Тёмный

Vietnam War Films from the South Vietnamese (ARVN) Perspective 

Подписаться
Просмотров 24 тыс.
% 552

A compilation of narrative film scenes and sequences featuring the Army of the Republic of Vietnam (ARVN) in the Vietnam War from the 60s-70s.
Through the Hollywood romanticization of America's failure in Vietnam, propaganda and modern portrayals of the North Vietnamese perspective of the Vietnam War, almost little to none have ever tried to portray the full Vietnamese perspective in a respectful light. Usually the North Vietnamese are portrayed as effeminate and inhumane, and the South Vietnamese ARVN as careless and weak fighters.
Rarely has the South Vietnamese perspective, other than the Viet Cong, been portrayed in one of the most famous wars about them.
Only books such as Lotus and the Storm and The Sympathizer have tried to capture that, but not really in film.
I have only found two South Vietnamese films made during the war, using their military, to help with the film. One, the Purple Horizon, which was shown throughout Asia and won a nomination in a Taiwanese film festival. There could be more South Vietnamese perspective films, but I could not find any other ones that feature the ARVN fighting.
To try to make a South Vietnamese film today would be impossible due to its unpopularity in both Vietnam and the United States, as well as the funding and faith for the project.
It is interesting to note how although both were funded by the South Vietnamese military, it was not as overblown in some propagandist message as one might usually associate military/government funded projects. It was very expressive, but sometimes confused in its messages, especially Purple Horizon which had an ending that felt incomplete and more about how conflicting love is.
Films:
Người tình không chân dung; The Faceless Lover (1973)
- Takes place in the 1970s
Phim Chân Trời Tím; The Purple Horizon (1971)
- Takes place in the 1960s during the many coups in the South
- Since its first premiere in 1971, a classic Republic of Vietnam (1954-1975) war romance feature based on a fiction novel by military writer, Van-Quang. The film was lost for more than 4 decades when the communist forces took Saigon, Republic of Vietnam's capital, on April 30th, 1975. Digitized and restored from surviving 35mm prints archived by Japan film studio Imagica Lab; now transferred to UCLA Film and TV Archive.
Watch in 1080p on Amazon:
www.amazon.com/Chan-Troi-Tim-Purple-Horizon/dp/B0779KPC8M
I forgot that there's also the film, Land of Sorrows, Đất khổ, starring a famous Viet song writer on here that is also from the South Vietnamese perspective: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-uGtCuiTG6RA.html
there is a movie made in Hong Kong that's part of a crime series called A Better Tomorrow III - Love and Death in Saigon, which happens to be set during the last days of the Republic of Vietnam, but is all about over the top action.
Also one of the scenes used napalm from a Cessna A-37 Dragonfly from the ARVN airforce (RVNAF) which would be hard to recreate now lmao.
CPL Phi is South Vietnam's Rambo
I wish there was an IMDB firearms page on these two movies on what types of weapons and equipment the ARVN use in these films.
The Viet Cong seem to be using the American weapons in the Purple Horizon.
Right off the bat I know there's the Patton tanks, Huey Helicopters, Dragonfly Jet fighter bombers, Tiger Stripe and ERDL camo uniforms.
Only the Faceless Lover featured Americans and mentioning Thieu

Игры

Опубликовано:

 

7 мар 2021

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 74   
@Kabutoes
@Kabutoes 3 года назад
The Purple Horizon was clearly about the 1960s era, covering the issues in the country ranging from the Viet Cong, to the various coups, to the Buddhist persecution, to the civil war tearing apart their country. There was a lot of things going on down South.
@channelofthepeople-98
@channelofthepeople-98 Год назад
Wow, i am glad you found some rare and obscure films based on ARVN perspective.
@tanatngo1946
@tanatngo1946 3 года назад
Republic of vietnam forever
@mlagamer8698
@mlagamer8698 3 года назад
Agree
@cooldude7062
@cooldude7062 2 года назад
but vnch no exist no more 🥺😆
@iosifvissarionovichstalin3895
@iosifvissarionovichstalin3895 2 года назад
Like 20 years omegalul
@tanatngo1946
@tanatngo1946 2 года назад
@@cooldude7062 vnch is still alive in the hearts of Vietnamese people who love freedom and democracy
@cooldude7062
@cooldude7062 2 года назад
@@tanatngo1946 ok what’s the capital of vietnam then… what’s saigon called now? 😆😆😆
@hoppinggnomethe4154
@hoppinggnomethe4154 2 года назад
Thank you for sharing. It really makes me sad looking at these footage. We were once the Oriental Pearl of South East Asia, and Singapore and South Korea ain't nothing at that time. Thanks to the withdrawal of the Americans and the Paris Peace Accords violation done by the ComNorth, we are no more.
@Kabutoes
@Kabutoes 2 года назад
History is complicated but I have hope for the future which is always ever changing
@hoppinggnomethe4154
@hoppinggnomethe4154 2 года назад
@@Kabutoes Thank you for your positive reply
@edwardle4493
@edwardle4493 Год назад
You wrong. South Korea was already richer than South Vietnam in the early 70s and Seoul look more glamorous than Saigon in 70s. You can look at Seoul 1970 image from Google to compare. If you search the youtube video "Asian Economies : Nominal GDP 1960 - 2020 (the source is IMF and World Bank)", South Vietnam's economy is not even in the top ten in ASIA. During Ngo Dinh Diem and Nguyen Van Thieu, the nation was plagued with high corruption, incompetent leaders, weak export, and lack of unity between people preventing them from growing to their fullest despite being richer than their Northern neighbor. Notice South Korea's economy did not really start to grow much until Park Chung Hee take control of the country and eliminate corruption as well as implemented several economic plans in which the people trust him and do exactly as he wanted despite being a dictator. South Vietnam Government did not have the support from the majority of the people in the South. They are not willing to donate anything to the government when the country encounter an economic crisis in 1970 to reduce inflation. South Korean people donated gold to their government during Asian financial crisis in 1997 which help them recover and grow. The situation in South Vietnam could get better though only if the leader ruled with a heavy hand to eliminate corruption and unify the people together. The cooperation between people and a capable government is what drives the country to a better future. South Vietnam is unlucky that none of that happen when they were still exist, despite receiving so much economic aid from the US.
@Kabutoes
@Kabutoes 3 года назад
Actually there is a movie made in Hong Kong that's part of a crime series called A Better Tomorrow III - Love and Death in Saigon, which happens to be set during the last days of the Republic of Vietnam, but is all about over the top action. Bullet in the Head is another one of the same vain, but more insane and dark. I also forgot that there's also the film, Land of Sorrows, Đất khổ, starring a famous Viet song writer on here that is also from the South Vietnamese perspective
@MyChocow
@MyChocow 3 года назад
The good old days when south Vietnam was free
@kokonut743
@kokonut743 3 года назад
ikr, communist vietnam is horrible. Full of corruptions and abuse of power.
@MyChocow
@MyChocow 3 года назад
@@kokonut743 all forms of government are corrupted, just somes hides it better than others.
@mrhdm5408
@mrhdm5408 2 года назад
it's not like modern vietnam is an economic hellhole, problably in the top 30 highest growing country in the world so it proves that the communist party does care for its people
@MyChocow
@MyChocow 2 года назад
I think Vietam communist care for their people more than any other communist party....keep in mind in 1979 Vietnam has a mini war with China....communist vs communist.
@CustodianHadrian
@CustodianHadrian 2 года назад
@@mrhdm5408 Except Vietnam got rid of communism after the USSR fell, and that's when their economy started getting better, so...
@johnquick4880
@johnquick4880 2 месяца назад
Wow this is rare, we never got to see the other side point of view back then, it was pre internet.
@JimmyVo-nr2sv
@JimmyVo-nr2sv 20 дней назад
I remember a scene that Cô Kiều Chinh read the letters "Tôi có một quê nhà và một mẹ già ..." , that scene bring tears to my eyes.
@Long-Hai-252
@Long-Hai-252 3 года назад
"Người tình không chân dung" tài tử Kiều Chinh thủ vai diễn chính.
@blueliqqqo8018
@blueliqqqo8018 Год назад
I love my nation South VietNam so much. Coz too much enemies my nation be killed so painful. Justice for Republic of VietNam.
@johnhungg
@johnhungg 4 месяца назад
Bro said you love your nation but ran like a dog in 1975
@HNHanRyang
@HNHanRyang 2 месяца назад
@@johnhungg ran away from killer
@hoangnam6048
@hoangnam6048 3 года назад
The main actor name is Hung Cuong.
@Kabutoes
@Kabutoes 3 года назад
Sorry the comment you posted before didn’t show up could you post it again?
@hoangnam6048
@hoangnam6048 3 года назад
ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-SkX7gHo-doE.html
@Kabutoes
@Kabutoes 3 года назад
@@hoangnam6048 thanks I’ll take a look. what’s it about again? I remembered you explained it before but I didn’t get to read it
@hoangnam6048
@hoangnam6048 3 года назад
@@Kabutoes The film name is Ván bài lật ngửa(The Flipping Card) The story is about a Vietcong spy in the South Vietnamese government,Even it is a communist‘s propaganda film, it still quite accurately describes South Vietnamese society during the Diem period. Also,this film has the same director with Purple Horizon.
@Kabutoes
@Kabutoes 3 года назад
@@hoangnam6048 wow that is a very interesting fact, when was this film made since the director is the same?
@vuthien9342
@vuthien9342 3 года назад
They are hero my country .
@mlagamer8698
@mlagamer8698 3 года назад
Yes ARVN a fallen kingdom
@tedmccarron
@tedmccarron 3 года назад
Interesting. I wish I could have seen the whole film.
@Kabutoes
@Kabutoes 3 года назад
They’re both free on RU-vid look them up
@vuongquocanhk16_hl79
@vuongquocanhk16_hl79 7 месяцев назад
5:09: Ca sĩ Hùng Cường kìa
@davenguyen1968
@davenguyen1968 3 года назад
Thank you
@tamdan5832
@tamdan5832 2 года назад
Republic of Vietnam important ❤️❤️❤️
@Kori-shimotori344
@Kori-shimotori344 15 дней назад
For those who claim the South was weak, the ARVN were effective, it's just that the advisors trained them for the war wrongfully, had poor commanders and corrupt comrades. The Phoenix program, tiller reform, Combined action program, Vietnamization and Easter offensive were all successful, in Repelling and defeating the VC and PAVN while also ensuring the South support, If the US invaded Laos and Cambodia for the HCMT, before entering Vietnam, never conducts S&D and continue and Expand CAP and Phoenix program, conducting Vietnamization and the Land to the Tiller reform early, defend the DMZ, invading only dong hoi and Quang Binh, while allowing the Japanese to Assist the US(By breaking the treaty) and Fortifying the South Further would've allowed the RVN(Republic of Vietnam), KOC(Kingdom Of Cambodia) & KOL(Kingdom Of Laos to survive and Stablize. They would've been prosperous, the 3 countries repelling communism would've let the US gain more confidence, and the world today wouldn't be socially divided while also being slightly safer, Richer, cheaper, smarter, and more prosperous.
@Kabutoes
@Kabutoes 15 дней назад
@@Kori-shimotori344 it’s very multifaceted conflict indeed, geography is probably the greatest obstacle as well. But where did you get the idea Japan could help? Did they show interest in it somewhere?
@Kori-shimotori344
@Kori-shimotori344 15 дней назад
@@Kabutoes I came up with then idea, some people answered on quora
@Kori-shimotori344
@Kori-shimotori344 14 дней назад
@@Kabutoes the idea of the Japanese joining was due to their Industrialization, morale, Hand to hand, and experience generals. In reality there were not allow to join in any war unless it was self defense, but even if Japan broke the treaty, The people wouldn't want to join any war
@RS-rj5sh
@RS-rj5sh 6 месяцев назад
Anyone know name of the lady at end, was she famous South Vietnamese actress?
@nguoioi1236
@nguoioi1236 Месяц назад
Kieu Chinh
@kjnguyen1385
@kjnguyen1385 Год назад
From late 1960s and early 1970s ARVN got their new weapons m16 rifle car 15 carbine m60 machine guns
@tranduyduytran2938
@tranduyduytran2938 3 года назад
Nice
@kjnguyen1385
@kjnguyen1385 Год назад
ARVN armed with old ww2/Korean war weapons like m1 garands m1/m2 carbine bar m1918 Thompson smg during early war
@squadcode71
@squadcode71 2 года назад
Nice film about ARVN, but just have to concern if the films portraying ARVN are illegal in Vietnam
@Kabutoes
@Kabutoes 2 года назад
There’s a lot of movies in Vietnam based on the Vietnam war mostly between ARVN and VC/PAVN since it’s kinda hard at the time to find American actors, sometimes dignified some times they wear beards (symbol of laziness)
@Franco_the_notable
@Franco_the_notable 2 года назад
My grandfather actually Ngô Đình Diệm
@hoppinggnomethe4154
@hoppinggnomethe4154 2 года назад
troll
@Franco_the_notable
@Franco_the_notable Год назад
@@hoppinggnomethe4154 red bastard
@horse_face3019
@horse_face3019 2 года назад
Was that the end???
@Kabutoes
@Kabutoes 2 года назад
I will make another one based on Hollywood films and another based on other asian films including ones made in United vietnam probably
@binguyen2277
@binguyen2277 Год назад
Hùng Cường trong phim chân trời tím,,
@tuanthanhtran8147
@tuanthanhtran8147 Год назад
❤❤❤❤❤❤
@RobertGuyen
@RobertGuyen 5 месяцев назад
Phim hay qua ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
@binguyen2277
@binguyen2277 Год назад
KBC 4671
@buikhan
@buikhan Год назад
The acting never changes with my people, even today. Oh well.