Video editing WITHOUT dGPU, is it POSSIBLE? 🔵⚡🔴 i9 11900k vs Ryzen 7 5700g

Просмотров 48 тыс.

% 962

TWO of the best 8-core CPUs that also have an iGPU ➡ Intel i9 11900k & Ryzen 7 5700g. Which is better for Premiere Pro Timeline performance? Can you edit video without a dGPU?
Buy AMD Ryzen 7 5700G here: geni.us/ZL5O5
Buy INTEL i9 11900k here: geni.us/D0GFnSD
🔴 AMD Test Bench:
CPU: geni.us/ZL5O5
COOLER: geni.us/Wxt1
MOTHERBOARD: geni.us/b1ZWg3
SSD: geni.us/NvzpAd
PSU: geni.us/QJ6R
CASE: geni.us/5WmCX
RAM: geni.us/ROBUn
🔵 INTEL Test Bench:
CPU: geni.us/D0GFnSD
COOLER: geni.us/QVi4Y4
MOTHERBOARD: geni.us/GiBA0
SSD: geni.us/nqMnp
PSU: geni.us/k5HWOQH
RAM: geni.us/ROBUn
My Go-to Online Store:
geni.us/amazhome - (Amazon) Paid Link*
Want me to check out some tech or interested in collaborating?
📩 email me: thetechnotice@gmail.com
FB: thetechnotice/
IG: @thetechnotice
#5700g #11900k #intelVSamd #premierePRO
Video produced by Lauri Pesur
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
GEAR USED IN THIS VIDEO:
[All 'geni.us' links below redirect to Amazon (or some other Online stores) and may earn commissions]
AUDIO:
-The Recorder + Mic I Use: geni.us/tscmdr-10l
-The $20 Camera Shotgun Mic I use: geni.us/takstar
-The Tie/Lapel Mic That I also use: geni.us/smrtlav
You also need this for the tie mic: geni.us/sc3adt
-Shotgun Mic I Use: geni.us/T35T
-My Main Headphones [CHEAP]: geni.us/dzv7Q
-My Main Headphones 2.0 [NOT CHEAP]: geni.us/as7q9v
-Best cheap Rechargeable Batteries: geni.us/oQHyx9T
VIDEO:
-A-roll Camera: geni.us/NvnoA
-Lens for A cam: geni.us/J009I
-B-Roll Camera: geni.us/wVlF8J
-Top Down Cam: geni.us/56576C
-Main Bokeh Lens 4 Sony: geni.us/k09oA
-The Wide Angle beast w OS: geni.us/9KfCwy
-Most reliable SD Cards in the world: geni.us/QMxxBnu
-SD Cards for A7s III I'm using: geni.us/v5O1OmD & geni.us/r15RT (cheaper)
-Super Small SSD for A CAM: geni.us/SW7QX
STABILISATION:
-My Cheap Tripod: geni.us/fcXt
-The Fluid Head on my tripod for smooth b-roll: geni.us/lhcJV
-MY CHEAP A Cam tripod: geni.us/oBNG
LIGHTS:
-Main Fill Light: geni.us/qTbE
-Hair & RGB Lights I use: geni.us/TdY1
-Fav Pocket RGB Light: geni.us/9LHo4B
-The Fire effect light: geni.us/GX5KA
-Best Ringlight to buy: geni.us/dUS9
OTHER:
-Favourite camera Monitor w LUT: geni.us/tecUD
-I get my music here:
▶Get 2 Months for FREE when joining Artlist/Artgrid below◀
Music & SFX Licensing Site: geni.us/TNartlist
Stock Footage Site: geni.us/TNartgrid
DISCLAIMER: I have to state that some of the links on this channel are affiliate links which means by clicking on them and purchasing the items I get a small commission. I'm part of an Amazon Affiliate and earn revenue from qualifying purchases.
[Paid Link*] Means that by clicking on the link and purchasing from the shop I'll earn commission from Amazon or other site(s). This does NOT change the price for you.
⏲
0:00 Intel vs AMD
0:41 Test Setups & Price
1:21 Premiere Pro
1:48 4k 8-bit 4.2.0 (h.264)
3:35 4k 10-bit 4.2.0 (h.264)
4:44 4k 10-bit 4.2.2 (h.264)
5:42 4k 10-bit 60 FPS 4.2.2 (h.264)
6:46 4k Codecs Conclusion
7:00 4k RED RAW R3D
8:10 4k CANON RAW (c200)
9:27 5k RED RAW R3D
10:17 6k RED RAW R3D
11:10 6k BRAW (Black Magic Raw)
12:29 8k Canon RAW (R5)
13:39 Conclusion - Which should you get?

Опубликовано:

30 сен 2021

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 158

@theTechNotice 2 года назад

Which one are you interested in? 🤔

@dokterreview6472 2 года назад

thats cause premiere pro use codec from intel, not from AMD. thats the key

@fullbars 2 года назад

TN Thanks for all the info. Can you recommend the best bang-for-buck prebuilt Premiere editing PC under $2k? You can provide an affiliate link, thanks again!

@FeaolPlay 2 года назад

5700G. Seems it has tonnes of headroom left untapped. 5700G has Vega GPU core which is supported by Premiere Pro, but only the Pro version in Mac Metal. I bet if Adobe enables support for Vega in Windows OpenCL then this test will have a completely different outcome. Kudos for the informative video.

@luisa9628 2 года назад

5700g. When you want to expand your business you can use the 5700g in one the of ASRock Rack Motherboards for a low cost, quiet, and, depending on how you set up your ZFS, blazing fast video editing server multiple people can work off of. IPMI, Dual 10gbe, ECC, built in.

@jimcim29 Год назад

What's the cooler you are using here for Ryzen 7?

@anl6652 2 года назад

In RU-vid, I couldn't find any video about comparing AMD Gpu's performance on Premiere Pro. And your video is the one I'm looking for. Thank you for making this video. Much appreciated.

@theTechNotice 2 года назад

Thanks 👊 glad you enjoyed it.

@TheMightyDel 2 года назад

Same

@3dbrother 2 года назад

To me AMD is winning by far. In Japan 7 5700G = 48,0000 yen with cooler and i9 11900k is 80,000 yen. Enough money left to add a nice graphic card for AMD.

@simplysurfing Год назад

HOw ? @ 480,000 yen its way multitude costlier than intel.......at least as per the numbers youve typed.

@sartajkhan6175 Год назад

@@simplysurfing 😂typing mistake

@LewisCostin 2 года назад

9:00 Those artifacts are called "screen tearing". It can be fixed in your GPU settings by enabling "V-sync" for Premiere. It may lower performance slightly but it can be fixed.

@7candide7 2 года назад

Hi. Thank you for the video. Can you please comment on the encoding part (H264 / H265 exports)? Are performances still correct?

@muhammadtayyab9543 2 года назад

i9 11900k is 490$ VS ryzen 7 5700g is 310$ and both performance is almost same and if we consider the price factor then RYZEN 7 5700G IS WINNER

@syaondri 4 месяца назад

2 years late but to add to it, if you buy b550 board you can also put 5800x3d or 5700x to enable pcie5.0 for that extra several %oomph in case you did upgrade to those dgpu (even more if they decided to go x8 instead of x16 for cheap cards)

@emadjs1 2 месяца назад

@@syaondriWhich b550 board support pcie 5.0?? 🤔

@syaondri 2 месяца назад

@@emadjs1 ah my bad it was 4.0, b450 only support 3.0

@johnriff 2 года назад

Great video. Very detailed and informative. Would fitting a 5700G in a Streacom FC8 power-limiting the CPU at 65 watts be good for video editting and stream capturing from an external source? Would the Intel I9 be better for that? (h264 codec)

@anulearntech 2 года назад

I plan to use davinci resolve, and plan to build a system for it and gaming + NAS, but not necessarily considering discrete GPU. I've heard that there are some news on davinci on AMD. So is it expected to work good on AMD with upcoming CPUs?

@MrEagleeye58 2 года назад

Hi Great video, would you please do an i9 10900 k into an 560 mobo comparison? the I9 11th generation has limited PCI 4 support. so may not be worth it to pay until the 12th gen becomes stabilized...

@cosmicfxx 2 года назад

Hi great video. But how would i9 10850k compare to Ryzen 7 7500g for video editing … which you think would be better until being able to get d GPU? Tia

@cw-hi4cb 2 года назад

Very good video. I was wondering how realistic editing would be on a 5700g. I was surprised by the conclusion though. All through the video it seemed like AMD was smoother, with fewer dropped frames in almost every example and without those artifacts mentioned on intel. All while using less watts and less cpu/gpu load. So it seemed odd to hear you pick Intel in the end.

@k.o.t.o.n. 2 года назад

yeah i dont understand it either..

@Weird_Quests 2 года назад

Looks hopeful for on-the-go editing on my r9 5900HX laptop (just for cutting) when I have my dGPU inactive.

@debashisraykarmakar836 Год назад

yeah me too..

@Klute1977 Год назад

He always says intel is better, might just be his preference?

@andrewmutavi590 Год назад

Me too,very weird conclusion

@harryofficial3743 2 года назад

Hey im panning on doing heavy 1080p editing for youtube can i do it on a 1650 laptop? I have 2 options either a zephreyes g14 5800h 1650 or acer nitro 5 3050 5800h the zephrus has a 100 srgb screen wheareas the later has 66 srgb screen and the zephrus is a way better laptop in every thing except the gpu so i prefer the zephrus but if heavy 1080p editing requires more than a 1650 ill but the acer also i am willing to drop down playback resolution.

@smileinurhand Год назад

Well details. Thanks for your knowledge. Can suggest some Budget motherboard for this . Need best overclocking. Could you tell a VGA Card for this Ryzen 7 5700G?

@MarcoAntonio-ki4tz 2 года назад

If should rise the size of reserved RAM for iGPU for the Ryzen CPU in BIOS. You'll see a pretty big jump in performance. Look for NB configuration, then UMA setings.

@animerealm1608 4 месяца назад

Bro will there be a big difference in video editing on davinci resolve and premier pro? I'll be using ryzen 5 5600g

@slavoslavo2140 2 года назад

How works Render, Hardware Acceleration Intel and Like AMD IGPU? You can compare time for video export?

@toth1982 2 года назад

What about rendering speed? For that every relatively modern CPU is OK?

@jylobo1112 2 года назад

Will the performance be about the same on Davinci resolve (not the studio version)

@knowwork9 2 года назад

What happens if i put an eternal graphics card with 5700g??? I need something for editing and gaming some help

@luisa9628 2 года назад

Are those videos done in All-i or Long-GoP?

@bfjoutdoors 2 года назад

Nice video! Have you done the same test with the same processors in resolve?

@theTechNotice 2 года назад

Yes: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-IEVlgGCP03s.html

@seanvideoediting Год назад

Im looking to buy a laptop for video editing, can I edit on a 10th gen i7 cpu without a dedicated gpu? I will mainly edit 1080p footage with some graphics animation.

@ThaGreatWhite813 Год назад

I'm planning on a build using the 5700g and upgrading it with a GPU later on. I want to use the PC mainly for screen recording OSRS and editing videos - and possibly streaming it as well. My concern is without a GPU I don't know if I'll drop FPS when I screen record and I've had that issue with my current laptop. Do you think that APU would be strong enough without a GPU or should I look into another route with a GPU from the get go? Thank you, and great video!!

@stefanvujic1879 4 месяца назад

I'm planning the same now, what is your experience with it?

@rafsan69 Год назад

Can I enable GPU acceleration in premiere pro using the iGPU(Vega 7) of AMD Ryzen 5 5600G.

@luisquesan 2 года назад

Hi! Thanks for the video, I wanted to ask what would you recommend me, I'm looking forward to build a pc without GPU for advanced photo editing, which CPU would you recommend me? One of those or maybe I don't need a so good CPU and I can think about buying a 5600G or something like that. Thanks a lot.

@hany_mohamed 2 года назад

And me too

@theunboxnetwork 2 года назад

Are intel's extrem CPU's better then standard CPU's.

@michahalczuk9071 2 года назад

*Thank you for the video!* My friend has decided to take 5700G because it was on large sale and she was waiting for 8 core for a year. I sent her this video as a proof that iGPU might actually be more usable than dGPU when using Premiere Pro! Don't forget that 5700G has some large OC potential since it's only 65W CPU.

@mgr5550 2 года назад

HI.....but this is just one layer/track of footage just laid on the timeline and played right ? no filters, no other video track overlay, etc correct ?

@theTechNotice 2 года назад

Yes, that's correct!

@KebongPHL 2 года назад

sir can you try i7 12700k? i was wondering how the 12 gen i7 video editing without gpu, because gpu this day is so expensive. thanks

@fiftyfive3331 2 года назад

Can you make one for i5 11400? As it is the most affordable CPU with decent IGPU.

@MILANDANGAR Год назад

My biggest question sir 5600g +3060 & 5600x +3060 how much difference in performance

@gabethepianist7572 2 года назад

Dude its such a helpful video you have no idea. Keep up the good work:)

@theTechNotice 2 года назад

Thanks very much! I'm glad it helped!

@fabiovillelaoficial 2 года назад

Very good video I've been looking for a material like this for a long time and I didn't find it. for h.264 and h.265 files quicksync shines w are the most common files on the market. I would love to see AMD's vega with an optimization within Premiere. I'm coming back to Intel because of Quicksync.

@sharmaparth 2 года назад

Thank you bro. This helps a lot. A suggestion if you can make a comparison video for other video editing software's too on the same CPU's ... Kudos

@theTechNotice 2 года назад

👍

@OzLBlackWhite 2 года назад

Great job as always dude !

@theTechNotice 2 года назад

Appreciate that

@LegionZGaming 2 года назад

but ryzen 7 is supposed to be on compete with i7 i dont think its supposed to be compared with i9, another disadvantage

@JayzBeerz 2 года назад

Great info. Love your content.

@theTechNotice 2 года назад

😉👍

@merochillin5316 2 года назад

Looking forward for your next video because i want to learn how to edit on Davinci

@NathanVu 2 года назад

I'm looking to buy a laptop instead of a desktop for 1080p video editing. Will the 11th gen with it's Iris Xe iGPU and 16GB Ram be enough? I'll probably just be editing and rendering 1080p video that's about 30 minutes long.

@khalidalam11 4 месяца назад

Good enough,you can use proxy also

@Lukaszpoluch 6 месяцев назад

Hello, is Ryzen 7 5700g still a good option for a budget PC at the end of 2023 for photo processing and simple video editing? I think it is an interesting processor, especially in terms of low operating temperatures, I live in Mexico, so I have to deal with high temperatures and a limited budget, so I am considering this processor and the later upgrade with the Intel Arc 750. What do you think about this solution?

@stefanvujic1879 4 месяца назад

I'm also planning to buy 7 5700G for video editing. It is definitely a great option for a budget. Without gpu, i will build a video editing pc for just 500$

@leocastillo.audio- 2 года назад

Thank you for this video, so good. Can you do the same but with DaVinci Resolve instead?

@theTechNotice 2 года назад

Wait for the next video ;)

@AzogDefilerFromMordor Год назад

what about 13th gen? and .265 codec at 4K

@jaspermilesss 2 года назад

Great video, aliexpress xeon bundles possibly? paired with a 1650 or similar. Not a lot of creator centered content much place else really and I find your content interesting as well.

@theTechNotice 2 года назад

😉👍

@ExploringDarknessGhostM6edia 2 года назад

The reason I subscribed to your channel after watching for many months the one thing that I noticed the most important is,, You're really honest and truthful !! You call it like you see no BS.... I purchase the AMD 5700 G Based on your reviews and the chip performed how you stated..Thank You..GregM from EXPLORING DARKNESS..

@simplysurfing Год назад

How is the 5700g performing for you now with the IGPU alone ? Does it edit 4K 150mbps files smoothly ? good timeline scrub performance ?

@joelespinozarubio9364 2 года назад

Due to the problem with GPUs, would you recommend buying an APU instead of a CPU for video editing? For my computer I want a Ryzen 5 5600x, but due to the shortage I am considering an APU. (My motherboard is a GIGABYTE X570 AORUS-Wifi)

@theTechNotice 2 года назад

Wait for my 5700g build and CPU review then you'll have a bigger picture if that's for you ;)

@dallatorretdu 2 года назад

I have a backup system on a design stand that I just updated with an AM4 motherboard. I was looking for a 5600G but that was really hard to find and still doesn’t run 4:2:2 HEVC so I got the 5600X…. Problem is that system is still on a Titan X which doesn’t do anything HEVC-related

@knowwork9 2 года назад

Can i run this code with 5700g?

@oldschoolpro 2 года назад

Great video bro. How about export/encode the video?

@theTechNotice 2 года назад

Check out my 5700g and 11900k review hopefully that will help, but generally Intel is faster. :)

@oldschoolpro 2 года назад

@@theTechNotice ok broo tx for the response

@user-qo2xj8wf6f 7 месяцев назад

Wish you used FRAPS or similar tool that shows exactly howmany FPS you get in preview window. 5K & 6K footage probably was in AVC and AVC hardware acceleration is only supported up to 4K resolution all NVIDIA/AMD/INTEL.

@OverLordkv 2 года назад

How much is difference if you put chipsets CUDA graphic card in system like this?

@theTechNotice 2 года назад

11900k is better. :)

@saktlonda3892 Год назад

@@theTechNotice do you get paid by intel for giving these fake intel hype 😂😂😂

@photoshopplanet1815 Год назад

is this Apu(Amd) is enough for 1080p davinci and photoshop heavy files ? i want to build pc (5700g or 5600g ) or should i go for i5 12400 i can not afford GPU its still expensive. Anyone please help.

@zet67 Год назад

Hey buddy, which one did you choose among these two?

@Nugromant 2 года назад

BRO ! This is the kind of video I was trying to find, editing without GPU, we need more in depth reviews for creatives, I hate that every single review is about gaming but just a few talks about real work, but bro, to be heads to heads, do you activated OpenCL for the AMD processor? Intel has quicksync, but AMD has OpenCL acceleration, that might utilize better the iGPU. P.D. Those "artifacts" is called "tearing" that happens when the hardware can't decode as fast as the video image, so there's a bit of lag between them.

@Nugromant 2 года назад

Sorry if it's a lot, hopefully you'll read my comment, since I don't have the access to hardware as you do to test things out, but would be awesome if you clarify or do a part 2 about the OpenCL and if it even makes a difference.

@theTechNotice 2 года назад

Yes, On AMD it was set to Open CL.

@FeaolPlay 2 года назад

@@theTechNotice It probably wasn't working correctly as Vega isn't listed as officially supported with OpenCL, hence the low GPU utilisation.

@bfjoutdoors 2 года назад

@@FeaolPlay he says multiple times that there are driver and support issues with amd in resolve.

@subratamoulick665 2 года назад

Can I edit 1080p and 2k video on i5 11500 without gpu with 16 GB ram ?

@khalidalam11 4 месяца назад

Yes you can, only 1080. For 2k or 4k I will suggest you to buy a second hand 1050ti or 1650 That will good enough for proffetional video editing

@uberheropatapon 2 года назад

This is a great video! I'm planning a build without a dedicated GPU as the prices are absurd right now and this is exactly the comparison I need.

@AbhishekIyerPhotography 2 года назад

So did you purchase AMD 5700g?

@denvera1g1 2 года назад

I really wish Adobe would take advantage of AMD, i mean, i get it, more people have Intel so its better to target intel, but if independant developers find it easier, and cheaper to work with AMD, why not put a small team on integrating VCE Also, VCE needs more features, so that might be why they're not leveraging it as heavily as QSV, though other software doesnt seem to struggle with AMD

@michaeldiso9842 2 года назад

Adobe should have done this a long time ago. Performance gains could also be expected if only premiere could make use of the VCE on amd gpus

@NiazMahmood1977 2 года назад

If I use Ryzen 7 5700g now and later add a GPU - will it boost my 4k/5k video editing performance in Adobe Premier Pro? Which GPU has better performance for 4k/5k video editing in Adobe Premier pro, AMD Radeon or nVidia GEForce?

@claritoresdiano1021 2 года назад

Nvidia

@saktlonda3892 Год назад

Amd Radeon is the best GPU on Market ....it's pure gold ..

@NlsHanDimitri Год назад

Thank you.

@TechTVusa 2 года назад

Artifacts? An Nvidia RTX 3090 will do the same thing without horizontal sync enabled.

@hadira2arifatauhazim4syuku80 2 года назад

yeahhhh finally, thanks too creator 🙏🙏

@theTechNotice 2 года назад

😉

@jakubmaslonka9184 10 месяцев назад

I actually never had a dGPU and I'm editing 4K videos. I was editing on AMD Ryzen 5 3500U but a month ago I upgraded to Ryzen 7 7700U and I still don't need another graphics card on system

@ahmednofal3865 2 года назад

thanks so much

@smileinurhand Год назад

In-depth explanations, thanks. RYZEN 5700G consumes a lot of power during long-term use. Say a similar Intel Processor would be helpful.

@HiTechBR 2 года назад

Tenho sofrido para editar meus vídeos no Premiere usando um i5-7500T, que é uma máquina da empresa que eu trabalho. Resolvi comprar uma nova para mim ontem, com o Ryzen 7 5700g, 32GB 3200MHz, Kingston 500GB M2, Asus B550M. Agora é aguardar chegar e ver a diferença. Meus vídeos de cerca de 30 minutos no premiere estavam demorando cerca de 2 horas para exportar... Não vejo a hora que poder trabalhar melhor!

@bodeex 2 года назад

Fala Robson! Como está sendo a experiência?

@HiTechBR 2 года назад

@@bodeex , tudo bem? A minha experiência está sendo fantástica. Esse processador da AMD é uma APU, ou seja, já vem com um chip gráfico interno, um Vegas 8. Verifiquei por meio do Passmark Benchmark que ele equivale a uma placa GTX 1050. Faz cerca de 2700 pontos no benchmark. Uma GTX 1660 Super faz cerca de 16 mil pontos, à título de comparação. Editei sábado um vídeo de 28 minutos com algumas transições e sem correção de cores (como sempre) e ele foi renderizado em 12,5 minutos. Muito bom. Percebi que o processador estava a cerca de 60% do poder total de processamento e a placa de vídeo foi à 95% a uma taxa de 68 fps. Não obstante, o trabalho deste sábado fiz no DaVince Resolve. Resolvi mudar de softwares pois o Premiere que eu tinha era do CS6 e estava bastante defasado. Mas realizei um teste também com o Premiere e os resultados foram melhores do que na máquina anterior mas não tão bons quanto com o DaVinci Resolve: O mesmo projeto utilizado no teste da mensagem inicial, que demorou 2 horas para ser concluído, ficou pronto em 15 minutos. Porém, a CPU rodou o tempo todo a 100% e a GPU interna ficou somente com 1%. Isso mostra que o DaVinci Resolve é mais bacana porque ele usa a CPU no que for necessário, mas se no futuro eu colocar uma aceleradora gráfica mais potente, poderei aumentar o desempenho das edições, o que não está ocorrendo com a versão do Premiere que eu possuo. No Premiere, o projeto possuía vídeos Full HD em um total de 4GB na origem. Verifiquei que durante o processamento o Premiere consumiu 22GB de RAM, o que achei exagerado. No DaVince resolve no sábado, um projeto semelhante ocupou apenas 10GB de RAM, o que me indica que o mecanismo de gestão de memória do DaVinci é melhor. Assim, parei por agora de usar o Premiere e estou usando o DaVinci Resolve, que é mais pesado do que o Premiere CS6, mas não faz cócegas na máquina. Ah, estou até mesmo utilizando o software Aster Pro e compartilhando a máquina com minha esposa. Nós dois estamos editando dois vídeos ao mesmo tempo e a máquina está rodando suave. Super recomendo essa configuração para quem não mais quiser ter dores de cabeça.

@aNetoo 2 года назад

Muito obrigado pelo seu comentário, estou querendo adquirir um ryzen 5700g, mas estava em dúvida se daria conta do Davince, pretendo editar vídeos full HD do dji mini

@HiTechBR 2 года назад

Hoje também estou com uma placa GForce 1050TI. Estou compartilhando a máquina em duas com o software ASTER Pro e precisava de mais saídas de vídeo. Uso para uma sessão duas conexões onboard com a APU e na outra sessão mais duas saídas onboard. Eu e minha esposa editamos vídeos no Davince Resolve ao mesmo tempo e não gera nenhuma lentidão. Bacana.

@HiTechBR 2 года назад

@@aNetoo dá conta sim. Coloquei o meu com M2 e 32GB. Está top. E ainda compartilho ele com minha esposa por meio do ASTER. Duas sessões de Davinci rodando ao mesmo tempo.

@goregejones7248 2 года назад

You can increase igpu performance in amd by alloting more vram

@mathieuyelle5170 2 года назад

2:30 - 3:20 is when you find out this guy has an Intel bias. Also price, energy consumption, they come into play.

@dbreardon 2 года назад

I just caught on to this channel and have watch a number of video.......One of the few channels dedicated to content creation rather than gaming. I really am enjoying the information presented. But there are hundreds of thousands if not millions of people out there still shooting 1080p in h.264 using a flat profile. So that means in post, they add in contrast, saturation and sharpness......all of can significantly effect both timeline playback, scrubbing and final rendering. This video just doesn't address any of those issue, unfortunately. So, I would really like to see a video comparing the 3700X (which is getting more and more difficult to find in stock these days), the 5600X and the 5800X compete against each other with an nVidia 1070, 2070 and 3070 for 1080p h.264 footage shot in flat profile with saturation, contrast and sharpness added back in post for timeline playback, scrubbing and rendering times. Heck, throw in the 5700G for comparison. From what I have seen, from a variety of sources, the 5600 is the slowest, but the 3700x is only about 10 percent slower than the 5800X which costs a whopping 33% plus more than the 3700X, plus it doesn't even come with a CPU cooler. But I have never seen a good video were they compare all three CPU's together with the same footage and the same fx added back in (for flat profile) at 1080p Yes, a lot of people do shoot 4K these days, but there are still a ton of people out there with 1080p cameras out there.....the entire Canon rebel line and even many of their full frame cameras.

@hany_mohamed 2 года назад

Greetings to you, you have great knowledge and I want to collect some pieces in order to start over again. I was intending to buy 5600g and still 5700g I had in mind and I would like to update later what do you advise me?

@dbreardon 2 года назад

If you are going to for an apu, I would go with a 5700g. 2 more cores can make a big difference,@@hany_mohamed

@hany_mohamed 2 года назад

@@dbreardon True talk, but the price difference is $100 between them, and this is a bit big compared to the difference, and this amount can be invested in a separate card. What do you think?

@RubberontheroadIndonesia 8 месяцев назад

It's a shame you don't answer every bodies comments as there is a ton of queries out there.!!

@mertaltuncu8062 2 года назад

Hi my GPU is AMD Ryzen 5 5600G, in Premiere Pro GPU usage does not go above 10% Can you help please? (i chose Mercury playback enginie GPU acceleration)

@theTechNotice 2 года назад

Yes, coz your GPU can't accelerate everything, it depends what you do it goes up when it can accelerated your codecs (effects) workflow.

@mertaltuncu8062 2 года назад

@@theTechNotice ✌🏻😃

@buggerlugz6753 2 года назад

Just while your waiting for your new graphics card to arrive eh? Gonna be a long wait mate, init!

@theTechNotice 2 года назад

🤣🤣

@BastianSchick 2 года назад

Thanks for the video! Bzt please switch off the music.

@JeffStrides 2 года назад

I edited all my 3 channel videos with Ryzen 3 3200G with no dedicated GPU!!! It's hard but not impossible. 16 GB ram and above is the main key for these type of CPUs. Thanks for this comparison.

@lmhkt Год назад

More or less the same here... Doing edits for my school on a Lenovo Tiny mini PC with a Ryzen 5 PRO 3400GE using Sony ZV-E10 8 bit 4k footage. I get 0 frames dropped in full res with an adjustment layer for color/looks. Vega 11 also supports hardware accelerated encoding! It starts acting up with playback speed adjusts, complex motion graphics and some effects though.

@fabiorodriguez7490 Год назад

Great video, I'll buy a 5700g for editing

@aftech2148 Год назад

Ryzen is next level First 65watt is absolutely beast and 7nm

@unnamed7462 2 года назад

can i rung AutoCAD without a discrete graphics card? (only with this processor)

@bakaneko6639 2 года назад

2:20 you can't eat that !

@theunboxnetwork 2 года назад

Amd for gaming Intel for workstations and editing

@theTechNotice 2 года назад

I could argue it's the other way around usually... 🤔

@theunboxnetwork 2 года назад

@@theTechNotice agreed 👍

@infinitales1 2 года назад

What about in filmora 12600k vs 5700g

@soikotsarkar7863 Год назад

nice video love from bangladesh

@azureablaze8721 2 года назад

If you ask me AMD is win win. Here in my country i9 11900k is over 200€ more expensive than R7 5700g

@theTechNotice 2 года назад

Oh yeah 11900k definitely expensive.

@sridhartn83 2 года назад

I am surprised that you gave it to Intel, seemed more of like a draw.

@simplysurfing Год назад

Wait a minute !!! what a untenable "test".......hes just checking playback....thats all.....theres no color grade or fx or filters or anything.....not even sound fx and any overlays or text NOTHING......just the footage dropped on the timeline, one single track... and played back. My i3 (6100) plays this back without a single dropped frame.....hell it played back 2 DCI 4K 100mbps files simultaneously overlapped without a single frame drop ....NO DGPU.... ofcourse media drives were all SSD. But what a joke of a test. In the real world u would just drop a clip on the timeline and playback and smile and go for render ? No wonder he never replies to logical questions from viewers posted in the comments section.

@kiranprabhu003 9 месяцев назад

Yes bro this video is biased Just a pointless video 😅😅😅

@simplysurfing Год назад

He doesn't even say NOW OVER TO AMD or anything.....we are here.....nice and smooth (intel) and pressing play over here (its already switched to AMD) gotta keep my eyes stuck to the corner of the video as i watch ? Ive heard of seamless transitions....first time im seeing it on a demarcation between products.....he seamlessly weaves in and out that you dont know which one hes playing.