Vocal Coach Reaction to Khalil Fong Live｜國外聲樂老師點評 方大同《三人遊》《愛我吧》《黑白》LIVE舞台  

老師厲害的不只準確點出方大同的兩個音樂偶像，還看出他的人格，低調、不吹噓、不浮誇，也是他的魅力所在。 也許不像其他有名歌手般紅得張揚，但他的音樂卻很真誠而耀眼。

天阿 方大同的兩位偶像 stevie wonder &Michael Jackson 都給老師說出來了

老師超利害，聞歌解讀大同的性格，低調不愛show off ，真的希望大同能趕快出來營業😢，miss him so much

他選擇的音階走向和唱法都是很時尚有品味的❤

2009 Timeless演唱會，我從國中買了聽了不下100便，謝謝大同守住傳統華語RnB最後的榮光

2024了，歌單裡方大同一直都在…

How I wish u can understand the lyrics! Khalil is really talented, you are right that those songs are all created by himself, and this video was way back from 2009. The second song is about him begging the girl to love him, yet at the same time he is saying nevermind please forget him.

雖然不是很懂音樂 但是方大同的歌 在編曲上面的 高低等等的 讓人特別有記憶點 也朗朗上口 LIVE 是第一次聽 我們看歌詞會懂他高低的編排理由 很引人入勝 也不無聊單調

I love love love Khalil Fong. I love his rawness, I love his songwriting style, I love how he performs that makes the songs so believable (if you read into the lyrics). it's like his whole persona is like a shy, introvert guy that secretly writes extremely romantic songs for the love of his life, even if the love of his life is never going to hear these songs --- that's how he makes me feel when he performs. So no, I don't want "perfect", I want the realness. I've been to 4 of his concerts, every time I enjoyed so much, even tho there's no fancy "production" so to speak, just him singing from his heart.

期待有小宇 同在❤️ 小宇絕對是台灣數一數二的R&B歌手 轉到老師頭暈

我想有些歌手在唱著自己的創作曲時容易帶給人這樣的感覺吧 方大同就是其中一個 專業分析出他唱歌的瑕疵 但他對自己歌的掌控度 就算出現破音都會讓人覺得很合理 好聽！

這場演唱會聽哭我好幾次，方大同的表演真的很動人❤

太愛方大同了 真的是很有質感的歌聲❤❤❤

You do have the pro and the taste. Agree that he is much more than a singer and a song writer, he is an artist indeed!

Absolutely agree! Honesty and sincerity is so important in art❤ And yes he writes his own songs, arranges and produces music and plays several musical instruments. His influences are Stevie Wonder, Michael Jackson and Earth, Wind & Fire, Marvin Gaye to name a few.

11:51 Live is vibe, technique comes second. I attended 3 concerts of Khalil, all of them are with perfect vibe. I accepted that he's not a technique king in singing. Listening to his music always gives me a feeling of being Loved

Super love him! He is a true artist!

小宇也是很棒的 希望有機會看到

聽到黑白就想說這是我選的wedding song

He did revealed one of his inspirations came from Stevie Wonder, this is when he started listens to him when he was 8 years old, and of course MJ as well.

老師評論真的都好專業❤

看到片尾還有下一集的方大同真是令人感到欣慰～讚啦～

We like Khalil just cuz he is so raw and true. Personally, i listen to his concert records way more than his regular EP. I really enjoy his live performance.

好愛大同！謝謝老師評論他❤

哇啊啊啊啊好期待！！！！

you correct ,he was inspired by Michael Jackson, Stevie wonder and beatles, if compare with JJ ,Jay chou in Asia, I may say he is the best one

四人遊和復刻回憶也很好聽😊

方大同是我r&b的啟蒙者❤

Hope we get to review more live performances from him!

More about Khalil pls! He's super talented

he is the best song writer and singer! kahlil!

推薦老師有機會也可以看看李宗盛的山丘live版！

終於有方大同了🎉

許願老師點評林家謙 another singer-songwriter in hong kong, recently very popular.

miss him so much ~ Khalil~

我想可以讓老師了解一下台灣宋念宇這位歌手

喜歡人性化的音樂

希望還有機會看到方大同開演唱會

indeed, Khalil love MJ and he love Stevie too! I prefer move "live". Live is the imperfect perfect.

please keep doing this!

我喜歡人性化的表演，另外老師有提到他的尾音處理，我個人想法是，方大同的歌詞寫得很好很容易有共鳴，唱起來有說故事，說話一樣的感覺，所以可能方大同才會這樣詮釋句尾

期待方大同

黑白整只聽完才點評，真的是很好聽

I denfintely prefer a live!!! even there are some little pitch loss. It make me feel real and a human making music. it also can show the singer singing style and true ability!!

2:01 exactly, that's what a LIVE performance for

簽到影片下方給你們點個讚👍 遇廣告看完看🈵

方大同的歌聽起來很舒服，我跟老師的感受差不多

唉唷 老師後面唱的好厲害😂

方大同好像真的是喜愛MJ,常常看到他摸仿他

謝謝！ 拜託請老師評論閻奕格在星光大道演唱的fighter. 我很喜歡這個頻道也很喜歡閻奕格，希望可以看到。謝謝

他是方大同誒😂 ❤

Obviously like somebody trains hard to become as close to perfection as possible. As raw as an ordinary singer?

lets check it out his songs with guitar playing on the stage~

方大同❤

同意橘老師說的~ 當你的呼吸情感都被歌手所牽動的時候, 細節的不完美不影響沉浸其中之外, 顯得更真實更貼近彼此.

I like his vowel swap lol (Eye instead of 爱)...I thought maybe he couldn't sing '爱" correctly, but it wouldn't make sense since he speaks perfect Mandarin. now I understand it's because the English 'I' sound is just easier to sing and do riffs and runs hahaha plus it's hardly noticeable.

方大同 covered Michael Jackson's "Bad" before

怎麼沒有翻唱的Nothing's Gonna Change My Love For You 呢 好可惜啊啊阿

😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊太棒了！是方大同系列❤ 他是公認的音樂才子，太喜歡他的歌了，很多首都很好聽😊，可以請橘老師re他的英文歌‘’Sing a long song‘’，還有‘’麥恩莉‘’都超好聽的👍🏻

I think what Rozette mentioned about the end note being short is the way Khalil trying to put the emotion of the story in it, like telling its story with the tone, and I enjoy live performance with some imperfect bit rather than like hearing a cd in live😂

方大同！！！🎉🎉

agree

希望老師可以講評一下另外一個R&B歌手 小宇宋念宇

🎉

Btw, you should try to listen to Wagakki Band. The vocalist using Shigin art vocal style to perform. It could be something new or different for you. Their most popular song is Senbonzakura, cover of Vocaloid song. But their other songs are great too.

方大同是教科書

To凱杰：幾年前的湖南衛視歌唱節目，獅子合唱團的“it's my life”，“百年孤寂”，明明唱很好，為什麼名次非常差，可以幫忙解惑一下嗎？感謝！

Want to listen to more of Ado's LIVE performances? It is recommended to buy Campanella BD concert albums and Mars BD concert albums

老师 方大同唱歌MJ的Billie Jean！

can you reviewn Stefanie sun’s online concert

期待老師可以聽宋念宇跟葉秉桓的歌😀

老師說的沒錯，方大同的偶象就是Michael Joseph Jackson

想要看点评李宗盛

藝術性來說，王菀之的藝術性應該比方大同高，希望可以有reaction

香港的杜丽莎 为什么到现在都没放 60多岁的声乐教练 林忆莲 容祖儿 gem都是她学生 参加了歌手

推小宇的live真的頂

老师听听任素汐！

你好 CZ MEDIA 請問可不可以聽一下胡琳的歌

什么时候做张敬轩😢

Please review 单依纯’s version of 三人游 🙏

Ado Ado Ado pls

ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-wrzZhXI6yjI.htmlsi=JEtSLeUCc3dgAqWq 如果喜歡他的話 這首這版本真的值得聽 無瑕疵的live

singing good is not everything. Sometimes when you want them to sing *perfectly*, they will lose their uniqueness. its the uniqueness that will make someone famous because it leaves an impression. khalil is one of them. See jj lin, jay chou even mj, gem all of them have unique voice that you can recognise the moment they sing the first word. some singers have great vocals, technique but nv famous. because they don't have uniqueness.

ado 呢！！！

好想聽有配樂版喔

大同的英文歌 rosy 为啥没有评论呢？

I really want to see the teacher’s comments on Wu Bai & China Blue’s song “Norwegian Wood” which was released in 1996, with a live broadcast, and comments on another song “Last Dnce”ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-9zhbiwn6LQM.html ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-xL7yVPPC58o.html

有點好奇老師會對阿杜的唱腔有什麼看法 😅

有可能把单依纯的三人游一起评点吗？

張碧晨呢

这里怎么这么冷清

幾時有楊宗緯？

where is khalil???

盧廣仲也是自己寫歌 老師一定會喜歡的！

想睇點評 張敬軒 🙏

方大同的三人遊都來了, 說好的 單依純三人遊 呢?

老師我聽不出哪裡不完美😂

He's American.

方大同的風格=低調、質感的代名詞

有才，但歌不太行