Тёмный

Tombow or WHSmith Dual Brush Pens - review: half the price, but which is best for urban sketching? 

Liz Chaderton
Подписаться 50 тыс.
Просмотров 11 тыс.
50% 1

I love Tombow dual brush pens for urban sketching or nature sketching, but they are REALLY expensive. So when I spotted that WHSmith do a dual brush pen, I wondered if they would be any good. They are half the price, but are they half the quality?
Two artists I really admire, Ian Fennelly and John Muir Laws, both recommend the Tombow Dual Brush Pen, so I gave them a go and I love them. It's great for your initial sketch and the lines will melt away when you put watercolour on top. They are good for adding tone, without adding water - so important when working on location. And the brush pen is fabulous for window panes! You are often fighting with time when sketching, so anything which saves a bit and lets you get information down is alright with me!
After a quick internet search, all I could find were reviews from calligraphers and they seemed to think the WHSmith ones were okay. In fact, more than okay. But hand lettering people don't ask the questions I need to know the answers to, so I decided to do my own comparison. As an artist, I need to know about the colour range, the blendability, transparency, light fastness.
In this film I compare the two available grey sets. Costs are correct as of April 2021. I compare the colour range and how they blend on cartridge and watercolour paper, along with whether they are warm/cool and if they split when thinned with water.
I won't give the conclusion away, but I think you might be pleasantly surprised! It's worth a watch if you want to save yourself some money.
If you enjoyed this review, then you might like to know I do a weekly watercolour tip, trick or technique which I wish someone had told me when I started to paint. I usually post it on Sunday evening, so if you want to be kept up to date, please subscribe.
Tags: Liz Chaderton, Ian Fennelly, John Muir Laws, urban sketching, usk, plein air, Tombow dual brush pens, WHSmith dual brush pens, review, how good, how to use, grey, gray, tone, detail, sketching, drawing, which is better, blending, uv resistance, light resistance, permanence, brush pens, dual brush pens, fray, fraying

Развлечения

Опубликовано:

 

7 авг 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 47   
@tracylamarca575
@tracylamarca575 10 месяцев назад
I watched this because I saw Tombow dual brush markers were an optional supply in the Line and Wash course. I use dual brush markers for rubberstamping - I had some Tombows ages ago - right now I have several different inexpensive brands I've had for a long time. Not a lot of neutral colors, so for "fun," I looked around online at Tombow pens and...I found a GREAT deal at Micheals' craft store here in the US. They have some packs of TEN on sale for $14.99! I buy yarn regularly from Michaels, but not usually art supplies, as they are usually too expensive. But this was quite a good sale AND I had a voucher to use as I earn money each time I buy yarn! (I'm telling you this whole story as it goes along with being "frugal" - the Scrooge comment you made still makes me laugh!) Of course, to be REALLY frugal, I wouldn't buy any at all, but since I can use them for a variety of uses, I DID buy them! Greyscales, Portrait Colors, and a Michaels exclusive Watercolor Favorites. And adding in some yarn (that was on sale, of course - I ONLY buy it on sale!) - I got free shipping. So that was satisfying "retail therapy!"
@LizChadertonArt
@LizChadertonArt 10 месяцев назад
sorry to be the cause of extra supplies! but that sounds like a bargain!
@ninafairyart
@ninafairyart 3 года назад
Really clear and informative! Your sketches are breathtaking 😍
@LizChadertonArt
@LizChadertonArt 3 года назад
Thank you so much! I have really missed urban sketching during lockdown
@joycolville3438
@joycolville3438 2 года назад
Love your sketches can see your style shining through even with buildings. You live in a beautiful area lots of fodder for interesting buildings. Thanks Liz
@LizChadertonArt
@LizChadertonArt 2 года назад
Thank you so much 😀 I was out sketching some beautiful Victorian buildings over the weekend.
@sueallen952
@sueallen952 Год назад
I just caved and bought a pack of Tombow because of all the hype, did not like them, found they were streaky and didn't blend well. On the other hand I have 2 sets of the WHSmith pastels and normal colours, fantastic markers!!! Great to see a review on them, also the Arrtx are fantastic!!!
@LizChadertonArt
@LizChadertonArt Год назад
Oh no!
@juststartingover2735
@juststartingover2735 10 месяцев назад
I agree about Tombow..they do not blend easily, easier to pull out a paint pallet🫤
@lovebritishhistory
@lovebritishhistory 3 года назад
A great review Liz, thank you!
@LizChadertonArt
@LizChadertonArt 3 года назад
Glad it was helpful! I do like using the brush pens
@LisbethDavies
@LisbethDavies Год назад
I really enjoyed this! I have a Tombow N65 that I bought at the Burghfield May Fayre pre-pandemic and had intended on buying more this week but having watched this, I now have a pack of WH Smiths pens in my Ebay basket instead - thank you!
@LizChadertonArt
@LizChadertonArt Год назад
Glad it was helpful! I’ve found they’ve stood up to the test of time well
@LisbethDavies
@LisbethDavies Год назад
@@LizChadertonArt Oh that's even better, thank you!
@charlottesmom
@charlottesmom 2 года назад
Your sketches are gorgeous!!! 💕
@LizChadertonArt
@LizChadertonArt 2 года назад
Thank you so much!!
@recoveringsoul755
@recoveringsoul755 2 года назад
What stunning large beautiful sketches you have!! So impressed. It's a shame the tombows aren't light-fast. I got a set of 11 partly because there was a grey but it was darker than I wanted for shadows
@LizChadertonArt
@LizChadertonArt 2 года назад
Yes, it is a real shame about the lightfastness. They are fine for sketch books. You can get uv protective sprays, which might help.
@niksiever3135
@niksiever3135 5 месяцев назад
Overall, I prefer the Tombow pens but I do lavender that pinkish separation on the WHS black.
@LizChadertonArt
@LizChadertonArt 5 месяцев назад
agreed on preference but it’s not so marked that for the price difference I would go with the cheaper
@daksta50
@daksta50 4 месяца назад
I thought the tombows blended better by not retaining the swatch edge as much as the smiths. Take out the pink black from Smiths and you’ve got 5 against 5 with the bonus of a blender in the tombows. Not to mention the more subtle light grey to extend the range. Tombows are pricier but I’d say a better choice. The longer tombows may proportionally last longer as well. Plus they’re numbered, making replacement a bit easier. If you were to spread the cost over the life of the pens, would it be worth opting for the smith’s?
@LizChadertonArt
@LizChadertonArt 4 месяца назад
of course only you can answer that for you. The point of the film is to show whether they are a good alternative…and they are. I do like the Tombows better but the difference is marginal, so for people on a limited budget the WHS are a good alternative. I needed to get six sets for a workshops, so it made sense to save a lot of upfront cost and they’ve held up very well.
@jmbosquesillo7203
@jmbosquesillo7203 7 месяцев назад
Thanks! I love those brush pens. I use them like watercolor for shadows and such, they smooth out and blend great with a water brush/brush. No clue what the cost is over there across the pond but they're under $15 for most 10 packs here.
@LizChadertonArt
@LizChadertonArt 7 месяцев назад
That sounds like a good deal to me!!
@susanhepburn6040
@susanhepburn6040 3 года назад
Thank you, Liz.
@LizChadertonArt
@LizChadertonArt 3 года назад
My pleasure, I hope you found it helpful
@bixnash1
@bixnash1 2 года назад
I like the WHS black with the purple tinge. I have zig pens which are = to tombow and love them. Paper makes a massive difference to this testing I found. Bx
@LizChadertonArt
@LizChadertonArt 2 года назад
interesting! never heard of Zig pens. will google.NYC’s paper makes a huge difference. pens which are waterproof on one May move on another.
@LizChadertonArt
@LizChadertonArt 2 года назад
just looked. Their watercolour brush pens don’t have the dual tip? or am I looking at the wrong ones?
@bixnash1
@bixnash1 2 года назад
They are exactly the same as tombow. Dual tipped. But......I did buy them years ago in France as I couldn't get tombow but they are still going strong. But I did find them in Amazon and I think they are quite a bit more expensive than Tombows.....the works do a similar product too but only work on certain papers. Cartridge is good. Bx
@LizChadertonArt
@LizChadertonArt 2 года назад
@@bixnash1 very useful to know! Thank you.
@misspinkkitty69
@misspinkkitty69 3 года назад
Hi Liz have you tried the Windsor and Newton brush markers. The have an artist pigment ink.
@LizChadertonArt
@LizChadertonArt 3 года назад
I have tried the WN pigment marker., but to be blendable they have to be used on a coated paper, I believe. They are light fast, which is great, but don't have the transparency I am after. I also found the chisel tip frays really quickly and the bullet tip is very thick. Do you use them?
@stellaball7289
@stellaball7289 Год назад
Really useful review! How did you find them over time?
@LizChadertonArt
@LizChadertonArt Год назад
They are still going strong!
@pesto12601
@pesto12601 8 месяцев назад
Your work certainly copies the Fennelly approach but pull it off amazing well.. I can only hope to one achieve the shading and perspective choices that seem to come easily to you.
@LizChadertonArt
@LizChadertonArt 8 месяцев назад
I was so excited when I discovered Ian five or so years ago. His work was like mine, but so much better! He played with colour and perspective in just the way I was trying to. I learnt lots from watching him, especially in the use of Tombows. They are a life changer when you are sketching outdoors. I was meant to go on a workshop with him, sadly cancelled when covid struck….
@pesto12601
@pesto12601 8 месяцев назад
@@LizChadertonArt Thx Liz for all you do to share on your channel.. I learn a ton just for watching your videos and would love to see a video where you show how to use the tombows... I have a full set of them as well as faber castell pitt makers in gray shades which I carry in my urban kit. Thx again!
@LizChadertonArt
@LizChadertonArt 8 месяцев назад
I’ll certainly see what I can do! @@pesto12601
@margaretmaguire3329
@margaretmaguire3329 Год назад
They can all be purchased individually the tombows
@LizChadertonArt
@LizChadertonArt Год назад
you are right, they can, i’s just handy having a range of greys and a bit more economic in a set…
@gorway7
@gorway7 Год назад
Yes, and I like the fact that tombow have cool / neutral/ warm greys as opposed to just tints of the same neutral grey. I only use 2, a light warm and a light cool and it's easy to just get one or both replaced when I need. Think I paid about £2.75 on ebay last time.
@LizChadertonArt
@LizChadertonArt Год назад
@@gorway7 Sound good!
@arthurmee
@arthurmee Год назад
You might know this already Jimmy Page has always enjoyed art and did go to Art College before becoming a rock god. 😊
@LizChadertonArt
@LizChadertonArt Год назад
I’ve been told that! I did see him in a local pub once….
@charlottesmom
@charlottesmom 2 года назад
I got the whole set of Tombows, stinks they are not lightfast.
@LizChadertonArt
@LizChadertonArt 2 года назад
It is a real shame - great for sketch books or something you might want to reproduce, but not for original artwork....
Далее
The lightweights ended Round One with a BANG 💪
00:10
#kikakim
00:23
Просмотров 11 млн
E35 :: Story of Ian Fennelly, the Artist
26:54
Просмотров 24 тыс.
Sketchbook Tour with Ian Fennelly | Urban Sketching
10:33
Sketching Brussels with Ian Fennelly
14:54
Просмотров 76 тыс.
Fast and simple urban sketching
25:51
Просмотров 8 тыс.
INSIDE OUT Inspired Art That Is At Another Level ▶ 2
20:25
SKETCHING Venice with Brush Pens by IAN FENNELLY
13:26
ГНЕЗДО ОС (@willkofficial - TikTok)
0:17
Просмотров 1,6 млн
Шойгу посадят?
1:00
Просмотров 3,5 млн