Top 25 Dancers on So You Think You Can Dance All Seasons 

These are only my favourites, so please respect my opinion. Since this show is all about being able to perform in different styles, that was my main criteria in making this ranking. I know some big favourites, including winners, are missing but it's because they weren't that versatile. No matter how amazing they are in their own style. Please comment down below with your favourites. P.S. I don't know why I said that Gaby is the only tap winner, I totally forgot about Lex when I wrote that.

I would've added Melanie Moore, Jasmine Harper, Marko Germar, Robert Roldan, Alex Wong, and Mark Kanemura to my list. I loved Gaby, Lauren, Lex, Allison, Travis, and Jeanine.

I agree with many of your choices but feel you were remiss in not including Melanie Moore season 8 winner and consummate all star and Alex Wong season 7. IMHO he would have won his season had he not ruptured his Achilles’ tendon. He also returned in an all star capacity. I do respect your choices and at this level, honestly, they are all deserving of high praise.

I miss SYTYCD so much. I always loved Twitch. 😍

Nice summaries of your assessments. Very enjoyable!

GREAT Video and hard to dispute your selects. That said, we ALL have our favorites and my top, all time "STAR" has to be Melanie Moore. Charisma and her impact on the overall show are unrivaled. Close second for me would be Fikshun who was not as complete or as trained as many of your top 25, but again, charisma and star-quality mean so much on this show. Last mention and is of course the most beautiful and mesmerizing dancer I feel on the series, Kathryn.

Eliana Girard is my favorite. I just wish there was room for her but your picks are good

Seeing THE Miss Ellenore Scott on the list is pretty much well-deserved, I would think. Like how the fuck did she manage to survive that wardrobe malfunction waiting to happen at the Argentine Tango routine (great choreography BTW)

I like your choices but Danny Tidwell and Travis Wall are some of the best of all time. They would have been #2 & #1

Lex Ishimoto should be in the top 3 dancers on SYTYCD. Even though, he wasn't too great at ballroom, he put up amazing performances on both of his ballroom dancing. Even Nigel Lythgoe said that Lex was a great all-around dancer. Ballroom dancing needs two people to perform and it is hard to judge individual performances based on it. When it comes to individual performances, Lex is second to none.

Absolutely phenomenal list! I agree with so many of your choices and you've shown me some earlier season dancers I wasn't familiar with, so thank you!

I agree with a lot of these. I love that you didn’t overlook Lacey and Lauren. They are both amazing! The only real big disappointment was no Alex. I know he had to leave early, but I have no doubt he would have won had he not gotten injured. Great list though! Couples next?!?

I so agree with your list versatility is so impt some winners are not versatile

Still to this day can't believe Jakob didn't win his season.

The fact that Melanie Moore didn’t make this list is an actual crime (but I did like your choices otherwise)

Lex belongs in the top five

Hard to choose between all the fabulous dancers that appeared...some really wonderful performances..thanks for posting

Nice compilation! Danny not at #1 is a crime and Sabra not on the list?!?!? Wil & Brandon & Lex…. I can never get enough of watching them

I totally agree that Danny or Lacey shouldve won season 3, Ive always said I think they got screwed because it was time for a female winner and they couldnt have Lacey win right after Benji won. Nothing against Sabra of course she was amazing but Danny and Lacey are just some of the greatest ever.

Jeanine actually did a good job at ballroom even if her partners didn’t do that well. If she had a ballroom dancer as a partner to do ballroom I’m sure it would’ve been a standout routine

I want you to know that I really appreciate your videos. I got into Sytycd late so I have not recorded any season. I miss this show and wish I could own all the seasons (I know copyright prevents it but I can wish).

Kathryn McCormick is one of the best contemporary girls the shows ever had and plus she was versatile too!

OMG THANK YOU!!!!! I agree sooo much, Gino DEFINITELY should have won. He was my favorite, but I also love Bailey and Mariah too.

I agree with your list, but Alex Wong deserves a spot in this list I guess.

There have been soo many great dancers on SYTYCD you can't go wrong with any of them. I will say some winners were surprises but when you remember that SYTYCD is about America's Favorite Dancer so technique alone won't win it for you it makes sense.

I'm just rewatching this and decided to comment. Of the 'non-winners', my favorites are Danny, Will, Billy, Janette, Allison and Koine. I was so sad when Will, Billy, Janette and Allison didn't even make it to the Top 4.

..INCRÍVEL..........ESPETACULAR..........

Yes!

A great list and some awesome dancers. Alex, Robert Roldan, Eliana, Melanie, Makenzie, Lauren Gottlieb, and Marko would be in my top 25. Lex would be in my top 5.

Blake McGrath isn't a top 25? He was probably the best dancer in S1 but they didn't want him to win for obvious reasons.

No Marko or Robert Roldan is just crazy

Jenna? Witney? Jazmine? Blake?

I don’t remember what her last name is but Melanie???? She won her season? Anyway she should defs be added to this list

Wait a minute Twitch wasn’t on this list nor Joshua season 3 winner? 🤯🤯🤔🤔🤦🏾‍♀️🤦🏾‍♀️

If memory serves me, your #2 pick - season 12 winner Gabby - had to audition twice (i.e. in two different cities) 'cause there were no audition-callbacks that year. Changing subjects, I'm surprised Melony didn't make your top 25.

Justice for Melanie Moore! LOL.

No one in season 17 could come close to any of these. This year is SO horrible it's embarrassing.

i dont agree but i love your choices

NEIL HASKELL?

I was with you most of the way until Melanie was not top 5, Alex wasn't in the list, and Mark didn't at least get an honorable mention.

No Melanie Moore! Any SYTYCD best without her is incomplete.

I would add tWitch, Amy Yakima, and Alex Wong!

Freaking weird choices for top 2

No anya and pasha

i dont agree but i love your choices