Тёмный

Trumpeter Fiume Cruiser kit review compared to Hobby Boss Pola 

Harry Houdini Models
Подписаться 20 тыс.
Просмотров 16 тыс.
50% 1

Развлечения

Опубликовано:

 

7 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 103   
@jonvicsison4895
@jonvicsison4895 3 года назад
Hey Harry I loved your presentation and content. I bought the Fiume today and it's everything you said, a real beauty! Keep it up!
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 3 года назад
Awesome! Thank you!
@johnstimitz2629
@johnstimitz2629 4 года назад
I’m an armor modeler, but I will say I love watching your videos! Your ship building videos are fun to watch because I love seeing your scratch building techniques. Looking forward to your next video.
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 4 года назад
Thanks John... I have some armour videos planned soon
@jcwoodman5285
@jcwoodman5285 4 года назад
I LOVE the wood deck sets🤗 They make a model REALLY pop!😍
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 4 года назад
I totally agree!
@mozzie__au
@mozzie__au Год назад
Bought the Pola today for $30 and yeah it's pretty rough but at the end of the day it's a great starter to practice on before you start those more expensive builds.
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels Год назад
That’s a good way to look at it Mozzie
@chase_with_jase
@chase_with_jase 2 года назад
I built the Pola earlier this year, got it as a bargain from BNA models for roughly $25. Ended up buying the wooden deck from Artworx as well as the etch set you showed. Wasn't the greatest ship I have built but looked a lot better than if I had built it out of the box. But do like Trumpeter / Hobby Boss ships, just finished the Condorcet and that was a terrific and well detailed kit.
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 2 года назад
As long as you enjoyed the process... :)
@chase_with_jase
@chase_with_jase 2 года назад
@@HarryHoudiniModels Yep even though it was a basic kit I found it an enjoyable build.
@modelnut
@modelnut 4 года назад
Watching this review Harry I have a Revell Prince of Wales part started & might pick up again, had issues with the bow section. Great review & advice. 😀👍🏼
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 4 года назад
That’s the old 1974 moulding in 1:570 scale? A wood deck would hide a lot of problems on that one. There is a lot of aftermarket to help improve that kit. Just depends how deep into the rabbit hole you want to go.
@modelnut
@modelnut 4 года назад
Harry Houdini Models Thanks Harry, didn’t thing of after market! It might sort out the issues. Cheers.
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 4 года назад
There is a ship load of stuff available for this kit.. well it’s nearly 50 years old!
@usssaratogacv3lefevre978
@usssaratogacv3lefevre978 4 года назад
Yes! ships. Flume looks like a very good kit. Might consider getting one.
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 4 года назад
I am sure you would like it.
@MrRon6977
@MrRon6977 4 года назад
Hey Harry!! Nice show and tell.
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 4 года назад
All I forgot was to give the teacher an apple.
@tomwark6446
@tomwark6446 4 года назад
Well Harry you did inspire me to do something water related , I will be blaming you for some time , I'm doing an International models asia, 60ft British power boat company motor torpedo boat in 1/35 scale .
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 4 года назад
Wow! That is going to be a good size.
@fallofmanbrand
@fallofmanbrand 4 года назад
Loved It!
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 4 года назад
Thanks Matey
@billclarke5916
@billclarke5916 3 года назад
Italian affair, Harry you bad boy. Thanks for the vid.
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 3 года назад
Glad you liked it!
@McCorduRoy1972
@McCorduRoy1972 3 года назад
Just buyed the Pola for 18 € good to know it, s a bargain.
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 3 года назад
It is as long you either don’t mind the lack of detail, or are happy to scratch build the masts and other missing details
@claytonmcclain182
@claytonmcclain182 4 года назад
Awesome video Harry. Was that a photo etch set of figures? The wooden deck looks outstanding really makes the kit pop. Ship building has really come a long way when I built them. Oops forgot are you going to add that great looking camouflage?
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 4 года назад
Yes and yes. Got to do that camo and well spotted. I do have some painted photo etch sailors in 1:350 to use.
@darylsmith9155
@darylsmith9155 4 года назад
Exactly as you said it mate.
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 4 года назад
Thanks Daryl
@sebastianrichard1387
@sebastianrichard1387 3 года назад
Pola from Hobby Boss = 14€ .My First Ship.Nice for Testing
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 3 года назад
Yes good test kit
@nikkibaugher2427
@nikkibaugher2427 4 года назад
Excellent! Wow...
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 4 года назад
Many thanks!
@monk_arnie
@monk_arnie 3 года назад
Спасибо! 👍👍👍 5⭐
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 3 года назад
я рад, что тебе понравилось
@nickbutler7935
@nickbutler7935 4 года назад
Crisp well fitting mouldings.
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 4 года назад
It was quite a surprise to see the Fiume fit perfectly out of the box. The Pola, not so much.
@henrysanchez4810
@henrysanchez4810 4 года назад
Trumpeter kits are great...
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 4 года назад
The new ones certainly are...
@nickcrook6121
@nickcrook6121 4 года назад
Excellent video.i love the Fiume and think i will have to get one.silly question,are the veneer decks self adhesive?
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 4 года назад
Yes they are! But I always add a little PVA white wood glue mixed with water to allow slip, which helps position it, and the extra adhesive makes sure it won’t lift later.
@nickcrook6121
@nickcrook6121 4 года назад
Thankyou Harry
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 4 года назад
I show how it’s done in my Varyag video about decks.
@darryldyke1264
@darryldyke1264 4 года назад
Thanks Harry. Was looking at buying the Pola but I reckon I'll give it a miss.
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 4 года назад
The Pola would come up ok, but only after a lot of work and aftermarket. The Zara and Fiume are great just out of the box.
@darryldyke1264
@darryldyke1264 4 года назад
I'd build the Fiume or Gorizia but Pola has family connections. Did you know that the ships are named for towns that were in Italy at the time? Pola is now Pula in Croatia and my wife has family there. That's why I want to build the ship. In fact we're still hoping to go there for a holiday in a few weeks. Fingers crossed.
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 4 года назад
Yes, I knew about the town names... The Pola is not a horrible kit, just under detailed, by modern standards. So just depends on your expectations and skill level how the end result will be.
@JP-qb4zn
@JP-qb4zn 3 года назад
The 1/350 Pola is a very poor copy of the 1/400 Tauro kits, which had some issues of their own. These issues were amplified in a scaled up, poorly done copy with more introduced when they attempted to modify the kit for motorization. The Tauro kits didn't offer that as they were intended to be proper static models. If I recall, this was one of, if not the very first Trumpeter kit back in 1999. I threw mine out and stuck with the 1/400 Tauro kit. That said, the new 1/350 Zara and Fiume kits are completely new and have nothing whatever to do with the Pola abomination. They are in every respect what you'd expect from a current-issue Trumpeter kit. Now repeat after me: go-REE-zee-ya. :)
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 3 года назад
You obviously watched my video where I go through the quality issues of the old Pola compared to the new mould Fiume.
@JP-qb4zn
@JP-qb4zn 3 года назад
@@HarryHoudiniModels I did. When I threw mine out, it was 2001 and no real hope of a back up kit or aftermarket to help it out.
@Leptospirosi
@Leptospirosi 3 года назад
@@HarryHoudiniModels I would add that the Pola is completely screwed up in shapes and even the aftermarket deck is badly done. If you confront the bow and the stern they are badly sculpted, the positioning of the main guns, particularly the rear one is off by almost 1cm, the wooden deck extends through the bow by almost 2cm. the whole assembly of the main turret is particularly crude and nor the main turrets nor the secondary ones resemble the real thing. I spent so much time trying to address the thousand of problems until I got stuck (and I still am after 5 years)trying to redo the weirdly shaped parapets all around the upper decks of the forward and rear bridge. The Pola kit is cheap, but it's not even worth that price IMO: it's a toy, marketed to be motorized and to came out with a half decent model you have much more work to do then on the legendary Nichimo Yamato 1/200
@robertabonugli2042
@robertabonugli2042 3 года назад
Grazie
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 3 года назад
prego
@stallebrass
@stallebrass 4 года назад
Hey Harry. Great video, you've inspired me to do a warship. I'd like to build HMS Mauritius (Royal Navy Light Cruiser), which was my grandads ship on D-Day, except no such model exists. As you're the man with the expertise can you recommend an alternative that would make a good representation of this ship. Not worried if its exactly the same but as close as possible would be great. I love to to detail up so more than happy using aftermarket parts like PE, gun barrels and decking etc and I'm happy to do some basic scratch building if required. Any help would be much appreciated.
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 4 года назад
A quick bit of research shows the HMS Mauritius was one of the Colony Class light cruisers. Not a lot of kits of that type are available. Best I could find was a small 1:700 resin kit of the Jamaica, which is very similar. www.scalemates.com/kits/larsenal-700-17-hms-jamaica--1004832 That may be both hard to find and a challenging kit to build. For a similar looking ship, but of the Town Class light cruisers, is the HMS Kent. Trumpeter do a very nice kit of it which could be fettled to look a bit like your Mauritius with some scratch and patience. www.scalemates.com/kits/trumpeter-05334-hms-belfast-1942--209582
@stallebrass
@stallebrass 4 года назад
Harry Houdini Models You legend, thanks mate. I’ll check them out.
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 4 года назад
The Trumpeter Belfast is the better kit, well moulded and will fit nicely, but has a number of accuracy issues. However if you are modifying it anyway this won’t matter. Prices vary for the kit. Retail here can be up to 15 shekels, but Amazon had it for only 10 shekels, with free delivery. So it pays to shop around.
@davidedippolito2700
@davidedippolito2700 3 года назад
Ahahah nice video, you're funny, by the way the correct pronunciation of Fiume is feeumeh
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 3 года назад
Good to know!
@franktozier3184
@franktozier3184 4 года назад
The Fiume kit looks better even though you'll spend a lot time on the PE
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 4 года назад
Oh they are just more parts, metal not plastic, it’s all good.
@philipratcliffe1408
@philipratcliffe1408 4 года назад
The lower hull was green, and you say her name as fe you me 👍👍
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 4 года назад
Fe Fi Fum Fe-you-me! Got it. Thanks. And yes I agree, the green lower hull would be the correct colour.
@joecalobeer6396
@joecalobeer6396 4 года назад
Oh my goodness! You worked in gorgonzola for the waffles👍🏼 Now add bacon and ice cream! Oh Mylanta!
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 4 года назад
Should I start a cooking channel?
@joecalobeer6396
@joecalobeer6396 4 года назад
Harry Houdini Models Uh, yeah! But only if it includes waffles!
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 4 года назад
Waffles are my super power!
@keithsmodelsandrcs6593
@keithsmodelsandrcs6593 4 года назад
Cool fiat i like it
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 4 года назад
Trouble is it doesn’t float very well....
@LuluTwoEleven
@LuluTwoEleven 3 года назад
Fiume!
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 3 года назад
Thank you
@hadynthomas6197
@hadynthomas6197 4 года назад
Dear Harry, you pronounce Fiume:-- Fee-you-may. I just googled it, all the best, Mr"T".(UK)
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 4 года назад
Thanks... did not know you can Google pronunciations... better learn the Gorizia one before I get strung up with spaghetti by the Mafisto.
@anlannut
@anlannut 4 года назад
Does the Pola have a crane to recover plane
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 4 года назад
The actual ship Pola does have one on the starboard side of Turret A on the deck at the bow. However the Hobby Boss kit does not supply this part. It would be an easy scratch job made from some thin tube sprue and rigging line.
@Deathbyreality1
@Deathbyreality1 4 года назад
After watching this video I think maybe I should finally finish my 1/700 scale Bismarck that is 90% complete only missing railings, life boats, float planes, and two 1/700 swastikas. I gave up on completing the kit because of those bloody swastikas and I cant justify spending even more energy than I already had spent trying to come up with a way to stencil or paint 1/700 scale swastikas.
@Deathbyreality1
@Deathbyreality1 4 года назад
I've been working on it for 5 years and 2 of those year were me looking at it with disgust.
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 4 года назад
1/700 can be tricky... I have only ever built a Japanese destroyer at that scale with photo etch railings... and it got eaten by a Kraken.
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 4 года назад
You should be able to source some swastikas the size you need as decals. I know you can sheets of them in various sizes. The red flag with white circle centre at the bow and stern should not be too hard to mask. Then add your aftermarket decal.
@chikabungiekirkhoff8669
@chikabungiekirkhoff8669 3 года назад
Awesome model kit subject, too bad it has to come from china.....sigh!
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 3 года назад
It is a lovely kit.. Trumpeter have come a long way in their ship kit quality.
@nakitaluckysibih5581
@nakitaluckysibih5581 4 года назад
Is it difficult to build the Fiume?
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 4 года назад
I have only dry fit a few parts so far, they were perfect, so looks like another great Trumpeter kit. I have built other Trumpeter ships and always found them a pleasure to make. The photo etch can be daunting, but it really is not that hard. For me, it’s an easy build. For you, it all depends on your experience and skill.
@nakitaluckysibih5581
@nakitaluckysibih5581 4 года назад
@@HarryHoudiniModels okay. Thanks Harry!
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 4 года назад
Just plan ahead with the painting, especially if you decide do do the red stripes on the foredeck or even the camouflage pattern for the hull and superstructure. As with all ships, it’s best to paint parts before assembly, or as sub assemblies, then put it all together and just touch up any joins afterwards.
@aaronjoustra4729
@aaronjoustra4729 4 года назад
Lovely fumes.
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 4 года назад
and not too smelly either!
@TiberiusMaximus
@TiberiusMaximus 3 года назад
yea I just built the Pola, it was damn awful.
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 3 года назад
You get what you pay for... but it can be improved with aftermarket
@nichenson7987
@nichenson7987 4 года назад
You have to pronounce it with your hands, too.
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 4 года назад
Ah ha! So that is where I was going wrong?
@ДмитрийШультимов
@ДмитрийШультимов 3 года назад
Ваша борода похожа на бороду Санта-Клауса
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 3 года назад
No presents for you this year!
@ДмитрийШультимов
@ДмитрийШультимов 3 года назад
@@HarryHoudiniModels Why?( I has been a good boy(
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 3 года назад
Ha ha ha... ok more kits for you!
@ДмитрийШультимов
@ДмитрийШультимов 3 года назад
@@HarryHoudiniModels Thanks, i very hope to this
@411maintainer
@411maintainer 3 года назад
THE WARSHIP PLANS LINK DOES NOT WORK
@HarryHoudiniModels
@HarryHoudiniModels 3 года назад
You are right... I think they changed it. Try: profilemorskie.com/350.htm#hc
@411maintainer
@411maintainer 3 года назад
@@HarryHoudiniModels that works....thanks
Далее
1/350 RN ZARA [Trumpeter] - Part 1/3
16:36
Просмотров 12 тыс.
Building the Hobby Boss Seydlitz in 1/350 scale
12:06
Building the Trumpeter 1/350  Italian Heavy Cruiser Zara
34:25
Wooden Decks video
10:31
Просмотров 47 тыс.