Guest jo bhi kehna chah rahe they adha adhura chhor rahe they.... Jinnah ko jaldi thi kyoki unhe TB tha aur wey jantey they ki his days are numbered...... Hyderabad me public hindu thi ruler muslim tha aur wey ultimately Pakistan chale bhi gaye..... Public par rezakaro ka attack na hota to shayad india capture na karta Hyderabad......same is true with kashmir too....public muslim ruler hindu...harisingh ne koi access ke liye sign nahi kiya preferred to stay independent....yeha bhi rezakaro ka attack hua jisse darkar unhone indian union me join karna lazmi samjha....indian army gayi.,.pichhe dhakela bhi par UNO e ceasefire se status quo ho gaya...pok reh gaya.... ....
LOL are you kidding me ? His explanation of Hinduism and Vedas and "caste" was ludicrous. 😂😂😂 Its exactly what one would expect from an ignorant muslim fanatic.
The gentleman is sharing his story. Let us give him his due. Sitting in 2024 it is easy to judge people on both sides. Let us not do that. There is more to both the countries than the hatred and divide that has been created. Let us dwell on areas we can build on amity
Being a senior citizen I want to inform both to guest and anchor that all four Vedas were revealed to Aryan Rishis here in Bharat ( Hindustan) , oldest Scripture The Rigveda was composed in the holy land Punjab ( Panchal ancient name , Panchnad a place in Pakistan you are aware of) . Rigveda contains names of all the rivers flowing in undivided Punjab, so to say that Vedas brought here is far from truth they were revealed here in the holy land called Aryavrat / Bharat Varash / Hindustan. Now it is proven history ( Scientifically) that Arya invasion/ migration theory is all western creation. Overall I find this conversation interesting and fair , guest has used Parliamentary language and I respect that .
Its wrong theory paddled by RSS and BJP alongwith other pseudoscience that its only invaders were Muslims and not them. All DNA evidence proves Brahmans cam from Central Asia
My grand father dada ji studied at Nanakana Sahib gurudwara. He wanted to visit Pakistan but unable to visit back. I have his picture in shakupura market. Want to visit myself one day. Gore were smart to create a divide in hearts and taught current rulers divide and rule
@@hiteshpatel2437 hahaha kya cheez ho tum harcheez pakistan wasay tum punjab ko kahtay ho occupied kiya howa hai kpk bolochistan lagay rehtay ho ab shakal dekhi hai apni punjab sy hi pakistan shuro hota hai P nikal hum yaha rehtay hai beta
پاکستان جب بنا پیسے نہیں تھے نواب آف بہاولپور نے بجٹ اور اخراجات کے لئے پیسے دیے۔اپنی گاڑیاں donate کیں archives میں ریکارڈ موجود ھے۔قائداعظم میٹنگ کے دوران اپنی چاے کے پیسے خود ادا کرتے تھے۔ایسے وقت جشن اور ساحل پر acquaruom کی باتیں گھٹیا الزامات ھیں شرم آنی چاہیے
JINNAH was an excellent lawyer when he started loosing his argument of MUSLIMS IN DANGER he swiftly changed IT to ISLAM IN DANGER AS A GOOD LAWYER WOULD DO he was neither a STATESMAN NOR A GOOD LEADER OR POLITICIAN, he wanted to achieve Pakistan by hook or crook, and he achieved it ,blood of lacs of PUNJABI HINDUS & Sikhs , Punjabi Mussalmans is on his hands
Did Jinnah killed thousands of innocent indian Muslim in Babri mosque issue, Gujarat 200 riots, Dehli riots and many other countless roits in India. It's nature of Hindu nature that's why Jinnah demanded a country
Means ye b hindu ki hi paidaish h jinna, iske dada/ pitaji krachi me muslim k bich me fish ka business suru kiya tha, iske grwale is business ko oppose kr rhe the, so is business k liye hi muslim convert ho gya jha ye business badiya chl gya, ye b h sayad khi pda tha maine, May b it's also reality
Incidently i got connected with this Video. I am truly Impressed with the way this gentleman has explained. Speaks without biases and prejudices. His clarity and expression are amazing.
M really so happy to see such a logical,sensible and enlightened discussion by these muslim brothers from Pakistan....really appreciate this❤.....citizens from both sides need to speak their mind atleast on online platforms like this on various issues concerning both sides.
Know your history: "Allama Mashriqi’s Order: 300,000 Khaksar Soldiers Reach Delhi and the Sudden Collapse of British Rule" by scholar Nasim Yousaf ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-F5kE4AlRsi4.html
@@ViewsNewsChannelNobody in India is taught the fact that the Caliph of Turkey had sent in 300,000 Islamic soldiers who took over Delhi on August 12, 1947..
@@2413sharefree ok thanks bro. Everyone has free will and you too have but I am happy that you don't want to have bad terms evenly. Thanks again. By the way, can I know your province please if you don't mind answering?
आपकी इस बात में मेरे दिल में आपके लिए इज्जत पैदा कर दी कि हमने अपने बच्चों को यह नहीं बताया की कुर्बानियां हमने दी है बल्कि यह बताया की कुर्बानियां मैंने दी है और जब मैं का प्रयोग होता है तो वह व्यक्तिगत हो जाता है और हम एकता का प्रतीक है
@@shabirahmed5980 GHANTA PADH JAAKE KOI PROPERTY NHI MILI SAARI PROPERTY WAQF NE CLAIM KRI THI INDIAN MUSLIMS JO PAK GYE UNKO HINDUS SIKHS KI PROPERTY MILI THI
@@VinayDutta-kw5yj oh you masiha of secularism jaake padh pehle A 2023 research conducted by Karachi University found that 9% of muhajirs were upper-class, while 17% were upper-middle class, 52% middle class, 13% lower middle and 9% lower class.[179] A 2019 study by Jinnah Postgraduate Medical Center found that Muhajir women have the highest employment rate and monthly income among all major ethnic groups of Pakistan.[180] And according to the 1951 census of Pakistan, less than 15 per cent of Muhajirs were unskilled labourers, with almost 61 percent classified as skilled workers and more than 5 percent belonging to professional and managerial backgrounds.[181] By settlements, 68.4% Muhajirs lived in planned areas and 88.9% have access to basic utilities.[182] They have been very successful in finance institutions, and have founded most of Pakistan's banking institutions including State Bank of Pakistan,[183] Habib Bank Limited,[184] United Bank Limited,[185] and Bank AL Habib.[186]
Very impartial analysis. Gandhi nehru has vision for India after independence. But jinnah and liyaqt has no clear-cut roadmap for Pakistan. Rightly said lot of political class of Pakistan fought among themselves for landed properties left by Hindus. Famous fight was between mamdot and tiwana family. Love from India but rootes in ICCHRA LAHORE. ❤
You can google it. During the struggle for India's independence 4771 were hanged, killed or sentenced to life imprisonment by the British 3728 of them were Sikhs. Sikh's percentage of India's total population was only 1.2%. Balwala Sahib g I like you very much. God bless you.
Tried verifying the fact but found no source for your claim In fact in 1857 around 8 lakh Indians were killed and Punjab didn't participate in 1857 war with British instead actually supported british along with western Rajputana states And thereby got huge favours in declaring all the friendly forces as martials races by British Maximum killings were of hindus and Muslims Strange claim
Oh please. Hitler and 2nd world war are the reason that British had to leave. Hitler broke British and queen was having problems managing vast India. It was then put on sale in 1945. America was an expected buyer but it backed out of bids at the last moment. Then Britisn asked Nehru and Jinnah to come up with a plan and this is how India and Pakistani came into being. The only true freedom fighter India has ever produced was none other than Tipu Sultan. The rest were on British payroll and grew up under British given English schools, freedom, radio, newspaper, parliament legal frame etc. These so called Indian freedom fighters like Gandhi, Jinnha, Patel, Nehru etc were aware of what was going on in England after 1st and 2nd world war. So they started protests for freedom under the British given freedom of protest.
@sabrinakhan8217 tipu sultan 😂vo jihadi Tha jo Islamic state banake baitha tha uspe koi thukta nhi hai Bharat me India Pakistan k madrsa musalmano k alawa aur tum pakka pakistani madarsachap hoge jisko history ka kuch nahi pata hai subhash chandra bose sabse bada leader aur freedom fighter tha jisne Hitler aur Japanese prime minister se alliance banaya tha Britishers ke khilaf 45 hazar azad hind fouz k sath google karle bewakuf pakistanio ka history madarsa ideology k mutabik two nation theory k mutabik banaya gaya hai 😅
@@sabrinakhan8217 The reasons for colonial forces' withdrawal from Indo-pak fall into 2 categories, i.e. global and local. World war is the global reason, whereas the navy's mutiny is one of the local reasons.
Very well covered. More space should have been given to the analytical part of the discussion. Time has come that we Pakistani and indians should be more and more impartial!!
محترم ذیشان بھائی آپ نے جو بھی گفتگو کی ہیں 100 فصد درست فرمائ ہیں ہم کو سازشوں کے ذریعے سے تقسیم اور لڑایا گیا جن خاندانوں پر ظلم ہوا اس میں انڈیا اور پاکستان کے لوگ ان کی آنکھوں سے آنسو اب بھی جاری ہیں گجرات پاکستان ❤❤❤❤❤
Muslim population as per 1941 census in Ludhiana, Amritsar, Jalandhar, kapurtthala , ferozpur was 50 to 70 %, And they were big landlords here Infact the first prime Minister of Pakistan nawab liyaqat Ali Khan was the nawab of karnal and muzaffarnagar of india. Partition gave a big blow to indian muslims
complete mass migration only happened in Pakistan.. the whole Muhammad Ali Jinnah's 11 August Speech was done so that India dont send across all the Muslim in Pakistan because they coudnt financially handle it.. so only 2/3 of the Muslim migarated in India.. while itself made sure that all of Pakistan is rid of it non Muslim... Thats why The Muslim population in India has gone up from 30m in 1947 to 210m in 2022, ie 7 times and essentially the second or third largest Muslim nation..
there were 2,373,466 Hindu and 1,520,112 Sikh constituting about 22.5% of Pakistani Punjab population in 1941.. reduced to 33,052 Hindu and zero Sikh.. in 1951. That's a 99.15% reduction in population. And please mind you we are only talking about the Pakistani Punjab .. 249,716 Hindu and 5,649 Sikh in Pakistani Punjab still a reduction of 95% of 1941 number in 2023.. comprising of 0.204% of the state population
I'm from London 🇬🇧 लेडी एडविना की जो बेटी थी उन्होंने अपनी बियोग्राफी में लिखा है की नेहरू के साथ उनकी मां के संबंध बहुत घनिष्ठ थे उनके बीच प्यार था जिसका सबूत वो खुद थी उनके पास नेहरू और एडविना के वो पत्र भी थे जिसमे खुलकर प्यार का इजहार किया था बाद में मोंटबेटन को जब पता चला तो उसने वो पत्र जला दिये थे.
अब पानी सर से ऊपर बह गया है ,अब केवल एक कम हो सकता है,दोनों देश प्यार से रहें ,तरक़्क़ी करें,एक दूसरे का ईमानदारी से सहयोग करें,सहयोग होगा एतबार करना,जो पाकिस्तान खो चुका है,पाकिस्तान को ही अब कोशिश करनी चाहिये।
Some Sikhs who come from Pakistan to India by killings their young girls in Pakistan by their own hands ,few of them settled in our locality Hoshiarpur Panjab
Hinduism had been present since 1500 BC. The main occupants of the subcontinent in ancient times before the advent of Mughals/Aryans/British were the Dravidians who worshiped nature/sun/planets and the entire cosmos. Their beliefs coexisted with scientific theories. An ancient old renowned Tamil lady poet, Avvaiyar, whose poetic verses contained content relating to atomic physics.
Very good analysis. I cent percent agree with him separate electoral shall not ve happend in those days. I always wish if pakistan and bangladesh will not divided then we indian stringest country in the world...
Edwina: “TAKE A woman with knockout looks, serious money, a handsome husband of royal lineage, amusing lovers, yachts, palaces, jewels, furs, killer outfits and cozy friendships with kings. Add feverish dissipation in youth, and respected work in later life. Top it off with a stint as the last vicereine of India and a passionate 12-year correspondence with Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru, that country's first prime minister after its independence. Set it all against the grandest houses in England during the first 60 years of this century and bingo: You have Lady Edwina Ashley Mountbatten.
Mahatma Gandhi and Nehru were no ordinary people highly educated, polished, humane and impartial. Nehru a pure Aryan Kashmiri Brahman (Pandit that is Butt) was extremely good-looking and Edwina (Edwina was pretty had some Semitic blood as well) when she saw him for the first time fainted. This is well documented. Her daughter (Lady Pamela Carmen Louise Hicks) also the family members of Nehru mention that their relationship was spiritual and not sexual. Nehru being impotent is surely very carefully planted disinformation. A howler of the century. Edwina surely loved Nehru dearly. Before Edwina married Mountbatten she was a known siren. Baalwala is a nice person but certainly not a historian. This is the typical U-tube history meant for the consumption of lay people. Nehru, Patel, Sardar Pratap Singh Kairon, etc. were like brothers. Had excellent teamwork. Moreover often Race and Religion can not be mixed. Islam is a Semitic-religion and Iran follows mostly Semitic-Islam but refer to an Iranian as a Semite (Yehudi-Arab, children of Abraham) and note the reaction. Iranians belong to the Aryan Race and most follow Semitic-Islam. Some Iranians did not convert to Semitic-Islam and continued to follow Aryan-Zoroastrianism. However by Race most Iranians whether Muslim or Zoroastrian are the same people that is Aryans. It is the same in the Indian subcontinent. Before Semitic-Islam arrived here most were Hindus or Buddhists. Thus Pakistanis are surely not Semites that is Arabs in this case but mostly of Aryan racial stock since they converted from Aryan Hindus. A Muslim can be of different races such as Aryan, Turk, Semitic, Negroid, Mongol, etc. thus not same people but followers of same religion. As simple as that.
She is absolutely right about manifesting and law of attraction. I believe same thing. You should try for things you want in life and pray for them but results. You should leave it to God. Sometimes he gives you what you want and sometimes blesses you with way more than that. And even if you don’t get what you want he is saving you from disasters. And sometimes just to remind you that you are not the master of your life. He is. Subhan Allah.
Pakistan became independent a day earlier as Jinnah wanted to get independence from British India with British Viceroy as its titular head. He is on record stating that he has no confidence in Congress Government giving independence after becoming free.
Plz convey this comment to mr. Baalwala...I'm shocked when he mentioned brahmanism , very detailed knowledge...One more thing godse didn't killed gandhi for 55 crore, its having very deep history based on brahman ideology...for this you should read Ashok kumar pandey books...
Know your history: "Allama Mashriqi’s Order: 300,000 Khaksar Soldiers Reach Delhi and the Sudden Collapse of British Rule" by scholar Nasim Yousaf ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-F5kE4AlRsi4.html
Watched your episode on ajit sarkar it's great . My father visit his house in icchra Lahore. There is baraat ghar made by my forefathers in icchra still exists.
Sirs, a major fear of indian muslim community including the muslim stalwarts like Sir Syed,Allama Iqbal, and Mr. Jinnah was the numbers asymmetry between hindus and indian muslims. A basic difference between the 2 was the origins of identity and civilization. Hindus' origin in india. Muslims' origin in Arabia. There was also the question of conversion to islam by choice or coercion which also had 2 narratives. Hindu view: By and large indian muslims are hindu converts. Muslim view: They never addressed this issue in any manner except remaining silent. And this is a very difficult issue as conversions started in 712 AD and continue till date over a long period of 1300 years.
Manto knew Very well that he won't be very famous amongst the other great writers in India ( which included many muslim lyricist also). By the way, hindi film industry till 1970 was dominated by muslims because in hindu religion acting or association with films was frowned upon( but surprisingly not in theatre)
Dear Mr Balwala I admire your logical,honest and fair views. You did not hype anything like an usual indian personality. A very good host. Very quite peaceful background. Best wishes from India. ❤
Know your history: "Allama Mashriqi’s Order: 300,000 Khaksar Soldiers Reach Delhi and the Sudden Collapse of British Rule" by scholar Nasim Yousaf ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-F5kE4AlRsi4.html
very objective discussion. love and respect feom across the border and pls read about someone called Brigadier Usman and his role in kashmir war of 1947-48. he is buried new delhi's lal quila
Zeeshan Bhai, 14th August was put on after a couple of years after 1947, just to be different. In the first year/ two years, it was celebrated on 15th August.
