This TUDOR is Perfect...on paper. 

Pelagos 39 is stunning. Best Tudor ever.

A Pelagos 39 with the matte blue dial and bezel would be killer! I’d also love to see an option with a date on the 39mm size.

Picked mine up last week and I love it. The sunburst dial is so subtle you hardly even notice it

Good, honest crunchy analysis. Positivity without fawning; critical, but constructive. Really enjoyed this; and I look forward to hearing from you soon.

I’ve watched a lot of videos on the Pelagius and I think you’re correct. The watch is great, but a matte finish might have made this the perfect watch. Still great value for the money and another hit from Tudor.

Your video title is spot on. I was called by my AD for this watch and I was totally underwhelmed in person. The sunburst bezel felt out of place, the sunburst dial seemed inorganic with the ethos of Tudor divers of the past, and the watch just ended up looking like the Seiko SPB143 to me for some reason. I think if they had done a faithful refresh of the Tudor Sub, I would have been satisfied.

I own one. Personally, I do agree with you on key things such as the dial but it grew on me eventually. Regardless of whatever Tudor does no one is ever going to be happy. Some things to point out, as a Pepsi owner, this watch is perfect in terms of wearability. Not too dressy or underwhelming, it’s the perfect balance of style and ruggedness.

I really like this watch. I was actually anticipating these upgrades like a more toothy bezel, the larger crown, rivetless bracelet and the T-fit clasp on the next gen BB58. But on a new 39mm Pelagos, I might have to pick one up sooner than later. I picked up the BB Pro recently and I think this would be a great addition to my one watch collection. 🤔

You nailed all of my hesitations as well

I am perfectly happy with my 42, I think it’s actually 41mm. I like that it’s all matte- such a solid tool. All killer, no filler!

Great review Max! This is what us watch nerds wanted to hear. Although I’m sure it’ll still be desirable by many

Grabbed a unused P39 for list price. I am very pleased with this watch, very comfortable and I really like the darker hue that the titanium alloy offers.

Great recap of the pros and cons. Earned my subscription. Obviously - just looking at their marketing - you’re not their target for this watch. They’re positioning it as a versatile dress/sports watch. Just saw the exhibition piece at my AD yesterday and was blown away; can’t wait to pick it up next month. Then I’ll have the tricky job of working out the perfect rotation with the BB Pro.

Very much agree with you on the comments and suggestions to Tudor. I had an LHD and loved it but due to the size of my wrist, I realized I loved the watch but don't love it on my wrist thus sold it. If Tudor does the same LHD without date and shrinks it to 39mm and thinner, it will be perfect to me. Another well-done review man!

I'm kinda sick of people talking like they know what the "Pelagos" is supposed to be. This watch is brilliant and the advertising is very clear that it's not intended to be a hardcore dive watch so stop telling them it should be when people like me will never go diving but want a rugged, yet beautiful watch to go on vacation with

I’m still unsure how I feel on the “sunburst” dial. It’s also wild to me that they went with 21mm

Very good review as always. I realized that your negatives weren’t bothering me and in contrast these were my positives. I just got mine and its a fantastic watch. I didn’t like the 42 size, neither the mat bezel. I guess it’s a matter of taste. I was concerned with titanium tone and feel, but looks and feels great

Your suggestions at the end are spot on ! 👍

Max! You just described my dream Pelagos at the end. Please bring it back in matte blue!!

I feel the same way. That dial texture and bezel finish on the standard Pelagos were always in the top of the list of things I loved about it, while size was not. I wish they made the 39 just like the standard

Great honest review! I really want one of these. I feel like this would be a perfect fit for me and tool enough that I'm blinging away at people which is important to me. It's purposeful and cool and reminiscent of great watches of the past while being a great modern execution. I hope for Omega's sake their Bond contract is air tight because this honestly looks like the perfect Bond watch if that watch were to be something other than an Omega Seamaster.

I literall don’t know what you are talking about. this watch is one of the best looking divers out there

This is just another option that Tudor is giving customers . This watch is an awesome release by Tudor and will fit many more wrist . The 42mm has some cool specs. But was too large for many . I will definitely be including this 39mm to my collection It’s perfect for what I am looking for in terms of function and form

Personally I’d love to get this pelagos 39 as is. But as I’m already trying to hold out for a blue version (and because I feel like blue would look worse with the sunburst than the black), I would absolutely love a matte blue version. That’s a dream watch to me

I agree with you 100%. I purchased the fxd in December so the lack of helium valve and 200m water resistance obviously didn’t bother me there. I love the lhd Pelagos. This one just feels a little off with the sunburst dial and bezel. A matte 40mm black or blue with 300mm would have been much more exciting to me. The Pelagos needs to be the purposeful “toolwatch” for Tudor. This will sell like hotcakes either way though.

I love the original Pelagos. I own the blue dial right hand drive version and wouldent change anything. I love the weight, the dial, the matt finish. I love the size. Its perfection. The buying experience and timing and price were also perfect. Overall , i love my whole experience with it. Its my daily and i really do where it everywhere day and night.

If they shrunk the blue Pelagos to 39mm, I'd eat it up. But it would have to be the exact same watch visually (outside of the size change). The dial and bezel would need the same materials and finishing.

Max, 💯 agree with your definition of the ideal Pelagos 39. In addition, if the square markers could eat into the rehaut, 42 mm style, would be perfect.

Thanks for the review. Good comments and observations. I like the watch even if it has strayed from the Pelagos DNA. I have to look at it in person tho to see what the sunburst dial looks like in the flesh. I might be okay with it, but there’s no denying that I wish it were matte black, or even the deep black found on my Tudor BB 36mm.

Good review. I’m more bullish on this watch. Today is the first day on the wrist but I’ve been searching for the P39 for months and was missing a do all watch since moving on from my BB. So far it’s exactly what I expected and wanted.

I have one and I love it!

I do like it a lot and I’m currently waiting for an FXD so when this was announced I thought oh no! But you’re completely right, if this was matte blue face and bezel I would have happily got this in addition to the FXD

I follow your RU-vid Chanel from France for 2 months now, and you made one of my favorite watch content. Awesome videos, the light, the music, the rhythm... all is very good. Fully agree on you point of view on the watch. The size is perfect but it lost the tools ingredients of its bigger sister.

Saw this watch in person at an AD just this morning. The sunburst dial and bezel are not for me, wish Tudor kept the flat colour/texture of the larger variant. The sunburst feels more fashion and less tool. Glad Tudor resisted the urge to include faux rivets though. So close, but not for me in it's current CMF. Hopefully more colour variants to come in the future!

Hi, thanks for the great video. If I could add some points to your wishlist for a revised P39, it would read as follows: 1. Add a date function just as the P42 has 2. Consider a saphire caseback like the North Flag had 3. Add a quick strap-/bracelet change option as one kind find with multiple other brands to switch between the titanium bracelet and i.e. the provided rubber strap Happy to pay a couple of bucks extra for what I would then consider to be the perfect watch!

Thank you! I thought the exact same thing when I saw it for the first time, and I still think the same

I agree 100 percent with your recommendations for a future 39 Pelagos: same case, same bracelet, blue, and matte. I've seen the LD 42" at an AD and really like it -- but I worry that a short period of time it will feel just a bit too big (in the height dimension).

A very smart move by Tudor, making a more compact, thinner version of the original Pelagos that will appeal to a wider audience. Featuring a more handsome dial & 3D lume plots, the in-house COSC movement similar to the BB58, titanium bracelet with the T-Fit clasp (instead of that spring-style eye-sore) and a complimentary rubber strap is a big plus. My only reservation until I get hands on is the sunburst dial and bezel aesthetic.

You are by far the best RU-vidr in your category. 🥇🥇🥇🥇

BB58 at 39mm with full titanium would be home run

I feel the same about the changes, the original had a special personality which has been lost a bit in the new release. Purists always are apprehensive with change and I am definitely one of those . Great video !!!

As much as there is heritage and tradition with the matte face, after owning one for awhile, I found myself longing for a little more visual stimulation. I personally welcome the new face and bezel on the 39. I intend to own one.

I have the Blue 41 with a date. I have a 7.25 to 7.5 wrist. I have been wearing it for the last week and fell back in love. I need a date. For a smaller wrist, the new Pelagos is a great watch. The movement alone is terrific. I think you are way too critical. For 4 grand it compares with the Sub, no date. These Tudors have a solid feel, that other watches lack.

i really like the look the dial and bezel of this watch. the subtle sunray effect is amazing.

I want one... Just in blue. It'll come. Will see... I feel traditionally, the blue color ones that Tudor makes tend to be more subdued. I'm just thinking of the BB58, the blue is more subdued to the black gilt.. even the ss metal used was subtlely different. Who knows? Maybe when a 39 Pelagos in blue comes, it may be a nice subdued blue, lose the red accent on the dial for a more monotone look, and maybe it may return to a flat/matte finish?

I think they nailed it with the pelagos! It kinda feels love the love child of the BB58 & Pelagos. 💕 a BB58 that looks more like a pelagos!

I'm still going to go for it I think! These days I just want to wear something under $5k that I can be more comfortable with.

Came for the watch, stayed for the videography. Well done! I agree 100% with your analysis. Add my name to the signatures on your communication with Tudor. Why they did not keep ALL the Pelagos DNA in the 39mm size has me shaking my head in wonderment. I will continue to just say 'No!' to a shiny Pelagos.

I'm more of a BB58 guy, but I agree with you: if Tudor made the tweaks that you recommend -- in addition to some variation of those 3D Pelagos dial markers -- it would certainly get my attention.

Well said! Thanks 👏😉

I think is an almost perfect watch (no such thing as perfect), and frankly, I'd rather have this over the your Sub 14060; better looking and at least half the price. As far as it being too shiny, I haven't seen it in person, but other reviewers have noted that it's not as shiny as they thought it would be. Even the sunburst is only noticible under the harsh light. But since I like blue, I might wait for a blue version.

I am still excited about the watch, although the sunburst dial might be a deal-breaker. The 39mm is a great size. I always thought I liked larger dial sizes more (43mm+) but I think I was simply following the crowd. I am starting to appreciate dials 40mm and smaller. I need to see the Pelagos 39 in person before making a judgement.

Weirdly the 39 has me looking at the FXD now, it's the Snowflake everyone wants just in a quirky package.

I think the watch is great and ordered it. I don’t think it was a bad as you say.

The more variants of 39mm pieces Tudor come up with, the more the BB58 OG Black dial becoming desirable. I think it is time to pull the trigger especially the strap/nato version.

I agree this needs to be matte. It would be simultaneously classy, understated, purposeful, and rugged. You hit the nail on the head asking for a modern version of the blue snowflake. It’s one of my favorite vintage watches, period, and it’s the pinnacle of Tudor’s past. A Pelly version of it would kick a lot of my watches to the curb.

It looked too good to be true on paper, even better on the wrist. I got it and have zero regrets, except wondering why I didn’t get it earlier! If it comes in blue I’ll get one too!

You right, I really want to see blue and it will be in my collection.

Spot on, and why i went for a Pelagius 42.

It'll be interesting to compare sales with those of the Black Bay 58. At the moment all we have are opinions from different commentators. They each have a unique charm, but let's just see how the market reacts over time.

a number of recent Tudor releases mentioned but for some reason the one you have to see in person to fully appreciate is the 58 925 silver. just a flat gray but somehow so compelling that i thought i heard it say, "buy me!"

I really like it. Don't really see myself buying it, but I must say if the BB58 had the same type of bracelet and clasp as this new Pelagos, I'd buy that for sure.

A matt dial similar the 42mm? no! That would be the same old boring TUDOR. Glad this piece is a 9.9/10 for making it more youthful, fun and suitable for all occasions and broader enthusiasts.

haha love that you snuck in that "Bedazzler" reference. Also add to your Tudor wishlist Grade 5 titanium please on a $4,400 watch--not Grade 2 like a $1,000 microbrand. Expect that we will see these uncoated Grade 2 Pelagos 39s scratched to heck on the resale market in a few months.

A very interesting view Max. I also have the LHD and love it for all the reasons that you mention. I have also seen the Pelagos 39 in the flesh and I must agree that the sunburst dial is very subtle but is a little more pronounced on the dive bezel, it also seems to be a lot lighter than my LHD. Do I want one? Yes, definitely. Why? Well it's different enough from the LHD to make it its own watch, also it's different enough from the BB58 looking like a watch that takes its cue from modern times like the flat sapphire crystal as opposed to the box type. I have to agree that a matt dial and bezel would be great but for me it might cross a tad too close to the LHD. Hopefully I'll get the call at some point. Some may rightly state that it dilutes the tool nature of the Pelagos family a little but I can live with that.

I think you’re spot on. Don’t quite understand the aesthetic decisions they made. Great that they listened about a smaller Pelagos - but something is missing. Reminds me of one of the recent vintage Seiko’s with the shine.

I find this a valuable review. You have shown the shinier (than 42mm Pelagos) and I definitely agree that its close but not the ticket. Thanks

I tried this watch in person and I love it. I'm actually working towards buying one soon. I've always loved the look of the Pelagos over the Black Bay but the size ruined it for me. If Tudor releases this as an LHD, it would be perfect for me.

I’ve not seen one but from pics I got the same impressions as you but I’m surprised you said it’s smaller size was a negative compared to the original. Ive always thought of the pelogos as a tool watch so for me it has to have a date. I would love a Matt black version with date or maybe a dark Matt blue version with date. It’s seem like a very strange watch to have in the range as It must be taking lots sales from the bb58 or maybe they are just really confident that the next 58 will get the attention back.

Bit harsh imho. I'm the same. I expected perfection and was surprised by the shinyness. But... I say... Give it few months and let's see if we get warmed up to it.

Really love your videos honestly. You're a wordsmith. Totally agree with everything you've said here Stay crunchy ha ha

The P39, my Ranger (which I love BTW), the BB GMT Pro and even the BB Chrono... Tudor has become the go to brand for C.O.R.C. members

Didn’t realize the sun burst texture on the dial. Good call. I was thinking to sell my 14060M for the Pelagius 39 as well as a Rolex 369 explorer.

I liked it when I tried it on but I found it a bit small for me. Noticed quite a difference having worn a 42 mm to the store that day. I’m not sure yet but it’s a great watch. Your reasons for not liking it are not mine and to be fair to Tudor if my wrist was a little bit smaller it wouldn’t be an issue at all. I really like the bracelet and how flat the crystal is. The dial and bezel are great in my opinion. I’m probably going to get an Omega Planet Ocean or Aqua Terra next. They tick more of the boxes I need. I’ve been waiting for something decent from Tudor and it’s nearly perfect.

I really need to check one out in person. Like you I’m a little on the fence about the shinny dial/bezel as well.

Nice review. Beyond the blue color, matte bezel and dial I’d add a date function. At 39mm would be perfect. That’s why I love my blue Pelagos so much, but I’d prefer it at 39-40mm to be the perfect daily. Still on my rotation nevertheless.

I'm not sure why a smaller Pelagos was needed. They advertise it on women which makes sense but I personally can't understand the fascination with small men's watches. That said it's good looking and the dial finish is great.

Watch is stunning in person!

While I haven't made the decision to buy or skip yet (need to see it in the metal), I totally feel you. I would have loved a 39 LHD, basically (with roulette date). Now I'd also be curious to see a blue version, but I'm concerned Tudor may say there is already one...the FXD. Wait&See !

I think this is the best modern diver I’ve ever come across. I found the matte boring and find the brushed satin to be the perfect compromise between the high polish sub and the totally matte Pelagos 42. My one and only diver going forward.

I dig the sunburst bezel. It’s so great! It’s playful and fun - it’s why I’m buying it

I’ve yet to see the 39 in person however mine is coming…soon I hope. I own the blue Pelagos and previously owned the LHD. It’s the perfect submariner in titanium. I understand the bezel & dial are slightly sunburst but provided it’s not too overt, it’s all good.

I perfectly agree to you. As an owner Pelagos LHD, BB58 black dial and blue dial, BB Pro, BB Chrono, and BB GMT, new Pelagos 39 is perfect size but has lost tool watch looks by adding sunburst dial and shiny bezel. The red "Pelagos" lettering is beauty but LHD also has it. I also don't understand why Tudor removed date upon downsizing 42mm to 39mm, as they can do it on BB Pro. Important factor of tool watch is robustness and not case thickness. Seems like Pelagos 39 is selling well as other Tudor new releases in past few years, which I bought six of them, but for me Pelagos 39 is incomplete to fill in the gap between Pelagos and BB58.

Oh man I'm so glad I dont have all the hang ups and trappings of a watch snob/critic. All I see is a stunning watch in a great material at a perfect size.

love the Pelagos 39 as it is . I recently purchased one

Great video! Ya I share your thoughts on the shiny factor! When I compare this to the bb58 it’s a no brained to go blue bb58! If they had this in all Matte I’d be all over it. Waiting on the square marker bb58 👀 that would be a cult classic.

Agree on most points, but no need for cream or any hint of faux patina lume on the next one. Great vid as always!

Tudor is kicking ass. looks great!

Nice review! Fair point but I think all mechanical divers are “lifestyle divers” in this day and age. The most famous diver of all is also mostly a statement piece. So, adding a less toolish and a little prettier Pelagos to the lineup is not a bad thing IMO. Makes it more practical for daily wear for 95% of Tudor’s audience.

I have the 39mm and the LHD and I share these sentiments. I’m keeping both and love both but Tudor barely missed out on what could have been the perfect Tudor. Go back to matte finish on the dial and bezel and please bring back the cream markers and hands like the LHD. I spoke with the President of Tudor USA while he was in Austin 1 month before the 39mm was released and told him what the perfect Tudor watch would be to me. They almost got it exactly as is described it, but missed on the matte dial/hands and cream patina, so close! Great job Tudor, keep them coming you are actually listening to us. I’ve bought 8 new Tudor watches in only 19 months from my AD in Austin and I’m a very loyal fan and customer.

I love the Pelagos 39, I really had a hard time choosing between this one and the BB58. I ultimately went with the BB58, but both watches are absolutely stunning.

I got to try one on over the last weekend. It's light and dainty. Yes, it is dainty. It's feels small, on wrist it looks small. I think the weight was playing a Jedi mind trick on me, I was instantly disappointed, I thought this was the watch, unfortunately not for me. On the positive side I found it's very nice to see in person.

For those wanting a similar looking watch at a fraction of the price, be sure to check out the orient kamasu. Excellent diver watch, and has a day/ window as well

I feel like Tudor is the watch enthusiast face of Rolex, but at the end of the day we forget the average customer who wanders in the AD isn't us. This new watch is the more contemporary option, the other side of the coin to the retro BB58. Even tho it shares the Pelagos name and DNA it might as well have a completely different name. I think very few people who were happy with the original or the FXD will be happy with the 39.

No-one goes diving with an expensive watch, they use a G-Shock.

I think the Pelagos 39mm is absolutely fascinating. And since we're going down this road, Tudor, I would like to see the 39 with a white face.

I would get it - still so sweet of a time piece.

Whats the name of the song being played while you were talking about your old watch? Around 1:43

Absolutely agree with you!

What are your thoughts on Resco Mechanical or Kobold? Have you done any reviews