TWICE JIHYO, reporting | Seipja teaser 

Hey, you Tzuyu fans who caused the trauma are back again. Be aware, Tzuyu fans.

i personally think that if that was the first thing that came to your mind there is something wrong with you, but besides that, yall are the ones resurfacing a traumatic event from 8 years ago because of a video thumbnail . a video which i'm guessing none of you even watched

⁠​⁠@@starvy1304 I bet you didn’t know what happened back then, JYP forced Tzuyu to apologize for waving our country’s flag. Who caused the trauma ? Are you a supporter of CCP?

@@jamesbond-sg3tm​​⁠​⁠​⁠​⁠ what meme～～ Is there any keyword？ I will search but I still think it’s not coincidence. Same hairstyle,similar wearing similar lines,background ..even the paper 📄 I love to know What kind of meme is it?

@@starvy1304​​⁠​​⁠as a Taiwanese, Tzuyu can't even comeback to her hometown as the identity of TWICE member. She needs to avoid telling everyone her nationality, and even the word "Taiwan" is prohibited because of the political issue between Taiwan and China. If tzuyu herself is putting effort to avoid the tragedy, why even should jihyo bring up all of those bad memories?

是啊台灣人死忠粉真的有夠多…結果呢JYP完全沒有給台灣一個好臉色呢…..要跪著賺錢就永遠別想爬著站起來

真的很諷刺，台灣真的是最挺TWICE,一直沒來台灣開唱，台灣粉還是最挺的，ㄧ般人早就轉粉了

Tzuyu fans are crazy

韓國公司就是看準你們台灣人死忠得要死想必也不會有什麼抵制的行為才敢這樣玩啊。 說白了就是看不起你們台灣。

先看清楚，這頻道是網路自媒體，點進去看看這是有很多知名藝人參加過的節目，劇本分鏡細節等等是由節目組企劃的，影片更改主動權是優先在節目組身上，光跟藝人和經紀公司喊話然後沒主動找節目組施壓他們很容易避開責任不理會的，優先究責媒體本身才是真的有影響力

옛날 트와이스 쯔위 대만국기 사과영상 의상이랑 배경이 이번에 새로 지효가 찍은 사진이랑 유사하다고 논란이라네요... 한국인은 하얀뒷배경 검은정장입고 제목 죄송합니다... 하면 사과영상 올리는게 국룰인데 그걸 이해 못하나봐요

처음에는 옛날 쯔위 동영상을 연상시킬수있는 장면을 쯔위 동료에게 시키는 게 극히 경솔하다고 대만팬들이 소속사와 제작진에게 엄청 킹받았는데 시간이 지날수록 쯔위개인팬과 지효개인팬 싸움이 된거같네요.

Delusional "fans" think she can't act serious for a variety show anymore because of Tz's unrelated incident 9 years ago

왜 지들끼리 싸움? 지나잘챙기지

憑什麼叫我們停止留言啊😂

這麼寬容大肚就不要去罵喝星巴克的藝人🤭

真的，尤其是在推特🙂

還能發現那些不支持這次節目行為的讚數破百的英文跟日文評論被刪掉了呢，真心失望。

志效身為隊長竟然還拍這種影片，都沒察覺到任何不妥嗎？ 明明團體合約還沒到期，完全沒在尊重台灣隊員欸，很想知道子瑜看到的當下是怎麼想的 這影片真的是來羞辱台灣人的

@@ChenZhiHua98_2.0 是專程來來羞辱台灣人的

笑死人，那麼多年前子瑜的影片都不下架了，你講道歉？你覺得可能嗎？？ 韓國對台灣市場很無所謂啦！擺明沒把台灣市場放眼裡，要也只會對中國大陸低頭道歉（表面道歉 但用公關手法讓中國人被罵的那種）

台灣人玻璃心😂

@@coolkiss7764好了啦 知道你最堅強了😢

誰規定的？ 就是沒考慮 懂？

​@@coolkiss7764 你閉嘴

​@@coolkiss7764你閉嘴

​@@coolkiss7764那活該被嘴爆

지효아, 어떤 상황에서도 난 항상 너와 함께 할 거야. 난 네가 이 세상에서 가장 좋은 사람이기 때문에 널 많이 존경하고 사랑해. 내 인생에 영감이 되어줘서 고마워 ♡

@@kyouhrumei people think JYPE is making this apology video (deleted) looks almost the same to Tzuyu's apology video(for her national identy). And this is considered as mocking

@@kyouhrumei Nah, if you watch the comparison clip you won't talk like this and giving such horrible example. It's not only about a black T-shirt

​@kyouhrumei 也許你的腦被取消了

@@kyouhrumei If you don't understand Taiwan's history, I suggest you seek understanding rather than making useless remarks.

한국은 원래 사과할때 검은 옷,벽 배경으로 사과하는데 그걸 뭐라고 하면 너는 인종차별 주의자야

開玩笑完全沒限度，這事對台灣人和周子瑜有多麼嚴肅，竟然當個區區小綜藝的宣傳梗

@@AtZch-qx9zk 是啊，這幾年來子瑜一直被不公平對待，我都忍了，但這次真的讓我氣到想出十台卡車包圍公司

You know what? The previous video did not include any fake apology scene. In the scene jihyo was talking "i will sue somebody. because i cant stand anymore ~ blah blah " this is totally fool witch hunt

찾아보니까 화날만 했노

한국은 원래 사과할때 검은 옷,벽 배경으로 사과하는데 그걸 뭐라고 하면 너는 인종차별 주의자야

Been fan since 2016. Been there when it happens and i dont see any wrong with this vid , it is not even so close to Tzuyu's... You are just creating non -existing problem... If you are a real ONCE you will not say this specially it involves 2 very close member. STOP IT FAKE FAN!

@@oncejamcertified 閉嘴

This has nothing to do with Tzuyu, why would they intentionally imitate that, that was years ago? Please use your common sense and stop being delulu 💖

​@@oncejamcertifiedthe opening jihyo say: I have something to tell you. it's as same as tzuyu apology video she said in chinese:我有話想對大家說

@@user-vg3hw6qp8upeople can say “I have something to tell you” anymore. Tzuyu does not give a fuck anymore. She’s not crying over this like y’all are.

Why are you causing problems between members. There’s nothing wrong with the video. You think twice would mock something like this especially Jihyo and remember she’s the one that formed the circle to protect Tzuyu when she was getting death threats at the time of this. There’s nothing wrong here. It’s y’all that are creating the issue. It’s not even close to mocking Tzuyu at all and I can assure you that Tzuyu does not see it that way nor does she care. Y’all are just sensitive

@@Aespa_pinks你怎麼能保證子瑜沒有這樣認為？？太過分了吧 樣子開頭以及拿著A4紙張 確定是巧合？

@@Aespa_pinks 你可能不懂這件事情對台灣人民來說傷害有多大，我們並非試圖造成成員之間的爭執，而是希望做出這樣節目的製作人能夠尊重台灣人民。

@@Aespa_pinks LOL,Is it me who caused the problem? HahhhHahhh u r funny. 🥴When someone feels uncomfortable, the joke should not happen because sensitivity is not determined by others. Although there's a saying, 'a thousand Hamlets in a thousand people's eyes,' but this time many share the same feelings as me, indicating controversy around this 'joke'. Now, let's talk about the issues with the video,We can compare both videos. From background settings, camera angles, to outfits, hairstyles, items held, bowing actions, and standing posture, they are essentially the same. There may already be comparison images online, or you can watch and compare yourself. I believe the company essentially wanted to use this type of 'meme' or 'joke' for marketing, but it failed this time. As for the artists themselves, whether as team members or idols, they should be sensitive to many issues and actions. When they choose to execute such a marketing plan, they must bear the potential negative comments or backlash. 顆顆你真有趣，問題是由我製造的嗎？當有人感到不舒服時，這個玩笑就應該停止，因為敏感度是由個人感覺和決定的。 雖然有句話說一千個人眼中有一千個哈姆雷特，但是從評論區來看，有很多人和我有相同的感受，這顯示這個「玩笑」確實存在爭議性。 接下來，我們可以討論影片本身的問題。許多人認為是子瑜的粉絲過度敏感，但我們可以比較一下兩個影片，從背景設置、攝影角度，到服裝、髮型、手上拿的物品、鞠躬的動作、站姿基本上都一樣。網上可能已經有對比圖，或者你也可以自己觀看比對。我認為公司基本上是希望利用這類型的「梗」或「玩笑」來行銷，只是這次失敗了。 就藝人本身而言，我認為無論是作為團隊成員還是偶像，他們應該對許多議題和操作有敏感度。當他們選擇執行這樣的行銷計畫時，就必須承擔可能引起的負面評論或反噬。

搞不好又是子瑜要道歉

經紀公司沒有嚴謹審核有錯，但這個是“網路自媒體”頻道，分鏡腳本等等主要是由節目組企劃，建議要把責任優先順序搞對，不然很難糾正錯誤，要先究責節目製作組，不然光找經紀公司沒用，這不是jype的媒體頻道，節目主動權優先順序要找對，找錯對象權利不夠也改不動。

​@@yummy7200 順序也很重要沒錯，但這整件事基本上三方都有問題 ootb端出這種企劃，JYPE讓這種東西審核過，志效同意拍這種影片

i personally think that if that was the first thing that came to your mind there is something wrong with you, but besides that, yall are the ones resurfacing a traumatic event from 8 years ago because of a video thumbnail . a video which i'm guessing none of you even watched

先說我痛恨這種蹭傷口的行銷方式 不過我暫時先不上車 幾個想法如下 1.這個節目是網路綜藝 就是大家常罵的網紅製作節目 網路節目 通常製作不如電視台節目嚴謹 因為工作人員數量就差很多 所以也相對容易出事 2.現在TWICE是老團 團員自由度比較大 想做什麼 公司基於信任 管的沒以前多 是有可能在未經公司端 足夠的審閱下 覺得節目性質沒問題 成員想錄節目就去錄了 3.其實以上兩點 都有解釋空間 我反而比較不解的是 志效在拍這種片頭時 沒想過哪裡怪怪的嗎 她是沒想到 還是缺乏共感 沒放心上? 難道她沒當年沒記憶沒經歷過 或沒敏銳度嗎? 不太對勁吧 當時TWICE全員是已經飛到了中國 節目還錄一半 突然被中國電視台封殺不能播 毫無收穫的返回韓國 如果說沒記憶 我是不能接受 不像是常被公司員工封為 TWICE中最有社會化sense的成員 所會犯的錯誤 所以這個預告企劃 到底誰在做主? 是公司授意蹭傷口? 還是網紅媒體自己玩火? 志效是自己決定還是聽別人的? 不管是節目組 或公司 還是志效本人同意 這樣玩不就代表私下決定跟子瑜翻臉了? 單就這點 我反而是最不解的

Bacot bgt fannya tzuyu mungkin gara² ga di kasih projek idolnya

洗了好幾篇 論點竟然只是怪罪子瑜瞎粉作亂 完全狀況外 這已經不是粉絲問題 而是失去對一個人的尊重 刻意對舊傷口撒鹽 換做南韓成員模仿這影片跟北韓道歉 或是換作日本成員跟南韓道歉 請問那些制帳外國人也會護航嗎? 還不是欺負台灣人小聲 根本搞錯重點

因為他們是外國人😀

😂😂😂😂

Don't be ridiculous, this has nothing to do with your fav

路人看熱鬧😂

檢舉更有用 請踴躍檢舉 尤其是事後的鴕鳥心態 配合公司運作 道歉文也刪 韓國搜尋也搜不到 只想裝死壓下去

저는 한국인입니다. 한국에서는 주로 사과를 할 때 검은 옷과 흰 배경으로 하고, 그리고 정치적인 이슈와 연관되지 않은 트렌딩(trending)이 되었습니다. 그러나 그 대상이 같은 소속사의 같은 그룹의 멤버라는 것은 정말 경솔하고 잘못된 부분입니다. 대만 분들 뿐만 아니라 한국의 팬들도 충분하게 잘못됨을 알고 있습니다. 쯔위와 대만을 주제로 한 건 아니지만, 사람들이 그 모습을 떠올릴 수 있다면 절대 하면 안되죠.

​@GGAMSUNG-vv4fl Thank you for your explanation (for how black cloth with white background is a standard combination of apology video in Korea). I get to understand how this kind of (fuxked up) thing happened in the first place. I guess Jihyo really doesn't see the gravity of that incident to be able to being aware of the insane resemblance of maknae's video... It's just really disheartening. Anyway, thanks again for ur explanation

@@letgourself Yes, I agree. I'm a little disappointed in the scriptwriter or Jihyo for making this up because it's a rude gesture, but I hope it never happens again.

이건단지 유행을 따라하는 것임 그이하 그이상도 아닌 문화차이임 더군다나 대만 프로그램도아니고 한국 프로그램임

@@user-md2jv6sd9i 한국 사람들만 보는 게 아니고, 더군다나 트와이스는 해외 팬 비중이 높음. 대놓고 같은 그룹이 중국한테 대국민 사과를 했는데 아무리 유행이라도 조심 했어야 하는 게 맞지. 무분별하게 욕하는 건 나도 반대지만 100퍼 경솔한 행동이었음. 아니었으면 왜 잘라냈을까요?

다시 편집했어요 그래서 없어진거죠

Who cares.

Ridiculi

噁心隊長志效良心被狗啃？沒有子瑜道歉今天twice還會紅？在人家傷口灑鹽就算還在地板上踩

所有爱子瑜的人都在乎，所有有正常的同理心的人都在乎

번역 : 왜 쯔위사건을 밈으로 삼을까요? 이 사건은 많은 사람에게 상처를 주었습니다. 하나도 재밌지 않아요.

因为自动翻译不太准确，所以翻译了一下 作为韩国人我也这么觉得。。 她也太过分了吧😢

​​@@uuuooo4624Thank you for your translation.🙏 I hope JYPE and the production team will be more cautious.😢

哈哈哈哈 funny

대만사람이에요

중국인이 유튭 못 봐요

真的，這墊底咖最會的就是談戀愛嗎，不紅才敢談得坦蕩蕩

大家冷靜一點...志效知情絕對不會拍這個影片的！！！應該是被告知拍攝的形式當下也沒想那麼多才拍的！

tzuyu has absolutely nothing to do with this video, she wasn't nominated or even Taiwan was mentioned. They used this fake apologize just to make people laugh. You were the ones who let out a non-existent problem. Accusing Jihyo of things she didn't do and will never do, especially as TWICE's leader. STOP.

대만어가 아니라 한국어로 댓글 적으면 더욱 JYP한테 강조가될겁니다

@@bealol0209I’m quite surprised that there’s still people supporting Jihyo. Tzuyu’s poor girl

쯔위 사과영상 패러디가 아닌데. 그걸 따라할 이유도 없고. 원래 사과영상들이 다 이렇게 함. 다만 연상될 수 있으니 조심은 할 수 있겠지.

I understand the annoyance of the taiwanese public/fans. It is a great act of unconsciousness to use this as "humor" when it has been real and had repercussions on the identity of not just the idol, but the taiwanese people. It is okay to demand delete the teaser, but it is not okay create almost a hate campaign against someone whose intention has been far from hurting her colleague, her friend. Call for conscience, stop re-victimizing and attacking others.

No. It's common when koreans when release new projects. Your comment is unnecessary

智孝不是模仿任何人停止编造的东西在你的脑海智孝爱子瑜

當時事情這麼大，難道不該有點敏感度嗎？😢 這開頭太像了

@@user-ef2it6vq3ewell that’s on you. It’s not, y’all just love to create problems among the members for no reason at all

志效被這爛公司害到變砲口😢

當時的事，就是錯誤行為讓公司團、員少賺錢！

希望子瑜和喜欢子瑜的人不要太受伤吧 别的真的无所谓 虽然肯定大家都很难受

tzuyu has absolutely nothing to do with this video, she wasn't nominated or even Taiwan was mentioned. They used this fake apologize just to make people laugh. You were the ones who let out a non-existent problem. Accusing Jihyo of things she didn't do and will never do, especially as TWICE's leader. STOP.

@@bealol0209 how ridiculous. the fact is the fake apology made a lot of people so mad.

能不能别扯China，又要怪，又拿来假虎威

oii 💕 é pra ler?

TWICE MEANS 0. 0 TALENT, 0 STREAMS, 0 SALES

Once (1) and twice (8) = 9

It's already deleted..

Go spread hate on someone else

@@hawaadk2786 蛤 所以我以後只要拍了得罪別人的影片再默默刪掉就可以了嗎？^_^ 不是都說沒有要跟你輕輕放下了嗎

@@everywan_j they also apologised 😆😄😁☺️😊

我不覺得我需要停止 臺灣人沒必要受到這種奇恥大辱😃👎

心碎滿地不只這個 Sana 身為日本人，發個文告別平成，都可以被網爆不懂歷史😅

沒耶，有很嚴重嗎？

@@coolkiss7764影響到台灣選舉不嚴重嗎？甚至對面央視還為了這件事澄清，不嚴重嗎？國際譴責一個公司把未成年少女推到風口浪，不嚴重嗎？

​@@coolkiss7764覺得不嚴重，我看你那時還只是一隻小蝌蚪在游泳而已吧（？

透過這個影片才知道 原來對韓國人來說 這件事只是一個meme… 甚至不是隨便一個路人 是子瑜的團員和經紀公司

講錯話，害大家少了中國大餅，本來就該深刻反省

I may be a troll but I'm a pretty troll😘

얘도 한국인은 아닌거같은데

BOO 👎DELULU 😪BOO 👎DELULU 😪BOO 👎DELULU 😪

This has nothing to do with Tzuyu, why would they intentionally imitate that, that was years ago? Please use your common sense and stop being delulu 💖

Stop being disrespectful towards jihyo work The world doesn't revolve around tzuyu

@@hyoji9723 twice leader has twice love relationships I’m so jealous😇😇😇

BOO

這影片對台灣的傷害非常大，我是臺灣人，我真的非常難過韓國節目羞辱我的國家

洗的非常賣力還用不同語言，一看就很假

fake comments

BOO 👎DELULU 😪BOO 👎DELULU 😪BOO 👎DELULU 😪BOO 👎DELULU 😪BOO 👎DELULU 😪

This has nothing to do with Tzuyu, why would they intentionally imitate that, that was years ago? Please use your common sense and stop being delulu 💖

Drama

我笑出來了啊😂

不必再責備成員，攻擊成員只會讓子瑜處境更艱難 該攻擊的是JYPE公司，公司對於此的敏感度完全沒有提升，他們需要輿論壓力來做出改變

这不是关于子瑜，现在他们删除了场景 删除你的评论，智孝没有做错什么

​​@@zyo97 除非得到jyp的道歉不然我不會刪 這不是刪掉就能輕飄飄的放下的事情吧 製作組可以息事寧人，但我也可以不接受 不管我算老幾都有發表看法的權利

@@zyo97 那子瑜當時有做錯什麼要穿著黑衣站在那裡道歉？！你有幫她講話嗎？！

She doesn't have any reason to be sad and you don't have any reason to be commenting this under Jihyo's solo activity. This isn't your storybook don't act like you can make shit up

@@orangejuice775 1. Jihyo has never had this kind of hairstyle before, let alone recently. 2. The background, the hairstyle, the black suit, the written paper, and most obviously the first sentence “I have something to tell you all” all resembles to Tzuyu’s apology video. This is not a coincidence, rather a sick joke.

@@daviddd0928 JIHYO HAS HAD A PONY TAIL MULTIPLE TIMES BEFORE BAHAHAHA no one has a copyright over a black shirt or white background be serious lmao. if you look at that thumbnail & see it as anything other than what it actually is then YOU are the problem. and if you think for one millisecond that it was done with malicious intent then i honestly feel sorry for you bc it must be awful to be that sad & miserable

Tz akgaes apparently feeling left out of the mass hysteria going on in kpop right now so decided to create their own conspiracies

yes she is sad seeing what you are doing to her leader

This has nothing to do with Tzuyu, why would they intentionally imitate that? Please use your common sense and stop being delulu 💖

⁠@@hyoji9723 Anyone who has seen Tzuyu's apology video knows it's an imitation. Please use your eyes instead of treating it as decoration😊

@@mys_Francisca Non-sense topic, that was years ago! Why would they even imitate that? like srsly

⁠@@hyoji9723 The show's team made a lowbrow joke to generate buzz, and I don't think it's something that should be easily overlooked

​@@hyoji9723I see you in every comment below. You tell people to use their common sense, but why don't use yours to understand why so many feel and comment the same? You can't ignore the fact that many people feel the same way that is different than yours. You need to learn how to respect others opinions and feelings.

nah

@@Camila-en9veshut up and get out

Yes….even the hairstyle is similar….very disappointed with Jihyo , thought she was a sensitive and caring leader…