Uncommon Stories in The Quran: Ya'juj & Ma'juj | Dr. Shabir Ally 

Pleasant presentation. The guest is honest and accurate in his approach and the presenter is sharp and her questions are well prepared.

Well done Jazakhallahukhairan Dr. Shabir. The story of yajuj wa Majuj in Quran contains a lot but you have to find master of Eschatology like Sheikh Imran Hosein

Shabir ali, you are so honest and truthful.i love you so much. You are the kind of scholar I am searching for, please be always just who you are now. You are my only hope.dont change your line of thinking for others

May Almighty Allah protect us

congratulations for 200K subscriber. May Allah keep long live our shaikh.

How many people agree with the view of sheikh Imran Hosein?? I admit it holds strong evidence to me

May Allah guide us to the right path

Separating facts from fiction seems essential for a religion to be credible. Looking into the contexts of the Quran we see that things are placed in a manner which is very rationale but in hadith it is always miraculous and strangely similar to Bible stories. E. g. the quranic attitude is that the prophet (pbuh) is seen as a man chosen because he was of exceptional character. But the hadith perspective is that he was already chosen by God and thus is of exceptional character. The quranic description of Adam is very straight forward and no Eve is even mentioned even but the hadith has the very exact description as portrayed in the Bible, that eve is made from his ribs and he was 60 cubit tall etc.

Alhamdulillah, Dr Shabir Ally you are a voice of reason. May Allah SWT increase you in knowledge. I look forward for you reasoned analysis.

This Dr is intelligent, but he's brushing over the hadiths relating to the gog and magog. If Allah wants to take the common sense out of the gog and magog, that is easy for Allah. These people exist, and if Allah wills, they're location will always be a secret even if it is in plain sight. Allah is capable of doing this.

Imran Hossain has nailed this topic. Listen to him atleast once.

Assalamu alaykum I appreciate your media Jazakallah It is very interesting I always follow you

Possible modern explanations of Yajuj Majuj 1 Hollow earth theory; inside earth or a portion of under 2 Aliens; from any other planet 3 Beyond Antarctic (any undiscovered, underwater continent) 4 Dimension : A barrier may be between us and them, like jins and they might try to invade our dimension 5 An experiment;

Quran had many things that conform it is the word of God (Allah). So we believe whatever Quran said.

This is such a simplistic analysis.

Millions of love for sabbir ali

thanks Dr Ally for your valuable contribution,I would request you to say about preferable commentary and translation of The Holy Quran...thnx

The best sheikh to ask this questions is sheikh imran hosein. Look for him please he will give u details about gog and magog and dajjal.

Alhamdulillah. Jazakallahu khair . May allah reward u in both the world's..

Though I like Dr. Shabir Ally's knowledge and researches on Quran, I have learned much from the mathematical divine cod of Quran that he recently came up with, but there is a slight problem and difference between the West Islamic scholars and east-middle east islamic scholras and their interpretations as well. since the west is more focusing on the outlook of something and based on that the easily explain it by the simple translation, and islamic scholars of east or Aisa are explaining it spiritually, the issue to which one shall I /we believe and from whom shall we/ I learn. anyways good job Dr. Shabir Ally

why he don't debate christian prince?

One thing I was impressed when heard was the fact that some Hadith need to be questioned. We Muslims don't question even a single letter from the Quran because we know and it has been proven to be the Word of Allah. As for the Hadith, some of them were selfishly written and some were not preserved. I was shocked to see a Hadith that said Prophet PBUH tried to kill himself many times if a narration delayed...most especially that the Hadith used Aisha RA as reference. My main interest is about UNDERSTANDING the reality in hadiths. İf not that we need many of them, all should be erase from history...

Everything has to be logical because Alla is logical

Jazakumullah khair well Great presentation

I can’t believe you people are questioning the existence of yajooj and majoog. What is wrong With you people. Authentic Hadith have been narrated by our Nabi SAW. YOUR Deviating people from the Haqq. Why do txts need to be re translated. Allah is Qulli shayin qadeer. Fear Allah and fear your for your deen!!!!

Yakut Majuj are clear to see. Right now they are peaceful. They have built power and will continue as they are getting better by the year. They will come for the final mega wave one last time. Right now they are planting themselves politically economically ...

The iron wall is a metaphor. Why just throw it away and take that literally and yet apply metaphors in other areas?

If i m not wrong there are other place of quran mentioned about gog & magog and the verse is like-and when the dam of gog & magog will open....but dr. Shabir said only two surahs of the quran.

From verses of Quran its clear that yegog and megog are trapped up somewhere because word فتحت implies in it, according to ahadith this matter was also discussed at the time of meraj among prophet ibrahim, moses, chirst and Muhammad PBUH, only christ told the prophet PBUH that on his descent on earth he will kill dajjal and yegog nd megog, Allah knows best about His Plans, but we cant snub ahadith coz if something look very odd this doesnt mean that will be faricated story, Im sure if some miraclius event wouldnt be in Quran , persons like Dr shabir nd Ghamdi would must hav snubbed as fabricated stories, if caves of men could sleep more than 300 years, if a camel of Saleh can come out of a mountain etc then anything could be happened...100 years back how we could beleive that bare footed arabs will compete in skyscrappers but now we can see with our naked eyes they hav built Burj Al Khalifa they are building burj jadda that wil be taller than burj khalifa, how could we know that mountains of black gold will be discoverd in gulf...but now we can see huge reservoires of black crude oil in gulf, so propheses are becoming true and true...nd we are still perplexed....

We tell Alla what he can or can't do

Yeah.. Muslim schoolars need re-evaluate their method of hadith criticization, including dajal, yajuj majuj, al mahdi, etc. They relying only on sanad, but the substansive (matn) it self are often problematics even contradict with the Qur'an.

Thank you , but do we know where are they sealed??

It is now proven that Dhul-Qarnein was actually Shah-an-Shah/king of Kings *Cyrus the great* ( who is also referred to as "the king of 4 corners of the world" ) By following the incredible stories of Dhul-Qarnein in Quran & Bible & the Hadiths, & how greatly Quran describes all the aspects & details of it , *there's almost zero doubts that Dhul-Qarnein was Cyrus the great who is referred to as God's annointed in the Bible* ! Also by following the details of the story, it is narrated that Cyrus built the prison of Yajuj/Gog & Majuj/Magog in a land somewhere in modern day Gogria/Gorgistan ! Interesting note : Dhul-Qarnein can be translated into both *The man of two horns* or *The man of two ages* !!! However we must always acknowledge that *Allah knows best* !

Love you Dr. Shabir.

The Quran Says that stars are used to strike jinn can you please answer this because it's bugging me and gives me doubts I'm sure I'm interpretating it wrong

Search For Sheikh Imran Hosein for this question to be answered

The problem with todays scholars is they want to explain everything literally.. And forget one thing we have limitations, our vision, frequency limit in our hearing proves If Allah is hiding them, we will not be able to see it... Even with all these technology we are not able to predict natuarl calamities... If everything is to be seen and verify with hadees and quraan , what is the point of believe in unseen??

Qarn also means Time , century

More likely for Yajuj&Majuj to be *volcanoes*, and everything else is symbolism/ metaphor or misunderstanding of the people. It will drain the lake and continue till the mountains. It can be that a tectonic plate breaks apart. If so, a plume of hot rock can rise from deep within the Earth's interior, which can cause massive volcanic activity on the surface. It often sound that in hadith interpretation, the lava was mixed with the consequences of it on people. 1) Cause vs effect. And 2) Yajuj &Majuj vs people during the period of time when it happens. Sources to check: ----------------------------------------------------- فَتَحَ اللَّهُ مِنْ رَدْمِ يَأْجُوجَ وَمَأْجُوجَ مِثْلَ هَذَا ". وَعَقَدَ بِيَدِهِ تِسْعِينَ. {Cracking of the tectonic plate} ---------------------------------------------------------------------- إِنَّ السَّاعَةَ لاَ تَكُونُ حَتَّى تَكُونَ عَشْرُ آيَاتٍ خَسْفٌ بِالْمَشْرِقِ وَخَسْفٌ بِالْمَغْرِبِ وَخَسْفٌ فِي جَزِيرَةِ الْعَرَبِ وَالدُّخَانُ وَالدَّجَّالُ وَدَابَّةُ الأَرْضِ وَيَأْجُوجُ وَمَأْجُوجُ وَطُلُوعُ الشَّمْسِ مِنْ مَغْرِبِهَا وَنَارٌ تَخْرُجُ مِنْ قُعْرَةِ عَدَنٍ تَرْحَلُ النَّاسَ (muflihun.com/muslim:2901b) According to me, our prophet has predicted: landslides, smoke, Dajjal-AntiChrist, "beast of the Earth", lava, then the Earth will rotate on the opposite way. Before the last stage we know other ahadith that say prophet Jesus will return and kill Dajjal.

It is us the british people that are majuj yajuj and dont be afraid of us

Quran 21:95 وَ حَرٰمٌ عَلٰى قَرۡيَةٍ اَهۡلَكۡنٰهَاۤ اَنَّهُمۡ لَا يَرۡجِعُوۡنَ‏ -__- Quran 21:96 حَتّٰٓى اِذَا فُتِحَتۡ يَاۡجُوۡجُ وَمَاۡجُوۡجُ وَهُمۡ مِّنۡ كُلِّ حَدَبٍ يَّنۡسِلُوۡنَ‏ -__- Quran 21:97 وَاقۡتَـرَبَ الۡوَعۡدُ الۡحَـقُّ فَاِذَا هِىَ شَاخِصَةٌ اَبۡصَارُ الَّذِيۡنَ كَفَرُوۡا ؕ يٰوَيۡلَنَا قَدۡ كُنَّا فِىۡ غَفۡلَةٍ مِّنۡ هٰذَا بَلۡ كُـنَّا ظٰلِمِيۡنَ‏ -__- If these verses don't prove that god is capable of bringing forth dead humans as some sort of zombie, or to make a race of creature the likes of Gog and Magog.... hmmm.... 🤔

Sorry, Aisha Khaja is not his daughter but Safiyyah Ally is his daughter, my Pardon.

The hadith is an authentic hadith so why does he dismiss the hadith and its narration? Trying to downgrade true hadith to appease to the western is not the right way. We as humans cannot comprehend the power of Allah and if something is beyond our understanding we should accept it as it has been narrated and not try twist it to appease

As per Quran Zulqurnain locked up yajuj and majuj behind an iron Wall sealed with lead. Their population is hundred times more than earth dwellers, they are locked up even to this day so where are they now , why has no one discovered them and the huge wall when Goole has mapped every inch of territory on earth. When we can see human beings why we can't see yajuj and majuj and the huge iron Wall behind which they are sealed?? Could Shabbir Ally clarify???

باسم الله ما شاء الله، أحسنتم

That nonsense uttered by Yasir Qadhi brought me here. And here people are criticizing Dr. Shabir for rejecting hadith... He is not using a new criteria of hadith rejection. its a classic criteria,written in all books of hadith criticism and is accepted by all the fiqhs of sunni islam. If a hadith contradicts common sense, its not dependable" The problem is, this principle is rarely used by sunni scholars..

👍👏well done sabbir

wall located around Kyrgyzstan in my opinion, but Allah knows best.

exactly Dr Shabir Aly is the voice of reason , Alama Ghulam Ahmad Pervez was a similar reasonable intelectual and Scholar in Pakistan ,later who was criticized and teased by typical and orthodox theologians for his reasonable/logical interpretation . While the ignorant so called molvis (theologians) rewarded him with fatwas (degrees) of condemnation of being infidel. Plz refer to Pervez 's book "Islam is a challenge to Religion ". Undoubtedly , Qur'an is miracle of Almighty Allah .

Thanks for sharing...Highly informative ~ Could you also give us your insights on Imam Mahdi (A.S) and the awful Dajjal that will appear in the end of times ? (Cause it seems to be a very controversial topic too). Thanks again ~

Assalamo alikum mashallah it’s lovely Hadith

I like this info but there was missing that what is the mountain where Ajjuj and Majuj are imprisoned Make a new video tell me that Its written in Quran history my aunt told me so I forgot it please tell it. Its my humble request please

we can see the entire world on Google earth and the wall has never been found

So his criteria for accepting or rejecting ahadith is whether they are “difficult to imagine.” So forget about the entire science of Hadith classification and just accept what you think makes sense. Unfortunately so-called “scholars” like him are leading people away from Islam. May Allah forgive him and guide him.

They will come down through wormhole portal .

They are already out

Assalam Alaikoum, i have been trying to understand. in my opinion allah knows best. Doest it ever occured to anyone to think about the mogolian. as history describe them as barbarian tyranic and causing devastation through every land the concurred. just a thought to consider

Why reject hadith... this is not a fair point of view that if you cannot interpretreject the hadith...there are many hadiths on this in almost every major book of ahadeeth. You can say that we do not know how to interpret this hadith. Because these are regarding the signs of qayama. Rasul Allah SAWW may be giving hints and not necessarily giving actual account of gog mgog trying to break wall... Wall may mean a separation of some type. And Allah knows best

Aslam alaikum for those who belong the churches it's time for them to transforms their to Mosques we're hoping that they're weren't late inshallah alhandulilah

Zaynab bint Jahsh  narrated that one day the Prophet  came out in a state of excitement with his face quite red, and he said: “There is no God but Allah. There is a destruction in store for Arabia because of the turmoil which is near at hand as the barrier of Gog and Magog has been opened like it; and he (in order to explain it) made a ring with the help of his thumb and forefinger. I said: “O Allah's Messenger! Would we be destroyed despite the fact that there would be pious people among us? He said: “Yes, when the evil would predominate.” [Al-Bukhaari and Muslim]

A suggestion to the host Ms Aisha Khaja. Instead of she saying "hey youTube", may be. "hey youTubers" or, "Hey RU-vid watchers" would be more suitable?

I think Pashtun Boy's the comment below is right. they are Ashkenaz and Thracians which were originated from Khazar. The people who are controlling the world and proclaiming word "New World Order" are Yajuj and Majuj. And not only that the people who claim that they are Jews are not real Jews they are these Khazarians. These tribes are mixed with other people in the world. So they are everywhere, who supports this New World Order, and who do corruptions and oppression all over the world. If one uses the correct methodology in the Quran and Hadith, it gives information more than what we need. Even though the Yajuj and Majuj are mentioned briefly in the Quran we can extract a mountain of information regarding these tribes.

When the title reads uncommon STORIES and when the host started with the words STORY of Yajuj & Majuj, they inadvertenly accept it for what it is .i.e. a STORY which means something made up. If you refer Yajuj & Majuj as STORY, indirectly indicating Quran is like a story book, i.e. written by somebody using imagination or from other manly sources. So the host or Dr.Ali really feel Yajuj and Majuj are true, they would not have used the word STORY.

Yasir Qadhi: Gog and Magog (Yajuj and Majuj / Islamic End Times)

21 Tips To Help Erase Sins - Prophet Muhammed SAW 1) Repenting 2) Performing Prayer 3) Performing Wudhu (ablution) 4) Attending the Jumu'ah Salah (Friday Prayer) 5) Waiting for Prayer 6) Doing good deeds 7) Performing Umrah and Hajj 8) Saying ‘Ameen’ after the Imam 9) Calling out Adhaan 10) Walking to the Prayer Place 11) Giving charity 12) Asking forgiveness from others on wronging them 13) Reciting Salawaat (Blessings) on Prophet Muhammad (S.A.W.S) 14) Being kind to animals 15) Praising Allah after Eating Food 16) Removing Obstacles from the Road or Way 17) Hide Other’s faults and sins 18) Observing Patience during Hard Times 19) Making some dhikr 20) Saying ‘Subhan-Allah’ 100 times 21) The best duaa for seeking forgiveness is to say : “Allahuma Anta Rabbi, la ilaha illa Anta, khalaqtani wa ana ‘abduka, wa ana ‘ala ‘ahdika wa wa'dika mastata'tu, a'udhu bika min sharri ma sana'tu, abu'u laka bini'matika ‘alayya, wa abu'u laka bidhanbi faghfir li, fa innahu la yaghfirudh-dhunuba illa Anta.” (O Allah! You are my Lord. There is no god except You. You have created, I am Your slave, I hold to Your Covenant as far as I can. I seek refuge in You from the evil of what I have done. I acknowledge the favours that You have bestowed upon me and I confess my sins. Pardon me, for none but You has the power to pardon).

The hadith could be a metaphor

This cleric is so dishonest he will not mention what he really knows that yajuj and majuj is a folklore story before Islam and the Arabs of Muhammad's days laught at the prophet for mentioning those stories.

So unbelievable that in the 21 century we still have people who believed in this ridiculous story.. arevthey not embarrassed? ?

These stories come right out of the Alexander Romances, man-made legends written not long before the Quran and popular in the region. It's interesting that their origin is never mentioned.

Stick to the literal meaning of the Quran and ahadeeth especially in Aqeedah, as understood by the Sahabah and the Ulamah who strictly follow them up to our time. We have some speakers now giving their intelect precedence to the daleel

I am muslim. But I have to challenge something which any logical person will agree to. The hadith is not to be added to the belief structure of a muslim. The data therein is questionable. shaytaan is so clever, he cannot infiltrate the quran so he pushes the hadith agenda that we as average joes accept.

Is it 9 or 99 times more of them?

Sad to see that he too has veered off .

Ezekiel 38 gives a complete narrative of a war against Israel by Gog and Magog and how Gog and Magog will be destroyed by God. The Quranic and Hadith narrative seems illogical.

Why two horns? What does a horn symbolize? Qarn might mean an age too.

Quran never says they will come back. It’s man made stories from bible and hadiths.

I agree with all scholars who have said " ONLY depend on the QURAN".It is the word of GOD. When people start relying on the Hadith for explanations, there is confusion and division . We cannot know for sure whether something in the Hadith is true or not---but we CAN rely on the Quran for the TRUTH.

Plz tell me by z d height of these

Many things were skipped.

You have seen them hundred of time all you need to focus on Quran, bible, world history , chinese history , present situation. And every single prove will point towards one nation. And they are released and human beings and they have almost took over all the word.

I love the host Aisha

This is a very interesting perspective. Is this the view of the schools of thoughts? Or is this a modernist perspective. I am not interested in the salafi perspective

Dr Shabbir needs to listen to Imran Hosein and get up to speed !!

Clearly the origin of them are from North Caucasus.

- من كل 1000 من بني آدم واحد فقط للجنة و 999 الى النار , أما في النار فواحد من البشر مقابل 1000 من يأجوج و مأجوج ....... يعني مقابل كل واحد من بنى آدم في الجنة سيكون هناك 999 ضرب 1000 يساوي 999000 من يأجوج و مأجوج .... يعني أن يأجوج و مأجوج مش من البشر - كلمة قوم وردت في سورة الكهف لوصف الناس عند العين الحمئة و عند مطلع الشمس و الموضع ما دون السدين , أما يأجوج و مأجوج فلم يذكرهم في القرآن أنهم قوم , بل ما ورد انهم كانوا يفسدون في منطقة محدودة فقط تخص القوم ما دون السدين و التي وصفتهم الآيات بأنهم لا يكادون يفقهون قولا , فمن كان لا يكاد يفقه قولا هم القوم ما دون السدين و ليس يأجوج و مأجوج - السد اشرف علي تشييده ذو القرنين شخصيا و وصفت الآيات مكوناته و التي هي من زبر الحديد ( الحديد الخام ) و القطر ( القطران ) , فيكون السد قوي و مستقر بوجود الحديد و غير منفذ للماء بوجود القطران و الذي عندما يستخدم قديما و حتى يومنا هذا لابد أن يفرغ على النار حتى تخف اللزوجة و يتغلغل في الردم . - الاشراف المباشر لذو القرنين يعني ان السد لم يكن كبير الحجم فلو كان ضخم الحجم لتطلب وقت طويل و من غير المنطق هذا..... فلقد ساعدهم ذو القرنين بعلمة و من خلال توجيهاته ( كمهندس) و كان القوم ما دون السدين اقوياء و التي بها تم إنجاز العمل ...... كذلك كانوا اغنياء فلقد عرضوا ان يقدموا خرجا مقابل هذا و لكن ذو القرنين لم يأخذ مقابل و هو في تتبعه للأسباب مر بتلك المنطقة و من غير المنطق ان يمكث هناك طويلا بل على الارجح استغرق تنفيذ السد وقت جد قصير ... ... 5- فعلا تظهر الردم اسهل لذلك وردت كلمة اسطاعوا لوصف هذا و فعلا نقب الردم ( ثقبه ) اصعب لذلك صاحب هذا كلمة استطاعوا ... الردم لم يكن جدار املس عالي و لو كان هذا لوصف عدم القدرة بأستطاعوا كما وصف النقب .... الشيء المحجوز لم يقدر على التظهر رغم سهولة ذلك و لم يقوى على النقب لوجود الحديد و القطران .....في الظروف القاسية يهجر الناس أرضهم و يفروا ما خف حملة و عادة لا يطيق الناس مجاورة المفسدين و لكن لم يهجر القوم ما دون السدين ارضهم فهي ارض خيرات برغم افساد يأجوج و مأجوج و لم يطلبوا لا قتل و لا عقاب ليأجوج و مأجوج فقط وضعوا ثقتهم في سد حماية و التي جعلها ذو القرنين سد حماية من ردم , سدود الحماية عادة تنهار بسبب التظهر أو النقب , لذلك حرص ذو القرنين على ثبات السد و أنه غير منفذ ....... أما يأجوج و مأجوج فالمطلوب الرجوع لقواميس اللغة و معرفة اصل الكلمة و اشتقاقها و ما هو الشيء الذي يفسد و يتم وصفة بأنه كثير الأج و المج على وزن ( يفعول ) ..... و ان سد حماية كفيل بوقفه و لكن مع الزمن يردم , حتى إذا حان الوقت و عندما يخرج في نهاية الزمان سيكون خروجه من فتح و سينسل من الاحداب و يموج البعض في البعض ....... بالمختصر المتأمل في نص الآيات و صحيح الحديث سيجده متوافق تماما مع المنطق و العلم .... و أما السد فهو على الارجح موجود في ارض اليمن المشهورة منذ القدم بالسدود , اشتهر اليمن السعيد بالقوة و الثروة و ايضا لسانهم كان فيه اعجمية و ينطبق عليهم القول بأنهم لا يكادون يفقهون قولا ...... عدن هي فوهة بركان عظيم , يقول العلماء أنه إن انفجر فسيكون البراكين الاخرى و كأنها العاب نارية ..... في صحيح الحديث انه من علامات الساعة ستخرج نار من عدن تسوق الناس لمحشرهم , أما الخبث و الذي ورد في صحيح الحديث و هو مصاحب لخروج يأجوج و مأجوج في حديث " ويلا للعرب من شر قد اقترب ...." فهو الخبث المصاحب للنار الخفيف الوزن و الذي ينتشر لمسافات كبيرة و الذي يصاحب البراكين ( هي نار باللغة العربية ) فيتسبب في هلاك للناس حتى على مسافات بعيدة و بعيدة جدا , و في حال وجود بركان عظيم فسيكون تأثيره على الحياة في الكرة الارضية كلها .... من علامات الساعة و هولها خروج النار و الدخان و لكن من المطمئن أنه سيحمى المولى عز و جل مكة و سيستمر الحج بعد خروج يأجوج و مأجوج و ستعود ارض العرب خضرة و انهار كما كانت في الماضي و سبب هذا التغير السريع هو بفضل ما يخرج مع البراكين من معادن يجعل التربة جد خصبة و هذا ملاحظ في جميع المناطق المجاورة للبراكين , فالبركان يحمل خير و اذى , و رحمة الله اوسع بنا من رحمتنا بأنفسنا اللهم الطف بنا جميعا و نجنا من هول الساعة و علاماتها يا رب

Yajooj from Majooj have been copied from Christians and Jews.

The most terrifying tribes man ever face

Dr Ally interprets the hadith literally, and then applies a human-centric rationality to say that the hadith taken literally are not sufficiently meaningful and hence not authentic. But this methodology used by Dr Ally is problematic. If a hadith is not meaningful from a human-centric point of view (which is the literal interpretation), then we should first see whether it is meaningful from a purely metaphysical point of view. The case of hadith on Ya'juj and Ma'juj, for example, can be meaningfully interpreted in the light of metaphysics, and hence their authenticity should not be doubted.

Do you people find it funny? I think it's hilarious!

How can a non prophet person has mirials...?

A few hundred yrs ago the world was still a mystery in many ways, america had'nt been discovered and people where superstitious, but today planet earth has been explored and mapped if there was an yajuj & majuj people anywhere on earth we would know about them

I m in love😌

We were told to lower our gaze from women and here it is A woman hosting an Islamic video Is it allowed Ask yourslef please And attack me not if I am correct

Dr Shabir, respectfully I regret your view, which is definitely without the Noor to see and understand, with proper methodology. Actually your words pushes listeners to put in deep sleep and wait for that time to come.which is absolutely dangerous!

Shabir Ally's methodology is that whenever he comes across a hadith that is ridiculous and implausible he dismisses it on that grounds as necessarily a false hadith. He never considers the possibility that the hadith is authentic and that it is muhammad who is genuinely saying things which nowadays when we are more rational and have greater understanding of the world seem ridiculous and implausible. Shabir Ally's methodology is biased with the foregone conclusion that muhammad must necessarily be a truthful prophet of God rather than adopting an intellectually honest, unbiased, neutral historical methodology that weighs up whether a hadith reliably reports what muhammad said.

Im thinking today its israel

Можно хоть субтитры на русском!?

I really like Dr Shabir and respect him a lot, but unfortunately I think on this matter his knowledge and understanding is lacking in Hadith, which is kind of apparent in this video. Firstly the claim that Allah revealed this story to prophet Mohammed in order to show that he is not ignorant of what they believe etc. is very problematic and would be much harder to adjust than Gog and Magog story I would say. There is an insistence in Quran to believe in unseen and what has been foretold or prophesied, افلا تؤمن for example, or يؤمنون بالغيب etc. This story is in relation with the signs of day of judgement, which will erect upon people who would have no faith, in opposition to a naturalistic explanation, the spiritual reason is more stressed here. So instead of saying that we are moving towards black hole a Muslim can say that disbelief would bring an end to this world. Now, each and every event mentioned in relation to this is not of the nature that if presented, people would accept it on the face of it, so is the case with Gog and Magog. I would love to write more about what I learned about this topic, but I know that most probably no one would read this, so I am trying to write the important bit. Look at the event from two aspects, future and the people who were facing Gog and Magog. Later is a super natural phenomenon that there is such a large community which is hidden from us humans, but the earlier is not. That there was a time, when human were aware of them, and they complained about them to Zulqarnain, and Allah by his grace gave him the power to overcome them. All the western scholars or scholars who live or and are influenced by materialism always discuss the future never you would see that they discuss that once they existed. And I say this without meaning any disrespect to Dr Shabir and all of the other scholars or famous Muslims or Muslims with large followings. Now again, coming back to the point that what would happen in the future, only people who would encounter it would know, from now we can just speculate. However about the past, we can look into and inquire. There are many scholars who write and speculate about who Zulqarnain was, and why they believe that the person was him. These Gog and Magog were not a community or a large group at that time, and may be they are still not. But they will grow in such multitude that they would outnumber humans in many folds, and that environment would be provided to them by Allah, they will drink all the water of the world and they would spread bloodshed and would not be defeated, neither they were before. And finally they would die because Jesus A.S. would curse them. Which Hadith or verse of Quran says that they are in such large numbers as of now? I hope that you try to reflect upon what I want to say, I am not a scholar or writer, I just want to share my thoughts on the topic, please ask if there is any question. Respectfully if Dr Shabir would give me an opportunity I would love to explain it further to him, which may benefit many Muslims and non Muslims alike, InshaAllah and Allah knows the best.

To understand this subject you need to have history and anthropology in you're holster. Also joining some dots but ultimately Allah knows best. Now here is my opinion. If you want it message me.

🔥🔥🔥🔥♥️♥️♥️💯💯💯