girl r u dumb the point is that shawn was a teen in these clips when justin's voice had matured as he's above 18 in all of those. its not abt how years old the clips are lol
@@ASadPigeon yes but those clips are from the times when Bieber was already in form . But shawn was just beginning his career. In other words, he wasn't in form.
Bieber sings better then I thought. I never really followed Bieber but I like the tone of his voice. I know Bieber has a few songs I like but I never watched or listened to him live. I think I might be watching Bieber little more now after this. Mendez is ok but I really enjoyed Bieber’s vocals
Not really a fair battle. Shawn’s clips are from his RU-vid channel when he is very young and not so polished as he is now. Justin’s clips are from his concert performances. To be completely fair, clips of Justin’s RU-vid videos of when he first started out should have been used. TBH, both are amazing singers🎤🎸🎼
I definitely agree with you.. shawn is much more than Justin... shawn is so passionate about music and singing.... Justin have always in the live concert he play a pre record song....
@@josivantorres2218 that doesn't really matter. neither one of them are formally trained singers. and they both have been singing most of their lives since childhood. so its a pretty fair comparison. shawn joined the music industry later than justin but that's something different.
I didn't know that Bieber is that good. A lot of people don't . He is so underrated as a singer. Not as an artist, just as singer. Good job that ur thoughts on Justin didn't stop u from giving him points. Can't wait until next Sunday
That's the main difference between them. Justin Bieber is just a good pop singer, Shawn is a complete music artist. As far as singing goes, they have totally different singing styles, so it's unfair to compare them. Both are good vocalists though.
@@elena79rus I disagree, I dont know anything about Shawn so I won't say anything about him but Bieber can play multiple instruments, he is a great singer, and he has an exceptionally good feel for rhythm
Shawn Mendes has improved so much techmique and tone wise. It's a shame that only old videos of Shawn were chosen. This doesn't represent Shawn's quality at all. Imo, he has surpassed Bieber.
Justin is definitely the better vocalist out of the two, but Shawn is really lovely as well. Even though Justin is super famous, I feel that no one ever takes the time to understand how good he actually is.
Facts people think coz he’s famous he’s overrated but NO! He’s actually really talented and I think he’s underrated as some of his best music isn’t popular at all
Justin's voice is better for pop music, because he can do some incredibly beautiful stuff with his voice. Shawn, on the other hand, has a much more powerful voice which suits better for rock music than pop.
This isn’t rlly a fair test since Shawn was going through puberty during most of these clips since he was like 16 but Justin was like 20 during these 🤷🏻♀️
Nah! In the first one, justin was 18/19. And in 2-3 others too he was 17 18. Well i can agree that shawn has done better than this. But even justin has much better performances
Justin still would have won because he was so good when he was younger . He can controle his voice so good especially in live videos. Then his voice changed and he's great but sound more flawless with his little boy voice. My opinion.
Hi! love your reactions but in this think you should also consider thar all Shawn Mendes clips where covers and Justin Bieber where originals so it's different when the song it's made for you...
He is an absolutely lovely person with a good heart but who had to go through some hard stuff. He's working on getting better aswell. I've met him and every time he was so sweet.
I hope you are joking, jb is one of the most popular singer in the world with 300milion dollars. And you are saying he is underrated? He is the most overrated singer in the world. He can’t even hit the highest note like Shawn mendes. Are you saying Justin Bieber deserve more fame and more money when he is very overrated?
I don't even look at the comments because I know the majority of the people would say Shawn Mendes but for me is Justin he has such a beautiful tone and an unique voice
"Justin Bieber's voice us deteriorating" when ? Almost all the clips shown of the Biebs are his latest performances, during the Purpose era. He hasn't performed anything so far after that era so when is his voice start to deteriorate tho ? I can agree that Shawn is improving but not on what you said about Bieber since he hasn't sing live for quite some time now.
Exactly. If she were to compare the most recent stuff from both, it would clearly be Shawn who is better. Honestly, I feel like she is just a bit biased towards Justin's voice in general. I'm no vocal coach, but some of these clips, Shawn just sound better and Justin would do the bare minimum, yet she'd give it to Justin.
@@kenetrice she doesn't make the compilation of videos, plus ur not a vocal coach, you might think he's singing better when in reality he might not be hitting the particular notes
I expected a fair battle somethin like Pink & Kelly based on how well Shawn does sing now. The comparison is definitely off in these clips and skewed toward Bieber, hence the “Whose Shawn Mendes” intro.
I still think Shawn was better💯 Even with these older clips... Shawn may not have the greatest technique, but he's waaaaay better as a vocalist and I like Justin...
@@mrmusicality994 by the way most of Justin's videos here old and is it that I want you to hear his new lives on the last album justice and Justin the highest singer in the world and also the highest Western singer
Some of here are commenting that they used Shawn old clips .... Did u noticed that they also used old clips of Bieber 😂😂 Clearly just say u hate Justin Bieber !!!! Btw bieber vocals is much better than Shawn ......
I just see a lot of coments saying that Shawn is better now. He is just one of the most overrated singer ever, make every little note sounds so hard, and I thing I've never heard him singing a song without low-keying it with a semi-tone or even a tone. Bieber is in a break after a 10 years career, he get married and all the stuff with Drew House, but when he will be back on stage, we will remember what a real performer is!
These clips were definetly not fair, Shawn is really better nowadays, I still find his upper range strained but he sings with a lot more ease, and his lows are DIVINE.
I could not say that someone is better than another, they are both so different. Shawn is very good, but Justin is too, I think Justin is vocally more versatile, he makes music in several genres. Instead shawn always remains in the same genre. Both are good. but I stay with Bieber.
Justin uses A LOT of auto tune. But I get annoyed by Shawn’s unpleasant nasal tone. Shawn can’t perform very well without his guitar too (stage presence) lol.
R I K O the clips were picked by a justin bieber fan so ofc he’s gonna win because most jb fans hate shawn so he chose the worst shawn clips and best justin
Shawn is a powerhouse singer and has an unique tone and Justin has a soft,emotional tone which is not really strong .Vocally and technically Justin is better
I agree, though I don't think Justin is better overall. They just have different singing styles. Justin's voice is better for contemporary pop music and he can do incredibly beautiful stuff with his voice, but Shawn's voice is more powerful, so he would be much better singing rock.
You don't just get it guys , shawn is really really good and an amazing artist , but justin is something else justin has a gift in his voice ; however shawn have an amazing voice too , but justin voice is naturally incrediable she said it already without intense 11:19 u can understand there why justin wins
Also, I'm no vocal coach, but that sexy ass raspiness in Shawn's voice (which he has learned to control more and make it sound more purposeful) is seriously STUNNING. In his earlier music, the raspy sound in his voice sometimes sounded "unintentional" or like he was pushing his voice too far, but honestly that is just a part of his sound. He controls it much better now, which is why you should have used more current music from him.
you could’ve pick up more recent clips of shawn. choosing to analyse his old covers of when he was still a kid going thru puberty and not experienced isn’t right. his vocals keep getting better and better day by day and he’s improved a lot technically
please do this again with a video not made by a bieber fan. the videos of shawn are from like 2015 when he wasn’t vocally trained and still started out; he’s on a whole other level by now
There are Videos from Shawn like from 2015 and he is a looot better now.It would be nice, if you could react to his voice from 2018/19 cause that's how he is right now yk. I'll just support him :)
I don't see Shawn tired in any of the videos. Justin Bieber does a lot more Concerts (Purpose Tour for almost 2 years) and even while walking and dancing Justin Bieber has better control. When it comes to Shawn Mendes he always stands or sits while sings. He barely dance but good singer
Definitely Mendes. Justin barely sings lol I don’t understand how celebrities still can’t sing after years and with all this money they could spend on vocal coaching.
Clip 1. You’re wrong. Bieber has more dynamic due to compressors active on his mic, he also had reverb and post production e.g. melodyne or similar can be clearly heard. Shawn was raw. Clip 2 You’re wrong. Bieber had the same post production. Shawn was raw again Clip 3 You’re right. Except it wasn’t double stacked. You can hear the original vocal before production playing back through the monitors as well as the post production and ‘auto tuned’ version. Clip 4 he says summer taaahm because he’s Canadian and it sounds better and less ‘theatrical’. Summertime is closed vowel. Summer taaahm is open voweled Clip 5 Again. Bieber has production. Shawn didn’t. Clip 6 Both were good to be fair however Bieber was straining a LOT. Clip 7 Bieber is straining a lot even lower down in his register. His jaw is clenched. You’re simply wrong. Clip 8 You’re right. He is straining a LOT but to be fair I think Bieber was on the cusp of puberty 😂 Clip 9 You’re right with both. Bieber was whiny though and very strained. However Shawn was really flat. Clip 10 Bieber had HUGE amounts of melodyne (auto tune) on that clip however Shawn seemed vocally tired and strained. Shawn has improved a LOT over the past few years and is by FAR better than Bieber vocally.
thank you for mentioning the environments these were recorded in . One is in a room with the acoustics of a high school gym has he sits, and the other has a mic plugged into a rack of effects. Maybe I'm jaded after a lifetime of recording and engineering live, but to me i think they should have sent you more comparable clips. Sorry not hating here, I don't have a horse in this race.
Justin’s better, whether the clips are old or not. I don’t follow Shawn except when he performs at award shows. And everytime he performs on it, it’s not good at all TO ME. The vma performance was vocally a mess to me. They look the same age here, so that’s why they are comparing the two. Y’all are saying “these clips of Shawn are old” well so are Justin’s. Then y’all making the excuse “well he didn’t have vocal training there and Justin has” how you know Shawn hasn’t had vocal training? Well if you guys want Shawn’s recent ones compared to Justin, then that wouldn’t be fair either because Justin doesn’t have many recent performances. So this video is fine to me. Look at Justin’s old videos at age 12 of him singing, he’s always been able to do runs and be smooth effortlessly. They both strain a lot sometimes.
I dont like either of them, but I can't help but to appreciate the growth vocally within them both. They both obviously changed stylistically because their range and depth changed due to puberty but they are both good. I would still pick Justin though. I do appreciate their vocal agility though 😊😊😊
Bieber vocals are better cause he had vocal coaching he can handle his voice better he's more clear and more beautiful. I wish you would have used videos when Justin played piano or guitar while singing. No one can compare to JB. He's amazing
Amazing how Beiber's bad attitude and negative press can colour your judgement without realising it! He sounded a lot better than Mendez who is quite a dull character and that seems to be reflected in his rather "vanilla" voice-sounds generic and sterile
