Тёмный

Tragic war crime as Nova Kakhovka dam is blown up. Who did it & why as Russia, Ukraine trade charges 

ThePrint
Подписаться 2,6 млн
Просмотров 106 тыс.
50% 1

#cuttheclutter #kakhovka #russianukrainwar
This is not a whodunnit. We don’t know who blew up Ukraine’s Russia-controlled Nova Kakhovka dam, one of the world’s biggest. Ukraine has blamed it on “Russian terrorists”, while Russia has alleged Ukrainian “sabotage”. Either way, it is a tragedy with massive consequences for years to come. In Ep 1247 of Cut The Clutter, Editor-in-Chief Shekhar Gupta looks at international conventions, explains why this qualifies as a war crime, and why it’s an all-out tragedy for humans and animals alike.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
‪@CoorgWildernessResort‬
More here - www.coorgwilde...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Watch Cut The Clutter Ep 1111 here: • Military & geopolitica...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Member benefits: theprint.in/su...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/su...
» Subscribe to our RU-vid Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintI...
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8

Опубликовано:

 

11 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 314   
@ThePrintIndia
@ThePrintIndia Год назад
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Member benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
@libshastra
@libshastra Год назад
I'm too deep into Ancient Indian History but this breach of the dam incident reminds me of Dasarajna war from Rigveda. During the Dasarajna war, Sudas of the Bharatas breached a dyke to drown his enemies on advice of Vashishta. It is probably the oldest recorded battle that used dam/dyke breaching to gain an edge over the enemy.
@mandarinandthetenrings2201
@mandarinandthetenrings2201 Год назад
You have understand S Mel, that dam's reservoir feed canal into Crimea. The wheat grown there is sold primarily into the Middle East. Which means there going to major food price increases and food riots. There going to be more instability in the region.
@libshastra
@libshastra Год назад
@@mandarinandthetenrings2201 It's great for Indian Farmers and Indian Economy. Middle East didn't collapse last year when things were more severe, it won't collapse this year when things are less severe (especially given that supply chains have adjusted to the realities of the Conflict).
@mandarinandthetenrings2201
@mandarinandthetenrings2201 Год назад
@@libshastra No Indian you are wrong and let me tell you why. You see you weren't taught this in school or by the RSS or BJP. After World War II, to fight the Soviet Union we created "Globalization" if country before World War II lacked good farmland, coal, oil, and iron ore they were a colony of the European Powers like yourself. But after World War II, America said if you side with America against the Soviet Union, America will protect your shipping for free, and you now go out get the oil, coal, food, and iron ore you need.
@mandarinandthetenrings2201
@mandarinandthetenrings2201 Год назад
@@libshastra But now Indian we no longer give that protection, the Soviet Union fell 30 years ago. Which mean any instability in the Middle East require India to go in and try and fix it. But the Muslims have told me you send Indian soldiers into the Middle East they will all unite and start using you for target practice.
@mandarinandthetenrings2201
@mandarinandthetenrings2201 Год назад
@@libshastra So going have live with high inflation because you put one foot in their waters or lands they will blow you kingdom come. They not let a Muslim hating bigot like you on their lands.
@nehaojha9094
@nehaojha9094 Год назад
Given that the Ukrainian counter-offensive has begun - it becomes clear which side did it. Most probably the Russians as it throws a major lever into Ukraine's plans. Ukraine wanted to cross the Dnipro and gain control the Sea of Azov to divide Russians forces into 2 parts. Now it can't plus Russian forces have smaller territory to defend now too.
@benothing3350
@benothing3350 Год назад
Thief breaks into a house with a knife & The owner is stabbed. Now the debate is "did the owner stab himself or the thief." The poor thief would go to jail if he did ,it must be the owner ...😐
@sasukepran
@sasukepran Год назад
Thief broke into the house, the owner stabbed and the thief is accused to stabbing th owner.. but little did other knows that the owner seemingly friend( the same which that earlier blown a pipeline) actually did the stabbing and want this to be blamed on thief so that he can continue to earn profit out of it.
@benothing3350
@benothing3350 Год назад
@@sasukepran how can a country without any decent submarine imagine to dive in super high pressure depths and detonate Power ful explosives. Especially since Superman doesn't exist
@vigilanthuman
@vigilanthuman Год назад
Shekhar gupta is more neutral than India 😂
@sudiptarouth
@sudiptarouth Год назад
Yeah! I started noticing too.😂. This topic, he should simply layoff .. but he keeps getting the memos from them masters
@maksrms
@maksrms Год назад
India is on wrong side. We are not supporting Russians who have been our long time friends. We are supporting an despot Putin who is forcing it's own people into war, forcing conscription on young Russians.
@angomgunindrosingh9178
@angomgunindrosingh9178 Год назад
He is pro ukraine. All his informations are based on western media reports which are not true.
@emge02
@emge02 Год назад
Shekher gupta is pro Rahul, that's all. Old hangover of Congress.
@urrasscal8380
@urrasscal8380 Год назад
@@emge02 congress and shekher both folllows jjesus christ just like jjesus committing ssuicide for the ssins of others similarly they want iindia sud commit ssuicide for the ssins of others. for example russia and ukraine committing ssins to each other so a third party who got nothing to do with this iissue like iindia sud commit ssuicide.
@draviaartistwithbat5756
@draviaartistwithbat5756 Год назад
50 meters is more than 50 feet. Meter to feet conversion never gets easier than this.
@aritrodasgupta2019
@aritrodasgupta2019 Год назад
SG said 15 metres is 50 feet
@lvanvan
@lvanvan Год назад
@@aritrodasgupta2019 15.24m=50 feet ...also feet mesure unit everytime reminds me of cave ppl mesuring everithing with hands, fingers and foots ... fits somehow and usA deservs it :D
@aritrodasgupta2019
@aritrodasgupta2019 Год назад
@@lvanvan that's exactly what I said
@NarendraKumar-hq5bv
@NarendraKumar-hq5bv Год назад
Great video. So horrific. Strange, that a war crime harms both sides. Like Russell noted -- Nobody wins a war....
@manjuchanku
@manjuchanku Год назад
For a change, can the viewers see a different commercial at the beginning.
@chubbymoth5810
@chubbymoth5810 Год назад
Considering Ukraine had no physical access the answer to the who did it rather obvious. How likely is it that Ukrainians snuck in with tonnes of explosives into this Russian controlled building? And took their jolly time to dispense those along an area? And not have any benefit of such action whatsoever. To make Russia look bad? As if that would still be required. In a time span of 50 minutes, the local mayor changed his story from no air attack to a whole night of attacks. After the first live interview where he claimed nothing had been noticed, a hasty call seems to have changed his memory of events somewhat. The water level of the lake had been increased this month to record levels as well. Guess who controlled that? And this was not a structure that could be damaged much by bombardment either.
@varunshivan9569
@varunshivan9569 Год назад
The thing is, this dam provides 60-80% of water to Crimea, so destroying it doesn't make much sense for Russia either. Anyway, who did this is not important because the consequences of destroying that dam are more critical than that.
@easwarsankar
@easwarsankar Год назад
​@Varun Shivan The question of who committed a war crime of this scale cannot be brushed aside. All evidence strongly points to Russia. The argument that they can't be this dumb to do such a thing openly is not valid. Just look at the objective facts that they controlled the dam. If they have evidence that the Ukrainians entered the dam to sabotage it, it is incumbent on the Russians to prove it. I am disappointed in SG for equivocating and playing the both sides game here as the facts are pretty strong, if not inconclusive in pointing the blame at Russua
@varunshivan9569
@varunshivan9569 Год назад
@@easwarsankar both of the sides have facts and valid reasons to blow the dam, right now there is no concrete evidence to point blame, both sides have shown their ugly faces by committing war crimes, so it's hard to believe one side only right now, even the nordstream pipeline explosion is blamed on Russia when it doesn't make any sense to why anyone would blow their own $$.
@stephanledford9792
@stephanledford9792 Год назад
@@varunshivan9569 My guess is that Putin realizes that he is not going to be able to hold onto Crimea, so cutting the water supply will be Ukraine's problem once they take the area back.
@abhinashkumar3161
@abhinashkumar3161 Год назад
@@stephanledford9792 lol
@ajijae5485
@ajijae5485 Год назад
A better comparison is Hirakud dam (5 km long & 60 m deep). Not Tehri, or Bhakra Nangal or Nagarjuna Sagar.
@A7T043
@A7T043 Год назад
The Blowing Up Of The Nova Kakhovka Dam On The Dnipro Occam’s Razor: Russia Did it! 1. Ukrainian Spring Offensive likely shortly. 2. Russian troops spread thin across frontlines extending from Kherson to SE of Kharkiv. 3. Problems of stationing of reserves across a wide frontage. 4. Problems of moving reserves and materials due to exterior lines of communication. 5. Flooding of Dnipro river and areas around deny space for an offensive to Ukraine - makes approach to the river and employment of armour difficult. 6. In effect, denies the Kherson sector to the enemy and adds defensive depth to the strategic prize of Crimea. 7. Permits re-deployment of Russian reserves to the Mariupol to Donbas sectors.
@homayuns2165
@homayuns2165 Год назад
Totally agree, Ukraine was waiting for ground to dry up for new western tanks.
@Takenyao123
@Takenyao123 Год назад
The dam was the only bridge in South. I don't think it would be that difficult to defend. Second if Russia has to blow up the dam why not drain it first because flooding will mostly effect the Russian side. And third draining or blowing the dam will prevent water to krimia region. There is no benefit to blowing up for Russia. Same like nordstream could have been turned off by Russian instead of blowing up which USA did.
@dev.0122
@dev.0122 Год назад
Interestingly I think Ukrainians did it, they have history of sabotaging projects like Nord Stream two, beside this Dam provides electricity to the nearby nuclear plant and the dry Crimean region. Infact rather than Russia it was Ukraine that wanted to narrow the scope of attack, because I think it did start the counter offensive a few days back and lost many soldiers thus in retaliation they blew up the Dam.
@Asswife
@Asswife Год назад
Ukraine loss more than 3000 men this week trying to break the Russian. Ukraine are desperate
@angomgunindrosingh9178
@angomgunindrosingh9178 Год назад
Pro ukraine point of view.
@SkSingh-tu8un
@SkSingh-tu8un Год назад
1. Trials for war crimes are conducted by the winner. 2. Dam Busters epic movie of the second world war comes to mind. Then it was hailed as a game changer 3. We have many Chinese dams upstream . Some years back flash floods in Himachal and Assam occurred. There was much speculation on whether water released was responsible. 4. Rules of war are for peacetime...dont recall our western adversary following them 5. It is quite normal to flood or waterlog a area if your adversary has an advantage. So if Ukraine was planning a offensive ,makes no sense for them to flood the place more so when it is the grain producing bowl of the country. Of course flooding would ordinarily be by releasing water not blasting the dam
@ishannagk2544
@ishannagk2544 Год назад
SG's problem is his reference habit w/o understanding the very source he refers from are biased . He should check what his "sources" were saying about the nord blast and their comments now . As indians we can be brutally honest about this war , no point playing defensive
@dharmvirbharti1037
@dharmvirbharti1037 Год назад
shekhar gupta is the same guy who made the fun of russians when they said "they didn't blowup the pipeline Americans did " that's why he's acting so neutral now 😂😂
@cssudhakar
@cssudhakar Год назад
He is a Congi Person who supports Pappu team
@urrasscal8380
@urrasscal8380 Год назад
this people r librandus. they r self inflicting ssycophant.
@vipularya6051
@vipularya6051 Год назад
DUFFERS, the dam was blown up by Ukrainians because it supplies water to Crimea.
@varun2250
@varun2250 Год назад
​@@cssudhakar Well the Skamgress before Pappu also followed similar foreign policy as today, aka during PM Manmohan Singh's time. But pappu has a knack for BS that simply can't be contained.
@Arunbadruka9
@Arunbadruka9 Год назад
It's not just war crime,it's the worst act against humanity.....water and air are the most precious resources 😢
@rajshekhar1147
@rajshekhar1147 Год назад
The people who destroyed gas pipeline destroyed this dam also .😀
@shekarnt
@shekarnt Год назад
Excellent comment
@lukebandolino882
@lukebandolino882 Год назад
All the murders in the World are committed by the same murderer
@urrasscal8380
@urrasscal8380 Год назад
@@lukebandolino882 so a third party who got nothing to do with this war sud commit ssuicide just like jjesus committed ssuicide for the ssins of others.
@sram8534
@sram8534 Год назад
Did you ask the same question when the Russian gas pipeline was blown away by, you know, who?
@maniaphobia4719
@maniaphobia4719 Год назад
In war and love anything is justified ; Syria , Iraq , Iran , Afghan talks about it ; Now Sudan ; Public suffers immensely; Camp life is a hell on earth ; Thank God ; South India never seen a sizable war as it is far away from Border lines ; ; South never even talk about armed forces after Independence; But Terrific unproductive, highly emotional War in Social media takes place in TV / Mobile Screens ; Temptations to waste time is irresistible ( irresponsible!!!)
@pramodpatil5336
@pramodpatil5336 Год назад
History repeats itself: "29 August 1941 The Russians have blown up the Dnieper dam at Zaporizhzhia, which feeds the Dneprostroi power plant, and have evacuated Dnepropetrovsk, the great industrial centre of Ukraine." Soviet Union destroyed it's own dam to stop Hitler's invasion
@ranjitpal9937
@ranjitpal9937 Год назад
IT'S Against UN Rule / Humanity . As Both Sides Are Blaming Each Other , There Should Be A UN Resolution To Investigate IT 👊
@benothing3350
@benothing3350 Год назад
UN is really a disappointment. Can't do anything concrete.
@ansmram
@ansmram Год назад
Whoever destroyed the Nord stream so secretly also did this, as they have both capability and motive.
@VimalPerera-hd8fr
@VimalPerera-hd8fr Год назад
Justice is a Luxuy amidst war William Shakespeare 🙏
@nedwright3257
@nedwright3257 Год назад
China neutral????????? LOLOLOL This guy has zero credibility after that statement
@urrasscal8380
@urrasscal8380 Год назад
he is a librandu .. so what else u expect from this people.
@Siddharth_Rao
@Siddharth_Rao Год назад
At around 3:40 mark, its Curious that you avoid using the word "dis-information" when talking about western media but don't have any problem attaching the same term to Russian sources.
@kakun63
@kakun63 Год назад
Masters will be angry
@DeccanPS
@DeccanPS Год назад
That's how a Western slave/stooge works. Always trust the master's.
@Takenyao123
@Takenyao123 Год назад
Western propaganda media is their trusted source of information.
@Takenyao123
@Takenyao123 Год назад
They never use any independent source or alternate source instead call them conspiracy theorists without review the information is the reason why I take them really lightly.
@savithakl7577
@savithakl7577 Год назад
Media in india love dollars
@BharatThatIsIndia
@BharatThatIsIndia Год назад
Europeans always bombed common people in war. Not only Hitler,but Churchill and USA bombed Hamburg and killed 25k+ people in a night. India and Pakistan had fought many wars but they have not directly bombed common citizen. They might have killed 10-20 people or bombed them but not on large scale. Obviously we have to discount the Genocide of Hindus and Bengali by East Pakistan. However that was not after war broke out but it was the one of the reason for the war.
@ed5928
@ed5928 Год назад
Paxtani proxies did many crimes against civilians directly in Afghanistan too Shameless and murderous country : 🇵🇰
@invictus4431
@invictus4431 Год назад
You forgot to mention the atomic bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. And that's the country that will lecture the world about the dangers of nuclear proliferation.
@vish_globalist
@vish_globalist Год назад
Let's not forget Hiroshima & Nagasaki even though the Japanese themselves don't want to remember who killed millions of the civilian Japanese.
@BharatThatIsIndia
@BharatThatIsIndia Год назад
@@invictus4431 Actually I didn't mention that bcz noone is using atomic bomb after that.
@fatgitchenko4793
@fatgitchenko4793 Год назад
let's generalise then, only Europeans do war crimes LOL how about only Europeans invent technology and everyone else is dumb? I don't believe that but about as intelligent as your comment. did you pass grade 10.
@akshayhiremath4584
@akshayhiremath4584 Год назад
All the international conventions etc. are for namesake. No sovereign country can hold another sovereign country by it. There can't be a law that is enforcing anything at the international level. This is against the basic idea of sovereignty. So quoting all these conventions in some section of some law is futile. Also as Justice Pal said in Tokyo Trials after WW 2, you can't hold a country responsible for war crimes. War is not a crime, especially when other countries involved have adopted similar policies. By that logic, US's invasion of Iraq is the biggest war crime of the 21st century, the whole country is completely destroyed for no mistake of theirs.
@orunabho
@orunabho Год назад
As John Mearsheimer suggested. It is great power game. Russia will make sure Ukraine goes back to stone age, and will be the bulwark against NATO expansion against Russia around its borders. It is not good or bad or morality issue. Great power politics and Ukraine is the unfortunate victim of that game. Pray for Ukrainian people.
@the__source
@the__source Год назад
Finland covers far more of their border and they joined NATO because of Russia. Quit spouting propaganda
@ThePrintIndia
@ThePrintIndia Год назад
You do make a strong point, but we'll just have to wait and see if indeed Ukraine ends up as the victim. Thank you for watching and writing in...best wishes, Shekhar
@orunabho
@orunabho Год назад
@@the__source the black sea fleet will be at risk for Russians. Not the Artic fleet. Thanks Lisa.
@sarvajeetmukherjee3290
@sarvajeetmukherjee3290 Год назад
Not just Mearsheimer ( who suggested that US should actually get into a millitary alliance with Russia so that the duo can counter the Behemoth that US inadvertently created post cold war . i mean the Chinese ) but also the left think tanks like Richard Wolfe, all of them have not only condemned the war but also seem to suggest that it is the US lead NATO expansion which is largely responsible for this war. They also agree that the war seems to linger only because the corrupt officials in the higher echelons of NATO are more interested in making money out this mess . All the wars that US got itself involved in post cold wars have actually seen US power wane while coteries within the Administration have gone richer . Seymour Hersh, the pulitzer prize winning journalist claimed that it was the Biden Administration which was responsible for Nordstrom-2 pipeline sabotage and not as what mainstream media was claiming. He went further to state that post Trump , the US is so terrified that they might have someone like him back ( he is vicious , vile , unscrupulous, racist and thinks of nothing but his own coffers) that even the mainstream media like Washington Post ( which people take quite seriously) and The Gurdian have been compromised to the effect that they are afraid to publish anything that might have a semblance to what Trump was and is saying . According to Hersh , the censorship ( Washington Post was even too afraid to publish his article ) by American Mainstream media moguls ( apart from the joke called Fox News ) is terrifying. They are labeling anyone who seems to question US interests in this war as Putin lovers ! Putin was the best bet that the Americans ever had to mend relations with Russia and they squandered it and appear to move direction less . Such censorship reminds one of the McCarthy era ( if you have read Farenheit 451 , you shall understand ) ...
@micecollective7555
@micecollective7555 Год назад
I know many Ukrainians in the UK and Europe (I live in Europe and am from the UK), all of them want to stand up to Putin and don't want to be enslaved by his brutal regime. 100 years ago Ukraine was briefly independent after WW1, but the Russian attacked it and took it back. The Ukrainians have as much right to self determination as the Indian in 1947.
@manojgunda2165
@manojgunda2165 Год назад
I like cut the Clutter because It is more like civils content than any news media article
@BornInBiafra
@BornInBiafra Год назад
Who blew up the Nordstrom pipe lines explosion that's Who
@maishjunior4651
@maishjunior4651 Год назад
Bt Russians are more likely to have done it in order to delay/stop Ukrainian counteroffensive.. Also it might be cause of previous damages of Ukraine shelling and Russia when they blew up road on that dam
@mobbu6527
@mobbu6527 Год назад
Animals? You mean dogs? Because unfortunately that's all people everywhere care about, the don't mind billions of other animals getting killed and suffering but when it comes to dogs getting scratched the whole universe comes to their aid. Sick of this dog obsession
@ArunPunnathatta
@ArunPunnathatta Год назад
About nord stream pipeline... You remember, that day you hinted it was done by Russia, because western media said so.... About new Russian law... Are you sure that the copy brought by Ukrainian journalist saying that the Russian passed a law as you described is true??? Or just a Ukrainian journalist saying so???
@DipakBose-bq1vv
@DipakBose-bq1vv Год назад
Ukraine has committed that war crime.
@VimalPerera-hd8fr
@VimalPerera-hd8fr Год назад
Monastery too goid sad to say as you are a seasoned veteran Sir
@anantthakur7166
@anantthakur7166 Год назад
Sir the counter-offensive has hit the wall as the water supply to Cimea has been affected, the river goes downstream and it is a massive problem.
@vipularya6051
@vipularya6051 Год назад
DUFFERS, the dam was blown up by Ukrainians because it supplies water to Crimea.
@kesavansrinivasan4035
@kesavansrinivasan4035 Год назад
Good account.
@emge02
@emge02 Год назад
In war this is inevitable, it's not a dinner party. Dam blown? No big deal.
@GaneshPatil-yc8fh
@GaneshPatil-yc8fh Год назад
We will not surprise after some day everyone know this are the same guys who had earlier blown gas pipeline😂
@jaydeepgadhavi5465
@jaydeepgadhavi5465 Год назад
Rivers forming a natural barrier in wars seem to be an older concept. With military technologies they have become easy to breach, however flooded areas are a problem not just for military movements but also civilian lives
@ed5928
@ed5928 Год назад
So u saying Ukr did it ??
@harshb747
@harshb747 Год назад
Nope. It is an older concept only for America. India, China, Russia don't have modern airforce in large numbers and still rely heavily on ground troops. And for ground troops, landscape is everything
@mandarinandthetenrings2201
@mandarinandthetenrings2201 Год назад
That not the problem the real problem is Crimea the reservoir behind the dam feed water canals into Crimea. Russian soldier will have no drinking water. Also, those canals help to grow wheat which then sold into the Middle East which will cause food prices to go up even further. We going to see rebellion and riots in Middle East.
@ShivamGupta-sr9zf
@ShivamGupta-sr9zf Год назад
Innocent animals pay the price for madness caused by humans.
@coolboyjay
@coolboyjay Год назад
Shekar ji, you missed out the fact that Ukraine has bombed the dam earlier- there is a NYT article on the same.
@benothing3350
@benothing3350 Год назад
This dam can withstand nuclear bomb from above . Himars that Ukraine used cannot even collapse a small bridge!
@TimBabych
@TimBabych Год назад
They tested targeting flood gates, not dam foundation. Dam itself was too massive to to be destroyed by an external blast.
@rajendrapradhan293
@rajendrapradhan293 Год назад
This is an act of Russia.
@robertbrowning41
@robertbrowning41 Год назад
SG Tehri is not the largest, it is the highest
@sanket2923
@sanket2923 Год назад
Respected THE Print Please make video on Saudi Arabia
@675dunes
@675dunes Год назад
To cut off land bridge and isolate Crimea from north it is in interest of Ukraine to have less water and have option to cross river southern side of which should probably be held lightly by Russians because of safety of water reservoir - my guess
@vipularya6051
@vipularya6051 Год назад
DUFFERS, the dam was blown up by Ukrainians because it supplies water to Crimea.
@675dunes
@675dunes Год назад
Looks like this is coming true
@NutopianBlr
@NutopianBlr Год назад
Cui bono … dear Mr. Gupta!
@ElizabethDebeer-kd3fe
@ElizabethDebeer-kd3fe Год назад
Poor animals
@urrasscal8380
@urrasscal8380 Год назад
just like mmosses kkilled so so aquatic lives when he parted the ocean.
@RainBow-ci5op
@RainBow-ci5op Год назад
It's like 9/11
@saiyedzaidi3609
@saiyedzaidi3609 Год назад
simple when things dont start to your way "sabotage" to make the public feel sorry for you and hoping big powers will come to your support
@abhishek1990
@abhishek1990 Год назад
@shekhi uncle please requesting you to do a CTC on Saudi’s soft power using sports. Keywords to Google for stories : PGA Tour, Christiano Ronaldo, Messi
@sarvajeetmukherjee3290
@sarvajeetmukherjee3290 Год назад
... while the Nordstrom-2 pipeline blow up was probably carried out by Americans and not Ukranians, and the blow up of the dam was possibly carried out by the Russians. Russians are well known for their ruthlessness when it comes to winning wars. During the Second World War , the Germans were appalled by the number of soldiers that the Russians were willing to sacrifice so that they could hold on to the objectives. However, i believe that the long term strategy that the Russians are willing to take is fight a battle of attrition in which they plan to simply wear out the Ukrainian/European millitsia. The reason the Russians are doing this is simply because they are an occupying force ( their main intention is to retain the occupied areas ) and they simply do not have enough men to do so ( Russian population is declining ). i still maintain that the NATO is fighting a loosing battle. It is better that negotiations are initiated as soon as possible so that Ukrainian lives are saved ...
@sayeedakhtar8647
@sayeedakhtar8647 Год назад
little correction to your KNOWLEDGE. i guess you are very much influenced by the AMERICAN media. present day RUSSIA is not SOVIET UNION. so for you to use RUSSIA and not USSR for 2nd world war to back your point seems as the AMERICAN who are stuck in the past. this WAR has it's root in 2014 conflict and it didn't start in 2022. WESTERN NATIONS back stabbed RUSSIANS when they violated the MINKS PEACE ACCORD and pumped MONEY and AMMUNITION into UKRAINE to weaken RUSSIANS . This claim of mine is backed by the fact that previous GERMAN CHANCELLOR ANGELA MERKEL herself admitted that the minks accord was meant to buy time to prepare UKRANIAN to go to war with RUSSIANS. it's bit rich for NATO to try to destroy and weaken RUSSIA when RUSSIAN offered PEACE but now as the WEST seems to be loosing the WAR peace has suddenly popped up in their minds. UKRAINE was just a pawn for UNCLE SAM to weaken RUSSIA and as they plan seems to be failing they would just bounce from the situation as they did in AFGHANISTAN , IRAQ , SYRIA to name a few.
@tony16991
@tony16991 Год назад
while the Nordstrom-2 pipeline blow up was probably carried out by Americans and not Ukranians, this was possibly carried out by the Russians. After making such a retarded contradicting statement at what point do you think you should shut up and not embarrass yourself further?
@mulamulelilumadi4717
@mulamulelilumadi4717 Год назад
See your point. What kind of mechanism would the sides put in place to observe the new status quo?
@the__source
@the__source Год назад
No. We want Russia ended. The world will be a better place without Russia.
@besam
@besam Год назад
Nato is not fighting but Ukrainian are. So in long term it is beneficial for Nato to have Russia keep fighting this war.
@--Dani
@--Dani Год назад
That resolution is just more of their smoke screen...
@TheSutov
@TheSutov Год назад
Earlier in the war, Russians warned that they have had mined the Kakhovka dam. It is therefore clear who did it. The remains are not even scratched from above but tectonically displaced-there is no doubt. Satellite image could show the explosion, too, but the US is saving it for later, I suspect
@vish_globalist
@vish_globalist Год назад
Russia loses big time because of the breach of the Nova Kakhovka dam. There are 3 main aspects to this : 1. The massive flooding damage to areas on the Russian side of Dneiper. These areas are primarily russian speaking. 2. Crimea's water supply & agriculture will be impacted badly. The dam can be rebuilt but that will take time. 3. Russian fortifications on the Dneiper banks will be destroyed. 4. Since flooding is primarily on the Russian side, some of the Russian forces will have to diverted to help the locals who have always been pro-russian. The dam is under Russian control. They just had to release the flood gates if they needed to release water & flood downstream. The dam was most probably destroyed by underwater drones or torpedoes. Ukraine has been using this extensively so far. Even the US realizes this. That's why the US govt sources have not blamed Russia on this unlike Nordstream. This is a huge escalation from Ukraine's side since the hundreds of thousands of civilians will be impacted because of this. It will be interesting to see how the Russians respond.
@TimBabych
@TimBabych Год назад
A. Simply releasing water through flood gates is a war crime, as author pointed out. Russia does not want that bad PR. B. Dam destruction makes sure Ukrainians will not be able to use it as a bridge. 1. Russians do not care about civilians. Kherson itself is just as Russian-speaking as Oleshky, and they shelled it daily. 2. From Rus point of view, is they lost South, Ukrainians would cut water to Crimea anyway, right? 3. Fortifications would be lost, yes, but a sea of mud is also a very effective defense 4. Russia claims that everything is fine, there are no evacuation requests(!!) They just do not care about those Ukr civilians, they perceive them just as traitorous as people of Kherson.
@CaptainRangeen
@CaptainRangeen Год назад
Everything is fair in love and war.! All the rules go for toss. Power wins and writes history and makes new rules thereafter.
@0609Bhuwan
@0609Bhuwan Год назад
Why would Russians Blow up a Dam when 1) most of the Flooding effects the lower lying Russian Held regions of Kherson Oblast 2) Put the water supply of Crimea at risk 3) Put the ZNP under threat ?? After loosing Bakhmut 15 days ago the AFU again lost badly yesterday in their long awaited "counter offensive" in Zaprozhia loosing 3700 fresh NATO trained troops and 50 Tanks [ including 6 Leopards ] ..Ukraine is now just flailing
@harshb747
@harshb747 Год назад
Nope, dam is under russian occupation. It is very difficult to blow such a big dam by sneaking in explosives in a war situation. Russia has done it for sure as revenge for nord stream
@mandarinandthetenrings2201
@mandarinandthetenrings2201 Год назад
It too late Indian, you got bigger problems that water the reservoir held was used to grow wheat that was then sold into the Middle East. Your going have more riots and revolution and that could de-stabilized the oil supply and cause problems for India which still gets 85% of it's oil from the Middle East.
@the__source
@the__source Год назад
They did it..
@Lee-pf6od
@Lee-pf6od Год назад
Why wouldn't Russians controlling the dam release CCTV footage of whatever happened?
@fatgitchenko4793
@fatgitchenko4793 Год назад
Kutehji the Russian blew up the damn.
@mxxmauuhan3597
@mxxmauuhan3597 Год назад
Everthing is fare in war
@user-kv3ww2gb2e
@user-kv3ww2gb2e Год назад
Could you tell why Russians want to do it on predominately Russian population? Water from Kachovka should go to Crimea? So you tel me who is benefits?
@A7T043
@A7T043 Год назад
See my comments above please.
@urrasscal8380
@urrasscal8380 Год назад
this people are librandus .. they don't use brain.
@TimBabych
@TimBabych Год назад
Simple. Russians want to win the battle and they do not care about the population. Also, if they lose the South, Ukrainians would be able to cut water to Crimea anyway, if they want to.
@VijeDerm
@VijeDerm Год назад
SG, superb interpretation, jury is out there
@lisagrobbelaar-el6ls
@lisagrobbelaar-el6ls Год назад
That is Russia
@mikeharland3358
@mikeharland3358 Год назад
What about our dam busters?
@benukakati9915
@benukakati9915 Год назад
India replaced by Phillipones as QUAD member at US order.
@erker6423
@erker6423 Год назад
Just ask the simple question: who benefits from this attack ? Ukr. Why: because i) this water has been feeding Crimea, ii) the dam and water structures have been part and parcel of RU's defence buildup, iii) already in Oct 2022, the operational head of the Ukr' s general staff has announced, that they will target this dam iv) civilian losses are irrelevant to the Ukr army, because these loses are denounced as 'pro-RU'. facts....
@DeccanPS
@DeccanPS Год назад
How can you expect a Western Stooge to say these? His funding will run dry immediately.
@jkardez4794
@jkardez4794 Год назад
Get yourself medically tested . Early dementia cannot be ruled out .
@Lee-pf6od
@Lee-pf6od Год назад
Why was CCTV of dam, working fine last year, suddenly not available as evidence?
@fatgitchenko4793
@fatgitchenko4793 Год назад
Kuteh Ukraine didn't blow up the dam, it was Putin, get tested for early dementia kuteh.
@dannydev987
@dannydev987 Год назад
Sir in any case right from onset of this war you seem to be anti Russia , why ?
@ratnasurin
@ratnasurin Год назад
8 June 2023 / Kherson Floods 😢
@NutopianBlr
@NutopianBlr Год назад
Ukrainian sources!
@the__source
@the__source Год назад
Russia did it
@mahaboobjan373
@mahaboobjan373 Год назад
Sir is it a conspirese of NATO alyes peopl say that zalanski is not botherd for his country and people
@Manikanta-hh7wp
@Manikanta-hh7wp Год назад
coping hared inferring Russians did it... lol This is exactly the reason why Russia withdrew Kherson. Russians are not knocked out of Kherson, it withdrew because they will be drown if dam collapses. Ukraine exactly did what is expected.
@pranjalipranjali2751
@pranjalipranjali2751 Год назад
15:30
@minimercadochimbundo1710
@minimercadochimbundo1710 Год назад
Pro russians stream blaming ucranians
@baraka094
@baraka094 Год назад
Shaker ji what about israel blowing up palestinian houses
@vinaysinha7598
@vinaysinha7598 Год назад
Kindly talk about upsurge in khaalistanis activity in Canada and its impact on Indo Canada relationship.
@Zambia974
@Zambia974 Год назад
😮
@factytop10s45
@factytop10s45 Год назад
The dam was under russian occupation so it's russian even the russian teolls where confused who did it
@NeelanjanBandyopadhyay
@NeelanjanBandyopadhyay Год назад
US blew up the Nord Stream pipeline. Poland has accepted it [and then deleted tweet also just as fast]. Stop putting American talking-points. Ukraine doesn't have capability to strike so deep and there is not one but several pipes, place hold charges and execute it professionally; in India MARCOS would do it. It was a joint CIA+ Navy Seals and Dutch errand boys Job.
@pranjalipranjali2751
@pranjalipranjali2751 Год назад
9:30
@paldenronaldo5136
@paldenronaldo5136 Год назад
Only Russia can do something like this
@cssudhakar
@cssudhakar Год назад
Its the Mr. Clown Zelensky who do not have balls to fight Russia directly has done it. Victory and Glory to Russia!!!!
@paldenronaldo5136
@paldenronaldo5136 Год назад
@@cssudhakar It is better to be a clown than crazy psychopath like Putin. Its been more than year after Russia launched war on Ukraine and where is the victory and I don't see there will be glory either for Russia by invading its neighbour and killing innocent people. There will be both victory and glory if the war stops as soon as possible and peace restored.
@urrasscal8380
@urrasscal8380 Год назад
@@cssudhakar typical iindian who were sslave for nearly 800 years & now giving lecture out here. u sud take ur librandugiri & shove it to ur own assssssss.
@NutopianBlr
@NutopianBlr Год назад
Russian government document in English?! 😂
@TimBabych
@TimBabych Год назад
There is a thing called Google Translate... actual.pravo.gov.ru/text.html#pnum=0001202305310067
@the__source
@the__source Год назад
RUSSIA DID IT.
@johngosling1
@johngosling1 Год назад
Once again, another excellent review by Shekhar ji. And he wears nice shirts too.
@jayantjolly
@jayantjolly Год назад
True sir!! But I believe he is wearing a "Kurta"
@DeccanPS
@DeccanPS Год назад
Excellent😂. He was just parroting the Western narrative. Complete slave of western media.
@johngosling1
@johngosling1 Год назад
@@jayantjolly Thank you for correcting me.
@urrasscal8380
@urrasscal8380 Год назад
@@johngosling1 he is just following jjesus christ just like jjesus he want's to commit ssuicide for the ssins of others.
@ashokkher9551
@ashokkher9551 Год назад
Advise ur mentor Howler gandy To go to ukrain, tach them about force & power,, it will solve their issues He should do ukrain Russia jodo yatra U will climb Everest & shout Allo o Akbar Mar jakad, jakad per jakad Mugal spokesman😅
@mehulsompura278
@mehulsompura278 Год назад
You have no stand but select Ukrainian version says where you are stop pretending
@krishdb38
@krishdb38 Год назад
I only watch russia ukraine analysis by you Your analysis is perfect always
@akshayhiremath4584
@akshayhiremath4584 Год назад
By this episode's end, I felt bad for poor animals. Yesterday, in a Twitter Space hosted by Bobby Kennedy, he was saying the casualties ratio between Ukraine and Russia is 7:1. For every 1 Russian dying in this war there are 7 Ukrainians dying. He was in support of ending the war and he said the US should let Russia keep Donbas and Luhansk and also settle on the Minsk agreement. This Twitter Space was co-hosted by Elon Musk himself and he was talking in this Space. Bobby Kennedy is running for President of the US in 2024. It seems the whole of the US right is in favour of ending the war with things favouring Russia. And there is an open talk kind of favouring Russia and China. The 2024 US election is going to decide who gets to keep what in this war. If Republicans win the election, Ukraine is screwed. Zelensky should have traded very cautiously all this while.
@5678sothourn
@5678sothourn Год назад
That is the biggest load of lies I've seen in this comment section
@the__source
@the__source Год назад
Where do you get this stuff?!🤔 Oh yeah, you are spouting Russian garbage..
@Lee-pf6od
@Lee-pf6od Год назад
US doesn't get to decide what territory Russia keeps.
@akshayhiremath4584
@akshayhiremath4584 Год назад
@@Lee-pf6od At the moment if US withdraws support Ukraine can’t continue this war
@Lee-pf6od
@Lee-pf6od Год назад
@@akshayhiremath4584 not really, there's a lot of ways it can drag out - never mind that the right leaning house speaker has already reaffirmed his support for a full Russian withdrawal. Elon Musk 🤣 he has no voice in this, you're really stretching.
@jibinvarghese656
@jibinvarghese656 Год назад
The problem is you are severely american biased..
@GolfNut867
@GolfNut867 Год назад
Ukraine clearly blew up the dam. They benefit more.
@user-zm9dt7sn8j
@user-zm9dt7sn8j Год назад
Clearly your comment is biased and has no arguments.
@MaryTongx
@MaryTongx Год назад
I am from Spain, my friend in Texas referred me to this channel you make a lot of sense but I do not understand anything until she referred me to a financial counselor in USA that help me to craft my portfolio and over a year we have been working together making consistent profit enough to get me a new apartment and care for parents.
@MaryTongx
@MaryTongx Год назад
it is not a he. It is a lady. I see most things she says and use to carry out trades are done by Steve. that is how I know she knows what she is doing. in her technique of over night trading she says she use stop loss and take profit strategy. She trade on her account and it reflects on your own @Joseph Green
@MaryTongx
@MaryTongx Год назад
@Joseph Green Her name is Christy Vallen D'souza . Look her up online, she is quite popular in America and a certified financial adviser.
@MaryTongx
@MaryTongx Год назад
@Joseph Green I have referred a few of my friends, she is working with them currently and they have improved greatly with their finances. I have made 153,000 usd since Nov with a capital of 10,000 usd that i initially deposited, she collects her fees after you have made profit and her style is such that I am in control of my funds and to a large extent also what happens on my account
@shashih5174
@shashih5174 Год назад
first
@Drganguli
@Drganguli Год назад
Ukraine will not be able to defeat Russia snd Russia will not be able to defeat Ukraine
@mulamulelilumadi4717
@mulamulelilumadi4717 Год назад
Zelensky copying KMT tactic against imperial Japan?
@5678sothourn
@5678sothourn Год назад
More like Russians up to their old tricks. Not the first time they blew up a dam in Ukraine
@darkprince1632
@darkprince1632 Год назад
Nika melkozerova is a part of nazistic organization called Azov, former member of Azov, before SO she was in group in ukraine who hunting and killing africans, jews, and other nation, who Azov thinking are not pure like they, ukranians, ukranian thinking they are pure blood and white skin, they thinking they are overlord, my friend from central african republic who was learned in one of Kyev university and lived in Kyev, was died from azov's hands, now nika is journalist and working for zelensky's war crime goverment
@urrasscal8380
@urrasscal8380 Год назад
iindia got independence because of hhitler ----he caused 2nd world war where britain got ffucked so they were unable to sustain iindian military force after the war they needed couple of years to fix this but in the meantime indian navy rebel and they get scared that what will happen if land army rebel and so wanted to get out as soon as possible so that's why india got independence.
Далее
Как подписать? 😂 #shorts
00:10
Просмотров 536 тыс.
Как подписать? 😂 #shorts
00:10
Просмотров 536 тыс.