I just wanted to clarify two questions which I believe the answers I provided were not precise: 1) In the Ḥanafī school, if a person has already made intention to fast in Ramadhan whilst being local and thus have started their fast. Subsequently, if they travel the necessary distance which makes them a traveller, they are not allowed to break their fast. However, if they do break their fast they will only make up the fast they have broken without giving a penalty albeit they will be sinful for violating the fast. 2) In relation to setting off before a certain time to count as a traveller in Ramadan: the ruling is that if a person is a Muqīm (local resident) at the time of Ṣubḥ Ṣādiq (true dawn), they must fast. The fact that they are going to be travelling later on does not allow them not to fast. And Allāh knows best.
Molvi Sahib here is a response to your video on kitab ar ruh. To say your level of scholarship and knowledge is abysmal and muqalidesque is an understatement. If you are able to respond do so ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-xE_Y-0Vd9eo.html&si=EnSIkaIECMiOmarE
Assalamu alaikum from Uzbekistan, brother ustad Yasir. Hopefully, you will become one of the most notable English speaking Sheikhs of our era. May Allah bless you in your chosen path and make you among those who will be neighbors of our Prophet Muhammad (S.A.W.) in Jannat ul-Firdaus.
@@asifahmad4748 Do you learn the history or share incompetent videos? You must be one of these three: Ignorant, troll or uneducated (in islam) and unknowingly working for Zionists (doing what they want to destroy islam from its root, which khawarijs have been doing). Whoever you might be, may Allah guide you to the straight path. All I say to you is: "Read, read and read".
Masha-Allah, lovely to see comments praising the wonderful manners of Shaykh Yāsir. A truly knowledgeable Shaykh who I learnt a lot from. May Allah grant him ʿāfiyah in this life and the next.
I love how Shaykh Yasir has evolved over the years. He used to be feisty, and now he seems to be the calmest person around. It's always a pleasure listening to him. I'd request you shaykh (hope you are seeing my comment) to upload more videos on your channel teaching about Islam and do a playlist on how to practice tazkiyat al-nafs and the sunnah methodology of tasawwuf. Love from Bangladesh!
@@muhammadprarie8819 Not at all; he's much more respectful and accommodating than before. And don't be arrogant by claiming all other sect deviants apart from yours.
@@muhammadprarie8819 I'm sure he feels the same about those deviant groups but I believe the reason he has calmed down is because being fiesty in the current climate are counter productive.
Guys, what humbleness this shaykh has is pure class. If you know him, he is a REAL SHAYKH. not a advanced student, I’m sure he wanted his introduction himself to be this way. It’s plain beautiful how a auch established Shaykh and Mawlana of Islam shows himself, then who are we?? Who?
He’s a sheikh 😅😅 𝟰𝟬 𝗱𝗶𝘀𝗴𝘂𝘀𝘁𝗶𝗻𝗴 𝗯𝗲𝗹𝗶𝗲𝗳𝘀 𝗼𝗳 𝘁𝗵𝗲 𝗗𝗲𝗼𝗯𝗮𝗻𝗱𝗶 𝘀𝗰𝗵𝗼𝗹𝗮𝗿𝘀 𝗮𝗻𝗱 𝗿𝗲𝗳𝗲𝗿𝗲𝗻𝗰𝗲𝗱 𝗳𝗿𝗼𝗺 𝘁𝗵𝗲𝗶𝗿 𝗯𝗼𝗼𝗸𝘀! 1. Allah can tell a lie. (Fataawa Rasheediyah, vol. 1. Page 19). 2. Allah does not know beforehand what His creations would do. Allah comes to know of their doings only after they have done something. (Tafseer Bulghatul Hairaan pages 157 and 158). 3. Shaitaan (Satan) and the Angel of death are more knowledgeable than the holy Prophetﷺ .(Baraaheen-e-Qaati'ah,pages 51 and 52). 4. The Prophet of Allah was not aware of his ultimate fate and of things beyond a wall. (Barraheen-e-Qaati 'ah, page51). 5. The kind of knowledge and the amount of knowledge of the unseen given by Almighty Allah to the holy Prophetﷺ has also been given to animals, lunatics and children. (Hifzul emaan,page 7). 6. Even the thought of the holy Prophetﷺ occurring during Namaaz is much worse than to be immersed in the thought of an ox or a donkey. (Siraat-e-Mustaqeem,page 86). (But the thought of Ashraf Thanvi or any other Deobandi Mullaa coming during Namaaz is justified). 7. The appellation Rahmatul Lil 'Aalameen is not an exclusive attribute of the holy Prophetﷺ . Other saintly persons also can be called Rahmatul Lil'Aalameen. (Fataawa Rasheediyah, vol.2, Page 12). 8. To the common people, the expression "Khaatim-un-Nabiy-yeen"means the "last Prophet". To the knowing people this is not a correct view. Even if a Prophet was to be born after the holy Prophetﷺ it would still have no effect on the concept of the finality of Muhammadﷺ. (Tahzeerun-Naas,Pages 3 and 25). 9. The holy Prophetﷺ learnt the Urdu language from the 'Ulama of Deoband. (Baraaheen-e-Qaati 'ah,page 26). 10. The Prophetﷺ should be respected as an elder brother. (Taqwiyatul emaan,page 58). (But to pay exaggerated and undue respects to the 'Ulama of Deoband is justified.) 11. If Allah so wills He can create millions upon millions of the likes of Muhammadﷺ . (Taqwiyatul eemaan,page 161). (But it is not possible to find peers of the ''Ulama of Deoband.) 12. After his death, the holy Prophetﷺ has mingled with dust. (Taqwiyatul emaan,page 59). (But the power of the 'Ulama of Deoband to benefit people ever after they are dead continues.) 13. All Prophets and Messengers are worthless. (Taqwiyatul emaan,page 29). 14. It is not necessary for a Prophet to be free from, and innocent of, every lie. (Tasfiyatul'Aqaa'id,page 25). (But nothing but truth comes out of the mouths of the 'Ulama of Deoband.) 15. A Prophet should be praised only as a human being and even less. (Taqwiyatul emaan,page 35). (But the 'Ulama of Deobandi-Wahaabi faction should be praised as much as possible.) 16. The bigger ones, that is the Prophets, and the lesser ones, that is the rest of the creations, all are without knowledge and are ignorant. (Taqwiyatul emaan,page 3). 17. The big creations, that is the Prophets, and the lesser creations, that is all other creations, are, in the eyes of Allah, more lowly than even a cobbler. (Taqwiyatul emaan,page 141). 18. It is permitted to call a Prophet as a Taaghoot(Satan). --(Tafseer Bulghatul Hairaan,page 431). (But it is kufr(infidelity) to belittle the 'Ulama of Deoband.) 19. A Prophet holds the same status amongst his followers as is held by a chaudhary(headman) or a landlord in a village. (Taqwiyatul emaan, page 61). (But the Deobandi Mulla, Rasheed Ahmad Gangohi, is the 'Mutaa'ul Kul'or the overall sovereign.) 20. Whosoever is named Muhammad or AleeSallAllahu Alayhi Sallam has no authority over anything. A Prophet or a friend of Allah can do nothing. (Taqwiyatul emaan,page 41). (But the Deobandi-Wahaabi 'Ulama hold sway over the entire world.) 40 disgusting beliefs of the Deobandi scholars and referenced from their books! 21. The holy Prophetﷺ had lost his wits. (Taqwiyatul emaan,page 55). 22. A follower apparently excels his Prophet in deeds. (Tahzeerun-Naas,page 5). 23. A Deobandi Mulla saved the holy Prophetﷺ from falling off Pulsiraat(the bridge over which the righteous will pass into Paradise). (Bulghatul Hairaan) 24. It is satisfying to say Laa'llaaha il-lal Laahu Ashraf Alee Rasool-ul-Laahand Allahum-ma Salli 'Ala Saiyyidina Nabiyyina Ashraf Alee and there is no harm in saying so. (Risaalah Al lmaad,page 35) for the month of S. afar 1336 A.H.; and proceedings of a Munuazirah (religious debate) in Gaya, Al Furqaan,volume 3, page 85). 25. Celebrating Meelad-un-Nabiﷺ (birthday of the Prophet) is like the Hindus celebrating the birthday of their Kanaihya. (Fataawa Meelad Shareef,page 8; and Baraaheen-e-Qaati 'ah,page 148). (But it is true Islam to celebrate days of the Deobandi-Wahhabi 'Ulama and their Daarul Uloom.) 26. The holy Prophetﷺ and the Dajjaal both are blessed with life. The traits which characterise the holy Prophetﷺ are shared by the Dajjaal also. (Aabe Hayat,page l 69). 27. The holy Prophet's ﷺ wish for something to happen is of no consequence. (Aabe Hayat,page 169). (But muchhappens at the wishes of the Wahhabi-Deobandi 'Ulama.) 28. Believe in Allah alone, and do not believe in anyone except Him. (Taqwiyatul emaan,page 14) 29. Before Allah, all Prophets and all friends of Allah are insignificant specks of dust. (Taqwiyatul emaan, page 54). 30. It is right to call the Prophet as your brother. - (Baraaheen-e-Qaati'ah, page 3). (Even if believing so is against the Qur'an). 31. Any Muslim who regards the Prophet or the friends of Allah to be Allah's creations and bondsmen and yet makes them his advocates and intercessors, calls on them for help, and gives nazrand niyaaz equals Abu Jahl in apostasy. (Taqwiyat ul emaan pages 7 and 27). 32. Durood Taaj is disfavoured and reciting it is not permitted. (Fazaa'il-i-Durood Shareef,page. 73 and Tazkiratur Rasheed vol. 2, page 117). (But to compose and recite elegies (marsiyah)on the 'Ulama of Deoband crediting them with much more excellences than those described in the Durood Taaj for the Messenger of Allah ﷺ is quite right.) 33. A saintly person of the Deobandi faction had been given a bath by Hazrat 'Ali (Radi Allahu 'Anhu) and Hazrat Faatimah (Radi Allahu 'Anha) had put on clothes on his (banned) body. (Siraat-i-Mustaqeem,Persian, page 164; Urdu, page 280). 34. Meelad Shareef Mi'raaj Shareef, Gharyee Shareef 'urs Shareef; Khatm Shareef; Soyem, Chehlum, Faatihah Khawani,and eesaal-e-Sawaab, all are unlawful and bad innovations and the ways of the infidel Hindus. (Fataawa Ashrafyah,volume 2, Page 58; Fataawa Rasheediyah,volume 2, pages 144 and 150; and volume 3, pages 93 and 941). (It should be noted that the Deobandi-Wahhabi-Tableeghi people who declare that celebrating Meelad(birth) of the holy Prophetﷺ is a wrong, unlawful, forbidden act of apostasy must be questioned how is it permissible and right to celebrate the foundation-day of the Daarul 'Uloom,Deoband, and to call upon an apostate women to inaugurate it; to celebrate the days and the death anniversaries of their Mul-laasand. their Muftis;to appoint the time, the date and the place of such gatherings; to hold political and non-political demonstrations; to establish institutions in the name of non-Allah; to ask for financial and other kinds of help for the propagation of non-AIlah.) 35. To eat a well known indigenous crow is a spiritually rewarding act. (Fataawa Rasheediyah, Volume 2, Page 1301). (But the eating of halwa (asweet dish) distributed on the occasion of Shabe Bara'at is forbidden). 36. To invoke the friends of Allah even though regarding them as His creations is forbidden. (Taqwiyatul emaan, 7). (But it is not forbidden if the 'Ulama of Deoband themselves invoke them). 37. To supplicate after funeral prayers is not permitted. (Fatwa of Mufti Jameel Ahmad Thanvi, Jami'ah Ashrafiyah, Lahore). (But it is not forbidden if the 'Ulama of Deoband themselves supplicate thus.) , 38. It is permitted to take gifts distributed on the occasion of the Hindu festivals of Holi and Deewaali. (Fataawa Rasheediyah,volume 2, Page 130). (But to take gifts distributed on the occasion of Faatihah and Niyaaz is prohibited.) 39. There is no harm in eating food, if clean, prepared at the houses of the meanest and the lowliest of people. (Fataawa Rasheediyah,Volume 2, page 130). (But clean and permitted food distributed on the occasion of niyaaz of Giyaarhveen Shareef is altogether prohibited.) 40. Drinking water from the sabeel (kiosk) set up by Hindus (apostates) out of the money earned through interest is permitted. (Fataawa Rasheediyah, Volume 3, pages 113 and 114). (But drinking clean water from the sabeel set up during the month of Muharram for the eesaal-e-Sawaab of Saiyyidina Imam Husain RadiAllahu Anh with money provided by the lawful earnings of Muslim is prohibited.)
As salaamu alaykum brothers, sisters, friends and foes. Please like, share and comment on this video, as well as subscribing to the 5Pillars RU-vid channel! Jazakallah khayran.
Dont say wahhabis Say anything else, but not that The nickname comes from Muhammed ibn Abdulwahhab You can see that his fathers name was Abdulwahhab, slave of Wahhab therefore, wahhabism this is wrong on many levels you can refer to them as isis, extremists but not this nickname
Even though I am not a follower of the maturidi aqeedah, I can confirm this sheikh has excellent manners and knowledge in the hanafi fiqh, I urge brothers and sisters to listen to what he says.
People can say whatever they want about the deobandi school, but when it comes to rigorous academic research, noone pulls out strong references as flawlessly as they do. No emotional sermoning, no sectarian nonsense, just genuine theological discourse. They know their stuff, and they know it really well.
Saying there is no aqiidah tells a lot about them.. thats one of the most important things in islam. What and how you belive and worship Allah swt. You cant start dancing and say uts ibadah. This is only a sect of the 73 sects..
@@zdravo3543 no it isn't a sect, it is a school like al-Azhar or Western equivalents such as Harvard, Oxford...Deobandis generally follow the Hanafi school of thought in fiqh and generally Maturdi in aqeedah, again this is a broad generalism
@@ShudrajiMleccha when you use a term you have to define it, we are talking about the 72 baatil groups mentioned in the ahadith, not general groups or schools of thoughts
Following a madhab is the safest path to enlightenment since hundreds if not thousands of scholars utilised that madhab's principles in further researching and fine tuning the madhabs stances given the varying times and impacts the ummah might be going through. Just as Imam Shafe RA had to alter certain positions after studying with Imam Muhammad Ashaybani, one of the brilliant students of Imam Abu Habifa RA, in Kufa and later in Egypt when he came in contact with the students of Imam Layth Ibn Saad RA. Alhamdulilah for the Quran and the Sunnah of our beloved Prophet Muhammad SAW.
I recently discovered this channel on Twitter, and today I discovered it on RU-vid with the recommendation of this podcast. Pleasantly surprised, interesting dialogue with a knowledgeable person. Interesting from the beginning to end, academically introduced answers without unnecessary emotions from either side ✔️. I heard a new style of discussion of Islamic topics, thanks to the host. 🤲 May Allah bless you and reward with the best! With regards from KZ 🇰🇿.
Thank you 5 pillars for inviting somebody from the deobandi school of thought and showing respect to one of our celebrated local scholars, and allowing him to present the much misunderstood school of thought in Sunni Islam. May Allah reward you. I would recommend you try to invite Mufti Abdur Rahman Mangera too. He has a very wide scope of knowledge and experience.
Masha'Allah... what an amazing display of character and understanding of nuances within the Muslim community by the Shaykh. May Allah swt bless him and brother Dilly for facilitating this. آمين يارب العالمين
Absolutely loved it. Thanks Dilly Hussain for doing this podcast with the sheikh. Got more of a in-depth understanding of how to deal with some of the issues we're facing as Muslims. Keep them coming bondu.
This podcast is gold.... I love how Shaikh yasir has leveled up and how both of you conducted yourself with really good manners and humblnes..... cant wait for the next one
JazakAllahu khayran brother Dilly and Shaykh Yasir. May Allah swt reward you both for this. This is something I missed. Views like Yasirs is whats needed in this day and age. Tolerance and how to navigate through discussions with muslims and non muslims. We do often see muslim online figures go harsh on each other and this podcast might be the cure, Allahu Alem.
As Salafi in aqeedah and shafici in fiqh, I find it fascinating how other madhab fiqh come to their ruling. May Allah bless all our four madahib. It’s bless from Allah we have different madahib it made our life easier.
Mash'Allah, it's nice to see the Ulama are reviving/rejuvenating Ilm-ul-Kalam at a time when it's resources are most needed. As to the question about studying in western academia, just read why Imam al-Ghazali became famous, not because he brought Quran and Sunnah to the falaasifa (they had their own way of interpreting it) but he studied their arguments so that he could give the possible response.
First time listening to the podcast.. Thoroughly enjoyed it all mashaAllah ta BarakAllah Some very pertinent topics dealt with swiftly but also with enough time and detail to them some small justice. Very courteous and respectful
MashaAllah a brilliant well done podcast.. Learnt many things and hopefully it is beneficial for others, look forward to more similar podcasts.. JazzakAllah khair
Asalaamu Alaikoum Great podcast Masha'Allah more people of knowledge like Shaykh please. May Allah swt reward everyone involved Aameen. Jazak'Allah Khayran.
Ustadh Yasir needs to share his knowledge with the muslims through social media more frequently. I like his approach and I believe many muslims and new reverts will benefit from him. There are very few Ustadhs presenting the hanafi school of thought on social media platforms. All I see are condescending and attacking debates which I never find appealing.
I came across Sheikh Yasir when he made the video response to Uthmaan ibn Farooq following the DH deobandi thing recently - I personally have never been inclined towards the deobandi school but the impeccable manners and respectful approach of Sheik Yasir was truly outstanding - a real ambassador of Islam. Perhaps Sheik Yasir should represent the deobandi school in the debate with Sheikh Asrar - He would do a far better job in representing the school than the clown who misrepresented them with his outright disruptive approach in the pre conditions of the debate. This I believe, would be of great value to the Ummah and close the discussion for good moving forward. These are the points of contention... these are the respective daleels. Done!
The funny part about Deobandi scholars is that their elders are respected and revered by the scholars on all sides. Imam of Haramain learn Hadith rubaiyat from Mufti taqi Uthmani. Sheikh Alawi al maliki, revered by the Barelwis, was a student of Sheikh Zakariyyah Kandhlawi. Imams of Haramain have all come to deoband, led prayers and praised them. Sheikh Ibn Baaz took hadith ijaazat from Mufti Shafi Uthmani. The Imams of Haramain, sheikh subayyil and others would call Allamah Darkhwasti as their Ustaadh. Sheikh Abdullah Khayyat would read out jumuah khutbah from the articles of Sheikh abul hasan Ali nadwi
MashAllah Beautiful conversation. Really impressed with Shaykh Sahab as well as Brother Dilly. Generally host does not have well thought questions as well as knowledge. May Allah protect the guest as well as the host. Jazāk Allāhu Khayran
Only Shaykh Yasir rahimahullah has change my path on searching the real aqaid of the salaf from salafiyyah to athari/hanbali, he was my key point on my journey, I always watch his lecture about the aqaid, if you guys truly have ikhlas without bias on searching the truth, you will come to the truth alhamdulillah. May Allah truly bless you shaykh I love you for the sake of Allah, I ask Allah if we dont meet in this dunya, then I Ask Allah to let us meet in the akhira to finally kiss your forehead. Salamu alaykum from the Philippines 🇵🇭.
@@Foreign.xx922 🤣🤣🤣🤦🏻omg another juhaal salafi😂😂😂. Did I say he was from the salaf🤣🤣 I said he was my key on searching the true aqaid of the salaf, He was the point where I needed to study the true athari hanbali creed, I know he is an ashari but doesnt mean, I came to the realization that I should indulge in the ilm kalam that they had, he had a series on what was the real creed of the salaf since I dont find salafiyyah creed to be the i’itiqad of the salaf because they havd certain views thst are not from the salaf. you stupid, see the difference. Look how stupid you are, asharis are not kaafir, did you even know it was the asharis muslim who remove the crusaders in the jerusalem?where was your so called salafi brethren, even Ibn Taymiyya RA fought under the banner of Ashaira against the mongol and crusaders yet you are here calling them enemy of the deen. you stupid filth.
How is it possible for someone who doesn't follow the path of the prophet himself has never studied under the circle of scholars that have a chain direct to the teachings of the prophet to the Qur'an and sunnah become aware of the aqeedah of the salaf himself. To preach to you about aqeedah of the salaf. Who are yasir hanafis teachers where did his education come from. Certainly not from any scholar that have a direct link back to the prophet. So please stop with your ignorant blind following sheep comments. The man is a self proclaimed wonder. Who reads and bases things on his own opinions and desires he is a heretic. This is the most dangerous form of spreading falsehood without backing a notion. You don't know whom his teachers are and what creed but you say he knows salaf aqeedah. This man is far from that. He belittles the biggest salaf scholars and is rude in his mannerism. RU-vid mask wearer. His reality differs from his RU-vid presence.
@@Foreign.xx922 🤣🤣🤣please kindly watch his videos, im not stupid like christian believe in a statement without any evidences, surely he reads from the book of hanaabilah when he explained the aqwal of the salaf when you watch his lectures and HERE YOU ARE ACCUSING HIM OF LIES AND SPEAKING FROM HIS DESIRES AND BRANDED HIM HERETIC, THERE’S NO DOUBT YOU’RE SUPER SALAFI🤣🤣🤣, AS USUAL without looking with his works and video, straight away brand him heretic because he was against your pseudo salafiyyah manhaj🤣🤣🤣.secondly read the asharis book where they get their aqaid from, from imam nawawi, to imam al bayhaqi and many scholars. the only differences between the people of athar and ashaira is that we dont indulge in ilm kalam while the asharis add the ilm kalam to refute those who adhere to the ilm kalam, its like muslim using the bible to refute christian, just the way the a’’imma of ashaira refute the jahmiyya,mujassima, karramiyah, mu’tazila by using ilm al kalam, the text is sufficient for us atharis while for them they add aql to explain the existence of Allah. but it doesnt mean they are out of the fold Islam, if you just read the book of imam Ibn Taymiyyah RA ya juhaal, yes he refute asharis but He said that this people were still under the banner of Islam, history tells even ibn Taymiyya RA again fought side by side with asharis giants, even imam Al albani said we will have no best commentary regarding sahih bukhari without the ashaira, this jaahil salafi brand them easily heretic if you are consistent that the asharis were ahlul bid’ah, why you salafis using imam nawawi books, using imam al qurtubi if they were heretic🤣😂, such a narrow minded person and you people are the cause of sectarianism. We believe the same thing, just different approach mate. Secondly show me where he belittle the scholars from the salaf?NOT THE SALAFI SCHOLAR BECAUSE I DONT ADHERE TO THAT, he just refuted a salafis scholar who attribute themselves from the salaf which they are far far far way from the i’tiqad of the salaf,they salafis indulge in something that speak ta’til over tanzih. Do you think we are all hanbalis atharis were salafi?there are many hanbalis/atharis against the salafi movement especially their aqaid and usul. Salafis like you are super hypocrite you forbid taqleed on maddhab but when it comes to your salafis scholar, just he disagrees with his views you label the person right away mubtadi. I been in from the salafiyyah circles, you cannot convince me anymore about your usul and i’tiqad and i’m studying under the real hanbali scholars in aqeedah and in fiqh ashaira/shafi’i scholar. Alhamdulillah. They help me to reach the truth.
,@@Foreign.xx922 I don't know what kind of hate you carry because one thing is for sure we know that bitterness can never become sweet no matter how much sugar is put instead it will change the whole taste into another different thing.
Masha’Allah very beneficial discussion. May Allah Ta’ala guide us all and give us at least outward unity in common issues so we can at least portray a united front otherwise we’re fair game for foes as they can see ample opportunities to exploit and ultimately harm us. An elder once said you younger generation will not find peace and common ground until the older generation is gone (dead) what I understood from this saying is that such things are so ingrained that only it’s removal can allow for reconciliation.
MashAllah a beautiful podcast. Good points defo all the main ulema need to get together and do a syallabus that all masjid should follow as basics of Islam teaching when our kids join up masjid to counter a lot what schools teach with explanations or just hire people who are in these fields to the masjid to do a workshop. Instead of getting another big chandelier
I have a BA in Islamic Studies and I advise you to take from the Ulama who have studied in Madrassa and not those who have studied Islam in Western universities. People would write kufr "for better marks". I just bashed the Orientalists and deviants. Still got a 2:1.
