A few my theories: Soobin: He seems to be the holder of the Magic since he is always activating the circle. He can see the past, present, and future. The dice might be a new way to activate his magic. It also reminds me of DnD dice which can control the players outcome of their stats, story, and little tasks. Yeonjun: He might have befriend or get controlled by the cat. He seems to the one that needs to be saved for the amount of times he dies in the video. Could be a king in a sort. Beomgyu: He knows Soobin has the power of magic. Shown in by the turn of the camera. Somehow he will betray the boys. He might be the first to be “corrupted”. Taehyun: He can maybe see emotions and possible outcomes. He is attentive usually, but not in this video. Maybe not wanting to see and hear something. Huening Kai: He might be able to befriend the dragon. He was in the sky. Not really sure his role in this. Also wanted to state the 9 3/4 that landed in the clock.
DJJS YALL ARE SO SMARTT😭😭 BUT DJJSH THE DICE ALSO REMINDED ME OF DND AND WITH THE HELP OF U SAYING THAT THE DICE CONTROLS THE OTHER PLAYERS I REALISED THE NUMBERS ON THE DICE WERE THE NUMBERS IN SOME OF THE MEMBERS "DREAMS" AND SOOBIN COULD B CONTROLLING THEIR FATES OR SUM LIKE U ALREADY PROB THOUGHT OF THIS BUT DOSUHDHDH AAHHHH, I LOVE THEORIZING YALL LMAOO
I THINK UR CORRECT HUENING KAI IS CONNECTED TO THE DRAGON! I WATCHED THEYRE MAGIC ISLAND MV AGAIN AND IT SEEMS LIKE A DRAGON FLASHED IN HIS MIND, THE OTHER MEMBERS HAD FLASHES TOO BUT HIS WAS A DRAGON AND I SEARCHED THE MEANING OF THE DRAGON AND IT IS ASSOCIATED WITH HEAVENS AND WATER!!
Honestly find it so suspicious how the cat showed up at that exact scene with Yeonjun. Like why do i feel like Yeonjun made some kind of deal with the cat...
It makes sense that he made a deal with it since for his scene it said back then i thought u were my salvation so i guess back in nap of star he thought the cat was gonna help/save him 🤷♀️
@@insertname4474 It is strange. It seems like Soobin and Yeonjun are the only two who have physically seen the cat with their own eyes. It's fascinating and makes me wonder if any of the other three boys will see it next...I guess only time will tell.
@@PJOandHOO1 I went back and watched the trailer soobin saw what i thought were the cats eyes but the more i look at it they might be a dragons not gonna lie and that would make sense in that in eternally mv there is a dragon flying and if they do become friends with the Dragon then this is the consequence since huening has the secret but soobin saw it first so there may be an underlining consequence we don't know yet thats why soobins invisible.
And to think of an innocent myself a year ago, seeing these boys debuting and never even imagining how dark and complex their storyline would be such little time later... It seems like BigHit found some really good writers/screenwriter/minds to come up with all these some years ago 😂
I think Gfriend was born on the island and kept their powers. TXT was born on the island too but they forgot the island and so they lost their powers. But Bts was the only ones who were not born there but are trying to get there. Idk it's just my theory
The thing is soobin ks getting closer to magic that all of them so he will probably be the one to lead them back to the magic island with yeonjun warning from the cat and heuningkais dragon to fly them there maybe? Also Taehyun has some sort of senaing power so he may be the one to warn the others about beomgyu since he be acting weird these day
What if the eternity girl has actually taken the form of beomgyu which is why we see him as the “dark” one trying to “end this world” and he is trying to tell the other boys to “remember his name”, maybe he knows what’s happening and he’s trying to save them.
What if YeonJun is to play the part of the girl in the comics? He’s shown to be really sad and possibly guilty in ‘Can’t you see me’, so maybe he is so desperate for release by death but because of his shapeshifting abilities, he can’t (just like the girl.) So the cat is the thing to make a deal with him, To destroy space and time. Which, he does. He burns down the stadium (the stadium being a metaphor of the space and time) and that’s why they’re seen standing on the rubble of what’s left of the stadium. And when it’s TaeHyun’s turn and we see him find YeonJun @ 15:32 dead, it was the cat keeping their end of the promise and granting him his death. Now, seeing that the members can time travel I’m sure YeonJun is technically still alive since they like to go back in time a lot before the stadium burned down.
I think the spirit that hug Soobin can be a manifestation of the Star, and the girl in the school skirt a bad spirit that can be connected to the cat or magic island
The way you connected the destroyed stadium with the vision in magic island made me make the loudest gasp. Your attention to detail astounds me. Not to mention when you connected choi and the Flower aboratorium friggn blew my mind.
@@xCeleste I just found something! In the end of Yeonjun's questioning film the Morse code reads 'promise'. Also, Yeonjun's chapter in the MV is called promise
@@xCeleste Please watch Laina Sunflower.... I think both of yours theories make sense together.... The Butterfly effect... And time travel... With the Utopic magical place that binds everyone in big hit universe together.... I think her theories and yours kinda go together...and may complete it others... Anyway check her out... it's so worth it
Actually, DKDKTV made a explanation story as well. Since they are koreans too, it is pretty easy to understand their theories/explanations as well, such Korean stuff we need to understand like yeah, the magic island and more things. They make explanations/theories of other's music video too.
About the "forgotten diary of the two" in BTS Love Yourself highlight reel Jin is at a crossroad (also the name of one of GFRIEND's song) when he sees a girl who accidentaly drops a red diary. He later picks it up and sees that inside was various notes and bucket lists. Also in GFRIEND's Rough MV we can see the girls writing in a similar diary, some even speculated that the girl at the crossroad was one of the members of GFRIEND. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-Oqksx-xkSg8.html Also in the wings era by BTS which was inspired by the book Damian the "egg" represents the world, what if "easter egg" represents a dream world/dimension ?
I agree with your last theory the most! That would make sense bc they r trying to remember their promise, their abilities and the magic. 'Find the Easter egg'. Another theory: the notes written on the mirror were the girl's. What if the glass mirror girl needs to break from the egg.. what if she is trapped in this other world. Since "i need to break out" written on the mirror. And bts has a large connection with mirrors and glass shattering. But im just grasping at strings at this pt
@@ijm7117 No, you actually reminded me of something. GFRIEND just released their concept photos for the next comeback , in one of the pictures there is a broken mirror and it's quite big ( as if we had to notice it ?!?).
@@lizzie9875 I thought It was Seokjin's father with Beomgyu. Not letting him go of the book. I just reminded by how the room looks, almost the same with the BTS Concept game trailer of Seokjin's father's office.
I think Yeonjun made a bargain with the cat thinking it would save them, but after all he ends up paying the price, one he didn't know at the time. I'm very curious what's going to happen in the next trilogy, which I believe it will be "the love chapter" because of what was written in the persona intro: DREAM, LOVE, HAPPINESS. If it is "the love chapter", I wonder if they are going to show the love between the boys, and how it's starting to fall apart. We still have to know what is "the star" exactly, like, is it another dimmension? Is the star personified in any way? I'm excited for another year with them
"I think Yeonjun made a bargain with the cat thinking it would save them, but after all he ends up paying the price, one he didn't know at the time" this just reminded me of jin and the shape shifter cat (which looked like a white fox in save me webtoon more than a cat) and the way that jin kinda made a deal with the cat too !!
My theories: Yeonjun is actually DIED. In nap of star he was killed by the cat and never leave the place however the boys didnt notice yet and thought that yeonjun(ghost) is still alive.Thats why taehyun saw yeonjun dead with cut at the same place.I guess the plants was covering him because his body was never found by anyone. (I think yeonjun started to reliaze he is dead in cysm scene where he was looking at his hand and his part 'save me' I think he want to be saved from death) Also in this MV where he constantly dead. Soobin soon notice it but didnt tell anyone yet because he didnt want to ruin their innoncence. Later Taehyun notice it too and thats why they were called 'the liar' for keeping the secret from beomgyu and heuningkai.They tried to bring yeonjun back to live with the Eternity book(?) Thats explained the symbol around the school at runaway MV(maybe some ritual I guess) Beomgyu however suspicious with taehyun and soobin behaviour and know that they are keeping a secret. He soon find out and i guess he tried to stop them from using the Eternity book because he know there must be a consequences or payback (I dont really sure) Thats explain beomgyu scene where he is fighting someone (maybe soobin) and his story which is 'which side should I choose'..I think it is either to choose his conscience (let yeonjun rest in peace) or his happiness (bring yeonjun back alive) Heuningkai is the only one that didnt know anything because his hyung tried to protect his innoncence. Thats all I got I will keep updating my theories ^_^
but what is the secret that hyuka has? his morse code in the introduction film is "secret", also in his photocard for the tdc:star album it has a phrase about a secret too
@@evelinramosmiranda619 It is sort of implied that he has a connection with the dragon shown at the beginning of the Eternally MV, so maybe that has something to do with it?
it might sound funny, but remember when txt was playing that game in 'we k-pop ep 15' and, when answered what none of the members have, BEOMGYU said 'a conscience', implying that (maybe)(1) all of them are trying to save yeonjun or (2) all but him (beomgyu) maybe (surely) i am just retarded but it's the first thing that came to my mind when i saw the word 'conscience' and i thought i might share it with you also, about the part in the video where Celeste says about Soobin and Kai's innocence, when they went to 'ban ban show', Soobin and Kai were the only ones wearing 'angel crowns'?? (idk how to explain in other way, i suck at english), while Yeonjun, Tae and Beomgyu were wearing 'devil crowns'?? idkkkkk, don't take me seriously i always look for hints/clues when they go to variety shows/interviews
While you were showing the eternity girl comic, i realized she has two different colored eyes! You might be onto something 😳🤔 Edit: aNd one is blue and the other a greenish color-
but she doesn't have odd eyes, she is a shapeshifter and has trouble mantaining her human form, which is the one that has blue eyes. the other has green. in the cover page it shows multiple forms, kind of when you cut different photos and try to make a face with bits of everyone (i don't know if i explained it well sorry)
Theory: What if YeonJun is to play the part of the girl in the comics? He’s shown to be really sad and possibly guilty in ‘Can’t you see me’, so maybe he is so desperate for release by death but because of his shapeshifting abilities, he can’t (just like the girl.) So the cat is the thing to make a deal with him, To destroy space and time. Which, he does. He burns down the stadium (the stadium being a metaphor of the space and time) and that’s why they’re seen standing on the rubble of what’s left of the stadium. And when it’s TaeHyun’s turn and we see him find YeonJun @ 15:32 dead, it was the cat keeping their end of the promise and granting him his death. Now, seeing that the members can time travel I’m sure YeonJun is technically still alive since they like to go back in time a lot before the stadium burned down.
My theories over this were all over the place I’m impressed you got yours together like this 😂 I keep on thinking that maybe beomgyu killed yeonjun when fighting with him over the eternity book cause of how he’s been all sinister (he bit the head off the gingerbread man in save me... creepy) and yeonjun being A) all covered in tomatoes/ blood in save me looking like he’d started a fight with someone, a fight beomgyu started and mainly directed towards yeonjun (those two were playing around) and B) being dead in eternity, then taehyun found yeonjun dead after which he is suspicious which is why beomgyu tries to kill him (with the tomato splatter and also in suffocation) . And like something about the cat maybe possessing them causing this conflict so it was possessing yeonjun and causing him to fight beomgyu then possessing beomgyu and causing him to kill yeonjun? Also possibly seeing into multiple futures like mirror universes hence mirrors and the door can go through and also the dice it’s like showing the different possibilities of these worlds. Heuningkai dead??? Anyways this is how fragmented my brain is atm 😂
1. I also think kai is dead or will die. I kind of thought it looked like kai was in heaven separated from everybody. He seems to be the most angelic w the wings and innocent aura. Also it could explain why soobin was crying. 2. Kai could just be so pure that he finds himself being separated from the chaotic mess happening amongst the rest of the members. Which is why in his vision he is alone and why his keyword is 'lonely?????
I think Beomgyu killed Kai. The dice number is 19, Soobin's age. The room number is 17, Huening Kai's age. The boy doesn't have any stripes on his jacket - Taehyun and Huening Kai were the only ones with no stripes on their sleeves. Then again, Beomgyu did try to suffocate Taehyun, so I'm not sure.
I don’t think the cat possessed Yeonjun because I think maybe Yeonjun was trying to stop Beomgyu from taking the book, which could represent the promise they all made. I think the cat possessed Beomgyu.
I just wanna say one new thing that is jimin might be the odd eyed cat too cause in serendipity he has odd eyes that green and blue his lyrics also says ' I am your calico cat' This chance is really low but it can be as till this day each group has a member that has odd eye eunha soobin or taehyun or might be yeonjun and in bu it's only jimin who has odd eye and that too in serendipity!! And for information serendipity is a huge connection to other two universe cause it has eclipse like introduction of +u and that iconic reference to gfriend eunha
I thought you would point out that the time on the clock goes to 9 and 3/4. Also: the ice cream sign says "5STAR" and possibly "Friends forever", so Huening Kai dropping that ice cream could be symbolic of losing their friendship. Also: I think the numbers on the dice and room have something to do with their ages/time -- If this is the case, room 17 is either Beomgyu looking at a scene from 2 years in the past or he is in Huening Kai's room. If you notice the stripes on their sleeves in the beginning of the MV, Huening Kai is one of the members without stripes on his jacket. The only other member with no stripes is Taehyun, and he is not 17 years old. I also think the 15 on the dice means he is trying to go back to the past, or there is someone who is 15 present on the other side of the mirror. When talking about the name, I thought it could also be the ghost, the dragon, the cat, or it could be the 6th star in the NoaS video that was only shown in the very first sky scene. Some people said this might be a ref to the member who dropped out of TXT before they debuted. AND: the red window at the end is very significant. It is isolated from the other windows and in one of the last scenes appears to be crying (dripping some liquid). I think this window represents Huening Kai. He is silhouetted in it in one of the final scenes. It shows how he is different and isolated form the other members and would match in with his word, "lonely".
Personally I hope they don't, if Seventeen does get a story line... I hope they get their own. This BTS, TXT, GFriend seemingly interconnected storyline is already waaay too confusing and has very slow progression. If they get any more groups involved I'm sure they would find it impossible to consolidate their story.
These theories hurts my brain so much😂😂😂 I feel like I'm waiting to them to combine all three groups to fully understand the connection of the stories. 😭😭😭
If you see the board behind Namjoon in Persona u can see there is a witch drawn (not if it's a witch) but we see witches in magic island MV when they break apart . It could be related
I've just noticed this, I dont know if I am right: In Stay Gold MV the last part where they are in the place that has a lot of flowers (I dont know what to call it) I kinda noticed It looks like they are in magic island (I dont know if I am right) (This just my own theories just wanna share it)
I've also noticed Yeonjun gets the cut only AFTER seeing the green-blue eyed cat. I am not sure if this timeframe matters, but I feel like every little thing has a deeper meaning haha. Edit: I also want to add the Hanahaki Disease. This is a fictional disease where the victim of unrequited/one-sided love begins to grow flowers in their throat and coughs out flower petals. The only way to cure the disease is for the beloved to return the feeling or when the victim dies (from the suffocation of the flowers). This could explain what happened to Yeonjun and why there are flowers growing from/around his body.
Everytime I watch this explanation/theorie video´s I feel like I´m very dumb. It is so amazing how you put all of this together. In some points it´s kind of an enlightenment and I got chills. Thanks for your hard work. 😁
Thank you for doing this. I all in love with TXT recent days after loving BTS about 5 years. I start to be curious about TXT after Run Away and now I want to know more after We lost the summer. Thank you so much for doing this.
It feels like Umbrella Academy too, Kai is like Vanya (no powers yet). I was thinking this the moment I saw the crumbled stadium and the lightening in the sky. It's like how no.5 sees the "end of the world" and tries to prevent shit from happening. Also death and actual depictions of death like states in the MV. Bighits getting bold. 👏👏👏
For the 17 on the door, the first thing that came to mind was Seventeen the group. Their recent song, "Left and Right" was about the choices we make in life. Which is the entire point of the BigHit Universe, choices. Butterfly Effect, which path do you choose when you come to a Crossroads, Left or Right? Everything comes back to psychology, the choices you make in your life define who you are, right or not you have to live with it. Coming to terms with yourself and your place in the world.
what do you think about the bakeneko/ nekomata theory? maybe that wasn’t yeonjun seeing himself dead (i thought it was weird, he’s seeing himself dead and not 😱) i thing it was the cat that stole yeonjun’s body and is draining (?) he’s essence with the flowers, seems like his purple blood is connected with the island
Beomgyu's voice gets disorted in Eternally and also in Can't You See Me! I think that also represents that he is sinister or something is off with him.
9:12 I think the reason Soobin cries when he looks at little Kai can be related to Carl Jung’s concept of puer aeternus (eternal youth). And ghostlike figure can be his soul or Anima (eternal feminine girl within ?). I got goosebumps in this scene and cried with him, as I feel I lost my childhood due to childhood traumas, that’s when children escaped to magic Island when world/home becomes a dangerous scary place. He may be referring to lost innocence, maybe aiming for immortality or eternal youth is ‘eternal dream’. So that they can save each other and stop Yeonjun (child within) from dying. The enemy remains linear time and aim as staying young forever, eternally
So now I'm thinking that the music videos are all extreme fantasies of events that happened before. The boys didn't wish under a star, they met at the *Starlight Festival* as children and promised to meet again next year. The festival attendees had similar masks as NOAS MV and if you look closely, the star has a very similar steampunk design as the star too. In Magic Island, they probably were returning from the practice room in Eternally because Soobin references his dream, plus directly references "세계가 불타버린 밤, 우린..." by typing "in my dream, we..." and Beomgyu brings up the practice room ghost that sits in the corner. In CYSM, it was a hyperbole of what happens in Eternally because there were the same scenes in both. The water bottle and glass falling, shot with the same angles, Yeonjun and Hueningkai stuck together, Beomgyu was in and out of the moment, Taehyun was uninterested in everything, and even at the end, they shot the same scene in CYSM where Taehyun and Yeonjun leave frame in the same order and it closes in on Soobin being sad and unsure. I still have to go over the text from their fake insta teasers but Beomgyu's teaser had Catcher In The Rye in code. Catcher In The Rye is about a boy who feels wronged and isolated by his environment, thinking that how they treat him is unfair. Maybe there's something in the book he wants to cherish and it is actually destroying them or he wants to destroy it due to content he doesn't want to see again but it's actually their salvation. It seems like he is telling whoever to not stop him and to let him go --the only word I can make out is 하지마/하지마라--. With Yeonjun, his story is connected to Paranoid Park. A movie about a runaway who accidentally murders a man and later on, gets picked out for questioning when police find the skateboard he used to kill the man. There's a moment where the mc writes a complete account of what happened and later burns it. What if Yeonjun did something and he wrote it in that book, but it was never destroyed. In Magic, the secret content behind the hidden password was a video where Soobin IG Live streams the boys in school after dark. They were very happy until something calls Soobin's attention with dread and the camera flips to a folder that says forever. It's not really said whether the incident was during their youth, during puberty, or this new beginning step where the members are becoming young men. But whatever it is, it's enough to plague them with morbid dreams. EDIT: I just had an epiphany. What if in Run Away, Yeonjun was writing a cathartic statement about what was bothering and was in the process of burning it, when Beomgyu attempted to save it. Because after Yeonjun burns the door, which seems like the entrance to their paradise(???), his scar from before went away. As if the scar was a physical representation of the anxiety that plagued him and he found relief and catharsis through burning that part. Beomgyu was the one who patched him up, like he was covering up his worries, and he tried to stop the burning. Also Hueningkai's movie brings up a lot too. He had Stand by Me, a classic American movie where 4 young boys go on a journey to see the dead body of a missing boy. One of the boys takes the discovery hard as his older brother had recently passed very young. BigHit is trying to signify that one of the members is truly dead, since this story centers around the 5 boys. Or that one of the members is metaphorically lost and struggling to reconnect with the group. Honestly, just a can of worms that gains a new meaning after each cb.
I think the book is mentioned in the lyrics of one of the songs of this album it either in eternally or mirror maze talking of a diary or something like that between two people. I also feel the lyrics are really related to the theory as the phrase in the window say remember my name and the lyrics said your name lingers on my lips
I don't know why, but I had a strong realisation once you said "destroy all of space and time" which is the reference to eternity girl. We do not have a confirmation (like what you said) if this is what bighit is trying to pinpoint or reference to. But, I should say, I immediately thought of BTS' WINGS. In Seokjin's 'Awake' episode, we hear about namjoon talking about a bird that should first destroy its' world and fly to god, being Abraxas. I am definitely not qualified for theories, this is all so mind-blowing to me, I really just thought of it hehe :))
What if with the phone beomgyu is able to see the truth “behind the reality”, like infrared glasses so that’s why he keep recording around idk I’m just guessing
I think the woman who comforted Soobin when he cried is the fairy of shampoo because in the lyrics they said something about long black hair. Also Soobin was in a sort of bubble which is similar to TXT' fairy of the shampoo performance.
Wait when they say remember my name they say that in the lyrics of magic island and what if when they first traveled to the magic island they knew the name of whoever it was and all of sudden because time travelling and stuff they forgot the name and soobin is trying to find it out so they can return to happiness.sorry I’m not sure if that made sense but that’s what I thought
THIS IS IMPORTANT I just saw the concept trailer for Eternity and at 3:17 you can see that the lights form the blue and green eyes of the cat I still dont fully know thw +U but I sure know this might help
I think they got those abilities in magic island when they got hit by the train because it shows that they were holding the parts of their bodies that changed. When they got hit by the train in magic island. Yeonjun is holding his head. Soobin covering his ears. Heuningkai holding his heart. Beomgyu holding his shoulder. Taehyun covering his eyes. (Just theory)
at the end of the mv, on the window it says, “remember my name.” i cried when i saw that. not only because of the beautiful mv, but those were my friend’s last words. in korean. “remember my name.” 💔💔
You know something, You maybe on something here Celeste, about Beomgyu in this storyline twilight nightmare Eternally MV, think about it was Beomgyu who has recording his camera on Soobin which was eerie, And, on 'Can't You See Me mv, it was 'Beomgyu tried suffocating Taehyun when light turn red dark, and it was Beomgyu has started the food fight on on 'Can't You See Me mv but the way he tried to suffocate Taehyun on 'Can't You See was kinda eerie strange like he tried to kill him, And, now on this 'Eternally MV we see Beomgyu tried to steal that same book that was on TXT 'Run video, that book has same symbol mystical mark that Soobin saw on white dice along with mythical symbol showing on 'Eternity before it disappeared, doing Soobin time traveler before he saw lil Kai running, when He pick Up the white diced that has numbers on it, could it be the same numbers symbol of the 5 members dreams, and could this book that 'Beomgyu tried to steal from that room against someone who tried to stop him that has some magical powers to destroyed that space chaos world, that we saw in this video before big stadium being destroyed, could Beomgyu be the secret hidden villain in this story could it someone in that room that tried to stop him from taken book be someone that Beomgyu knew about but Beomgyu wants to warn others but couldn't get out, Could this guy In room tried to stop Beomgyu be someone we Army's know who tried to destroyed this world space to make Beomgyu members suffer could his name begins with a letter 'J ??? I mean this is Bighit you know never know, The way Beomgyu recording Soobin on camera at end like nothing happened was kinda eerie to me, could Beomgyu sees this ghost girl to, and Is he related to this ghostly figure, could this ghost girl that's haunts Soobin in this storyline is connected to Beomgyu or connected to letter 'J could this guy that tried to stop 'Beomgyu in that room tried to stop Beomgyu from taken that book out could be the one that causing what happening to kthat ghostly girl, could Beomgyu knows what has happened about, but kept quiet in a secret, that maybe 'Beomgyu tried to use this book to destroyed this space world chaos in order to bring this ghostly girl or lady back to life could this ghostly girl end Up being Beomgyu 'Sister or Mother and could this ghostly lady be connected to guy who tried stop him In that room in Eternally mv, I don't know it just my opinion thinking. So basic we sees time goes back on TXT Eternally mv with 'Soobin, and who else we knows does time traveler in Bighit storyline, I'm not gonna say no name let Bighit surprised us, I just remember the scriptures in 'Awake It just feels so familiar again it just my opinion thinking.. Go watch RU-vidrs 'WholesomeAzns opinions at end video of 'BTS Summary Highlight-Reel, and think of connection in Bighit it may sound insane but who knows when it comes to Bighit, just saying.. Excuse my long post..😁✌
I heard another theory from when "can't you see me" came out that said boys manipulate each other. Soobin and Taehyun manipulate Kai and Beomgyu while Yeonjun is confused, but further back it is the cat that manipulated everyone to destroy magic Island
I also want to add that the white stairs Huening went up led to him being separated from the other members, and one of the phrases written on the mirror in the beginning was "Don't go up the stairs." I wonder who wrote that and who was trying to warn him.
Did anyone else notice that in the cover of the comic "Eternity Girl" the girl on the cover had blue and green eyes. it even says that the girl can shape-shift so there is a possibility that she is the cat and shes creating the chaos between the boys just to achieve her own peace.
In an interview i heard that... Yeonjun told that can't you see me was the aftermath of the burn down of the magical world and the world... After that fire they started to face difficulties in their friendship
Okay so my guess is that 'the cat' is actually some evil being. It "promises" to give the boys some special gifts, which we see in the Magic Island MV that they get different kinds of 'gifts'. But the guys don't realize that the cat is evil. And the star or the ghost trys to warn them. And the book is somehow the connection inbetween. Only soobin is the one who understands through his dreams and all. And when he tries to tell the others, they don't pay much attention and he is cast away, turned 'invisible'. Then at Boemgyu's part. I think the other person we saw in the room 17 is Soobin himself who trys to stop Boemgyu from taking the book. We have also seen that Boemgyu is being weird with all this 'world ending', setting the forest on fire and trying to suffocate people. I think he ends up shaking hands with the evil cat.
i think the 'forgotten diary of the two' might be a diary by soobin and taehyun, since they are the only two who know that yeonjun is dead (soobin saw yeonjun's bloody face in the beginning and taehyun saw him in the moratorium ). soobin and taehyun are also the only ones who are holding their fingers crossed during the can't you see me choreography which basically means they are lying and have secrets. also i am not sure about this since i don't know if the run away mv is connected to the txt universe, but taehyun could've found out that yeonjun was dead in the end of the music video- because the cut on his finger magically healed, but the doll was burnt when he picked it up from the floor. i love how complex this universe is-
My theory of yeonjun is that the fire I following him cause he broke the rule on the train to close his eyes while going though the tunnel, but instead he opened them breaking the rule. I think the fire and the crown you see in taehyun's section are his punishment.
Also I noticed that the boys walk away from Soobin in the last section, it looks a lot like how the boys walked away from Soobin in can't you see me. Like he's lonely yet again and is invisible.
i strongly suspect that the next +u film/mv in their comeback will directly continue from the end of eternally just like magic island did with it (the dark clouds, storm and dragon)
23:55 it may be Soobin and Yeonjun's diary since Soobin approach Yeonjun in the beginning but he saw Yeonjun with blood. And Beomgyu's trying to protect/steal it in the Room No. 17 and maybe Yeonjun was the one who's pushing Beomgyu so that he couldn't get out of the room. Then noticed the blood in the room that signifies Beomgyu ended up killing that man. And all through out the video, Yeonjun was the only member that was seen 'dead' by himself and Taehyun. Taehyun also saw him dead because he was also killed by Beomgyu in Can't You See Me MV. I dont know if this all connects but this is my thought.
I think the part of the 'remember my NAME' is refering to the girl which is the star. That they should remember the name of the girl which is 'STAR'. And according to my resources, for tommorow x together star is another name for dream: the emotions swelling up inside as you look up at the starry night sky, the growing excitement about tomorrow - chasing the stars mean you are remembering your childhood dreams. ‘The Dream Chapter’ will unfold the stories of what they encountered as they grew. So i think that the NAME they should remember is their DREAM.
A thing that I know about the cat: it appers 4 times in TXT's videos. 1. Nap Of a Star MV, 2. Magic Island MV, 3. Eternity Concept Trailer, 4. In Eternally's MV. (Someone said that this cat is who is controling the boys, especially Yeonjun, maybe...IDK...)
The Choi child is probably soobin ie if the universes are connected. I mean, jin & soobin both time travel so they might be the 'two' who share the book
tbh i feel like “remember my name” could be yeonjun bc it shows him dead or bloody a lot and he could be telling the other member to remember him, and “what exactly did we do wrong” could be soobin bc he seems to be the only one that’s aware of everything and he could be questioning what they did wrong to deserve everything that’s happening. (sorry if this is confusing. i’m not that good with explaining thing)
the eternity girl comic that u have shown makes me think a lot of eunha the eyes color the fact that she has a lot of physical apparances (at the end of crossroads, when the rooms break down, she keep changing apparances) the hair is brown and not too long not too short which is a hair that eunha had a lot of times (also in their last trailer) the school uniform too (their last trailer) i thought that that girl feels lonely and to be honest i always see loneliness in eunha's eyes in tftmn or crossroads ect! which makes me think that she indeed is the ghost if the ghost is the eternity ghost and sorry for my english
if txt are looking for song of the star, could it be gfriend??? i mean you guys can see on gfriend crossroads lyric it said "unfurling singing star, will you hear it?" it means that gfriend already found song of the star or gfriend are the song the star itself and there's a lyric too on crossroads "shining star, will you see it too?" I wonder if Gfriend's message is addressed directly to txt? and txt are actually looking for gfriend? and that's why we see the girl on the lake on magic island is eunha with uniform school just like on gfriend butterfly effect, and the girl on eternally are probably umji or eunha i wonder if they trying to give an clues or message or maybe a warning to txt? idk hahahah
That beomgyu "what side should i put my trust in" reminds me of his outfit in their album The Dream Chapter : Eternity ( Starboard ver. ) Beomgyu's outfit is dark blue (and white), HueningKai's outfit is white (and black), and the others is black (and white). Maybe it's just me overthinking, but its always in my mind, don't know why
