Tribal People React to PINK FLOYD - WISH YOU WERE HERE Pulse Live

Подписаться 252 тыс.

Просмотров 498 тыс.

50% 1

Tribal people reacting to Pink Floyd's Wish You Were Here performance live at Pulse
Our patreon: / trybals
Buy a coffee for Adnan: www.buymeacoffee.com/trybalse...
Merch: trybals.myspreadshop.com/
Follow us on:
Facebook: / trybals-105923538317572
Instagram: / trybals_official
Twitter: / trybals1
Please note that this is a reaction video and contains commentary.
For the original video please click here:
• Pink Floyd - Wish You ...
Consider supporting PINK FLOYD here:
/ @pinkfloyd
If you are the original copyright owner and would like this video to be taken down please reach out to me at trybalsofficial@gmail.com
All the participants in this video are from Sindh, Pakistan.
Make sure to leave a like and valuable suggestions and please support our channel by hitting that subscribe button. Thanks for watching
www.copyright.gov/fair-use/
Copyright Disclaimer under section 107 of the Copyright Act of 1976, allowance is made for “fair use” for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, education and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.”
#TribalPeopleReact #PinkFloyd #WishYouWereHere

Опубликовано:

22 фев 2022

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 1,3 тыс.

@TRYBALS 2 года назад

So, can any of you guys guess who I was talking about at the end of this video? P.S. I know that the man on guitars might not be Roger Waters, I listen to their audios most of the time so I'm really unaware how they have changed over the years. My sincere apologies 🙏

@tondalayakapoofnick2681 2 года назад

David Gilmour

@ThomasKelly669 2 года назад

Floyd never stopped developing always pushing boundaries of technology like YES and Radiohead in modern times Time/great gig in the sky, also from. Dark side of the moon album, touches so deep Going to see Australian pink Floyd tribute band with a girl from Algeria was an amazing experience for Muslim girl that grew up in The country side, She was amazed at vocals joining time and great gig together

@carlymestep9001 2 года назад

Hey man nice gun?

@hcfan109 2 года назад

There are so many versions of this song. I don't know.

@TheDoctorFlay 2 года назад

David joined as a second guitarist while Syd was still in the band. Syd didn't leave the band. The band left Syd. Due to Syd becoming more erratic and unreliable, the band decided not to bother collecting Syd on the way to a gig as they usually did. They felt guilty ever since, especially Roger (the Bass guitarist) who had become close friends with Syd. The video you used is from years after Pink Floyd had also parted company with Roger Waters, so Roger is not in this video. A few years later Roger did perform the song with Pink Floyd at the Live 8 concert in 2005.

@flamoby 2 года назад

When I was a little girl my dad used to turn off all the lights in the house and play Pink Floyd. To this day Dark Side of the Moon it's like lullabies to me

@mraza9 2 года назад

Same.

@rockymillwood3347 2 года назад

❤✌I put my girls to sleep with it from time to time.

@thisismagacountry1318 2 года назад

Was there a nice, if unfamiliar, smell in the air? There always seems to be whenever I play Pink Floyd.

@flamoby 2 года назад

Come to think of it....hahahaha.

@televinv8062 2 года назад

🙏👍

@magnificentfailure2390 2 года назад

When I was in 10th grade (14-15 years old) I knew a girl named Robin who introduced me to this song. I had a crush on her, but she was my friend's girlfriend. They had a really terrible fight one time, and she took her own life afterwards. Years later, I learned how to play this song, but I can't play it without shedding tears for her and the life she should have had.

@TRYBALS 2 года назад

Sorry sorry to hear about her. May she rest in peace 🌷

@magnificentfailure2390 2 года назад

@@TRYBALS Thank you for that. I also hope that she found peace. Thank you for this channel.

@julilla1 2 года назад

My condolences to you. So very sad, and I wish she was here, too. 😢

@leeryder676 2 года назад

Man 😟

@SteveSmith-zz4ih 2 года назад

That would be so so painful (sorry for your loss) the unfortunate thing it happens far too often at all ages and sex, i reall yhope young folk can see that there are plenty of other people out there that will love them - come hell or high water.

@cheshirehat93 2 года назад

Pink Floyd breaks all language barriers.

@joyalexander5842 2 года назад

I read through some of the comments. I am so glad that people are seeing the hard work you are putting into your videos. I like the different color backgrounds for each person. I remember Parvati was so excited to be attending the wedding. Tribals is the reason she is able to go and take part. I hope she is smiling and having a wonderful time. Sisterly hugs, Joy Texas, USA

@TRYBALS 2 года назад

Thank you Joy, that was another wedding she was talking about that she attended. This one is more important to her. It's one of her brother's wedding 🙂

@limner123 2 года назад

I was also pleased and impressed with the clever editing Edit: and I'm also from Texas!

@guys8162 2 года назад

The gentlemen are wonderful. Their culture is so different to mine and I automatically expect them to not like the Western music, but to see them smile at Michael Jackson and to sort of fancy Cyndi Lauper in previous videos and enjoy different music makes me smile.

@hollywhatley5510 2 года назад

Muhkitair... I know I'm spelling it wrong... his fixation on Cindi is the cutest thing! The acrylic pour he does is amazing. These guys (as well as Pavarti, she isn't in this one) give me hope that maybe the world isn't all that bad

@Yks0 2 года назад

@sko1beer 2 года назад

I want them to react to watching gay porn for the first time

@SparkyOne549 2 года назад

Music is universal, it has no boundaries.

@zainm5919 2 года назад

michael jackson is liked in every corner of the world why would they be any different lol

@GrandmaLoves2Scuba 2 года назад

I was 16, he was 21. 46 years later he died. We met in 1972. When I hear this song I have to turn it off. The pain is too intense. Not that it was our song or anything, ( in fact his fav was Angie from the Stones. And Beast of Burden, again the Stones). But the lyrics kill me. We were two lost souls swimming in a fish bowl, year after year, and I truly wish he was here. I'm in tears just writing this. I will do my best to finish the video. Sorry for dumping guys... This is such a beautiful song that it breaks my heart to not be able to listen to it. I'm out. Love you guys.

@RM-ke3sj 2 года назад

From one Grandma to another.... i don’t know you but I was so touched by your message. Sounds like you had 46 good years with your man and that, in itself, is wonderful. Big hug....

@JF-kv1gm 2 года назад

Oh, some songs just open up the wound, don't they? It's a beautiful thing that you had so many years together. So sorry that your soulmate passed. Sending a virtual hug and praying that you find joy and wonder in the times ahead.

@kjpcgaming9296 2 года назад

We all share a heart. And this one cuts us deeply. It's a reminder of all that has been taken and all that's been lost. The song speaks truth and that's the deepest cut.

@PoeticExistance 2 года назад

You know, he's still with you. and he wouldn't want you to be sad. He had the time of his life, and just like yours, and mine as well, all things will come to an end, and those we leave behind are going to miss us, as well.

@PoeticExistance 2 года назад

My condolences for your loss, my heart is with you.

@jessesimmons4503 2 года назад

“Everyone has some sort of inner problems” Very true words.

@TYoung023 2 года назад

If you were to do more Pink Floyd, I would suggest “The Great Gig in the Sky” (studio version). It is mainly a female vocalist (Clare Torry) hired by the band who sings without using words. Through just the powerful feelings she conveys with her voice, the stages of dying can be understood. Denial, Acceptance, and the Final moments basically. A beautiful song, especially when you understand it’s meaning before you listen to it!

@KootFloris 2 года назад

I agree: Great Gig in the Sky. It also will feel very accessible for these tribal people, as the singing is closer to Pakistani tradition, while still being very different.

@kellyrhoads1341 2 года назад

Agree

@cjhnm9492 2 года назад

Listen to "Time" right before it

@carysfaerie 2 года назад

I second that

@joeday4293 2 года назад

Ohhhh, GREAT suggestion. No translation necessary.

@AnonYmous-uw2qm 2 года назад

I absolutely LOVE THIS ...this is how we can come to know one another, with no politicians, war mongers and hate spinners getting in the way. Music is..... real communication

@am4793 2 года назад

These guys analysed the song very well. They knew the depth of the writer's feelings. 👍

@Dorelaxen 2 года назад

"Did they get you to trade your heroes for ghosts" As I get older, that lyric comes back to me often. Yes, they did get me to trade my heroes for ghosts. So many that I grew up on and with are now gone, more every day it seems. I know life is a zero sum game, but it never, ever gets any easier. I just get number to it, I think. Comfortably Numb perhaps.

@julilla1 2 года назад

I get it, though "Comfortably Numb" reminds me of some events of my childhood and hurts that way. But now, "Time" really gets to me, 'no one told you when to run, you missed the starting gun.'

@CognitiveDissident. 2 года назад

Shine on, you crazy diamond.

@88wildcat 2 года назад

The lyric that has always got to me in this song is "did you exchange a walk on part in the war for a lead role in a cage." The lyrics for the whole song are fantastic but there has always been something about that particular line that has always been the spinal cord of the song for me.

@jeannie7469 2 года назад

Lost my best friend to addiction. 7 years later I still cry every day.

@TRYBALS 2 года назад

May their soul rest in peace 🌷

@Nosirrah2112 2 года назад

God bless

@servo66 Год назад

I love that they all say "bro" a lot. Just goes to show, no matter where you go, bros will be bros.....

@jallenwatson8109 2 года назад

First time I realized David sang notes too, always thought another guitar was doing it. Thanks for enlightening me with this version. I wish Parvarti could have seen this one.

@TRYBALS 2 года назад

Parvati is busy for a while, she has a wedding ceremony back at home.

@Uthgardloki 2 года назад

@@TRYBALS may the wedding she is attending go off without a problem and the couple who are to be wed, may they have as happy a life as they strive for.

@TRYBALS 2 года назад

@@Uthgardloki Amen, though it reminds me a question she asked when she watched Rammstein live for the first time: "Do they play at weddings?" 😃😜🤘🤗❤️🌷

@Uthgardloki 2 года назад

@@TRYBALS I would love to see rammstein perform at a wedding I officiated at lol I've performed 3 weddings so far.

@Hundhammer 2 года назад

@@TRYBALS rofl...

@supitzsammm 3 месяца назад

Just found this channel and it's incredible seeing people from the other side of the world appreciating Pink Floyd.

@mustafapessoa 2 года назад

I'm 18, I myself am Tribal, and it's my mother tongue that you're talking in, and the way you explained this song in depth was amazing. I was surprised. Thank you for this video.

@Gemini_Mama 2 года назад

Once again Trybals, you've left me smiling ear to ear. I hope you and they all know just how much joy these videos are spreading all over the world! Muharam is my favorite to watch, because he always looks so happy to be listening to something new, and like he's actually trying to *feel* the song. All of them are wonderful to watch, truly. Sending gratitude, love, and joy, from Minnesota, USA!

@apexmitch7986 2 года назад

"Wish You were Here" is the best song ever written -- all genres.

@ADRAGONSLIFE 2 года назад

Comfortably Numb is the best in my opinion . But all Floyd is awesome . Lol

@kingboagart899 2 года назад

Maybe..

@rohankurian5641 2 года назад

This is #beautiful ❤❤❤

@Kbax3614 Год назад

But then there are tons of a7x and dream theater songs better than that both emotionally and musically.

@igfernando2007 2 года назад

I'd love to see or hear something from their (Tribal) culture that would be considered valuable, beautiful, folky, very dear to them and let us send our comments, let us react to it. Perhaps each could chose something to show us, a prayer, a song, a story, a painting.... etc

@natasakrpina160 2 года назад

Igore that's a great idea! I was thinking the same thing. We could have a proper interaction like that. 😊

@2degucitas 2 года назад

THIS! /\

@nuxboxen 2 года назад

Please Yes

@christiansky942 2 года назад

Ustad Manzoor Ali Khan was mentioned in the Mongolian throat singing video. Good stuff

@Vidchemy 2 года назад

You did a good job explaining the main topics in the song. It is not always easy, as there are differences in culture and interpreting meaning as well as emotion. To these gentlemen, sadness needs more loud voices and chest beating, while in some Western cultures, immense sadness is expressed very subtly. Also, it was about the feelings of a man toward a fellow man, so less emotion might be expected.

@followtheboat 2 года назад

Some valid observations there 👍

@SithCelia 2 года назад

Reading these comments and remembering various PF lyrics in other albums, I'm thinking about that one reference to quiet desperation being the English way in "Breathe." Quiet desperation is just what I hear when I listen to Gilmour sing "Wish You Were Here." He's sad in his remembering his friend, but he's reserved in his emotions.

@Angela-jc8bk Год назад

One thing I would have said to clarify is that this song is about when the pain of losing someone is not fresh and immediate. It is pain that one has learnt to live with, the quiet grief that stays with you always. That you feel when you are unexpectedly reminded of the person by sight, scent, or sound.

@subg8858 Год назад

Yeah I don’t think that’s it. This is in fact very coldly performed music emotionally. They have appreciated more subtle music than this

@Angela-jc8bk Год назад

@@subg8858 I don't find it coldly performed at all. Those words sung quietly, flavored by ancient grief and anger, the taste of regret and wondering if things could have been different had you tried harder.

@davepetros3827 2 года назад

Thanks for these, Trybals. Editing these reactions has to be quite the task. Your effort is worth it from my perspective

@TRYBALS 2 года назад

It really is, but every second working on these is worth everything ❤️

@usuallyclueless4477 2 года назад

Please show them "time" by Pink Floyd. I believe they will have a lot to say about it.

@dyl7257 2 года назад

Very interesting reaction from the Trybals team!. As someone who lives with mental health issues this song calms the storm in my head when it arrives! Thank you for showing this masterpiece to the reactors!. Much love 🤘

@rahratman8712 2 года назад

The song is expressing so much beauty too - like "this is so beautiful, and I wish you could be here to see it and be part of it" so there are layers of emotion expressed. It's bittersweet. A very different tone than hurt, since one is about a man destitute and this is about a man who has gained everything but misses his friend. ❤

@VinnyMickeyRickeyDickeyEddy 2 года назад

It's beautiful to hear their impressions of these songs I've heard so many times. It makes them new again.

@johnthompson6374 2 года назад

Comparing Cash and Pink Floyd is interesting. While both songs are connected to addiction and loss they are both from two very opposite perspectives. While David Gilmour was sharing his feelings of losing a friend many years ago Johnny Cash was sharing his feelings of regret for those he had personally harmed including himself. Both have been on my list of top 50 for years, including NINs version of hurt. It really pained me for Parvarti to miss an introduction to Pink Floyd, I hope you will be able to right that wrong. Wish You Were Here has always reminded me how all of us have had to make choices alone and as a society and many of those choices we may never get to change or make again. Connected more than ever, Peace/JT

@yodude9624 2 года назад

Gilmour

@johnthompson6374 2 года назад

@@yodude9624 oops, not sure how i did that, Thank you.

@micarsenijevic2313 Год назад

7.40 " you will receive what you choose " nailed it

@marcusbergman6116 Год назад

This is one of my top 3 favorite Pink Floyd songs. Good pick.

@angelagraves865 2 года назад

💗💗Pink Floyd is truly unmatched in music. I love this song but I was really hoping they'd get to hear/see Comfortably Numb with it's epic guitar solo and light show. Maybe have them compare David Gilmour's playing in this video against that in Comfortably Numb. Regardless, I'm really glad they've gotten to see at least a little Pink Floyd. 💗💗

@TRYBALS 2 года назад

Personally, I also wish I could have played it. But you if you see, I try to introduce new music to them based on the previous one. This is on the same topic but with a whole new perspective. Comfortably numb is still on the list 🤗❤️🌷

@flamoby 2 года назад

@@TRYBALS you do a fantastic job. Excellent selections.

@roachdoggjr45 2 года назад

@@TRYBALS Please do "shine on you crazy diamond". It's my favorite and I am a musician who thinks this is one of the best ever made. Here is the link; ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-CiXNIjGX1hY.html Please sir, their reaction to the saxophone at the end would be amazing, their reaction to the live setting would be interesting as well. This song also has lights and stuff as well, best to watch it in a dim room. (I would say dark room, but you have to film them, you can't do that in the dark). Thank you for your consideration, great work as always! You are on the path to a million subs. Or more... :)

@Caperhere 2 года назад

@@TRYBALS There are two more good addiction songs I can think of about addiction. She Talks To Angels, and How To Save A Life. Kris Kristofferson also wrote a popular song about Johnny Cash’s addiction.

@Somer-set 2 года назад

You prefer that to the Shine on you guitar??

@manlioyllades 2 года назад

They should react to 'Comfortably Numb' from the same concert (Pulse). They'll be amazed at the guitar sólo and light show.

@andrewstanton1790 2 года назад

Thank you so much for this! You are all so thoughtful and kind. God has blessed us with your videos. Your perspectives brought new light to an old song for me. It was beautiful.

@esthermorgernstern5627 2 года назад

Yet another great reaction! I am going to be very brief today. Just wanted to let you know how much I enjoy your channel and how much I enjoy every one of you. As I said before...I do not have any family and everytime I watch you channel, it's like coming home to friends and family. Much blessings and peace to you all. I wish upon one day we could meet...

@TRYBALS 2 года назад

Hey Esther, I remember you saying same on another video. And I'd like to remind you that we are like a family indeed. Lots of love, looking forward to meet you and everyone else someday hopefully 🤗🤗🤗

@battygirlrachel 2 года назад

Agreed! It's almost like sitting down for a chat and catching up. There are a couple channels I watch that give me that vibe and I never miss a vid. When I was younger I had friends I could talk to about anything for hours... I don't have that any more so this channel in particular or special to me for that reason.

@ScotsyCajn 2 года назад

Oh, this song. Tears forming in my eyes as the first few verses are sung. I had hoped this would be the album version, but, it’s this one was just as good. This song is powerful to me. Always has been. Now, that my best friends dad, Mike, has passed away last year… it means even more. He was a huge Pink Floyd fan and would have LOVED to see this video. Thank you so much for each of y’all’s hard work. Love you all very much. 🖤💖

@shayloman1912 2 года назад

My favorite of all time bands to listen and sing with.

@andreasgrunenberg8010 2 года назад

You guys are all awsome, Wisdom and authencity. Everyone of you

@pdog547 2 года назад

This is an amazing channel. Screw politics and media, this is real. It restores faith in humanity, something I think we all need right now. Thanks from Canada.

@Sankara561 2 года назад

Another great song choice. The songs that are timeless cultural landmarks are the best to hear the team's opinions on.

@flamoby 2 года назад

I would love to spend the day just listening to Abdul talking. He has a lot of very wise insights. He reminds me of a friend's father from Karachi who passed away last month.

@Caperhere 2 года назад

Great choice, happy they liked it.

@tamgsmith8077 2 года назад

I love this. The simplicity with which these people think is beautiful. Once again teaching us that no matter what we are all human and emotionally we are one.

@truthsayers8725 2 года назад

this is a painful song for me to listen to. my best friend, of well over 40 years (we shared a birthday, one year apart) died from a cocaine induced heart attack. i had no idea he was using or i would have intervened. he passed 10 years ago this coming August... Ron, i wish you were here. i miss you terribly

@sundaywasabi 2 года назад

Sorry for your loss! I've never known Ron, but I too wish he was here, so you could have more than just good memories of him.

@MrRicehard 2 года назад

Thank you once more for the beautiful content and the tears in my eyes.

@Cheyanne999 2 года назад

Thank you for the pick-me-up in the middle of a rough day, loved the video and song choice. Lots of love from our family to yours!❤️ (ps please pet the kitties for us)

@DrBlazer50 2 года назад

This song always gives me goosebumps and makes the hair on my arms stand up. I've shed a lot of tears because of this song! Pink Floyd has caused me to shed enough tears to fill an Olympic swiming pool.

@steveaumann6335 2 года назад

Excellent video, I’ve listened to that song for years and never knew the meaning, thanks for sharing.👏👏🙏🏿

@nenaelliott8058 2 года назад

I love this channel. You do such a great job picking just the perfect song for the TRYBALS to listen to. You play some music that I would probably never listen to if it weren't for this channel, so I guess I'm l learning to. I love the reactions you get from these kind people.. they seem to have such insight... You do such a wonderful job. Thanks

@hm_nn_5633 2 года назад

Never in my wildest dreams ... these guys reacting to Pink Floyd. You have my utmost respect.

@jacobmarshall5391 2 года назад

"Time", "High Hopes", and, "Shine On You Crazy Diamond", are all great 'Pink Floyd' songs.

@-Tidgy Год назад

The power of music, one of only a few universal languages. Whatever age, gender, culture, religion or race you are, no one will never dislike Pink Floyd, music that is capable of reaching every corner of our planet. Sounds like no other, never to be topped. Long live Pink Floyd, best band of all time. Love from the UK 🇬🇧

@WhatILoveAboutMusic64 2 года назад

I've watched a few of your videos and I'm always amazed at the insight that comes from the tribal people. For example, one gentleman mentioned something to the effect of "You get what you choose". Simple yet profound. I would love to meet and listen to them :) Please tell them how much I appreciate their insights and wisdom.

@geoffreybudge3027 2 года назад

Thank you for your program, I see us more and more as one flesh 🇺🇸

@ScoundrelSFB 2 года назад

So happy Syd Barret struggle was mentioned and justice was done on his behalf and his plight was explained and these fine gentlemen empathized. Damn this was a good one.

@Toka972 2 года назад

Amazing song. For years it was used to test the performances of sound systems and speakers - the studio version had the highest quality and range between bass and twitters... Still to this day, one of the most amazing and still used for calibration. Try this at home - find a good version - then when you play it, try to arrange your settings so you can hear the very beginning of the 1st guitar arrangement without having bass and twitters getting crushed later. It is extremely hard because this is one of the softest and sensitive start. If you manage this, congratulations, your system is on point.

@DustinManke 2 года назад

Pink Floyd has always been one of my favorite groups, ever since I first heard them. Love the content.

@alpha-alpha-alpha 2 года назад

I love the lyrics that makes you think and makes you be more alive

@depotdevoid 2 года назад

This is one of my all time favorite songs. Thank you for this video.

@hollywhatley5510 2 года назад

I have thoroughly enjoyed each video TRYBALS has put out. Adnan, your ability to bring people to real experiences and emotions never fails. Thank you. 😊

@kellyrhoads1341 2 года назад

My favorite band. Two of my fav songs, this one and shine on, both deal with Syd and the pain they feel watching his schizophrenia and drug addiction. Watching their reaction was beautiful. Thank you for this gift

@jotwee63 2 года назад

Wish you were here is not about syd barett, as stated many times by Pink Floyd in various interview

@soulbrotherno1708 2 года назад

These guys show a lot of respect for the music! Very nice!

@DerGlaetze 2 года назад

The international language of great music does so much to bring the world more together.

@P4ndieEy3ss 2 года назад

This song always evokes the deepest emotions. So glad you shared this masterpiece with our wonderful participants. You do a wonderful job researching the song and explaining the intricacies. Thank you all for your channel, it brings joy in a world gone mad.

@JohnLeePettimoreIII 2 года назад

now it's time for "The Great Gig In The Sky". there are very little lyrics to translate, but it is still (in my own personal opinion) one of the most emotionally powerful songs ever made.

@Markinfilm 2 года назад

Makes me cry everytime.

@christiansky942 2 года назад

I support this

@yourcommentisntfunnyv2709 Год назад

nah

@Alba52warrior 3 месяца назад

Love to watch these lovely guys just chatting away listening to music just so peaceful love it 🫶🤜🤛

@Triggerhippie70 Год назад

This is one of my favorite Pink Floyd songs, and a quick story. My husband and I were set up on a blind date by a mutual friend. I had this song on my answer tone when people would call me on my cell phone anyway he called me to set up our first date and left me a message when I called him back. This was his answer tones so basically we had the same answer tone I was very impressed with that. 15 years later here we are with our beautiful daughter.

@TRYBALS Год назад

Such a wonderful story, thanks for sharing it ❤️

@Thetruthbetold60 2 года назад

@TRYBALS you have a beautiful channel. I am inspired by it because you show that no matter the cultural divide, we can learn things from one another and find common ground through emotions that we all experience no matter where we are from or the languages we speak. I enjoy listening to the thoughts and interpretations of your guests and the honest effort they put in to finding connections with their own life experiences, and the way they are open to the new experiences. 💗

@headpump Год назад

I have friendly respect for all members of the Trybals team. In spite of our cultural and experience differences, we are all walking on the road of life together..

@asianguy6174 2 года назад

Brilliant interpretation from an unlikely source. The sheer humanity and empathy of these people is moving. Mankind the world over seeks understanding and compassion.

@jamesflynn7054 2 года назад

Always entertaining, thank you for the video!

@janacariad 2 года назад

Very interesting reactions! For me this song will always be associated with the funeral of my dad's cousin who was also my teacher when I was a child, and I'm a rather quiet griever as well... I'm screaming inside, but not on the outside... Looking forward to the other song you mentioned! On that note - I'd be very interested to see reactions to Bonnie Tyler's "Total Eclipse of the Heart". She's an amazingly talented singer with a unique voice and the style of the song, Wagnerian Rock, is also one of a kind.

@Toka972 2 года назад

An amazing song and a huge part of music history. The studio version had one of the highest quality of recording ever. It was the absolute best for more than a decade and was used by professional for performance benchmark for sound systems and speakers. Try this at home: find a good studio version. Try settings that allows you to hear the very first guitar chords and see if your sound system can perform them while being able to play the rest of the song without hurting the speakers. The start of the song is one of the most gentle ever recorded and it is a great technical performance. If you manage to bring it out, congratulations : you performed a calibration and your sound system is on point.

@musicfanBRA 9 месяцев назад

Thank you for these videos, it's a treat to see both a vintage Pink Floyd and the reactions of these gentlemen. They catch the vibe of the song.

@shampoovta 2 года назад

Pink Floyd has amazing stage shows.

@joisagirlsname 2 года назад

Great song choice! Really hard to interpret accurately as pink floyd use so much metaphor and phrases with two or more meanings (and each meaning matters). This song is particularly dense with these, so you've done really well. 😊

@Futt.Buckerson 2 года назад

The next songs from Pink Floyd should be from Dark Side of the Moon. That album is so intense and chilling. Undoubtedly one of the most beautiful rock albums ever written. The Wall is fun, but Dark Side is where it's at. I don't know that Syd's problem was addiction, so much as latent mental health issues that the drugs made worse. But the two can look the same, and sometimes it's both

@stefanbach7652 2 года назад

It was LSD and he took way too much and his brain burned out.

@Futt.Buckerson 2 года назад

@@stefanbach7652 I'm very familiar.

@mindofzack4073 2 года назад

I feel honored to hear what these beautiful people have to say. Thank you.

@dragonmori3034 2 года назад

Whenever I had heard this song it was not only grief but also of longing for a loved one that was lost/gone. The best way I can describe it is like a longing from the heart but it isn’t screamed out into the world, but more of a whisper in the heart. Not sure if that totally made sense, but that is how I always interpreted it.

@Nashiki20 2 года назад

They liked Johnny Cash so much you should do "The man in Black". Dolly Parton is also a great story teller song writer. For her I would recommend "Coat of Many Colars". I was VERY happy to see the reaction to "Zombie" by the Cranberries, one of my most desired! I sometimes like to think you did it just for me! :)

@digitalblues01 2 года назад

Another great video and song choice. Show them Stevie Ray Vaughan please.

@digitalblues01 2 года назад

In case you didn't know Stevie had gotten over his addiction and alcohol but then died in a helicopter crash after a concert on a mountain tragically.

@joinizwe 2 года назад

I love this 4 split screen where the music video is placed in the center.

@pdog547 2 года назад

Yes, definitely the best way to do it. This channel does it right.

@peppermoon7485 2 года назад

Excited for this one! Watching it now ❤️Pink Floyd ❤️🤘

@ronaldmcisaac 2 года назад

good, humanizing the humans on the other side.

@Alex-dh2cx 2 года назад

Another amazingly well written song is Vincent by Don McLean, it's about Vincent van Gogh and his suicide and those who feel like they're not understood or cared for: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-4wrNFDxCRzU.html

@GrandmaLoves2Scuba 2 года назад

Thank you for the link, and the memories. Another stellar tune!

@LockRainmaker 2 года назад

Another artist I listen to once referred to this. "Vincent van Gogh why do you weep, you were on the way to heaven but he road was steep. And who was there to break your fall? We're guilty, one and all"

@firstlast9102 2 года назад

Watching these videos has caused me much joy here lately. What beautiful people. I love their wisdom & the way that they think & respond. Thanks for making these.

@AmberPearcy 2 года назад

Absolutely love this! Pink Floyd is my favorite band. I’m so grateful I stumbled across the channel yesterday and met some new friends here. You are all lovely people and I am also learning things from you. I can’t wait to see what else we will discover together!

@michaelb1761 2 года назад

The difference in tone was Johnny Cash was expressing sorrow, a painful sorrow, while Pink Floyd was more of a melancholy, like they had given in to what happened and accepted it. That's how it makes me feel, anyway. Also, I don't think I have ever heard a singer who was able to wring emotions, either sorrow or joy, out of me like Johnny Cash. He wasn't particularly talented as a singer, guitarist, or song writer, but he seemed to pour his soul into every performance. That made him one of the greats.

@ryanlynn146 2 года назад

I really enjoyed how we listened and then you spoke of the song. Please do some other songs. I love watching the reactions on all of your faces, lovely. Bless you~

@merjahiltunen3235 2 года назад

I'm from Sweden. I thankyou for theese videos, I've learned a lot from them. You are showing that there are more that unite us people from diffrent backgrounds than separates us. Please give my best regards to the lovely persons who are watching your videos.

@kokothegreat5583 3 месяца назад

Music can bring us all together to live in peace ✌️❤

@katewade9992 2 года назад

The clean shaven man with glasses has such an appreciation of music, he sings along & dances in his seat.

@kevinmackfurniture 2 года назад

Pink Floyd's music is Universal and Timeless. The lyrics speak to people regardless of background

@bobbylewisfdl1166 2 года назад

So cool to get other cultures of people to express their feelings and perspectives on a sing such as this, you truly captured it here and so beautiful

@tracylynn1461 2 года назад

I am so glad I found these videos today.. In a world that promotes fear of people who don't think the same or worship the same or look the same, this is a reminder that the things that make us the same far outweigh the things that make us differnt! And that the situations we face are the same no matter where in this world we are! I have watched several of your videos so far and will likely like most of them! Thank you for creating content that promotes understanding and gives me hope for a future where we all can just be ourselves and be accepted! Many blessings from Oklahoma USA

@betsya7054 2 года назад

As usual, I have a new appreciation of a song Ive heard many times. This was a great choice. I love all of the fellows, and the modest person behind the camera is fantastic

@queencelestyna 2 года назад

This is one of my favorite songs in the world! I am so happy they were able to hear it.

@joaolima3059 Год назад

Greatings my friend's. I was very happy with the comments of this gentlemans in their simple and genuine words. So quickly understood the meaning of the song and the feeling of the music. Their interpretation and comments are certainly the best one's I ever heard. Congratulations from Europe, Portugal. Keep doing it. Obrigado