Sometimes I think that who in this world would have thought we have people like Shri V N Prabhakar who might go unrecognised by us common people if not for platform like yours …Thankyou so much Shri V N Prabhakar for taking out time from your schedule and giving us the insights we all deserve ….I have become your fan and you should also do more episodes on this podcast …your podcast is the best thing I saw on internet in a while
Thank you so much Prabhakar Ji for taking us back to our ancestors and the lives they lived. The Ming boggling details and peerless storytelling makes this podcast one of the bests on YT. Thanks a ton! JK Super Podcast for this wonderful interview. 🙏🏼
Oh wow!! Aaj maloom pada about ASI. Awesome!! Kitna patience chahiye!! Indians hamesha se superb engineers, architects and traders the. Very very informative and interesting Thank you so much JK Cement and AdQuarters India. Wonderful and unique content.
Wow..great.. What an informative one.. Explained everything in very simple way..Dr.Prabhakar is the stalwart in Indian Archaeology.. and working well in various fields of Indian Archaeology.. Congratulations to both of you...👍 Expecting more in future as well
Amazing talk sir....and coming from Southern part of India, your hindi is simply awesome as we Northern part of India people dont ever try to learn Telgu, Tamil, Kannad but we will comment on your educational background...pathetic😢. You are doing wonderful job sir, keep doing. As you always say in classroom its not about name of civilization, what we learn from them is most important. Naam gum jaayega, chehra ye badal jayega but what is eternal will be always eternal, the way Harappans integrated such a larger geographical area is simply amazing without any imperialistic approach thats simply awesome. Kudos to you sirji🎉
Oh! Iske pehle nahi suna hu harappa ke baareme Ancient civilization ke andar itna kuch hai wah! I am impressed JKCements podcast looking f forward to next episode
I would like to know about kalp vigrah. Is there any relevance in the information that we find in the internet. Please do ask the guest speaker so that we can get a clear picture.
Like you guys made series on and of indian railways and its affiliated companies. Sir please bring more content on Indian infrastructure and growing sector or department of indian companies as well as private companies. This will help us to gain deep knowledge regarding to indian growth in infrastructure as well as indian companies and private companies.
DR GUPTA has discovered ancient DATTATREYA TRADITION at DHOLAVIRA. DATTATREYA HILL at DHOLAVIRA. DATTA-TREYA MODERN TEMPLE at DHOLAVIRA. DATTA-TREYA PANDIT at Dholavira. Dattatreya & ancient CHANDI MATA tradition at Dholavira. Dholavira Board writings depicting Datta-trya tradition.
Such an opportunity to learn from this eminent person. Unfortunately moderator stops his flow of information, Interrupts and asks a not so important question, and the flow is lost
Nahi mila ,,,tamilnadu mein kam jari hai ,,,dna same mila haryana se tamilnadu tak,, uttarpradesh west. " sinouli " hathiyar warrier rath wheel copper pot women warrier mila ,,, two horse wala rath hai ,,spoke mila ,,, sinouli super site hai ,,, bhartiyata sabhyata ko padhne ke liye ,,Assam mein kam jari hai
वह इसलिए क्योंकि इनकी कार्बन डेटिंग से पता चलता है कि यह छः,आठ,सौ साल से पुराने नहीं हैं। जबकि मैसोपोटामिया की मिट्टी की पट्टीकाएं मिस्र के पपायरस के स्क्रोल और ग्रीको रोमन पाषाण लेख हजारों वर्ष पूर्व तक ले जाते हैं।
Greek historians came to India with proper dates and geographical locations mentioned. Vedas on the other hand, is missing dates, proper geographical locations.
@@democracy123 You are wrong Vedas have proper location and dates but they accept only those civilizations which are related to them.. How much archeological excavations have happened in Bharat till date?? Go check you will get to know.. How western historians have refused to accept our archeological evidences. We shouldn't forget most of excavation work happened during colonial period where most of the historians were missionaries. What you expect from them? When their only purpose was to convert Bhartiyas. They never accepted evidences locations given by then Bhartiya historians. Even after independence Nehru appointed leftist historians who had same intentions. They don't accept Sindhu Saraswati civilization where all scientific evidences are available. They created false Aryan dravinian invasion theory which proved wrong by archeological evidences. Even then many western and some leftist Indian historians are still propagating same theory Now they made it with little change Aryan migration theory.. So first read Indian historians like Dharam Pal ji, Sita Ram Goyal, Radha Kumud Mukherjee, Yadunath Sarkar n others.. Then make your impression.
@@kunwaravinashsingh Kash western and leftist historians ke bajaye kuch Bhartiya historians ko bhi padh liya hota.. Foreign countries ki chaka chaundh me jo apni virasat ko bhool jate hain ya use accept nhi karte hain aise unfortunate logo ko Koi kya kahe.. That's why it's very important to know own history.. Feeling pity on such people.
Indus Valley civilisation had more connections with Middle East Persian and Near Eastern civilisations than Endia of today. There is no word called Hindu written or mentioned in Bhagavad Gita or other religious texts and neither its Sanskrit word ,Hind Hindi Hindu Hindustan names were given by Arab Mughal Persian and Turk Islamic Conquerors, India name given by British Empire
@@DoloMalo-mw4zl India name was known well before the British Empire. Originally in ancient times Indus was called Sindhu nadi (in sanskrit), and it was in times BCE. The sound "s" was changed in "h" in old Iranian/old Persian language so for Persians during Achaemenid empire the river was called "Hindu". That is why for old Persians (and we are talking here of the periode long time before islam appeared) Hindustan = region behind the Hindu river. Persians were trading a lot with ancient Greeks and in Greek the sound "h" is not pronounced, the name of the river became known in Greek culture as Indos and then by Romans as Indus. In around 300 BCE a Greek explorer and diplomat Megasthenes travelled to India during Mauryan empire and wrote a book or kind of account of what he observed (history, economy, society, habits) named "Indica". India name was then known in Europe from ancient times and it was just a linguistic variation from the original sanskrit word "Sindhu".
What about Ramayan & Mahabharat? When do the ASI place these 2 historical wars in our history? Are they before Harappa? Contemporary to Harappa? Or After Harappa? And what about Vedas? I don't agree with the proposition that Harappan civilization went back to rural settlements from cities. They might have travelled East & built cities in Gangetic planes.
Why is "Saraswati" River Praised so greatly in "Rigveda" if Rigveda is believed to be from 1200-1500 BCE? It is scientifically proven that "Satluj" has stopped feeding "Saraswati at least 8000 years ago. which left this river just a seasonal river. and when the maansoon (season) which was feeding this river got diminished then civilization started collapsing, like Harappa collapsed at the last. Now this is also proven that Harappa was collapsed at least before 2000 BCE. The seasonal river flowing over the dried "Saraswati" is known as "Ghaggar-Hakra". and was left with very less water from some random mansoon, without any proper water source. This is the situation of this river in so called "Rigvedic period of 1200-1500BCE. So why would anyone praise for such a small river? when already Gigantic rivers were available like "Ganga" and Yamuna" (These rivers are also praised in Rigveda. but Saraswati is like this- 1- अम्बितमे नदीतमे देवितमे सरस्वति (This means River Saraswati is greatest in Mother, River and Goddesses) 2- इ॒यं शुष्मे॑भिर्बिस॒खा इ॑वारुज॒त्सानु॑ गिरी॒णां त॑वि॒षेभि॑रू॒र्मिभि॑: । पा॒रा॒व॒त॒घ्नीमव॑से सुवृ॒क्तिभि॒: सर॑स्वती॒मा वि॑वासेम धी॒तिभि॑: ॥ “With impetuous and mighty waves, she breaks down the precipices of the mountains, like a digger for the lotus fibers; we adore for our protection, the praises and with sacred rites, Sarasvati the underminer of both her banks.” Read the words used for this river in "Rigveda". Who will believe that this is for a river which is just a very small seasonal river. The fact is. Rigveda is way older than people think. "Saraswati" river was in this stage only before 8000 years ago, when it was directly connected with "Satluj" and before that it was also connected with even "Yamuna". Entire Paleochannel of this river still exist, which shows the complete route of Saraswati, from Himalaya to all the way till See in Gujrat coast.
Harappa sabse pahle mila iska matlab ye nhi ki use harappan civil kaha jaye.. Ise Saraswati Sindhu hi kaha jana chahiye varna jo Saraswati nadi ke aas pas ki sabhyata ko fir harappan civilization kyu kah sakte hain ?
Industrial society advance nhi hai marketing society advance hota hai? Fir to Germany UK US se Bharat advance hua? Spast hai ki saraswati sindh civilization sayad democracy raha hoga jabki Mesopotamia Egyptian civilizations autocratic raha hoga..
Mr. Rajan ko Greek Roman scriptures to real history dikhte hai magar Vedic scriptures history ka part nhi lagte? Ye sara scripture jisme Bharat ki history science sab kuch vidhman hai agar history ka part nhi hai to kya hawa se a gaye the? Prabhakar ji Madras se study karke aye hain to unhe Bhartiya civilization ko Saraswati-Sindhu manne me problem hai jabki kafi sare senior scientists use Saraswati Sindhu sabhyata hi mante hain. Par Madras me Christians ke asar ki vajah se waha ke adhikansh archaeologist sare archeological evidence hone ke bawjood saraswati sabhyata ko nakarte hain.
😂😂😂...sir explain Kar rahe hai, I guess aap ne suna nahi ki Gujarat me 100 se jayda sites hai Harappan ke jisme Dholavira ek major site hai, Gujarat me na sindhu river hai naa saraswati river hai, to Gujarat ko kahan rakhenge Sindhu-Saraswati Sabhyata me?? Anyways kuch to log kahenge logo ka kaam hai kehna.😅
@@archaeologycafe1308 not talking about saraswati sindhu civilization.. You listen carefully I was mentioning about Vedas.. Listen what they were commenting.
Please read your comment above, where you are raising concern about sir's educational background and his probable mindset. Don't take it personally but you should be careful before commenting on someone's contribution in field.
Why is "Saraswati" River Praised so greatly in "Rigveda" if Rigveda is believed to be from 1200-1500 BCE? It is scientifically proven that "Satluj" has stopped feeding "Saraswati at least 8000 years ago. which left this river just a seasonal river. and when the maansoon (season) which was feeding this river got diminished then civilization started collapsing, like Harappa collapsed at the last. Now this is also proven that Harappa was collapsed at least before 2000 BCE. The seasonal river flowing over the dried "Saraswati" is known as "Ghaggar-Hakra". and was left with very less water from some random mansoon, without any proper water source. This is the situation of this river in so called "Rigvedic period of 1200-1500BCE. So why would anyone praise for such a small river? when already Gigantic rivers were available like "Ganga" and Yamuna" (These rivers are also praised in Rigveda. but Saraswati is like this- 1- अम्बितमे नदीतमे देवितमे सरस्वति (This means River Saraswati is greatest in Mother, River and Goddesses) 2- इ॒यं शुष्मे॑भिर्बिस॒खा इ॑वारुज॒त्सानु॑ गिरी॒णां त॑वि॒षेभि॑रू॒र्मिभि॑: । पा॒रा॒व॒त॒घ्नीमव॑से सुवृ॒क्तिभि॒: सर॑स्वती॒मा वि॑वासेम धी॒तिभि॑: ॥ “With impetuous and mighty waves, she breaks down the precipices of the mountains, like a digger for the lotus fibers; we adore for our protection, the praises and with sacred rites, Sarasvati the underminer of both her banks.” Read the words used for this river in "Rigveda". Who will believe that this is for a river which is just a very small seasonal river. The fact is. Rigveda is way older than people think. "Saraswati" river was in this stage only before 8000 years ago, when it was directly connected with "Satluj" and before that it was also connected with even "Yamuna". Entire Paleochannel of this river still exist, which shows the complete route of Saraswati, from Himalaya to all the way till See in Gujrat coast.
@@ScienceBehindSayings great question indeed! But we also need to understand the form of Rigveda we are getting was complied much later as we know Vedas belongs to Shruti Parampara (following guru-shishya parampara), Mandal 4 to 6 of Rigveda is considered as oldest one. Rest of the mandals were added later period but the memory was there, people had witnessed the mighty flow of river Saraswati. What is interesting here the sanskrit meaning of word Saraswati is "knowing oneself". One most important aspect about limitation of archaeology and literature is archaeology deals with past material culture which we get in bits and pieces but literature is vast ocean of knowledge which is coming down to us in the form of written form generation after generation. So I feel it is also important to keep in mind about the limitation of two disciplines, it's not vice-versa but interestingly Rigveda talks about the same Geographical region where we are getting the remains of Harappan Civilization. 😊
Naa inko budget deti hai government na koi significant task ye log karte hai ! Naa Dwarka, mathura,,Ram Setu, kuch bhi significant task inn logo ne kiya last 75 yrs se! Khali "Shree Ram Mandir exploration ke alawaa!!! Baas moti salary uthaao 10/15 historical sites pe 10 /15 saal se jugaad strecture khada karo aur marramat karte raho decades Tak! Kyaa raaj hai bhaisaab ??? Moti commission milti khai kya kaam ko lambaa kheechnee me !??? Common man like ? Yee marammat kahai khatam hi nahi hoti bee ??? Saahab ! kuch Dwarka mathura,Ram Setu, indreprest, Mahabharat sites , sarasvati Nadi pe concrete khoj ke laao jo duniya maane !!! Other countries me bhi khojo international magazine me khoj publish karo, seminar rako ! Patta to chale Akhand Bharat kaha tak thaa ! Tum log bass mughlo ki biryani khaa ke Delhi me mast aaish karo !!! Sorry personal mat lo bhai ! Par Desk ke liye feelings ko samjho aur kuch achivement doo !!!
He doesn't want to name anything as Hindu related yeh legtist librandu he is very particular doesn't want to give any credit to hindu civilization 😮😮😮😮
