I'm a big fan of Rocky boots. I never owned a pair of bates so I cannot comment. I will tell you that the Thorogood are about the best fit I've had compariable to redwing boots.
Have owned a pair for about 3 - 4 years. Soles on both stares to separate and liner inside ripped in the heel area. But I’m still going to order another pair. They were comfortable and did well by me. Good review!