This tool will help improve your critical thinking - Erick Wilberding

Подписаться 20 млн

Просмотров 6 млн

50% 1

Explore the technique known as the Socratic Method, which uses questions to examine a person’s values, principles, and beliefs.
--
Socrates, one of the founding fathers of Western philosophical thought, was on trial. Many believed he was an enemy of the state, accusing the philosopher of corrupting the youth and refusing to recognize their gods. But Socrates wasn’t feared for claiming to have all the answers, but rather, for asking too many questions. Erick Wilberding digs into the technique known as the Socratic Method.
Lesson by Erick Wilberding, directed by Draško Ivezić.
Support Our Non-Profit Mission
----------------------------------------------
Support us on Patreon: bit.ly/TEDEdPatreon
Check out our merch: bit.ly/TEDEDShop
----------------------------------------------
Connect With Us
----------------------------------------------
Sign up for our newsletter: bit.ly/TEDEdNewsletter
Follow us on Facebook: bit.ly/TEDEdFacebook
Find us on Twitter: bit.ly/TEDEdTwitter
Peep us on Instagram: bit.ly/TEDEdInstagram
----------------------------------------------
Keep Learning
----------------------------------------------
View full lesson: ed.ted.com/lessons/this-tool-...
Dig deeper with additional resources: ed.ted.com/lessons/this-tool-...
Animator's website: adriaticanimation.hr/
----------------------------------------------
Thank you so much to our patrons for your support! Without you this video would not be possible! Amaury BISIAUX, sarim haq, Jay M, Constantino Victor Delgado, Andrea Galvagni, Andrew Tweddle, Laurel-Ann Rice, Fernando A. Endo, Courtney Marcott, Anna-Alicia Brooks, Mustafa, Helen Lee, pam morgan, Juan Pablo Rodriguez Morales, ANNE FINE, Gerardo Castro, Siddharth Toshniwal, Justice Boehmer, Michel-Ange Hortegat, Enes Kirimi, Aravind C V, ND, Samyogita Hardikar, Vanessa Graulich, Vandana Gunwani, LvL042, Abdulmohsin Almadi, Andrew Brodski, John van den Berg, Anandha Krishnan, Geoffrey Bultitude, Mi Mi, Thomas Rothert, Christopher McVay, Izhari Ishak Aksa, Declan Manning, Javier Aldavaz, Ivan Yeung, Jaime Camacho, Irene Au, Роман Валесюк, LunarQueen, Iza, Brian Elieson, Paul, Grayson Garbarino, Oge O, Weronika Falkowska, Stefano Esposito and Nevin Spoljaric.

Опубликовано:

11 апр 2021

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 2,8 тыс.

@m1kyll4 3 года назад

The most powerful way to win an argument is by asking questions. It can make people see the flaws in their logic.

@arrietty1619 3 года назад

Why? Jk

@VaughanMcCue 3 года назад

I found religarse interlocutors too dishonest and spew up obfuscations, such as my most recent experience had the turkey grasping at dogma because thinking was anathema. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-UOHMg7IkzHU.html

@DudewithaGoodMood 2 года назад

Not always

@shishi6799 2 года назад

However, if their mind is closed, they will refuse to see any flaws in their own logic.

@TeKeyaKrystal 2 года назад

true .. except for with me b/c my tail will come up with an answer for everything

@cyanidepopcorn0107 3 года назад

Nobody in ancient Greece: Socrates:"WHY?"

@manofgod7622 3 года назад

How did this commend get hearted wtg

@gokuldevin 3 года назад

@@manofgod7622 jealous much?

@josiahtron8673 3 года назад

I can hear this comment😭😭

@AndreaTheSin 3 года назад

@@manofgod7622 trending meme

@tinienteabanil2922 3 года назад

"Tell me why"

@shimpiyaa 3 года назад

Socrates : why? Socrates' mom : BECAUSE I SAID SO.

@ariel7301 2 года назад

This might be the funniest comment here 😂😂😂😂

@crybaby4525 2 года назад

@rice cooker 😂

@muledhumichael5093 2 года назад

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

@spongelob6872 2 года назад

@rice cooker But his mother is...

@user-rc2gy5ik5n 2 года назад

@rice cooker it doesn't matter, that's how our Greek mams answer too .

@EternalSilverDragon 2 года назад

I tried to use this with my dad. His critical thinking didn't go up, only his volume.

@actionlockermuscle5158 2 года назад

lol

@ngwanankgudipercy9766 Год назад

😂😂

@Dontgetyongbo33d 8 месяцев назад

💀

@spicytank262 8 месяцев назад

Lmfao

@PSR_Macky 7 месяцев назад

😂

@gardenhead92 3 года назад

The Socratic method isn’t for proving that you have the answer - it’s to show the other person that they don’t either

@daniellewardd 3 года назад

As the video said, the method is to bring to the surface the person’s assumptions, biases etc as well

@_kopcsi_ 3 года назад

no. the Socratic method can lead to the answer. you simply didn't understand it.

@alex2005z 3 года назад

@@_kopcsi_ how does it lean to the answer?

@valesnts 3 года назад

@@alex2005z i think it gives answer because it makes people think thoroughly of the questions, what process it might have (hypothesis) and eventually understand whether the question was the ultimate curiosity or is there another thing that needs to be found out first. I think socratic method is both, providing answers and more following questions. But either way, it makes the person thinks instead of just accepting direct answer (which some people simply won't understand and also not caring for the process).

@alex2005z 3 года назад

@@valesnts how does it make people think troroughly questions?

@bruhmoment1271 3 года назад

"We can make anything a quote by putting them into quotation marks" -My critical thinking

@ItsDeveloper_ 3 года назад

Here before 50 likes

@alex2005z 3 года назад

All the fake Sun Tzu quotes be like:

@onlyerr 3 года назад

"Yesn't" - Sun Tzu

@abhishekanand5974 3 года назад

exactly!

@deepblue1987 3 года назад

”insert dramatic quote here” -Famous Person

@shyeannegunn4514 2 года назад

I'm a medical student, and I just realised that a lot of my lecturers use this method when teaching us. I've had really bad ones who completely shut down every answer if it's not the "right" one, and make you feel absolutely useless. And thankfully had really good ones, who made you question why is this method used, why not the other, and these lecturers even admit that there is no one right answer to a problem.

@actionlockermuscle5158 2 года назад

Just do take it in , plenty of time to challenge assumptions when you qualified

@samgerney7213 Год назад

Most people are taught that "you only need a good job to become rich". These billionaires are operating on a whole other playbook that many don't even know exists.

@michealdouglas8206 Год назад

No one is stopping you from having brilliant ideas and starting a company

@christophercook7170 Год назад

@@michealdouglas8206 most billionaires have family that are extremely wealthy and their children, who have done nothing to earn that money apart from being born. Essentially they are hording wealth and their not being taxed appropriately. It's extremely unlikely you'll become a billionaire from a good idea this is evident in the population of billionaires in comparison to normal people. The American dream isn't real and it never was.

@cassyhard7436 Год назад

@@christophercook7170 yeah just that I can't get a millionaire loan from my dad like Jeff bezos, or my family can't afford to pay harvard like Bill Gates family

@julietrings8104 Год назад

@@cassyhard7436Successful people don't become that way overnight. What most people see at a glance-wealth, a great career, purpose-is the result of hard work and hustle over time.

@poltykelsey4890 Год назад

@@julietrings8104 Yeah! I agree with you sir.If you want to be successful have the mindset of the rich, spend less and invest More. Don't give up your dreams.

@muhammadrizkyst85 3 года назад

Bruh... I always thought that i was asking too much questions. But now I realize that that's a gift. I won't be afraid to ask anymore.

@chainjail4834 3 года назад

I feel like Socrates was sentence to death because he was asking too many questions and being annoying lol

@pimpilikaa 3 года назад

@@chainjail4834 lol

@ohven2923 3 года назад

@@chainjail4834 How was Socrates being annoying? Was asking questions annoying? If so then how? Would you sentence someone by being annoying? Or would you sentence someone because he/she was asking too many questions? Or would you sentence them because they were asking too many questions AND being annoying? If so then why?

@muhammadrizkyst85 3 года назад

@@ohven2923 there was even a time when people actually hate someone who can read lol. The reason is "culture". Different time different culture. Strange, but that's history.

@ane9898 3 года назад

Asking questions are actually signs of smart people. Yet, I was bullied back in school when I asked a lot 🤣🤌🏻

@riunosk 3 года назад

gaining brain cells every time ted ed uploads

@AaronChristopher869 3 года назад

I love Ted Ed

@fathfez7991 3 года назад

Also erasing the remaining annoying tiktok shits

@benjaminhawkins6386 3 года назад

After some proper education, you will learn that central nervous system neurons are not created after childhood. If you are gaining brain cells, they are mostly glial cells. You should be leery of all information. Ted has strong biases. They have fantastic production quality, but ought to be supplemented with your own research and a healthy helping of caution.

@rehan4223 3 года назад

@@benjaminhawkins6386 ???

@shreeyamittal1771 3 года назад

@@benjaminhawkins6386 I wanted to say that, but simply 'that ain't possible' might have given the wrong message.

@sirreginaldfishingtonxvii6149 2 года назад

Honestly feels like we need more of this. Both in schools and just in society in general.

@ayyysample5058 2 года назад

I actually took a critical thinking class in university last year and at first the questions seemed like common sense until I got my results back 💀

@ronkirk5099 3 года назад

Critical thinking is probably one of the most important life skills a person needs to learn, but it seems to be in short supply of late.

@peterlohnes1 3 года назад

it is not even considered, everyone is 100% certain they have the right answers. The education system is failing

@nikouai 3 года назад

@@peterlohnes1 it is failing the society in general. But maybe the people who create the laws and education systems, etc in most countries don't think it's a failure? :)

@The_unexplained 3 года назад

Yeah, clearly. Those who raise questions against vaccines are called anti vaxxer🤦‍♂️

@dnhdfnfkrjxjxfjjggj3002 3 года назад

@@The_unexplained and those who raise questions against these anti-vaxxers are termed brainwashed masses🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️

@The_unexplained 3 года назад

@@dnhdfnfkrjxjxfjjggj3002 Well, our questions are not answered and our proofs clearly destroys the people who support vaccine's narrative but still they believe vaccines are safe. What should we call them?

@chrisklugh 3 года назад

The Ego is threatened by questions it does not know, so it attacks the messenger. Enough bruised Egos and a Witch Hunt will be called out for. Because the only way to settle an Ego is to destroy what threatens it.

@kroolini3678 3 года назад

cancel culture in a nutshell

@rowanbrown5541 3 года назад

@@kroolini3678 That's not remotely the same line of reasoning. Unless cancel culture means something very different to you

@rowanbrown5541 3 года назад

Exactly what happens when you question anti-vaxxers logic

@barkinkarakas9500 3 года назад

@@kroolini3678 I don't really understand what do you mean. What is cancel culture?

@barkinkarakas9500 3 года назад

@@rowanbrown5541 did you even watch the video???

@djayjp 2 года назад

One key aspect of this method that, unfortunately, isn't mentioned in the video is that it gets the other person to reach their own conclusion which can be much more effective in getting them to believe it rather than being opposed to an idea simply because it is explicitly stated to them, in lecture form, by another.

@illyk6450 2 года назад

Might I add: don't wait for someone else to ask you questions about why you believe something. Ask yourself where it's coming from first, no matter what it is you believe, no matter how uncomfortable it may be to question it. You cannot effectively defend your belief from someone else unless you are able to defend it from yourself. "I believe this." "Why do I believe this?" "Because X." "But why X?" "Because Y." "But where did Y come from?" Etc, etc, until you reach the core of it. Or you find a dead end, or it starts to circle. A belief should not defend itself using itself. A belief should stand like a tower, with a clear line of logic based on something that cannot be shaken. Utilizing this method is a very good way to quickly gain a better understanding of yourself and the world around you.

@muhammadizzuddin5154 Год назад

I asked myself things like this when I’m high on weed 😭

@ankitatantuway9733 Год назад

thankyou for this clear advice.I note this in my diary🤍

@username_ee 7 дней назад

Well written.

@eeshakabra6857 3 года назад

I love how at 4:10 the narrator specifically points out that its success is very dependant on how the teacher uses the technique and that's actually very true. If teachers themselves dissuade you from asking too many questions there's a good chance that you would start restricting your curiosity. I know it can be annoying in a class of 20-30 students for each one to ask so many questions. But instead of flat out stopping a child from asking it can be redirected at the least if nott answered immediately. That's solely my pov though

@dumbdoggie21 3 года назад

I personally feel like the whole system should be improvised

@charlietran7712 3 года назад

What solution would u propose to redirect questions considering their time with every student is limited?

@schnitzelberry 2 года назад

Exactly what I keep telling people!! I'm a freshman and since I was born, I've always been an extremely curious person and I can't resist an intellectual challenge but the private Authoritarian like religious schools I went to (one that I also got expelled from) strictly prohibited all that and it just makes me so frustrated. Like how on earth can I take them seriously if they can't admit that as people, we don't have all the answers? And how will an ancient book answer all our problems? So many contradictions and flawed logic, how can there be any reasoning?

@schnitzelberry 2 года назад

@@dumbdoggie21 Improvised? That's not nearly what we need. We need to revolutionize the system as a whole in an effort to prioritize critical thinking skills. If not total revolution, what?

@schnitzelberry 2 года назад

@@charlietran7712 Maybe we can set one period of the day for learning, while the students write their questions and insights and the second period for discussion, and upon that review will follow. What's your opinion?

@valentine3725 3 года назад

"Don't believe everything you read on the internet." -Socrates (circa. 1569, Australia)

@hstacker93 3 года назад

The country or continent? 😂

@sambz7705 3 года назад

It is weird but Apparently it's both

@AttilaAsztalos 3 года назад

"Don't believe everything you read on the internet" - Abraham Lincoln ...fact check your sources, man...

@totalme302 3 года назад

Why? - Socrates

@marcopohl4875 3 года назад

but why would I do that?

@raenashaikh3377 2 года назад

This logic still holds true tremendously and is proved again and again thru methodological psychological studies. I recently read an article on how to talk to an irrationally rigid person out of a rigid opinion. And that was by asking him critical questions back on what he claims to be the answers instead of telling him what you think is the answer.

@samikshamalhotra1537 6 месяцев назад

Could you please provide the link for the article..seems like an interesting read

@overcookedwater1947 3 года назад

I'm sure I have a Socrates in my head because everytime I think if something my brain would start to question with Why's and How's. Often to the point that I start question life and reality itself that it often feels maddening. It also keeps me up at night

@overcookedwater1947 3 года назад

The question are often similar to that one with the "Just and Unjust" conversation

@xogirlbossxo2316 2 года назад

Bro you hella smart

@overcookedwater1947 2 года назад

My grades beg to differ

@overcookedwater1947 2 года назад

Besides the things that keep me up at night are just avou petty stuff. Small and insignificant. Think of it like overthinking every decision

@overcookedwater1947 2 года назад

*about

@krishagohil1780 3 года назад

I burst out when Socrates actually started acting like a midwife at the mention of being one xDDDDDdD breathe, breathe, breathe, push, push, push.

@Ratigan2 3 года назад

the animations are always so unique and quirky with creativity :)

@Uyhn26 3 года назад

LOL YESSS

@dream.5708 3 года назад

Lmaoo samee

@anonme_ 3 года назад

Another Krisha spotted. Hello there!

@krishagohil1780 3 года назад

@@anonme_ oh hello

@mapperid 3 года назад

judges: Socrates you are sentenced to death socrates: Why I must die? judges: You create a radical logic? socrates: what is logic? what is radical? Am I enemy to you? what if i am your best friend? will you still consider me a radical? judges: ...... here we go again

@kellyortiz367 3 года назад

👌🏼🤣🤣🤣💀

@An_anshika710 3 года назад

Haha he must have asked 🤣

@shantanu9404 3 года назад

Judges: well logic is reasoning conducted or assessed according to strict principles of validity. You're neither our enemy nor our friend. You might be the enemy of the state. And yes we still consider you to be radical. And one more thing, yuh guilty.

@zainabhaider2479 3 года назад

socrates: It is not possible for me to create anything, for me to create something, I would have to be a demiruge imposing logic, reason and order. How can the imposition of such be radical?

@nicolegunayanaying7329 3 года назад

judges: We are the judges. We determine whether you're radical or not, so cut the cackle. Moreover, you are more capable of doing anything. And well, based on the facts provided and in accordance with the law, you shall drink the executioner's cup of poisonous hemlock.

@mallelasaicharan6257 Год назад

I always follow this question orientated approach in my studies and life . I ask questions most of the times than answers.

@sle2470 2 года назад

Critical Thinking is an essential skill that should be taught to kids as early as possible. It should be right up there with reading, writing and math.

@elvinamadodefrancis4745 Год назад

That subject would probably be my second favorite subject behind social studies.

@AmberAmber 9 месяцев назад

Agreed! I'm just sad that Parochial school (nvm the c‧ptsd from *all that* ) ‧ an inherently faulty education for any youth (especially those with intellectual curiosity who want truth) ‧ ensured I didn't know *any of this* ‧ Critical Thinking Skills, The Soccratic Method, Logical Fallacies ‧ existed as subjects ‧ not 'til internet. I'm sad about disinfo grifters ‧ but ℅ critical thinking skills, I'm more skeptical, & thus more effective in my acquisition of post‧secondary‧ed.❤❤❤❤

@AmberAmber 9 месяцев назад

@@elvinamadodefrancis4745 Same!!! Except I also throw hard science in as equally fascinating & complementary to the humanities now too!❤

@weiner01103 5 месяцев назад

unfortunately, this cant happen because "you have to obey your elders" or "religion told you to do this, so you have to do it, no questioning allowed"

@Some1inFNQ 4 месяца назад

it was taught as a part of reading when I went to school. High school English class, we first looked at the difference between a primary and a secondary source, then we did a lesson on reading for an author's bias, how to identify said bias, and how to balance it with further research from more secondary and contemporary secondary sources. And then we went into critical thinking, to guide the formation of our questions giving thought to our own bias, and how to overcome it. I was taught having the academic discipline to apply intellectual honesty to your own work has been the foundation of all human advancement. I wasn't taught what to think, I was taught how to ask intelligent questions and how to dismantle lies. I was very, very lucky.

@shinobix4925 3 года назад

"An effective Socratic educator must be well versed in their subject. Rather than bullying their students or showing off their superior intellect, they should be modest, genuinely curious and affirming of every contribution.”

@hrsh042 2 года назад

Why do you rephrase it, If I may ask?

@JigiHendrix 2 года назад

@@hrsh042 Prime example of " Louder for the people in the back "

@dickharry910 Год назад

Why?

@silencedowellii7872 Месяц назад

This would be a very good viewpoint, but we don't live in an ideal world, don't we?

@simranmalhotra7364 3 года назад

I want Socrates to be my friend. The conversations would be more enlightening than my 12 years of education...

@schnitzelberry 2 года назад

We need more people like that today. People need to stop seeing arguments as a bad thing and rid away boring small talk

@lx4302 2 года назад

"Can I be your friend, Socrates?" "What is a friend? What is considered a friend? Why do we need to declare friendship? Why is it morally right to be a friend?"

@rosedawn8046 2 года назад

You need 12 years of education to just understand his basic thinking and the capacity to broaden your mind. Basic 12 years of education is the foundation for you to study beyond. However it’s also wrong to assume that people need only that. It’s like rice. You need other dishes to complete the meal but rice is the staple

@Neptunedx 2 года назад

Hello I am Socrate

@simranmalhotra7364 2 года назад

@@Neptunedx I would prefer the Greek one!! 😉😉

@arcie3716 Год назад

Oh, so when Socrates constantly asks questions, he is a philosopher but when I do, I am annoying 🙄

@raphaeldouglas9361 2 года назад

Successful people don't become that way overnight. What most people see at a glance-wealth, a great career, purpose-is the result of hard work and hustle over time.

@prosperotos889 2 года назад

Yeah! I agree with you sir.

@prosperotos889 2 года назад

If you want to be successful have the mindset of the rich, spend less and invest More. Don't give up your dreams.

@christophercook7170 2 года назад

@@prosperotos889 People come here with the aim of chasing money more than knowledge and that will damage your progress, trust me. Chase knowledge first and I promise! The money will follow you just like it's following some of us now.

@agathaherry3571 2 года назад

@@christophercook7170 That's very correct sir!! And that is why most of them end up losing they money to scammers.

@sarahthompsons5843 2 года назад

@@agathaherry3571 Don't be in a haste to invest. Know what and who you are investing to and be sure that the person will deliver before investing.

@dannagonetofar7352 3 года назад

4:12 My teachers: I pretended not to have heard that.

@user-mq3yz1ij2o 3 года назад

"Our" teachers

@triscuit4000 3 года назад

Agreed. I have also had so many teachers who were bullies and narcissists. They were convinced they were doing the "right" thing, too.

@dzanegulles 3 года назад

Ughh same

@tuode721 3 года назад

totally agreed(´；ω；｀)

@felougabular2652 3 года назад

@@user-mq3yz1ij2o true i too have extreme left and extreme right teachers, kinda hard to argue with both extremes.

@waleedkhalid7486 3 года назад

I often use this with my biology students to get them to learn how to design and interpret experiments. It’s difficult for them to wrap their heads around at first because the vast majority of schooling relies on memorization, not understanding. I aim to help my students break down biases in experimentation and help them think in a way that can assist them even in normal life. By the end of the semester, there are usually a few who begin to understand. It’s always satisfying to know I’ve trained students who will go on to think about things based on logic.

@djayjp 2 года назад

The difference between a lab assistant and a true scientist.

@arafreshad 2 года назад

As a biology student myself, that's awesome to hear!

@ayeshakhalid44 2 года назад

hats off!

@djayjp 2 года назад

@Kaen It's just an old book with zero supporting evidence. I could write stuff in a book too. Does that make it true? There are millions of stories that have been circulated throughout history--does that mean they're true too? The degree of one's conviction ought to always be proportionate to the degree of objective, verifiable evidence supporting the claim in question. Question and you will reach something even more sacred than faith: truth.

@djayjp 2 года назад

@Kaen Nobody possesses absolute truth: only evidence can yield that (in a limited way: in degrees, other than self reflexive logic). Evidence, by definition, isn't something that can be written down. Everyday thousands of people claim to experience something supernatural, for thousands of years, yet no evidence is ever provided or obtainable.... You must believe in Santa Claus too.

@blaisemarak 2 года назад

Socrates lived like some many thousands of years ago. He thought of many things which our thick headed society still doesn't have the brains to think of even today . The dude is truly something .

@beastman.330 2 года назад

This was shocking. I randomly clicked this all droopy and chilled and all of a sudden my mind just opened with the few words you have spoken, like I was 21 year-old.

@shubhajoshi9505 3 года назад

I would love to have a conversation with Socrates about morality and life

@YashSharma-wu7kr 3 года назад

Kyon?

@rehan4223 3 года назад

@@YashSharma-wu7kr kyuki banda bohot intellectual tha

@raccoon2276 3 года назад

hes busy right now come back later

@oussamanhairech5178 3 года назад

you can play assassin's creed odyssey, you will meet him at some point

@tahah.babikir7698 3 года назад

You can still find people like socartes... consider starting a socratic school...

@ChipmunkRapidsMadMan1869 3 года назад

The height of wisdom is to understand that education illustrates the depth and breadth of one’s ignorance.

@Mrfallouthero 3 года назад

"Knowing more let's you know little you know"

@Vugen18 2 года назад

This is pure knowledge. Thanks so much, i hope u know how important and how much this helps others!

@cjp5690 2 года назад

This is absolutely stunning to me. I always do this with everyone i know my whole life. I always downed myself for it. Wow...just wow

@oyfum2638 3 года назад

U know, Socrates feels like that one guy u can just talk for hours with without end. Wonder what a podcast with Socrates would look like? (If, u know, he were still alive)

@vas2.1025 3 года назад

may be it would be him going,"hum uhum humuhumuunn huhhuhuhuh hhh huhamna gbhjbakbgahavvkcahcjagkhgvcahmch ba jmcvjabchalejgckaeejs" as shown in the video XD

@limemime565 3 года назад

Can't wait for the next Joe Rogan podcast with Socrates

@tatleman5314 3 года назад

Probably a long story about a topic full of questions with a conclusion as "I actually don't know much about this subject".

@iteor7320 3 года назад

It would probably be very long...

@aadikochhar4028 3 года назад

The last slide of the vid shows us a peak of mimic that was originally a painting (could be a reference what socarates would have looked like)

@Axelgear2006 3 года назад

Depicting Plato as a squat dude with muscles to spare. That's some good historical accuracy.

@axelpatrickb.pingol3228 3 года назад

Still cannot believe Aristotle was a wrestler...

@Axelgear2006 3 года назад

@@axelpatrickb.pingol3228 When you have slaves doing all your manual labour for you, you can afford a life of leisurely philosophy discussions while dropping some dude in a supplex at the gym.

@chusty93 3 года назад

Well, Socrates was a soldier in his youth, should make sense

@NDOhioan 3 года назад

@@axelpatrickb.pingol3228 In Ancient Greece, a truly educated man mastered both the mind and the body.

@zlatan4467 3 года назад

Plato was known for his "plateau" Wide shoulders, by the wrestlers.

@WellnessWarriors779 9 месяцев назад

Everything about this video is simply perfect. Thank you.

@mimosapudica9742 Год назад

as someone who keeps on asking questions, i was always made fun of and even thought of as weird by my workmates. it nearly affected my self esteem, but after learning about Socrates, somehow i don't feel bad about myself anymore. i've come to embrace myself.

@wishicat4298 3 года назад

I used that on my classmates and i found out that most of them are flexible thinkers and i unleashed their critical thinking

@gjahmato8704 3 года назад

Why ?

@airshipflea5219 3 года назад

@@gjahmato8704 LMAO

@arcxena_ 3 года назад

@@gjahmato8704 oh you

@wishicat4298 3 года назад

@@gjahmato8704 ok i asked them what subject are they confident then i asked them of various problems that will bend their answers

@ilikemonkeys5653 3 года назад

@@wishicat4298 why?

@ChipmunkRapidsMadMan1869 3 года назад

“An effective Socratic well versed in their subject. An educator should be modest, genuinely curious and not bully students into their way of thinking” (I am paraphrasing). well we are in a significant shortage of those these days.

@alex2005z 3 года назад

Unfortunately

@MWhaleK 3 года назад

Which Socrates him self wasn't as in real life he seems to have been filed with false humility and largely wanted to make him self look good by making others look bad. At least that is what I came to understand after reading I.F. Stone's book on Socrates. It also helps to look at some of his most famous students like Critias "the first Robespierre".

@pgchris87 3 года назад

@@MWhaleK If you are going to read something, read the original text or a direct translation even, not a biased interpretation of the original. just a suggestion..

@billqiu4692 3 года назад

One part you left out was "affirming of every contribution"

@inamullahsajid1206 2 года назад

very well explained.

@ghadeerdr2352 Год назад

I wrote the whole script in regard to study it to improve my English skills and knowledge and i have to admit that it was really hard and rich with good vocabulary and expressions ❤️

@gregwall6553 3 года назад

Thank you Mr, Hughes, world history teacher, Canyon High School 1976-1977.... Canyon Texas...

@niranjanr8075 3 года назад

Thought I already had a tool for critical thinking “Ted Ed” 💕 Edit: Btw just to clarify: Socrates did not oppose democracy, he reasoned that everyone getting a vote when they have no social responsibility or social awareness is dangerous. He reasoned this with a scenario to another leading thinker of his time. He later reasoned that the present structure is not democracy but demagogue. He loved the idea of democracy but to give the right to vote to anyone and everyone who don’t even care just for the sake of it, was something he was against. And we are experiencing it’s effects aren’t we?

@aanchaljain5297 3 года назад

Yea unfortunately ..we're facing it's effect...Indian elections OP

@demodema5192 3 года назад

Yes but then again if only some people are allowed to vote for e.g. those that want to vote are allowed to vote after registering for the vote prior everytime. This will make sure people actively register to vote and then vote. So now only people who are ready to register very time and then vote will do it but then that may only leave a party and members as majority of voters. There by not being a effective democracy?

@CraftyF0X 3 года назад

And this criticism of his stands correct till this day, all of these ponits are valid concerns against democracy.

@abhishek.rathore 3 года назад

@@demodema5192 One thing which is very wrongly executed in modern democracy is the concept of political parties. Democracy was meant to be a rule by people. But having parties makes it all non-democratic again. Imagine a party with a leader where all the members of the party follow the leader (sounds familiar? Caz it is), all those says thousands of people are just following one idea instead of representing their own and eventually coming up with better ones. Like isnt that just like dictatorship with multiple dictators choosing who gets to rule on the popularity basis. Like isnt democracy means ruling the country together by a bunch of people who are chosen by the country itself. I may not have been very clear here but I guess someone will understand what I mean here.

@latiie 3 года назад

But how would the government know who are the "right people" to vote??

@preetinair3447 3 года назад

We need more Socrates in our society in general. "An educator should be modest"- some of them are, but "be genuinely curious"- hard to find such educators these days...

@pahlevidewa226 2 года назад

I'm glad I'm not the only person who often Answer the question with questions Sometimes if you found someone deadly wrong about something, It's better to not tell them "You are wrong" right away.. But ask them "Why it is right?" And forced them to think and realize they are wrong by themselves..

@NicoleBarden-Writer 10 месяцев назад

It is by asking questions that you are able to gain a better understanding of where the person is coming from. As we all experience situations different, it is helpful to learn how others think and come to their response. That is what I try to do with my writings, by telling a story that is designed to make people think and feel. Hopefully they start to examine their life and the actions of others.

@joshu1918 3 года назад

Guards for the trial: hey you can’t exit here Socrates: are you sure about that?

@hstacker93 3 года назад

I heard that’s how Chapo got out

@AttilaAsztalos 3 года назад

I can't? Well, THAT MAKES NO SENSE! *Chewbakka defense deployed - opposition destroyed*

@arunasuresh3174 3 года назад

Thank you Ted-Ed for educating and instilling the best values you can in the future generation! Much appreciated.

@enjybadran7876 3 года назад

I'm a kid & they are installing me from my capsule to build the next generation

@keivenciadouge2565 3 года назад

hands down the best explanation of the Socratic method I have received.

@frogery 2 года назад

critical thinking is possibly the most important skill we need to develop as a society in this age of mass information and distrust. the difficult part will be getting people to let go of their biases and question their own beliefs in order to approach truth.

@hish33p32 3 года назад

"If lying to your troops to boost their morale is just or unjust" i immediately thought of Erwin Smith's charge against the Beast Titan right off the bat

@iamdshiva1388 3 года назад

😂😂

@christi3 3 года назад

honestly same

@gustavorazo3211 3 года назад

Ong 😂

@elenas3571 3 года назад

0:50 “The only witness I enjoy being is a hostile one. That is why I intend to answer every question with a question”

@VarshaManoj 2 года назад

Woah. That was helpful. I was always doubtful whenever I asked a lot of questions during a conversation.

@unclesamzbastardsonu.s.b.s9315 2 года назад

"... even on his deathbed, the philosopher was ever curious about what lay on the other side.." Socrates: "What are you!?!?!" Death: 🤬!!!

@xanderabbey8529 3 года назад

I've actually been using this method throughout my life without knowing the name of this thinking method. It's served me will, I tell you.

@youraveragenanamistan 3 года назад

I love Socrates and how damn smart he was. Great video as always!

@kokosensei5231 25 дней назад

Thank you for share!

@tufailahmed7596 2 года назад

philosophy and psychology are so important that they should be taught as compulsory subjects in school and college

@nattie911 2 года назад

I would add a course on healthy relationships too

@ryanbrachamonte6348 3 года назад

Schools nowadays prefer to teach WHAT to think as opposed to HOW to think. Love these videos 🙏

@urmama54 3 года назад

its always been what...

@controlequebrado4455 3 года назад

That's literally what schools were made to do so...

@gabrielamarino2411 3 года назад

That’s their social role, indoctrination

@Some1inFNQ 4 месяца назад

@@gabrielamarino2411 Not so much if you didn't go to a school where every days starts with young, unformed minds making a pledge to a flag or a god.

@jbpalma2190 3 года назад

Thank you for this, TED-Ed. I'm an educator and I found this insightful!

@lil----lil 2 года назад

"The life of the unexamined is not worth living." This quote is the one that I live by daily. If you look around, this is the reason why we've so many problem in today's world.

@JackPullen-Paradox 8 месяцев назад

The unexamined life is not worth living.

@sitproperlywhilewatchingph423 7 месяцев назад

Then how to examine life? What is the example of examined life ? What are the problems occur if not followed ?

@JackPullen-Paradox 7 месяцев назад

@@sitproperlywhilewatchingph423Good questions. I think the problems are that one would not understand oneself and would suffer a degree of unhappiness because of that; one would not know the Good and therefore, would not do the Good. Socrates thought that everyone would do the right thing if they understood what it was. I suppose to examine a life, one must question like Socrates did every choice of significance in one's life. In other words, apply the Socratic method or something as effective in uncovering falsehood or revealing truth to one's life. Socrates himself and I suppose Plato and Aristotle are examples of people who followed Socrates to a great extent. Alfred Adler, Carl Jung, and Sigmund Freud might be others that we know have studied themselves intensively in an attempt to understand themselves and to root out inconsistencies.

@chillinggrin84 2 года назад

Dammm, very fluid animation, not stiff at all, and perfectly aligned with the material given...

@mithileshs5242 3 года назад

Ted should keep making videos on Greek Philosophy. It's so insightful.

@TheDhammaHub 3 года назад

The mere act of getting asked a question already forces you to think harder about it - the Buddha used a very similar approach in debates of his time!

@rehan4223 3 года назад

No doubt a very true statement indeed

@aditimuthkhod1252 3 года назад

the Buddha A man of culture, I see

@Handle35667 3 года назад

Is that why most people get upset when you ask them a question?

@TheDhammaHub 3 года назад

@@Handle35667 It certainly plays a role ;D But the main part likely is that you question their understanding of something by asking

@Handle35667 3 года назад

@@TheDhammaHub How am I questioning their understanding by asking a question?

@saitama3294 Год назад

I love the animations, super fun! And as always superb informative video.

@mlb_lois 2 года назад

What a nice video to start the day! Thank you :)

@npsea2398 3 года назад

The animation is just soo good

@beyash2151 3 года назад

Lots of love from India❤️🇮🇳

@konan8353 3 года назад

Lots of hate from India 😈🇮🇳

@LeoDas688 2 года назад

Every time I watch Ted video, I learn something new, which change my perspective, thanks for making such video

@guleidhasan816 3 года назад

This bringins my head days I had with my fallow friends we used to come for 4 to 6 people then we'd had discussion about life, politics and educational traps. I don't why but I was often talkative and they were respectful and listen to me then all in suddenly my whole arguments turn negative when I became someone who often see compelling bad or negative issues among those topics then they once GULEID we've listening to you, you said it well but we never hear you putting the solutions I astonished and thought a lot why is that so I decided to quit my whole arguments and become listener so that my arguments shouldn't put bad space me and my friends. But now I got my some hint why am I so.

@syedarushda2108 3 года назад

Happy to hear this narrator's voice again !!! Both Addison Anderson and Jack Cutmore-Scott are the best !!!!

@adammaximus9957 2 года назад

I believe I was Socrates in my past life. I've been doing this my whole life.

@adrianvanleeuwen 26 дней назад

I like that the last scene was based on the famous painting of Socrates. Nicely done video with animation to show your points!

@user-wt7eo5ob8h 2 месяца назад

huge endorsement for this part❤, it’s really helpful🎉 Your logic power wake me up, have a peaceful ☕️😊

@jairosolutan1045 3 года назад

This is why i like watching TedEd Its educational and fun it also helps me study history

@MdHossain-tz6br Год назад

"Wonder is the feeling of a philosopher And Philosophy begins with wonders" Like seriously.....It's really wonderful

@kirremtremmeh6495 8 месяцев назад

More people should realize this thank you!

@nphuocxuandung 2 года назад

I am glad that we have some real interesting conversations in comments here.

@anubhavluitel 2 года назад

Please give recognition and awards to whoever makes these animations for all the TED-Ed videos!

@Neerana7 3 года назад

The narrator voice is so awesome so as the content ❤️

@mahlomolamonene744 11 месяцев назад

Awesome video 🎉

@vietvu1490 3 года назад

I have been using this method without knowing its name. But I agree, not many people apprecieate it; also not everytime I stayed calm and focus only on solving the problem.

@chainjail4834 3 года назад

I'm kinda like Socrates. I keep questioning my mom until she got mad lmao 😹

@arrietty1619 3 года назад

Same

@schnitzelberry 2 года назад

xD same except I'm like this with everyone and I don't even realize until someone tells me to shut up and just agree for once lmao

@wancheng89 3 года назад

2:33 Socrates doing Lamaze breathing is something I didn’t know I need 😂

@jeton9153 2 года назад

I was always fascinated by ancient Greeks, their ideologies and lifestyle is very interesting

@metalslug97 3 года назад

I had to watch this video twice. Once to listen to the content and another to enjoy this great animation.

@itsreallygoodlooking 3 года назад

Great video. Critical thinking is a significant tool!

@productgirl 2 года назад

What I love most about Socrates is the possibility that he never existed but is only a living character created and reported by Plato in his writings ❤️

@JackPullen-Paradox 8 месяцев назад

You are questioning authority. That's the spirit.

@tilkesh 11 месяцев назад

Thank you very much.

@spiritoxi 3 года назад

One of the most important skill that we need and to instil into young generations today

@franciscosanchez-hp9sf 2 года назад

Most digestible explanation of the Socratic method I've ever seen!

@cruisepaige 2 года назад

I went to law school when they still used the Socratic method. It was difficult but amazing for my brain!

@theselfproclaimedchef Год назад

Can you explain what that is?

@AI-hx3fx 2 года назад

I learnt more about Philosophy through this video than my basic Philosophy class in university. Our professor was too lazy and shoved graduate-level texts from his favourite German thinker down our throats.

@laibamasood4317 2 года назад

always love this kinda content

@augusthavince8909 2 года назад

I have recently learned that thinking of hypothetical situations can lead to disingenuous people with a selfish agenda to get into what-about-isms. I think having the latest and best understanding of history along with what is ethical and humane is better than hypothetical situations.