You can't rate a window correctly without hindsight. Falcao, Blind, Rojo, Herrera, Shaw, Di Maria was a great window at the time but in hindsight it was mid.
Agreed, more than strong chance we could look back at this and say 'how tf did we change the whole hierarchy & still buy the managers dutch/ajax wet dream from 5 years ago?"
The success of the window can only be judged at Christmas. We need Ugarte to come in and give Toby Collyer a chance in the first team. If we can resolve the injury crisis, I think we'll do really well this year.
I agree. Our major problem for these years has been a porous midfield. Even if you have good defenders, a porous midfield will always put them at risk and they will make mistakes.
I really hope that United hold on to their valuation of Ugarte, like in the Branthwaite case, don’t pay overprice any longer. It’ll take a couple of windows, but in the end others clubs stops raising the fee when they hear United being interested.
It can’t be a 10/10 transfer window because we haven’t sold well or enough players. We have signed some good players who fit the way we want to play better but failing to bring in money and moving out players that don’t fit and or need to go is too big of a deal to overlook.
Title talk is delusional at best. We still have too much deadwood to get rid of first, avoiding so many shots conceded per game and scoring more goals before we can even talk about titles
@@fplgregfrost a couple of good games against tired players at the end of the season mean nothing. Even in those games his on the ball play was still poor. Have you forgotten how useless he was when he was playing in midfield From October to December? He was awful, which is why he was dropped until the end of the season. One of the worst players I’ve ever seen in a United shirt.
@@brun4775 I think he's very limited. But he's a great professional, loves the club, doesn't kick up a fuss. I personally would be asking how much Napoli want for Osimhen, If they sold him for 70-80 to us they could buy lukaku for 35m and Scott for 25m. I would get Osimhen and send Hojlund on loan to Wolves. I was talking about McTominay. Amrabat is not a massive loss if we don't get him. We need Ugarte though.
It hasn’t been for 7 weeks. They had talks, went away, without closing the door to it, and now have come back, because the business that needed to be done has happened.
McTominay has one 10 goal season, no other double digit season. 177 Premier League matches, 19 goals, 4 assists. Tackle success 54%, pass accuracy 82%. NOT A GOOD PLAYER. Average or bad at everything.
@bikesnipets. Spot on mate. Folks are too sentimental about McTominay,a decent player but not a top four standard to which we aspire. To say he is improving at the age of 27 is a sign of how low a standard we are prepared to accept.
Loan or no loan 51 mil they same they paid for him is crazy , If the player is successful you don't sell them... If they have average or bad season then you can't sell them for the same you paid .. Imagine doing that with say a sofa or something i paid 300 last year used it for the year now i would like 300 for it .. Crazy.. haha
Im really tired of people bringing up Amrabat, he was around for a whole season and he failed so on to the next and better players. That's the stupidity we use to do in the past, we should stop celebrating mediocrity
Im sure Mourihno sed the same thing about KDB... Give the guy a chance, he was played out of position, then had to settle in a midfield that had to cover for mcguire n evans.. Towards the end of the season we got the Amrabat we needed. He was playing CDM.. Loom at our last 4 games...
@@Sekatings He didn't play at left-back in the league after September and only played one cup game in the new year at LB after that. From October to December he played in the majority games, including all 5 CL games after his debut, in midfield and was truly awful. Maguire, whom he played in front of, won PL Player of the Month in this time. Amrabat is easily one of the worst players ever to play for United. That's why he was dropped until the end of the season. A couple of hard running games against tired players at the end of the season do not change anything.
