Glad to hear you mention you might get compliments from others on Unwind even if you "like it but don't love it." I have had the very same experience! It does smell better on me (anyway) after I've worn it for 15 minutes or so.
My favorite from the Tumi line is Atlas. I live in FL and with the weather, I just get the most use out of that one. The red one has Sauvage vibes and 19 degrees has Aventus vibes. Neither needed in my collection. Great review. I'll keep my eyes out for this one at Burlington's near me 👍