I liked the Black Nickel bass more than I did the Silver Plated bass. The Black Nickel had more of a focused sound and spoke better than the Silver Plated.
I've got a Yamaha B441 and the Black Nickel sounds more like the Yamaha's Gold/Brass. I have the Bass flute because of its broad, low tone. So my personal preference is the Black Nickel
I get that, they are both so fun to play! In terms of practicality, alto will probably be used more for ensembles etc. Also, I have found more sheet music for Alto than Bass, but I don't think you can go wrong with either!
I think purple, like what lines the case, is my favorite color. Gina, I think bass is my favorite flute in the family. Well, bass guitar is my main instrument, so why not? Great sound, too! What does a bass flute typically retail for?
I can't afford it right now anyway, but I want the black nickel one and can't find it anywhere. I hope they have it by the time I'm able to buy one. I specifically want the Trevor James brand after watching your videos.
I usually like and get a lot out of your reviews. However, in this one, there was way too much about the bag, case, crutches, etc., and hardly any playing for comparison of the two flutes. So, I wasn’t able to really make any judgement at all.
As a technician, I agree. The embouchure hole requires hand refining and finishing in its production. No two are exactly alike. That's where the tonal differences will occur in two flutes of the same make and model. The finish makes no significant difference. There IS a psychological difference. When I polish my flute, I truly believe it sounds better - but I know there's no difference, I'm just focusing, enjoying and appreciating it more.
