As much as I like Owen, I found it confusing that he wasn’t even _considered_ for elimination in the horror movie episode after he shoved Izzy in front of the killer.
Leshawna's season 2 elimination was also terribly written. No one knows what would make Harold get dumbed down and trust the villains (Duncan, Courtney, and Justin) in voting off Leshawna. This happened shortly after Beth convinced Harold to vote off Duncan. The fact that Harold chose to side with two of the people that he did not like, just to get rid of his home girl (Leshawna) over someone who has been constantly mean to him (Duncan). Leshawna never has a decently-written elimination. Season 1 had her eliminated because Chris counted every mention of Leshawna as a vote, while Season 2 had her home boy Harold dumbed down and side with the villains. Season 3 was already confirmed her elimination (at the hands of Alejandro) the moment we saw the trailer in 2009/2010. If that's not enough, she beats Heather up, even though the former mean girl is trying to be honest and talk Leshawna down.
Finally someone understands that! Everyone talks about how bullshit LeShawnas Island elimination was, and though I agree, *very* few people, other LeShawna fans included, talk about how her other eliminations were just as bad, if not worse
The most unfair elimination by far is Leshawnas in TDI it’s ridiculous none of the jury wanted Leshawna gone the shows creators just wanted to come up with a way to get her out because they wouldn’t have been able to do it fairly
I think the reason Owen was so insistent on voting off Beth in TDI was because he realized if the others thought a little bit more, they’d realize they lost also in part due to him.
No elimination tops Leshawna's one. She was suppose to win season 1 from what I heard. She's so underrated and really a great competitor. To do well twice getting 5th in island, 8th in Action only to come 15th in world tour made me sad 😢. I was hoping she'd get added to all stars and have another chance, but as we all know every character was ruined that season and horribly casted.
You could had also mentioned Search and Do Not Destroy, another case of Heather escaping elimination and another person gets the boot instead, in this case, it's Trent. This is the most infuriating case of Heather escaping elimination in the first season, at least to me. Not only she drove a wedge between Trent's relationship with Gwen by kissing him, but Heather also gets a gift basket with immunity, once again being granted undeserved plot armor at the expense of someone else, and it has to be Trent, the victim of Heather's sleazy scheme.
I'm actually glad you mentioned Zeke's tdi elimination, because yeah it was super unfair from a writing perspective. Homeboy wasn't even actively malicious, he's just spewing the beliefs his father had, while Courtney was actively toxic to everybody. Heck, Zeke was willing to jump and even had no complaints about making the hot tub. But the writers wanted to plot armor Courtney so hard, both him and Tyler had to suffer bs eliminations.
@@ListsofLegends There was another elimination that was shocking (at least from my perspective anyway) in World Tour with Zeke when he lost the stick. If he hadnt lost the stick there wouldve been no elimination at all that episode and Zeke might not have needed to turn feral for his story to continue. Even if he got eliminated in a later episode he couldve at least had some dignity instead of how it went down.
I think the IDEA behind Geoff’s elimination was suppose to be that the other campers assumed that the winner of the season is decided on by a majority vote; whether that be from an outside source, or by other campers (similar to the finale of total drama action). In that way, the reasoning of voting him off for being the nicest guy makes sense.
The campers really seemed kind of dumb to assume this, rather than the last episode being a final mega challenge for the prize. The only time there was ever a vote for the winner was because Beth and Duncan tied for the final challenge (though that aftermath episode was very entertaining 😂)
Leshawnas elimination in TDI was just Unfair. Everyone said her name by accident (accept Katie and Sadie) And even the bird said her name, Twice! I think she was actually supposed to win the first season. #LeshawnaDeservesBetter
True. I thinks that why she was eliminated(that’s if They already planned on who the winner of TD Would be), it would interfere with the finale of it just being Owen and Gwen. Again Like I said, That’s if they already planned on the winner of TD would be. So we can’t be sure if this is why.
At TDI episode 22, when the eliminated contestants were gonna vote someone for the dock of shame, Leshawna was eliminated but if I was there I will straight up say Heather 10+ times.
I always felt like Justin's TDI elimination brings how nice the Screaming Gophers members really are into question. Specially Owen, who's supposed to be likeable. Yet he sold out and didn't do the right thing all because of a cake.
@@InsertFunnyThingHere He might not hate her, but that is besides the point. She did something wrong, while Justin did nothing wrong (hell, he even helped put out the fire early in the episode). Cake or not, it was a pretty obvious vote there, but the writers needed to keep Heather around.
Some eliminations just felt rushed like Anne Maria for an example, she could've had a bigger role if she stayed around longer but it was wasted cause of the fake diamond, then Amy and Samey, first off Samey was literally only in one episode after Amy's elimination, she needed WAY more screentime and please explain how Amy even got back to the island just to get back at Samey? If that was the case lots of other competitors could've done what she did
I’m just gonna say it here, Total Drama does not work in the 13 episode format, it gives them so little time to flesh these characters out. There’s a reason why people love the first three seasons and the Ridonculous Race so much.
All of leshawna and lindsays eliminations felt like a "oh well, lindsay was just a filler and leshawna was getting old" when neither was the case, they both should have made a come back or at least made it back into the game. heathers whole TDI thing with justin just felt super forced
In the second TDI Izzy elimination statistically heather should have been voted out when comparing how many people voted Izzy vs how many people almost definitely voted heather
Woo, coming up to bat for All-Stars. Alejandro was a dead man walking in All-Stars. He would have gone in Regatta if he didn't win, and he definitely got lucky in Zeek and Ye Shall Find. He was a pariah going into the season, only focused on getting revenge on Heather, and once he did that he wasn't fussed about being seen as anti-social. Sure, he did end up being framed for some of the drama, but he wasn't helping himself. Duncan's thing in All-Stars wasn't that he was never nice before, it's that he was having a breakdown dealing with the erosion of his bad boy image and the possibility of him not actually living up to that idea any more. In Island he was still very much seen as dangerous, but it'd had been at least a year since World Tour in All-Stars, and there wasn't any indication that he'd gotten up to anything while dating Gwen. Considering how much of his ego has been tied to his image from the start, it's no wonder he deteriorates when the edginess seems to be waning. Courtney seemed to have snapped to using Gwen a couple of episodes prior, so forgiveness or not she was setting herself up for failure. Chris probably changed the challenge on a whim because he legitimately hates Courtney (which is probably why she went in World Tour too, once her usefulness for drama had come to an end). And Zoey getting immunity is irrelevant to the elimination, because if it wasn't her it would be Scott, and he was gunning for Courtney at that point. Lindsay...I just defer to the one comment already here that talks about it being a joke that people take too seriously. Let's not forget gags like her being confused by the instructions of Hide and Seek way back in TDI.
iF fANFICS COUNT THEN YOU COULD COUNT lESHAWNA IN TD52 as her plan to get Heather booted by putting her in a pit fails as Leswana got the second most votes after Heather, and Chris didn't feel like looking for Heather and decided to eliminate Lesawna instead, Unlike other times Heather stayed in the game this is purely karmic for Leshawna as unlike in TDI it was Leswana own undoing for not thinking things through
actually the whole geoff being a good guy for the reasoning of his boot in island is just a lazy excuse to vote him off especially when he wasn't a good guy when you look at the whole harold bullying
Leshawna has the most unfair eliminations... Heather should have gotten out a bunch of times in TDI, Duncan could have been voted out instead of Courtney (I'm glad she got voted out though), and I swear most of the All-Stars eliminations were hot garbage
How come Noah's WT elimination is there but Staci's elimination isn't? They had pretty much the same type of elimination, their team should've won but due to Chris suddenly giving the opposing team the win, they get voted off instead, fair vote, but their team should've won. Justin's TDI elimination wasn't really shocking either. Heather getting 5 votes mean in a tie? Yea, but it's just that someone voted off someone else, probably Cody voted for Trent because he was jealous of him how Gwen actually likes Trent over him. How exactly would Heather being in TDI final 2 would make the finale better? Owen vs Gwen was just great, Heather being in the finale, wouldn't improve it, infact instead it would make it worse, way worse. TDI is not her season to win, WT exists, so I don't get your comment there. About Lindsay's AS elimination and the scene where she doesn't know how to push a cart, I feel like most people overreact to this way too much, yea it was sorta dumb, but it was a one-off joke that wasn't meant to be taken too seriously, she pushes it normally after that, she was just tired, and even then, Lindsay was never that bright, so it's not exactly out of character.
I cant agree with you on the last one. Also Lindsay saying no lipgloss is worth total drama is out of character as well. As you can see. Somehow they managed to f up lindsays entire character in 1 episode by these 2 things. Not knowing how to push is extremely out of character even for lindsay
@@autumnvelkoz4523 Courtney only made Lindsay push the cart because the other Heroes could not decide. In fact, if Chris did not care about the love triangle drama to determine teams (Gwen was a villain for how she ended up with Duncan, while Courtney (completely disregarding her antagonistic role in season 2 and 3) is treated as the victim), Gwen (a rightful hero instead of Courtney) would never force Lindsay into pushing the cart, sealing the fate to one of the show's most kind-hearted contestants.
I loved the part where you said “Mr. Coconut getting more time than Ezekiel” damn, what a roast bro, but so true but my favorite WTF elimination moment, not exactly WTF, but it was the right thing to do. I’m talking about Brick in Total Drama: Revenge of the island. I know Annie Marie you mentioned is gone with him, but Brick had such motivation and potential to be such a greater character for his heroic bravery in the mine episode, he legit sacrificed his life to not 1, not 2, but 3 people on the other team he was versing against in a fucking 3v5 team battle in that episode. No matter what the situation being, by being down to people on his team against the “enemy team” he put his own life at risk to save 3 people from a possible death from the mutant gophers, the mutated Ezekiel, if not, then maybe even the toxic waste when on the verge of death from Mike, Zoey, and Cameron, he put his life on the line…. like a true military man. Even though he got voted off and especially when Jo tries/demands him to leave him, his response…. NEVER leave a soldier behind. Then puts all 3 with the rest of the remaining characters. And flew off into safety, even though he got voted off and lost the 1 million prize, he knew it was worth to lose his spot so far into the game to not win 1 million dollars. And before I stop my lovely reason and passion of why Brick was a wtf vote. He never left anyone behind, friend…. Or foe. Also, I respect Mike, Zoey and Cameron, saluting the eliminated soldier for saving all 3 of their lives. For what I can tell, he is a hero in my book. ❤️🫡 ❤️
DJ probably got eliminated due to it being a purge challenge Basically since DJ probably screamed first, He was eliminated Whenever there is a purge challenge the person who comes last( Or screams first considering DJ)means theyll be eliminated Also DJ is the only TDI character to never get eliminated due to contestant votes Tdi: Purge Tda: Quits WT: Gets disqualified due to being the only one left on the team
Dawn's elimination not being on the list is kind of a wtf moment. There is no way what Scott did should have worked. He was the one holding the bag with all the stolen items in it. At least a couple of people should have been smart enough to be sus of that. Just going to say he didn't have the immunity statue at that point and he should have been the one who went home with such a obviously bad trick to try to get someone else voted off.
Ikr, I get that Dawn was weird and off-putting to most of the other contestants, but framing her as a master thief? Especially when Scott isn’t exactly subtle about his past as a criminal?
People say pi was bad but man all stars makes it look like a masterpiece Zoey should've have been in the finals providing she almost made it to the finals in roti also even all the evidence they gave Zoey she wasn't still convinced that Mal wasn't Mike
Max’s elimination takes the cake for the dumbest elimination to me. Even though I don’t really like Max it still made me pissed that Chris just said “you’re out because I say so.”
Yo great video I seen there was some new transitions it looked like tried I think they made the video popped but you might not of known about this but Duncan’s elimination was WTF it has been confirmed duncan chose the elimination and that was unfair no crap he would choose Duncan and also they lost the challenge when they got there first but since they never touched the totem gwen and Heather won then chef chooses who’s out
Anne Maria's elimination is dumb and unfair. She got tricked when that diamond is fake. She changed her mind, but it was too late. Then, she was replaced by Dakota, I mean Baldkota and she's back in the game before she becomes the complete mutated Dakotazoid.
Ella most memorable Heather most hilarious Lindsay most confusing Anne Maria most greedy Courtney most badass Leshawna most wtf Beth most plot amour Geoff most stupid Ezekiel most sexiest Mr coconut most sad
I have an idea for a video Top 10 or 8 whatever number, forget characters, let's be real, some characters like The vegans (Laurie and Miles) are forgotten, even Beardo who was only an episod it's more popular than Vegans
Yeah and Beardo could have been a more helpful teammate to his team than Leonard. Who was that dumb to keep the guy who thinks he is a wizard for another stay. I would have voted off Leonard and kept Beardo!!!
mike is the weakest mal taught scott lesson in all stars he letted fang punch him and carried back to chris that actually helped mal by injuring him and bring him back to chris
well heres my theory why they shouldve voted beth. i have a feeling when beth put that lemon thingy mabober in the vault it had osme stuff in it that caused owen to hallucinate losing them the challenge
When people say that they don't wanna vote Leshawna out, why did Chris make it mean that they wanna vote her out and why does the parrot count? That's totally unfair!
one elimination i always didnt like and i feel nobody talks about is heathers in TDA like duncan and harold just automatically forgive leshawna and the next episode they are back to disliking her
I’m just gonna pretend DJ’s was an off screen vote and he didn’t have enough allies and his screaming gave away his weakness even more than earlier in the season
While i do agree that leshawnas elimination is the most unfair in td history, i cant stop feeling bad for poor trent. He got voted in both the seasons BECAUSE of Gwen, and also got DUMPED by her. Although not eliminating him early in tda wouldve made me dislike him a bit since he woukd become obsessed. But still, i feel like he has 2 of the most unfair eliminations ever
The number 9 obsession was really bad randoms he should have talked to Gwen about it rather than go behind her back but mistakes were made on both sides
lindsay: rigged in the race when leshawna and izzy didnt compete and uncan and owen didnt make it TDA voted herself like cmon TDWT Lost to a shirt (ngl dj's shirt is great) TDAS can push a stroller like she is the shopping queen a storller when its just like a shopping cart
fun fact The reason Lindsey voted herself off in the episode was an excuse cause her voice actress had to leave the studio for reasons for the rest of the season suddenly so they couldn't change the episode
theres a theory mal knows alejandro because he watched world tour and he knows that ale is the most minplutated player in total drama history thats why mal made him look a noob he knows his tricks
