ALL CREDITS TO THEIR RIGHTFUL OWNERS UPLOADS EVERY TUESDAY (pacific time zone) ((sorry for the video delay)) Next Video: Dreamcatcher Vocal Ranking 2019 (WITH REASONING)
1. Mina 2.Chaeyoung 3.Tzuyu (like JYP said is the member that improve the most and her vocals are good and she's stable ) SORRY IF I WROTE SO MUCH ABOUT TZUYU IT'S BECAUSE SHE'S MY BIAS AND THINK SHE'S A GOOD VOCALIST :'D
not to be bias 1. Mina- i like her tone the most compared to others even out of all twice members. I love how angelic her voice is and her voice color is pleasing to my ears. But i had to agree that she still needs to train her vocals because her voice is sometimes so low that you cant totally hear her. But im gonna give it to her for being a naturally vocalist considering she only trained for a year in jyp and had to debut early in twice. And i think i can tell thats one of the reason why she need a little training. 2. Chaeyoung- eventhough shes a rapper her vocals is pretty awesome too. Even better compared to other vocalist members. 3. Tzuyu- i love how much she improved compared in sixteen. Inspite of that her vocals for me is too bland. She sounded too plain to me when singing. Theres nothing exciting on her voice and nothing to looks forward. Well i guess her vocal color is too bland for me and not my taste.
1. Mina = Chaeyoung Mina has a beautiful tone, and Chaeyoung has a better technique, but both of them are pretty good vocalists considering Mina never got the proper training and Chaeyoung ended up training more as a rapper 2. Tzuyu Tzuyu has been steadily improving since debut, but Chae and Mina are still ahead of her considering their tone and projection.
Let's be honest chaeyoung technic it's not that good,that's why she always sing with falsetto,while the real note was belt. I prefer mina but I respect ur opinion😍
Imo 1: Mina (I don't know why everyone has been trying to come after Mina for both her vocals and dancing like shush. Mina is a great vocalist and an amazing dancer) 2: Chaeyoung (Chaeyoung is very talented. She can sing, rap, dance, write lyrics, and more. However I just don't rethink she's a as good as Mina is due to her sounding out of tune at times.) 3: Tzuyu (Just because she's last doesn't mean she's bad. She's a good vocalist and is improving each and every day. Tzuyu really snapped from debut to now.)
1. Chaeyoung 2. Mina 3. Tzuyu No, im not being biased. Mina has a very fragile voice, as she sounds very shaky and unconfident. Chaeyoung is slightly above average, and Tzuyu's voice tends to crack and sounds a little unstable. They all have room to improve!
in my opinion 1) Mina 1) Chaeyoung 1) Tzuyu We cant really rank these three yet or tell how well they can sing yet jyp hasnt let ANY of the 9 girls except jihyo and nayeon to use their real voices, resulting in false judgement as seen in vlive snippets, or the odd occasion of a song these three girls have a very wide vocal range. Mina can hit whistle notes, as well as sing very low. She lacks confidence, and likes to play it safe by singing in falsetto most of the time, but fun fact she can actually hit those notes in her full voice if she really tried hard enough. Her voice is ofc perfect for ballads and slow jams, as her tambre is very soft and elegant. Unlike most in the group, minas voice is very smooth and is rarely unstable or heard straining. She has great breath control. Mina also has the ability to do vocal runs very well. Chaeyoung isnt given enough singing parts, but when she is its sO obvious that shes an EXTREMELY talented singer. I havent heard her belt a note before, but i know that her falsettos can go higher than mount everest. She has a beautiful low range as well, which makes her a very versatile performer. Its a sHAME that she never gets to sing as much as rap. She also lacks the confidence even though her voice is amazing. Tzuyu is a tough one to crack. During Twices early years, tzuyus voice was kinda unstable and went off key a lot. But as time has went on, her voice has just kept improving to the point where her voice has almost exceeded most of those in the group. Although she never gets to show it, Tzuyus voice can go VERYYYYY low. Like, OCEANs deep. Most of her lines thus far have never efficiently showcased her natural low ranged voice, and usually makes her strain. As much as she can go deep, her voice can also falsetto very high like chaeyoungs (as heard in strawberry). Alike chaeyoung, i have never heard her belt notes before, so i cannot say how her voice full voice sounds. If you have time, please check out SaDaTzu's cover of beyonces Dance for you - in this cover tzuyu goes like sOOO deep.
Personally it’s Chae=Mina>Tzuyu. But potential wise it’s completely the opposite order. Tzuyu’s younger and is improving faster than anyone in Twice but she’s quite pitchy and at this current stage she’s definitely 3rd to me, but give it a couple years and I think she’ll be able to get 2nd. Chae and Mina are at the same stage. I think Chae’s not improving much recently as she’s sort of the rapper but with what she’s got, she’s great. She’s got my favourite tone, and she sounds better to me in low, mid and higher ranges. So she’s my personal favourite but recently she’s seemed worse than she was before, so Mina is catching up. Mina sounds amazing in some songs but in others her voice can grate, if she worked on her projection and nasality is say she might be better. At this stage/from past videos, Chaeyoung sounds the least pitchy, she’s the strongest and imo sounds the best in multiple ranges. She doesn’t really get to the range she sounds grating, she just doesn’t sing in it lol, so I’ve yet to actually find her voice uncomfortable. They’re all pretty close, but MiChaeng are definitely in the lead, Tzuyu will likely catch up
@@alpacarosait are you just going to reply most of these comment trying to bring down one of the twice members? You can have your own opinion but plain out hating on a member for your own biased opinion is stupid
3. tzuyu has the most potential among the three but i personally find her range average and her tone and projection a little bland, she is also unstable at times. however she has been improving most lately as mina only gets trained as a dancer and chaeyoung a rapper. 2. mina she has a pleasing tone and a calming voice but her projection is not the best and she doesn't stand out that much because she didn't receive much training. 1. chaeyoung she has a pretty good technique and lower range, and sings as well as she raps. mina's tone is more pleasing than hers, but i think she supports her voice better. sadly, she has not been improving much lately as she is their main rapper and doesn't currently train as a vocalist. mina and chaeng are at a similar level but i personally prefer chae's voice :-)
I'm a vocalist myself(6+ years of experience)and I grasp music really easily, I'm great at identifying vocal ranges, techniques, and voices. Chaeyoung is the best here, because she uses the proper technique whereas Mina uses an airy technique. Chaeyoung is technically better.
@@chaeyoungslovie I'm a vocalist for 10+ years and I think mina has better support, higher and lower range, pitch, falsetto and riffs/runs. I'm not sure about the middle range and I think they're pretty much the same there. Besides chae is nasal. Mina is too but not as much as chae. Chae sounds real good though. I need a michaeng duet.
@@theresadavis2004 if your talking about lows then Chae is definitely way better also Chaeyoung is less nasal and airy than Mina. Her larynx positions are also more relaxed. Chaeyoung has better sense of dynamics and projection than Mina. Lows- Chaeyoung>Mina Mix- Mina=Chaeyoung Falsetto- Mina>=Chaeyoung Agility- Equal Dynamics- Chae Pitch- Equal Vibrato- Equal
If Nayeon is promoted to a main vocal. One of these girls can be promoted to Lead vocals along with jeongyeon. The perfect fit is Chaeyoung. But only if she will be aware of it.
I personally like Chaeyoung's voice the best in the group(after Jeongyeon) but everyone has their own taste. But yea Chaeyoung has much better technique than MiTzu
I think Mina's voice sounds the best for me. But sometimes she just lack in confidence and I think she needs to be trained more for her vocal techniques but nevertheless her voice is beautiful. 1. Mina 2. Chaeyoung 3. Tzuyu
For me: 1. Chaeyoung She just sounds so good and i’m happy JYP is finally giving her singing lines so she can improve even more in the future. She’s also pretty young and has a lot of time to improve 2. Mina She does get more lines than the other 2 which is why i think it give the illusion of her being better than Chaeyoung. But she’s still very good though and had such a perfect and angelic voice. Its just very fragile and she hasn’t improved that much since debut compared to the 2 others 3. Tzuyu Definetly the mist improved member. She completely changed herself from debut to now and she sounds so good. She just tends to somehow be very weak in her singing sometimes and her voice is not good when it comes to showing emotion
For Me 1.Mina(Angelic Voice,Good For Ballad) 2.Chaeyoung(As Good As Mina She Ranked Lower Because She Doesn't Show Her True Talent 3.Tzuyu(She Improves A Lot But Still Need To Train More)
I Think Its Like This 1.Chaeyoung(4th Best Vocal In Twice many Onces are Saying the Same Thing) 2.Mina(5th Best Vocal in Twice Many Onces are saying the same thing) 3.Tzuyu(6th Best Vocal in Twice Many Onces saying the same Thing) Twice Vocal Ranking 1.Jihyo 2.Jeongyeon 3.Nayeon 4.Chaeyoung 5.Mina 6.Sana 7.Tzuyu 8.Dahyun 9.Momo
1. Chaeyoung 2. Mina 3. Tzuyu Chaeyoung id overall a very well rounded idol being able to rap dance and sing Tzuyu as an idol is very average Mina isn’t as good as chaeyoung but has improved a lot since debut and has good high and low notes
personally its Mina> Tzuyu= Chaeng (i dont really need to explain Mina) Tzuyu is very stable while singing, yes her voice is bland but she is still improving. While Chaeyoung isnt stable but she can sing higher while still sounding very good
My opinion 1 chaeyoung- she is the best technically and her tone ok and she is one of the most stable in twice 2 mina - her tone is very good , techique is nice and she is stable
Yes agreed. Technically speaking Chaeyoung is the best vocalist after the vocal line. Mina has a beautiful tone but as a singer myself I notice a lot of times that she sings really breathy. She's uses that half air half sound "technique" which is common amongst JYP idols. And Chaeyoung sounds so relaxed and comfortable singing at any range, meaning she has at least some sense of support.
@@Lailaatt Yep. And also because “she has an angelic voice” Angelic voice doesn’t = good technique. Chaeyoung is noticeably stronger and better than Mina
I agree it’s just that jyp never gives her the lead vocal worthy lines (she was suppose to be a lead vocal) to show her voice more and now she has anxiety so she lacks confidence.
1-Mina: La estabilidad de mina no es la mejor ya que su voz es bastante aguda, pero la autocontrol muy bien y ella ha logrado hacer notas altas sin ninguna dificultad.(mi opinion) 2_Chaeyoung : Controla muy bien su voz, pero poco ha cantado si nos referimos a vocal por lo que no se puede opinar mucho, pero la verdad tiene un gran talento y una perfecta estabilidad 3_Tzuyu: Al igual que mina no tiene una perfecta estabilidad ya que a diferencia de mina y chae ella tiene una voz más grave, que también es difícil de controlar si no eres experto pero lo logra muy bien(siendo sincera)
I know it’s not live, but Tzuyu’s in Fancy’s last chorus were too great. My ranking of all, the three members highlighted: 1. Jihyo 2. Jeongyeon/Nayeon 3. MINA 4. CHAEYOUNG 5. TZUYU/Sana 6. Dahyun/Momo
Mina doesn’t have that weak of a voice.. her performance of born really shows off her more powerful voice. I feel like if she had a little more confidence she’d be an amazing lead vocalist for twice.
Yes. Ppl say she's always singing in falsetto but it's really Mina whose singing in falsetto constantly. Chaeyoung has shown in "Touchdown" that she can belt really well, and she is great singing in her chest voice and mixed register.
For me it's ; 1. Mina (she is supposed to be a lead vocalist according to 2018 Twice members sources news , that JYP offers her that position along with main dancer... but she choose to be main dancer and denied lead vocalist) 2 . Chaeyoung / Tuzyu
Simran Sucharita i agree. Although i didnt know mina was offered to be a Lead Vocalist. Where can i find more information about that? I cant find anything. I would apreciate your help
@@Faeriiexx mina and nayeon using half air half voice thecnique ehich is really hard because of yg and if you watch sixteen mina is totally better than chaeyoung in vocals her voice is very good and her thecnique is very good for one year trainer
@@helinkaraduman4000 The half air half sound technique is actually unhealthy. Sixteen was also years ago. Mina was a better vocalist then because Chaeyoung mostly rapped. Chaeyoung surpassed Mina technique wise now
1.Mina's voice since the time of sixteen has been chic💓 2.She has wonderful vocals even though she is a rapper 💓 3.y you have a very deep voice that I really like 💓
in a technical sense i think that mina and chaeyoung are on the same level due to their different strong points, with tzuyu coming last. in a more personal sense i've always liked tzuyu's vocal color a lot, i'm not sure what it is about it but i like it.
Hi, i really wants you try to delet all commentaries sayin' bad of tzuyu,mina and chase, well, if it looks rude, I'm really sorry wasn't my intention:(, and i can't force you to do it, it's because this is so uncomfortable and infantile :/ (if you will try do do it,thank you
1. Mina The only one in twice, besides 3 mix who i've heard support, instantly making her the 4th best. Her approach to singing is very heady, making her sound light and not too strain-y even when straining (especially above B4), although her headiness has a price, her projection 2. Chaeyoung and tzuyu I can't really tell who's better between them. Chaeyoung's voice actually sounds very frail like mina's except with no support and she tends to resort to falsetto too much when going above B4/C5. For tzuyu, she sounds the most balanced out of them 3 but seems to be not supporting as well
@Sana Nasa fun fact: what i'm saying are facts. Mina is the best vocalist in twice after jihyo, nayeon and jungyeon, and what i've meant by "support" is vocal BREATH SUPPORT, not fan support dummy. Better go to school and improve your reading comprehension instead of being obsessed on hating tzuyu with unreasonable reasons *LMFAO*
1) Mina 2) Tzuyu 3) Chaeyoung Chaeyoung does better in slow songs (her melody project) but since she does not have parts in twice's slow songs she does not get to fully showcase her abilities as a vocalist
@Sana Nasa tzuyu is not BADDDD but mina and chae are simply alot better thats final, she is ranked 8th after momo, like even sana is better, i am not hating btw i love tzuyu alot but like being biased in these things pisses me off, even if she's someone's favorite that person cant say she's the best singer just because she is their bias, we looking at talent here and i think chaeyoung won this ofc
Ngl tzuyu sounds best in MR removed tho. I think shes more stable actually compared to the other 2 cuz i litearlly cannot hear mina in any mr removed. However Chaeyoug has the best technique but she is also kinda quiet. Mina is really good with higher notes but is also quiet.
My opinion: Chaeyoung-mina-tzuyu Chaeyoung already has a nice and sweet voice. Her technique in singing is mostly falsetto and quite unstable but I can see that if she was trained more in singing and guided, her singing will be more beautiful thus she's the number one for me in these Mina's voice is also sweet and fragile her voice is quite unstable for me when singing considering that she's being guided with her parts and as a vocalist more training and practicing and her singing will improve more As for tzuyu, her voice may be sweet but for me it wasn't good compare to the two(my opinion only tho I didn't mean to sound like bringing other member down i just don't have the right word to voice my opinion better) she is being guided and trained considering that she's a vocalist and thus improving her singing through the years We all have different preferences and I just voiced mine through the comment don't reply here if you have different opinions because I don't care about yours sorry to be mean this has been long I will end it here
@@wnurmaisarah2015 tzuyu isn't stable.... That's prerecorded, because chaeyoung and mina are so stable they don't even prerecord they just sing live and honestly idk what's more convincing, pls stop being biased chaeyoung is obviously better..
