Since you love pineapple try VS natural collection of Pineapple & Shea. Bought the whole collection - wash/scrub/lotion & mist when they where on sale ( think it still is on ) . Love it
I'm not sure how I feel about it. I blind bought Bare Vanilla Sol and Velvet Petals Sol. Honestly, the vanilla smells very ordinary, but there's an odd note that doesn't sit well on my skin. And Petals kinda makes me want to sneeze.😂 I REALLY don't like to bind buy but I'm about 75 miles from my nearest store and it rarely has all the new stuff. Glad you liked your picks!