Tolkien’s Abandoned Rewrite of The Hobbit

Подписаться 1,1 млн

Просмотров 111 тыс.

50% 1

History of The Hobbit: amzn.to/4abcTz6
The Annotated Hobbit: amzn.to/3xoSkAB
History of The Hobbit (UK): amzn.to/3IXBifx
The Annotated Hobbit (UK): amzn.to/4cDJ9MR
Hit subscribe and the bell for great Tolkien content every week!
Nerd of the Rings on PATREON: / nerdoftherings
NOTR merch: nerdoftherings.creator-spring...
To purchase artist work, check out these amazing artists!
Tulikoura - www.deviantart.com/tulikoura
Matthew Stewart - www.matthew-stewart.com/
BellaBergolts - www.deviantart.com/bellabergolts
Magdalena Katanska - www.artstation.com/magdalenak... / qualiney
Jerry Vanderstelt - vandersteltstudio.com/store/
Anna Podedworna - www.artstation.com/akreon
Jenny Dolfen - goldseven.wordpress.com/
Kimberly80 - www.deviantart.com/kimberly80
Turner Mohan - turner_mohan
Ted Nasmith - www.tednasmith.com/shop/
Anke Eissmann - anke.edoras-art.de/anke_illust...
Aronja Art - / aronjaart
Ivan Cavini - / ivan_cavini
Sara Morello - www.artstation.com/saramorello
Matěj Čadil - www.etsy.com/people/matejcadil
Tulikoura - www.deviantart.com/tulikoura
Aegeri - www.deviantart.com/aegeri
Justyna Dura - www.artstation.com/justynadura
Sergio Botero - www.artstation.com/sboterod
Noe Leyva - / noeleyvart
Clemence Morisseau - www.artstation.com/kahirie
Edvige Faini - www.edvigefaini.com , edvige.faini edvige_faini
Miriam Ellis - www.miriamellis.com
Stevce Lazarevski - www.artstation.com/artofstevce
Álvaro González - / alvarofernag_art
MirachRavaia - www.deviantart.com/mirachravaia
Magdalena Olechny - magdalenaolechny.com/
Beren and Luthien - Ralph Damiani
tuor coming to vinyamar - Matej Cadil
Túrin Turambar - Alan Lee
Smaug and Bilbo - Andrea Piparo
Bilbo, bard and thranduil - anotherstranger_me
Riddle Game - Ted Nasmith
Riddles In The Dark bilbo - John Howe
Fantasy landscape - Felix Englund
gollum cave - felix englund
elrond and bilbo in rivendell - anotherstranger_me
Gandalf the Grey - Kinko White
Distant Mountain - Felix Englund
Gandalf the White - Andrea Piparo
King Aragorn - Steve Airola
Minas Tirith - Abe Papakhian
A View of Hobbiton From The Hill - Ted Nasmith
Shire hills - Šárka Škorpíková
Gandalf The Grey - John Howe
Gandalf - Kinko White
bilbo’s tales - Tolman Cotton
Professor Tolkien - Kinko White
Gandalf - Daniel Dougherty
Fireworks - Lída Holubová
Gandalf and Shadowfax - Ted Nasmith
Gandalf and shadowfax - Catherine Karina Chmiel
Gandalf and the Witch King Ride - Kip Rasmussen
Gandalf and Shadowfax - Anke Eißmann
Shadowfax - Catherine Karina Chmiel
Thorin - Kinko White
Cloudy view - Felix Englund
thorin - Jenny Dolfen
Thorin - Kinko White
Gandalf and Thorin - Ted Nasmith
The King Under the Mountain - John Howe
gandalf - Jenny Dolfen
Gandalf - Elrodimus Flash
Gandalf - Catherine Karina Chmiel
Thorin bilbo portraits - Kinko White
Bilbo - Elrodimus Flash
Bridge to Rivendell - Alan Lee
Tolkien, the Professor - Kinko White
Bree - WITN
At the Sign of the Prancing Pony - Ted Nasmith
Forsaken Inn - RalphDamiani
The Last Bridge - Ralph Damiani
Mitheithel Bridge - Soni Alcorn-Hender
An Elf-stone - Miriam Ellis
Gandalf - Catherine Karina Chmiel
Bilbo there - Kinko White
thorin oakenshield - Tolman Cotton
Gandalf, A Light in the Dark - Matthew Stewart
Felarof and Leod - Catherine Chmiel
fili and kili - Tolman Cotton
Hobbit and horse - Catherine Karina Chmiel
Dwarves - Eric Fraser
snowy river - Sara Morello
Trolls - Ted Nasmith
trolls cave - Matej Cadil
gandalf - aegeri
gandalf - John Howe
Bilbo closeup - Kinko White
Sting - John Howe
GOLLUM & BILBO - John Howe
Gandalf the White - John Howe
Gandalf - Anke Eissmann
Orcrist, The Goblin Cleaver - Ted Nasmith
Glamdring - John Howe
Gandalf - Elrodimus Flash
Elrond - Anke Eissmann
A Ranger of the North - Anna Kulisz
Rivendell - Alan Lee
Rivendell - Jerry Vanderstelt
thorin and co - Turner Mohan
Lorien - Catherine Chmiel
201015 - felix englund
A Ranger, A Wizard, A Burglar - Abe Papakhian
Legolas - Matthew Stewart
radagast - tolmancotton
The Spiders of Mirkwood - Ted Nasmith
Visit to Bilbo - Alan Lee
The One Ring - John Howe
Fantasy Mountain - Felix Englund
Professor Tolkien - Kinko White
mountainside lake - Felix Englund
Prof JRR Tolkien - skullb*st*rd
Conversations With Smaug - JRR Tolkien
Forest farm - Felix Englund
Dwarven entrance - Felix Englund
Thrain Discovers the Lonely Mountain - Ted Nasmith
rivendell at sunset - kuliszu
lone tower - Felix Englund
Traveler in the mountain - Felix Englund
Misty Mountains - Felix Englund
#thehobbit #tolkien #bilbo

Развлечения

Опубликовано:

29 мар 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 233

@etienneporras7252 2 месяца назад

I always assumed that the original, childish feel of the Hobbit was because while the Narrator of The Lord of Rings is Tolkein's character, whereas the Narrator of the Hobbit is ostensibly Bilbo's voice, not Tolkiens

@pacmanfan1214 2 месяца назад

This was the vibe I got too; The Hobbit is supposed to be Tolkien's translation of the portion of the Red Book of Westmarch written by Bilbo as a memoir of his travels, There and Back Again. It totally fits with Bilbo's personality that he would write in a more whimsical storytelling way while the portion written by Frodo, LOTR, was darker and more serious. The prologue to LOTR is honestly one of the most brilliant framing devices I've ever seen in any form of media and it ties together two works with such different tones very well.

@Enerdhil 2 месяца назад

The Hobbit started as a literal bedtime story for Tolkien's children.

@Enerdhil 2 месяца назад

Bilbo is the original author of The Red Book, so it had to be his story from his viewpoint.

@etienneporras7252 2 месяца назад

@@Enerdhil I don't believe Bilbo himself wrote "The Red Book" specifically. He wrote There and Back Again and the Silmarillion, which was then compiled along with the Lord of the Rings by Frodo into the Red Book of Westmarch by Sam's descendants. The Gardeners compiled the Red Book of Westmarch, Bilbo wrote the first two portions of it. The Appendices were added later by Elessar's Royal Scribe iirc.

@Enerdhil 2 месяца назад

@@etienneporras7252 I was only responding to your comment about Bilbo being the narrator of The Hobbit. He started The Red Book. Of course, Frodo and Sam came later and contributed to it.

@DannerBanks 2 месяца назад

I love how the Hobbit is more whimsical. Glad that it wasn't changed

@IlSqueak 2 месяца назад

The Hobbit is a book I will read to my Grandson, The (Return Of The King And The Downfall of) The Lord of The Rings is a book that he (they) will have to discover themselves.

@i_DONT_get_IT 2 месяца назад

Tolkien was Committed completely to continually refining, checking and harmonizing all his written works. His hard work is clearly evident in the final product, unmatched, to say the least. For instance, I love the clarifying adjustment when he later added in the counsel of Elrond regarding the change of plot from the hobbit during “riddles in the dark” when Bilbo said “and if some have heard me tell it otherwise, I ask them to forget it and forgive me”…

@swordmonkey6635 2 месяца назад

It was also because of Christopher's editorial input of his father's drafts in letters back and forth to and from his father that JRR Tolkien constantly refined and worked on stories and worldbuilding. Christopher was a stickler for detail and continuity and would catch issues and inconsistencies and provide feedback for his father who would then revise his drafts.

@i_DONT_get_IT 2 месяца назад

@@swordmonkey6635 they were a great team!

@christophermcclellan8730 2 месяца назад

@@swordmonkey6635”damn the boy!” Christopher is the reason he ever wrote the hobbit down to begin with.

@JetForceFive 2 месяца назад

Part of the appeal of The Lord of the Rings is that it is a darker, more complex evolution of the world and tone of The Hobbit. By retro-fitting The Hobbit to better match LOTR, Tolkien would have inadvertently minimized its overall legacy; The Hobbit is the accessible gateway to the greater work for generations of young people. I first read it at 14, and as I matured to 16 and 17, LOTR provided themes and dynamics that I was more emotionally & intellectually mature enough for. Not everyone had my same experience of Tolkien naturally guiding me through young adulthood, but I'm sure many have. I think it's all perfect as it is.

@LeeBrasher 2 месяца назад

I concur, Your Excellency.

@honeybadger4245 Месяц назад

Exactly! I read The Hobbit when I was 13 and started reading The Lord Of The Rings for the first time when I was 15. Tolkien's works deeply impacted my view of the world. I first read one of the German translations of LOTR though, which has a much more colloquial and easy-going tone than the original. I didn't read it in English until I was in my 30s.

@JetForceFive Месяц назад

@@honeybadger4245 That's interesting about the German version, but for the time period, that makes sense. I feel like if The Hobbit had the same tones and esthetic of LotR, not only would many younger folks be a bit overwhelmed with either the horror or the vastness of the lore - it likely wouldn't have been assigned by school teachers. Which is really where it gained traction in the States over generations. A lot of 8th and 9th graders were assigned things like Animal Farm, Lord of the Flies, To Kill A Mockingbird and The Hobbit.

@MotherAlgorithm Месяц назад

I agree, I read them when a child with no knowledge of either story and it was an unrivalled experience.

@gothngo2943 2 месяца назад

I'm glad it didn't change further. Bilbo was never truly harmed by the Ring, and I'm glad his cheerful voice is still the narrator. He had no idea yet how serious things actually were when he finished it.

@Big_Tex 2 месяца назад

On a re-read it occurred to me that “the Narrator” in The Hobbit reminded me of Peter Falk in “The Princess Bride”.

@astrotter 2 месяца назад

I see some influence from C.S. Lewis in that style as well. The wry little asides to the reader remind me of the Narnia books.

@brianj.841 2 месяца назад

Inconceivable! ;-)

@ScooterDoge 2 месяца назад

That feels accurate. Like when it says “But you probably already know that” or “you’ll remember that from before.”

@quazzydiscman 2 месяца назад

I love this man's dedication. It keeps the Tolkien's universe alive for me...

@hudsonball4702 2 месяца назад

Now we know why Jackson had Thorin act the way he acted to BIlbo in the first movie.

@mbryson2899 2 месяца назад

If that's the case it explains Tauriel as well.

@hudsonball4702 2 месяца назад

@@mbryson2899 how?

@mbryson2899 2 месяца назад

@@hudsonball4702 It is just as accurate to the apocrypha. The constant orc ambushes were another of PJ's inclusions that fits the bill.

@SMiki55 2 месяца назад

@@mbryson2899Tauriel didn't appear in the rewrites though, they reached only Rivendell

@valentinkambushev4968 2 месяца назад

The Hobbit trilogy definitely shows why Tolkien abandoned this rewriting. You can't give the Hobbit The Lord of the rings' spirit without sacrificing what makes the Hobbit the Hobbit.

@Hero_Of_Old 2 месяца назад

That wasn't the issue with the Hobbit movies.

@valentinkambushev4968 2 месяца назад

@@Hero_Of_Old It was one of the problems.

@teleportedbreadfor3days 2 месяца назад

The Hobbit is simply another aspect or faucet of the larger Middle Earth world, part of the bigger and more magically diverse picture. It really baffles me how badly modern Hollywood fails to see something so obvious and simple.

@i_DONT_get_IT 2 месяца назад

The idea in my opinion is the hobbit was written as a children’s book. LOTR was written as a more serious book for adults. Plus many other things

@valentinkambushev4968 2 месяца назад

@@teleportedbreadfor3days but once you put it next to Lotr, you definitely see how different they are. At the end of the day, the Hobbit is still a children's book, while Lotr is for teens and adults. It's honestly impossible to make a successful adaptation of the two that take place in the same world.

@meglosthecaramacking 2 месяца назад

I think he should have continued with it, but not to replace The Hobbit entirely. This could have been a companion book with a different title, perhaps the previously used The Quest of Erebor. Something to exist separately from The Hobbit book. It could even perhaps have shifted its perspective to Gandalf. Let it be more focussed on his actions - allowing the reader to see the attack on the Necromancer etc…

@MerkhVision 2 месяца назад

Yeah, that’s exactly what I was thinking! I would love to read the rewrite, but not as a replacement of the original, just in addition to it.

@Kelnx 2 месяца назад

I'm sure that Tolkien also understood how old stories varied based on who wrote them, which is another reason why the difference in tone between The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings makes them seem more "authentic", not less. I've always found that difference to be one of the great things about the whole work. The Hobbit is clearly told by a modern man who put together an ancient tale from some long lost telling of it, but The Lord of the Rings is more like a primary source, written by an ancient character from the past. I always loved the contrasts in that.

@captainez4387 2 месяца назад

The whimsicality of The Hobbit is what makes it my favorite book

@liamhiggins3787 2 месяца назад

I love these videos about how Tolkien wrote his stories. They are such interesting facts and I would love to see more. Maybe a series about his earlier mythology and later revisions of the Silmarilion. Keep up the great work 👍

@MerkhVision 2 месяца назад

Agreed, learning about his writing process is fascinating. Learning about the creative processes involved in great works by the masters is inspiring!

@robertwkalkman9603 2 месяца назад

I first read the Hobbit and LOTR in 1977 and I have never really stopped reading them over and over again. I read the Silmarillion when newly published. That's all fine and good. But today is so much better. Having analyses like this available, giving the opportunity to ponder the stories and back-stories, with insight provided by others who apparently were able to devote more time to it than I was is very refreshing. And I'll agree with others here that Nerd of the Rings is very high quality stuff. I'm impressed by Girl Next Gondor as well. There are others more mediocre. They still have something to say. But the really good ones are gems.

@benjaminallen3371 2 месяца назад

I didn't know about Tolkien's abandoned rewrite and subsequent revisions. All I knew were the changes made in "Riddles in the Dark," Gandalf's version of the quest, and his addition of specific dates to the journey. His rewrite makes me appreciate what Peter Jackson did with The Hobbit Trilogy even more.🙂

@Tareltonlives 2 месяца назад

The Hobbit trilogy definitely shows what the rewrite would look like: definitely something great, something powerful, something part of Lord of the Rings , but it wouldn't be the Hobbit.

@woody5476 Месяц назад

I actually think the trilogy was not something great. They made it stressful and more like a video game. It was awful.

@Tareltonlives Месяц назад

@@woody5476 I'm in the minority of really enjoying those films.

@jonatanrullman Месяц назад

"great" and the Hobbit movies in the same sentence. This is a weird timeline.

@BoroMirraCz 9 дней назад

@@jonatanrullman True. The Hobbit movies are more in line with "amazing" than with simply "great".

@MessianicJewJitsu 2 месяца назад

10:20 well the ring may have made bilbo feel the need to muddy the waters of how he got the ring. Influence felt immediately regardless if the reader knows it's origin or not. It's like it unfolded with Tolkien himself and he put it together as he gained new insights too.

@MerkhVision 2 месяца назад

Your last sentence is true about Tolkien’s creative process, according to the experts who’ve studied his life and work. It was a process of discovery for him, of things slowly revealing themselves, and old ideas gaining new and deeper meanings and expanding and intertwining almost on their own!

@NomadUrpagi 2 месяца назад

You are the most quality lotr channel. Every video is relaxing and enjoyable.

@MessianicJewJitsu 2 месяца назад

Right on the heels of a Tolkien Road Podcast episode. Happy Easter weekend!!!

@TheSilentHeel 2 месяца назад

I LOVE this style of video from you. As much as I love your lore videos and history of Middle Earth, it would be so cool if you became a kind of "Steward of History and Unfinished Tales" and documented the history of Tolkien's writings with your usual outstanding research and knowledge. Cheers for the great video!

@JessWLStuart 2 месяца назад

I've always wondered! Thanks for this video!

@robhaskins Месяц назад

I remember how the authorized paperback editions had a disclaimer on the back that the Ace books were not authorized and should not be purchased. An amazing time-it only added to the books' mystique.

@logansfury 2 месяца назад

This is a great upload. I find today's subject matter particularly fascinating. It seems you did a lot of reading of lesser known works to put together the information for this video.

@istari0 2 месяца назад

The History of the Hobbit is next up on my reading list once I finish The Letters of J.R.R. Tolkien. Personally, I wish he had finished that rewrite; I think it would have been a fascinating read.

@KarlMonsos 2 месяца назад

Thank you for another great upload!

@_mrcrypt 2 месяца назад

Great insights, as always! Thank you for sharing 🍷

@nickdavidson7841 2 месяца назад

As much as I love the Hobbit as-is, I think we're missing out on a version that's more aligned with LotR both in lore and tone. I'd love to read that. Though the more childlike tone of the Hobbit is what drew me in initially as a 10-year-old. Wish we could have both!

@STMukr 2 месяца назад

Bravo Nerd. That's really usefull. God bless your work. ❤

@user-lp3ew1xb5u 2 месяца назад

Reminds me of Walt Whitman's inability to move forward after Leaves of Grass and how he spent all of his productive years rewriting and rewriting it.

@anonimoalfin 2 месяца назад

Fascinating video. Thanks for your awesome work.

@kevinmoore4845 2 месяца назад

Wow. Just when I believed I knew everything! This video is so captivating. I think all of Tolkiens' Hobbit changes would have enhanced curiosity in the larger world of Middle Earth. Well done.

@Epic_BostonMobTales 2 месяца назад

Hell yea dude this is awesone and im glad i listen to ur advice lost tales was awesome

@jannerwingfeather 2 месяца назад

This video has my mind spinning imagining the possibilities of what could have been! I personally wish he had completed the fully revised version! I believe it would have been amazing!

@mikeblair2594 2 месяца назад

I grew up living on the streets from 13 to 19 years of age. I'd take honest work if it were offered, but trying to find a proper job wasn't happening for a scruffy punk rocker even though I toned it down. So it happened that from time to time that I would find myself incarcerated in juvenile halls and such places of ill repute. I found that the hobbit and the lord of the rings were some of the best books to take one out of whatever cell they've found themselves in and put into foreign lands amongst foreign people. Though I consider Tolkien to be a bit long winded, that's not such a bad thing when all you have is time. I appreciate that you fill out the characters and their back stories and their futures. You've A new sub. Cheers

@nvb195 2 месяца назад

Great video !

@user-sd7ri9fy4i 2 месяца назад

Nice work dude thanks

@yourmaninlondoncollecting5749 2 месяца назад

Thanks a lot for this addon info 🙂👍

@Alaedious 2 месяца назад

Thank you so much - I had no idea that Tolkien had undertaken such revisions! 😊❤

@emilywagner6354 2 месяца назад

I'm glad he abandoned it. The whimsical charm of the Hobbit is what makes the book so special.

@otherperson 2 месяца назад

Have you yet done a video on the full history of the writing of the silmarillion? Would be a great watch.

@theredqueen2283 2 месяца назад

This channel and Tolkiens work helped pick me up from Rock bottom a few years ago, I hope it continues to flourish and bring joy to the middle earth community. The common ordinary folks, Hobbits. Looking forward to seeing more content, best regards

@Tolkienosaurus 2 месяца назад

It would have been so cool if he had made a lord of the rings epic out of the Hobbit. It would be nice to have had both Hobbits in my cupboard.

@dougpowellmusic6415 2 месяца назад

It would likely have helped Jackson and company make a better trilogy without all the nonsense and manufactured story lines

@off-labelbotanist5355 2 месяца назад

I suppose thats why the Forsaken Inn is on maps, but not referred anywhere I could find it

@Kili121416 2 месяца назад

Wonderful stuff

@12classics39 2 месяца назад

I still think The Hobbit’s narrator fits in the framing device just fine, because we are reading Tolkien’s translations of the Red Book. Considering Bilbo’s story is more child-friendly than Frodo’s, it would make sense that Tolkien translated it with the addition of a bit of first-person commentary and modern references. Whereas Frodo’s story was so much richer and more sacred and significant to the history he was translating, that he didn’t dare add anything to it.

@epperton 2 месяца назад

I would listen to your narration of the books :)

@mononoke721 2 месяца назад

Never knew Tolkien attempted a more considerable rewrite of the Hobbit, will have to check out that history of book. It's understandable why he would feel motivated to do so in order to bring the book more in line with his other works, but thank goodness he ultimately didn't as the Hobbit stands as a classic of children's literature that is special in it's own way.

@nicholasconder4703 Месяц назад

Given what is said here about the proposed changes to Thorin's character in the rewrite, I suspect that Peter Jackson may have been aware of the abandoned rewrite and decided to incorporate some of the Dwarves' personalities into his version of The Hobbit. Some of the proposed changes to the dwarves' personalities seem to fit what we see in the films.

@reppepper 2 месяца назад

I’m always surprised when people say “need cleaned” instead of “need cleaning “ or “need to be cleaned”, but it seems to be a more widespread construction than I realized.

@floridaprepper751 2 месяца назад

great video sir, i did not know he did that.

@CartoonHero1986 2 месяца назад

Would have written in a character like Tauriel and shoehorn in a love story between her and Keely? LMAO

@Debbie-henri 2 месяца назад

I think there is much that is very charming about The Hobbit, especially as it is written for children. It's a good way of introducing our children to this lore without throwing them in the deep end with Lord Of The Rings, which is considered rather dry for many adults, let alone our own little halflings. No, I think Tolkien did right to do things this way.

@bubble_gum_witch 2 месяца назад

Im glad it stayed as is. I always loved hobbit better than lotr, i really wouldn't have liked those changes

@Blade4952 2 месяца назад

I would have loved to read this re-write. I love the original Hobbit, but this sounds very interesting.

@TheHoneyBadger-yh5vj 2 месяца назад

God bless you and your work sir 😇😇😇

@D.Rivera-bh6xc 2 месяца назад

When I need to get away I click on this channel and dive into the Tolkien world. I am currently rereading The Fellowship of the Ring

@Big_Tex 2 месяца назад

I prefer to think The Forsaken Inn is still a going concern on the frontier of civilization. Like in LOTRO.

@DerekLippold 2 месяца назад

Yeah, LOTRO seems to pick up a lot of those threads

@christophercanadatheist 2 месяца назад

If only Tolkien had edited out the lines about the express train and the creation of golf, which is literally my least favourite sentence in all his writings. Show me on his maps where the trains and golf courses are…

@Enerdhil 2 месяца назад

Can you imagine Hobbits hitting a golf ball with those short arms? "next hole Par 19 🤪😂

@jonsmith6331 2 месяца назад

Middle earth is our earth in the past. The narrator in the hobbit is basically a modern person, so you don’t need to worry about the trains.

@GRWelsh7 Месяц назад

Tolkien had very few bad ideas... And this rewrite was one of them. Another was the sequel to LOTR titled "The New Shadow." To Tolkien's credit, he recognized these as bad ideas and abandoned them. What an incredible genius.

@1forthepriceof218 2 месяца назад

I wonder what the legendarium would look like if Tolkien had been given enough time to complete and perfect it.

@JonRowlison Месяц назад

I never saw the elves being called 'gnomes' - that would have been confusing. I'm still trying to figure out if goblins are, in fact, just regular orcs.

@mysticmoose6123 2 месяца назад

Gandalf didn't need elrond to read the elf runes. He needed elrond to find the dwarvish Moon-letters. A bigger plot hole given all the dwarves present.

@colinleat8309 2 месяца назад

I'm patting myself on the back, I remembered ALL 13 Dwarves name's in Thorin's company without breaking a sweat! 🤣. My copy of The Hobbit is 1990 publication, so I haven't read the original, but I am aware of the changes Tolkien made. Thanks Matt 👍. 🖖😎🤘🇨🇦

@Seer_Of_The_Woodlands 2 месяца назад

it would be nice to live in a world where Tolkien would have re-written the hobbit and written and completed The Silmarillion. it's a pity that we don't live in that world, who knows what we could have learned more from the Middle Earth. Great Video !

@thebrowneyesofmandalore6524 2 месяца назад

@Nerd of the Rings: could we possibly get a video of how you would go about making the Hobbit films if it was under your control? How would you make it different? What are some things about the current films that you agree with? Personally I feel that the Hobbit trilogy gets a bit too much hate. For what Peter Jackson was forced to do by the studios he managed to do a pretty good job with what he had. Despite questionable filming choices and writing choices (*cough Tauriel (who alone I think is an alright character, just never should’ve been shipped with Kili)) he managed to fit it in pretty well with the Lotr books and films which seems pretty similar to what Tolkien himself was doing.

@valethemajor 2 месяца назад

Hey NotR, what music are you using in your videos? It's so contemplative and I'd like to worldbuild (and smoke my pipe) to it. I think my brain would subconsciously recall your vids and help me out. You credit all the art so I feel like I'm missing something with what your music is.

@Enerdhil 2 месяца назад

Yes.... Contemplative.😴

@magnvs1017 2 месяца назад

maps of valinor next please

@willmatheson 2 месяца назад

"The dragon passed like an express train" is a description of Gandalf's fireworks - in the first chapter of Lord of the Rings!

@MrLiffeloffe 2 месяца назад

Have you done a video on "The silent watchers" In chirit ungol?

@LifeFX856 2 месяца назад

This explains why Peter Jackson made so many changes to the movies. He actually used many different sources for the trilogy!

@bobsmith284 Месяц назад

George Lucas: Star Wars Ultra Spacial Edition. Tolkien: Hold my beer.

@Pixellated-kb3vx 2 месяца назад

Theory vid idea: If Bilbo kept the ring in LOTR? Also, I'm looking forward to your New Zealand vid!(Please reply, it would be amazing!)

@i_DONT_get_IT 2 месяца назад

That was my exact request in Nerd of the rings previous video! I agree. What if Bilbo had kept the ring…

@Tar-Elenion 2 месяца назад

A very impotant change: "The feasting people were Wood-elves, of course. These are not wicked folk. If they have a fault it is distrust of strangers. Though their magic was strong, even in those days they were wary. They differed from the High Elves of the West, and were more dangerous and less wise. For most of them (together with their scattered relations in the hills and mountains) were descended from the ancient tribes that never went to Faerie in the West. There the Light-elves and the Deep-elves and the Sea-elves went and lived for ages, and grew fairer and wiser and more learned, and invented their magic and their cunning craft, in the making of beautiful and marvellous things, *before some came back into the Wide World. In the Wide World the Wood-elves **_lingered in the twilight of our Sun and Moon_** but loved best the stars; and they wandered in the great forests that grew tall in lands that are now lost.* They dwelt most often by the edges of the woods, from which they could escape at times to hunt, or to ride and run over the open lands by moonlight or starlight; and after the coming of Men they took ever more and more to the gloaming and the dusk. Still elves they were and remain, and that is Good People." Flies and Spiders Originally: “before they came back into the Wide World. In the Wide World the Wood-elves _lingered in the twilight before the raising of the Sun and Moon;_ and afterwards they wandered in the forests that grew beneath the sunrise."

@kalmarfanatic04 2 месяца назад

This video blew my mind!!!! I had no idea Tolkien started a rewrite of The Hobbit 😱

@wagon9082 2 месяца назад

Good video

@redmo11 2 месяца назад

At 00:04 my brain saw a blue muppet figure-skating on a yellow lake... lol

@simtye88 День назад

What song musical do you use in the background music. They use it in a world war 2 documentary

@V0ldy 2 месяца назад

Could you make a video adressing Gandalf's relationship with the other races as in how they perceive him. He seems to have some sort of diplomatic immunity. I can't seem to find a video that clarifies this point Ty

@PrototypeOnDemand 2 месяца назад

voice over🔥🔥🔥🔥

@luudest 2 месяца назад

2:36 „Express train“ I wonder what express train was there in Middle Earth …?

@federicaesu8580 2 месяца назад

I wish Tolkien had completed the 1960 version of The Hobbit to have something more in line with the epic pace of the Lord of the Rings. . I can understand why he decided to abandon his task. A simpler introduction helps the readers to understand that initially nobody - not even Gandalf - realized that Bilbo had started by chance a chain of events that may lead to either victory over the Dark Lord or catastrophe for the free peoples.

@xshayahyawzi3666 2 месяца назад

How would Aragorn be 10 years old then? He was 87 years old in Lotr which was set 60 years after The Hobbit. This implies he was 27 years old then.

@MADicer357 2 месяца назад

Frodo spends 20 years in bag end before departing with the ring

@xshayahyawzi3666 2 месяца назад

@@MADicer357 ah yes, thanks for correcting me

@Enerdhil 2 месяца назад

@@xshayahyawzi3666 Now I'm confused. I thought you were referring to Bilbo being in Riverdale when Aragorn was there. I am pretty sure your math is correct and Aragorn would have been 27 years old, which means he was likely not living there anyway. He certainly wasn't ten years old.🙄 The other poster referred to Frodo being in Bag End for 20 years- wasn't it 17 years? Anyway, that is LotR and not The Hobbit.

@xshayahyawzi3666 2 месяца назад

@@Enerdhil Okay lets try to figure it out but in reverse order Aragorn was 87 years old when he met Frodo. Frodo left the Shire after 17 years of bilbo's 111th birthday. So by that reckoning Aragorn was was 70 years old at the time of Bilbo's 111th birthday. And bilbo was 50 years old at the time of his adventure. Leaves ys a gap of 60 years. So yes what Aragorn was 87-17-60=10 years old at the time of bilbo's adventure. It was my fault that I missed that Frodo stayed in the shire for 17 years even though I am mainly a book fan. :)

@xshayahyawzi3666 2 месяца назад

@@Enerdhil It was 17 years as frodo was 33 years old at bilbo's birthday and when he left the shire he was 50 years old. You are correct. :)

@hobbes1887 2 месяца назад

Some what ifs for you, my firend: What if Smaug or Shelob got the ring? What if Thranduil got the ring? What if the Blue Wizards had been successful? What if Balin had been successful? What if Smaug had attacked KhazadDûm or Belegost instead of the Erebor? But most of all What if Eärendil had sail the Fellowship to Mount Doom xD

@johnopalko5223 2 месяца назад

I'm not familiar with the Ace edition. My copies of _The Hobbit_ and _The Lord of the Rings,_ which I bought way back in 1978, are published by Ballantine and carry the inscription, "This Is the Authorized Paperbound Edition," which implies it was blessed by Tolkien's estate. Alas, they were apparently not printed on acid free paper as there's significant foxing. I do like them, though, because the cover illustrations are paintings that were done by Tolkien, himself.

@davidh.4944 2 месяца назад

Sorry, but the linked cover art on the first Ballantine edition (I also have copies, a treasure received from my grandfather) were not done by Tolkien, but by Barbara Remington. You can easily find details and images of the original online.

@johnopalko5223 2 месяца назад

@@davidh.4944 I'm just going by what it says on the copyright page. Mine says, "The cover painting, Bilbo comes to the Huts of the Raftelves, is by J. R. R. Tolkien. © George Allen & Unwin Ltd., 1937, 1951, 1966." The cover paintings of the Trilogy, also by Tolkien, are The Hills: Hobbiton-across-the-Water, Fangorm (sic), and Barad-Dûr, respectively. What I have is the seventy-first printing, of November, 1978. Earlier printings may have had different cover art.

@davidh.4944 2 месяца назад

@@johnopalko5223Ok, well my apologies then. It seems we have different covers after all. I was assuming it was the very dramatic and beautiful three-part paperback cover of the first edition I have. Come to think of it, I have seen that illustration before, but I was not aware it was done by him. Thank you.

@johnopalko5223 2 месяца назад

@@davidh.4944 No worries. After scores of printings, it makes sense that there would be changes. I envy you your edition. Cherish it.

@Colin13ify 2 месяца назад

I think a rewrite of The Hobbit would have been a good thing. To match the theme Tolkien worked out over the years in LOTR.

@ElladanKenet 2 месяца назад

I'm fine with Legolas being present in the Narrative of The Hobbit. Being an elven prince, almost certainly grown, and in high standing of a reclusive kingdom, it would've been pretty hard not to see him, even if he was never outright named. Obviously he wasn't in the original story because he hadn't been conceived yet. Not really judging the quality of those films, which are pretty universally considered inferior. Just saying I understand the logic of adding him in, as connective tissue. As for Aragorn... the only reason I can think of why he wouldn't be in Rivendell during the events, is if he was spending time with the Dunedain and maybe learning their ways. He'd have been, what, 10? Certainly old enough to start squiring and assisting with stuff. And in lieu of being king, the assumption would have been that he would become a ranger and need to be familiar with their ways and the realm of Eriador/Arnor, so being away at the time IS logical.

@artemkras 2 месяца назад

This turned out to be a brilliant move: two books for different audiences. First, you read Hobbit as a child. As you get older, you read LOTR. Also, we kind of got the revised version in the PJ's movie.

@starwarsbrainbusters5587 2 дня назад

You should rank all Tolkien books/series from worst to best (:

@senseiAR 2 месяца назад

Can you make a new "what if video"? I would like to know "what if bilbo joined the fellowship"

@spencergellsworth 2 месяца назад

Weird how much of this ended up in the Hobbit movies. Or in the purist fan edits that are the only versions I can stand to watch.

@colinbaldwin313 2 месяца назад

Do you own a copy of the original 1937 Hobbit? I've heard that it's one of those books which is now only sold online for exorbitant prices.

@adpirtle 2 месяца назад

I think Tolkien took the right approach with the third edition, making very small tweaks that brought The Hobbit more (though by no means entirely) in line with his larger mythology without sucking all of the charm out of it. Excising the narrator would have been the worst sin, but I also don't think The Hobbit needs to be chock full of references to its sequel.

@vladtheimpaler9577 2 месяца назад

Fanfiction is underrated.

@evanseifert8858 2 месяца назад

Nice.

@laurajasmin7624 2 месяца назад

I’m curious if the “she” that is referred to is Ingahild Grathmer 🤔

@Cyberdemon1542 2 месяца назад

I think an explanation is that Bilbo is an unreliable narrator and just made some stuff up and embellished other stuff. It doesn't mean it's "untrue" but rather it is true from his point of view. Him writing that Gollum gave him the ring, may be an attempt to look himself more heroic than he actually is.

@jamesanderson7379 2 месяца назад

Do Tolkien fans like the hobbit movies? or is it just me.

@trissy8820 2 месяца назад

Im sure its a mixed bag but as others would say. Im pretty sure theres a good three hour movie in the trilogy if you chop off a lot of the fat, a big less cgi/green screen and tone down the cartoon physics. But its not nearly ad egregious as amazons filth Rings of Power.

@anni.68 2 месяца назад

@@trissy8820 Why do you believe that RoP is "egregious"?

@trissy8820 2 месяца назад

@@anni.68 it simply just disrespects the source material (i know they're in their own universe, version of middle earth whatever you wanna call it) while clearly requiring pieces of the source material to function narratively, while saying they're doing their own thing. Not to mention the main character is a rude generally mean person who goes as far as to threaten gynecide of a species while absolutely nobody but the bad guys acknowledge that behavior. I could literally go on for paragraphs about how this plot line is contrived and not really worth any Tolkien fans time, but i can also leave a link to a good 12 hour or so break down as to why the show is bad put far better than i can. But the author of this series put more work into his video series than the show runners did into the show ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-EAam2VRq6wM.html

@Enerdhil 2 месяца назад

I have only watched The Hobbit movies once. There are a lot of things to like, but many more to hate. I suppose PJ and Philippa had to include a female character to get women and girls into the theaters, but Tauriel?! Nooo!😱

@Enerdhil 2 месяца назад

@@trissy8820 I generally agree with everything you posted, but I am not sure The Hobbit series was any better than TRoP. I think the one thing that makes it hard to figure out why the show runners made the storylines they did was they did not have hardly any rights to The Silmarillion or Unfinished Tales. That means that if they had made a lore-accurate series, they would have been sued by the Tolkien Estate. My hat is off to Bezos for coming up with this scheme.. What an ingenious way for him to get the intersectional series he wanted based on the skeletal entries in the LotR Appendix B. He is forced to present a lot of new characters and events in the series to "fill in" what's missing from the Appendix. Take Galadriel, for example. She did very little in the Second Age, so if Bezos has Galadriel featured in season one, he is not violating his contract with the Tolkien Estate. See what I mean?

@kerickwalters2749 2 месяца назад

I was slightly miffed at the changes made in the LOTR films .. but what was done to The Hobbit was akin to blasphemy.

@lonewolf5238 2 месяца назад

I don't know if you read comments, but if you do, I would ask for your forthright opinion on Peter Jackson's three part treatment of Tolkien's classic work, the Hobbit.

@Enerdhil 2 месяца назад

It sucked.🤪