Vocal Coach Reacts to TREASURE - Autotune VS Live Singing 🤔 

The part you mentioned: not lip synced, a different member hit that ending word. If you know each member's tone's you know that it was hyunsuk, not haruto that said that ending word. But also I totally understand... there are definitely songs with hard choreo that some bands on certain occasions will lipsync or have touched up, so i don't blame you for the suspicion

The part where Haruto moved away from the mic is not lipsync, because that part is sing by Hyunsuk. It’s always like that for the part. *CMIIW You can check it from their other stage performances, so you could get the full image of them singing. My personal fave is the MMM stage at Teuday, indeed one of the best live performance!

YG artists are known for having stable live, Hyunsuk was the one singing that part you were suspicious of lipsync 😌

The 6:00 part is not lipync. if you really have a good hearing you will hear a different voice. It's not Haruto that's why he removed the mic. It's Hyunsuk's backing vocal

Treasure is from YG Entertainment. Same company with blackpink, bigbang, winner,ikon and yg are known as company who dont really use vocal backgrounds, their artists singing live mostly in their performances even when they debuted.

Hey!...Justin... the part you mentioned and asked us to tell you in the comment section is NOT lipsync. Treasure always like to add adlids and hype whenever they perform. When Haruto moved away from mic, Hyunsuk sang the last part. That show was radio show and all the idols always sing LIVE at those shows. Hope my comment helps you to understand.

Their voices really sound like a studio ver. That Haru’s scene when he moved his mic away, is actually because that part is for Hyunsuk. To hear their raw vocals, you can try watching their tmap eps, radio guests, and this: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-Ma6wjuaAups.html

It is NOT lip-sync. If you are good you can distinguish the tone was different because the part Haruto removed his mic was sang by a different person. Treasure usually do that - sort of adlibs - when performing live. And of all people you said that to Harturo!?!! Haruto even changes his vocal/tone range during live performances/concert just to show the mic is on.

the entirety of Treasure has trained for a long time and love music/singing. they even openly admit when they have voice cracks on stage, for them its always live singing even if the backtrack is loud. they have done R&B and its AMAZING. the rappers can be vocalists and even their raps in R&B flow beautifully with the vocals, its not awkward at all. For the part where they sing at the radio, it is live. when he moved away from the mic, it was another member doing the adlib. they have many adlibs during songs or concerts, many of them change based on what the member feels like saying. in an unedited performance you can hear them making funny noises and laughing on stage too. just proves their mics are always on!

I am quite curious how a singer can't differentiate two tones. Haruto and Hyunsuk have quite different voices and distinguishing them is easy. Haruto raps with a deep voice whereas Hyunsuk has a high voice. I doubt how much of a good singer you are. Treasure or even yg artists never lip sync. Their voice cracks and everything can be heard because they don't lip sync. If you doubt their capabilities you can check their trace concert. They have sung each every song even if they were tired.

If you want to watch treasure singing accapella you should watch their live streams and tmap episodes where they are playing games. They don't mind singing without backing tracks and show their raw vocals they even do it impromptu and produce songs impromptu as well

THE LYRICS GOES LIKE THIS: "We can believe hangsang geulaessdeus-i us-eum-eul ilhji ma jeoldaero" Haruto did: "We can believe hangsang geulaessdeus-i us-eum-eul ilhji ma--" Hyunsuk then sang: "jeoldaero" Listen to Haruto and Hyunsuk's voice more and you'll know how. Btw, that video is from a radio show, where all of their guests have to sing live, whether they like it or not.

Believe it or not? This TREASURE group is insane ! At their young age they can Produce Songs, The Vocals is high quality, The Rap is fire + Dance and Visuals. Full package Group.

Treasure rappers actually can pass as vocalist, they are also good at singing especially Haruto (the guy with deep voice) You should watch their videos from Teuday and Trace (Treasures first concert last april 9-10) because they’re literally singing live. It’s available here on RU-vid 😊 oh and by the way the part when you say it’s a lyp sync, it was actually sang by the other member (Hyunsuk) since Treasure do a lot of ad-libs and you can tell by the vocal tone that it is not a deep voice like Haruto 😉

The moment haruto stop hyunsuk fill in that part . Radio shows are always 100% live. Haruto is a low tone rapper while hyunsuk is a high tone rapper. I'm not a vocal coach, expert or anything like that but I guess many teumes will beat you on that part.😅 I guess we memorized everything about treasure that we can even recognized who's who even if we're not looking. Anyways thank you for reacting to Treasure !!!!!

For us fans its so easy to get the difference between Hyunsuk's voice adlibs in Haruto's part in My Treasuse on the radio part you think he is lipsync, but still for non fans I think is not that dificult to distinguish, their voices are not even similar.

They are known for their stable vocals , if you reacted to a full stage you will know that they are singing live . They do a lot of adlibs hope you see them 👍🏻

This just proves how talented TREASURE are, people kept thinking that their performance in SKETCHBOOK is lip singing but you know what the rule is in sketchbook, you MUST SING LIVE!!!!

PLEASE READ THIS. the part you said “lipsynced” and moved away from his mic- 5:46 that is Haruto. And Hyunsuk, the other rapper was singing along that part with him. Haruto have low tone and Hyunsuk, high tone

That was not haruto turn that was hyunsuk's turn that is why he moves the mic. As their fan we can recognize their voices easily.

I just love treasure 💎 and I hope for more TREASURE videos and reactions . They are the best 4th gen group 🧿🦋. #treasure And about Haruto's moving away from mic well it was someone else part . #haruto

6:00 It's not Haruto's voice, it's Hyunsuk in the back💙

If you're not into live singing that's almost like the studio vr., watch their TRACE concert clips since they adlib more on those stages. And NO. Haruto did not lipsync coz it was Hyunsuk who sang on that part. 😊

treasure just had a concert, i would recommend watching those performances since you can really tell in those stages that they are singing live.

Jikjin radio live will satisfy your yearning for them to sing live. It is much clearer. The video capture is wide. There it is better

They just had a concert and it was soo amazing live

Treasure let's go Treasure is really good at doing live everything ❤️😍😍😍

The thing is most of the award and music shows are pre recorded and muted the real audio that's makes the group look like do lipsync but when you watch fancams they actually sings live mostly from mnet shows and other reason, music shows doesn't just film 1 take. They do it 4 or more times that the group is exhausted from dancing that they would just lipsync

Hyunsuk actually sang the part when haruro moved the mic away from him

Bro they do have rnb and ballad songs, u just need to check out

when haruto moved away the mic it's hyunsuk part lol

Someone need to make an updated version of this autotune vs live video with teuday and trace's footages. It pisses me off with the way he reacted to it. Or he could just reacting to teuday or trace's videos.... seriously!! You can clearly hear the back fucking track when they sings live... because their voices will be louder...

The part where you say that he drop the mic and there is still someone else singing its not him or the backtrack it's the other other Rapper who did it. It how they do it during live they like go back and forth with their parts like an adlib if that's how you call it. And I think if you really wanna hear the live you can chose other live Perf bcoz the one the you choose is mostly on a Music Show and they usually do pre recording. So they might be singing live but still you can hea the backtrack. But honestly speaking their voice even in live actually sounds the same like a backtrack. Regarding them doing like rnb or different version of their songs, they already done it. They already did piano version, Brock versions of their songs. If you really wanna see them live you can look for their vid during TEUDAY FAN MEETING or Their Concert. You can be sure to hear their voice there. Thank you

This vocal coach can't even distinguish two different voices. I'm confused!

It’s Hyunsuk voice when Haruto move his mic, because it is his part…

I think Haruto's voice gets even more deeper.....while he's rapping live....thats impressive

You can also watch their concert performances they're amazing!

This only cut for certain members so the video can't show the whole members cam but if you watch the original video it shows all the members and you could see who is who singing or doing adlibs I could guarantee you they're singing live since pre debut, sometimes they do use loud backtrack especially for dance break even dance break sometimes they're doing adlibs too

treasure is that one group that wont hesitate to sing live or even without instruments because THEY CAN SING,,,esp the vocal line

6:02 Hyunsuk was doing adlib there

Treasure rappers and vocalist are stable even on live thats why it sounds like studio version! You should watch their concert fancams to hear their raw vocals.Btw, all of the videos you played was live.

if u want some raw raw vocals, i recommend to watch their teuday (fan meeting) and teuconcert (first concert)

They just done their concert month ago, and there are clips live from the offline fans. It's not lipsync, pure live.

They realy love to put lots of adlibs.. ❤️

you can watch the TRACE concert clip. Treasure Sang their songs live with some note changes.

they have RNB SONGS AND BALLAD.YOU COULD REACT TO DARARI,BEAUTIFUL AND ITS OKAY.

I see that many have already clarified them and I don't know if you already saw the comments, but it was NOT lipsync. When haruto moves the microphone away a voice is heard because hyunsuk sings the last word.

I'm here for Justin looking so mindfucked by Haruto's phantom voice 🤣

You should react to a live performance of "MY TREASURE", you'll know that it's really live, the one who raps at the end is not haruto but hyunsuk, Teume's(treasure's fans) can identify their voices since they have their own unique way of rapping. And just by watching "YG TREASURE BOX" and "TREASURE MAP" you'll know that they really aren't lip syncing. They have a lot of video clips that you can watch singing live. Here is the evidence: TREASURE MAP EP:58 - Everyday ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-QnflVowapuQ.html It must not be enough since they have a lot of videos singing live.

Haruto the one you say lipsync is not cus the when he move the mic hyunsuk is singing,,, and that show is radio for live singing 🤗

Wow finally! Another Treasure reactioooon😭❤️

Now I'm kinda of angry at your suspicions about lipsync on Haruto's part. Please see their live vocal in Trace concert or Teuday or fancam full stage I wish you were really a vocal coach... SIR?

If you want unplugged version you should react to their first concert Trace 🤟

Hyunsuk said that word it was live

You should apologize to Treasure fans and Treasure members because they don't lip synced

That's hyunsuk part when Haruto moved away his mic.

Hello coach. I understand the part you were confused about lip sync. Actually that wasn't Haruto's part (the one that put the mic away). It's actually Hyunsuk's (the first rapper). It's an adlib. And yes! If you want to watch them singing fully live, without the use of fine or backtracking (or whatsoever, sorry don't know the correct term), you can watch their survival show called YGTB. it's a hundred percent VOICE and mic only w/ of course instrumentation. Every ep has a duration of not less than an hour so if you think you can't carry it, you can just watch some video compilations or cut of their performances from the said survival show. I'll give you one. JEONGWOO SINGING WHEN WE WERE YOUNG BY ADELE (YG TREASURE BOX OR YGTB). Nevertheless, I don't hate you for what you said. Of course it must've been a misunderstanding. But I'll be glad if you go watch what i said above.

If you want to compare autotune vs no autotune check treasure trace concert tht the real live and they also mention some parts may not be going too well...so tht mean no autotune, Also you can watch Station Z Ikon Day Radio They sing without music I'm not teume but I don't want idols being mistreated like this

ALWAYS LOVE YOUR VIDEOS PLEASE REACT TREASURE WAYO VOCAL LINE. YOU WON'T REGRET IT ♡🙏

My favorite song by them so far is still their debut song Boy. As I was watching this I was thinking "I think he's really going to love Yedam when he gets to him." The hardest thing for me has been continuing to tell them apart. I've gotten better at it and with most of them I think I have them memorized. I still get some of them confused though. I'm just glad to see him react to Treasure because I had been requesting it for awhile.

Another one sad that word that's why he moved away from the mic

if you want to here more melodic rapping from them check out their b-side tracks like darari, U, come to me, beautiful, b.l.t. & ballads like it's okay, orange and slowmotion

Sometimes watch the full video. Check out orange live cuz that's like an rnb sounding song or darari and then listen carefully. This guys are from yg and they'll never lipsync when performing. I know you're not a full time fan of them but the tone is literally different.

I would highly recommend checking out other videos of them. This compilation doesn’t show a lot of the vocalists strengths, plus it seems that the last video they added was ‘My Treasure’ which was their comeback over a year ago. The members have grown tremendously and improved in that time.

Teuday, trace concert or radio show performances are live 🥰 Thank you for reacting! I hope you’ll react to them again soon ❤️

You should react to their live "everyday" in teuday Or their concert

Those boys is very very talented they have such a good and powerful voice and rap. The deserve all the love and support. Treasure are really TREASURE 💙💎

rappers in treasure usually back each other up so hyunsuk (another member) was rapping with haruto. So when haruto moved away from the mic (possibly bc his tone was too low and didn't want to risk not reaching the note) hyunsuk filled in and sang that note for him! all live, no lip sync. looking forward to more treasure vids :)

TREASURE IS VERY ADMIRABLE AND VERY TALENTED. THE BEST GROUP FOR ME

Thank you so much for reaction Treasure again 👍🏻

When Haruto remove his mic, it was Hyunsuk who back him up 😄. Thats what the rapper line do, sometimes the let other rappers read their line

The clips of them at the radio session were all live, no backing vocals. The rappers are already trained to sing, YG don't play with live vocals.

Haruto moved away his mic because other member sing that part.

YG's artist never know how to lipsync.

then you should react to treasure's bang bang bang performance on their concert.

Yes justin, weve been waiting for so long for you to react to treasure..🤗🤗🤗 rap,choreo and lord their vocals..

Yes omg Hyunsuk sounds exactly the same when he performs in my opinion he sounds better live

It's not lip sync, it's the part of Hyunsuk, you can see the difference of the voices and in the every performances he make that

Thank you so much for making this video I'm feeling very touched 🖤🖤

I would like to inform you that the 6:00 part where u said Haruto lip synced, it was live. Those radio studios or smthng are always sang live by singers. When he put the mic away from his mouth and stopped singing, if you'll hear the part PROPERLY, the voice or tone was HIGHER compared to Haruto's deep voice. Hyunsuk sang that part, his voice is a bit higher than Haruto, so I'm sure you'll easily distinguish it if you were listening closely. Teumes know that Treasure creates adlibs sometimes. I hope before you criticize, you should've listened to the clip repeatedly, you should've listen closely not just base it by the video. I'm just saying this as a suggestion or reccommendation for you, so that the next time you create this type of videos, you will not be criticized in the comment section.

React to "Cant take my eyes of you" cover by yedam, jihoon and jeongwoo..pls

Can you probably react to their concert performances, I think if you watch their concert you might be less confusion or suspicion since it's concert. Btw disclaimer, in their concert, the audience cannot scream due to covid restriction in Korea during that time. My top favourite performances are mmm, bang bang bang cover and darari rock version but you can watch all performances. It is available in RU-vid ｡◕‿◕｡

Well if it's YG artist, they purposely remove the mic sometimes and only sing some parts of it(which you can literally hear their voice singing the parts and not lip syncing). But in this case, Haruto remove the mic because his part ends there and the one that you hear is Hyunsuk's adlib.

They just had a concert would suggest that you react to their performances.

You got the wrong video. Treasure's vocals have always been great live. This comparison video does not do their vocals justice.

i just hope this guy read all the comments. n facts YG stage presence is A+

With you jimin please

treasure is the best love u so much treasure the best k pop ever❤❤❤❤

on haruto's part, other member sang that part that's why he didn't sing it~

TREASURE have their mics always open 😌

It was hyunsuk voice when haruto down the mic and its was hyunsuk

If u wanna hear their clear voices, watch 'Wayo' cover by treasure (vocal line)

Rappers and dancers can sing also..they are all rounder.. you may listen to Orange, and hyunsuk, haruto, mashi and yoshi covering "Blue" by Bigbang.

If you truly know the members by their voice ( which you don't but that's totally fine since you react to so many groups) that part where Haruto moved away from the mic is not lipsynced. It was sang by another member, Hyunsuk. But the camera didn't catch that. I'm surprise you didn't catch the two different tones of voice even after replaying it a couple of times as Haruto and Hyunsuk have VERY different tones

You can watch Treasure concerts

THEY ALWAYS SING LIVE. 6:02 is another rapper's part that's why he moves the mic away.

Treasure has got amazing live stages Also ATEEZ is one among their best live performers,,their vocals are just amazing

Solo Treasure puede darse el lujo de cantar mejor en vivo que en estudio

Just love it how you just keep on appreciating them 😭🥺💙

i hope and look forward to see the reaction of baekhyun "all i got" and "cry for love" trust me u will be shocked and amazed