This is all based on opinion. Just because we don't like some songs from a band doesn't mean we hate the band. Averages: PhantomSD: 6.54 Lilly: 7.23 Kaizer: 6.42
If anyone is intrested this is my band ranking: 1: Roselia 2: Afterglow 3: Poppin'Party 4: Raise a Suilen 5: HHW 6: PasuPare 7: New shitty boy band/Argonavis Other than 7 I like them all.
@@someoneelseishere5964 Yeah, that was uncalled for in my part. My apologies. Argonavis the new boy band in my opinion is terrible. I hated the 4 songs they released so far.
PhantomSD can you make the video with just Kaizer’s and Lilly’s scores. You are completely entitled to your opinion but I would be more entertained looking at somewhat objective viewpoints and your nonstop incorporation of preferences are heavily hyper aggressive and incredibly biased. If you feel like it, I wanna see the video with those deliberately trying to think analytical and build scores rather than seeing nothing but one person giving ugly scores that fuck up the whole average because they’re angry at a band they hate and because they can’t sit aside that preference. You have every right to your opinion. BUT their actual analysis would make this video much more entertaining rather than someone blowing out the total because they’re not actually being remotely critical.
@@Allen-yv5xg First, I don't hate any of the bands, but frankly some of the are at most OK bands. I try to be as unbiased and critical as possible can but I can't just give a a higher score to songs that I don't like. But, Sorry you feel that way.
MayaFey Plush Well to me Roselia songs are very good but they need more music diversity. They really do because I used to love them but as I went on I started to get really bored. Pastel palettes and hello happy aren’t boring it seems like you haven’t read the story nor listened to their songs. I recommend listening to all of them carefully before you call them “bland” and “nothing special”.
For now, I find that every band has their own reasons to do live, Popipa,they want to find the "heart pounding moments" and sparklin thingy... Roselia, they just want to be the first because they believe they can make impossible songs.. Afterglow, they just want to hang out..... Pastel Pallete, they are idols so I *didnt* hate them so much..... HHW, wants to make world smile....
The rating of any song below 40 in a nutshell Person A: Hmm, this is pretty good Person B: I agree, it's really good indeed Person C: NOPE IT'S THE WORST SONG IN THE HISTORY OF MANKIND And the position of Person C keeps rotating between the three.
Donny Whisnu Kaizer has a taste for rock or metal music I would bet, it’s biased yeah but lilly is also pretty bias about their song choices. Just like how they only prefer pop or happy music. Phantom just tries not to be bias and is more interested in how well the song is made.
Am I the only one here whose taste is pretty random like I don't think a single cover song is that bad?(and also the fact I dont actually favor a band for covers like whenever I like the song it's either the cover is better than the original or something like that?)
I really like most covers. Engrish can pass most of the time, like for red fraction and life will change. Reach out for the truth is just I- WHAT. I can’t understand almost anything. In the original you could have heard more! But, I don’t hate Afterglow. They have great songs like Butterfly and Roki. (Edit) Afterglow covers are my love and happiness along with sorairo days, the upcoming morfonica cover, alot of hhw covers, and the song that got me into persona, kimi no kioku. Also i love you reach out to the truth.
Nothing wrong about it though, it's normal. My opinion's even worse... like, worst song of Roselia is even better than any Pasupare song. Lmao forgive me Pasupare fans.
I'M F**KING DYING, IN 8:43 THAT SERIOUS AND EPIC SCENE OF FIGHTING SAMURAI IN DARK AND THAT CUTE AND UNTROUBLE SONG BY PALETTES, THIS IS SO FUNNY I'M DYING LOL HELP
pasupare has such low rankings for most of their songs... who hurt you guys (except for lilly apparently). and then roselia on the other hand is like, concentrated at the top though, it’s kind of heartwarming in a way seeing most of the songs have a decent overall score? by the time the video’s at its halfway point the overall scores have already entered the 7s which is neat......
@@negarhythm nonono xd i mean the rubriks or criteria should have been about their voice or something, not what they've covered, apparently they just based it on their taste of music.=3= I also noticed that they gave low rankinngs on pasupare. Nevertheless nice video!
Same...if it were a serious rating I think it's easier to digest when you remember it's just a preference thing rather than a serious technical score. We all have our 1s somewhere lol
@@sylvierose2799 Sorry for this essay lmao, but the other English songs you mentioned are 'Life Will Change' and 'Red Fraction', right? Kasumi and Yukina sing those songs. As a native English speaker (yes, I was born and raised in england >.
Thank you for respecting my opinion. (some people in my comment section don't.) I thought Kaoru's voice was really good. But what ruined the song for me was Kokoro. Her singing really didn't fit the song, imo.
@@PHANT0MSD good thought, we are at the same stand I guess xD Kokoro's part i think made it a bit of a downfall. Overall still good song. And yes, as I observed the other comments almost everyone can't withstand the ratings given.
@@bintangsalt2975 real concert?? ._. of course they are lol, their seiyuu can playing their instruments after all. even then there is RAS making the other 3 band buried more under RAS name to actually do live :v
The fact "Reach Out to the Truth" was so low really hurts my heart since it's from my favorite Persona game 💔but "God Knows" being in the top 25, "Discotheque" being number 21 and "Life Will Change" aka my favorite Persona 5 song being number 17 makes up for Persona 4 being so low Edit: also "Hare Hare Yukai" for me personally would've been higher on the list while "Shunkan Sentimental" would've been much higher just because I have so much love Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood❤️ Also "Kimi no Kioku" has to be my favorite Persona cover because of how much it sounds like the original and deserved to be a little higher same goes for the Attack on Titan song but happy to see "The Crow Song" pretty far up the list also I'm very happy to see "Cruel Angel's Thesis" in the top 3 but personally that song would be number 1 for me
Reach out to the truth sounded very off. Same thing with kimi no kioku. Kimi no kioku is one of my favorite songs of all time but the cover from Roselia just sounded weird to me.
Bandori and I have been in a relationship for about a year now and lately I’ve noticed us drifting apart. I’ve been seeing another game the past couple of days, Love Nikki. We were together a while ago but I knew we weren’t meant together. This video inspired me to not let go of BanG Dream, we’ve had so many amazing memories together, I can’t leave.
If u asked me to rank Hello, happy world cover songs Romeo 10 Gogo maniac 10 Dragon night 10 Shin takarajima 10 Love trial 9.9 Happy summer wedding 9.9 Himawari yakusoku 9.9 Alien 9.5 Taiyou iwaku chaos 9.5 1,2 Fanclub 9 Koi wa chaos simobenari 9 Fantastic dreamer 8 Silhoutte 8 No bias, i like all bands, except yukina, i dont like her and her story (not songs) xD,
6.5/10 on popipa glamorous sky. 8.9/10 on roselia zankokuna tenshi no teeze. have them listened to the original ones? sigh. i believe this was biased. i smell subjectivity on rating
I don’t exactly judge by band, I just like listening to the covers. My thoughts are subject to change very fast anyways and could never be accurately quantified by numbers (which I think is a weird practice in and of itself), it just depends on my mood. Some are catchier than others or have more of a connection for me, sure, but I dunno, I like listening to all five bands’ covers.
In terms of their opinion (which is basically what this is), I actually had fun seeing their preferences shine! lol If these were in terms of genre/technical stuff I think then I'd tweak and salt a little ll9 -but yes Lilly mvp-
Thanks lilly for scoring fairly. The other reviewers are being too biased because they don’t like pasupare or hhw. I love aya voice and also miku really makes a great voice with kokoro. The band I cant stand is afterglow, hate that weird voice.
It’s called opinions they are scoring off of what THEY like! Lily may like others more than the other two who cares ppl are complaining over other people’s opinions which I think is stupid :/
It’s personal opinion, so it may seem biased to someone who doesn’t share those opinions. I thought he was p chill but that’s cuz I have similar tastes
Guys I don't think they are biased atleast for me the ranks are according for songs I know and vocaloid covers on top though some songs sure are biased!! Still it's their list . Also to PhantomSD Argonavis is not shitty maybe give them more time!!!
Oof my most favorite band is HHW (HHW>>>>>>>>the rest) but I like all the songs, I don’t think I have any I particularly dislike. If I had to rank them tho, Afterglow would be last since I have the least amount of favorite songs from them (Faves being Lost One’s Weeping, Hey-Day Capriccio and Crow Song)
Feel so bad for whoever Lilly is. While I disagree with a lot of low scores I can tell like she’s the only one actually trying to be objective and validate their opinion and everyone is FUCKING draining the score because they just simply DONT like the band and aren’t trying to be analytical at all F for them.
i don't really care for the bias but like holy shit i've been into vocaloid for forever and i didn't even know that that was miku miku ni shite ageru's pv (i do think you're all being a little harsh on them; it's a group vote, and everyone is undoubtedly going to have different tastes, especially in a small group like this. with them all having vastly different tastes, it's honestly perfect.)
People need to calm down. This video is opinion based. So what? Personally I think it's interesting to see what type of music different people are into. Not everything needs to be super serious. Phantom was just trying to have fun making a video with his friends. Chill out.
