I love this scene because it's probably the only one that portrays Cal as a human being for a split second, he watches the funnel fall in disbelief and even looks at the passengers in the way as if to express some actual concern for them, then just immediately goes back to pushing people away from the lifeboat
Did you know that they made Caledon even more evil in the original script? Fabrizio was gonna die either way...... In this scenario the funnel falls on him. But originally he wasn't gonna get crushed. After Titanic sank completely, he is still swimming to reach Collapsible A, but he gets clubbed by Cal with an oar, creating a massive headwound. He utters his last words: "You.... don't .... understand. I '..... have .. . to go... to. America. "It's that way" Cal points into a direction with the oar. Then Fabrizio loses consciousness and dies.
@Smoking tattletale Gaming I think I remember seeing him drinking whiskey or something like that when the stern was rising up. That was terrifying and I don't think I could tolerate being on a ship sinking or not
@@senabecool7232I read he threw chairs and whatever he could find into the water to help people float to avoid drowning. Some people are just born resourceful.
His mother would probably never know what happened either, since those tickets were not in his or Jack’s names so there would have been no record of him being there. It’s as if he would have disappeared.
@@nathanviebranz9111Olaf and Sven probably went to the White Star Line and let them know that two other men used their tickets, if only so that Fabrizio’s family would know what happened to him.
At 0:27 you can see Cal watching people in water about to get crushed, but immediately in the next shot you can see him keep doing what he was doing. "Meh, ok. Back to work". lmao
If you think that Fabrizio’s death was sad in the theaterical version you should hear about the alternate way James Cameron had planned for him to die but ended up cutting it because it was too graphic. Fabrizio ends up swimming over to the lifeboat that Cal is on and tries to pull himself onto it only to be struck in the head by the oar that Cal is holding, causing his scalp to open and beginning to bleed out. Cal then leans over and mockingly tells Fabrizio “If you want to get to America you’d better start swimming” Fabrizio ends up dying from blood loss and hypothermia. Really sad that he does die regardless but at least he wasn’t murdered in cold blood basically.
Pretty dramatic scene, Cal reacting at the funnel falling down as it falls into Fabrizio's way which I think he went the wrong way. 0:23 0:26 Cal opens his jaw in shock at the chaos then looks over at people in its path which he was like, Uh oh. Oh no. Oh great. 0:27
That would've been a bit silly, making Cal downright cartoonishly evil. I think he made the right decision changing that. Cal in the theatrical version is a horrible piece of work, but not unrealistically so. I think we've all met or known people who've met someone like Cal in real life.
Poor Fabrizio, I feel sorry for him, he was good guy. And the funnel could fall on Cal's lifeboat, and he also could be killed. This scene is terrible.
^ It really is miraculous Cal didn’t perish along with everyone else. There’s really no reason he shouldn’t have. The only reason he lived is because he’s important to the overall plot. So Cameron made it so that Cal only JUST survived by sheer dumb luck, managing to sort of commandeer that overturned lifeboat, smacking away anyone who tried to get close. Honestly, I’m surprised he wasn’t shot by Murdoch earlier when he stepped forward to say “we had a deal, damn you!”..
In real life, the funnel actually collapsed to the starboard side. It barely missed Boat A (the one Cal is in the movie) and B and caused a wave that washed them 50ft away from the ship.
In real life, the light on the ship was not that bright, it was hard to see anything, the water was not crystal clear, much less it was calm water, it was really dark water with waves
I love how it portrayed Titanic as a character instead of just a big ship as Thomas Andrews refers the ship as a "She". That sound shows the pain that Titanic suffers while sinking, in its like she's screaming for "help!"
0:22 The sound of the metal scrape noise of the funnel detaching drives Cal his full attention to witness the ruckus of it as it falls down. Then at 0:26, Cal opens his jaw in surprise with horror and fear as the initial funnel makes a second, louder, eerie and scary metal scraping sound as he turns as 0:27 he turns around, breaking his attention at the funnel towards the people about to get crushed in which I think he was like, "Oh no!"
Even in a life and death struggle, Cal is acting like an arrogant boss/overseer, putting the little people in their place (in this case, refusing them space on the lifeboat)
Due to the angle of the ship's tilt, the cables on one side of the funnel found themselves supporting the full weight of the multi-ton smokestack instead of the weight being distributed fairly amongst them all. Funnels One and Two were lost that way whilst Three and Four were broken loose from their moorings by the ship snapping in two.
The first and second funnels collapsed mainly because of water pressure crushing their bases, not the angle of the ship. And the third funnel collapsed because its base was severely damaged by the breakup. The fourth funnel, most likely, didn't fall as early as often depicted. A number of survivors recall seeing the fourth funnel still standing as the ship went nearly vertical, while nobody recalls that funnel falling during the breakup.
Actually, funnels were designed to withstand their weight at a 10° angle at bad sea/weather. They were however relatively thin, which caused the water pressure to damage their base and make them fall. Notice how all 4 funnels were at the same inclination angle at the same time yet only the front one collapsed at that moment
0:27 That creaking sound effect, mixed with a bit of brass horn is actually a recycled audio file from Terminator 2. It was used in the T-1000's helicopter chase scene, when the SWAT van the T-800 drives bursts a tyre and tips onto it's side.
Quand j'etait petit (et encore maintenant en fait 😅) je me repassai cette scene en boucle une bonne vingtaines de fois, je sais pas pourquoi mais j'adore trop le bruit que fait la cheminée en tombant 😅
April 15, 1912. 2:15 am. Titanic is doomed, plunging into the pitch black ocean. The water reaches the base of the forward funnel, and crushes it. Suddenly, the gigantic mass of the steel begins crashing down towards the starboard side, as the guywires snap. It smashes the water, killing the swimmers under it and barely missing the two remaining collapsible boats. It causes a wave that washes the collapsible boats 50 feet away from the ship.
It took Titanic 2 hours and 30 mins to get the bown and wheelhouse underwater. After that, the sinking rapidly accelerated. Every mayhem we see: funnel falling on Fabrizio, grand staircase flooding, props out of water, lights out, snapping in two and finally going under all occurred in the last 10 minutes that followed.
I know, I didn’t want him to die, and I screamed as loud as flamingo the youtuber when he died (Dw it wasn’t when i saw the re-release, which i saw 2 times)
If the movie's depiction of the sinking was more accurate, the funnel would have actually missed him. According to survivor accounts, the forward funnel fell towards the starboard side, basically the opposite side from what is depicted here. Doesn't matter much though, Fabrizio is a fictional character and Cameron had already written his death on the script.
Lightoller himself, stated that the people that went up to the stern lessened their chanches of survival, the passengers would have been better off if they atleast tried to climb onto a collapsible, since they were the only 2 boats that still were near the titanic.
What sound effect is that while the titanic funnel is collapsing part :25 to about :27 I’m trying I love titanic it was a phenomenal Ship my favorite ships
Even though the plot was fake the fear the screaming was probably as real as we will get to that night and when I do see and hear these scenes...I bawl...knowing it's probably what it sounded like
The “NOOOOOOOO!!!” Fabrizio screamed out really got me on my nerves the first time I watched ‘Titanic’,later on seeing that his screaming, ended by him being crushed to death
Getting crush by a funnel is a quick death compare to people who freeze to death by the Atlantic water. To those who been rescued, they described it felt like you been stabbed by a knife multiple times.
For wondered why the funnels collapse or fall, well that because of implosion and some shake from split so the funnels collapse, the funnels aren't designed for that.
Although the lights of the real Titanic could have never acted this way, due to how the ship was powered, something even scarier happened. Survivors recall that the lights weakened and began glowing a "devilish red" color towards the final moments of the sinking.
It's due to sudden temperature change. The funnel was so hot and then when the cold Atlantic water touched its base, it suddenly became cold and that made the thin body aliminum/steel to buckle and implode, causing it to fail.
@@AdoboDad are you dum?, this happened, people froze got crushed and died, the funnels were heavy., and people died instantly, So People did get crushed.
Actually I was thinking since the funnel being so heavy it would nt have sank and floated and ppl could have stood on top of it when the ship sank.Jst thnkng
I still don’t understand why the funnels fell was it from gravity being at an angle like that the cables should have kept them in place but they snapped again was it because of gravity.
No. The cables didn't support the weight of the funnels. I'll try to explain the best I can, but doing so by only text may be difficult: The funnels weren't just what you could see above deck (18 meters tall). They actually went all the way down the ship to the boilers; so, they basically were very long, empty tubes. They were supported by their own structure, the cables were there to help control deformation from lateral forces (such as wind or by the ship going up and down under rough weather). You can picture it by seeing some of the very tall, very thin radio steel antennas, they support their own weight but have cables attached to prevent them from going too over one side when the wind pushes them in one direction. Now, during the sinking, the water was rising quickly in the decks below, but the interior of the funnel case was empty because it was sealed at almost every point; so, the water outside the funnel was creating enormous pressure against the thin steel wall (it was designed to support itself and wind loads, not water pressure) and it basically started to compress it until failure (imagine it as you crushing an empty can with your hands). Then, the funnel above the deck was pretty much rootless and fell. The cables could not keep it in place because they weren't supposed to do so. So, the cables snapped because the funnel was already falling; the funnel did not collapse because the cables snapped. I hope this helps :)
@@carlosadriantinajerovelazc4338 interesting so it’s like an upside down funnel id imagine one funnel was attached to multiple boilers. Titanic had 6 boiler rooms. So it must be the way Titanic sank because Lusitania sunk with all the funnels in place.
@@ryans413 yeah, kind of. Each of the first three funnels were attached to multiple boilers at the bottom, then, quickly fused into one tube that rose all decks and 18 m above the boat deck. There's some longitudinal sections of the ship available online, there you can see how they were. And, about the Lusitania, their funnels were thicker and shorter, thus, more rigid. That combined with the ship sinking much faster probably didn't allow the funnels case to gain enough stress to fail before the ship had hit the ocean floor.
@@carlosadriantinajerovelazc4338 I just watched a video called what’s inside Titanic by the you river Jared Owen very good video so I understand now. If you haven’t seen it I’d recommend it.