Тёмный
No video :(

VIEWERS Rank Sekai Songs [AS OF 10/11/22] 

MarceCloud 39!
Подписаться 12 тыс.
Просмотров 39 тыс.
50% 1

Shortly after making my own rankings of every Sekai Cover/Original song ( • Ranking ALL 163 ProSek... ) I made a poll asking as many people as possible to fill out with several categories for ranking Sekai's songs and other related things. I got a total of 835 responses, with only 3 of the 9 categories being optional. I plan to do this again next year so if you disagree with the results, be sure to subscribe to be in the know for when you can give your input!
discord server (we have Sekai dedicated channels!- they broke any ties that this survey had!): / discord
The Categories
---------------------
0:00 - Intro
0:26 - Top 50 Best Sekai Cover/Original Songs
7:45 - Top 10 Worst Sekai Cover/Original Songs
9:33 - Top 10 Best Sekai Alt Vocals
13:16 - Top 5 Best VS Alt Vocals
14:39 - Top 10 Best VS Only Songs
17:32 - Top 10 3DMVs
20:10 - Top 10 2DMVs
22:48 - Top 5 CD Improved Songs
25:34 - Top 5 Best Vocalists
27:12 - Outro
__________________
Outro Music:
Title: Doitagain
Composer: 円盤P (Enban-P)
Game: Hatsune Miku: Project DIVA Future Tone

Опубликовано:

 

17 авг 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 601   
@delulu_soup
@delulu_soup Год назад
the fact the half of the "worst" songs are actually my favourite songs wtf
@fishfard
@fishfard Год назад
same💔
@zhekaichong4934
@zhekaichong4934 Год назад
Me too except number 10 and roki
@rileyw19
@rileyw19 Год назад
FR LIKE ROKI, TEO, LAW EVADING ROCK, OTOME DISECTION, FORWARD AND BRING IT ON??
@Jordan-Ramses
@Jordan-Ramses Год назад
I like the best and worst list pretty equally. I'm going to give the voters the benefit of the doubt and say that they didn't like that version of Otome Dissection and not the song itself. Or it could just be song fatigue? If you hear any song too many times you're going to hate it. No matter how great it is. I lived in Seattle in the 90s. It was 30 years before I could hear 'Smells like teen spirit' without hating it.
@mxilraa
@mxilraa Год назад
YES,I DON'T KNOW BUT WHY MUST LOST ONE'S WEEPING,JUST BE FRIENDS,TEO AND BRING IT ON!?!?!?!?!?!?C'MON I KNOW WE ALL HAVE A DIFFERENT TASTE BUT-
@charcoalify
@charcoalify Год назад
I’m genuinely so sad to see Lost One’s Weeping at worst, it’s my favorite song and I don’t understand why people so heavily dislike it 😢
@charcoalify
@charcoalify Год назад
I’m thinking that it’s likely because of Ichika’s harmony in the non-alt version. It doesn’t clash well with Shiho’s singing, so I can somewhat see the dislike for that. Still, the non-alt song is super amazing, and I feel like there are MANY worse songs. But seriously Shiho’s cover for that song is the best thing to have ever graced my ears.
@jayren9838
@jayren9838 Год назад
I always thought Ichikas high notes always suited shihos lower voice idk
@charcoalify
@charcoalify Год назад
@@jayren9838 True! Although I personally find it to be a bit odd sounding in Lost One’s Weeping, but that’s just my opinion.
@galaxydoesartz2395
@galaxydoesartz2395 Год назад
Honestly I don’t like the Sekai ver that much because it doesn’t hit the same way that the original does. Idk, it just feels weaker
@Yunanarts
@Yunanarts Год назад
Ahhhhh lost one’s weeping and just be friends are my favorite songs! Also where’s Sasei on the top 50??
@ceve
@ceve Год назад
Aun no Beats is still my number one song in the game. I just love the cover, it hits all of my heartstrings and I hope a full version is released
@taffyblxxm3408
@taffyblxxm3408 Год назад
Dr. Funkbeat's rating surprised me A LOT (I thought it would've atleast made 2dmv but apperantly not 😭)
@squishydishy1593
@squishydishy1593 Год назад
RIGHT????
@shortkq
@shortkq Год назад
the animation is so good bro
@darcy___
@darcy___ 11 месяцев назад
THE MV IS SO GOOD I HAD TO PAUSE TO ADMIRE EACH FRAME BRO
@twilightsine1998
@twilightsine1998 Год назад
As a REAL Mafuyu's Bug voter, I wanna talk about why I like it. Of course I cannot change how y''all feel about the alt vocal, I just want to say that I do not have the niigo bias nor character bias. I like the cover because it kind of reflects the chaotic and about-to-collapse mentality of Mafuyu, and my ears don't find it bad. I feel her strong feelings through the vocal. But it's okay to have different opinion. I also get some very unpopular opinion, like I never enjoy Showtime Ruler since my ears find it too noisy, no matter how many times I listen to it. But I won't judge it as a bad song because it's only my own feeling. I hope I have made my point clear that not all voters for Mafuyu's Bug alt vocal are biased because of the unit or character who sings it. (disclaimer: I am a WS fan XD)
@MarceCloud39
@MarceCloud39 Год назад
I feel like the Mafuyu Bug voters are less biased than the Smile ID 3D MV voters (I voted for it myself, but uh, do not think it should have had the chance to beat Ego Rock 💀)- hence the heart. Also bc I like to encourage not overly mean discussion in general.
@EveIrkens
@EveIrkens Год назад
Honestly I agree about Mafuyus alt. It's chaotic and very messy. But I love it. There are Sekai alts that I really don't like because they come off at best underwhelming and at worse, literally hurt my ears. Her alt isn't one of them. I feel like it like it fits the character and the song really well.
@yuakim
@yuakim Год назад
Seeing Rui as one of best the vocalists but not Haruka, Ichika, Nene and Toya baffles me so much... 😨
@MarceCloud39
@MarceCloud39 Год назад
I am actually severely disappointed in some of the results, but not because they don't match my own opinions (there’s a lot of that too tho lol). I'm disappointed because people blatantly ignored what the category was just to vote for their favorite group/character. This isn't me being salty, I know for a fact that this is exactly what happened. Towards the very end a TON of Mizuki related things had their rankings jump massively- in every single category. If it weren't limited to one per Google account I'd say it felt like someone botted it- it was that severe and sudden (I checked, it appears there was no botting involved, but there was a massive influx within the last 2 days). The most overtly noticeable jumps being USSEEWA going from 31st to 26th place (this is inoffensive) and Ego Rock's 3DMV 1st place lead going from being a landslide to being by only 6 votes (this is what I have a problem with). This might sound accusatory and conspiratorial to you so I actually have further evidence of this being the case... People voted for the Tondemo Wonderz 2DMV before I removed it as an option. It wasn't out yet, I removed it because of the delay, and yet it got votes before said delay. I only put the survey out earlier than originally intended because I got a hit Sekai related tweet and wanted to take advantage of it to get more respondents. This wasn’t a problem for the other commission song 2DMVs that were a part of the anniversary celebration and not yet released. WxS stans are just going to vote for anything Tondemo related, even if they hadn't seen the 2DMV yet because they’re just that biased it seems. It's obnoxious for me, someone that wants REAL results for the Best 2DMVs, not stan culture nonsense. I wanted people to vote based on the quality of the video itself, not what song it is or who's singing in it. For example, the Dreamin Chuchu cover is not good, but it has a very nice 2DMV so credit where credit is due. Some of the results are BAFFLING to me unless people are merely stanning (some results, not all- I believe a good chunk are understandable even if it’s not how I'd personally vote). Stan culture is plague and I hope if people are reading this in 2023 they will choose to actually vote how the category is asking you to judge. Best Song is for the songs by the groups/characters you stan, Best Vocalist is for what characters you think sing the best, and Best MVs are for what MVs you think are visually the best- *regardless* of what song is being sung (the first two categories feel voted for accurately/properly, the last one does not). Obviously there’s going to be overlap with fave songs and fave MVs, but these results are so inconsistent in a way that it’s clear that song bias was strong in categories where it shouldn’t have been (seriously, Journey for 2DMV but not Ultramarine Hymn??? They’re BOTH animated segments of the game’s stories. What’s the difference other than the song itself??? I cannot imagine the thought process of voting one but not the other unless you’re judging the song which you weren’t supposed to be). I thought my instructions on the survey itself were clear about all this, but I guess some people just do not read. That’s why I’m disappointed. 😐
@MarceCloud39
@MarceCloud39 Год назад
@#1RuiKasa Fan Yeah if it’s actually a favorite MV that’s fine! When you see the results you’ll see some MVs that are lackluster next to some of the others they’re in the Top 10 with and stan culture feels like the only possible explanation for why those known fan favorite songs were pushed so high over other songs that probably deserved it more (like I said, Journey is in the Top 10 2DMVs but Ultramarine Hymn isn’t??? Make it make sense 😭)
@mooniecake
@mooniecake Год назад
I honestly voted which mv I thought was the best but I haven’t seen every mv and I haven’t heard every song lmao It’s really annoying how they probably just picked chars cuz they liked them not their voice or picked mvs based on the group
@MarceCloud39
@MarceCloud39 Год назад
@@mooniecake That’s exactly what happened as evidenced by what happened with Tondemo’s 2DMV. It’s a mix of MVs you’d expect to be there because they’re worthy from the obvious high effort put into them and MVs ranked higher than they probably should be because of the song itself is a fan favorite. I had forgotten to mention extends further down the rankings beyond what I show, like Top 20 instead of just Top 10 so my disappointment will most likely run deeper than anyone else’s.
@gracejudith8643
@gracejudith8643 Год назад
It could be an artstyle thing for Ultramarine vs Journey?? Idk, I slightly prefer the Ultramarine artstyle but I'd still vote for both because they're fully animated
@velionya
@velionya Год назад
Sure I like mizuki as a character, but the amount of things they won shows the amount of bias towards them. Sure my votes probably had a bit of bias towards ichika (quite sad about her results) but most of the other top songs and covers very much deserved their place
@MarceCloud39
@MarceCloud39 Год назад
HEY YOU! YES *YOU*! Be sure to come back here around October 10th to partake in THIS YEAR'S survey! I will be posting the link as a pinned comment as soon as it's open to the public! Let's aim for 1000 participants this year!
@starrshort6403
@starrshort6403 Год назад
Omg yes
@dragonz2574
@dragonz2574 Год назад
See you there!
@starrshort6403
@starrshort6403 Год назад
@@dragonz2574 yea!!
@epislog178
@epislog178 Год назад
Of course
@zenlingkok9740
@zenlingkok9740 10 месяцев назад
It's around timeeeee
@whynot4929
@whynot4929 Год назад
girl i'm shocked that the ray, bokura mada underground, and doctor funk beat 2dmvs didn't make it on the top 10.....
@MarceCloud39
@MarceCloud39 Год назад
BMG got 110 so it was close, but people treated it like a song popularity contest when the prompt of the section literally said to only focus on the video quality 💀
@cellokopi
@cellokopi Год назад
@@MarceCloud39 ikr its literally a whole ass anime in itself
@gorgeousinlonely
@gorgeousinlonely Год назад
the lack of haruka :(( i think she really has one of the best voices unfortunately i feel like she doesn't get the attention she deserves, but it's whatever. great vid!! thanks for getting this out!!!! also i really did NOT expect the shiho kagerou daze alt vocal, out of all of her alt vocals i really don't think it's a stand out? also CANNOT believe that mafuyus bug alt vocal was so highly rated it's one of her weakest. anyways im glad that haruka wasn't dead last for the vocalists at least
@justanotherrainyday9213
@justanotherrainyday9213 Год назад
Haruka's IF solo is amazing.
@in_somnium
@in_somnium Год назад
@@justanotherrainyday9213 frfr the people who did not vote it are now my enemies
@andieamigu5214
@andieamigu5214 Год назад
Also Minori, her voice is so cute but not in a annoying way, it's actually calming 🥺
@topiaz
@topiaz Год назад
Haruka is such a good vocalist tbh
@saturn4264
@saturn4264 Год назад
Ichika too. I was surprised she wasn't in the top. Her vocal is powerful. Gunjo Sanka, Hibana, Six Trillion years are examples of her good voice
@EveKamishiro
@EveKamishiro Год назад
Dappo Rock is an awesome cover, it gives a ton of power to Daisuke's and Toki's voices, and theyr'e super good. I don't get why is it highly disliked.
@MarceCloud39
@MarceCloud39 Год назад
It’s all because of Len sounding terrible in the game ver. He single-handedly ruins it for a lot of people. I am desperate for solo alts (also because let Rui say “fuck” too lol). At least they fixed him in the album version so he’s not so grating during those awful chorus moments.
@saturnmoth4807
@saturnmoth4807 Год назад
@@MarceCloud39 im so confused, he literally doesnt sound horrible at all he basically sounds the same way he did in the og
@nxpstablook
@nxpstablook Год назад
@@saturnmoth4807 ikr!!
@NUISANCE_ANIMAL
@NUISANCE_ANIMAL Год назад
I just don’t like it because they did that thing where they pitch it down slightly.
@EveIrkens
@EveIrkens Год назад
Lens tuning is baaaad. That's how alot of sekai covers end up through. Everything else is good but the tuning is just off on the VS.
@SurpriseLily831
@SurpriseLily831 Год назад
I don't understand why Otome Dissection is so hated😭
@fishfard
@fishfard Год назад
frr its one of my fave pjsekai songs
@kakyoinnoriyaki6393
@kakyoinnoriyaki6393 Год назад
Compared to Deco*27 ver, it sounds weird.
@shizuaireal
@shizuaireal Год назад
SAME I LOVE IT -🍰💝
@scream19961
@scream19961 Год назад
the cover sucks
@apollosdread
@apollosdread Год назад
it's been stuck in my head for the past few days, i love it
@chloeisabellabalusa8895
@chloeisabellabalusa8895 Год назад
the voters bias is so unreal 😭
@moraghraikenori1139
@moraghraikenori1139 Год назад
Then again, it is really hard to be objective when it comes to video or audio performances, but I agree some of this is kind of ridiculous.
@urmom.com___
@urmom.com___ Год назад
the fact that 1 MMJ 3DMV got on the best baffles me. What happens to Kakuri Perriot and Shojo Rei? MMJ mvs are criminally underrated.
@Error-gz3pp
@Error-gz3pp Год назад
It was Romeo and Cinderella too, which while not a bad MV was almost definitely only there because of the ship moment. Karakuri Pierrot is such a good 3DMV too…
@starrshort6403
@starrshort6403 Год назад
AGREE
@theodorech20
@theodorech20 Год назад
I kind of fear when most of Leo/need and MMJ songs are in bottom, even though L/n has many excellent songs and MMJ excels so much in covers (i am Leoniigo fan BTW, but every unit has something great so i decided to pick at least one song for each unit) Also slower songs like Saisei might be very low too...
@MarceCloud39
@MarceCloud39 Год назад
The Worst 10 doesn’t include any song for being slow. There’s only 3 L/n songs in the Top 50 tho, all 3 being commission songs. At least MMJ did better. No songs in the worst and they have 6 in the Top 50- 3 comms, 3 covers. The biggest W L/n has is one of their vocalists doing something that otherwise only Mizuki was able to achieve in rankings: multiple songs in the Top 10 Best Alts. Also something cute is that every group has one of their members in the Top 5 Vocalists. That’s the *one* category where everyone seems to have been treated as equals as proven by the results. I even generally agree with it for my own personal rankings minus the absence of a different MMJ member that I would put as my favorite vocalist overall.
@scraccarcs4077
@scraccarcs4077 Год назад
@@MarceCloud39 HARUKA!
@gummymarkers
@gummymarkers Год назад
to all sekai fans: i love you, you all are like family to me. i appreciate everyone in this community ... but yall are weird man like cmon bug as the best 2dmv what are you thinking sincerely a concerned leo/need fan
@gracejudith8643
@gracejudith8643 Год назад
Bug's MV has a very pleasing artstyle and i love all the graphical touches with the glitches and the way the characters spin on the line about spinning But that's my graphic designer brain putting some justification on it. Peaky Peaky would be my Number 1 based PURELY on how slick the motion graphics are
@8pierrot89
@8pierrot89 Год назад
?????? i appreciate 2DMVs that can "do a lot" with minimal graphics - that's the old vocaloid way and you can't convince me it's not good??
@dissonantcity8710
@dissonantcity8710 Год назад
tbh I agree there are so many better ones. I feel like people voted for it cause the song is such a banger
@delulu_soup
@delulu_soup Год назад
bug 2dmv is really good but theres other good 2dmvs from other bands like l/n
@loveloveaii
@loveloveaii Год назад
I love Bug but man the 2dmv really wasnt THAT good
@brii6644
@brii6644 Год назад
I voted for mafuyu bug solo and the reason why I like it it's for the interpretation, how her voice starts to get stronger as the song goes and the chaotic vibe it gives me. I just really find it pleasant to hear.
@lselm244
@lselm244 Год назад
There arent any MMJ songs on the 2DMV section, the N25 and WxS bias is too real 💀 Im surprised ID Smile didnt appear on that section tho, since it appeared on all of the other ones
@MarceCloud39
@MarceCloud39 Год назад
My guess? It’s too new and unlike WxS stans who voted for Tondemo’s before I removed it bc of the delay, Niigo stans have some principles and didn’t vote for an MV they haven’t seen yet.
@dumbpablo5755
@dumbpablo5755 Год назад
IKR ITS A CRIME i love niigo and wxs BUT WHERE IS PARASOL CIDER ON #1 ITS SUCH A GOOD MV
@yuakim
@yuakim Год назад
WHERE IS DREAM PLACE AND PARASOL CIDER 😭😭😭‼️‼️‼️
@yoisakis.
@yoisakis. Год назад
​@@dumbpablo5755 I KNOW I LOVE PARASOL CIDER SM
@aspnn
@aspnn Год назад
i get that you have no control over the votes but please project sekai fandom,, only 3 leoneed songs in the top 50 rankings?? 😭😭 in my opinion leoneed has the top (if not the best) songs in the game but its obvious how many people in the fandom completely ignore them and forget about them ☹
@aspnn
@aspnn Год назад
LEONEED GOT SHOWED UP MORE IN THE TOP TEN WORST SONGS THAN THE TOP 50 BEST…..😟😟
@in_somnium
@in_somnium Год назад
the wave 1 covers were kinda meh but the latest songs they had absolutely slapped (lost and found, calc, voices, etc.)
@sofiaklmpks
@sofiaklmpks Год назад
@denjistoast personally i would vote it low but only bc if the sekai cover. i ADORE the og ver of lost one's weeping, but the sekai cover is pretty weak. but yeah, leoneed solos
@starlightparades
@starlightparades Год назад
honami mochizuki
@rb.v
@rb.v Год назад
The project sekai fans really appreciated shizukus vocals I wasn’t expecting that..
@rb.v
@rb.v Год назад
Rui doesn’t deserve his place though, he’s good but the fact that he’s higher than ena and akito is concerning. He was only there because people liked him and not that he actually sang good tbh
@kirbbb1995
@kirbbb1995 Год назад
@@rb.v the fact that nene wasn't there is the real crime
@rb.v
@rb.v Год назад
@@kirbbb1995 IKR, replace Rui with nene and we’re good to go
@tsrkfn
@tsrkfn Год назад
@@rb.v I was half expecting Tsukasa to be there because people always put him so high in voice rankings and that probably would've been worse. I don't agree with Akito though, I like him as a character but his VA is rather new so I wouldn't consider him a top 5 (no hate to Imai ofc)
@projectashe2593
@projectashe2593 Год назад
I genuinely love Rui’s voice and have all his alts on my playlist, it is the most pleasing voice to me 😕
@Diomu_
@Diomu_ Год назад
Yesterday I saw Marce's comment and thought: it can't be that bad, she's exaggerating but now... i totally agree 💀
@Otaku0129
@Otaku0129 Год назад
I'm really hoping that Ichika will get top 5 vocalist one day.
@MarceCloud39
@MarceCloud39 Год назад
She made Top 10! …as #10, but at least she’s in the Top 10 at all
@andieamigu5214
@andieamigu5214 Год назад
@@MarceCloud39 YES! That makes me feel better somehow 💙
@LegoCityFilms
@LegoCityFilms Год назад
SHES MY FAVORITE
@hickorydaisy4117
@hickorydaisy4117 Год назад
Whoever didn’t vote for Cup Noodle Prohibition for 2D MV is either blind, or a global player who has never been blessed by this wondrous gem. Probably blind, given that the winning song isn’t on global servers either. I know I’m probably strange, complaining about the placement of a song that came in second, but you get what I’m saying, right?
@granddragon5330
@granddragon5330 Год назад
no, personally, you are completely right
@in_somnium
@in_somnium Год назад
they went blind seeing the 2dmv /j
@Qilinkasa
@Qilinkasa Год назад
They still don't know how vocaloid MV can be silly and fun sometime
@in_somnium
@in_somnium Год назад
the lack of honami made me lose faith in humanity other than that shiho slayed
@vbsenthusiast
@vbsenthusiast Год назад
so true
@MarceCloud39
@MarceCloud39 Год назад
Since it's the shortest category of all of them- here's the FULL results for best Vocalist 1. Mizuki Akiyama - 568 (68%) 2. Rui Kamishiro - 407 (48.7%) 3. Shiho Hinomori - 374 (44.8%) 4. Shizuku Hinomori - 368 (44.1%) 5. Akito Shinonome - 343 (41.1%) 6. Ena Shinonome - 342 (41%) 7. Toya Aoyagi - 308 (36.9%) 8. Nene Kusanagi - 273 (32.7%) 9. Kanade Yoisaki - 268 (31.1%) [best wishes to her VA] 10. Ichika Hoshino - 264 (31.6%) 11. An Shiraishi - 255 (30.5%) 12. Mafuyu Asahina - 250 (29.9%) 13. Tsukasa Tenma - 226 (27.1%) 14. Kohane Azusawa - 204 (24.4%) 15. Haruka Kiritani - 200 (24%) 16. Airi Momoi - 132 (15.8%) 17. Emu Otori - 130 (15.6%) 18. Honami Mochizuki - 105 (12.6%) 19. Saki Tenma - 97 (11.6%) 20. Minori Hanasato - 73 (8.7%)
@gooeyshears4721
@gooeyshears4721 Год назад
Poor Minori. Even out of universe she's unlucky and unpopular
@AustinWithAHead
@AustinWithAHead Год назад
What happened to kanade’s voice actor?
@rb.v
@rb.v Год назад
Rui doesn’t deserve his place.. not because he’s a bad singer but because he’s higher than Akito and Ena
@goodnightprince
@goodnightprince Год назад
HONAMI AND KOHANE THAT LOW?? me personally i would never allow that
@justanotherrainyday9213
@justanotherrainyday9213 Год назад
Why is Rui so high? It's not like I think he has a bad voice, but there are better vocalists.
@id10cyy
@id10cyy Год назад
how do people hate just be friends 💔 its legit so good
@romin8829
@romin8829 Год назад
I love the best singers just having stunning voices and excellent control of their vocal cords and then there's Rui Also, the Shinonomes war for the 5th place is so in character for them lol
@MarceCloud39
@MarceCloud39 Год назад
I know! Ena was winning for most of it, but Akito had his moments and got it in the end. The best vocalist category was actually the main one I scrolled to whenever I saw the amount of responses rise because I had to know which sibling was winning. It was somewhat entertaining.
@yarshmellow2323
@yarshmellow2323 Год назад
Honestly idk why people like Rui's voice so much when the rest of the top 5 outclass him so much.
@amira.6942
@amira.6942 Год назад
i agree that in the song chosen at that part he sounds boring but majority of the time he sounds so good what
@romin8829
@romin8829 Год назад
​@@amira.6942 I maybe expressed myself badly, sorry. I didn't mean to say that he sounds bad. What I meant to say is that Rui's singing isn't so different than the average person, while the others have a pretty good vocal control. Rui's singing shines not because of his skills but because of his voice, so charismatic that it covers for it.
@amira.6942
@amira.6942 Год назад
@@romin8829 ohhhh i see you’re right
@nxpstablook
@nxpstablook Год назад
HELLO?? CHILDREN RECORD?? WHY IS THAT BANGER SO LOW Edit: not the Mizuki stans clogging up the top 10 alts 😭 Edit 2: IM SO GLAD SHIHO GOT IN THE TOP 10 ALTS SM SHES SO UNDERRATED Final edit/thoughts: Man the WxS and Niigo stans kinda ruined this one for me. The 3dmvs and 2dmvs were not fair in my opinion. Like all the 3dmvs were just WxS and HOW ON EARTH did Bug get 1st for 3dmvs?!?!!!????? How is Doctor = Funk Beat not top 5 for the 2dmvs? AND WHY IS EVERYONE SO BIASED 😭 Loving the shiho appreciation though. I am still mad about Children Record however. And sad about how under appreciated VBS is. And dappou rock! It slaps!
@borderlinecase
@borderlinecase Год назад
this comment is completely how i feel 🥲
@Error-gz3pp
@Error-gz3pp Год назад
Honestly I think the dev team was experimenting with Wondershow’s 3DMVs, which is why they’re generally more unique from the other ones (the use of a different stage layout for almost every song and stuff like the acting implemented into Smile Survey Team, the most energetic choreography between the five groups, and the way Ego Rock’s 3DMV mirrors the original MV). That being said, I think stan culture definitely played into Wondershow being so dominant over the 3DMV category. I mean, I like Showtime Ruler, but I don’t really think it should be in the top 10. And honestly, while I may be biased since Tondemo-Wonderz is a plague on my already declining mental health, I don’t think Tondemo-Wonderz should be in the top 10 for 3DMV either. It’s fun and energetic, but I personally find As You Like It and Chururira Chururira Daddadda more fun. I completely agree for the 2DMV thing. How Bug got first in 2DMVs is beyond me since it’s basically a bog-standard Proseka 2DMV + some glitchy effects, and same for Doctor=Funk Beat not making top 10 at the very least (despite the song itself being… debatably bad, the 2DMV is quite good). I’m surprised that animated MVs like Bokura Mada Underground, Journey, Gunjou Sanka, and Tokugawa Cup Noodle Ban didn’t end up topping the list. Hell, I’m personally of the opinion that Cinema’s effects are better than Bug’s. I think Bug only got voted for best 2DMV because the song itself is basically the most popular in the whole game.
@nxpstablook
@nxpstablook Год назад
@@Error-gz3pp I completely agree! Wondershow is cool, but the top 10 was ridiculous
@riajuu5046
@riajuu5046 Год назад
I'm here maybe to give some insights on what people's thought regarding Bug that wins 2DMV category. The thing is people don't watch all the 2DMVs available on RU-vid or even during gameplay (device issues). In RU-vid too, I bet people just watch songs that they like while songs like Dreamin' Chu Chu which considerably bad, people would not watch that MV so hence they would not vote for it since they don't know the MV's quality. I think people just vote based on what they had watched. So Bug being no 1 is not surprising (although such an unfortunate) since it is the most popular song and many people watched the MV too. And the votings format for the section is we can choose multiple options. Maybe people not considering it the best, but since we can choose 15 options (cmiiw), people just include it no matter what.
@hickorydaisy4117
@hickorydaisy4117 Год назад
If a song has both a 3D and a 2D MV, I don’t usually ever watch the 2D one… I like getting to see all the costumes I own, you know?
@squishydishy1593
@squishydishy1593 Год назад
Right, I would’ve chose doctor funk beat and bokumadaunderground’s 2DMVs to be the best but since so many people fucking hate the covers they don’t bother looking at their mvs. Me personally bug wouldn’t have even made on the list especially not in 1st place. There are so many other better 2DMVs out there. I’m surprised parasol cider didn’t make it on the list
@hickorydaisy4117
@hickorydaisy4117 Год назад
I’m surprised there weren’t more songs on the list that are out on global, also
@squishydishy1593
@squishydishy1593 Год назад
@@hickorydaisy4117 I watch the 2dmvs cuz it’s one of the easier ways to get the full version of covers while also having something visually please in the background to look at. Also because there are some times where I don’t like the game’s choreography choices.
@medicmain68
@medicmain68 Год назад
I love dreaming chuchu
@ceve
@ceve Год назад
Also, people didn't like Forward and Sekai? I love those two.
@Prefixcial
@Prefixcial Год назад
Came back to say utsuro wo aogu, stella, and both of kanade’s center songs deserved to be in the top 50
@kakyoinnoriyaki6393
@kakyoinnoriyaki6393 Год назад
Also YY. That song is one of the best VBS cover
@Prefixcial
@Prefixcial Год назад
@@kakyoinnoriyaki6393 yes! YY deserved to be there too!
@yuukkas
@yuukkas Год назад
i will never understand why a lot of people think Rui's singing is better than Akito's, sure he has a great voice but Akito's VA is way more skilled
@burikinodance
@burikinodance Год назад
... because they like his voice better? It's not rocket science, like how Mafuyu's VA is less experienced than a lot of others but is still my second-favourite vocalist due to how she uses her voice
@yuukkas
@yuukkas Год назад
@@burikinodance Rui's singing is always almost the same. He has a charming tone but never tries to go very high or very low, Akito on the other hand and a lot of other characters don't just relly on their voice quality. If people like Rui's voice that much, good for them, but he is not the best singer at all.
@vbsenthusiast
@vbsenthusiast Год назад
a lot of my faves got in top 50 but a lot didn't... (looking at alter ego, airhead, ama no jaku, earth's final confession, happy halloween, kokoroyohou, heart rate 0822, yy, rimokon, and lost and found)
@LordShrecc
@LordShrecc Год назад
kokoroyohou is sooooo good
@torra9979
@torra9979 Год назад
I’m gonna speak my truth here. Where the hell was kanade tomosu sora in any of this list. That song is easily one of the best and most emotional, AND has one of the most stunning 2DMVs…and ur gonna say it wasn’t even CLOSE to some of these other songs which are, quite frankly, overrated as hell? 😭😭😭 cmon… Also, wtaf is Teo doing in Top 10 worst songs. There are much worse songs. AND Leo/Need/MMJ got effed hard with this polling. The more you watch it…the more the bias piles up. It’s really disappointing ngl
@andieamigu5214
@andieamigu5214 Год назад
*This*
@marinamoraes6174
@marinamoraes6174 Год назад
How the heck Bokura Mada Underground djdn't make event top 10 of best 2DMVs? It's literally one lf the only fully animated MVs!!!
@lunarnoona
@lunarnoona Год назад
LITERALLY when I didn't see it there I was thinking "is everyone crazy? It's FULLY ANIMATED and it's really well done too."
@asukaay10
@asukaay10 Год назад
I was also wondering same with Gunjou Sanka. Like Journey made it but Gunjou Sanka didn't?!
@borderlinecase
@borderlinecase Год назад
REAL
@tricologe
@tricologe Год назад
i cant believe worldwide wander wasnt in the best 2dmvs :( i think it was really cute!!!
@robloxreal5918
@robloxreal5918 Год назад
YESS not appreciated enough
@topiaz
@topiaz Год назад
TRUEE it's such a cute mv!
@earthy_x6
@earthy_x6 Год назад
Agreed with everyone in the Best Vocalist category beside Rui and Shiho. - Rui is arguably the best vocalist of WxS but he doesn't surpass Akito. Akito has sang in the 5th octave several times while Rui never attempts to do so. - I won't talk about complicated singing techniques here but Shiho is really weak on her high register. Ichika is the main vocalist of L/n for a reason.
@squishydishy1593
@squishydishy1593 Год назад
I have no experience in music and I really just listen to what I like so this might sound unbearable but I agree that shiho isn’t the best vocalist. But I like her on some songs like peaky peaky etc and she’s also probably my favourite proseka character… but sometimes she sounds like she’s sleeping while she singing. In bokumadaunderground and lost ones weeping it seems like she just can’t get any higher. Like her voice seems flat on the ground kinda but I think that’s because they wanna kinda keep that sort of cool girl tomboyish type of vibe with her character and I think like I said it works with like. Cooler songs like peaky peaky where they’re supposed to be badass 😎 and like tough as nails but sometimes it drags her down and it’s sad because I like her a lot n she’s like my favourite and like awesome and stuff but yea I agree with you. Sorry for this long ramble idk how to. Like word it but also sorry again about all the nonsense because I don’t know anything about music other than like do re mi fa n stuff. Have a good day 👍
@squishydishy1593
@squishydishy1593 Год назад
AND YOUR E LIKE. so right on your ichika point as well. LIKE she gets so much flak because she’s in like every song yadda yadda yadda and “poster girl syndrome” nonsense but it’s like she’s like the most well rounded compared to the others but when they sing together in bits it sounds nice but when one of the other members takes over u can hear the discrepancies in the voices. Like in honamis Stella and shihos lost ones weeping. Like I feel like ichika is stable and people slander her for no reason at times
@squishydishy1593
@squishydishy1593 Год назад
AND not to say ichika doesn’t have flaws but a lot of what people get at her for is just kinda nonsense to me personally
@river5253
@river5253 Год назад
this is criminal. How did Saisei and Machi not even get in the top 50? this is horrible. Saisei is one of niigo's best (maybe if you don't understand Japanese it's less so, but while the lyrics are certainly amazing the song itself is amazing as a whole so). And Machi is VBS's best song, period. An just slays. all of the people who voted, we need to chat.
@leezabet1212
@leezabet1212 Год назад
YES!! also kanadetomososora can fit here
@kirbbb1995
@kirbbb1995 Год назад
the best 3d mv ones having a bunch of wxs proves that wxs consistently has the best 3d mvs. like all of them are bangers
@yarshmellow2323
@yarshmellow2323 Год назад
Im so glad Ego Rock got its rightful place as the best 3dmv. Like Emu!! Does the dance!!! What more could you want.
@peytonsdeatharea4351
@peytonsdeatharea4351 Год назад
Toyas vocals in doctor funk beat are so good idk why yall dont like it and btw i didnt expect lower to be not in the top 3 from what i remember its like the 2nd most popular nightcord song behind bug
@kohammy184
@kohammy184 Год назад
The fact that lower is in the top 10 shocks me like I thought it was one of the most underrated songs I'm so happy
@emerygrey1582
@emerygrey1582 Год назад
A lot of the mizuki """bias""" is literally just because a) the songs they get are absolutely amazing and b) they have a super good voice with a lot of range and power, it doesnt have to do with the character being popular at all.
@dreddick1235
@dreddick1235 Год назад
Agreed! It gets a little frustrating seeing people write off Satou Hinata’s singing ability just because Mizuki is popular. I’ve loved her voice since revue starlight and she’s just as good in prsk
@andieamigu5214
@andieamigu5214 Год назад
Yep, even with all this bias involved I still agree that Mizuki actually deserves that 1st place on best vocalist. Somehow Hinata always ends on whether franchise/ unit I'm interested in lol.
@bakaama1445
@bakaama1445 Год назад
Mafuyu's Bug cover is genuinely one of my favourites in the game tho 😭
@arha13
@arha13 Год назад
It feels like she’s having a breakdown which I love
@MarceCloud39
@MarceCloud39 Год назад
So, uh, yeah, about that Mafuyu Bug thing... I had most of these assets ready to go but not numbered like 3 days before the poll ended because after checking daily, everything seemed to have settled their placements by that point. I’m trying to tier the current event in JP Sekai, but wanted this out asap so it was super handy to have all this ready. Mafuyu’s Bug solo was actually looking like it was going to get kicked out for Kanade Cutlery, but then the Mizuki surge happened and with it came a Mafuyu Bug surge too. With how much more finite they just made alt tickets I really don’t want to buy an alt that I actively dislike. I wouldn’t force any of you guys to do such a thing either so I hope that can be respected. Mafuyu really has so many better alts I could be using her tickets on instead. Syncing to the Niigo version’s gameplay is annoying as well, and let’s not forget audio balancing with the one clip not from a cell phone recording. I try to make my audio quality as consistent as possible for headphone users. The surge caught me off guard so it’s actually easier to make a brief shitpost style thing than to incorporate it in some way. I’m already losing a day of grinding to my late birthday festivity, I don’t want to lose another to audio balancing nonsense. If anyone is actually pressed about this you can just make your own ranking video and praise Mafuyu’s Bug solo to high heavens, it’s your right- as it is mine to not want to put forward the effort to modify this video for its inclusion. If it were higher (like at least 4th or 5th) and more steady for the duration of me holding this survey I might have sucked it up and bought it, but a last minute 9th place boost isn’t special enough to warrant that for me. Again, sorry, but also not really. I hated this alt before the survey and this has made me like it even less
@whatamidoing5683
@whatamidoing5683 Год назад
I believe I voted in this and I tried to be pretty even with group distribution (to be fair my second favorite unit is MMJ so I'm probably one of three people who voted for Viva Happy LMFAO). Doctor Funk Beat and Bring It On being in worst does not surprise me but I am glad that they were 1 and 2 in most-improved because deserved. Also Rad Dogs in the best 2DMVs is surprising but I like that one so I'm happy about that. Sorry about the voting influxes, that always sucks and it's kind of frustrating when you're a fan of a less popular group but what's new haha. I still had fun participating and I hope you do it next year e: it is interesting though now that I think about it because I am VBS's no. 1 stan but Beat Eater surprised me in the 2DMV section. I'm pretty sure the 2DMVs I voted for that are from VBS were Devil's Manner and Traffic Jam (and maybe Doctor Funk Beat? idr). No shade to beat eater it's my fave VBS song it's just interesting because I feel like there's not a lot going on. ALSO HOW IS STELLA NOT IN THE RUNNING FOR BEST 2DMVS 😭
@andieamigu5214
@andieamigu5214 Год назад
I'm the 2nd, I love Viva Happy so much 🥺. The point of the og song was, "what if Miku were a seiyuu idol". But now she is with the seiyuu idols, how wonderful is that?. And well, I started playing the game because of MMJ after all
@charlesierobison
@charlesierobison Год назад
i am honestly shocked that no alt duos made it in the alt vocal sections! Even if you can argue for stan culture, the fact that people werent voting for their "ship" duos surprised me. I love some of the alt duos! An Touya children record is god tier (honestly the whole cover is god tier. in the album version they added a spray can sound effect, chefs kiss) and the tsukasa-nene chururira is so gooddd. Honestly i think a lot of alt vocals got robbed (i mean where IS Ena MKDR????????) But overall I was just shocked to see only solos!
@dfloriza
@dfloriza Год назад
I got a hearty chuckle when I saw that it was the Shinonome siblings that were virtually tied for 5th in the VA category, and just imagined Ena and Akito arguing about it 😂 Also, the absence of Starry Sky Melody and Nene's cover of it is CRIMINAL. Y'all sleeping on that one lol
@topiaz
@topiaz Год назад
IT'S SUCH A GOOD SONG AND NENES COVER IS SO GOOD
@gemanimates
@gemanimates Год назад
I’m a bit surprised that phony and 88 are BELOW the iPhone ringtone but lots of people just vote for their favourite character or group anyway (I was not involved in voting by the way)
@hoshiworks_aster
@hoshiworks_aster Год назад
17:15 Honestly this was an amazing winner as is, but the fact it got 39% of the category's votes (potentially *by accident* mind you)?! Chef's kiss. Godspeed, wowaka.
@Taliashort
@Taliashort Год назад
Omg I was agreeing the whole video and when it showed dappou rock and teo on worst songs I nearly screamed 😭
@MarceCloud39
@MarceCloud39 Год назад
Don’t fret too much- At least Dappo Rock gets redemption in the Most Improved on CD category! The hate is all because of Len in the game version, something they actually fixed for the album version. We need solos of Tsukasa and Rui in the game tbh. Those would actually sound really good (unless they mess of the mixing) ngl
@yuakim
@yuakim Год назад
ESPECIALLY TEOOOO, what is that doing there hello???
@Taliashort
@Taliashort Год назад
@@MarceCloud39 I need a Rui solo ver I think they did Tsukasa so wrong by making him sing in it 😭😭
@afonsomonteiro2003
@afonsomonteiro2003 Год назад
Some of my favorite songs (sung by MMJ / Leo/Need) are nowhere to be found or placed ridiculously low which is kinda sad 💀 I don't wanna accuse anyone of bias of course... But yikes... Do people seriously dislike Teo? And where's Karakuri Pierrot, my poor favorite song... And although I don't love the lost one's weeping cover, the Shiho cover slaps so hard Im surprised it didn't get mentioned On the other hand, I didn't vote for the cd category bc I wasn't sure of the differences, but omg? Law evading rock and Bring it on are some of my least favorite songs and yet they sound so good in the cd, I might actually start listening to them Anyway completely agree with the Mafuyu Bug bit. I understand why the raw emotion might be appreciated, but objectively the cover does not sound good at all. When I do it it's not awe inspiring it's just raspy and annoying to the ear why is Mafuyu special lmao
@borderlinecase
@borderlinecase Год назад
teo is godly
@Prefixcial
@Prefixcial Год назад
If, metamo reborn, and parasol cider deserved to be in the top 50 also
@joceyyy_
@joceyyy_ Год назад
guys i love bug just as much as the next niigo stan but like best 2dmv?? really??? there are so many better ones, and I’m just upset that love trial didn’t even make it into the top 10 for 2dmvs, I love that 2dmv so much
@sillychuu
@sillychuu Год назад
Why is teo in the top ten worst songs??? It's amazing 😭 feel like some ppl voted it bc they don't like the chart
@thatonedrfan9546
@thatonedrfan9546 Год назад
I started crying when I saw top 10 worst songs what the heck guys 😭 /hj
@kokoro7996
@kokoro7996 Год назад
This was my first time partaking in the survey and it was fun!
@justanotherrainyday9213
@justanotherrainyday9213 Год назад
Alright, I'm frankly upset on how bad L/N and MMJ was treated. Honestly, I felt like the Lost one's weeping cover wasn't even that bad! I understand that one might not like the harmony, but it's not as bad as some other songs. Of course, this is my opinion. Please do not attack me for it!
@justanotherrainyday9213
@justanotherrainyday9213 Год назад
Also, so happy for Shiho scoring so high for the alt vocals! Justice for [1]! The Shizuku Milk Crown cover was the first I bought, 100% worth it!
@sillychuu
@sillychuu Год назад
Venom and bug being #2 and #1 makes a lot of sense, I literally feel like I'm ascending when I listen to them
@tama_aka
@tama_aka Год назад
LETS GOOOOO AKITO AND SHIHOOOOOO for the best vocals... Im pretty happy
@salt7532
@salt7532 Год назад
how did voices not make it into top 50
@yuridisorder
@yuridisorder Год назад
THE VOTES WERE SO BASIC 💀💀 AND THEY PICKED GOOD SONGS AS WORST TOO 😭 WHY WAS EVERYTHING ABOUT MIZUKI.
@akitoluvr2618
@akitoluvr2618 Год назад
Nah cause this was lowkey disappointing ngl, so much wxs and n25 and for what😭 Also Teo, Lost ones weeping and forward in the top 10 worst?? What were y’all thinking 💀
@akitoluvr2618
@akitoluvr2618 Год назад
Obvi quite a few songs I voted made it into the top 50 but it was so damn sad not seeing either Alter ego or Mirai there 🙁
@yuu2124
@yuu2124 Год назад
im so surprised how low aun no beats ranked given how much hype it got
@ayasnow5047
@ayasnow5047 Год назад
Oop, the niigo stans going at it again, Mizuki is a great and all, but defo not the best character in the game. The only reason she sounds powerful is cuz she's singing with Mafuyu and Kanade. Nene, Toya, Kohane, and others deserve to be in the top 5 way more. And Bug as best 2D MV????? SRSLY??? AND NO DEVIL'S MANNER IS BEST 3DMVS BUT YES TO IDSMILE???? At this point, I shouldn't get angry over those votes, I should just be proud of my superior tastes. Y'all srsly sleeping on MMJ and LeoNeed. Just cuz they "have no personality", which is not true, btw, yall need to have extremes, does not mean they suck. Bruh.
@MarceCloud39
@MarceCloud39 Год назад
I like the ID Smile 3DMV, but dear god the fact that if I didn't close the poll when I did it might have overtaken Ego Rock as best 3DMV... frightening
@ayasnow5047
@ayasnow5047 Год назад
@@MarceCloud39 Yes, it is good, but not that high, they've done better ones
@ayasnow5047
@ayasnow5047 Год назад
@@MarceCloud39 Also based Ego Rock deserves 1st place, by a way larger margin
@everythingz888
@everythingz888 Год назад
Ok I’m so confused with the comments. Yes there’s a ton of bias but isn’t that expected when asking viewers for personal opinions? Opinions are…naturally biased. It’s definitely annoying especially with the MV sections but I don’t see the problem. Other than MMJ and L/N being shafted ofc It’s just everyone is like “Omg this list is so biased” like OF COURSE it is. What did you expect?
@yuakim
@yuakim Год назад
I'm wondering though if that bias still shifted towards things that are UNRELATED to the characters such as 3D and 2D mv's, I swear I could name a couple of VERY good mv's from MMJ and L/N that should have appeared here...
@kirbbb1995
@kirbbb1995 Год назад
nene not being in the best vocalist category i'm PISSED.
@illulamati4651
@illulamati4651 Год назад
rip metamo reborn :( thought itd at least get in the top 50... or 2dmv (seriously its 2dmv is so cool guys) oh well tokugawa and ego rock deserve those placements
@powafan
@powafan Год назад
the worst song list really hit me when Lost One's Weeping was #1, it's literally my favorite song/cover in game.
@lizzyserf
@lizzyserf Год назад
auaugh so many of the songs on the "worst" list are ones i love shkjgndfg... but for a more meaningful take, i REALLY disagree with mizuki's "lower one's eyes" being on the list?? not that it's bad by any means, but in my opinion, ena's solo is just SO much better. she just has so much more power and makes it sound so much more... desperate i guess?? i love it also in general i am. very annoyed about the lack of leo/need ... idk what it is but everyone seems to dislike leo/need so much ??? like do project sekai fans just not like rock music???? mmj got robbed too but as a leo/need fan first and foremost i have to complain about them not having much
@boknyangz
@boknyangz Год назад
seeing so many songs i like ( forward, dappou rock, sekai, dr=fb, bio and lost one's weeping ) being in the most disliked list hurts my soul
@kirbbb1995
@kirbbb1995 Год назад
ooh... this list is concerning... this is why i never listen to proseka fan opinions/hj
@MarceCloud39
@MarceCloud39 Год назад
Kinda a mood tbh. For me, the least expected but valid takes from this were that 1 member per group made it to the Top 5 vocalist (yay for equality for the groups for once) and MMJ not being in the worst list at all two years in a row (Dreamin Chuchu was understandably close both times tho, Luka doesn’t sound very good on it).
@chronosred7544
@chronosred7544 Год назад
Dr funk beat was robbed of best 2dmv
@orangesoda330
@orangesoda330 Месяц назад
12:15 this makes me so happy omg my girl is finally getting recognition for that banger cover
@EveIrkens
@EveIrkens Год назад
TONDEMO-WONDERS in the top 5 where it belongs! Hell yeah. Seriously everytime I play the game that's the song that ends up stuck in my head. Honestly the top 5 songs are all bangers. Voters have good taste. Also please tell me who thought covering Teo was a good idea. I love the original but the cover, what went wrong??? Same thing that happened to Lost One's Weeping I'm guessing... poor l/n. Lens cover has no right being that good though like holy hell.
@sofiaklmpks
@sofiaklmpks Год назад
the fact that the vampire, parasol cider, tondemo, and chururira 2dmvs weren't in the top 10 for 2dmvs and toya wasn't in the top 10 for vocals was criminal
@yomiiku
@yomiiku Год назад
OTOME DISSECTION, ROKI, BRING IT ON, LOST ONE'S WEEPING?
@hickorydaisy4117
@hickorydaisy4117 Год назад
The worst covers list is 50% “I actually like this one tho…” and 50% “OW MY EARS!” Lamo
@GH0STY000
@GH0STY000 Год назад
Don’t get me wrong, I love akitoya singing together, but tf happened at the end of Doctor = funk beat
@Heyyoe_
@Heyyoe_ Год назад
Really disapointed of the lack of leo/need here but it is what it is
@gretchbia
@gretchbia Год назад
HOW IS PARASOL CIDER NOT IN THE 2DMV SECTION ?? AND LOST ONES WEEPING AS THE WORST SONG ?? theres no way LMAOO
@kaleidosode
@kaleidosode Год назад
mizuki having 68% of best vocalist votes as they deserve
@saturnmoth4807
@saturnmoth4807 Год назад
why do people hate roki ln cover sm its like rlly good
@leoneedwiki
@leoneedwiki Год назад
i wasnt surprised that bug was number 1 for 2dmv's and songs. its such a banger i listen to it too much its unhealthy.
@ceve
@ceve Год назад
Never heard Rui´s version of At God's Mercy but I'm happily surprised. Also glad Shizuku was in the top, she has the best voice in my opinion
@Prefixcial
@Prefixcial Год назад
Moonlight is so emotional why is it ranked so low
@cerulean1003
@cerulean1003 Год назад
Yeah uhh you were not kidding about the bias in some of these wow. Like especially with Alt Vocals and the MV categories those got baaaaddd. Alt Vocals was populated too much by Mizuki and left some really good singers out by the wayside (nothing for Haruka, Airi or Toya?), 3D MVs didnt have terrible choices aside from ID Smile but a lot of them could have been swapped out for more interesting ones (like 1-2 Fanclub, Children Record or Karakuri Pierrot) and 2D MVs was just people voting for what they watch on YT and not what was actually interesting, Bug is fun but was a bit too high, Rad Dogs probably shouldnt be there and i dont get why Journeys there but not Gunjo Sanka when their kind of the same thing. And again a lot of really good ones got left out and its a shame. (no Shoujo Rei, KING, Nonsense Literature, Bokura Underground, Peaky Peaky, Dreamin Chuchu, Metamo Reborn etc......) I understand bias is a thing everyone has and you dont realize your doing it but this was getting kind of ridiculous yall. Also bummed that L/n and MMJ got mostly left out of the top 50 again, they had a lot of good songs people didnt vote for. (Ikanaide, Hello World, Stage of Sekai, Earths Final Confession, Metamo Reborn, If etc....) I dunno if its intetional or just the popularity of VBS/WxS/Nightcord creeping up once again. Either way thanks for doing this, hopefully this issue doesnt happen again next year.
@NUISANCE_ANIMAL
@NUISANCE_ANIMAL Год назад
weirdly specific hot take: any time an ingame cover changes the key of the song, it automatically becomes shitty. examples include Glory Steady Go, Bocca Della Vérita, lower one’s eyes, IDSMILE, Doctor=Funk Beat, Ego Rock, telecaster b-boy, and Bitter Choco Decoration.
@aguilera2966
@aguilera2966 Год назад
Unpopular opinion Journey's 2d mv shouldn't have been that high up. The concept of an anime style opening is great, but if you pause to actually look at the drawings there's no harmony between the colors or they are just straight up ugly, and some frames even look drawn by a teenager rather than a professional. As a mafuyu fan the one where she's standing in sekai which is supposed to represent the serious argument at the end of the n25 story is so goofy, like what is going on with her chest? I'm not very experienced with animation but my assumption has been that it was extremely rushed to meet the deadline or all the budget went to the other mv. Kinda crazy that it was so high up in the votes but not Ultramarine Hymn. Talking about 2D mvs, the nijiro story 2Dmv always warms my heart, the drawings are just so adorable although it's one of the simpler ones in comparison to other WxS mvs. And the dappou rock one is one of the most creative ones, although intentionally ugly it always makes me smile.
@danheng
@danheng Год назад
the way most of my favs r in the lower ranks ...... edit my hot take on . well. this juts felt like a popularity vote im sorry with mzk basically dominating all categories (as they should,) but the way ichika wasnt even in the top 5 best vocals threw me off
@danheng
@danheng Год назад
its FINE (tears in eyes)
@yukiyukiyunyunyun2685
@yukiyukiyunyunyun2685 Год назад
I have a HUGE Mizuki, Akito and Ena superiority belief so if any future videos gets rigged again, just know, I believe in Akito and Mizuki supremacy
@KK-gt6kh
@KK-gt6kh Год назад
Voting by favourite group in the mv section is like disrespecting what Ena and Mizuki do in the story. Hope next time people will vote genuinely and not vote a mv that hasn’t even come out💀
@bandelby5365
@bandelby5365 Год назад
Olay quick thing, we all know that if Shizuku had a Solo of Earths Last Confession, it would Solo ALL OTHER SOLOS
@charlotte4503
@charlotte4503 Год назад
i 100% agree with the best vocalist section, shiho is barely ever included in top 5 for the ones i’ve seen and she thoroughly deserves her spot in this (also all the other rankings it’s rui being 2nd, and mizuki being 1st is perfect)
@user28397v
@user28397v Год назад
as a vbs oshi i feel the need to ask where is alter ego?!? now i get why it would be rated lower (cough) pubs in en server (cough cough) but it’s actually not on the list, and children record and devil’s manner so low?!? and tokugawa cup noodle mv not at #1?!? the mostly niigo but also wxs bias is showing i get that they are amazing but some of these rankings are just… eh. also i’m even more sorry for l/n and mmj stans 😭😭
@MarceCloud39
@MarceCloud39 Год назад
Alter Ego is somewhere in the Top 60, probably Top 55 iirc.
@scarleo1404
@scarleo1404 Год назад
Damn- I can’t handle this lost one’s weeping slander 😭
@Ayayayayagi
@Ayayayayagi Год назад
Thanks for your hard work again! Also Mizuki's Lower and Venom being ranked higher than Ena's? I'm disappointed in you psekai fandom 😔 another note from me: I know my opinion probably doesn't matter as much since I had no idea this poll was going on, but personally wouldn't have voted neither Journey or Gunjou for top 2DMVs because A) despite the smoother animation for most parts, and the fact all of it was literally made by one guy, the VBS bias in Journey pissed me off (like c'mon the animator couldn't make it any more obvious that they don't like L/N) and B) while Gunjou looks nice and closer to the card art, the animation is extremely jarring at certain parts (the kanamafu part near the end, the part where minoharu jump and shizuairi just... pose in like minimal amount of frames?, the anhane part where the power gets cut off and shihosaki one where she catches saki from falling over... oh and the part where haruka sees her past self in minori)
@sev4289
@sev4289 Год назад
is it just me or was the transition to traffic jam smooth
@zphyrr
@zphyrr Год назад
NIGHTCORD STANS WHERE U AT MIZUKI SLAYED THE TOP 10 OR SO ALSO THE DISRECPECT FOR TEO, LOST ONES WEEPING, BRING IT ON, ETC- LIKE WHAT thinking these songs (or covers??? idk what their called all the covers for all the listed songs are good) are less than an A tier is CRIMINAL ty all for putting doctor funk beat in its place
@platypus3674
@platypus3674 Год назад
Only thing I don't get is how one minute ROKI, Doctor = Funk Beat, Dappo Rock, and Bring It On are in top 10 worst sekai songs and then they're in top 5 cd approved songs
@MarceCloud39
@MarceCloud39 Год назад
That’s exactly the point though. The worst category is judged based off how they sound in game, the CD part is based on how they sound on the CD. A lot of songs got tweaked on the CD release. Some changes were minor like improved mixing, others straight up had re-recorded lines like Bring It On. Then there’s Adventure Log that has completely different line distribution compared to the game version. They’re not the same.
Далее
VIEWERS Rank Sekai Songs [AS OF 10/11/23]
25:20
Просмотров 24 тыс.
Wishlist Songs of Mine that got Added to Sekai
22:45
Просмотров 142 тыс.
Re-Ranking all Project Sekai Covers w reasons!
24:17
Просмотров 78 тыс.
3 Losers rank prsk colorfes cards
14:12
Просмотров 3 тыс.
PRSK RANDOM SAVE ONE DROP ONE
19:36
Просмотров 21 тыс.
My top 5 Project SEKAI covers from every unit
10:25
Просмотров 10 тыс.
me & my friend rank project sekai songs and cards
17:32
ranking project sekai commissioned songs ☾
20:39
Просмотров 63 тыс.