It’s so crazy to me that jongseob is this incredibly talented at the age of 16!!! Like he’s rapping is literally insane. Not to mention that he has 25 song credits under his name at the age of 16
what makes this album better is knowing that intak and jongseob have writing credits on all songs!! i think by now they each have 20+ writing/composing credits as recognised by the komca
31:13 i love that you picked up on the soulful tone that keeho has bc he used to sing in a church choir. not only is he so enjoyable to listen to but it's so distinct from other voices in kpop!! he also definitely has one of the best lower registers in 4th gen which i feel like we haven't heard much of
In one of their interviews, Soul said that he's okay with his part on doom du doom, which could reflect his whole situation that he's okay getting limited lines and that he's comfortable with that and just focus on his dance solos, pretty much. That's how I put it. He's still not confident with his voice and I hope that he gets more lines as he see fit.
Yes. And he's openly saying he's not comfortable with English. He found English is very difficult. That kinda explains why he got only 'Do it 5x like this' line in DILT. Bc they also prepared the English version of it. And that's maybe why his part in their English covers are always too little. May be his line is the easiest and most comfortable for him to do. He will actually be comfortable when he sings in Japanese. I'm waiting for FNC to promote them in Japan. They have every resources to make it big there.
I love how well Keeho and Theo's voices work together. Keeho's voice is so soulfull and Theo's voice is so delicate, but both of them sing with this whinie nuanced phrasing that I really really like.
MIRROR MIRROR is my favorite on this album, J.DON who participated in the lyrics and the composition, often participate in P1Harmony's albums, and his songs tend to be my favorites. He's part of the band N.Flying who is also under the same company as P1harmony and SF9, you should definitely check them out too.
I don’t think they have official “main” vocals but most say Keeho and Theo. Since Jiung also raps maybe that’s why people figure he’s more of lead vocal and lead rapper. I feel that all 3 had close to equal amounts of singing and ad libs in this album.
p1harmony have self introductions that they released for their debut: keeho & theo: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-eSUj4oVeRMQ.html jiung & intak: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE--wyS9vFx67U.html soul & jongseob: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-p1FdjbdlThM.html i'd also recommend this guide! it's not too long, more recent than others and shows off a good variety of their talent :)) ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-hMnx33rvipE.html this is a more "unhelpful" guide lmao it shows off a lot more of their personalities and dynamics while also touching on their talents :D ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-M8VD_zELobI.html i hope you enjoy your p1ece journey with piwon
I highly recommend that you watch the self introduction videos!! They really give you a good sense of the members' personalities and how they interact as a group. They are fun, funny and heart felt.
I’m so excited for this reaction this is my first P1Harmony comeback and this album had me floored its soo good😫 It’s so hard to choose a b-side and I absolutely love the title track🫶
I actually really like this way of doing an album reaction! This is how I listen to albums normally. No distractions first time through just feeling the music!
the way i’ve had mirror mirror on repeat since it dropped… it’s sick hahahah the track and my obsession w it lmao thank you caitlin for introducing me to these wonderfully talented fellllaaaaasss 🥹
I just wanted to say that as someone who 100% wants to feel the _vibe_ of a song before diving into the lyric videos, I really appreciate the new layout of your reactions. I understand that people want their lyricists to be appreciated and I definitely do love all our genius songwriters but at the end of the day, even if I know the lyrics and intention of the songs it still doesn't change the fact that it's the melody, the production, and the vocals that hook me first and I'm OK with that 🤷🏻♀
Theyre so underrated it fustrated me!! (sorry my grammar) i hope you could watch their movie P1H : The beginning of new world….also, i hope you could do a reaction on their self-produced songs in soundcloud cuz jiung and jongseob apparently have such a bop songs,i really want to know your reaction on them…they really are all-rounded boy group and i hope their effort will be paid off in the future 💖💖
I’m gonna get to everything eventually! I’m aware of the movie and their covers. I’ll probably do albums first but I will definitely get to everything! 😁
I stan P1Harmony since pre debut and every time I see someone who gets to know them and enjoys their music and says nice things about them I feel so proud and happy 🥰 thank you Caitlin! I'm so excited for more Piwon content in the future ❤️
LETS GO!!!!! Black hole is literally top 5 for me ☺️ I fell in love with the song the second I heard it. Jiung and Jongseob are my biases. My babies 🤌🏾
I would like to say that I still liked the old format more when you showed videos on the screen with the distribution and translation, because I watch every your video and in this way I discovered a huge number of new songs and groups. but if such a format is much better and more convenient to you, or you did it because of copyright issues, THEN EVERYTHING is FINE!! I won't stop watching your reactions anyway and I was glad to see this reaction :) and now... HOW MUCH I'VE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS VIDEO!! This album is amazing and I'm glad you liked it too. I live for your reactions to p1harmony!!! I also became the stan of this group quite recently. now I'm madly waiting for your reaction to the xdinary heroes album. I haven't listened to anything from the album on purpose yet so that we can listen to it "together" ahahaha
It wasn’t because of copyright. It was Because creativity I didn’t like my other format. I didn’t want to film album reactions because it was boring for me but I knew that everyone wasn’t going to like the change. I honestly had a lot more fun filming it and editing it. For now this is what I’ll probably do. Regardless glad you enjoyed the reaction! 💕
AAAHHH I WAS WAITING FOR THIS!!!! it's crazy how underrated piwons music is, especially when they have writing credits on ALL OF THEIR SONGS (except for ayaya) and even composing credits on some. They have composing and full writing credits on your favorite track of this album, A Different Song For Me, liiikkkeee...😭 I really reeaaalllyy hope the soon get the recognition they deserve!!🙏
I’ve been a p1ece for over a year now and I cannot stress enough how incredible their music is. Their other albums too, every song is a masterpiece and they have choreography for every song I’m pretty sure and they know how to put on a SHOW. They’re hilarious too, their variety shows are incredible and I laugh at everything they do, you will not regretting stanning p1harmony :)
P1Harmony just don't miss, I guarantee you their every album is a top tier 👌🏻 with every comeback they're just outdoing themselves! These boys are so talented ahhh Also I'm loving the new format!! We can focus just on the music, then you're doing a deep dive into the lyrics? It's a great idea 😊 + your editing is so fun haha thank you for an amazing reaction to this incredible album and thank you for making me smile 😁
I really want to just stand up and applaud you for this beautiful tribute to P1Harmony’s newest album! Not only was the music phenomenal but your reactions were so wonderful and entertaining. You made me laugh, and dance, and cry with you at the wonder you feel when you first hear such a great piece of art through music! I hope P1Harmony gets to see this; your reactions. It’ll make them feel that all their sacrifices had real purpose and their music does have value and is loved! Thank you for sharing this with us! Welcome to the P1ece family!
i was waiting for thiss😭 i was scared bc i thought it would be on patreon and i cant-i rlly hope we get to see more p1h reactions from u i hope you check out their other albums too❤
This whole vid made me smile like crazy for an hour straight :) Thanks... P1harmony is the first group after exo that made me stan in about 2,3 seconds ♡ Like, wow... Talent! Have a nice day! Greetings from switzerland
Since you enjoyed this album sm i'm so excited for you to check out their older songs and so happy you found them because they have so many more jems in their discography 💕
I am so happy to see your reactions to p1. I am honestly in the same boat as you, I suddenly decided to check out a few of their songs a few weeks ago right before the comeback and now I'm obsessed. All of their music is so A+ and their performances are so amazing to watch every time. I have had a chance to watch some of their variety content as well and they are so funny and so entertaining, made me fall in love so fast. 🥰
i’m so happy to see that you really enjoyed the music video and the album and became interested to know more about them! they definitely deserve to get recognized by a lot more people. I really started to stan p1h because of their music too. they really do have some of the most high quality b-sides. all of their other albums are just as good as this one
~As long as you're happy and enjoying doing the album reactions this way, that's all that matters to me! I hope it's more enjoyable for you, that you get to do a deeper dive in the songs/albums in the ways you want, and that you are HAPPY with the final product. 🖤
Thank you so much for this reaction Caitlin ❤. This album is a MASTERPIECE. My favorite bside by them is DIFFERENT SONG FOR ME. I love that song so much. I cried with that song.
full transparency, i occasionally skip some parts in your vids when you react to multiple groups and i remember skipping your reaction to p1harmony in a vid a little while back (i was aiming for a specific group reaction at the time lol so give me some grace) and I HATE I DID THAT. BUT because of your reactions to them, i have become a fan😭like deadass i have not felt this way about a group in a hot minute 😭😭
you asked who produced black hole and i'm pretty sure the duo moonshine was apart of it. they've produced for so many kpop artists but you'd probably recognize their sound from some superm tracks (infinity, monster, super car, tiger inside) and nct dream (we go up, hello future, hot sauce, etc.). moonshine never misses! piwon works so well with them on this song.
What I like from this album is it showcase vocal line's ability and colors a lot. Like they take turns doing the same parts which are usually done by the main vocal only. With that, it's safe to say P1harmony got 3 main vocals. The the repeated 'gimme that' in Black Hole 'nanana' chorus is also Soul. I forgot if I ever wrote this under your comment section, but I consider Soul as sub vocalist bc his voice often be in the background or layered with other's. And I just know he's okay and comfortable with what he's got right now.
I actually dont really like the fact that your are checking the lyrics after listening to the song but i am happy that you are evoluating with your channel and you look even happier after your break. I absolutely love that you are checking p1harmony. They are one of my ult and they deserve much better
Understandable but honestly as someone reacting to the music I had a lot more fun with it this way. I also liked editing it more this way. I know some people aren’t gonna like my change but honestly I like the format better and i can actually focus better but I know I can’t please everyone.
@@caitlinbensonn its okay to me ! Just do what your are more comfortable with im sorry if i was mean it was not my goal. You are the priority and its your channel you can do whatever you want !
Me, listening to her say "Keeho's voice on Swagger has a lot of soul and he sounds so good", knowing she hasn't listened to Mirror, Mirror yet.... LMAO
I've stanned P1Harmony since Scared Era and this is by far my favorite album 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 its just *chef's kiss🤌🏽🤌🏽🤌🏽 I love watching them grow and evolve musically.
i waited for this the whole week aaa it was worth it. ure my fave piwon reactor now fr ur vibe is just it, the vibe piwon deserves💯 cant wait for ur future reactions to their other albums ❣I agree jongseob has to sit down for a bit he's being too much🤣🤣
The Friday pick-me-up I needed!!!! Thank you, Caitlin! First off I wanted to say I am here for whatever you do, but I really love your new format for album reactions! I like reading the lyrics and having a little analysis after each song- great idea! Second, I 100% agree with you in regards to this rap line.... like you, I listen to a lot of kpop and in my opinion P1 has one of the most formidable rap lines I’ve seen in a looong time. Then you add this vocal line?!?? Like how is this group real we are so lucky 😭 Last thing.... when you mentioned live stages 💀 you are not ready for Black Hole live, my soul straight up left my body. I thought I’d be okay because I had already heard the song, but I was very very wrong 😅 Thank you again for a great reaction! ❤️
I´m happy you´re editing the videos more like you used to at the beginning, like having fun while putting all the effects and distorting your voice. I always thought it was great and hilarious. Actually I´m happy as long as you feel good doing this content. You are awesome💜
It's so fun to see you get into p1harmony and I was totally vibing with you through this whole reaction! And of course you can do the videos just the way you want to. You do you! I personally loved this video! If you have enough time and want to get to know p1h more I recommend watching their own introduction videos that are on their youtube channel. They are from the time of their debut but I find them so helpful to get to know their personalities. Plus those videos were the ones that convinced me to stan them ;) Thanks
You have no idea how happy it makes me to see you react to p1h like this, the new album is so insane THEY OWN MY HEART, DIFFERENT SONG FOR ME, I CANNOT- 😭💜💜
Finding Keeho as bias is a good thing you did cz he's in my bias list & his savage things i like the most cz it reminds me of his bestie Kevin from tbz cz like they seem like the same personality typo person on the way they interact with fans most kinda brother from different mother vibes they give to me😄 & one more surprising fact is JACOB & keeho went to the same vocal academy in Toronto😄
So Intak choreographed his dance part and rap in black hole but this group every single one is a ACE they are my ults for a reason and it easy to see why I love watching you fall in love with them my heart swells with pride very p1ece made:) welcome;)
I discovered you because of your lengthy reaction to them before your break and man the way I love how you were floored by Jiung but was high because of Keeho. Our Libra babies. Love how you're getting deeper the rabbit hole. See you in the -nth level. There's no going back now ^^
i wouldnt know album review reaction videos can be this fun i loooove it!! thank you for making reaction videos for p1harmony and reacting their skipless album (of the year)
if i’m honest i do prefer the old layout because i really can’t differentiate voices and seeing the lyrics videos (although they’re wrong a lot) on screen helped me follow along- BUT- your channel shouldn’t be dictated only by other people’s thoughts, it should be run in a way that you enjoy. so if this is something that you prefer then by all means continue with it! it’s your channel and your reactions, whatever helps you enjoy them the most is what you should do imo!! futhermore i really enjoyed this reaction!! i’m also just getting into p1harmony and you always point out things in the production that i didn’t even notice which makes it more enjoyable for me when i listen again haha! thanks for this lovely video 💕
I loved your album reaction (as per usual) and I'm so glad you see the talent in our boys!! Also you're saying Jiung right and its In-tak (think taki) plus Jong-so-b (bah sound). And I've missed you so much, I hope you enjoyed your break!!
Thank you for reacting to p1harmony! 💕💕💕 I also stanned them super fast 😭 like in the span of three days I love the new way your doing it (regardless) because I do it that way too, I remember reading the lyrics to Before The Dawn a bside to their last album and I cried so hard
omg I was waiting for you to react to this album because it's just soo good! I really wanted to hear what you think about it because I LOVE your reactions so much!! P.S. Change is good, we grow when we make changes so I'm really happy that you want to experiment with different reaction videos styles! Sending lots of love
ok but im so into the new format 🤍 i loved it before but i totally bc feel more related to this one bc honestly it’s how i do my first listening so i kinda vibe with this, and girl lmaooo the whole editing 😂 feels like i’m in my room listening to music with a bestie lol, i really really really appreciate all your hard work but especially the way you challenge yourself and try new things out of your comfort zone, it’s so inspiring and it shows how much you care about the content you’re creating and obviously the way you care about us, thank u cait ❤️ love u!
Jongseob started his rap when he's 11 and become the winner of kpopstar 6 and then join a some company. unfortunately he didn't get to debut.. But,, im so happy bcs he debuted with p1harmony, the group with full of talented kid.. and their chemy r crazy.. , he is insane, p1harmony r insane.. genius kid 😊
Ma'am!! you were so right, after this album I watched their variety content your P1Harmony marathon. I was dropkicked since the first song and Gotta get back had me in a chokehold by the chorus. I had no more space for any new groups and here we are! somehow they already one of my ult groups right next to Monsta X, Seventeen and The Boyz. I hate you so much and I cant thank you enough😂😂 Edit: I just heard That's it in the reaction and it drove me absolutely feral. But when I tell you I lost my mind during that's it, I was evaluating the whole K-pop industry to see who had a better discography. Also They sold over 100k in their first week for this album! Not surprised in the slightest.
I personally really like this new way of reviewing albums! it just make sense cause this is how i normally listen to albums, first listen and then lyrics 😄
i must confess i am in a great shock that you solved them and what they are trying to do in the album without knowing anything about them and their storyline. like you easily spotted the connection between the songs. this is not their first doing btw they have been doing this for every album. as they always say, each songs, including their fully self written composed songs, have connection one and another with having great messages.
P1harmony has their own self introductions on their channel, but here’s a 1 hour helpful guide to them ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-9FnzelefOXM.html you could pick which you prefer
I LOVE the new way you make album reactions, cuz I get what you mean when you say it got boring❤️It also kinda makes me enjoy the music a little more. The only thing I would have liked was if you showed the lyric video that you were watching too, but like maybe just who is singing, cuz I get a little confused with the different voices, but I really like how you don't show the lyrics in the first listen and then break it down afterwards😍😍❤️❤️
I've been meaning to listen to them more, they and Purple Kiss are two groups that I am finally getting around to listening to after getting to know them on ReacttotheK content - they both did the classical music edition quiz thingie ( P1Harmony version here if anyone wants to enjoy, they are so charming ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-Q2xCfmCe4Zo.html), and I just love those so much. So anyway, thanks for this whole reaction so I can get into it for real.
I was thinking as you are checking the lyric videos by yourself if you don't mind placing them in the bottom corner or somewhere cause I usually listen to the album first time with you so seeing who is singing what really helps. If it's not possible then it's fine I like this new format also and the lyrics analysis is a great addition.
Not someone asking you why you listen to the highligh medley... even if it "spoils" it, it truly can't prepare you for how insane every single song on this album is. I don't think it spoils anything at all.
pretty sure p1harmony don’t have official positions (like main, lead etc.) but imo Theo: main vocal Keeho: main vocal, sub rapper Jiung: lead vocal, lead rapper, lead dancer. (main slayer/all rounder) intak: main rapper, main dancer soul: main dancer, sub vocal, sub rapper jongseob: main rapper, sub vocal
Intak is pronouced: In-Tak like taki the chip instead of In-Tac like tic tacs Theo name is pronouced: like tay-o in korean but the way you pronouce it is still fine i hope that hepls thats the easiest way i can explain it lol You pronouced both keeho and jiung's name correctly tho along with jongseob and soul :)
Love P1harmony , 3 mts that I know them seems very long cos their music is so good I spent just 1-2days consumed all from their debut time. I remember all names real quick Keeho Theo Soul Intak Jongseob and … My man also Jiung competence ACE with cute look crazy personality and talented in all dimensions. I watched P1H movie,They r such a good actor esp. Theo…while Jiung and keeho r so funny. I love my life stan Piwon they r so up lifting artists.
Can you react to their other covers they are soooo good (good for you by olivia rodrigo, at my worst by pinksweat ) and also their b sides like reset, if you call me(which they wrote themselves), nemonade, pyramid and that's money. They also have dance covers. To learn more about their personalities you can watch their shows sassaek harmony and harmony forest . They are sooo funny
