Yes my bighit plan way before debuting them that means he is trying create his own universe with his artists by having their own story line n looking at this it makes bighit different from other company if u are noticing now alot of companies trying to copy him by making a story line in their music
Maybe. It could also have been planned to have been given to BTS. It's kinda sad, but it's quite common. For example, Blackpink have been given songs that were meant for 2NE1 at least once.
You talking about Yeonjun being the eldest and thus having already lost his childhood innocence and then playing his hilarious tiktok dance was editing gold and I just want you to know that!
Yeah.... I noticed it too.... At first I think the different eyes means the person that been controlled by the cat. Yeonjun once meet the cats. And beomgyu once act like being controlled by something. So, I think it might be like a sign the the person is under controlled by something.
I honestly didn’t think that BTS’s and TXT’s storylines were connected but after seeing the comparisons of the Make it right MV and Puma MV.... I’m starting to believe they are 🤯 wow
I think that TXT will have time to build their own backstory before connecting to BTS but yes some aspects are connected to BTS and Gfriend too! I wonder if Seventeen will be connected to this Universe too 😌
@@hairu5618 pledis stans surely doesn't like that shared universe thingy so now dont tell me "it doesn't matter what pledis stans think" cuz it does matter:)
Fun fact: when soobin's eyes changed at the end, he was in the middle. If we follow the logic that he turned into a dragon, it seems like the other members represent the wings of the dragon. What if the dragon represents them all together? Or them working together somehow?
I think I just used up my last working braincell 😵 Boy, Bighit should just release a fantasy movie at this point, ' cause it's sure gonna be better than most ! 💜
So psychologically, they change from being innocent to unleashing a monster in the dream chapter... //TU In Nap of a Star, TXT first met as lil monsters, and and by the end, they grew and looked like humans with deformities. In Magic Island, they look completely human. Does it mean TXT are becoming more monstrous when they look more human?
Do you remember that BTS and Gfriend have Like a glass bead and BTS broke the bead and causing to blackened the bead which was bad but since they were normal before coming to Magic Shop and Magic Island and as for Gfriend they are actually born from Magic Island and since they can't go back they slowly getting distant to each other
7:46-9:06 goosebumps This song is somewhat connected to them This lines“Too young to be on my own this world’s a jungle full of warriors the zeroes in on your neck, Thousands of eyes get to the internet watch out, your enemies will be everywhere “how long til i reach my dream?” Only gunshots ring out on that question Again i run up so i can breath again” “Gotta run, feel happy somehow I’ve never felt like this before Facing freedom for the first time Woo, i feel happy somehow My choice is my leader i am my own believer” It’s like they’re trying to reach their dream but the all they hear are “gunshots” it’s like gunshots represents negative comments thousands of eyes gets into the internet it’s like they are pressured not to make any mistakes
The genius of TXT/BigHit. Three stories simultaneously told in one music video. 1. Perspective on freedom vs danger 2. Personal journey of the boys 3. Story line of TXT Universe
OMG...I never ever thought that the BTS and TXT universes had connections like this...this is beyond amazing... like,really. You could become a detective fr. This makes me even more interested in TXT. But wait...if these were actually true, does this mean, BigHit planned all this even before TXT debuted????? WHAT??? THAT'S THE MOST MINDBLOWING THING EVERRR. THIS WOULD BE THE MOST ICONIC THING EVER TO HAPPEN IN KPOP HISTORY
Chocolate Madness Well maybe. But we also have to remember that TXT is still an actual group with their own story(which I’m sure you’re already aware of) and I doubt that they’re the villians (maybe). Like, I dun see BH creating TXT just to be the villians in a already made story. We also have to take account of GFRIEND. In my perceptive, TXT seems like clueless babies stuck between the BU(Bangtan Universe)and GU(GFRIEND storyline) Besides “We all pretend to be the hero’s on the good side. But what if we’re the villains on the other?”
@@thenon-painter4747 Both groups have their own path (standalone storyline) but it will intersect some day (shared storyline). I still believe they're in the same world tho it's too early to tell. As for gfriend and the other sublabels, they could be a parallel universe. Not sure.
I noticed in the mv that yeonjun represents the puma that got killed, while beomgyu and soobin are its "children" (sorry i dont know the right word for this haha it's not my first language) I dont know how to explain, but you can see the references about it along the mv... I didn't see anyone talking about it, is it because it's too obvious or because i am the only crazy who saw that? Jdjsjsjdjsjdjs
I bet they will have a song named ''dragon'' in the future maybe like in their fifth or sixth album XD İmagine.. in the future bts and txt in one mv as the hero and the monster fighting :d Bish I couldn't
I’m finally caught up with all of TXT’s music videos up until “Puma.” I actually listened to the whole album before watching the mvs. I also watched your theory videos and everything for TXT :) I need a break, it’s a lot of information to unpack and learn lol I wrote all of this down when the “Puma” mv came out. This is an interesting mv. I love the song, the music, and everything. It’s like we’re actually at the first shadow of TXT. I saw the beginning of a reaction video for this mv and they were talking about how it’s also about a puma/cougar that escaped a zoo, she (the puma) didn’t attack anyone or did anything bad. Whoever caught her, killed her. This is so sad, I was surprised to hear all this. (I also, finished watching that reaction video after I watched the mv.) Also, the mv is about “a puma that escaped from a zoo.” Taehyun describes the mv on the Studio Choom Behind video: “At first, puma enjoys the freedom…Then faces the reality where everyone keeps up their guard towards him…We conveyed a suffering boy’s feelings through the puma." This is the video: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-4q-QdgR1jwY.html This is the video of the performance: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-DI-p_p4jjlk.html The entrances of the cave when they’re in the tunnel (at 1:30 in the mv) reminds me of J.R.R Tolkien’s dreams. Where he talks about an opening/doorway to a cave with light or something like that. He also had drawings of it. This also reminded me of Jung talking about the cave in his dreams. The red color makes the cave look like hell. It’s like the way Jung describes it (showing the inner parts of the soul). You’ve talked about it in another theory video. You know the one about the dream he had, about the water being like blood. I’ll share this video again, it’s one of the best video’s that describe it: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-l6oh14vfhlI.html Soobin has a different eye color, but Puma’s can also have blue eyes. It’s funny he said he looked like a wolf in the making of the mv. I think he meant that as a joke. And he is the leader of TXT, that could be why his eyes are a different color. Most cats live solitary, if they were together it would be called a pack or pride (with lions). TXT is wearing different colored spots in most of the mv, maybe they are different kinds of the same species. This mv reminded me of ‘Blood, Sweat, and Tears.’ Especially the part with the red cave, the arrows that land around Beomgyu. Also, reminded me of the ‘ON’ mv. Near the end in the “Puma” mv the rocks that TXT are crouching on look like the ones from the ‘ON’ mv. Also, I see a bit of ‘Black Swan’ in parts of the choreography, the hand gestures TXT is doing in the mv at 1:23, and at 1:42 when they raise their arms up and bring it down slowly. I also remember the part of the choreography for ’N.O.’ from BTS, it’s the part Yoongi is helped by Namjoon to get onto Jin and Jungkook’s backs. It looks like when Yeonjun is on Huening Kai and Soobin’s back (at 0:30 in the mv). And in the background, you can hear ‘No…’ as part of the song. (When Yeonjun gets off their backs). Some of the lyrics reminded me of ’N.O.’ And a bit of Fake Love, the choreography it’s a bit like a marionette being controlled. I think one of them said that the movement is doll-like in the making of one of their performances. I don’t remember where I saw it and read. Maybe that was for the “Can’t You See Me?” mv, either way, it’s cool. The symbolic meaning of a puma, as we might expect, deals a lot with strength, power, energy, and vitality. Other meanings include action, nobility, patience, silence, decision, leadership, guardianship, and self-assurance (self-confidence or confidence). In most of their mvs, it feels like TXT were sure about things like their promise and dreams at one point; now they lack some confidence and seem lost about themselves. I hope to see them overcome all of this, watch them grow as individuals and as a group. These are big cats, so the puma is also a symbol of stealth, cunning, and skill. As a totem, the puma reminds us to employ patience and strategy to hunt down what we want. A Black panther (can also be considered a puma); as a totem represents magic. To have this animal behind you as a spiritual animal, makes others feel like you are truly magical and that there is something mystical about you. Panthers also represent feminine energy; it’s a bit like the “anima” or feminine aspect of one’s psyche (soul). The meaning of Puma (as well as the symbolism of mountain lions or cougars) speaks to us of inspection, observation, and scrutiny. In the wild, this creature will stare at an object, unmoving, for what seems like an eternity. Further, she does this with stillness, patience. To those of us who heed the puma as a guide, we would take great care to observe our own lives with the kind of intense focus the puma does. People who have identified the pumas, mountain lions, and many others as their animal totem are people who typically come into this world with a spiritual knowing. Those who attract this animal totem have a deeper understanding of spiritual things. They are very psychic, intuitive, and are likely to be artistically inclined. Although I don’t have totems or spirit animals I feel like all three of these things describe me; a bit psychic, very intuitive, and very artistically inclined. (I’m an artist.) This also describes TXT and BTS, they are intuitive and we know they are all artistically inclined.
This may be one of my favorite theories of yours. Everything connected so smoothly and made so much sense. It was like following a trail of string and finding treats along the way. Especially moments like at 8:08 made me connect to this theory in such an emotional way, that I don't think I'll ever forget it. The way you explained this made it easy to understand! If anyone else tried to explain it to me I don't think I would have gotten the idea. Near the end was so satisfying, like watching someone solve a puzzle and put the last piece in. I cannot imagine the amount of work you do to put these together, thank you so much
Hey i wanna tell you, the fact that most BTS members have fire moons, they behave in extroverted way, its suitable for their philosophical metaphorical expressions in their albums. While TXT their young brothers, most of them are water moons, mostly scorpio moons, 1 pisces moon and 1 libra moon.. this is suitable for their philosophical psychological concept in their album related to how you interpreted it, about how they express the inner instinctive primitive dragon as the self, to go to the route of darkness, while BTS somehow come to the high moralistic side as the hero archetype... and TXT express the opposite, from the dark aspect of the self. But this is just my basic perspective..i just love this interpretation and its synchronized to their moon signs... Scorpio moons/or water moons are dark, yin, amd introvert... If there are any insights from you guys, i welcome your perspective. I just need to tell you all this is so good... Similar and resonated to their moon signs
I always get surprised when I remember how deep this storyline is...It's actually so sad. I try to feel the lyrics, the music...The choreo. They express feelings through their music, so we can connect with them.
I honestly thought bts and TXT were connected somehow but this sort of proves that but I have my own theory what if there is nothing behind it just the lyrics teaching us to love, speak and be ourselves not worrying about what others think. My other theory that isn't necessarily related is that BigHit has time travelers who traveled to the future saw their groups success and then went back to the present time then and started making up these storylines if there is a specific storyline and I say if there is a specific storyline because some of the bts members said that they don't even know what goes on.
I think the BTS members do know what's going on most of the time, but it's a lot of work so they might be tired to notice or not be sure about somethings.
I freakin' knew that Soobin's eyes weren't that of puma, but when u said dragon... I'M SHOOKETH! I glitched like Huning at Taehyun's magic tricks haha That make sooo much sense tho!
Holy shit... So in BTS' story, we had seen how the Persona confronted the Shadow which is kinda like the Hero, the best part of yourself that you show to others, confronting the Monster, the ugly, dangerous, and dark part of yourself, come to an agreement and balance each other out. But in TXT's story, we see it from the perspective of the Monster who has yet to confront the "Hero" that will balance out their dark side and save them from themselves... Oh my god that's genius
bighit really loves contradictions-- angel & devil, persona/shadow/ego, crown & horns, blue orangeade, demian, etc. glad that they're also teaching us to be aware of our darkest side, even learn about it.
@@thenon-painter4747 no i mean umbrellas in an mv. Like actually being used. We've seen them everywhere, in bts and txt. In the room practice on the side. They've got to be in some choreography or something. And i'm so impatienttt i thought bts was gonna use them but then they never did so now I'm hoping for something. Probably with eternally...
I’m mind blown... got chills as the video was playing. Thank you so much for clearing up everything and giving us the beauty of understanding this in-depth. Wow
"Those who see them attack them because they see them as a danger" people feel threatened by the talent and passion the boys have thus attacking them and ignoring their potential and turning a blind eye to their greatness 😢💜💚
SO THEIR FREINDSHIP MADE THEM CATS AND DOGS TO EACHOTHER THAT MAKES THEM FREINDLY TO EACHOTHER? THEN THEY HAD A FIGHT THAT TRIGGERED THEIR PUMA SIDE (DANGER?).AND THEIR SEPERATION IS NOT ONLY CAUSED BY THEIR FIGHT BUT ALSO THEIR TRANSFORMATION. AND THE CAT SIMBOLIZES THEIR FEAR COMING TO LIFE SINCE THEIR FRIENDHIP DEFINES THEM THE CAT ATTACKS WHEN THEIR ARE FREIDSHIP IS IN DANGER OR IF THEY ARE ALONE, THEN THIS ISOLATION CREATES THE MOSNTER IN THEM. SO WHEN THEY ARE TOGETHER THEY ACCEPTS THEIR MONSTROUS SIDE BECAUSE OF THE THEIR LOVE FOR EACHOTHER BUT IF THEY ARE ALONE THE CAT THAT REPRESENTS FEAR TAKES OVER THEM. I LEARN ALOT FROM YOU THANK YOU i learn faster here than at school😂 and i think thats not good😅
I will sum up this as them getting ready to face THE REAL LIFE since they aren't in THEIR DREAM anymore. That's why I totally agree with the symbolism of the end of YOUTH and INNOCENCE for the begining of them experiencing MANHOOD. Anyway, this is a great explanation. Very well done 🤗
Honestly i like ur theory better than others cause ur theory somehow connect well with all of their songs and it really really makes sense. U are awesome! Thank youu..
I don't follow TXT's universe closely but I'm getting more interested in them after this album. Big thanks to you and your explain series for helping me understand them better.
Thank you so tremendously much for these videos. They are EVERYTHING. And to those like me who need a little filter to understand the MV, videos like yours are a gift ❤️
I love how you ended your lengthy, in-depth, well-researched video explanation with “This all I have for you today”. Thanks for helping all of us connect the dots!!
12:44 So you're telling me *That adorable Odd eyed Kitten* is the representation of their fear??? I believe you :D Your the bookish theories and you have more braincells than me and my friends combined.
So in one aspect, bu and tu is not in parallel universe but are in one and same universe where bts is the hero and txt plays the villain role. This gets more interesting. I wonder what will be the role of gfriend here....
Ah yes. Youth dealing with hostility and yet not wanting to give up what they value Innocent and Dangerous "Perceived as a thread that must be stopped" The puma escaping its cage symbolizes ...what Cat and dog is in friendship and innocence in a simpler world. Puma is what was hidden that came out with the breakdown of relationships and perhaps...their own mistakes or something external? It is interesting...that they can be transitioning from innocence to a form of being the villains of their own narratives. ....isolation brings on the manifestation of insecurities with the breakdown of relationships. In Make It Right, BTS and ARMY is really the focus of the video. In txt...it's much more about the danger of isolation which is more about a dialogue with their generation on issues that are hard to talk about...compared to BTS themes....which, while they talk about challenges, usually discuss uplifting themes that tend to focus on BTSARMY. That's really interesting
no voy a escribir en ingles porque ya de por si tengo el cerebro trabajando mal jajajs pero por favor no puedo creer que toda la historia de txt sea tan oscura, incluso mas oscura que la de bts (por el hecho del concepto).En cierta forma ya estaba notando algo de conexión con sus universo, ademas ya conozco de antemano a big hit y esto no me sorprende. Lo que si me deja con la boca abierta es como todo se relaciona y lo bien que lo hacen, sinceramente me estoy volviendo muy fan de toda esta storyline QUE ENCIMA SON ENTRE GRUPOS!!! no puedo esperar a ver como todo esto progresa y que este acompañado con música, imágenes y un mensaje demasiado poderoso. es simplemente increíble, Bookish Theories no se si vas a entender este comentario pero te ganaste una nueva suscriptora, ahora mismo voy a ver el resto de tus videos para estar mas informada con todo esto jajajs, sos muy buena te adore. GREETINGS FROM ARGENTINA!!!!! Bighit fighting! MOARMY fighting!
half way the vid and Im already anticipating for the next TU mv which is my big fat guess "Eternally" and see your take on it hahaha. also: In my theory I think Beomgyu is also guilty tho since I think he's the one who started the fire on magic island which makes sense on his lines in CYSM "you turned your back when we/you watched the fire burn" i think in the photoshoot he's also tagged as the guilty one and he started the food fight in CYSM. So for Yeonjun, I think he's mostly the member who foresees the future but he chooses not to tell the others somehow. In Run Away he burned the book, and Beomgyu tried kill the fire but it was still burning after. Then when he wore the glasses then the giant door burned after. that might've meant he knew something that the others dont. but i dont know hahaha i've been thinking a lot of this but it could also be that I switched the roles of each members hahaha when eternally comes out i hope my theories would still make sense or else i'd be a clown haha
You explain everything so clearly and connect everything so well~ thank you once again for your hard work! I'm already looking forward to TXT's next album and mv's XD though they should rest first-
I can't wait to see your theories about eternally!! And I am the only one who thinks that the place where Yeonjun was stand out in the final is similar to where he sees himself died in eternally? (Sorry for my bad english)
The fact that a dead of an animal (ok,yes,this is a dead of a puma so it's not usual thing to happend,but still) caused national outcry...wow,i didn't expect people to be that kind
I love your theories so muchhh.. Maybe that's why eternally depicts so much duality, because they're moving on to a different phase and are confused between their both sides
