammohdkhairuddin1749 4 года назад

I just bought a Canon EOS M200 to learn photography. Your channel really helped me to learn the basics of photography. Thank you :)

@MarkDenneyPhoto 4 года назад

Awesome! Glad to hear it Adam!

@jhoang861 4 года назад

all this time, i had that golden spiral in lightroom and didn’t know it! Thx for sharing!

@MarkDenneyPhoto 4 года назад

Happy to do it!

@Trblmkr07 4 года назад

If you look at the pictures using golden spiral, and the pull up the rule of thirds. You'll see that that center for the golden spiral no matter where you place it, is also an intersection for the rule of thirds. So the golden spiral isn't really showing you anything that you don't already know, and IMO, doesn't really help because some of your examples, the center of focus will not be on a rock in the foreground, but the waterfall and the light. Because we know, our eyes always go to the lightest part of a photo, so golden spiral didn't really work for that example.

@PBlair-ns9nn 4 года назад

Another gem! Thanks Mark!

@alang6402 4 года назад

I think the golden section it works very well for images like paintings that are already literally constructed to exploit it by setting the format of the frame to perfectly match the golden ratio. Such images contain figures or similar point sources of interest, often cast in relation to others that tend to be expressive in themselves. The information viewers need to extract from the image takes up very little area and the artist uses the golden spiral, and many other techniques, to help the viewer navigate the image. For landscape not so much where there are contrasting features that are not in themselves expressive -- there is no allegorical narrative to decode in nature but that is not to say it cannot be dramatic, powerful and moving, or simply comforting. Check Ruskin and the Sublime.

@Dolmen254 2 года назад

Mark, recently discovered your site, one of the best, thank you. Merry Christmas to you.

@philmalone1982 2 года назад

A Golden Spiral crop overlay in Lightroom! WHO KNEW? I'm now in the process of going through old images and using this. Great video......again!

@paulhopkins8391 4 года назад

@mark denney there are a number of apps available for Android or iOS that will enable you to use your phone with the different composition rules in. I find this helping when looking for a composition

@nelsonclub7722 4 года назад

Wouldn't it be helpful if all camera manufacturers included this overlay like they do the grids!!!! Excellent vid as always

@MarkDenneyPhoto 4 года назад

That would be amazing! Maybe one day.

@jimmason8502 4 года назад

@@MarkDenneyPhoto Mark, it seems like the tight part of that spiral ends up on one of the 1/3 lines intersection points. So The Golden Spiral and Rule of Thirds are not so far off. Plus I've seen quite a few interesting street photographs where the 'no rules" method of composition seems to work well too.

@JulesMoyaert_photo 4 года назад

@@MarkDenneyPhoto I believe Olympus OM-Ds have in live view.

@G0FUW 4 года назад

Interesting analysis Mark. I spent some time studying the work of a famous landscape artist and found he used four 'rules'; rule of thirds, the golden ratio (aka spiral), triangles (as per LR overlay) and what I came to call 'dropped thirds'. I read a book where he shared some of his process and in the example discussed the painter starts with a 3x3 grid and then sketches the scene to fit that grid. He had the skill to be able to select the most appropriate 'rule' for the scene he was painting. The 'dropped third' is an interesting one and it is effectively the rule of thirds but with half of the bottom third cropped out. Once I had figured it out it was clear to see in many of his pictures that did not quite fit any of the 'normal' rules - his shorelines are often below the lower third line, and it works very well, making more of the mid ground and distant subjects. He clearly developed his own 'style' over time. I also found that in his paintbrush he had the ultimate 'Photoshop' tool; if an island did not sit quite where it looked best, he painted it where it did look best, if the lakeshore was not at its best from his viewpoint he painted a different shoreline. One of my favourite pictures of his was found to be a composite of at least three different views, which all exist, but not in one place. You cannot see the join but it does fit the 'rule' that we find so visually appealing.

@terihooverartandphotography 2 года назад

Do you have the name of this artist?

@G0FUW 2 года назад

W Heaton Cooper

@mniblick1 4 года назад

Great advice to visualize an imaginary 9 (or 6) when composing a scene. I plan to use it. Thanks.

@sksignsdesignsmarketing3993 4 года назад

Just re-edited two of mine from last year, and wow. Huge difference. Thanks!

@richardsmith533 4 года назад

I seem to remember reading somewhere that the ROT is just a simplified version of the golden ratio anyway. So Its not too surprising that images that seem to conform to the ROT will also fit the Golden Ratio. These are both good tools to help with compisition but I don't think they can ever be the whole story. There will always be images which do not appear to fit either rules that are still great images. Maybe such images are "the exceptions that prove the rule". Which I think actually means "do what feels and looks right - there are no rules"!

@tungalpilt6307 4 года назад

As far as I know the rule of thirds is just a simplification of mathematically expressed principles of golden ratio (1:1,61) and Fibonacci sequence (which actually contains golden ratio). If one turns the F. sequence (golden spiral) on the screen, then it can point the same four crossings of horisontal and vertical lines at the distance=1/1,61 from the corner, i.e. golden ratio. Fibonacci introduced his sequence at 1202 AD and the principle of golden ratio was known in India at 200-400 BC. In my opinion the Fibonacci sequence / golden spiral provides more powerful composition.

@RGMGFitness 4 года назад

Nice video! I agree...I think images edited using the golden spiral can often look so much better than just following a typical rule of thirds. Great reminder for me to use this feature in lightroom...thanks for the video!

@MarkDenneyPhoto 4 года назад

Thanks so much! They definitely seem to have a pleasing flow to them that’s for certain!

@unlockscotland 4 года назад

Enjoying your videos Mark. Well done

@TylerCampbellOutdoors Год назад

I would still be classified as a beginner and have been using the Rule of Thirds. Interesting concept. Thank you for sharing

@alanhumbard8298 4 года назад

Great video Denny. You gave us a lot of food for thought. I swear that I learn something on every one of you videos.

@MarkDenneyPhoto 4 года назад

Thanks so much Alan! Thats music to my ears!

@trbowlin 4 года назад

Thanks. I learned a lot in this video.

@onemansview 4 года назад

All those rules are tools and we tend to want to try to reach the perfect composition too much. We should not forget that the final goal is the image not "does it cross perfectly all the lines of the rule... "

@johnburne1252 4 года назад

Nice to see someone understanding and using this method/guideline. there is a camera that has an overlay of this, the Olympus E3, i use one. there may be others.

@arunakalu 4 года назад

I didn't even know LR had other composition rules except the ROT, until I saw your video :-). Still 80% of the time, I let my eyes and mind do the composition work and if I am still not happy and confused I used the tool, to justify my compositions or do a better job. Now I know another tool I can use, Thank You.

@canoradam 4 года назад

Wow, just when I thought your videos couldn't get anymore helpful! I can't wait to go home and try this out on a bunch of my photos I've been wanting to frame.

@MarkDenneyPhoto 4 года назад

Great to hear you enjoyed it Adam!

@MSmith-Photography 4 года назад

The Golden Spiral sounds like a high priced ice cream. 🤣🍦

@MarkDenneyPhoto 4 года назад

Hahah! You're right!

@MrMisuma 2 года назад

When I first got into photography, I thought the rule of third was just a silly thing. But the more I shoot, the more I tend to use it when it fits the photo.

@donaldkelley5785 4 года назад

Awesome Video, Mark !!

@jamesberardino5420 3 года назад

Thanks for this video, Mark! I had been looking for a golden ratio overlay/plugin for lightroom for ages, who knew it was already there!

@stevenrun34 4 года назад

The golden ratio is approximated as 1.618.. as it's an irrational number. Another neat way to compute it is to divide sequential numbers in the Fibonacci sequence. Your result is more and more accurate as you go down the sequence. So the two are innately related, and just happen to fit beautifully with all kinds of things in nature from tiny flowers, to the proportions of a face, to the structure of a galaxy. The rule of thirds is also the quotient of two such numbers... 3 over 2... and at 1.5, it's within 10% of the golden ratio-- which is probably where the whole rule of thirds comes from to begin with. It is just so much easier to eyeball "about a third..." in the field than 1.616....

@MarkDenneyPhoto 4 года назад

Perfectly said Steven! Thanks for checking out the video!

@smaakjeks 4 года назад

You see every ratio you want to look for in nature. Not just 1.618.

@bt.c.1829 11 месяцев назад

I wish I could share the photo I created with the golden ratio! I'm thrilled with it!!🎉🎊🎉

@Bengalgirl2 3 года назад

Thanks for the video Mark!

@frtzkng Год назад

I do use both, and I also tend to re-size or crop my images to a 16:10 ratio, which is very close to the Golden Ratio

@officialjpnyc 4 года назад

Ahhhh that’s awesome thanks for the tips mark! Also if you want an alternative to Instagram try out dayflash it’s a new social media platform that really gives creators the credit they deserve. The best part is that it has no algorithm so your content will always be seen and the photographers there are seriously showcasing amazing work

@snoopaka 4 года назад

Lots of fun things to think about and terrific information. Great video Mark. 14ish minutes went by in a flash!

@MarkDenneyPhoto 4 года назад

Thanks so much!

@HikersRefuge 4 года назад

Usually one would try composing on location with the rule in mind. Choosing it once seen that the scene in front is forming pretty close to it. Not afterwards. Reason it works (also stated already in comments) is because you basically are putting a point of interest in an intersection of the rule of thirds. But the rest of the spiral has not much to with it since the rest of the composition does mostly not at all follow the way my eyes would work through the images (at least for me), meaning you can imagine (when in post) it moving through the image off course and „it (kind of) works“ for sure but therefor more just because of intersection of thirds. In the example of the cliffs with the shoreline splashing vertical the spiral was even placed wrong and it „worked“. But all nitpicking aside, beautiful images and that’s what counts! Also rule of thirds etc. is not always what grabs attention. Why your one image worked better than others can have to do with the fact that the arrangement in concentric. Meaning all the steep hills around lead the eye towards the center or away from it what ever philosophy one likes better. On a fast Plattform like IG making it easy for the viewer to consume will enable them to react faster and positiv hence more interaction on your image.

@niftytwo 4 года назад

That’s a great idea Mark. It will give me a very positive way of constructing my photos. Thank you for your help. Neville

@MarkDenneyPhoto 4 года назад

Thanks Neville and a big thanks for watching this week's video!

@georgeumber6287 4 года назад

Interesting video and worth trying for editing images. The golden spiral as a compositional tool seems to look for patterns for the sake of finding patterns. The eye tends to move in straight lines and sweeping curves when looking at an image, not in a spiral or circular manner. It is interesting that the end zone of the spiral finishes along a rule of thirds line in one direction and it could be a version of the rule of thirds.

@TheMoodyPhotographer 4 года назад

Very interesting subject I find the photo @10:10 represents the golden spiral perfectly 👏🏻 I use the rule of thirds more often in landscapes, but in woodland way less, especially if im restricted in a way that I don't want to go wide because I don't want to include the sky

@MarkDenneyPhoto 4 года назад

I’m glad you think so! Yeah I’ve always found it difficult to accurately use the rule of thirds in woodland scenes.

@m2rer1k 4 года назад

Great video Mark!👌 I never stop learning.. lol.. I havent use "Golden spiral" so much, I find it not easy to see the golden spiral in view finder, but maybe more easy to play with in lightroom when you can show up the spiral lines over the imagines. But I've been used "Rule of third" and "Golden point" every time since I saw a RU-vid video about "Rule of Third" for couple of month ago, I learned that "Golden point" is not "Rule of thirds..!" "Rule of thirds" is that when subject is tall and bigger than half of the frame, - if subject is smaller than half of the frame, then it called "Rule of Golden point". The way to use these 4 point where the Lines of Rule of thirds meets have change the way I shoot my pictures, its more easy to make "leading line" and balance to the image now.😄👌

@clevershades 4 года назад

If you do have the rule of thirds overlay on your camera you can use that to help with the spiral. Put your interest on one of the intersections, then review the composition to see if it swoops around. Just something I got into the habit of doing shooting macros of flowers and end up applying it to a lot of compositions

@henrycruz45cal 4 года назад

Really! You can make all rule of 3rds images fit the spiral, the spiral ends at a cross point.

@lesliewood8382 4 года назад

Had to go back and look at the wildflower photos I took this afternoon. I'm challenging myself to understand why I prefer some compositions of a group of flowers and not the others. Well, the golden spirals always won out. This video was just what I needed today, thanks!!!!

@MarkDenneyPhoto 4 года назад

Glad to hear it Leslie! Thanks for checking it out!

@abibstopherwilliam 4 года назад

Really loving the new angles of you photo lair!! It all looks so atmospheric!

@MarkDenneyPhoto 4 года назад

Many thanks William! It took me quite awhile to get this dialed in just right!

@simonekoffman 4 года назад

Thank you so much for this Mark. You made it very easy to understand.

@MarkDenneyPhoto 4 года назад

Many thanks - I'm glad you think so!

@CrowleysArt 4 года назад

Hey Mark, I know as you said you wont find any cameras that have the golden ratio built into them, but it would not be to hard to take a clear piece of plastic and trace the golden ratio on top of it, and then you could place that on your LCD screen to get a visual while lining up your shots.

@MarkDenneyPhoto 4 года назад

Ahh yes that's a good point!

@S133S 4 года назад

Composition is my favorite subject when it comes to outdoor photography. I tend to push my subject to either right or left, never center. My personal reason is that it challenges me to balance it, I may fail most of the time and end up with large uninteresting blank spaces in my photo, but I am aware of it that means I am learning something. :-)

@MarkDenneyPhoto 4 года назад

S133S I’d say that was perfectly said! I feel the exact same way!

@richardpowellTV 4 года назад

Thanks Mark, that's the best explanation of the spiral I've seen. As for the "Rule" of thirds I never deliberately use it although I always have the grid on my camera! I just find my composition and if it happens to fit into thirds so be it. Composition first, ROT second!!

@MarkDenneyPhoto 4 года назад

Many thanks Rick - I’m glad to hear you enjoyed it!

@leosievanen 4 года назад

Thanks again for another inspiring video! I will most definitely try the golden spiral on pics. It has been so easy to stuck to just using the rule of thirds as the main composition rule. Keep up the good work!

@MarkDenneyPhoto 4 года назад

Thanks so much for checking out this weeks video!

@JasmineApple 4 года назад

Great info! I found that my eye started closer to the center of the golden spiral and swept out, rather than starting at the outside and sweeping in. Either way, it made the golden spiral easier to understand & visualize.

@MarkDenneyPhoto 4 года назад

Thanks so much Jasmine!

@TheAGATODEMON 4 года назад

The golden ratio looks nice to our eyes because we see it everywhere and we are familiar with it. The fibonacci's number "has shaped" the forms of nature through the millions of years of evolution because all nature shapes and forms have been under the pressure of the same physical principles from the beginning all the way to the present. We just can't ignore how nice it is to our eyes to see it. Very nice video as always. Thanks Mark.

@MarkDenneyPhoto 4 года назад

Much appreciated David - glad to hear you enjoyed it!

@Mrtee1950 4 года назад

Thanks again for a great video Mark. I have struggled with composition all my photographic life. That is not to say I can't compose my images, I just feel it doesn't come as easy to me as it does to others. I am not sure I agree entirely with your take on the Golden Ratio. I have to be honest is really feel the same way about it as you explained the rule of thirds, you can very much aply to most images if you look hard enough. Like most composition rules, it points to a golden rule. Don't centre important aspects of your image, offsetting something, up, down, left or right works better. Anyway, as always your videos are great, thanks.

@bd1630 4 года назад

Maybe not available on DSLRs but have availability to use on iPhone with ProCam or Lightroom app to take pics. Seems like easy fix for camera manufacturers to add option to change grid similar to options on smartphones.

@MarkDenneyPhoto 4 года назад

I would love it on my Sony and Fuji X-T3

@arildthingvoll5967 2 года назад

Amazing video! I will try The golden spiral on my landscape photos!

@SinaFarhat 4 года назад

Very nice! I go by my instinct when I compose my photos depending on the story I want to tell with my street photo or if I take environmental portraits/ cityscape photos. I do recognise that I need to spend more time on the crop tool in lightroom in order to get the most from my photos! Keep up the good work!

@blue_ranger 4 года назад

The overlay also works in the crop tool on Photoshop and with similar controls (Shift + 0) to cycle through.

@barrysharoff6537 4 года назад

Thanks for the video, Mark. It does raise a question for me: I saw you overlay the golden spiral on your old photos, and use it to crop the one with the tree. However, you didn't crop any of the others except minimally. You said that by applying the overlay you discovered that they were worth saving, but for me I couldn't see how placing the overlay on them made these photos any better. I didn't see them as different even after you applied the overlay. And when we print, we don't print overlay lines or shapes. In other words, since you didn't crop your photos after applying the overlay, your showing me how the overlay fit spots on the image didn't show how it could improve the composition of the image by cropping differently.

@brendalg4 3 года назад

Would have been better to use the same photos he showed with the rule of thirds instead of entirely different phhots

@smashexentertainment676 4 года назад

Human brain naturally seeks patterns. You can overlay any grid over the image and if you look long enough you'll find that it fits. In the end your eye decides what looks cool.

@MarkDenneyPhoto 4 года назад

Agreed!

@rfern263 5 месяцев назад

I’ve seen dozens of videos on this subject and they all have one in thing in common. Few of the photos used for demonstration were taken with the golden spiral in mind. They were retrofitted with the golden spiral angle that fit the already captured image. This begs the question, is the golden spiral really a composition technique easily usable before pressing the shutter? The answer is not really, particularly since the rule of thirds, which is much easier to use, generally applies to photos claiming to adopt the golden spiral.

@J0hnny8ravo 4 года назад

You’re right! The most liked image (helicopter) has nothing to do with the golden spiral. But it looks good.

@MarkDenneyPhoto 4 года назад

🤣

@maximuscassius3121 4 года назад

Dude I’m glad I just found you...facts you cannot master photography like martial arts...you strive for the unattainable 👍🏾😎

@iaincphotography6051 3 года назад

If people understand the Fibonacci numbers better and know it is the Fibonacci spiral things make more sense but never forget we read from left to right. Also many painters use an arabesque in their compositions!

@washingtonradio 4 года назад

Compositional rules are really guides to help people understand how to compose better images. They are best used by beginners who have not developed good compositional habits. But how to frame an image also depends on what you are shooting. Also, as one gains enough experience there many instances were the rules should be broken, but this takes experience to learn.

@jgreenler 4 года назад

I love this. Reading some comments about compositional rules being immaterial or that they are meant to be broken and I agree. But I also strongly believe that you need to understand and master the rules as fundamentals before you begin to consciously break them. It's one thing for Ansel Adams to break the rules to create tension. It's another for an amateur like me to think my photos "break the rules" when, in fact, they just might not fundamentally be very good.

@MarkDenneyPhoto 4 года назад

Very well said Jeff! Thanks for checking it out!

@LucianoStabel 4 года назад

In my opinion, since you know what you're doing, rules are made to be broken. I'm also a tremendous fan of the golden ratio. I used to have an app on my mobile that overlays the phone camera with the spiral. It was a nice exercise before shooting with my actual camera. Another cool video, Mark!

@MarkDenneyPhoto 4 года назад

Thanks Luciano!

@carlstawicki1915 4 года назад

I like to crop landscapes with the golden ratio if it works. Bakker's Saddle is another good alternative to the rule of thirds.

@dimensionless99 Год назад

Thanks, that was interesting. My two cents: every composition "rule" has its place, depending on the situation. Even framing the subject dead center sometimes is the way to go, or at least and perfectly valid option. Also, I love how you framed yourself around the right third of the frame for this video, and your computer roughly traces a lone around the left third. Very pleasing 😉

@sigurdurg1558 4 года назад

I rarly use this but when i find a photo i can use it for im usually rly pleased with the result

@MarkDenneyPhoto 4 года назад

Same!

@smitkapadia8080 4 года назад

A very curious and intriguing composition technique. Never really thought about the Golden spiral before. Thank you for explaining me this amazing golden spiral rule to use in my photos!

@MarkDenneyPhoto 4 года назад

Happy to do it and hope you enjoyed it!

@donaldgould1293 4 года назад

,Thanks Mark, I found that very helpful. I will start to use this. I find the rule of thirds useful, but I just seem to have moved to simply looking at an image to see if it was balanced. This will be helpful. Interesting that you say the video was sponsored by Squarespace, but that did not stop an advertisement coming up during the video. Not complaining, just mentioned it. Thanks again.