India's so-called Hindutva movement is boiling down to focus on winning elections after elections for one particular party. We people who want to see a Hindu India flourish and prosper need to now understand that BJP is just like any other party and that it will take lobbying and putting pressure to get the policies that we want like freeing of Hindu temples or changes in Education. If need be, we should come out on the streets too!
@@smoky3302 congress is never going to be hindu again its a lost cause the only thing we can do is put pressure on bjp to get things done in our favour freeing hindu temples is the most imp issue and thn allowing those temples to start modern gurukal system this is imp for the survival of our civilization
@Water Farmer I dunno if they overthrow this Gandhi family and some of the Islamists in the party who control the party via the family also leave, CONgress could do some course correction to at least the Center and we should want that...
Dear Mr Prakash. Thanks so very much for getting this brilliant man over. He embodies what I think India should be about. Basically I consider you the greatest host and a moderator as I have seen you doing brilliant work being the moderator in many different channels. Keep up the good work my friend! Keep getting such guests who stimulate our mind and spirit and make us proud to be Indian! Jai Hind.
Great discussion Abhinav. I will take this opportunity to thank & congratulate Sood Sahab for the brilliant book ‘Ultimate Goal’. Reading it has been nothing being less than eye opening and most ‘Real Education & knowledge’. I have made my children read it and it’s clear to see that they are a bit shaken. Truth usually shakes & shocks you at times when you know it with an open mind. 😊🙏🏽🇮🇳🚩
Except Hindutva is still in its early stages. It should be rethought again. Modern day Hindutva, as we know it started with Savarkar and pretty much ended with him. On the ground, there is zero improvement or scope. We need new leadership and better ideas on how to even create a full-fledged movement that is capable of uniting the masses.
What masses do you want to unite? Do you welcome Dalits, Muslims? The Chinese consider the people of Hong Kong, Taiwan, Mongolia, Tibet to be Chinese, hence their desire to unite them to China. Do you consider Pakistanis, Bengalis, Nepalis to be Indian?
England carries Saint George's Cross on their flag ,so do Scandinavian and Nordic countries, who are champions of all kinds of rights and secularism carries cross of Saint Philip the Apostle on their flag ,still they preach us how to ensure religious equality
@Born Again Harrapan Do you know the very definition of secularism, complete detachment of state and religion ,you can’t call yourself secular when your state flag carrying a religious symbol
@Born Again Harrapan In India, if Modi swore his oath on the Bhagavad Gita, what do you think the media & public reaction would be? The US doesn't give holidays on the festivals of religions other than Christianity & Judaism. A Christian missionary's representative sits on their "Religious Freedom Commission". Face it: The US is categorically less secular than India. Also, you ABSOLUTELY cannot dismiss symbolism. There are many Hindus who are otherwise secular, but want to see their nation represented symbolically by their own cultural heritage. Why can't they get that here? Why are they shamed into admiring a marble graveyard built by out-groupers as their national monument (after the latter destroyed so much)? Most of the Hindutva activism would subside, if we got what they (the Western nations) have. Until then, it's better to recognize conflict & proliferate interests.
I was so looking forward to this conversation. I was disappointed with the audio quality and my interest gave way midway. Hope better audio quality prevails in future discussions.
Such a different topic, such an interesting guest bikram ji....but sound quality not good...it is more important to have such topical conversation in hindi, because in an attempt to cover all the people you have missed the majority Hindi speaking people from north. Because literacy level is a bit less in north compared to south...so it's necessary to have more exposure to such topic by Hindi medium..u can cover the rest by English subtitle...
I request all the indian yutuber to atleast fix the audio n make sure its audible before you start interview plz.....we want to listen to these experts more n more but its all ruined cause of Audio
I dont think saying Hindu nationalism, because the term Hindu can be interpreted with civilizational sense, not as per exclusivist religious meaning as Mr. Sood is saying. Even if we bring Hinduism religion as the underpinning of Hindu nationalism, it is not exclusive of others as the Abrahamic faiths, rather it is inclusive by nature.
Good to see abhinav after a long time and after becoming VP he is still operating this channel. But I doubt you will now call AIM as a guest as he is very critical of India's People Party.
The sound system of the host very bad. The interviewer repeated the questions and failed to ask questions appropriate to RAW head. Missed opportunity. :(
The han nationalism has an edge over hindu as han first of all is an ethnic Identity which mostly share same culture and language religion is never a important component in china to begin with. Hindu is a loose term used for many Dharmic tradition and hindutva is s new phenomenon hindus in the past even in present identify more with their caste and lingual identity than religious one. Han or Chinese nationalism is more coherent than hindu nationalism.
@@nomanor7987 ask munda ,Bhil,gond,tamil etc are they aryan or not. But many of them religiously identify as hindu. Hinduism is a religion not an ethnicity hindu nationalism is a civlization based nationalism not ethnic based.
@@glycontheserpent4336 okay then you are like the Islamists, who are Muslim nationalists then? They fight for one Islamic Ummah and yearn for a Caliphate like you yearn for a Hindu Rashtra. But what about Pakistanis and Bengalis who are Indian ethnicity but Muslim religion? Do you disown them because of their Islamic religion and ignore their Aryan blood? The Han Chinese don’t care about religion, they are atheists so they are unified by blood and ethnicity, not religion.
@@nomanor7987 The only diffrence between hindu nationalist and islamic nationalist is that unlike islamic nationalism we don't want to convert whole world in to Islamic faith. Hindu nationalism is comparable to Zionism . Zionism seeks to create a Jewish state and now when they have Israel they seek to protect it. Hindu nationalism just want India to remain hindu that's it .
Please do a video on Olympics and Indian athletes. The problems they face and how to grow the athletic talent pool in India. If Bollywood, IPL can be industries then surely Sports can be an industry as well contributing to Indian economy. What will it take to turn it from individuals excelling at their sport to am ecosystem that will not hamper but help these sports persons contribute their might to the nation. Will crowd funding help or an IPL style setup?
The Manu (overmind) governing China works on Uniformity, Domination, Homogeneity, Control, Discipline, Outer Perfection, Linear Time Perception, Binary Thought Process. ( Masculine) The Manu of India is on the Feminine side that's why Bharat Mata. In India the Manu is characterized of Diversity, Principle of infinity, Cyclic Perception of Time, Non-Binary Thought Process, Unity in Diversity, Flexibility, Plasticity, Inner Perfection, Accommodative Behaviour and Compassion. The clash is at the level of Manu (Overmind) Excerpts from Sri Aurobindo publications.
@Bella this is talked in the books published by Sri Aurobindo and the Mother. The broader topic is the Overmind, which has been discussed in details in Synthesis of Yoga by Sri Aurobindo. However these are supraphysical topics and one needs to have prior knowledge in this area. You can always search session on Overmind by Sri Aurobindo.
@Bella Not at all. India has to still realise her full potential. As per Sri Aurobindo, India still has a destiny to fulfill in the World. Her work in the world is still incomplete.
That's the thing India does not have any rigid principles, India exactly reflects a Hindu state, the nature of sanatan dharma is to accommodate anything under the sun, problem arises wen sum elements consistently try to attact the dharam that accomadates n adapts(n s our policy makers n dalas destroyed the true idea of India with their unreasonable policies, esp gandhis n local parties) . Even on individual level we r so diverse one feels praying to just Lord shiva is hindu enough, one feels by following just Geeta he can consider himself a hindu, ul find seekers, n also serving makind will justify his right to b a Hindu. So we can never frame a rigid set of goals for a Hindu state. There r just brief guidelines we shud luk upto, dharma n right balance of everything (its the core principle of nature n sanatan dharm). Personally I feel that without the idea of nationalism we ll fall apart, it's the pillar of our existence as a state, the institutions which r massively influenced by flawed Liberal ideologies, left, communism n western ideas are overlooking this fact. They take pride in safeguarding a single individual At a time, but wat they r doing is fuelling the elements that are crushing the nationalists n the idea of nationalism.
Han= Homogeneous Aryan Natural Sanskar Whereas Hindu= Heterogeneous Integrated Natural Dravidian Union with all other Cultures of the world. Therefore Han is the SUBSET of Hindu race. Hence no clashes between the two. Or for that matter between any other cultures.
We need to stop analyzing further what is Nationalism. We need to ACT and make India a Vedic Nation and a Vedic State! The DNA of our Nationalism is Vedic! No apologetic behavior in doing that. It's unfortunate that even after 74 years of Independence we are still discussing & analyzing Nationalism.
Han nationalism is not based on one blood , language and culture either -- like most manufactured ideas , in China - there are vast regional differences in DNA in different regions like Inner Mongolia , Tibet , Sichuan , Guangdong , Hubei etc etc. Each of these provinces have a different language , different culture even different ways of thinking. The divide between Northern Chinese and Southern Chinese is very well known , documented and spoken about. The only thing that large, so called single ethnic countries like Russia , China do - to remain united , is use authoritarian measures. In that respect if India can achieve equal or even better unity through spreading an ideology like -- Hindutva , then that means India has been more successful than any of these traditionally large empire -like countries. Things are moving in the right direction after centuries. The Western countries use the construct of "race" to maintain order in their nations. Likewise we can use a cultural construct - Hindutva to achieve order.
Lots of incorrect statements about China. China doesn't have 1 language, it has many. The Chinese government cleverly classifies many as "dialects" but in fact they are in fact distinct languages since they are incomprehensible by those speaking other dialects. China also peddles their unity in diversity with a quiet Han Nationalism driving things in the background. India is more or less moving in the same direction. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Languages_of_China . Read this Wikipedia entry on Mandarin: "Many varieties of Mandarin, such as those of the Southwest (including Sichuanese) and the Lower Yangtze, are not mutually intelligible or are only partially intelligible with the standard language. Nevertheless, Mandarin is often placed first in lists of languages by number of native speakers (with nearly a billion)."
China is ultrasensitive about certain things - a quest to show unity of their nation and a desire to be #1 in everything so they added distinct languages all as "Mandarin" and surprise Mandarin is then the largest spoken language on Earth. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mandarin_Chinese
Hindu Nationalism/Hinduism is currently seen as bad, like never before, in Western World, thanks to hinduphobic propoganda, especially since 2016, by Global (and Indian) Islamoleftist Nexus. To counter that, We should portray it against Han Nationalism. Western people just hate CCP, if we can establish Han Nationalism as the Cause of Xi/CCP's Aggressive Policies, Hindu Nationalism would surely look much favorable in front of Han Nationalism. And Hopefully resulting in less attacks on Hindus and Hindu Culture, as there'll be more focus on Han Nationalism, But for that, Indian people should use terms like "Han Nationalism" as much as possible on Social Media platforms, that Media houses and Think Tanks can grab that term, and REPORT tweets and posts having terms like Hindu Nationalism on Social Media platforms whenever you see. Also while using Han Nationalism, blame it as the Cause of CCP's Aggressive Policies. Abhinav, please next time use - Hindu Nationalism "Vs" Han Nationalism, instead of Han Nationalism "&" Hindu Nationalism. Show Hindu Nationalism, against Han Nationalism. Jai Hind.
As per ex- RAW Chief Vikram Sood, he is pointing out that there is no place for PM Modi... We are not going to fight a direct war with China and economy is the key . If PM Manmohan Singh was there India would have been a 5 Trillion dollar economy by now and would have handled China and Pakistan intelligently and diplomatically.. PM Modi's Govt seems to be on a weak wicket vis a vis economy and reason why China and Pakistan seem to be provoking India time and again..
PM manmauni baba rule had it been extended from the 2012 policy paralysis we'd have hit 2% growth rate and civil society collapse easily today. Not to forgot the terrorism and blasts which would have been a routine effort with full on corruption and freebies.
There's no conflict with the Chinese nationalism absolutely as long as it's confined with in China, the problem is with the CCP's expansionist communist nationalism by no stretch of imagination can Tibetans be assimilated into their versions of Chinese nationalism or even communism for that matter without force.... Technically this must not be acceptable to Indian communist but unfortunately the leaders are lured by the largesse disbursed generously..... luckily the communist are a fading force in India & even in pockets where there's influences like in kerala they're in coalition & electoral success is sustaining by adopting cultural practices like ramayana reciting & yoga's admist the cadres....
English must be outlawed permanently In place of this artificial language, Samskritim should be lingua franca. Aryavart can't be united without Samskritim
हा हा हा इंग्लिश को outlawed करने के बात इंग्लिश मा करे है क्षत्रिय छोरे। तेरे बात में दम से पर इसमें एक समस्या है भारत के नॉर्थईस्ट और तमिलनाडु की एक बड़ी जनसंख्या इस प्रस्ताव को स्वीकार ना करे। और मुसलमानो और ईसाइयों को भी इससे दिक्कत होए से। संस्कृत को आजादी के समय ही राष्ट्रभाषा का दर्जा देना चाहिए था अब काफी देर हो चुकी से।
I support Sanskrit being the official language of India but whats that about banning english bro? Why? The problem is not with English, its with us, don't hate English which has its benefits, hate our own colonized mindset.
@@NatrajChaturvedi I don't hate English. To remove the problem, you have to hit on its root. English needs to be permanently banned it was imposed on Aryas forcibly. It's our right to ban all those things imposed on us forcefully. Benefits? 😅 It has zero benefit, it's stealing intellectual property, confusing youth, destroying native culture.
@@glycontheserpent4336 Xti@n demonized North East & tamil Nadu. It can be undone depending on the leader. लेकिन आपके '' सबका साथ सबका विकास '' वाले नेता बस socialism की गौद में है जैसे कांगरैस थी
India should break up into about 40 separate countries. Smaller countries will be easier to govern thus allowing for a higher standard of living for everyone.
@Swastik Shukla हा हां हा थारे को पता भी है european union कै बनने से पहले कितनी जंगे लड़ी गईं। और छोरा अगर तो इस बेवकूफ से agree करे से तो तू भी एक नंबर का मूर्ख से। विश्व इतिहास में balkanization से कभी किसी मुल्क rar भला नहीं हुआ।
@Swastik Shukla हा हा तू तो पूरा मूर्ख ही है छोरे गरीब मुल्क में peaceful balkanization कभी न होवे। अभी तो तू बोल ले पर जब सच्चाई में ऐसा हुआ और जब तेरी जान और घर की इज्जत पे हमला होगा न तब तू समझेगा।
You realize, how easily Islamic Pakistan to your west (and east also earlier) would have gobbled you up? Without a Large standing Military force, (which is only possible when you are one huge united country) you have no chance against the aggressive and hostile neighbours you have!!
