Тёмный

Two Words Are Destroying India 

Indologia
Подписаться 4,3 тыс.
Просмотров 7 тыс.
50% 1

This video explores the increasingly common use of the term "South Asia" and its potential implications for Indian cultural identity. We delve into the origins of this terminology and analyze its effects on how the region's history and civilization are perceived.
Key topics covered:
Historical context of the Indian subcontinent's various names
The emergence and adoption of "South Asia" as a regional descriptor
Comparison with other regional labels used globally
Analysis of media and academic usage of the term
Potential long-term effects on cultural and historical narratives
Perspectives on geographical labels versus civilizational identity
The video presents a balanced examination of how language shapes our understanding of regions and cultures. It offers insights into the complex interplay between modern geopolitical terminology and ancient civilizational identity.
Suitable for those interested in Indian history, cultural studies, geopolitics, and the power of language in shaping perceptions.
Follow me:
Twitter: ⁠ / indologia⁠
Instagram: ⁠ / ⁠
RU-vid: ⁠ / @indologia
Whatsapp: whatsapp.com/c...
Telegram: t.me/indologia
#IndianSubcontinent #SouthAsiaTerminology #CulturalIdentity #GeopoliticalLabels #IndianHeritage #LanguageAndCulture #RegionalIdentity #HistoricalNarratives #CivilizationalStudies #MediaAnalysis

Опубликовано:

 

27 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 131   
@NativeVsColonial
@NativeVsColonial 4 дня назад
If the continent of India is “South Asia”, then Europe shoud be called North-West Asia.
@PawanKumar-bw3vr
@PawanKumar-bw3vr 4 дня назад
Far West
@srikrishna2561
@srikrishna2561 2 дня назад
Europe is a different Continent.
@NativeVsColonial
@NativeVsColonial 2 дня назад
@@srikrishna2561 So it’s not connected with Asia? What defines a continent according to you?
@Amit-ws4os
@Amit-ws4os 2 дня назад
​@srikrishna2561 Subcontinent of India literally floated from Africa to Asia. What makes you think Indian Subcontinent is Asia. The so-called Europe is connected to Asia far longer than Indian Subcontinent
@kamartaj3010
@kamartaj3010 День назад
@@NativeVsColonialtectonics plates define the continent
@amitpratap7551
@amitpratap7551 День назад
"South Asian" is a phrase used when you want to avoid using the word Pakistan.
@coremanishmehta
@coremanishmehta День назад
Couldn’t be more clear
@karolbagh3793
@karolbagh3793 День назад
100% Indian Muslim know they are Arabs, 100% Indian Hindu think Muslims are Indians. 😮😮😮
@scorpio9414
@scorpio9414 День назад
Underrated comment.
@UjwalRam
@UjwalRam День назад
It’s the other way round - Muslims think they are Arabs but we know they are converted either by sword , force or feeding hatred.
@WeAre-p3u
@WeAre-p3u День назад
Indian are converted . They can't name 5 generation.
@kingmanly-n9r
@kingmanly-n9r День назад
How insightful... Take a bow.
@karolbagh3793
@karolbagh3793 День назад
@@kingmanly-n9r 🙏🙏🙏
@Jk-ko6tc
@Jk-ko6tc День назад
The two words are: Government Job.
@AvionicsDev
@AvionicsDev 6 часов назад
This should be the TOP comment! 😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣
@karolbagh3793
@karolbagh3793 День назад
Garba is a secular festival, Because Muslim men wants to dance with Hindu Girls. But, Ramnavmi Yatra is communal
@ramnathnayak113
@ramnathnayak113 День назад
"Muslim men wants to dance with Hindu Girls..." Oh, c'mon!! Everyone knows why those criminals come and its not to dance.
@UjwalRam
@UjwalRam День назад
Pakistan is formed to make Bharath look bad and evil . Atleast Bharathiya should hold their culture, name close to their heart. And stand by our identity. 6:01 👍
@naamkoitamna8675
@naamkoitamna8675 3 часа назад
Eye opening video. We all should call Indian Subcontinent from now.
@karolbagh3793
@karolbagh3793 День назад
Islamic Expansion has no permanent friends or Enemies, no permanent name or face, no permanent democracy or dictatorship (🇧🇩🇵🇰) Only Expansion is permanent.
@ArtVandelay-av-av
@ArtVandelay-av-av 4 дня назад
words and terms have deep impact
@explorer8824
@explorer8824 2 дня назад
Very important point have come up by this video. 👏
@karolbagh3793
@karolbagh3793 День назад
Conversion is like a MLM - Multi Level Marketing scheme. First you get converted Then you convert others Then others convert others.
@ramnathnayak113
@ramnathnayak113 День назад
Its a Ponzi scheme.
@chiragbhamre
@chiragbhamre 2 дня назад
thank you for raising a critical point
@akbrahma7739
@akbrahma7739 3 часа назад
It's called low-esteem amongst the Indians who are wannabe white, and subtle acceptable racism that Anglo-speakers push. Ignore the commenters, you keep pushing, keep doing what you're doing. Infact go more hard.
@Kirti-i1h
@Kirti-i1h День назад
We people of Uttar Pradesh are different from rest of India and that's why I conclude that we are South Asians. That's it. 🤡
@saqibyounus2459
@saqibyounus2459 День назад
The indian ocean should also be called as Afro-Asian ocean.
@TejaDurgi
@TejaDurgi День назад
Great video i was thinking about the same from a while.
@sidharthcs2110
@sidharthcs2110 День назад
"Indian" and "Pakistani" themselves are not that representative of the populations of the respective countries if you think about it... Just look at the states and provinces of India and Pakistan.... There are people from the gangatic plains, people from the Himalayas, pashtoons, Bengalis, Tamils....etc.... Do you think they entertain the idea of classifying them as just Indian/ pakistani when they're in a foreign land ?
@k_now7632
@k_now7632 23 часа назад
Bro is after deepstate.💀
@saimaheshburra7987
@saimaheshburra7987 3 дня назад
Very informative video thanks for making for us
@RahulkumarMak
@RahulkumarMak 7 минут назад
Pretty sure it's termed by endians (elite Indians) themselves.
@sohan_89
@sohan_89 День назад
India is also a loose geographical name, tamil nadu, kerala etc are the actual places that consititute it.
@giridhar4837
@giridhar4837 3 дня назад
Love your content ❤
@PawanKumar-bw3vr
@PawanKumar-bw3vr 4 дня назад
Far west is the proper term I have started using
@ArtVandelay-av-av
@ArtVandelay-av-av 4 дня назад
so very well made
@सौरभYadavendra
@सौरभYadavendra День назад
#इंडिया
@karolbagh3793
@karolbagh3793 День назад
ANCIENT INDIA, also known as BHARATVARSHA, encompassed a vast territory that has been reduced over time due to various invasions, empires, and colonialism. Here's a rough estimate of the territory lost: 1. Pakistan and Bangladesh: These countries were part of ancient India but were separated during the 1947 partition. 2. Afghanistan: Ancient India extended into present-day Afghanistan, but it was lost to Islamic invasions and later became a separate entity. 3. Tibet: Tibet was an integral part of ancient India, but it was annexed by China in the 18th century. 4. Nepal and Bhutan: These Himalayan kingdoms were once part of ancient India but gained independence over time. 5. Myanmar (Burma): Ancient India's territory extended into present-day Myanmar, but it was lost to the Burmese empire. 6. Sri Lanka: Although not physically connected, Sri Lanka was culturally and politically part of ancient India. 7. Parts of Central Asia: Ancient India's influence extended into present-day Uzbekistan, Kazakhstan, and Xinjiang (China). The territory lost by ancient India is estimated to be around 20-25% of its original size. Here's a rough estimate of the original territory: - Ancient India: approximately 10 million square kilometers (3.9 million sq mi) - Present-day India: approximately 3.3 million square kilometers (1.3 million sq mi) Keep in mind that these estimates vary, and the concept of a fixed territory is complex in ancient times. Nonetheless, it's clear that ancient India's territory has been significantly reduced over the Centuries.
@lamedude8976
@lamedude8976 День назад
I can see the problem western media is propagated but the thing is that in literature they still call it indian subcontinent and on ground level south asian people like me still stay together its not make us lose our identity but instead it unites us brown people here so i dont think this thing it should be a major problem but still western media intentionally doesn't promote indian identity which should be a problem instead saying south asia is bad
@Sachin6197
@Sachin6197 День назад
i understand a certain apprehension to use south asia i have always been fond of using desi for all the countries of the subcontinent
@rajparab5051
@rajparab5051 2 дня назад
yes this is more important than fixing the road in front of my house
@bkb23plus
@bkb23plus 2 дня назад
See the larger picture bro
@sm8315
@sm8315 2 дня назад
@@bkb23pluslarger picture ? Gutter, drains, falling bridges ? Collapsing airports ? Scams and fraud ?
@aaaaaaaaryan
@aaaaaaaaryan 2 дня назад
exactly wth iis he yapping about...nonsense issue...correcting others instead of urself...classic indian mentalilty
@indrajitbanerjee9376
@indrajitbanerjee9376 2 дня назад
Your road can't be fixed by commenting on RU-vid ( and taking a stand against your own country on the internet). If you really want to fix the road, put pressure on the municipal body.
@jyothishkumar3098
@jyothishkumar3098 2 дня назад
Of course let's bury the weapons of our defense department because why are they fighting at the borders instead of fixing your roads? Clearly fixing the road is more important than defending territory. And we could also stop blaming Islam for the direct threats on innocent people in its sources which its followers spread, because it's just words and terrorism exists everywhere regardless. We could ignore everything to fix your road. Because national Identity is as much of a rich people problem as Taylor Swift concert tickets being too expensive.
@karolbagh3793
@karolbagh3793 День назад
Q: Which/Who's version of Islam is real Islam ? A: There is only one Islam, what Prophet Muhammad said and What he did during his lifetime. EVERY THING ELSE IS TO DECEIVE AND FOOL YOU.
@jyothishkumar3098
@jyothishkumar3098 День назад
@@karolbagh3793Semi-sentient NPC
@tivo3720
@tivo3720 День назад
Correct 💯.
@fl0ppyd15k
@fl0ppyd15k 3 дня назад
True!
@ProgressPost
@ProgressPost День назад
Kya hauwa uda rahe ho yaar?? Aise bahot aye aur chale gaye, Bharat/Hindustan/India chalte ja rahe hain, aur chalte rahenge. Jitna mujhe samajh hai, India partion ke baad Indian subcontinent ke naam se nahin jana jata hain. Hamara desh kanaam India hain aur baki ka duniya hame isi naam se pukarte hai. To kya bekar mein hawabazi kar rahe ho yaar?
@akkkkk813
@akkkkk813 День назад
U don't read news
@krupeshdesai
@krupeshdesai День назад
India is western name. Why you need it ? May be it should be Hindu Subcontinent?
@User-059-42
@User-059-42 День назад
What a load of crap. 😂😂😂
@UjwalRam
@UjwalRam День назад
You must be that South Asian
@direwolf7491
@direwolf7491 День назад
Brishit spotted
@poojalive14
@poojalive14 4 дня назад
🙏🏼
@lembubodoh
@lembubodoh День назад
It is Borat. It's the very nice
@Bengalinationalist
@Bengalinationalist 7 часов назад
India as a Country never existed before 47,bengaki nation since vedic era 🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩
@sidharthcs2110
@sidharthcs2110 День назад
You're just paranoid
@SP-qe2cr
@SP-qe2cr 3 дня назад
Except India, no other neighbour will accept the term 'indian subcontinent'...so better be south asia and not talk about it
@unedited159
@unedited159 2 дня назад
Who cares about neighbours accept or not
@jagatsimulation
@jagatsimulation 2 дня назад
Indian subcontinent is correct term. But converted PPL think they are arabs
@SP-qe2cr
@SP-qe2cr 2 дня назад
@@unedited159 the world cares, because your neighbours have your territory under their control...looserrrrs
@jyothishkumar3098
@jyothishkumar3098 2 дня назад
​@@unedited159some neighbours would call all countries their own, and occupied by others. We only care about the opinions of those who respect us, and God will be our protector.
@piku6006
@piku6006 День назад
Before you know it all the Pakistani territories will be known as south asian terrorist and this is how u shift blame from perpetrators to innocent people .
@SP-qe2cr
@SP-qe2cr 3 дня назад
This is not correct, calling it Indian sub continent will not be accepted by Indian neighbours and western countries will have to create two sepaarte names for them, so south asia is perfect name until India gets right or might over its neighbours.
@eucenor4171
@eucenor4171 3 дня назад
this is absolutely correct, you arent even focusing on the problem. its not an issue of whether we call the region south asia or indian subcontinent, its about how the tags are used to ruin image of individual countries by generalising them to the entire region. when crimes happen by pakistanis and south asian tag is used to describe the perpertrators, it doesnt just ruin india's image, it ruins nepal, bangladesh, bhutan and sri lanka's image. if they used indian subcontinent, then that wouldve ruined just india's name. anyways, problem is generalisation of crimes and specialisation of achievements, not the tags used.
@kingmanly-n9r
@kingmanly-n9r 2 дня назад
Keep it simple. Lets not use the term "South Asia" altogether. If an Indian does it, say it was an Indian, if a Pakistani does it say it was a Pakistani. Don't club us together. And if you want to club us together under a collective term, better call it the "Indian subcontinent", because, NEWS FLASH, there was India before the partition in 1947. Attempting to erase that memory, would be a crime against the ancient Indian civilization.
@SP-qe2cr
@SP-qe2cr 2 дня назад
@@eucenor4171 so why call asian ? chinese korean and japanese are different, why call some one european, europe has like fifty different cultures....you are not making sense
@SP-qe2cr
@SP-qe2cr 2 дня назад
@@kingmanly-n9r Foreigners dont care about how ancient your history is but how impactful you are at present stage...stop this snobbish behavior or elese your country will break into two more.
@alani3992
@alani3992 2 дня назад
Downfall of Indians is they keep referring to some nepotism of the past, but don't strive for personal improvement/introspection. Nobody cares about how ancient you are, but how un-civic your own behaviors are.
Далее
Why Yes = No in East Asia 🇯🇵🇰🇷🇨🇳
19:10
Brawl Stars expliquez ça
00:11
Просмотров 6 млн
Always Help the Needy
00:28
Просмотров 7 млн
Understanding Indian Civilization
26:33
Просмотров 387 тыс.
The REAL Story of Donald Trump
39:54
Просмотров 2,1 млн
Early Central Asia, a Quick History
18:22
Просмотров 35 тыс.
About the Bengali language
21:30
Просмотров 45 тыс.
Indian Countries Outside of India
12:07
Просмотров 190 тыс.
How to run these SACMS that are only possible in India
12:53
Muslims debate with a Hare Krishna Monk
20:51
Просмотров 2,9 млн
Brawl Stars expliquez ça
00:11
Просмотров 6 млн