If you like the elf holy hydration and want to try a really good spf try Naked Fridays cabana gel cream spf it's as a Target. No white cast on my melanin and the price is a little higher but I use it without moisturizer bc it's that good.
Hey!! I haven't actually tried Sugar baby on but it seems like a true light pink that would need a lip liner on dark skin. The elf pink me girl is similar with a warmer undertone that can easily be worn without a lip liner. Hope that helps💕