Prof samatar learned his lesson the hard way , you will always be a Somalilander no matter how hard you try to feel at home, they will always look at you as an outsider
Thank you Prof Samatar for the clear and concise delineation of what you have seen in Somali and think. I 100% agree with him. I know lots of Somali people hate or dislike this erudie and honest man simply because of he is from X clan and I belong to Y clan or he is pessimistic. Galyr is my uncle, but I admire AND agree with Pro. Samatar more!
prof: axmed ismail samatar turubka meel kale ka baadh kakakakakkakaka prof galayr tnx adiguna walee waad iga qosliseen wey fiican tahyan in marka maarkaa si cad loo hadlo inkastoo sida qawaan ee loo hadlay ay aad u xumayd
Prof Samater walee waa halyey codkarnimo iyo aqoon aad u xeeldheeri ka muuqato oo sida uu sharaxayo waxyaabihii uu kusoo arkay Muqdisho ay wax badani ku duuganyihiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiin, Living with the reality is the only way that you can succeed.
Professor Samatar as a Northern Somali i agree with you, and i am saddened you had to endure that kind of sickening tribalism. Please do not let it discourage you. Somali nationalism is bigger then what individual unproductive tribalist think or believe. God bless Somalia.
Proff Galaydh waa realistic mowqif kiisu cad yahay oon aan nina u joojin, prof samatar siyasadu nin jilicsan uma baahno oo markiiba cabanaya, Galaydh, c/laahi yusuf buu la tar tamay oo kabadiyay, shariif buu la tar tamay oo ka badiyay, walina macabanayo waayo wax uu dareen san yahay in siyasada ninba malin leeyahay. sidii ay horeba usoo martay as PM, Prof samatar control your emotion.
Prof Samatar adigoo kale haddaan heli laheyn ilaa 10 siyaasi oo muwaadin xalaal ah sidaada oo kale ah waxbaa noo hagaagi lahaa ilaah ha idin xafido adiga iyo kuwa kula midka ah ee qabiilka iyo qurunkiisa ka gudbay oo sidaa cad u qanci kara dad intay soo hor istaagaan.
I felt saddened when Prof. Samatar answered the question and expressed his disappointing experience of Somali's disgustingly clannish politics. I hope he regains confidence and returns soon with clear vision and determination. I hope he finds ways to cope with and endure the anguish he expressed to conquer tribalism and achieve his aims in Somalia and for Somalia.
waa yaab! nin prof ah oo hadna dhaqankiisu yahay kii jaahiliyada, casrigii jahliga dhaqankiisi ayuu cali khalif la yimid ceebtiisa xitaa ma asturi karo, any time dhulbahante iyo khatumo ayuu ka baxi wayay war mesha wa kulan soomaliyeed ee aderaw isku xishood oo hana ceebeen khayr allaha ku siiye
Ninkan Isagaaba ubaahan in uu la qabsado waxa dhabta ah ee ka jira soomaaliya waayo wuxuu u hadlayaa sidii isagoo ah ajnibi ama soo uruuriyay xumaha oo keliya (Negative) sidaas darteed waxaan dhihi karnaa Isagaaba ubaahan in la saxo oo llagu dhaho war ka hadal wanaagga iyo Horumarka dhanka kheyrka ee ha uhadlin sidii nin soo guul dareystay oo weliba waayay wax uu mudo badan raadinayay balse ku soo guul dareystay si ba'an!
and It will be helpful to start building relationship with them first and then rest of the DIR. I am not Isaak and have no position on Somaliland vs Somalia debate but i am certain that whatever Waqooyi people decide it will be lead by Isaack tribe not any other tribe of the former British Somaliland. It is conceivable Prof. Samatar as president supported by Isaak majority (Somalia or Somaliland) but not Prof. Samatar president supported by Hawiye,Darood or Rahanwayn. This is my humble opinion.
waxan odhan laha prof samatar adeerkay baan ahay illaah ban kugu dhaarshee somliya hakalaban turubkana meelkale hala aadin dhalinyarta kubahan dadka kubahan somliya kubahan mgacaga iyo maskaxdadu kawyn...somliland meeshan siilaanyo la dabaal dagayo ee dadkii lagu gumooday please sharaftada ka reer...ee somliya oo dhan ba laga sugaya si kale wax ugu qabo wadanka hadii aad awoodo ama somlinidadas kudhimo cid aad tahay ma jirto dir ma tihid qabiilna ma tihid somali baa tahay wana lagu ogyhy thts it
wallaahi It saddens me to see prof samatar in uu sidaa dareemayo oo uu leeyahay nin shisheeya ah ayaan dareemay marna reer waqooyi marna dir oo maqan aan war ku siiyo samataroow meesha boob iyo degaal baa ka socda soomaalinimadana cidna marti uguma tihid marka hadii la is boobayo oo xaqaada aadan u dagaalamin yaa u dagaalamaya inanka gudubiirsi ama dir boqol sano ka dib oo break gareeynaya darbigaa ku horyaalo maanta,jiljileecaa jooji fight libaax ogow aniga iyo milyan som wa kutaageersanahay..
waa qabyaali cali khaliif bal wuxu kala gurayo dayaa ahmed na wuxu ka hadlayaa sidee loo xalayaa dhibka somalihaysata isaguna wuxu ka hadlayaa dhulbahantee waar tag tuug yahw
walee waa runtaa anigu maka soo jeedi somaliland..lakiinse waxaaan ka soo jeedaa Puntland...waxaan ku dhihi lahaa walaaleheen reer somaliland Magaca iska badela.....waa magac murugo,iyo xanuun leh ...........
Prof. Samatar maybe in a next life or something the somalis will be ready to elect its leader based on merit not tribe Or Hundred years from now. You are absolutely too advanced for the current politics of Somalia. Your concepts and mindset is at least one hundred ahead of its time in terms of somalia. So change the tactics, be pragmatic and start with your own region (gabiley), then next and so on and so on. 4.5 dictates that DIR is one section and as far as i know Isaacks are the majority.
Scww, marka xigta waxaaan maaanta ku faraxsanahay in uu Prof. Ahmed Ismacil Samatar uu fahmay meesha uu ka yimid iyo cda uu yahay iyada oo soomali la wada yahay hadana cid kastaaaba waxay ku nooshayhay meeshu ilaahay ku beeeray waxaanan xusuusin lahaa Professor ka in uu yahay nin samaroon siciid ah oo sacad muuse dhaleeen markaaa waxaaan odhan lahaaa meeshaad ka timi waad taqaana ee intaaad cafis ka dalbatid dalkaagii welcome to Somaliland hadii kale dhado roob mood. wabilahi tawfiq viva S/land
So sad inaan maqlo in Samatar sidaa lagu yiri waxaanse kasii xumahay inuu sidaa uga jawaabay isna....Isma dhaanto iyo dhasheed yaan dalkii u xil saarnaa hadaba?
Pan-Somalism, Greater Somalia dream is alive kuwa eey kaga dhegantahay reer-hebel. ama hebel-land ogaada in eey nool yahiin mawaadiniin aaminsan Greater Somalia mana socondoonto in Somaliweyn eey u go-go.do cadow fikirkiisa(Divide and Rule) ayagoo soo adeegsanaya kuw meeshaan aad moodo in waxa loogu yeero Hebel-land in eey iyaga baxsadeen oo eey iloobeen in ereyga Hebel-land uu ka yimid gumeysi..
Professor Samatar.....what you experienced in Xamar is not something new. The people of the Northern regions have been facing this kind of injustice since 1960 being, treated as second class citizens and aliens of the republic. Who can seriously blame reer Waqooyi for seceding from Somalia?
niyow odaygaa dhintay waxba afka ha iigalin, wuxuu ahaba dhimay wanaag iyo xumanba. adigana waxaan kugula talin lahaa in aad xag xagashada ka dayso Xafida hulaah Prof Ali khalif Galaydh.runtii waxaad kunacaysana maha wax kale ee waa c/laahi bay is hayeen.
qofkii ka cara oo difaaci waaya marka dalkiisa lasoo weeraro qaanuunka dowliga wuxu ku xukuma taraitor ama khaainul wadan. saasa norway u maxkamadeysa qofkii xiligi naasiga wadanka ka qaxay oon difaacin. Maryooley munaafaqada iska dhaafa somaliya daleeel baad uga dhaqaaqdeene.
Hassan Shire Xero kuma wada jiraan labada nin. Nin waa nin run sheegay oo waaqicaga Xamar ka jira sheegay nina waa nin eedaadaya oo mel uu qabsado la'a oo khayaali iyo aabahey goblan ku hataatacaya.Waa la ogyahay midba kuu yahay nacasna loo sheegi maayo.
runta hadaan la isu sheegin dhibka lama dareemayo waxna laga qaban maayo.samatra waa runtii nin aan aad u qiimeeyo soomaali sax ah ahna marka hadanan runta siu sheegin wax xalin mayno soomaleey shaqo badan baa noo taalo iyo in aan isu tagno oo dalkeena dib u dhisno..
Mida kale naceyb shakhsi ah aan u qabo majiro cali khalif galydh balse dadka in been aad u sheegto ayaan kaso horjeeda boowe, runta haku deeqdo hadi aad magac qabiil ku difcayso yeysan ka indha tirin xaqiiqda cabdulahi iyo cali isku mizana maha isku tariikhna maha. isku majaalna ma aheyn
samatar magaladad u dhalatey tag oo war bixin ka keen umad dhibateysan ha xag xaganine siyasada ayad ku jabtey markas ku ciil baxeysaa umad dhibateysan halka ad siyasad iyo ka hadli laheyd wali wali lagu dhiftey minisota la joog
mid kasto idinla fiicani hadhaw ayu ficil xumaadaye how dad waynow ka fiirsada. odayaal daalay dooni mayno dalkibay naga kharibeen , is qabsi is cay cay ka bixi wayeen ti gaar koda ahayd ayay danti umada ka hor mariyeen. odayashan way so qaten wakhtigodi in aynu 'aged day care' ku xarayno ya loo bahan yahay, where is my new generation get up, wake up don't lisen to this old pple ..youth is a power my dream sooner or later one day it will come .
Samatar wasn't that wise after all.....Im glad he got what he deserves. after all, you can teach an old dog new tricks. Prof. Samatar, you are always welcome in Somaliland. lol
Somaliland was never part of Somalia and it never will be...why don't they instead focus on their own country, get rid of terrorist in somalia and build a stable modern government for themselves.
magaalo 20 sanno dagaalo ka socde mawaxaan laga filayn aaad soo aragte? Hadaad dadka iyo dhulka u damqaneeso maxaad u qabate? Mise inaad kursi ku fariisato kaliya ay ku xirantahay inaad dadka wax u qabato Allah aa mahad leh oon kursi noogu kaa dhiibin Afkaada kalabax muqdisho dhulkeena anagaa dhisaneena
war labada mutacalin way sii yara kala mutacalin sanyihiine mayay laba meelood ka soo kala hadlaan mise qaraabay yihiin. muqdishana may farah kala baxaan oo ay waqooyi aadaan /
sxb waxaad tiri abdulahi ayuu ka rayay taasna sinan way ka sareysa mida kale darjo la qaato wax laguma noqdo aniga prof iska dhaafe xitaa aqonyahan hose uma ictiraafsani, wa run abudlhai PHD ma wadan iyo jamacad midna hadna sas ay tahay waxa u ahaa adiga lagu weydiin mahayo oo umada somaliyeed aya marag ka ah, cali baba tuug qaranka lacagtiisi dhacay inuu yahay umada aya og marka sxb qofku waxaa lagu amaana ficilkiisa ee aqoon kali ah waxba ma tarto imsa aqoon leh ayaa gun illaahay ka dhigay!
Caadi iska dhig Sxb horaa loo yiri qofku wuxuu ka indha la'yahay wuu ku dhiiradaa c/dilaahi yusuf aqoon waa lahaa wuxuuna lahaa aqoon xiligaa ugu fiican balse adiga primary school masoo martay si aan iskula fahanno aqoonta micnaheeda mise waad iska hadashay adigoo asaasku kaa maqan yahay aqoontu waxay ukala baxdaa noocya badan imkastoon wakhti hayn aan wax ku qoro haddana waxaa aqoonta kamid ah waxa loo yaqaan Army and local defense oo kahadla howlaha ciidamada iyo difaaca dhulka cabdilaahina wuxuu ahaa senior defender and operator of attack enemy in and out wax loo yaqaano taas uu kusoo bartay dalka ruushka iyo talyaaniga si guud cabdullaahi wuxuu ahaa major corneal of tactical army and intelligence cop marka saxiib waxan umalayn inadan taariikhdiisa aadan aqoon amase aatahay dadka aqoontoodu ku dhisan tahay boobsiga iyo bood boodka so talk about what u know no what u don't and also corneal abdalla was speaking four language somali English Russian and italiano legitto'd so look before u leab
SAMATAR WADANKU WUU BUR-BURAY WADOOYINKA, QASHINKA, SHAQO LA'AANTA,LAALUUSHKA IYO DHAMAAN WAXAD KA HADLEYSO OO DHAN WAA SAX' LAAKIIN XAL AYA ALOO BAAHAN YAHAY EE IN LA'IS EEDEEYO OO KALIYA LOOMA BAAHNA EE MAR WALBA WAA IN RAJO LA MUUJIYAA, EE ADIGI DHANKAADA KA QABO, GALLEYRNA WAAN FAHAMNAY HADALKIISA EE WADANKA MIDNIMADIISA HAKA SHAQEEYO, IN WAX LA EEDEEYANA WAA LAGA FIICAN YAHAY,,,,,,
Prof-yada isku ma jiraan wallee; Waxay u kala baxaan mid aqooneed iyo mid qabiileed. Video-ga inoo cadeeyey. Galaydh waxaan leeyahay, fadlan jooji qabiil magacaabistan badan ee aad media-ha la hortaagantahay hadh iyo habeen. tolow kama daalo miyaa? Wax dhaama kan teen; u feker somalinimo ha u fekerin beelnimo. Doqon fowqal doqon
Dalka Somalia ayuu niyada ka jabinayaa o hada yaad usheegeysa shaqadad ma adan soo gudan intaas uunbaad noo sheegtay hadii adan adigaba ka hadlin maxaa kula gudboonatay inaad qashinka dhulka 20 sano dolad la aanti ka jirtay magalada muqidhso inooga shekeyso abahii wase in lagu dilo beey aheed magaalo 20 sanno dagaalo ka socde mawaxaan laga filayn aaad soo aragte? Hadaad dadka iyo dhulka u damqaneeso maxaad u qabate? Mise inaad kursi ku fariisato kaliya ay ku xirantahay
ninka shir walba uu ka hadlo qabiilkiisa u dooda prof baad tiriye hadi uu kun PHD qaato waxba anfci mayso waayo qofku waxa uu wax ku noqdaa ficilkiisa, abdulahi isagoon BHD wadin ayuu qaran somaliyeed boorka ka jafay oo dawalad u horseeday halka kan aad profka ku sheegayso uu 2012 tolkii magaciisa ku qarabanayo oo r/barlamaan ku raadinayo hadna uusanba ku helin. abdulahi ysuf xiligi uu jogay lascano lama gumaysan jirin taasna ogow hadi cali baba karti iyo aqoon leyahay ha xoreeyo gobalkiisa
Bal noo sheeg tariikhda madaow ee abdulahi yusuf aad ka hayso? abdulahi 1962kii waxa uu watay bilad dahab ah oo u gidoonsiyay jen dauud cabdule xirsi oo ahaa jen somaiyeed ki u horeyay xilgaas cali khaliif muxuu ahaa bal? hadi ad abudlahi tarikh xumo oga dhigayso SSDF ma aheyn mid isaga u gooni ahyed ee somali o dhan ayaa wada furtay marki danbe halgu kala tagee ssdfna danbe kama galin soomali waayo jabhaduhu way badnaayeen jabahadaasna shacabna ma xasuuqin mdaxwaynana ma ridin ee sas ula soco
kkkk Nin dhalasho iyo calan ama diin kale qaatey ama si kale hadaan u dhigo, iksa dhiibey ma sheegan karaa callankii ii ka dacwoodey ama iska dhiibey??!! shareeco islaam iyo sharci gaalo modna ma qabo.
Liiban faadumo STOP insulting your brothers...Soomali qabiil wacal ah ma jiro ee xishoo. if there is any one who us faraac as you put it it will most likely be you as your last name is Faadumo. Aight. Somalia soomali baa Wada leg including you
